Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Клинико-психологические особенности несовершеннолетних, осужденных за насильственные преступления сексуального характера)

1OT3biBol~JuquaJi~BoroonnoueuTa ua ~uccepTaquouuyro pa6oryBapTaHHH raHH3 ApmaJiyHCOBHbl«KJIHHHKO-DCHXOJIOruqeCKHe oco6eHHOCTH HeCOBepmeHHOJieTHii'X, ocy~eHHbiX3a uacHJibCT.B_enubie npecrynJienuH ceKcyaJibHoro xapaKTepa)),npe~cTaBJieuuoii ua coucKauue yqeuoii cTeneuu Kau~u~aTa ncuxoJioruqecKuxuayK no cnequaJibHOCTH 19.00.04- Me~uquucKaH ncuxoJiornH.LJ:weeepTaiJ;HOHHOe[.A.HeeJie,ll;OBaHHeBapTaiDIHMH,ll;HBH,ll;YaJibHO-IIeHXOJIOrwieeKHX, JIHqHOeTHbiX HrroeBHI:o;eHOaHaJIH3YIIOBe,n;eHqeeKHX xapaKTepHeTMKHeeoBeprneHHOJieTHHX, Oe)')K,ll;eHHbiX 3a HaeHJiheTBeHHhie rrpeeryrrJieHHH eeKeyaJI:OHOrOxapaKTepa.AKryaJI:OHOeTb TeMbl HeeJie,ll;OBaHMH He Bbl3biBaeT eOMHeHHM M orrpe,n;eJIHeTeH, BOrrepBbiX,He,n;oeTaTOqHbiMrreHXOJIOrMqeeKHeHKOJIMqeeTBOMllOBe,n;eHqeeKHeHeeJie,l(OBaHHM,oeo6eHHOeTHpaeeMarpHBaiOI:o;HXHeeOBeprneHHOJieTHHXrrpeeTyTIHMKOB, B TOM qJ1eJie B KOHTeKeTe ITeHXOJIOrM"lfeeKMX aerreKTOB eOBeprneHHOrO,n;eJIMKTa M HX B3aMMOCBH3eM Me)l():{y eo6o:H: M e ,n:eTeKo-po,n:MTeJibeKMMH OTHOIIIeHHHMM.Bo-BTOp:oix,rrorpe6HoeTHMH( KpHMHHOJIOrHqeeKOM,:u;enoropH.n;arreHXOJIOrMqeeKOM,rrpo<PeeewoHaJI:OH:OIXeeKeOJIOrM"lfeeKOM,rrpaKTMKTieMXMarpM"lfeeKOM ),rroeKOJI:Oey, e O,ll;HOM eTOpOHhi, y,n:eJI:OHbiM Bee rrpeeryrrneHHM eeKeyan:oHoro xapaKTepa,eoBeprnaeMbiX rro,n:poeTKaMH, B :o;eJIOM He eHIDKaeTeH B TeqeHHe pH,n;a JieT; e ,n;pyro:H:eTopoH:oi, - B rroene,n:Hwe ro,n::oi rrpow3ornen poeT qMena rrpeeryrrneHw:H:, eoBeprnaeM:oixrro.n:poeTKaMH B oTHOIIIeHHH ,n:eTe:H: eBoero nona.Ba:>KHOOTMeTMTbTaiOKe,qTOBeoBpeMeHHOMMe,ll;H:o;MHeKOMrreHXOJIOrHHHe,n:oeTaTOqHo rrpe,n;eTaBJieHhl pe3yJI:OTaTDI eorroeTaBJieHHH ,n;aHHOM rpyrrrrDI TIO,ll;pOeTKOBe rro,n:poeTKaMH-ITpaBOHapyiiiMTeJIHMM, eOBepiiiHBIIIHMM ,n:pyrwe BH)l;hl rrpeeryrrneHMMpa3HOM eTeTieHM TH:>KeeTM M e rrpaBOTIOeJIYIIIHbiMH rro,n:poeTKaMH.3HaHMe ,n:aHHbiXoeo6eHHOeTeM TI03BOJIHT 6orree TOqHo pa3pa6aT:OIBaTb rrporpaMMbl rreHXOJIOrMqeeKOMITOMOI:o;M TIO,l(pOeTKaM e ,n:eJIMHKBeHTHbiM llOBe,n;eHHeM.2TaKHMo6pa30M,HaYLJHbiaHHTepec,rrpmmneHHbiH,n;HccepTaHTOMKaHOMallbHOM)' CeKcyfuiBHOMY IIOBe,lJ;eHHIO HeCOBeprneHHOlleTHHX, OTBeqaeT Bbi30BaMCOBpeMeHHOH )I(H3HH, a)l;HCCepTa~HOHHOe HCClle)J;OBaHHe 5.1Bll5.1eTC5.1 aKryanhHbiM HCBOeBpeMeHHbiM.B~eHrp,n;HccepTa~HOHHOfOKOMIIlleKCHOeHCClle,lJ;OBaHHer .A.HCCne,n;oBaHH5.1BapTaHHHKnHHHKO-IICHXOllOfHqecKHXIIOllO)I(eHoOC06eHHOCTeHHeCOBeprneHHOneTHHX, ocyiK,n;eHHbiX 3a HaCHllbCTBeHHbie rrpecryrrneHH5.1 ceKcyanbHOfOXapaKTepa,HXCOIIOCTaBneHHeCOC06eHHOCT5.1MH,n;pyrHXrpyrrrrIIO,I1;pOCTKOBCKpHMHHallbHbiM aHaMHe30M H rrpaBOIIOCllYIIIHbiX IIO,ll;pOCTKOB, a TaKiKe Bbi5.1BlleHHeB3aHMOCB5.13HocyiK,n;eHHbiXKllHHHKO-IICHXOllOflfqeCKHX3aHacHnbCTBeHHbieoco6eHHOCTeHrrpeczyrrneHH5.1HeCOBeprneHHOlleTHHX,ceKcyanhHoroxapaKTepa,cxapaKTepoM ,n;eTCKO-pO,I1;HTellbCKHX OTHOIIIeHHH B HX CeMb5.1X H IICHXOllOflfqeCKHMHacrreKTaMH COBeprneHHOfO ,n;enHKTa.Hcxo,n;H H3 :noro, ,n;HccepTaHTOM orrpe,n;eneHa ~enh Hccne,n;oBaHHH KllHHHKO-IICHXOllOflfqeCKHXHaCHllbCTBeHHbieoco6eHHOCTeHrrpecryrrneHH5.1HeCOBeprneHHOneTHHX,CeKcyanhHOfOxapaKTepa,BH3YLJeHHeocyiK,n;eHHbiXCOIIOCTaBneHHH3aCoco6eHHOCTHMH rto,n;pOCTKOB, ocyiK,n;eHHbiX 3a ,n;pyrHe BH,ll;bl rrpecryrrneHHH pa3HOHCTeiieHH TH)I(eCTH, H rrpaBOIIOCnyiiiHbiX IIO,I1;pOCTKOB.ITonoiKeHHH,BbiHOCHMbie3a~zy,HaorpaiKaiDTHaYLJHYIDHOBH3Hy,TeopeTHqeCKyiD H rrpaKTHqecKyiD 3HaqHMOCTb )J;HCCepTa~HOHHOH pa60Tbl, HanHqHeKOTOpbiX B)J;HCCepTa~HOHHOMHCClle,lJ;OBaHHH HeCOMHeHHO.ITepexoM K aHanH3Y pa6oTbi, cne,n;yeT cpa3y OTMeTHTb, qTo oHa BbiiiOnHeHaTIIJ;aTellbHO,co,n;epiKaHHe rrpo,n;yMaHO,Co,n;epiKaHHe rrepBoii rnaBbi,COCTOHHHerrpo6neMbi;qeTKO opraHH30BaHO H llOfHqHo H3llO)I(eHO.B KOTopo:H: BcecTopoHHe paccMorpeHbi coBpeMeHHoeOCHOBHbieKllHHHKO-IICHXOllOflfqeCKHeoco6eHHOCTHocyiK,n;eHHbiX IIO,ll;pOCTKOB; $aKTOpbi, Bll.H:HIOIIJ;He Ha $opMHpOBaHHe H IIpOHBlleHHe,n;eBHaHTHOfO IIOBe,n;eHHH HeCOBeprneHHOneTHHX; IIpHqHHbl H <}laKTOpbi <}lopMHpOBaHHHfOMOCeKcyanbHOCTHHrre,n;o<}lHllHH;OC06eHHOCTHIIOllOBOfOCaMOC03HaH.H:HIIO,I1;pOCTKOB, COBepiiiHBIIIHX HaCHllbCTBeHHbie rrpecTyrrneHHH CeKcyanbHOfO xapaKTepa,M,lJ;eTCKO-pO,lJ;HTellbCKHXOTHOIIIeHHHBHXCeMbHX,CBH,lJ;eTellbCTByeT0IIIHpOTe3Ha~Horo Kpyro3opa aBTOpa I1 rrpaBOMepHOCTH HCXO,ll;HhiX IIOJIO')I(eHHM ,ll;HCCepTaHTa 0Heo6XO,ll;HMOCTH KOMIIiieKCHOrOIICHXOJIOrWieCKHXI13~eHIDI.

OC06eHHOCTeMKJIHHHKO,- HH,ll;HBH,ll;yaJihHO,- I1 COI.:t;HaJihHO-rro,n:pOCTKOB,COBepiiiHBIIIHXHaCHJihCTBeHHhierrpeczyrrJieHH51 ceKcyaJihHoro xapaKTepa.BTopa51CO,n:ep')I(HTrJiaBa uocB51:£neHa MeTo,n:oJiorwrecKOMY o6ocHoBaHHIO pa6oThi.xapaKTepHCTHKHBbi60pKH,MeTO,L(HqeCKOrOKOMIIJieKCa,0Ha3TaiiOBHopraHH3aQHH IICHXO,L(HarHOCTH't:leCKOrO HCCJie,n:oBaHIDI.CJie,n:yeT OTMeTHTh, qTo HCIIOJih30BaHHhiM aBTOpOM MeTO,n:HqecKHM KOMIIJieKC,BKJIIOqaiOm;HM KJIHHHKO-IICHXOJIOrH't:leCKYIO ,n:HarHOCTHKY I1 IICHXO,n:HarHOCTHqecKHMrraKeT MeTO,ll;HK, a6COJIIOTHO rrpaBOMepeH ,L(JI51 peiiieHH51 3a,n:aq, IIOCTaBJieHHhiX aBTOpOMIIpH rrpoBe)J.eHMH 3MIIHpHqecKoro HCCJie,n:oBaHI151, OH II03BOJI51eT BCeCTOpOHHeKJIHHHKO-IICHXOJIOrH't:leCKHeHacHJihCTBeHHhieOC06eHHOCTHrrpeczyrrrreHI151HeCOBepiiieHHOJieTHHX,ceKCYaJihHoroxapaKTepa,I13~I1ThOCy')I()J.eHHhiX3arrpoBeCTHHX11cpaBHHTeJibHhiM aHaJIH3 C oco6eHHOCT51MH IIO)J.pOCTKOB, OCy')l(,n:eHHhiX 3a ,n:pyrHe BH)J.hlrrpeczyrrJieHHM pa3HOM cTerreHH T5:[')1(eCTH, a TaK')I(e rrpaBorrocrryiiiHhiX rro,n:pocTKOB.KaqeCTBeHeCOMHeHHhiX,ll;OCTOHHCTB)J.aHHOrOKOMIIJieKcaCJie,n:yeTOTMeTHThBeroHeCOMHeHHyiO rrpaKTHqecKyiO 3HaqHMOCTh, IIOCKOJihKY OH MO')I(eT 6hiTh HCIIOJih30BaHCIIei.:t;HaJIHCTaMH B o6JiaCTH Me)J.MI.:t;HHCKOM I1 IOpH,n:HqecKOM IICHXOJIOrHH, B KJIHHHKeIIO)J.pOCTKOBOMrrorpaHMqHOMIICHXHaTpHH,BCHCTeMerrpo<iJecCHOHaJihHOroo6pa30BaHH51 I1 IIOBhiiiieHI151 KBaJIH<iJHKaUHH pa60THHKOB IIpo<iJecCHOHaJihHhiX CJIY)I(6 HCHJIOBhiX Be)J.OMCTB.TpeThiOrrraBy,IICHXOJIOrHqeCKOrOHBKOTOpOHcpaBHHTeJihHOrOOIIHChiBaiOTC51KJIHHHKO-IICHXO,L(HarHOCTHqecKOrOHCCJie)J.OBaHI151,xoqeTC51 OTMeTHTh OT,n:eJibHO.Tm;aTeJihHhiM 11 rro,n:po6HhiM aHaJIH3 pe3yJihTaTOB Ha Bcex 3Tarrax rrpoBe,n:eHI1513MIII1pH't:leCKOrOHCCJie,n:oBaHH51,CHCIIOJib30BaHHeMo60CHOBaHHhiXMeTO,ll;OBMaTeMaTHqecKOM CTaTHCTHKH I1 cpaBHHTeJibHOrO KJIHHHKO-IICHXOJIOrH't:leCKOrO aHaJIH3a,rro3BOJI5IeTyTBep')I()J.aTh,qTorro~eHHhiey6e)J.HTeJihHhiMH I1 ,ll;OCTOBepHbiMH.pe3yrrhTaThi51BJI5IIOTC51.uocTaToqHo4)::l:aHHbie, TIOJiyqeHHhie B pe3yJioTaTe KOppeiDII.I,HOHHOfOaHaJIH3a, TI03BOIDUOTaBTopy, Bo-nepBbix, Bbi~BHTh HMeiDII.I,Hec51 B3aHMOCB513H, BO-BTOphiX, nocTPOHTh cxeMyB3aHMOCB513eH TICHXOJIOfHtleCKHX OC06eHHOCTeH HeCOBeprneHHOJieTHHX, OCY)J(,ll,eHHbiX3anpeczynJieHH51CeKCYaJibHOfOxapaKTepa,CTICHXOJIOfH"tleCKHMHacneKTaMHCOBeprneHHOfO ,l.I,eJIHK~a H xapaKTepOM ,ll,eTCKO-pO,ll,HTeJibCKHX OTHOilleHHH.Boi51BJieHHa51 aBTopoM TpHa,l.I,a B3aHMOCB513eH (B3aHMOOTHorneHH51 no,l.I,pocTKOB cOTI.I,aMH,3TIHJieTITOH,ll,HbiHTHTIr.A.caMOC03HaHH51) TI03BOJI51eTo6ycJIOBJieHHOCTH3TIHJieTITOH,ll,HbiMaKI.I,eHzyai.I,HHHHapyrneHH51TIOJIOBOfOBapTaH51H ,l.I,OCTaTO"llHO y6e,ll,HTeJibHO rOBOpHTb o6npOTHBOTipaBHOfOTHTIOMxapaKTepaaKI.I,eHTyai.I,HHCeKCYaJibHOfOxapaKTepa,TIOBe):.1,eHH51TIO,l.I,pOCTKOBHapyrueHH51MHTIOJIOBOfOCaMOC03HaHH51 H ,ll,eTCKO-pO,ll,HTeJibCKHX OTHOilleHHH, HrpalOII.I,HX Be,l.I,yii.J,ylO pOJib.Onpe,l.I,eJieHHa51 ,l.I,HccepTaHTOM coBoKynHOCTh B3aHMO,l.I,OTIOJIH51lOII.I,HX KJIHHHKOncHxonorH"tJ:eCKHX H TICHXO,l.I,HarHOCTH"lleCKHX MeTO,l.I,HK, HaH60Jiee peJieBaHTHhlX ):.1,1151H3Y"tJ:eHH51TICHXOJIOfHtieCKHXoco6eHHOCTeHTIO,l.I,pOCTKOB,OCY)J(,ll,eHHbiX3aHaCHJibCTBeHHbie npecTyTIJieHH51 CeKCYaJibHOfO XapaKTepa, TI03BOJIHJia HHTerpHpOBaTbTIOJIY"tJ:eHHhie,ll,aHHbieBTICHXOJIOfH"tJ:eCKYJOxapaKTepHCTHKYTIO,l.I,pOCTKOB,COBeplliHBillHX CeKCYaJibHhie npeczynneHH51, BKJIIO"llalOII.J,ylO B ce651 CJie,l.I,ylOII.I,He 6JIOKH:COI.I,HaJibHO-CeMeHHYJO CHzyai.I,HlO, OC06eHHOCTH COBeprneHHOfO ,l.I,eJIHKTa H ,ll,eTCKOOTHOilleHHH,pO,ll,HTeJibCKHXKOMMYHHKaTHBHhieoco6eHHOCTH,oco6eHHOCTHcaMOC03HaHH51.HecoMHeHHO,Ha3BaHHbiX 6JIOKOB BKa"tJ:eCTBa,3MOI.I,HOHaJibHO-BOJieBOHTeXHonorn"lleCKHxapaKTepOJIOfH"tJ:eCKHeccpepblonpaB,l.I,aHHO,ll,HC<jlyHKI.I,HOHaJibHbiH KOMTIJieKCHcBe,l.I,eHHeTIOJIOBOfOaBTopoMKJIHHHKO-TICHXOJIOfH"tJ:eCKHXOC06eHHOCTeH HeCOBeprueHHOJieTHHX, OCY)J(,ll,eHHbiX 3a HaCHJibCTBeHHhie npecTynJieHH51ceKCYaJibHOfOxapaKTepa,KpHMHHaJibHhiMaHaMHe30MOTJIHtialOII.I,HXHHXOT,l.I,pyrHXnpaBOTIOCJIYillHbiXrpynnTIO,l.I,pOCTKOB.TIO,l.I,pOCTKOBCTipe,l.I,CTaBJieHHhiHKOMTIJieKC B COBOKynHOCTH C TICHXOJIOfHtieCKHMH acneKTaMH COBeprueHHOfO ,l.I,eJIHKTaII03BOJIHJIr .A.BapTaH51H Bbl,l.I,eJIHTb ,l.I,Ba THTia HeCOBeprneHHOJieTHHX, ocy)J(,ll,eHHbiX 3aHaCHJibCTBeHHbie«rr o ,l.I,aBJI51IDII.I,HX».npeczynneHH51ceKCYaJibHOfOxapaKTepa:«nepBepCHBHhiX»H5B 3TOH CB.SI3H CJie,n;yeT OTMeTHTb rrpo.zzyMaHHhiH IIO,LJ;XO,D; aBTOpa K HCIIOJih3yeMOHTepMHHOJIOrHHH;:i6-eraT0'4:HOy6e,LJ;HTeJibHOe060CHOBaHHeBBO,[(HMbiXaBTOpOMTepMHHOB.lJeTBepTaSIHCCJie,D;OBaHH5IrJiaBaHOTe'4:eCTBeHHhiXIIOCB51II1;eHa06C)')K,LJ;eHHIOHX .