Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Энергетический баланс импульсного пересоединения)

OT31IBo¢HIIYfaJihHOro OITITOHeHTa Ha .[(HccepTaumo BonKoHcKoii HaTaJIHH HHKonaeBHhi"3HepreTHqecKHH 6aJiaHC HMITYJihCHOrO ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51", ITpe.[(CTaBJieHHOH Ha COHCKaHHeyqeHOH CTeiTeHH KaH.[(H.[(aTa ¢H3HKO-MaTeMaTHqecKHX HaYK ITO CITeUHaJihHOCTH01.03.03 -<PH3HKa ConHuaB.[(HccepTaUHOHHoii.[(HHaMHqecKa51MO.[(eJihpa6oTeH.H.HMITYJihCHoroBonKoHcKoH:MarHHTHoro.[(eTaJIH3HpyeTc51ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51.HBpa3BHBaeTc51ocHoByMO.[(eJIHITOJIO)I(eHa H.[(e51 0 TOM, qTO TOITOJIOrHqecKa51 ITepecTpOHKa MarHHTHOrO ITOJ151, I13BeCTHa51 KaK"ITepecoe.[(HHeHHe", MO)I(eT peaJII130BaThC51 HHhiM CITOC060M ITO cpaBHeHHIO C TeM, KaK 3TOITpOHCXO.[(HT B .[(H<l><l>Y3HOHHOH 06JiaCTI1.

I1MeHHO, K MarHHTHOH peKOH¢HrypaUHH ITpHBO.[(HTpaciTa.[( TOKOBOrO CJI051 Ha CHCTeMy Mf,lJ,-pa3phiBOB B ITpHCYTCTBHH HOpMaJihHOH KOMITOHeHThlMarHHTHOrO ITOJ151 (MaJia51 .[(H<l><l>Y3I10HHa51 06JiaCTh H)')I<Ha TOJihKO .[(J151 reHepaUHH 3aTpasoqHoroB03MymeHH51).PeKoH¢HrypaUH51coiTpOBmK.[(aeTc516hiCTphiMITpeo6pa3oBaHHeMMarHHTHOH:3HeprHH B KHHeTHqeCKYIQ H TeiTJIOBYIQ :meprHIO ITJia3Mhl.TeMa .[(HCCepTaUHH 51BJI51eTC51 aKTYaJihHOH, ITOCKOJihKY .[(0 CHX ITOp :mepreTHqecKHM 6aJiaHCITpouecca ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51 ITOHHMaJic51yrrpomeHHO,poeT TeiTJIOBOH 3HeprHHycKopeHHhiXITOTOKOB ITJia3Mhl He 6hiJI 06o51CHeH, BKJia.[( B :mepreTHqeCKHH 6aJiaHC 06JiaCTI1 BTeKaHH51 HeHCCJie.[(OBaJIC51.BMecTecTeM,.[(eTaJihHOeTeopeTHqecKoepaccMoTpeHHeITpeo6pa3oBamrn3HeprHH B ITpouecce MarHHTHOH peKOH<l>HrypaUHH 51BJI51eTC51 He06XO.[(HMhiM, ITpe)l(,[(e BCero, .[(J151o6o51CHeHH51 CITYTHHKOBhiX Ha6JIIO.[(eHHi1.Bo BBe.[(eHHH o6cy)l(.[(aiOTC51 COBpeMeHHOe COCT051HI1e ITp06JieMhl, aKTYaJihHOCTh TeMhl.[(HccepTaUHH H HOBH3Ha ITonyqeHHhiX pe3yJihTaTOB.

TaiOKe, KaqecTBeHHO OITHCaHa ¢H3HKa.[(HHaMHqecKoro ITpouecca HMITYJihCHoro ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51 B ITpH6nmKeHHH ITorpaHHqHoro CJI051,HCITOJih3yeMoro B pa6oTe.B1-oH: maBe aBTop ITOKa3hiBaeT, qTo B cnyqae HeC)KHMaeMoii ITJia3Mhi, oiTpe.n.enHB ¢opMy¢poHTaHcKopocThMarHHTHOrOITOJ151I1Dny.[(apHoiiCI<OpOCTHHaBOJIHhiHeMIIeTqeKa,COaCTOpOHhlBOCITOJih30BaBilll1Ch HeiTpephiBHOCThlO Bn I1 v n -TaK)KeHOpMaJihHhie0R-o6JiaCTHKOMITOHeHThi(outflowregion),HDn Ha ¢poHTe BOJIHhl, MO)KHO ITOJiyqHThrpaHHqHhie ycJIOBH51 .[(J151 1-rO ITpi16JIH)I(eHI151 B o6JiaCTI1 BTei<aHI151. 3TO IT03BOJI51eT B pa3)J,eJie 1.2HCCJie.[(oBaTh 6aJiaHc 3HeprHH B xo.[(e ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51 He TOJihKO B OR-o6nacTH, HO TaK)I(e6nep6bleB o6nacTH BTei<aHH51, r.[(e ero OCHOBHOH oco6eHHOCThiO oKa3hiBaeTC51 ¢opMHpoBaHHeo6nacTHITOBhiilleHHOH MarHHTHOH 3HeprHHHa.[( HITO.[( OR-o6nacThiO,ITepeMemaiOmeH:c51BMecTe c Heii (travelling compression region, TCR), a TaK)I(e OTpHUaTeJihHOro B03MymeHH51MarHHTHOH 3HeprHI1 B o6JiaCTI1 pa3JieTa.,lJ,anee, B pa3.[(eJie 1.3 I1 rJiaBe 2 .[(HCCepTaUHH, HCITOJih3Y51 ITOXO)KHH aJirOpHTM, aBTOp HaXO.[(HTpellleHHe3a.[(aqHonfl 6onee cnoJICJ-LblX ucxoOJ-LblX KOJ-Lrjluzypmfuu,I<Or.[(a TaHreHUHaJihHhiHpa3phiB o6pa3oBaH HeCHMMeTpHqHhiMH H CKpemeHHhiMH MarHHTHhiMH ITOJI51MH.

IIoKa3aHo, qTo,ITO-ITpe)I(HeMy, B ITpH6Jimi<eHHI1 HeC)I(HMaeMOCTH, KHHeTHqeci<a51 3Hepri151 YCI<OpeHHhiX ITOTOKOBITJia3Mhi ITOJIHOCThiO qepiTaeTC51 H3 MarHHTHOH 3HeprHH BHYTPH OR-o6nacTH, TaK qTo B o6nacTHBTei<aHH51 MarHHTHa51 3HeprH51 B uenoM coxpaH51eTC51, ITepepaciTpe.[(eJI5151Ch B ITpocTpaHCTBe.B3-eH:rnaBe .[(HccepTaUHH ITonyqeHhi pellleHH51 .[(JI51 HMITYJihCHoro ITepecoe.[(HHeHH51 6CJICUMaeMOUnfla3Me.TaHreHUHaJihHOrOY CTaHOBJieHO,pa3phiBaCqTo.[(J151CI1MMeTpi1qHhiMHHCXO.[(HOHMarHHTHhiMHKOH¢HrypaUHHITOJ151MI1ITJIOTHOCThlO pellleHH51 Ma.JIO OTJII1qaiOTC51 OT HeC)I(HMaeMOrO CJiyqa51,I1BBH.[(eO.[(HOpO.[(HOHO.[(HaKO TeiTeph pOCTKHHeTHqeci<oii (11 TeiTJIOBoii) 3HeprHH BHYTPH OR-o6nacTH MO)I(eT 6hiTh o6o51cHeH TOJihKO cyqeTOM o6mero )'MeHbllleHlUI TeiiJIOBOH H MarHHTHOH :meprHH B 06JiaCTH BTeKaHH5I.

B pa3.D;eJie3.3rryreM qifcneHHoro Mo.nenHposaHH5I rroKa3aHo, KaK MeH5IeTC5I ¢opMa OR-o6nacTH, ecnH,BMeCTO TaHreHI.J;HaJibHOfO pa3pbiBa, HCXO.D;Hj'IO KOH¢Hrypau;mo 3a.D;aBaTh B BH.D;e CJI05I XappHca.Be o6uteM4-oi1: rnase pa6oTbi rrpHse.neHo 2D peiiieHHe 3a.naqH B C)KHMaeMOH IIJia3Mecny'-tae.IloKa3aHo, qTo CHCTeMa pa3pbiBOB, o6pa3j'IOW:a5I Terrepb OR-o6nacTb, BKmoqaeT 5pa3pbiBOB. IIocne.nosaTerrhHO corrracoBbiBa5I H3MeHeHH5I Mf,l(-rrapaMerpos Ha KmK.D;OM H3 HHX,asTop Haxo.D;HT peiiieHHe .D;JI5I O-ro rrpH6JimKeHH5I so scei1: OR-o6nacTH. ,l(anee, .D;JI5I HaXO)K.D;eHH5I¢opM pa3pbiBOB, HOpMaJibHbiX K HHM KOMIIOHeHT MarHHTHOfO IIOJI5I H CKOpOCTH B 0R-o6JiaCTH,a TaK)Ke 1-ro IIpH6JIH:)KeHH5I B 06JiaCTH BTeKaHH5I, HCIIOJih3yeTC5I JIHHeapH30BaHHa5I CHCTeMaMr,n: ypasHeHHH, KOTOPJ'IO y.naeTc5I csecTH K o.nHoMy ypasHeHHIO (4.47) .D;JI5I z-KoMrroHeHThiBeKTOpaCMern:eHH5I~z·BeropeiiieHHeBXO.D;HT<l>YHKU:H5IQ,HCTQqHHKaCB5I3aHHa5IC3JieKTpHqecKHM rroneM rrepecoe.D;HHeHH5I.

Bhipa3HB narrnac-<Dypbe o6pa3 3TOH <l>YHKU:HH qepe3cKopocTH Xo¢MaHa-Tennepa .D;JI5I OT.D;eJihHhiX pa3pbiBOB 11 x-KOMIIOHeHThi MarHHTHoro IIOJI5I Bo6nacT5IX Me)K.LJ:Y pa3pbiBaMH, asTop cosepiiiaeT o6paTHoe narrnac-<Dypbe rrpeo6pa3osaHHe, BenepebzeKOTopoM.D;JI5IMr,n:3a.naq3aHMCTBOBaHHhiH H3 cei1:cMonorHH. BTaKoroTHrrarrpHMeH5IeTMeTO.D:KaHb5Ipa-Xyrra,pa3.nene 4.2 rro.npo6Ho paccMaTpHsaeTC5I 3HepreTHKaHMIIYJihCHoro rrepecoe.D;HHeHH5I B C)KHMaeMoi1: rrna3Me.TaKHMo6pa30M,asTopoMpeiiieHbi5Ba)KHhiX3a.naqBo6nacTHTeopHHrrepecoe.D;HHeHH5I HapacTaiOmei1: cTerreHH CJIO)KHOCTH. IIonyqeHHoe B rnase 43a.D;aqJ106HMIIYJibCHOMrrepecoe.D;H:HeHHHBC)KH:MaeMOHIIJia3Me.D;JI5IMarHHTHoro2D peiiieHHeo6mei1:HCXO.D;HOHKoH¢Hrypau;HH rrpe.ncTaBJI5IeTc5I HaH6onee cTporHM H caMocornacosaHHhiM Ha cero.D;H5IIIIHHH.neHb.B KaqecTBe 3aMeqaHHH K .D;HCCepTai.J;HOHHOH pa6oTe MO)KHO OTMeTHTb CJie.D;j'IOW:ee:1.

Ha CTp. 25 He IIOH5ITHO, rroqeMy 6hiCTpa5I MarHHT03BYKOBa5I BOJIHa "pa3HOCHT" ITO 06JiaCTHBTeKaHH5I(IR)B03MYIIJ:eHH:e 3JieKTpH:qeCKOfO IIOJI5I H "He pa3HOCHT" B03MYIIJ:eHH:e MarHHTHOfOIIOJI5I.2. Ha CTp. 29 Bp5I.D; Jill MO)KHO yrsep)K.ll;aTb, qTO Ha CaMOM ¢poRTe rreTqeKOBCKOH y.napHOHBOJIHbi, MaCIIITa6 KOTOpOrO-7011, CJie.D;OBaTeJibHO, MeHbllle rHpOpa.D;Hyca HOHa, BbiiiOJIH5IeTC5IycJIOBHe BMOpmKeHHOCTH (16).3.06n5ICHeHHe rrepepacrrpe.neneHH5I MarHHTHOH 3HeprHH B o6rracTH BTeKaHH5I Ha.n OR-o6nacTbiO B TepMHHaX 6hiCTpOH MarHHT03BYKOBOH BOJIHbl I13JIQ)KeHO Ha CTp.

67 HeqeTKO. KaKH:eH3 HCIIOJih3yeMbiX ypaBHeHHH (3.D;eCh H .D;aJiee, B rnaBe 4) ee OIIHCbiBaiOT? KaKa5I 06JiaCTb Ha pHC.1.8b COOTBeTCTByeT 06JiaCTH"rrepe.D; rrepe.D;HHM ¢poHTOM y.napHOH BOJIHbi"?4. B 3aKrriOqeHHe K rnase 2 6hmo 6bi )KeJiaTeJihHO o6'h5ICHHTh J<aqecTBeHHO, rroqeMy B crryqaeHeC).I(HMaeMOH rrna3Mhi He rrpoHCXO.D;HT o6MeHa 3Hepmei1: Me).l(.ny OR- 11IR-o6nacT5IMH.5. <!>OHOBbie KOH¢Hrypau;HH MarHHTHOfO IIOJI5I, HCIIOJih3yeMbie B .D;HCCepTai.J;HH (TaHreHI.J;HaJibHbiMpa3pbiB, CJIOH XappHCa) He CO.D;ep).l(aT KpHBH3Hbi MarHHTHbiX CHJIOBbiX JIHHHH H, XOT5I II03BOJI5IIOTrronyqHTh peiiieHHe 3a.naqH .D;JI5I HMIIYJihCHoro rrepecoe.D;HHeHH5I, He rrpHrO.D;Hhi .D;JI5ITeopeTH:qecKOfO OIIHCaHH5I .D;pyrHX Ha6JIIO.D;aeMbiX B MarHHTOc¢epe 5IBJieHHH, Cpe.D;H KOTOpbiX6anrroHHhie BOJIHhi, rrepecTaHosoqHa5I HeycTofiqHBOCTh, 6aYHc-pe3oHaHChi 11 T ..LJ:.

K KaKHM06JiaCT5IM MarHHTOc¢epbi IIpHMeHHMbl IIO.D;06Hbie KOH¢Hrypai.I;HH?6. ToHKHe TOKOBbie CJIOH C HOpMaJibHOH KOMIIOHeHTOH MarHHTHOfO IIOJI5I B HaCT05IW:ee BpeM5IMO.D;eJIHpj'IOTC5I B KHHeTHqeCKOM IIpH6JimKeHHH. bbiJIO 6hi HHTepeCHO cpaBHHTb Mf,l(-peiiieHHeC pacrra)J;OM TaHreH[(MaJibHOrO pa3pbiBa C perneHM51MM, IIOnyqeHHbiMM B KMHeTWieCKOMrrpH6nmKemm.TaiOKe MO)I(HO CLJ:enaTb HecKonhKO MenKHX 3aMeqaHHH::l.HeMHoro HerrpHBbJqHo, qTo Mr,n: pa3pbiBbi, rro51Bn51IOIIJHec51 B perneHH51X LJ:n51 HeC)I(MMaeMoH:rrna3Mbi, Ha3biBaiOTC51 yLJ:apHbiMH BOnHaMH, XOT51 Ha HHX MeH51IOTC51 TOnbKO MarHHTHOe none I1CKOpOCTb IIna3Mbl.2. B IIOLJ:IIHCH K p11c.

1.1 cneLJ:osarro YKa3aTb, KaK HOpMHposaHbi KOOpLJ:HHaTbi, qTo6hr y qHTaTen51C03LJ:aJIOCb rrpaBHnbHOe rrpeLJ:CTasneHHe o reoMeTpHM OR-o6nacTH.3. B XOLJ:e H3nO)I(eHH51 o6nacTb ycKopeHHbiX rrna3MeHHbiX IIOTOKOB Ha3biBaeTC51 TO OR, TO FRo6nacTbiO.4. Ha CTp. 43 ypasHeHHe (1.3) HeToqHo Ha3BaHo ypasHeHHeM Hepa3pbiBHOCTH.5. B IIOLJ:IIHCH K pHc. 3.2 He YKa3aHo, B03MYIIJeHH51 KaKoH: senHqHHbi rroKa3aHbi [(BeTOM.6. B HeKOTOpbiX cpopMynax (HarrpHMep, (3.39), (3.44)) rrpHcyrcTByiOT orreqaTKH.0TMeqeHHbie 3aMeqaHH51 HH B KOeH Mepe He CHH)I(alOT [(eHHOCTH pa60Tbl.Pe3ynbTaTbr LJ:MCcepTa[(HOHHOH pa6oTbi H.H.

BonKOHCKOH xoporno H3BeCTHbi crre[(MaJIHCTaMB o6naCTH cpi13HKM MarHHTOCcpepbi, OHM orry6nHKOBaHbi B Be)l;YIIJHX MHpOBbiX I13)J;aHH51X I1rrpe)J;CTaBneHbl Ha KpyrrHbiX pOCCHHCKHX I1 Me)KLJ:YHapOLJ:HbiX KOHcpepeH[(I151X. llx HOBI13Ha,aKTyanbHOCTb, )J;OCTOBepHOCTb I1 3HaqJ1MOCTb He Bbl3biBaiOT COMHeHHfi.TionaraiO,qTo LJ:MccepTa[(HOHHa51 pa6oTa H.H.BonKOHCKOHcooTBeTcTsyeT KpMTepH51M,ycTaHOBneHHbiM «llonmr<eHHeM 0 IIOp51)J;Ke IIpHC~K)J;eHH51 yqeHbiX CTeiieHeH», a CaM aBTOp3aCn~mBaeT IIpMC~K)J;eHH51 yqeHOH CTeiieHH KaH)J;H)J;aTa cpi13HKO-MaTeMaTHqecKHX HaYK ITOcrre[(HaJibHOCTH 01.03.03 -cpH3HKa ConH[(a.ABTOpecpepaT IIOnHOCTbiO COOTBeTCTByeT COLJ:ep)l(aHHIO )J;HCCepTa[(HH.OcpH[(HaJibHbiH orrrroHeHT,,l.(OKTOp cpH3HKO-MaTeMaTHqecKHX HaYK,BeLJ:YIIJHH Hay<IHbiH coTPYLJ:HHK<l>eLJ:epanbHoro rocyLJ:apcTBeHHoro6IOLJ:)KeTHoro HayqHoro yqpe)I(LJ:eHH51"I1on51pHbiH reocpH3HqecKMH HHCTHTYT"ronosqaHCKa51 llpHHa Bna)J;HMHpOBHa184200 ArraTHTbiyn.

AKa)J;eMropOLJ:OK, LJ:.26a,rrrMTen. 8155579553 golovchanskaya@pgia.ruK.r.Opnos.