Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Статистическая теория структуры хроматина)

OT3bIB(puquzurrHof o ornoHeHra Ha Ar{cceprar1nonH},ro pa6oryoHa:apona JleouuAa lfropenu.ra6.CrarucrurrecKaq reoprrflcrpyKTypbrxpoMarr.rHa",npeAcraBneHHyro Ha col4cKaHue yvenofi creneHl4 Ka:r.4z,AaraSra:Hxo-uareMarr4qecKr4x HayKrocneIII4 tulbHocrl4 02.00.0 6 - Bucorovonerynf,pHbreco eAr.rHeHr,rtrfiuccepraqux II.w. Hasapona rpeAcraBnrer co6ofi Teoperr4qecKoe vccrreAoBaHr4e$zsuuecxzx acIIeKToB rlpocrpaHcrnennofi opraHr.r3arlrzr{ BeruecrBa xpoMocoM B flApegyKapl4orl4'recxofi KJIOrKI4.Cpa3BI,ITpIeM gKcnepI4MeHTaJIbHbrxfeHerl4rlecKoro MarepuaJra B Jll4TeparypecAenano aKTyaJIbHbIrra pa:pa6orKyaHaJrH3a.I{6rrlMeroAoB r4ccrenoBaH7sHaKorIneH orporr,rurrfi Maccr4B uH(foprraaqr{H, qroanpo6aqurc pa3ntlqllbrx MeroAoBB pe:ylrrare 6nnpr nonf{eHbl AaHHbre o crpyKTyp e uefocrarr,rcrrzrrecKoroilvraavrprKe xpoMocoM, Korophre, BcBoro oqepeAb, rlorpe6onalu Susrzuecxofi IaHrepnperar\r4n.

llocxolrxy B cocraB xpoMocoMBXoAf,r 6I'rororu'recKlIe MaKpoMoJleKynhr (AHK, PHK, 6enru), oco6esnocrlr vrx noBeAeHr.f,oKa3anocb BO3MOXHbIM I43r{arb B paMKax MoAeJIbHbrx crrcreM c r4cfroJrb3oBaHl4eM Teoperr4rrecKHxMeroAoB crarl4crl4qecxoft (praavxll MaKpoMoneKyn.fiawuaxfltrotryJl{pHav 6ucrpopa3Bl{Baercg.

WccreroBalvrs,,o6lac6B Hacro.flrrlufi rraonnenr oareHbBbrrloJrHeHHbre cor4cKareJreM,HaxoAgrcr Haocrpl4e HayrlHofo IlollcKa, a HX nOCTpOeHHhre r4M MOAeJIr,r Mofyr cyrqecrBeHHo nOMOrrbKaKpa:pa6orxe ieopuz, TaK H B aHaJII43e sKcnepl4MeHTaJrbHbrx AaHHbrx. B srofi cBs3r.{aKTyaJrbHocrb[paKTI{aIecKalI 3HarrrlMocrb Al4cceprarluonuofi pa6orrr He Bbr3brBaror coMHeHr4fr,.B14a ee HavqHa,UEHHOCTb TAKX{E I,IMEET BCE IIIAHCbI OKA3ATbC' HA BbICOKOMYPOBHC.[uccepralll4{ cocrol4T I43 BBeAeHI{tr, nrrreparypHoro o6:opa, rrerhrpex fJraB c onrrcaHr,reMoprlrlnHaJlbHblx pe3ynbraroB, BbrBoAoB u cnracKa nr4Teparypbr.

Pa6ora r43noxeHa Ha107crpaHr.ruax, coAepxnTBo Bnelenrau105 nrareparypHbrx r{crorrHr4Ko s m 3gpr4cyHKoB.o6ocnoBaHa cBr3b MelKAy aKTyanbHoitAls MoJreKynflpuoft 6uoloruznpo6nerr'rofi plccneAoBaHl{.fl yrIaKoBKpI feuer[qecKoro Marepr4anaTeoperI4qecKI4MI'I 3an.a'{aMvr, Koropble MolKHo c$opnrynupoBarbacrIeKToB.\prrBKJreroqHoM .sApe14alanrrce ee noJrr.rMepHbxPesylrraru, Koropble yAanocb noryrr[Tb cozcKareJrlo npr4 pIXpelregr4l{,rlpeAcraBneHbl B BI4Ae rloJloxenrafi, BbIHocI4MbIX Ha 3alrlrrry.

llo4po6no orl.rcaHacrpyKTypaAr4cceprarlnonnoft pa6oru.B nepeofi rJIaBe coAepxlarcr o6sop Jrr..rreparypbr, cocrorrquft us 4ny< 6onrurr4x piprenoB.B nepnon'rI43 HHX npeAcraBneHbl coBpeMeHHbre Aocrr4xenr.rflMoneKynxpuofi 6uolorHu e o6racrusKcnepI4MeHTaJIbHbx IEccle4onanrafi Mynbrl4Macmra6uofi crpyKTypbr xpoMarr.rHa.Kparyoorll4caHo crpoeHrlev6zonoru'recKlle Synr<qvn xpoMocoM,a raKxe $usuuecxzeocHoBbrsKcrIepI{MeHTiuIbHbx MeroroB Snyopecqenmrofi ru6pn4usa\vuXpoMocoM,crIoMolIIbIo Koropbrxrlonflalorvr<ousopuarlr{oHHoro 3axBara.4aHHbIe uu(poprraaqzrcorpocTpaHcrBeHHoMpacllonoxeHl{I4 pa3n[qHblx r{acrKoB xpoMocoM 14 r,rx B3ar,rMHbrx rrepeMeuleHr4rxB xoAeBHyrpI'IflnepHbIX npoqeccoB. I4gloxeurr coBpeMeHHbre rrpeAcraBneHnfl o xpoMocoMHhxreppl'ITopl''IsxI{ oOlelrsoficrpyKType orneJlbHbrx xpoMocoM. Bne4eno roHsrpreoMarpr4rleBHyrpI{qenHbIX KoHTaKToB, onl4caua zn$opMallas., Koropyro MoxHo ronyqr4Tbrrpr4 eeaHaJrr.r3e.llpune4enuAaHHbIeoAI4HaMI{Ke KoHIIeBbrx yqacrKoBxpoMocov.BrIeJroM, HecMorpr Ha6onrnrofi o6reu nepnnuuoft gKcnepl4Menra;lrnofi rznsopr'raqnn, raHlrtxrns r4HTeprrperar\vrvHa$usrzuecxoM ypoBHe rloKa HeMHofo, tITo 4aer 6omruofi upocrop An.s [ocrpoeHr4fl pa3nr4qH6rxcrarr4qecKlzxtt4r4HaMrrrecKr4xruo4eneftxpoMarrlHa.Bropofi pa3nen o6eopuofi rJIaBbI nocB{rrleHcratucrfl'{ecl(ofi$rasHr<ra MaKpoMoneKyn,orrrrcanr4ro r43BecrHbrx ruo4ereftKoropbre 6r,rrru ucrroJrb3oBaHbr cor4cKareJreMAl4ccepralluoHHofi pa6ore.

Bne.4eno rIoHsrI,IeoBoft u rno6ylxpHofi xoH$opMarlr4sxuoluuepuoft qell4 u rlepexoAe MexAy HIIMII. llo4po6no npoaHaJru3r.rpoBaHa MoAeJrb vrrny6xonBo3MoxHbIe MexaHI43MbI QopiuuponaHzr cxla4uarofirno6ylsr, Koropas rocoBpeMeHHbrMrIpeAcTaBneHI4sM yAarIHO oIIr4cLIBaeT rIpocTpaHcTBeHH)'Io opraHl,I3arlr4lo xpoMaTrlHaB KJIeTOIIHOMa4pe. ConocraBJIeHbI crarlrcrl4rlecKlIe xapaKTeprrcrr4Kkr cKra.qtrarofi ra pery;rapHoft mo6yl,aTaKXe pacuraBa KonbIIeBbIx MaKpoMoneKyn. Anrop no4po6Ho o6cyx4aer aJpopr.rrMbr,rIo3BoJItIolIII4e QoprrarzponaTb cKraAqarylorro6yny BMoreJrbHhrx crrcreMax, [ocKoJrbKypa:pa6orxa raKux anropnTMoB cocraBJl{er oAHy r{3 KnroqeBhrx 3aAaq ero zccre4onaHzfi.flpzne4eurr pe3ynbrarbl Teoperl4r{ecKoro alaJrvr3a uan6oree r43BecrHbrx uo4ereft.rlrrHaMr.rKr{MaKpoMoJleryl (tuo4enu Paysa,3vrralra, penraqufi, .qr,rHaMr{Kr4 rronr,rMepHbrx xoneq).IrlgnoxenuocHoBhI rvccvrrulkrBHofi AuHaN{r4:rla rracrvll- oAHoro rI3 uara6olee [onyJrrpHbrx rro.4xoroBMe3ocKonl4'recxoft MoneKyntpuofi 4nuauI4KH, I{cnoJlb3yeMofo B KoMnbrorepHoMMoAeJIHpoBaHLrurlo JrI,IMepHbX CpICTeM.Bo ntopofi fJIaBe I{3noxeHa crarl4crur{ecKaflMoAeJrb, rlo3Borrsrcqat Ha KaqecrBeHHoMypoBHe oorscHzrr oco6eunocrv crpoeHrlt rI4rII4qH6x Marpr{u BHyrprzrlenHbrxKoHTaKToB,rlocrpoeHHblx rlo sKcnepI'IMeHTaJIbHbIM AaHHbrM MeroAa r<on$opuarlproHHoro 3axBaraxpoMocoM.B pauxax srofi raoAenu yraercs.I4nreplperlrpoBarb AoMeHHyro crpyKrypyHepapxl4rlecKylo BHyrpeHHIoro crpyKTypy raKr.rx AoMeHoB14MaTprdrlbr KoHTaKToB,KpyrrHoMacllrra6Hyro cerperarlurcMarpI'IqHbIX cefMeHTon.

llpe4noxeH opl4rl4ua-irruufi anropr4TM KoHAeHcarIr{r4MaKpoMoJreKynhrBcKilaArlarlro ruo6yly, IIo3BoJItIoqufi npe4craBllTb r4epapxarc cKnaAoK B Br4AeAepeBa Ksrlr Hpaccqlararb crarl'Icrl'IqecKl{e Beca KoHTaKTOB MeXAy pa3nr4qHbrMr,r MoHOMepaMr.r.BaNnrrnr(paxropon'r {BJlrercs rerepononl4MepHocrb cKnaAbrBaenaofi ruaxpoMoJreKyJrbrr,r yrrer Bo3MoxHocrr4KoHTaKTa MexAy 3BeHbtMt4 pa3HbIX MaKpoMoneryn. Ycpe4HeHlzeno BceM peanr43arlarM rrpoqeccacKJraAbrBaHr4q fro3BoJr.r{eT paccqr,rTaTb 3HaqeHl4fl SJIeMeHToB MaTpr{qbl BHyTpr4rIenHbIX KoHTaKToB LIcorIocTaBHTb pe3ynbrarbr c 3Kcnepr,rMeHTaJlbHbrMr,r AaHHbrMr4.Tpemr rJraBa rrocB.f,rqeHa MeroAaM co3AaHufl crpyKTypbr cxra4varofi rro6ymrKOMIIbIOTOpHOM SKCIIOpIIM9HT9, SKOHOMI4IIHOMnO OTHOIII9HLIIO KBBbITIITICJII{T9JIbHbIM peOypOaM.MeroA KoH(bopMarlr4oHHo-3aBr4cr4Moro crrHTe3a rrpeArronaraer rrocrpoeHr,re KoHAeHcupoBaHHorococrorHrafl norzuepuofi rleflr{ KaK TpaexTopl,rr4 cnyqaftHoro 6ryN4anrar qacrkrrlbrcaMonepece.reuufinpI,r6esHaJrkrrrilvr KoporKoAeficrnyrorqero rroreHur{aJra [pr.rr.f,xeHur Kco6creeHHoMy cneAy.

Pacqer ros$(fuqueHra 3ay3neHHocrrr rpaeKTopr{r4 rro3BoJrfler yrBepxAarb,rrro 3arlelreHus B rrocrpoeuuoft raxurra o6pa:olr crraAqaroft rro6yre He Bo3HHKaroryBerlF{eHr4rl ee AJrr{Hhr Ao 30000 3BeHbeB, B orJrr.rqueKoHTaKToB Ans cKraAqarofiLlcKnroqeH[erraorpaBHoBecuoftnprdrro6yrsr. Marpnqauo6yJrbr r{Meer ece oco6eHHocrr4, na6moAaeubre B gKcrrepr.rMeHTe, 3aroHxofi crpyKTypBr, qro cBs3blBaercscorcyrcrBr4eM ferepo[onrzMepHocrr.rAannofi MoAeJrr4.

B xaqecrne lper{MyrrlecrBa MeroAa rconQopuaqrroHHo-3aBracr4MoroBcr,rHTe3aorMeqaerc.fl cra6umsocrs crarncrrrqecKr{x csoftcre no:nnxaroulefi crpyKTypbr nplrMOAenlIpoBaHI,II4 TerrnOBOf O,4BLr}IteHr{.SCOCTaBI'IOTUIX ee MOHOMepHbTX 3BeHbeB..{anee paccMorpeH anbrepHarprnnrrfi Mero,q rrocrpoeHr,rfl [onr4MepHbrx KoJrerI Ha rax3ror [oIXoA rrpeAnonafaer $opnavponauuecocroflHr.rr nornrr,repuofi qerrr, onucannofi BoKpyr rpexrr,repHoftHa3hlBaeMbrx pemeroqHbrx xr4BorHbrx.KoHAeHcr{poBaHHoroApeBoBI,IAHoft pemero.rHofi crpyKTypbr, Koroparlcrporrrc{ rryreM rronaroBoro Ao6anresnsnernefi, coeAr4Hrrouprx coceAHrle y3nbr perrerKkt.

Taxax Mo,4enb HecKonbKo xyxe Bocrrpol43BoAr4TcrarllcrllqecKlre xapaKTeplrcrprKr.r cKna.{rlarofi rno6ynu (ycpe4ueHHbrepaccTorHr,r{ MexAy 3BeHb_flMr.r r.r BeporTHocTr43BeHb-flMl,t BAonbB pa6oreSopuraponaHplroqenu)In, KpoMe}rxroro, Hecra6IanrnaKoHTaKTa3aBr4cr4Mocrr4 KBaAparaoT paccTorHr4r MexAy3THMr4B AlrHaMr,rqecKlrx oKcnepI,IMeHTax.orrr4caH TaKXe MeroA nepeAaqu qerrta, peaJrr,r3yrouuitcrra4uarofi uo6ymr rryreM orlrlenneur{rguuavuqecxufi noAXoAr.r [epeHoca KonbrleBbrx yqacrroBBAoJIb npocrpaHcrBeHHo-3arlomrxrorqeft npunofi. fiattuar. MoAenb rircnoJrb3oBaHaHccJIeAoBaHr4.rr Ar.rHaMr{rrecKrirxKcsoficrn crraAqaroft uo6ylrr, pe3ynbrarbrAJr-rrKoropbrxnpeAcraBneHbr B uereeprofi fJraBe.TperrxrJraBa coAepxr4T TaKXe onucaHze aJlroplrrMa, rro3BoJrrlorlefo rrpoaHaJrrr3l4poBarbcrpyKTypy Marpr4rlbr BHyrpr{qenHbrx KoHTaKToB, He orpaHr,rrrr4Barcb pacqerou ua6moAaeMbrxBflora3ano, rrro cyrqecrBoBaHr4e uepapxrrr{ecKoro noprAKaBoKcrrepr4MeHTe napaMerpoB.opraHrl3arlur{ Bnyrpr,rcrpyKTypHbrx AoMeHoB MoxHo o6napyNrarbcrroMorqbro cneKTpaJrbHbrxMeroAoB KoMrIJIeKcHofi reopuu cerefi.

llpone4eunrrfi anarus HarnflAuo rroKa3brBaer pa3nu:.tus.MexAy Marpr,rrlaMr{ BHyrpuuerrHbrx KoHTaKToB Ars npzeofi fleano, cItrta4uaroft u pannonecuofirno6yn.B uerneprofi rraneAano creftJrr{HroBoe orucaHr{e au(f$yszu MoHoMepHoro 3BeHacrclaAqarofi rno6yne. llpe4noroxeHr4r o roM, qro rcaxAufi MoHoMep BoBJIeKaer BcoceAHr{e B rrpocrpaHcrBe 3BeHb.f,, rrrlcJrogKcrreprirMeHT€rJrbHbrMr{ AaHHbrMr4.orABI4)KeHI4eKoropbx orlpeAensercfl npocrpaHcrBeHHoft crpyxrypofirro6ymr, u o6 orcyrcrBrlr4 e Hefi 3arle[neHr{fi, npuno4rrcMerueHr4{ MoHoMepHofo 3BeHaBBpeMeHIlK 3aBr.rcuMocrr4 cpeAHeKBaApar}rqHoro<M2>P't, xoporuo couacytorleficrMo4erupoBaHl{e MeroAoM DPD aaer .rym 6oneecrrJraBn}afoBpeMeHHyro 3aBncrrMocrb c rroxa3aretrcw 0.374+0.008, B To BpeMr KaK aHaJlorrlqHafl 3aBl{cl{MocrbAns paBHoBecnoftrro6yruBoclpor,r3BoAr4Tcs 6oree roqHo.flstas. fJraBa Ar{cceprarlr4r4 crour HecKoJrbKo oco6Hsrou, [ocKoJrbKy n uefi paccMorpeHaTeoperr{qecKas MoAeru ueo6paruuofi agcop6ryuu rroJrHocrbroclyuafinoro 6nnapnorocorroJrr,r-Mepa Ha oAHoMepHlro rroAnoxKy anaJrofurrHoro crpoeHras.

floKa3aHo, tITo rIpI4 Bo3MoxHocrlrunorocrofinofi yKnaAKr,r 3a crrer o6pa":onauur cKnaAoK nepxuufi cnoftgKBlrMoJrbHofo cocraBacoBpeMeHeM rrprrHr4MaercorronllMepaBluI krryeurcnofi uepe4yrorqeftcx [ocneAoBa-TeJrbHocrr4 3BeHbeB. CAeraHa acr4MllTorprqecKar orIeHKa 3aBlrclrMocrlr gHepu.rr,r agcop6upoBaHHoro conoJrLrMepaor eroMoxso cAenarbAJrr4Hbr, coBrraAaloular c pe3yJrbraroM qr,rcreHHofo pacqera.BbrBoA,trro BAr4cceprarlHoHnofiMareMarrarrecKr4x rrao4erefi, orrr{cbrBaloturrx Bo3Hr,rKHoBerIr4epa6ore paccMorpen prAra ceoficrsacocrosnufi 6raororraqecxzx MaKpoMoneKyn.