Отзыв 1 оппонента (Электронное строение нанокомпозитов на основе низкоразмерных углеродных наноструктур)

OT3bIBoQnqnanbHoro orrIoHeHTa Ha AuccepralllroHuyro pa6oryBep6uqxoro Hurcolaq IInaHoBtlrraHa ocHoBeH[3Kopa3MepHblxyrJrepoAHblxcrpoeHrre HaHoKoMrro3r{ToB<<3.nercrpoHHoerraHocTpyKTyp>),yqeHofi crenenu Kar:.4kr4uraxI4MI4lIecKI4xHayK IIorrpeAcraBJreHHyroHa cor4cKaHr4ecnequiurbHocrflM 02.00.21-xurvrus rBepAoro'Ierav 02.00.01 - HeopraHrlqecKatxvrMvtfl,tBrtlorcq reMol4yrJIepoAHbIeHaHoMarepl4illrbrB uacroqque BpeMqHtr3Kopa3MepHbre6ommoro KoJnrqecrBaHayrIHbIXfpynn Bo BceM MI4pe.HenpepunHo pacrerr{ccJreAoBauu.f,rrr,rcro ny6luraqnfi,ilpor,r3BoAHbrM.BrtocBsuleHHbrx yrJIepoAHhIM uauorpy6xau,rpaQeuykrHXrrepByro oqepeAb, r4HTepec K AaHHrIM MarepI4iLJIaMBbI3BaH vxnoreHIII4aJIrIpI{MeHeHUtByHr4KarrbHHrv[,rcsoficTBaMr4,KoTopbre o6ecne.Iusaro'r 6olrnrofiBue4peHl4eAaHHrIXMarepI4a"IIoBpa3iluqHbrxo6lacrgx, B ToM irrrcJle,B Mr4KpoSneKTpoHt4Ke.npoqeccbr 14co3AaHI4eycrpoftcrB Ha ocHoBeyrJIepoAHbIxrexHoJrorr4qecKr4eB coBpeMeHHbrenaHorpy6orKaK pa3Btrrr4fl MeroAoB yrlpaBJleHvfl, vrx olerrpouuofiu rpaSena rpe6yrorcrpyr<rypofi, TaK pr uccreAosaHrafi MexaHu3MoB vtx AonI{poBaHI4t u ssalalaoAeficlauit,B pe3ynlTaTe 3Tofo.BO3Hr{KarOilIlIX[zccepraqrroHHarpa6orar4ccneAoBaHr4rocrpyKTypbr uBep6uqrorocsoficrsoAHocreHHbrx yrJrepoAHbrx nanorpy6orI4saHoslrqaHuroraqnocBquleHaHaHoKoMrIo3I4ToBHa ocHoBe 3arIoJIHeHHbIXu rpa$ena.

Mo4u$uraqrar[yreMBHeApeHutoAHocreHHbrxyrJIepoAHbIx nanorpyoorpa3rurrHbrx MarepuiuroB Bo BHyrpeHHr{eKaHuLJIbIcsoficrs OCHT, qro tBrqerctI43MeHeHue(OCHT) no3BoJuer ocyilIecrBJrrrb HarrpaBJIeHHoeseo6xoAuuulrycJroBr4eM p.nfl co3AaHI4t ycrpoficrnHa vxocHoBe. AxmyanonocmbnponeAeHHbrxB xoAe AasHoft Al4ccepraul4oHHofipa6oru onpeAerqerct Her4ccneAoBanrafiToJrbKo Heo6xoAraMocrbro paspa6o:rrucrpyxrypu3JreKTpoHHofiHoBbIX MeroAoB rlpeIIe3I4oHHoro KoHTporqocHoBHbIXTeHAeHIII{fiu rcoppetnluft',OCHT, Ho 14r4ccJleAoBalvrfl,onpeAeJrruorrlr4xKoHeqHyro crpyKTypy iloryrlaeMhlx TaKI{M o6pasorr,rHaHoKoMIIo3I4ToB.pa6or, nocBquIeHHbIXSneKTpoHHoMyHecvrorpr Ha $onburoe KoJrrlqecrnoony6JII{KoBaHHbIXcrpoeHrrloyrJrepoAHhrx Hauorpy6or14 MeroAaM vxrr,to4u$uxaquu, HeKoropbleHeAocraroqHoSyH4alrenrzurbHbreBonpocbr rroKa ocrarorcq 6es orBera.

Oauofi I43 TaKvxpa6oralpo6leu, perxeHuro roropofi I{ trocBtilIeHa AI4ccepraIrLIoHHaqr4ccJreAoBaHHbrxBep6uqroro H.IrI.pa3MepHocrll yrJlepo4uofi noAno)KKIrHaocraercr Borrpoc o BJrr4tHIrI4Tl4rrbrnsauuogeft c'IBvIfl,B03HIIKaIoxII4eB ru6p ulou HaHoMaTepI4aJIe.fluccepraqr{oHHar pa6ora npeAcraBJreHa Ha 120 crpauilqax lerrarHororeKcra uBKJIIoqaer53 pucynra, 18 ra6nuq 14crrr4coKJrvreparypbr, coAepxall\uit 160 ucroqHzKoB.lraccepraqur coAep)Krrr BBeAeHlre,Tpr,rrJraBbr,BbrBoAbr14crrr4coKJrr,rreparypbr.Bo eeedeuuu o1rscHrercrnrr6op o6rerravccJreAoBanuft,orpeAenrrorcr ueJrr4rr3ara,uv pa6oru.B nepeoit zra6e rlpeAcraBJleno6sop Jrr4TeparypHbrxAaHHbrxo MeroAax [oryrreHprr,ceoficrsax r{ crpyKType HaHoKoMrro3rrroBHa ocHoBe yrJrepoAHbrxHaHorpy6or n rpaQena.Ilponegensuftaua.nl,I3rlo3BoJr-fleraBTopy nrr6parb orrrr4MiurbHyro crparefr{ro r4 MeroAr4KyI4ccJleroBarruit.JIureparypHblfi o6:op AocraroqHo JraKoHr4qeH,Ho rrpr4 oroM oxBarr,rBaernpaKTI{qecKI4Bce Ba}r(HhIeacrreKThrxuv.vrr4MareprlurJroBHa ocHoBe yrJrepoAHbrxHauorpy6orc 3anoJrHeHHbrMr4KaHiLJraMr4v Mo)Ker 6urrpeKoMeHAoBaHB KaqecrBe orAelrHofiny6ruraquu.Bo emopoil znaee Ar4cceprarlr4r4[peAcraBJreHa[ocraHoBKa gKcrrepuMeHTa,orucaHbrMeroAbI cI4HTe3av aHarrr43ar,rccneAyeMuxo6rerroe.

ConpeMeHHhreMeroAbr r4ccJreAoBaHzr,r4cnonb3oBaHHbres AaHHofipa6ore, rro3BoJrmorBcecropoHHer,rrroJrHoorrr4carbcrpyKTypy r43neKTpoHHoecrpoeHue prcyqaeMbrxB Aauuoft pa6ore o6rexroe.B mpemueil znaBe o6cyN4arorca ocHoBHbre pe3yJrbrarbr r4ccneAoBaHr{r.AnroprloKa3blBaerycilerxHocrb rrpeAroxeusofi I4M MeroAr4KV3arroJrHeHvfl.BHyrpeHHr4xKaHaJroBOCHT HeopraHI4qecKLIMI{Marepr4airaMuvt AeMoHcrpr4pyere$SerrrlnHocrb 3Toro MeroAa.falee,[pI4 rIoMoIrII4BcecropoHHero aHanvsaaBTopycraHaBJrrrBaerBaxHefiurue KoppeJurlr4r{MelI(Ay crpyKTypofi noryvaeMbrx HaHoKoMrro3r4ToBu rrx cnoftcrsaN4z.

Anrop BbrrBrqerBrI4sHI4ecoorBercrBvq pa3MepoBKpr4crzlrrJraBHyrpeHHeMyAr4aMerpyrpy6rra Ha crpyKTypyflonyqaeMblx HaHoKoMIIo3rIToB14crerreHb B3arlMoAeftcrel{qMexAy Kpr{craJrJrour.rrpy6rofi.Kpolreroro,BrlpeAcraBnessoftAr4cceprauuouuoft pa6orevccneAoBaHbr rutrrbrsgafiNaoAeftctsvfiMe]KAyBHeApeHHbrMKpr{criurJroMr,rcresxofi uaHorpy6Kr.rH rroKa3aHo,rrro3JIeKTpOHHatCTpyKTypaKOHeqHOfOHaHOKOMnO3r4Tapa3HOCTbrOOIIpeAeJrrero,IHe TOJTbKOpa6or BbIXoAa, Ho vr HzuIurII4eMxr{MlrrlecKofo cBq3blBaHut. Zcnolrsy-tcoBpeMeHHbreMeroAbI anuwrsa 3neKTpoHHoficrpyxrypbr rBepAbrx reJr, Bep6zqr<unrH.I4.

rroKa3brBaer,qroAassuft TI{II B3al4MoAeficreus peilJrrr3yerc.rrlyreM .racrzqHofi rvt6pugvzaquz Cu3d vt C2p,op6uranefi. llpu groM creleHb 3Tofo nsauuo4eficrBnfl,yBeruquBaercr BMecre c Ar4aMerpoMOCHT.AnropI4ccneAyer ssal,IN,{oAeftcrBvtrMe)KAy yrnepoAHbrM JrrrcroM vr AonaHToM Bcl,IcreMaxpa3nurlHofi pa:vepuocrl4 - oAHoMepHbrxyrnepoAHhrx nanorpy6oK 14AByMepnofinreHKrI rpa$eHa. leranrnuftcpaBHl4TeJmsufi aHaJwr3rroKa3ilJr HilJrr4rrr4exr{Mr4rrecKorocB_r{3brBaHr4rJrrrrrrbB oAHoMepHbrxcTpyKTypax, B To BpeMr KaK gJreKTpoHHoecTpoeHrrerr.rlrb pa3Hocrblo pa6or BbIXoAa.AByMepHofinreuxu olpeAeJrtrerc-f,Aorrr4poBaHHofiTaroe cr4creMarllqecKoe vccneAoBaHr{e pa3rurrHbrx HaHoKoMno3I4ToBrlo3Bonl4noaBropy He roJrbKo o6uapyxurbBDKHhreKoppenrrlr4rr Me)KAy crpyKrypoir u csoficrsaN,IlanoJryqaeMbrxHaHoKoMrro3rrroB,Ho 14 rrpeAno)KLITbMoAeJIb B3al4MoAeitcrsufl,AonaHTa cyrnepoAHbrM JrutcroM, ocHoBaHHyro Ha pa3AeireHul4 3apsAoB MexAy nanorpy6rofi14B3ar4MoAeficrezz3JreKTpoHHofinrorsocruKpr,rcrulJuroMvlHa creHKax OCHT c saprloroftMoAeJI6 IIo3BoJIuJIa cBq3arbrrJrorHocrbro Ha BHeApeHHoM HaHoKpr4craJrJre.lauuatgJreKTpOHHyrOCTpyKTypy IIOIyrraeMbrx HaHoKoMfIo3LtToBc ocHoBHbIMII napaMeTpaMpIBHeApreMbrxcoeAraneHufi.ZcnolrsyqI,I ycrelrrHononyqeHHbre B xoAe pa6orrr AaHHbre,aBTop npeAJIo)KTIJIpeaJrr43oBa,TMeroArrKy cr4HTe3a 3rrr4TaKcr{aJrbHororpa$enaHa noJlynpoBoAHuKoeofinonnoxKe.BsaKrrcqeHuu pa6oru[peAcraBJreHbr ocHoBHbIe BbIBoAbI Al4ccepralluu.

BcenonyrreHHbrepe3yJrbrarbr npeAcraBJrrror cyruecrneusufi HayqHo-[paKTl4rlecKrlfiunrepec, anpeAcraBr.f,rorcflo6ocuoeaHHblMl4.BhrBoAbrrro pe3ynbraraM Ar4ccepraur4r4orMerr4T6 HayqHyrc HoBrr3Hy pe3yJrbraroB pa6oruBaNsoBep6uqxoroH.I4.flolyueuuhre B xo4e pa6orbr AaHHbrerro3BorrvtrurnpeAJIoxI4Tb MoAeJIbB3aI4Mo1eitcrsusAOrraHTac yHrepoAHbrMJrktcToMB yfJrepoAHbrxHaHoKoMfro3uTax,a TaKxe JIe|JII4B ocHoByuoAroxrerpaQeua Ha noJrynpoBoAHr4KonoftHoBofo MeroAa noryqeHur KBa3r4-ceo6oAHoronyreMr.rHrepKanrqr{kr repMaHr4fl.

Paspa6orannrrftAr4cceprauuouuofipa6oruBep6zqruuH.VI.BpaMKaxKBa3r4-cBo6oAsororpa$ena flBlrfl,ercflHosHfi MeroA rroJryqeHr4qHecoMHeHuofiyAaueft anropa u 6ez coMHeHrrr6yaer rocrpe6onaH yrreHbrMt4rr rexHoJIofaMI4BOBCeMMrrpe.Mareprrara) roroprrfiOrAemuo cJreAyer [oArrepKHyrb BbrcoKoeKaqecrBo kt3Jro]rceHr4rrro Qoprvre,qro oco6eHHo rIeHHo npr4 TaKoMrrpeKpacHorrpor{nnrccrpr{poBaHh JraKoHrrrreH6omuronr o6r,eue iloryqeHHbrx pe3ynbraroB.llpe4craureHHbre B pa6ore AaHHbre v BbrBoAbrHa r4x ocHoBe npeAcraBJltlorctAocroBepHbrMrru o6ocHonaHHbIrvtu.poccuficKr{x 14Pesylrrarbr Ar{cceprar\w 6uru [peAcraBJreHbraBTopoMHa pa3rr.rrrHbrxMexAyHapoAHbrx roH$epentrytflx) a rarcKe ory6rzroBaHblB BuAe crarefi B BeAyqI{xMelxAyHapoAHbrxHayqHbrx )KypHaJrax (4 HayqHbre crarbr4 vr 6 Te3I4coBAoKJIaAoBHapa3nr4qHbrx ron$epeuur4.rrx vAr4cceprauuoHuoft pa6oruny6luraqufi,corerqauurx).Bep6uqroroB KaqecrBe HecoMHeHHoro Aocrol{HcrBaH.I4.

cJreAyer orMerurb sucoqaftuufiyponeurABe u3 Koropbrx ony6nnroBaHbr B )rcypHaJraxNature Publishing Group.Vragassue ny6nzrar\r4rt troJrHocrbro orpalraror coAepxcaHr4eAr4cceprarlr4oHHoftpa6oru.AnropeSeparraKxerrpaBr4JrbHoorpaxaerocHoBHoe coAep)KaHue Ar4cceprauuounofipa6oru. Co4epNanue pa6oru coorBercrByer cneqr4iurbHocrqu02.00.01 - neopraHr4rrecKatxvtMvts.B qacTr,r cr4HTe3aMaTepr.riuroB14 r4ccJre[oBaHr4flxr{Mr4qecKofo cBr3brBa}jnfl.Me)KAyuaHorpy6rofi u sHeApeHHbrMHaHoKpr4craJrJroMu 02.00.21 - xuvtus, TBepAoro reJra B rracrlrgneKTpo sH o fi crpyKTypbr HaHoKoMrrI4ccJreAoBaHrr.rr03r,rroBrr.llp"AeraJrbHoM o3HaKoMneHuvrc reKcroM Ar4cceprarluosHofi pa6oruBo3HrrKJroHecKonbKo3aMeqaHnfi u nonpocon:B pa:4ene 2.1.2.4.

Jrr4TeparypHoroo6sopa aBTop apryMeHTrrpoBaHHoo6ocHonrrsaerOCHT HeopraHr4qecKr4Mr4coeAr4HeHuflMu143paclJraBa.AocrorrHcrBa MeroAa 3arroJrHeHr4qO6cyN4arorcr rarcKe r.r orpaHvtqeHr4fl,AaHHoro MeroAa, oAHaKo Hr4qefo He roBopr4Tc-soupo6reue orAeneHr4rrrpoAyKTa,To ecrb 3arroJrHeHHuxOCHT, or z36urKa HeopraszqecrofiSasu, Koropar r4crroJrmyercqB xoAe cvHresa. 3ror)Ke Borrpoc pacnpocrpa*fl.ercfl. v Hape3yJrbrarr4BHyroqacrb Ar4cceprarluossofi pa6orrr. B SKcnepr4Mernarssofi qacrrr vr Bo6cyNgenr4r4pe3ynbraroB Hlrqefo se coo6ruaercfl o roM, rarofi us6rtrox HeopraHr4qecKoroBeuecTBarrclonb3yeTctr B xoAe clrHTe3a.B reKcre pa3AeJra 3.1.2. roBopr4Tcr o Aecrrr4KparHoM MoJrbHoM coorHorrreHr4uBHeApfleMoroMarepr4arav OCHT, Ho s ra6rzqe 3.1 c rapaMerpaMr4cr4HTesa(c.43) yKa3aHocoorHollreHIre I : 1.

r{ro rrpol4cxoArr c zs6rrTKoM BHeAp.rreMoroHeopfaHr{qecKofoBerrlecrBa,ecJII4 raxoeofiI4Meercr, r4cnoJrb3ylorcg IwI KaKI{e-To MeroArI orAeJleHr4r ocHoBHoforIpoAyKTaor ocrarKa HeopfaHr4qecKoroBerrlecrBa,Koropoe He BorrrJroB KaHaJrbrOCHT, aTarcKeKaKoBBhrxoAloryrreHHbrx Marepr4ilJroBrro HeopraHurrecxoftSa:e? Beporruo, orBerbrHa 3TI4BOTIpOCbIMOIKHO[Onyr{r4TbC nOMOrrIbrOMeTOAOBr{CCIreAOBaHVr,AOTTOJIHHTeJIbHbTXTaKI,IXKaKpeHTrenorpaQur noporrrKa,cKaHrrpyrouar 3JreKTpoHHarMr{KpocKorrvrvt g.p.Bo6eopeJII4TeparypbI roBopr4Tcr oBalxHocrr4 noryrreHr4rrpa$enaHanoJIyrIpoBoAHtrKoBo[noA.noxKeAn.f,co3AaHr,rrycrpoftcrn Ha ero ocHoBe,a rarc(e roBopurc.flo seo6xoAuMocrt4 pa3BUTLrfl,MeroAoB Qopuuponanzr3rruraKcr4iurbHoro rpa$enaHarIoJIyrIpoBoAHt4KoBbrxnoAno)KKax, rrocKoJrbKyAannrrft rran rpaQesa o6ta4aer Haunyq[ruMr4xapaKTepucrl4KaMl4 AJIIco3AaHr'r-f,noJrylpoBoAHrrKoBbrx ycrpoficrn.HecnlorprHaycneuruufi cI4HTe3rpaSeua Ha rrony[poBoAHr4Konofino4ro]KKe repMalanfl.B pa6ore oAHaKo,orcyrcrByror AaHHbrerro r43MepeHr4ronpoBoAr{Mocrr4rr rroABr4)rcHocrr4Hocr{Tetefi zapr.ga.B o6aope Jrr4TeparyphrroBopr{Tc-so BalKHocrr4nonyqeHr{fl KBa3r.r-cBo6oAnoro,To ecr6cla6o nsaurto4eficrBylouero c rroAnolrKofi, rpaQena Ha noJrylpoBoAHt4KoBbrxnoAJro)KKax.AnroppeilraeraroMoB repMaHr{r noA clofiAaHHyro 3aAarry rryreM r4HTepKzrrrrrlr4r4orrr{TaKcr4anbHororpaSenaHanoAJro)KKe Ni(l11).lauuueQoroolruccr.rousoficrIeKTpocKoIII4t4c yrJIoBbrMpa3perrreHr4eMAeftcrBrrreJrbHocBr4AerenbcrByroro6 ocla6leHytuIcBt3I4 c rIoAJIo)Kroft, o4naKo rlocne I4HTepKarrrq[r{ repMa]Hufl Bce eilIe MoxHo sa6lroAarscocro{HutNi3d Ha ypoBue Oepuz.

HacromroHaJrr4rrr4e3Trrx cocroquuft BJrr4rer Haceoftcrsa rpaQena vlr'e flBrflercfl rrv nperrrrcrBr{eM AJrr ero A€LJIbHeftruerokrcfroJrb3oBattus?BceBbIIxelepeqI4cJIeHHbIe3aMeqaHur kr Borrpocbr orHocqrcrI4cIIoJIb3oBaHI,IroloryqeHHhlxB pa6oreMarepuanoB B xaxnx-rz6oK Bo3Molr(HoMyrexHoJrorurxuycrpoftcrnax n 6yAyilIeM, oAHaKoHIIKaKHe 3arparr4BarorocHoBHbrepe3yJrbrarbr14BbrBoAhrpa6oru, r4Hrr B roefi vrepe He cHrDKaroree HayrrHyrorleHHocrb.Taxuvo'3lerrpoHnoeobpasorra, Al,Icceprarrr4oHHa-spa6oraBep6uqroroHuroraql4saHosuraacrpoeHl4e HaHoKoMno3I{ToBHa ocHoBe Hr{3KopinMepHbrx yfJrepoAHbrxHaHocrpyKTYP",trPeAcraBJIeHHatHa cor4cKaHr4eyveuofi crerreHr4 KaHlipr/Luraxr4MrrrrecKr{xHayK rlo creIII4iLIIbHocr.tM02.00.2I -Xuurus rBepAoro rera u 02.00.01 - HeopraHr4rrecKatxlrMl4t yAoBJlerBopaer rpe6oBaHztM n.

9 dlono)KeHrrr o noprAKe [pr4cy]c 2;eHvAyrreHbrxcreneseft>)yrBep)ICAeHHorollocranoeJreHr4eMllpanzrelbcrBa P@ or 24.09.2013 Ns842, a eeaBTop, 6esyclonno, 3acnylcl4Baer nprrcy)KAeHr4rucnouoft yveuofi crerreHr4 KaH4.u11araXI4MI4rIeCKI4XHayK.OQuuuanrurrftouuoHeHT,HayK,AOKTOpXr4MUrreCKVX3aBeAyrouufitaioparcpuefi reporcz4rrbrxcoeAr4HeHr{fiu uarepr4iuloBHar4xocHoBeI4OHX rau.H.C. Kypnarona PAHfI.B.

llpurxoAqeHKoflogrucr lI.B. llpuxoAqeHKoV.reHHfi ceKperapbITIOHX rarra.H.C. Kypnarolt999l, MocKea,JleulrucxzftTe;r.:*7(495) 955-48-50, prikhman@gmail.comA.A. Boumun.II.T.H..