Ю.М. Ткачевский - Прогрессивная система исполнения уголовных наказаний, страница 39

OH^ CO ~ c e fO'IeBMAHOCTbloiC B R 3 b I B a e T IIOJIOXMTeJIbHOe MJIMPMM M3AOMMqeB MJIM CaMOAYPOB.T a ~ a nHarJIRAHOCTb~ P M H ~~ AM~ ~KB ~ TP eHa Ko q~M ~HAOJIXHOCTHbIX JIMq O p r a H O B , MCocymAeHHbIx B ~~BMCMMOCTM~ e M O H C T p M P Y e T C RK a K OnbITOM, n P M M e P O M APYrMX OCYXAeHHbIX, T a KM C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ nOBeAeHMeMIMO C Y w e H H O r O . Ann YCMJIeHMR HarJIRA-nonasroqxx ~ a ~ a a aH ~a n~o s e g ,e H M eHOCTM ~ ~ o I ' ~ ~ c c M CMCTeMbIB H o ~ ~ agMMHMCTPaqMS3 O p r a H a , MCnOJIHRIOuero ~ a ~ a a aA~o n~x Hea ,o n e p a T M B H o M ~ c e o 6 n e ~ n m qMH~$OPMMePOBaTb ( p e I C J l a ~ M p 0 ~ a ~npMMeHeHMeb)I I ~ o ~ ~ ~ c c M BCMCTeMbIH o ~ ~ CpeAMK.

CaMbIM B a W H b I M , CaMbIM H ~ ~ ~ I ~ J I ~ M ~ I M .~ c e f iMaCCbIH a x o A R q M e C R B OAHOM M e C T e JIMlUeHMR CBO6 0 ~ b 1HMeH)T P a B H b I e BO3MOXHOCTM H a yJIy'IUIeHMe ~ c J I o B M C~O~A e p -OT MX ((3aCJIYrB B Y ~ O J I O B H O - M C ~ O J I H M T ~ J I ~ Hn OeA~ ~a r O r M K e OTHOCMTCRA O C T Y ~ H OHC~T~~ ~ I ~ J I ~ M nOp MC HT qHM n an e p e x 0 ~H aX a H M R . I C a ~ ~ e - n ~OrpaHM'IeHMRi6oB 3TOM OTHOlUeHMH AJIR OTAeJlbHbIXOCYXfEAeHHbIX HeAOIIYCTMMbI. Bce 3aBMCMT OT IIOBeAeHMH OCYXCAeH-T y MJIM MHYH) C T Y n e H b I I P O I ' P ~ C C M B H CMCTeMbIO~~AOJI-X e H C O n p O B O X A a T b C R OqYTMMbIMM, 3Ha'IMTeJIbHbIMM M3MeHeHMRMMp e m M M a MCnOJIHeHMR HaKa3aHMR.

JIMIlIb n p M~ T ~ o ~ ~ ~ c c MCMCTeMbI.B H o ~ ~T ~ K3aKJIH)'IeHHbIe,,O C y X A e H H b I X AaHHOrO M e C T a JIMLUeHHR C B O ~ O & ~MJIHI~ ~ M c ~ M ~ J I M HB~ OPMHHoC~K ~O ~'IaCTM~M T. A.HOrO.co6m~em3TOIV~ ~pe6o-BaHMR O C Y ~ ~ H pHe a J~I bIH ~O OWYTMT~npeMMyqeCTBa ~06pocosec~HOW OTHOLUeHMR K HCnOJIHeHMH) HaKa3aHMR M HeraTMBHbIe IIOCJIeACTBMRECJIMOHM O X e T Y J I F L U M T b YCJIOBAR O T ~ ~ I B ~ HHMa KRa 3 a H M R , TO3 T O AOCTynHO B r p a H M q a X , YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX 3aXOHOM.MHMqMaTMBbI M nOBeAeHMII OCyXfleHHOrO.Bce 3aBMCMT OTBaHHOCTM.

H ~ ~ H ~ Y M T ~ JMaJIOOqyTMMbIeI ~ H ~ I ~ ,M3MeHeHKR YCJIOBM~~CO-B M ~ CC TT e~M H e K O T O p b I e 3 J I e M e H T b l ~ T ~ o ~ ~ ~ c c MCMCTeMbIB H o ~ ~MOrYT OTHOCMTbCR M H e KO BCeM OCYXAeHHbIM. H a n p M ~ e p n, e p e B O A BA e p X a H M R O C y X A e H H b I X T e p R l o T CBOG c ~ ~ ~ y n n p y r oMJlMq ~ Yf Ci T p a LUaIOaMfi X a p a K T e p .

IC ((MeJIOYM, H e 3 a ' I e M CTPeMMTbCR, ((MeJIO'IbD MICOJIOHMEO-IlOCeJIeHMe AJIR HeKOTOPbIX K ~ T ~ ~ o OCYXCfCAeHHbIX~ M GHenpMMeHMM. B COOTBeTCTBMM C 'I.3 CT. 78 YMIC P a H e n O A J I e X a T3JIOCTHOrO HeMCnOJIHeHMII p e X M M H b I X n p a B M J I , HeAMCqMnJIMHMpO-H e YCTpaLUMT.HanepeBoAy B3T0 O~CTORT~JI~CTBO~PPTMJIMOBHMMaHHe MHOrMe~ o n o ~ ~ ~ - n o c eonc yex~A e~HrHrb I enpMoco6oonacHoMP e q M A M B e I I p e c ~ y n J I e ~ M f OCyXCAeHHbIei,K nOXM3HeHHOMY JIMLUeHMH)C B O ~ O & ~B I C J I y 9 a e 3 a M e H b I 3TOrO H a K a 3 a H M R B n O p R A K e nOMMJIOBa-1 0 p M ~ ~ b 1 .

OHMlO ~ O C H O B ~ H H nOO J I a r a I o T , ' I T 0 YCMJIeHMe 3Ha'IMMOCTMM3MeHeHMR y c J I 0 ~ M f iMCnOJIHeHMR H a K a 3 a H M R OCYXJ(eHHbIX, YCMJIMTBOCnMTaTeJIbHOe 3 H a Y e H M e I ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ CMCTeMbI.c c M B H o ~ ~HMR JIMLUeHHeM C B O ~ O H~ a~ 0I n p e ~ e J I e ~ ~ bCpOK,lfiO C y X A e H H b I e , KO-~ J I ~ M ~ HI I Tp o~r pI e c c M ~ ~ o fCMCTeMbIiAOJIXHbI HPMMeHRTbCR KTOpbIM C M e P T H a R K a 3 H b B n O p R A K e nOMMJIOBaHMR 3 a M e H e H a JIMLUe-O C y X A e H H b I M O ~ O C H O B ~ H H On ,p M HaJIM'IMM no-HaCTORllJeMY~oroMJIM H e r a T M B H o r o n o a e A e s mH e o 6 o c ~ o ~ a ~Y J~I yoq UeI e H M e- no 3 a C J I y r a M .HMeM C B O ~ O A ~ OI ,C Y X A e H H b I e , H e llpOUIe,I(IlIMenO3MTMB-JIe'IeHHR B MeAMqMHCKMX y'IpeX,l(eHMRxY C J I O B M ~MCnOJIHeHMR~HaKa3aHMROCYX~~HH~IMH e; 3aCJIYXMBUIMM 3 T O r 0 , P a 3 B p a q a e .

r MX M ~ p a f i ~HeraTMBHO BOCnpMHHMaeTCR MHbIMM OCYXAeHHbIMM. ~ P M H C~ n pMa - ~eBeAJIMBOCTM n p M MCnOJIHeHMM H a K a 3 a H M R AMCKPeAMTHPYeTCR. B MeCT a x JrMrUeHMR C B O ~ O A ~nogo6~oroIP O A a HeCnpaBeAJrMBOCTb 'lawe B C e NBCTpeqaeTCR n p M H ~ O ~ O C H O B ~ H H OYJly'IrUeHMMM~ c J I o B MCOAepXCa~~HMR OCyXAeHHbIX-aKTMBMCTOB. C p e ~ aOCYXAeHHbIX AeJIMTCR H a c(JIH)~ M M Y M K O BH~ ((ITaCbIHKOBD, 9 T O HeraTMBHO C K a 3 b I B a e T C R H a 0 6 c ~ a HOBKe MeCT JIMLUeHMR C B O ~ O ~ ~ I .C ~ O C O ~ C T B YM~ HT~O~OCHOB~HHO~TO MYB n e p B O M CJIy'Iae H e n p M M e H e H M e n e p e B O A a B KOJIOHHIO-UOCeJIeHMe K T P e M KaTerOpMfiM OCYXAeHHblX I I p e A O n p e A e J I e H O oco6o BbICO~ 0 f OnaCHOCTbH)iBMX JIMYHOCTM.KOJIOHMRX-nOCeJIeHMRX O C y X A e H H b I e HaXOARTCR H a C O ~ C T B ~ H -HOM MXAMBeHHM.

~ O B T O Mn e~p e B O A HeM3JIe'IMBLUMXCrl: O C y X A e H H b I XH e ryMaHeH.B 0 3 b ~ eMHYH)~~ O P M Y~ P O ~ ~ ~ C C H B CMCTeMbI,H O $ ~CBR3aHHYH) Cy x y A m e H n e M n p a B o B o r o nonoxeam o c y m n e H H o r o . B M H T e p e c a x ryMaHM3Ma O H a B HeKOTOPbIX CJIYYaRX H e n p H M e H H M a K OTAeJIbHbIMK a T e r O p M R M OCYXAeHHbIX.' CM.,Hanp.: ~a.S ~ ~ U H OA. S Unp06JIeMb1~IIOBbIIIIeHMR ~ @ @ ~ K T ~ B H3aKOHOOCTUJJaTenbCTBa0 YrOJIOBHbIX H ~ K ~ ~ ~ H u RB0np0Cblx / / C ~ . ~@@~KTUBHOCTYIIIpaBOCYAURno YronoBHMM AeaaM. Kannnunrpa~,1980. C.74; Conoeaes K). A.

npo6neMbr cosepIIIeHCTBOBaHUR IIOO~pUTenbHbIXHOPM COBeTCKOrO UCnpaBUTenbHO-TpyAOBOrO npa~ a / / C 6 .C o s e p w e ~ c ~ ~ o s aa~an ~e o ~ o ~ ~ a OCHOB~ e n bucnonnenun~ ~ xYronoBnblx Ha~ a a a n u lM.,. 1988. C. 42.136KypCa 0 6 ~ 3 a T e J I b ~ o r o3aKPbITOrO TMna.T ~ KB ,'l.4CT.130 YWIC P@ YCTaHOBJIeH3 a n p e T BOABOPeHMR H a C T P O ~ MPeXCMM~~B TIoPbMe ~ ~ P ~ M ~ HX eHH -~ I XWMH M XCeHqMH, MMeIOqMX n p M ce6e MaJIOJIeTHHX ~ e ~ eMf MHBaJIMiAOBI M I1 rpynn.Bce MCKJIlo9eHMRM3 O ~ ~ nMP a BXM J I n p M M e H e H M R ~ P O ~ ~ ~ C C M B H O ~ ~CMCTeMbI AOJIXHbI 6 b 1 ~ bXOPOUIO M3BeCTHbI BCeM OCYXfCAeHHbIM.137~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ C C CMM CBT e HM a~- XHapaKTepHaL U M p 0 ~ 0 f i BO3MOXHOCTbH)AO~YCTMM,eeHeOAHOKpaTHOrO IIpMMeHeHMR.OCYXA€!HHB ~KOJIOI~~H n n o64ero p e x n M a 6b1n n e p e B e A e H c 0 6 4 Y~C J I~O B M ~ ~O T ~ ~ I B ~ H M RH a K a 3 a H M R H a C T p O r M e YCJIOBMR.

H p M H a A J I e X a q e M lTOBeAeHMM OHM O X e T 3aCJIYXMTb BO3BPaT H a 0 6 q ~ eYCJIOBMR O T ~ ~ I B ~ H MH aI KI a3aHMR, a a a ~ Me H~a 06nerse~~b1e.T a ~ a a((qMpKYJIIIqMII)) M3 OAHMX Y C J I O B OMT~~~~ I B ~ HHMa KHa 3 a H M RB A p y r M e M O X e T 6 b 1 ~ bH ~ O A H O K P ~ T H OBonee~~.TOrO, O C Y X A ~ H H ~ I ~ ~M O X e T , H a n P M M e P , 3 a C J I y X M T b A O C P O ~ H ~l TI e~p ~e B O A M3 T H ) P b M b I BKOJIOHMH), a 3 a T e M K a K 3 J I 0 c ~ ~ b l fHapYUIMTeJIbip e X M M a BHOBb lT0n a C T b B TH)PbMY. BOBMOXHOCTMTaKMX HeOAHOKPaTHbIX lTepeBOAOB BJ I y 9 U I y H ) MJIM XyALUyH) CTOpOHY 3aKOHOM H e O r p a H M 9 e H b I . Bce 3 a B M CMT OT IIOBeAeHMR O C y X A e H H O r O , OT er0 OTHOUleHMR K O T ~ ~ I B ~ H M X )HaKa3aHMR.Pean~aaqn p~o~r p~ e c c ~ ~ ~CMcTeMbIofi6a3~pyeH~ ac n~p M M e H e HMM IIOOIIJpMTeJIbHbIX M O X p a H M T e J I b H b t X H O p M YrOJIOBHO-MCnOJIHMT e J I b H O r O M YrOJIOBHOrO lTpaB.B T e K C T e p a 6 o ~ b 1M b l yXe KaCaJIMCb B K p a T q e n p o 6 n e ~ b 1n p M M e HeHMR nOOlIJPMTeJIbHbIX HOPM, P e r J I a M e H T M P y l O q M X lTpOrpeCCMBHyH)CMCTeMy.

B ~ ~ H ~ KM~Ce fRBHOBb.iHO MHeHMH) H. A. C T P Y ~ K OBB ~ ,YrOJIOBHO-MCnOJIHMTeJIbHOM ( M c ~ T ~ ~ B M T ~ ~ ~ H o - T ~ ~ ) J o B ol TMp) a B e lTOOqP M T e J I b H b I e H O p M b I RBJIIIIOTCR pa3HOBMAHOCTbH) y I I O J I H O M a 9 M B a H ) q M XHOPM. n p M KOHCTPYMPOBaHMM l I 0 0 q P M T e J I b H b I X HOPM, I l O J I O X e H H b I XB O C H O B Y M ~ M ~ H ~ H M R Y C J I O B M ~ M C I I O ~ H ~ H M R H C~ TKO~P~O~HHYMerROBCMRrqeHMR, y n o ~ p e 6 n e ~@0p~yJIaa( ( M O X e T 6 b l ~ b ) )TOJIKYR.ee, H. A.C T P Y ~ K O~ PBM X O A M T KB ~ I B O A Y , TO y n y 9 m e H M e Y C J I O B M ~conepwa~HMR O C y X A e H H O r O H e RBJIReTCR er0 lTpaBOM, a I I p a B O M aAMMHMCTpaUMM M e C T JIMUIeHMR C B O ~ O A ~ I .

'O C H O B ~ I BH~a RT CepM~ M H e ( ( M O X e T 6 b I ~ b ) ) a, B T O P b I Y ' I ~ ~ H MnoK ~YrOJIOBHO-MCIIOJIHMTeJIbHOMY l T p a B y K a T e r O p M s e C K M Y T B e p X A a I o T , r T 0m.( ( O C O ~ ~ H H O Cl TT0~O q p M T e J I b H b I X HOPM ( B C ~ X6e3 MCKJIlO9eHMII T.)B YrOJIOBHO-MClTOJIHMTeJIbHOM l T p a B e COCTOMT B TOM, 9 T O OHM l T p e A 0 -CTaBJIRKlT I I p a B O H a l T O O q p e H M e TOJIbKO C0OTBeTCTBYH)qeMYTYcy6ne~-T e J I b H b I X I I p a B .

~ P M H I I T MPeLUeHMII~0 I I O O q p e H M M 3aBMCMT OT YCMOTPeHMR aAMMHMCTPaqMM M T Y u . ' ~ P M B ~ Ae ~q eM OAHO MHeHMe lT0P a C C M a T p M B a e M O M y BOIIpOCy.COJIOB~l T~OBJ I a r a e T , 9 T O (( IIOOIJJP M T e J I b H a R H O p M a MClTpaBMTeJIbHO-TpyAOBOrO l T p a B a C O A e P X M T lTpeAIIMCaHMe 0 BOBMOXHOM, a H e AOJIXCHOM ( o ~ R ~ ~ T ~ J I ~ Hl ToOMO q)p e H M MOCyX,L(eHHOrO 3a B a p M a H T lTOBeAeHMR, B KOTOPOM r O C Y A a P C T B 0 3 a M H T e p e C O B a H O . n 0 ~ 0 6 ~ b l fcnoc06i@ O P M Y J I M P O B ~ H M R AMClT03MqMMl T 0 0 q p ~ ~ e J I b ~ HOPMbIofiMClTPaBMTeJIbHO-TPYAOBOrO l T p a B a B l T o J I ~ 0 f im.A....M e p e OTBe9aeT ~ T O T ~ ~ ~ H O C TlTPaKTMKMHMlTpaBOBOr0 PeryJIMpOBaHMRMClTOJIHeHMR YrOJIOBHOrO H a K a 3 a H M R , A e J I a e T er0 AOCTaTO9HO I ' M ~ K o ~ ~ ,n 0 3 B O J I R e T J I y 9 U I e Y 9 M T b I B a T b MHAMBMAYaJIbHMe O C O ~ ~ H H O C T MJIM9HOCTM O C Y X ~ ~ H H O ~ O ) > .