Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Особенности синтеза и электронной структуры графена на подложках на основе d- и f- металлов)

OT3LIB ()cf)HIJ:HA.JlhHOrO OllllOHEHTAHa.l(HCCepTaQHOHH)'lOpa6oryIJy.l(HKOBa,l.(MHTpiDIAJieKCaH.l(pOBWia«0co6eHHOCTH CHHTe3a H 3JieKTpOHHoii crpyKTyphi rpa<f>eHa Ha no.l(JIO)I(Kax HaOCHOBed-Hf-MeTaJIJIOB», npe.l(CTaBJieHH)'lO Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTeneHH01.04.07 -KaH.l(H.l(aTa <f>H3HKO-MaTeMaTHqecKHX HayK llO cneQHaJibHOCTH<f>H3HKaKOH.l(eHCHpOBaHHOfO COCTOjJHIDI.,l.(HCCepTaQIDI fly.l(HKOBa ,l.(.A.nccne.l(oaaHHe3JieKrpoHHoiinpe.l(CTaBAAeT COOOH o6nmpHOe 3KCnepHMeHTaJibHOe3HepreTHqecKoiiHKpHCTaJIJIHqecKoiiCTPYKTYPhirpa<f>eH-co.l(ep)l(amnx cnCTeM, nonyqeHHhiX pjJ.l(OM MeTO.l(HK. Mccne.l(oBaHHe .l(eTaneii npoQecca CHHTe3aHoco6eHHOCTeii 3JieKrpOHHOHKpeKHHranponnneHa,aTaK)I(eHcnHHoaoiiCTPYKTYPhiMeTO.l(aMH cerperaQHHrpa<f>eHa,nonyqeHHOroaTOMOB yrnepo.l(aMeTO.l(OMCKB03hnneHKHnepeXO.l(HbiX H Kap6H.l(H3aQHeH CJIOeB pe.l(K03eMeJihHbiX MeTaJIJIOB, paCIIIHpj{eT B03MO)I(H0CTH~ npoH3BO.l(CTBa .l(aHHOro MaTepnana H KOHCTpynpoaaHIDI HaH03JieKrpOHHhiX ycrpoiicTB Haero OCHOBe.

11MeHHO B03M0)1(H0CThlO npHMeHeHIDI llOJiyqeHHbiX pe3yJihTaTOB B llpDH3BO.l(CTBerpa<f>eHa onpe.l(eAAeTCjJ BbiCOK~ 3JITYaJibHOCTb pa60Tbi.,l.(nccepTaHT noCTaBHJI PM aa)I(HhiX Qeneii, .l(OCTH)I(eHHe KOTOpbiX onpe.l(eJIHJIO BhiCOKYIO<l>YH.l(aMeHTaJihHYJOHnpaKTnqecKyiO3HaqHMOCThpa6oThi.Hayquaa uosuJnapa60Thi3aKJIJOqaeTCjJ B TOM, qro 60JihiiiHHCTBO npe.l(CTaBJieHHbiX B )J;HCCepraQHOHHOM HCCJie.l(OBaHHHpe3yJihTaToB nonyqeHa anepBhie :- BnepBhie nccne.l(oBaHa 3JieKrpOHH~ CTpyKTypa rpa<f>eHa, c<f>opMHpoaaHHoro MeTO.l(OMCVD Ha MOHOKpHCTaJIJIJiqecKoii noaepxHOCTHNi(IOO),HMeiOmeii HecopaJMepeyiO eMyKpHCTaJIJIHqecKyiO crpyKTypy. IloKaJaHo, qro 3HepreTnqecKoe noJIO)I(eHHe, a TaK)I(eHCKa)l(eHHe JIHHeHHOro xapaKTepa .l(HCnepCHHnCOCTOjJHIDJ B OKpeCTHOCTH TOqKHKCBH.l(eTeJihCTBYJOT 0 CHJihHOM B3aHMO.l(eHCTBHH Me)I()J;y c<f>opMHpOBaHHhiM rpa<f>eHOM HHHKeJieBOH llO.l(JIO)I(KOH.

TaK)I(e TIOKa3aHO, qro B CJiyqae C HeCOpa3MepHOH TIO.l(JIO)I(KOH,<f>opMHpYJOIQHHCjJ rpa<f>eH HMeeT HeCKOJihKO .l(OMeHOB, TIOBepHYTbiX .l(pyr OTHOCHTeJihHO.l(pyra Ha-30°.BhrnBJieHo, qTo npoQecc HHTepKaAAQHHAuno.l( rpa<f>eH HaNi(lOO)6oJihiiiHX TeMneparypax H apeMeHax 3Kcno3HQHH, qeM no.l( rpa<f>eH HanoKaJaHo, qTo 3JieKrpOHH~ crpyKTypa rpa<f>eHa HaNi(l 00)CJIOeM 30JIOTa ll0.l(06Ha KBa3HCB000.l(HOMY rpa<f>eHy, T.e.OKOJIO8 3BB TOqKernnpoxo.l(HT npHNi(lll).BnepBhiec HHTepKannpoaaHHhiMCOCTOmHe JIOKaJIH30BaHOH HMeeT JIHHeHHYJO .l(HCnepCHIO B6JIH3H ypOBHjJ <l>epMH B TOqKeK30Hhi EpHJIJII03Ha.-flpOBe.l(eHO CHCTeMaTJ~qeCKOe HCCJie.l(OBaHHe CHHTe3a rpa<f>eHa MeTO.l(OM cerperaQHHaTOMOB yrnepo.l(a CKB03b llJieHKH nepeXO.l(HbiX MeTaJIJIOB, npH 3TOM BapbHpOBaJIHChB~hi yrnepO.l(HbiX llOMO)I(eK(BOTir,MOHOKpHCTaJIJIHqeCKHH rpa<f>HT) H MeTaJIJihi(Ni,Co).

IJpe.l(CTaBJieH aHaJIH3 npOQeCca CHHTe3a, TIOKa3aHO, qro <f>opMHpOBaHHe rpa<f>eHa BOBCeX CJI)11I~X npOXO):{HT qepe3 O):{HH H Te )l(e :nallhl. flpHBO,Z:{HTC~ xapaKTepHCTHKa KaKnpoMe)I()'TOqHhiX :nanOB, TaK H KOHeqHOM CTa,Z:{MM CHHTe3a.-flOKa3aHO,qTOnepexo,Z:{HhiX(Ni,CHHTe3rpa<}>eHaMeTO):{OM cerperaQHHyr.rrepO):{aCKB03bll.JieHKMCo) MeTa.rr.rros npoxo):{HT npw TeMnepaTypax nop~):{Ka 250 - 400°C, qTocyi.QeCTBeHHO MeHhiiie, qeM npw MeTO):{e CVD Ha rex )l(e MeTa.rr.rrax.- llOKa3aHO, ~ rpa<}>eH, Bbipai.QeHHbiM MeTO):{OM cerperaQHH CKB03h n.rreHKY K06a.JihTa HallO):{JIO)I(KeMOHOKpHCTa.JIJIHqeCKOrOKpHCTa.JIJIHqecKyiOCTpyKrypy,arpa<}>HTa,HMeeT3Jiei<TpOHHIDIBbiCOKOynop~oqeHHyiOCTpyi<TypaCXO)I(aCrpa<}>eHOM,Bhipai.QeHHhiM MeTO):{OM CVD Ha no,Z:{JIO)I(Ke Co(0001) .

TaK)I(e noKa3aHo, qTQ CHJihH~cB~3h rpa<}>eHa c HH)I(e.Jie)l(al.QHM c.rroeM Co MO)I(eT 6hiTh oc.rra6.rreHa npw nOMOI.QHMHTepK~QHH aTOMOBTOqKHK C):{BHraeTc~Au,npH 3TOM sepiiiHHa KOHyCa 1t COCTO~HMM B OKpeCTHOCTHK ypoBHIO <l>epMH.- Hcc.rre,Z:{OBaH npoQecc CHHTe3a rpa<}>eHa qepe3 Kap6H):{H3aQHIO c.rroes pe):{K03eMe.JihHhiXMeTa.JIJIOB, HaHeCeHHbiX Ha rpa<}>HT.

flOKa3aHO, qTo BHe 3aBMCHMOCTH OT MeTa.JIJia H runarpa<}>HTOBOM llO,Z:{JIO)I(KH <}>opMHpOBaHHe rpa<}>eHa npOXO):{HT qepe3 O):{HH H Te )l(e 3Tallhl.llpO):{eMOHCTpHpOBaHO<l>YH):{aMeHTa.JibHOeOTJIHqM:e):{aHHOroMeTO):{aOTMeTO):{a<}>opMHposaHH~ rpa<}>eHa nocpe):{CTBOM cerperaQHH yr.rrepo):{a qepe3 c.rrou nepexo):{HhiXMeTa.JIJIOB.-llpO):{eMOHCTpHpOBaHO, qTO Ha n.rreHKe Dy, HaHeCeHHOM Ha MOHOKpHCTa.JIJIHqeCKMMrpa<}>HT, <}>opMHpOBaHHC rpa<}>eHa npOHCXO,Z:{HT npH TCMneparype OKOJIO 1 000°C, llOCJiellOJIHOMKap6H):{H3aQHHCJIO~ MeTa.JIJia.fuyqeHa 3JICI<TpOHH~xapaKTepH3YIOI.QIDIC~ JIHHCMHOCThiO 1t COCTO~HHM OKOJIO TQqKM:C):{BHrDMTQqKH,AupaKa):{03HepmifCB~3H1, 83B.CTpyKrypaKrpa<}>eHa,30Hhl JipHJIJII03Ha Hflo.rryqeHaHH<}>OpMa~0paCI.Qen.rreHHH 1t COCTO~HHM rpa<}>eHa llO CllHHy.Ycnexypa6oThiCllOC06CTBOBa.JIOHCllOJib30BaHHeQe.rroroKOMn.rreKcaB3aHMO):{OllOJI~IOI.QHX MeTO):{OB HCCJIC):{OBaH~ llOBepXHOCTH ~ no.rryqeH~ M:CqepnbiBaiOI.QCMHH<}>opMaQHH o6 o6beKTax.

C.rre):{yeT OTMeTHTh BhiCOKYfO 3<}><}>eKTHBHOCTh 3KcnepwMeHTa.JibHoroHCCJIC):{OBaH~, ):{OCTHrHYTOrD nocpe):{CTBOM KOM6HHaQHH CTpyKrypHOro MeTO,Z:{a ):{H<}>paKQHHMe):{JICHHhiX 3Jiei<TpOHOB C MeTO):{OM <}>OT03JICI<TpOHHOM cnei<TpOCKOllHH OCTOBHhiX ypOBHCM HBa.JICHTHOM 30Hhl, ,Z:{aiOI.QHMH llOJIHOe npe):{CTaBJICHHe 0 KpHCTa.JIJIHqecKOM CTpyKType M3yqaeMhiXCHCTCM, HX KpHCTa.JIJIHqeCKOro COBepiiieHCTBa H 06 3Jiei<TpOHHOM 3HepreTHqecKOM CTpyKrype3ano.JIHeHHhiX3JICI<TpOHHhiXcoCTO~HM.Hcno.rrb3oBaHHe3THXMeTO):{OBno3so.rrw.rroc<}>OpMHpOBaTb Qe.JIOCTHOC npe):{CTaBJieHHe 06 MCCJie,Z:{yeMhiX CHCTeMax H npOTCKaiOI.QHX B HHX<}>H3HqeCKHX npOQeCCaX. 3-fo onpe):{CAAeT BhiCOKYIO CTCllCHh .Z.OCTOBepHOCTH llOJiyqCHHhiXpe3y.JihTaTOB H 060CHOB3HHOCTb c,n:e.rraHHhiX Ha HX OCHOBe BhiBO.IJ:OB H HayqHhiX llOJIO)I(eHHM.Pa60Ta xopoiiio o<}>opM.rreHa,qeTKO H3JIO)I(eHau HJIJIIOCTpHposaHa.

Bee ee qaCTH.rroruqecKH o6ocHoBaHhi.flo .IJ:HCCePTaQHOHHOM pa6oTe lly,n:HKOBa ,A.A. MO)I(HO C,n:e.rraTh HeCKOJihKO 3aMeqaHHM:fu1.TeKCTa;aMCCepTa:U;ffMHeSICHO,M3KaKMXcoo6pa)KeHMMBbi6Mpan:MCbpe;aK03eMeJibHhie MeTaJIJibl, MCITOJib30BaHHhie ;aJISI CMHTe3a rpa¢eHa MeTO;aOM Kap6M;aH3aQMM.2. He;aoCTaToqHo ;acran:hHO npoaHan:IDMposaHa cnMHOBaSI CTPYKTYPa Mccne;ayeMhiXCMCTeM. XoTenoch 6hi y3HaTb, nposo;aMJIMCh JIM M3MepeHHSI co cnMHOBhiM pa3pemeHMeMrpa¢eHa, c¢opMMposaHHoro Mcro;aoM cerperaQMM Ha Co/rpa¢MT?3.

B pa6oTe He y;aeneHo ;aoJI)KHOro BHHMaHHSI 6onee ;acran:hHOMY aHan:M3Y MexaHM3Mao6pa30BaHHSI rpa¢eHa Ha ITOBepXHOCTM ITJieHOK nepexO;aHbiX MeTaJIJIOB, B qaCTHOCTM, pOJIM;ae¢eKTOBMM;aMCJIOKaQMM B npo:u;ecce KpMCTan:JIM3aQMM rpa¢eHa npM ITOHH)KeHMM TeMnepaTypblcooTBeTCTBYfOI.QeM noHM)KeHMM pacTBOpMMOCTM aTOMOB yrnepo;aa s CoMNi nneHKax.Bo3HMKillMe 3aMeqaHHSI He yMaJISIIOT QeHHOCTM npe;aCTasneHHoro Mccne;aosaHHSI.,l(MccepTaQHSI IIy;aMKOBa ,l(.A. npe;aCTaBJISieT co6o:H 3aKoHqeHHoe HayqHoe Mccne;aosaHMe, sKOTOpOM co;aep)KMTCSI pemeHHe p}l;aa npo6JieM, MMeiOI.QHX cyi.QeCTBeHHOe 3HaqeHMe ;aJISIpa3BMTHSI COBpeMeHHOM ¢M3MKH KOH;aeHCMpOBaHHOrO COCTO}IHHSI.ABTope¢epaT ;aMccepTaQMM ;aoCTaToqHo nonHo ocsei.QaeT CyTh pa6oThi.

Pe3yJihTaThipa60Tbl ony6JIMKOBaHbl B 6 CTaTb}IX B Be;ayl.QMX OTeqeCTBeHHbiX,l(MCCepTaQHSICOOTBeTCTBYeTCITeQMaJibHOCTM01 .04.07-M3apy6e)J{HbiX )KypHan:ax.¢M3MKaKOH;aeHCMpOBaHHOrOCOCTQ}IHHSI.BQenoM,;aMccepTaQMOHHaSI pa6oTa IIy;aMKOBa ,n:.A.3JieKTPOHHOM CTpYKTYPbi rpa¢eHa Ha ITO;aJIO)KKaX Ha OCHOBe d-M«0co6eHHOCTM CMHTe3aMf- MeTan:JIOB» OTBe-IaeT BCCMTpe6osauuHM «lloJio)KeHHSI o nopH;aKe npMcy~eHHSI yqeHhiX CTeneHeii» BAK MMHMCTepCTsao6pa3osaHHSIMHayKM PcD (IIoCTaHosneHMe IIpasMTeJihCTBa PcD OT 24.09.2013 N2842),npe;a'h}IBJISieMbiM K KaH;aM;aaTCKMM ;aMCCepraQHSIM, a ee aBTOp 3aCJIY)I(MBaeTnpMCy~eHHSICMYMCKOMOM CTCITCHM KaH;aM;aaTa ¢M3MKO-MaTeMaT~CCKHX HaYK ITO cneQMaJibHOCTlf 01.04.07 ¢M3MKa KOH;aeHCMpOBaHHOrO CQCTQ}IHHSI.0¢MQlfaJibHbiM OITITOHCHT;aoKTop ¢M3MKO-MaTeMaTMqecKHX HayK, npo¢eccop,npo¢eccop Ka¢e;apbl 3KCITepMMeHTaJlbHOM ¢M3MKMCaHKT-IIcrep6yprcKoro nonMTexHMqecKoroyHMBepcMTeTaMM .ITcrpa BenMKoroa;apec: 195251 , r .

CaHKT-IIcrep6ypr,yn. liOJIMTeXHMqecKaSI, 29Ten. (812) 552-77-90e-mail : petrov@physics.spbstu.ru~~laQl:r:.-.._B .H. lleTpOB.