Отзыв официального оппонента (Особенности синтеза и электронной структуры графена на подложках на основе d- и f- металлов)

OT3hIB O<I>IIIJJIAJihHOro OIIIIOHEHTAmt w 1ccep Ta t.1,H10 CT yLLHK OBa )J,MvrrpH51 AneKcaHnpoBH.Lra « 0co6eHHOCTH cirnTe3a H 3Jre 1npo 1-11-1 oi1crpy 1nyp b1 rpaclle1-ia Ha no.iv1m1<Kax Ha ocaoBecl-11f-MeTanJIOB », npencTaBne1rny10 HaCOHCKaH11e yc1eHOH CTener-rn KaH,D,H,D,aTa cp11311KO-MaTeMaTHY:eCKHX aayKn o c rr eu: 11anbHOCTl101.04.07 - cp113HI<a KOH,D,eHCHpoBaHJ-!OfO COCT051HH5!.BHaCT05!w,eespeM5! rpacpe1-1B c11nynp11cy11.J,11x eMy yHHKanhHbIX 3J1ewrpo1-1HbIX11CBOHCTB, nopO)l()J,el-JHb!X ero ,D,ByMep t-lOH npHpO,D,OH , paccMaTpirnaeTC5! B MHpOBOH aayKe l<aKH3H6on ee n e pcneKTHBHbIH nonynpOBO)J,HHKOBbIH MaTepHan, opHeHTHpOBaHHblH Ha C03)J,aI-IHecsepx6b 1CT p onel-1cTsyrou.lHX3ne 1npom -rh1xycTpOHCTB.0,D,HaI<oyHHKanbHbIMHcBoi1cTBaM11o6nanaeT TOJlbKO MOJ-10Kj)HCTM J111LieC!<HH rpacpeH B CB060,D,HOM COCT05!Hl1l1; np11 Bblpaw, 1rna1-IHHHarl O)lJl Q)l<KeemCBOi1c·rnacyw,eCTBe HHOMO,D,11cp11L.1,11pyeTC513aB.3ne1npo1-11-1oj;'1 no,nc11cTeMoj;'1 l1 KpHcTan11.Hcrec1<11M noneM no,D,JIO)I<Irn.3Jle l<Tj)OHl-lblXl1cjlH3HKO - XHMHLieCI<l1XCBOHCTBrpacpeHa,ccreTB3al1MOLI,eHCTBH51CCB513 H c 3THM H3yt.Je1rneBbipaw:eHHOroHa110.[1,JlQ)KKaxc11 eco p a3 M e p1-wl-1 c 1-!HM Kj)l1CTMJ1HY:eCKOH CTpyr<Typoli 11J1I1 MMOH3yqeHHbIMl1 rrepcneKTHBl-lbIMHMeTOLI,aMvl , T3K HMH KaK MeTOA cerperau:m1 yrnepo.ua CKB03b CJlOH rrepeXO.Ll,HbIX MeTannos 11Jll1'-1 e p e3 tjla3y Kap 6 HLI,Yl 3alll1H CJIOeB pe,.QK03eMeJibHbIX MeTanJlOB, npe.ucTaBJl51eTC51 HHTepeCHOH BJ-Jayc11-10M H Ba)K l-JOH 8 npaKn1'-!eCKOM nnaHe 3a,D,aY:eH .A1cryaJlLHOCTh TCMLI)J,Hcceprnu:110HJ-JOe Hccne.uosam1e fly,D,11K0Ba )J,.A.

nocB51W:eHo pernemuo ar<TyanbHOH 11npa 1nv1c1ec 1rn Bm1<1-10!1 3a,D,acr11 no H3y11em110 MexaHH3MOB Cl1HTe3a rpacpeHa MeTO,D,OM CVD aa1-1 eco pa3Me p1-101'1T0111rneCJJOHivteTanJIOB,acrpacll eHOMrrepexom-1b1xTCl iOKerpar-111 1-111Ken51 ( 100) , MeTO,D,OM cerperau,1111(N i,1nyc1e HHJOCo)Hc1epe33JleKTpOHHblXyrnepo,D,a CKB03b1<ap6H,D,H3au,11ro pe,nKo3eMeJibHbJXCBOHCTBrpacpe1-1aHa BCex(G el ,CTa,QH51XDy)pocTa.K%J1 1oc1esbIM soncpocoM npaKTH'-!ec1<0ro npHMeaemrn rpacpeHa 5!Bm1eTC5I coxpa1-1e1-111e HM csol-1y 1-JH1<aJl bHOM3JleKTj)OHHOH1-taH03J1e 1npoHHh1eCTpyKTYPhl,nprr6opbI11LITO.uaeT B03M0)I<HOCTbm -1e.up5!Tb3TOTMaTepHanC03.[l,aBaTbBHa erorrpoH3BO,D,CTBO.OCHOBeITo3TOMYu.eJ1e 1-1a npaBJte 1-nwe H3yYeH11e BJJH51Hl151 THDa IIO)J,JIO)I<l<YI, a TaK)I<e H3y11eHH5l HOBblX MeTOLLOB01 1-rre3arpacpe1:-1asm1< 1-10,H opHe 1-1T11pyeT pocc11i1cKy1D aayKy1-1.a onepe)1<a1ow,ee pa3BHTHeJ-JaH6onee aKTYMb l-lblX 1-rnnpaBJJe HHH HaH03JleKTpOHHKl1.BCB513H c 3 TMM .D,11ccepTau1101-1.Ha51 pa6oTa fly,D,111<0Ba )J, .A.

BeCbMa arnyanhHa, rrocKOJlbKYn OCB51LU,eHa c paBHHTeJlbHOMY 3I<Cnep11MeHTMbHOMY H3yY:eHHID MeTO)J,OB CI1HTe3a rpacpe1-rn Han ow 10>KK ax, npe,D,cTaBJ1mow:11x co6oi1 MOHOKpHCTMJlbI HJlH nJleHKHcl-Hf-MeTannos. Oco6oe13 1-JvJ MaJ-lvJe y,nem1eTC)l HCCJJe,.QOl33 1-ll·ll O 3Jle JCT]JO HHOH CTpyKTY[Jhl CHHTe311]JOBaHHOro rpatpe 1-1a , aTaJOKe ee MO,.QHq)HJ<all,MH npH l10MOUJ,H Hl-!TepK3Jl5lL.l,HH aTOMOB 6narop0,1J,1-IOI'O MeTanJla 30JIOT3 B11poc-rpa1-1crno Me)KLLY rp atjl e 1-10M H 11 0,nn0>1<Koi1.)l,o cTOBCpl-IOCTbHCrIOJJ b30BaI-JHeMHaycrnhIXKOMnJieKCaIIOJIQ)J<eHHtlcaMbIXHBbIBO)J,OBCOBpeMeHI-IbIX)J,HCCepTaUHHIIO)J,TBep)I<)J,aeTC5!3KCrrepHMeHTMbHbIXMeTO.UOBcj)OT03ne 1crpo H1-1 0/;l cneKTpocKon11H , peaninyeMbIX B HOBei1urnx ycTaHOBr<ax HayYHoro ITapKaCa1 1KT- rl eTep6yprCKoro1-uny LJ e 11v1 )1BESSY -I I (r.rocy.D,apcrne1-11-1 oroy1-111Bepc11Tern11Ue1-1Tpac111-1xp0Tpo1-11-1oroEepnH1-1).

pa6oToI1 B cnepxnb1co1<osaKyyMHbIX ycJIOBH5IX 1-1a aTOMHO-LIY!CTbl Xno13epx1-1ocnx ,11 e 11 ocpe;J,CTl3e l-IH O13Bb1pa UJ.MBa1-1MeMBbl COKOM11xapaicre p113a u,11eifBaI<yyMe ,nnettOL!Hbl X130Cilp0113130)J,11MOCTbl0cTpywryp3 KCnepMMewraJ1bl-Jbl Xpe3ynr>raTOB, rpaMOT l-ff>TM COOTHecemieM p e3yJlbTaTOB c mnepaTypHbIM11 JJ,aHHblMl1.BJJ, Hcceprnu,11Huarrn own onr1e1-1b1 cne,lJ,y•omHe pe3ynbTaTbI, x apaKTep11 3yFom11eo1llOBlfl llOH:I.l lo,lJ,o6 paH h l o n n 1Marrbr-1b1e napaMeTpbI 11 ocymecrnne1-1 Cl1HTe3 rpatpeHa MeTOJJ,O MCV D Ha n o,lJ,JlO)!me,QeTanb HON i ( I 00) ,r.n yy:eabI11 pol3eJJ,e1-101<p11cTaJTJ1111-Iecr<a5IcpaB 1-1 ea11e cvl CCJICf l Ol3a l-!MeHMeIOmea aecop a3Mepay10 eMy Kp11cTanJT11Y:ecKy10 cTpyI<Typy.H3JTeKTpOHHM113y'-IeHHbIM p a aeeM3Me 1-1e HMHcTpyKTyparroITyY:eHttororpacpeHOM Ha rro,n;JTmr<Ke,[(MCnepC MOHI-JblX3aBHCl1MOCTeHI1Ni(l l l ).rpatll e r-ia,ITpoBeJJ,e 1-10)J,11tppaKUI10HI-lblXJ<a jJTl1l-I ,13bl 3 1Ja1-111 bl X 1'Jl-f'rep 1<arn1u11ei:1 MO HOCJI 051 aTOl'vlOB 30JJOTa.2.P a3 p a60Ta 1-1 11 11cn oJJh30 Ba1·1 MeTO,lJ, cm-1Te3a rpacpeHa , oc1-10BaHHblH Ha MexaHH 3 Mecer perauv1H aTOMOB yrne po.l1,a L1 ep e3 CJIOH n ep exo.n;ttoro MeTaJTJla, HaaeceHHbIH Ha rpatjrnT0By10flOLl,JlO)[(J(y,3 Kcnep11MeI-!TaJJbHO 113y Y:eHbl 3aI<OHOMepHOCTI1..napaMeTpos CH HTe3a OT 11crronb3yeMoro MeTaJina (NiCI1HTe3a, IIOJiy'-IeHa 3aBHCl1MOCTb11n11Co)HT11naoo.nnm1<K11(1\Jo1101<p HCTaJ1J111Y ec 1<J.·1i1 11 sr11 n11pos111 T 11':1 ec 1mi1 rpacp11T).

IToKa3aHo , YTO op11 11cnoJJb30 sa 1-11111I IJJe ll J\111<06an bTa.1-J a1-1ece1-LJ-J OHIJblCOKOy nopJ!)J,OLl e HHblHc 11JJbHOi1 CB5l3bIO cI-ta MO l-10Kp11CTaJIJIHY:eCKl1HrpacpeHc)J,OMeHaMHrpacp11T ,60JlblliOHMO)KHOIIJlOlll,aJJ,11,C11HTe3 11 poBaTbxapaKTep113y1om11J1c51rrneHKOH K06aJTbTa.

IT0M11Mo 3Toro , rro.n; rpacpeH 6brn 11HTepKM11poBaHMO J-J OCJlO H aTOMOB 30JlOTa, '-!TO np1rneno [( C)J,BHry TO'-IKH ,Il;HpaKa B I-IarrpaBnemrn K ypo~H.10Cj)epM 11 ' '-!TO MO)l(J-10 TpaKTOBff[b I<aK nony':leH11e KB a3I1CB060JJ,HbIH: rpacpeHa.·3.3 1< c nep11Me 1naJl bHOJJHCjHjJy3Mvl yrnepoLI,a11 3y l.f e l-lMeXal-!Yl3MCl1HTe3arpacpe1-Ia,OCHOBaHHbl Hc1epe3 CJ10H pe,iU<03eMeJJbl-lbl X MeTaJ1JJOB, HaHeCeHT-lbl XHaI-ta rpacjrnTOBbJe110L1.s1m 1<KM.

c o.n 1-1 013peMe 1-1J-J oi:1 Ka p 6 11 ,i:t11 3aq11ei:1 3TMX cnoeB. IT01<a3ai-10, LJTO BHe 3aB11c11MocT11 OT1<0 111< peT1-1 oro f-Menurna(Gel , Dy)cpopMHpOBam1e r pacpeHa rrpo11cxo.n;HT CXO)I<J1M o6pa3oM: op11TeM n e p aTypax oT>rmra ,lJ,O 900 -10 00 ° CTeM 11 epaTypax nops1 .nKaI 000 -1 I 00 ° CcnotlMeTaJTna rrpespaw:aeTC5I B Kap611,lJ,, 11 TOJlbKO rrpvicp o pM11pyeTC 5l rpacpeH. BcocT05! 1-1v1i:1 1-pacl)e 1-ia 11Me11a 11 111-1ei:1H h lH xapa KTep B 06nacT11 TO LJKH)Ke 13peM51 TOLJI<a ,Il;11pa1<a 6hJJJa CMew:e1-1a[-la1-206011x CJTyYa51x n 11cnepc11nK 30HblnJ3p11nmo3 1-ia, HO 13 TO3B OT ypoBH51 <DepM11 , 'ITO MO)Kl-IO 11p11n11caTbn epe 1-10cy 3ap sr,lJ,a c n o.nnmKKM Ha rpa(peH.11pal<:THLICCKan 3H3 1HIMOCTb pa60Tbl OCHOBaHa Ha TOM, '-ITO 11CCJTeJJ,OBaHHbl e MeTO,llblCM J-1 Te3aHarrne m <ax130CnpOH3130Ll,11M bl Ml1 ,p ac npoc-rpa 1-1e1-1Hb1i:1YIMeTaJ1J10B ,1-IaH eceI-IHblXrJ OTe J-!L(l1 aJlbH OMeTo.nC VD.0 1-1.H6oneeHarpacp11T,npOCTbIMHMoryT6bITbB51BJT5!lOTC511-Ja,lJ,e)KJ-[ b fMl1 ,pearri-f3au1111 ,11cooJTb30BaHblJJ,n51YeMW11j)OKOnpoMbrw11 e H1-1oron pOH 3 130,lJ,CTBa rp acpeHOBbl X ycTp OHCTl3 , fJ OCKOJlbKY OTHOCHTeJ1bHO .[l,e wesbt 11 JJ,OCTym-1bl )J,Jl51MaccoBoro11cooJ1b30 Bamrn.11 ecopa3Mep 1-1o i:1Hf te as1b1-1 ocT 11noI1ccs1eJJ,0Bmrneon-1owe1-11110copa3Me p1-1b1xKrpa 1-1 ei:1CI1HTe3ar pacpeHy,nmarpacpeHano3BOn5IeTN i( l11 ) ,rrp11Ha11xN i(lOO),rroBepx1-1ocT11apryMeHTHpoBaTbTpe60Batt115!MCIIOJTb30Ba1-11111BKJ<aLteCTJ3e11 0 ,i:tnm1<e1<.Ouemrn coJJ,ep1KaHttn JJ,ttccepTauwwBo BBeJJ,e1urn 06oc1-10BbIBaeTc5! ar<TyaJTbHOCTb ,cpopMyIIHpymTc5Iuenb,ll MCCepTa JJ MOJ-11-l OH pa60Tbl , OTIHCblBaIOTC5I o6J,eKTbI 11 npe,n;MeT I1CCJleJJ,OBaHH5I,113aJJ,a 411np11130.[1,51TC51v1c nonb30l3a 1-1Hb 1eMeTO.l:i:bl.B) lH CC epTa u,11 11 .

BblH OC l1M bl eHeMTaior<eccpopMy1u1poBaHhIHa 3a u.1_1-1Ty, OIU!CbIBaIDTC.51 HocHOBHbienoJIO)Ke1-11151I<paTI<O o6ocI-IOBbIBaFOTC51 l-JaY4Ha51HOl3 H3 H8 11 11paKrw1ec1<a51 3 HaLIH MOCTb p e3yJibTaTOB HCCJie)J:OBaI·THM , coo6matDTC51 naHHble 06 l1Xan p o 6a uM kl H 0 JI WIH OM Bl<JJ a.ne 8 13TO pa.Bn e p Bo iim aneco 11 c 1<aTeneM11poaHan113 11pouaHaHay<-11-rn.51JIHTepaTypa110TeMeMCC JJ e;.:1,0sa1-11151 11 np1rneneHbl pe3 yJibTaTbl HeKOTOpbIX TeopenP-IeCKHX H 3KCnepHMeHTaJibHblXpa6o T .naiom11xo6meenpencTa1rneHHe06ofrbeKTax11ccne,noBaH115I:Kp11cTaJIJIHL1ecr<otiH) J!e l<T j)OHH OH CTJJ YT<Type 11n ean&Horo rpacpeHOBOro CJI0.51; MeTonax CHHTe3a rpacpetta , B TOML1H CJ1eCVDH MeTonax , oc 11 osa1-11-1.

b1e Ha npouecce cerperau1111 aTOMOB yrnepona 113 o6beMaMeT aJ1na: Tex 11111<a HH Te p1< e:ui v1p o Ba 1-1v151 6 na ropon H&Ix MeTaJIJIOB 11 conyrcrsyFOm11e H3Me1-1eHH5! s·.r n e 1npo 1-1 1-10J;'1CTpy 1cry p er p acl)e1-1a .):lena10Tc5!BhIBOJJ.hI06aKTyan&HOCTl1HanpaBJ1e1-11151,06oc1-I Ol3bl naJOT CH KOHI<peTHbl e Han pasJieHH51 HCCJie)J:OBaHHH .Bo B T opou rsrnBe H 3Jimr<e HbI MeTO.lJ:J.Fiecr<He acner<TbI pa60Tbr: np11BeneHo 01111ca1-111eMeTonatj)OT0 3Jl e rcrp o 1-IHOHcnel<TpOCKOTIHl1 ,BTOM'!HCJiecyrnOBbIMpa3pewe 1rneM ,11poa 1-1aJ111J H po13a 1-1 xapa1<Tep 11HcpopMau11H , 11onyc1aeMoi1 3THM MeTO,L(OM. IToMHMO 3Toro , on11caHi'vl e T@'Ll LlH Cj) p8 KLlMkl MeLlJJ e HHbl X 3 JJ e l<TpOHOB , l1CTIOJlb3 0BaE-l HbIH aBTOpOM )J.JI51 xapa1<Tep113au1111KpHcT ann H L1ec1<0 1CTp y 1<Ty p hI11 3y 4aeMbIXCHCTeM.ITp1-rneneHbIoco6e1-1HOCTH3 1<c 11 e p11 Me wr an &HbIX y cTaHOBOK, B KOTOpbIX np0Bon11n11cb 11ccnen0Ba1-nu1..

BuenoM MmK.HOCLJ l1TaTb , 4TO aBTOj) I1CllOJib 3 0BaJI Ha116onee COBpeMeHHbie H HHcpopMaTHBHbie HaylfHble MeTO)J:bI,13 OC HOB HOM ane K BaTHbJ e 11 0 CTa BJie HHOH 3 ana"Ie )J:HCCepTaUHH, a TaIOKe nponeMOHCTj)HpOBaJIx opo w ee r!O l·I HMa HH e tj)l13 H Ll eCKOH cyrn HCl10Jlb3 0BaHHblX MeTO)J:OB 3KCnepHMewra.T pcTbnrp acj>e 1-1a .r JiaBa no c B51ll1eHa o n11ca1-1mo 3newrpo1-1ttoi1 11 Kp11cTann11qec1<0Hccl)O j) M HpoBa 1-11-1 oro1<p11cTaJ1JJ HYec1< y10y c J10B 11 51MHHac T pyKTYP Y ·llp11Bene1-1b1TeM 11 ep a T y pHblMN i(l 00),n onnmrmep e )KHMaMn aHHbre,11Me10metlOTHOC5IIIIHec51npoBe,neHtt51CHHTe3a.I<cTpy1<Typb11-1ecopa3 MepHyTOCVD,Kna1-1Hb1eonpouenypeITpencTaBJieHbIBJJ H51HHl1 HH Te p KaJJ HUHH 6n a ropom 1oro M eTaJIJia ( 30JIOTa) B npocT paHCTBO Me)KJJ.Y rpact1eHOM 11H 111<e J1eM .

n p0Bene1-10 c p aB 1-1 e 1-111e HCCJJeL\yeMOH CHC"reMbl c rpacpeHOM , ccpopMHj)OBaHHbTMN i( I I I ),l"IO j lJIO)l( KeBHM e Jo w_ej;j COp a3MepHyfo KpHCTaJIJLHlfeCI<YfO CTpyKTYPY-"ICTB e p T OMLll1lj)([)y3H11aTOMOB11e p eX OL(l·l b lXHarJiaBeom1 c aHy rn epon acMeTO)J:CHHTe3 ar pacpHTOBOMMeTaJl JIOB . ,I.(eTaJibHOrpacpeHa,ITO)J:JIQ)KKHqepe3OCHOBaHHhlHHaHaHeCeHHbleOITHCaI-lbI CTamrn pOCTa rpacpetta,11pouecceHaHeeOT)J:eJibHOeCJIOHBHHMa J-LMey neJ1e 1-10 n poM e)KYT0 4H bl M 3Ta naM . JlpoaHaJIH 3HpOBaH lllHj)OKHM c11eI<Tp o6pa3UOB, B I<OTOj)b[XYJcrl OJlb 3013aJIJ1Cb p a3JJ H4H bl e Tl111bl ( r1Hp OJIH T H4eCl<I1H 11 MOHOKpHCTaJIJLHLJeCK11H) rpaqrnTOBblXn o; (nmKeK 11 p a 3 1-1&1e(N i,Co) M eT aJIJi bT.