Отзыв оппонента Пудалова В.М. (Многощелевая сверхпроводимость допированных купратов)

T ~ M ~ T, ~RP K~ c~c ~ ~ T ~ ~ H o Hpa60~b1H o % H e T e p R e T CBOIOaKTYZlJIbHOCTb, HeCMOTPR H a 3 ~ a 9 H ~ e J I b H b l fCPOKi(OKOJIO 30 J I ~ T ) , I I P o L U ~ A L U H ~CO~ BpeMeHHOTKPbITHR KYnPaTHbIX CBePXllPOBOAHBKOB. M H T ~ C~~~a yc 9 ~ 0TOYKHfi3 P e H H R CBR3aH C TeM, 9 T OAKW~JI~HOCTU ~H O B U 3 H a TeMaTUICEi.OCTWTCR H e A 0KOHUa P e U e H H b I M HCBepXIIpOB0,QHMOCTHIIapaMeTpa B3THXBKYnPaTHbIXMaTepHZLJIaX,CHMMeTPHXTaKHeBOnPOCbI, KaK MeXaHM3M11 CTPYKTYPaCBePXIIPOBOAIILQeTOCBePXIIPOBOARLqHXA ~ pH~ 3 J I H Y H b I X IlpaKTEIYeCKEIXKOHAeHCaTOBBn p H J I 0 X e ~ H f iH ~ O ~ X O A H M OBTCIIe T 0 3JIeKTPOMaTHHTHbIe C B O ~ C T BB ~cJIoIIcTo~~ C p e A e H p a 3 J I H 9 H b I e IIpOXBJIeHkiR.

no6oneeMaTepIIZLJIaX,BTCn,KOJIJIeKTHBHbIe MOAYMHOT030HHbIX CBePXIIPOBOAHHKaX.TaKXeH AHCKYTHPYIOTCRnoJIHoe3HaHkieBHYTPeHHerO3 @ @ e ~Axo?e@co~a~aB3THM IIPHYHHaM OCTaeTCR ~ K T ~ Z L J I ~ HT eOM~ a~T H K a AHCCepTauEIHw e J I e G B C B e p X n P O B O A R w e M CIIeKTpeBTCII KyIIpaTOB-CJIOHCTbIXOIIpeAeJIeHHe 3HepreTHseCKMXII H 3 y s e H H e 3JIeKTPOMaTHIITHbIX C B O ~ ~ C T BAXO~~@COHOBCKHXKOHTaKTOB.B B ~ A ~ H CBOAKHHR,OCHOBHbIX~ E I T I I P Y ~ M OJlPiTepaTYPbI~~(111A H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~OE ~I R~ ~ MB O119M CTpaHHU COCTOHT 113 IIRTH TJIaB,Pe3YJIbTaTOBHBbIBOAOB,~ ~ K J I I O Y ~ H I I Xa, T a K X e C n H C K aH~HM~HOB~HM~~).fnaea 1 (coepxnpooodxque cooiicmoa ~ynpamoo)11MeeT 0630p~b1iiX a p a K T e p .

B ~ e iIiI p a B e A e H0630~ K P H c T Z L J I J I H ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ CTpYKTYpbI p ~ 3 J I H 9 H b I X a 3 BTCn MeTaJUIOKOCHAOB,C B e p X I I p O B O n R ~ H XC B O ~ ~ C TMaTepHZIlOB,BHeIIOCpeACTBeHHO CBX3aHHbIX C T ~ M OAEICCePTauHH,~OCHOBHbIeCBeAeHHX0CTPYKTYPeweJIeGBCBepXIIpOBOAriIQeMCIIeKTpe,HMeEowHeCRIIpeACTaBJIeHHR 0 IICeBAOweJIeBOM COCTORHEIII. B b l ~ e J I e H b 1A a H H b l e IIOKa3bIBaIOwHe p a 3 J I H r k i eC B O ~ C T BB H Y T P ~ H H ~ ~B H~ e U H H X C U ~ ~ - I I J I O C K O C TKPHCTaJIJIHYeCKHX~~~PeLUeTKaX KyIIpaTOB.0 6 3 0 ~,QOCTaTOYHOIIOJIOH AJIR IIOHHMaHHR A H C C ~ P T ~ U H O H H Opa60~b1~~H O T p a X a e T COBPeMeHHOeC o c T o R H n e ~ ~ c c n e n o ~ a ~B~ Kl f Oi . H r~ n~a~ b1 ~ewe pa3 c @ o p ~ y n n p o ~sa,qas~,a ~ b ~ peruae~b~fiB, Q H c c ~ ~ T ~ ~ H o Hpa6o~e.Ho~~B rAai?e 2 ( A ~ d p e e s c ~ aCneKmpOCKOnUXxBTCn)YCTaHOBKa,HCIIOJIb3OBaBWHeCRMHKPOTPeuHHeBHCCJIeAOBaHHbIXo6pa3qax.OTpaXeHHR BSNSMOHO-kinJIROIIHCaHa 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHm MeTOnHKa Hk i 3 ~ e p e ~ H fCIIeKTpOBiIIOJIH-aHnpeeBCKOT0OTpaXeHHRn p l l ~ e ~ e ~ Kbp1a T K H e3@@e~~MHOTOKpaTHOTOaKpHCTaJIJIaX.O I I H C ~ H IIpHHQHIICBeneHHRHa06aHnpeeBCKOr0IIepeXOAaX (MHKPOKOHT~KT~X~ ~ J I J I H c T H Y ~ c K o TTo HII~).B rnase 3 (i?fccnedooaHue ~ ~ o z o q e n e o o icsepxnposodu~ocmuis pmymHbzx ~ynpamax)OIIHCaHbI 3 K C I I e p H M e H T a J I b H b I e p e 3 y J I b T a T b I HCCJIeAOBaHHR PTYTHbIX BTCII T H I I a 1201, 1212 H1223 MeTOnOM a ~ n p e e ~ c ~CIIeKTpOCKOIIHHofiMHOTOKpaTHOTO O T p a X e H H R .B rnase 4 ( M ~ o z o q e n e s mcsepxnposodunocmb s donuposa~~bzxBi- u Tl-~ynpamax)OIIkiCaHbI O C O ~ ~ H H O C TAOIIHPOBaHHRHKyIIpaTOB, 3 J I e M e H T a p H m R Y e f i ~ aKOTOPbIX C O A e P X H THeCKOJIbKO CJIOeB C U O ~ .

I I ~ H B ~3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIe~ ~ H ~ Ipe3yJIbTaTb1, n O K a 3 b I B W u H eMHOT030HHOCTb C B e p X I I p O B O A R u e T O KOHAeHCaTa B P R n e C O ~ ~ H H ~ H H ~ ~ .H O B H ~H HAOCTOBePHOCTb.~H O B H ~HaYYHbIXH~p e 3 y J I b T a T O B , Q H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ H O pa60~b1H H O ~ ~COCTOHTB TOM, YTO DJIR BTCII K y I I p a T H b I X C O ~ ~ H H ~C HHg,H ~Bi,~ H TI, C 0 ~ ~ 0HfABYMRiIIJIOCKOCTRMHCu02 B ~ J I ~ M ~ H T ~ RPYHe fOi ~~e~,C I I O M O u b I O a ~ n p e e ~ c ~CIIeKTpOCKOIIHHofiSNS I I e p e X O n O B H aM H K P O T P e u H H e , a B T O p YCTaHOBHJI HaJIHYHe OnHOTO C B e p X I I p O B O ~ R u e T O KOHneHCaTa. An2C O ~ A H H ~ H CH ~ABYMR~H T P e M R IIJIOCKOCTRMH Cu02 a B T O p 0 6 ~ a p y ~CJ'ueCTBOBaHHe,~nIIO~ p a f i ~ eMf ie p e , ABYX C B e p X I I P O B 0 , Q H ~ H XKOHAeHCaTOB.

Ha ~ X O ~ ~ @ C O H O B C K ISIS? X KOHTaKTaXaBTOPOM O ~ H ~ P Y X ~p eH3 0~HIa H C b 1 , H H T e p I I p e T H P Y e M b I e KaK J I e T e T O B C K m M o n a .~ O C T ~ H O B3KCIIepHMeHTOBK ~OTJIHYaeTCR KOHKPeTHOCTbIO H YeTKOCTbIO, IIOJIyYeHHbIe aBTOPOMp e 3 y J I b T a T b I BHOCRT ~ a X ~ b 1BKJIanfiB H 3 y Y e H H e M e X a H H 3 M a C B e p X I I p O B O ~ H M O C T H B KyIIpaTHbDc.COenHHeHHRX. ~ O J I Y Y ~ H Hpe~3 yIJ I~b T a T b I ,QOKJIanbIBaJIHCb aBTOPOM H a HeCKOJIbKHX P O C C H ~ ~ C K H XH MeX.4YIlaPOAHbIX HaYYHbIX K O H @ ~ P ~ H ~ H R X .H ~ K O T 3Oa M~e Y~mIH~R , KOTOPbIe MOXHO CAeJIaTb IIO TeKCTy AHCCePTaqHH:1.H3OIIHCaHHR M ~ T O ~ ~ H Y ~ YaCTHC K O ~( ~r J I a ~ a2) H e RCHO, YTO HMeHHO AeJIaJI aBTOp.BIIaparpa4e2.1OnEICaHbI MeTOn EI YCTaHOBKa DJIH EI3MepeHHII BOJIbT-aMnepHb1X XapZTepEICTEIK EIEIX nPOEI3BOHHbIX.HO YCTaHOBKaEI MeTOn ~ ~ I J I pE aI 3 p a 6 0 ~ a ~ bR1 .Ha.IaJla ~ E I c c ~ ~ T ~ ~ E I o H pa6o~b1.H o ~ ~CJI~~OBX661~ OnaTb~ ~ ~ J I E I K ~n~oEaI Eo I~ a p e ~TeMa,2.2~ .

~ o H o M ~3anOJIrO~ ~ B ~noI MCCbIJIKEIHaCOOTBeTCTBYIoWEIeGonee, s ~ P~c.2.1,2.2,2.8oax npocTo KonHpyIoT. B naparpa4eOnEICaHa MeTOnEIKa EI3rOTOBJIeHEIII MEIKPOTpemEIHbI, KOTOPaR TaKXe 6b1na pa3pa60~aHa~ O H O M ~ ~ ~ EIB OnEICbIBaJlaCb~ I MHeOAHOKPaTHO B CTaTbIIX EI AHCCePTaqEIIIXer0 y9eHEIKOB.PHC. 2.3, IIOCKOJIbKyCKOnEIpOBaH 113 ~ E I C C ~ P T ~ ~ E I Opa6o~b1H H O ~ ~x . x . B a ~3amEIme~~ofi,B MTY B 2012r.CJI~~OBZUIO6b1 naTb CCbIJIKEI H a IIePBOBCTO~HEIK B IIOnIIEICRX KOH3.B npEIBeneHHbIx dI/dV XapaKTepEIcTEIKax 3asac~y1o( ~ a n p .

,Pac. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4)4 0 p ~ JIEIHEIEIape30HaHCa CJIOXHaR EI pa3HaR y Pa3HbIX ~ ~ ~ J I ~ K cTOTo B .@KT H e 06cyxnae~c11.~oJIoX~HEIIIMEIHEIMYMOB H a PHC. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4 EI 4.2 H e COBnanaIoT C IIpOBeAeHHbIMEIBepTHKaJIbHbIMEI JIEIHEIIIMEI. ~ ~ ' ~ S I C3THOM~YHHeCOOTBeTCTBEIH)H ~HeT. Ha P~c.3.2, 3.3 EI,~ a ~ 1 6 o nIIPKO,e e H a PEIc.3.5 EIMeIOTCR MkIHEIMYMbI, KOTOPbIe H e OnHCbIBaIoTCII EIcIIoJIb3ye~ofiEI~~epnpe~aqEIefi.~~'~IICH~HEIJIEIE I IXOTRI,6b1 O ~ C ~ X ~ ~ H 3ETBIXI I MEIHEIMYMOB B nHCCePTa~BEIHeT. Ha PHCYHKe 4.4 IIOsTEI IIOJIOBEIHa MEIHEIMYMOB HEIKaK H e EIHTepIIpeTEIpOBaHa.

Ha c ~ p . 5 9aBTOp neJIaeT BbIBOn 06 0nHoweJIe~ofi CBepXIIpOBOnEIMOCTEI B Hg-1201 EI 1212. HO H a PHC.3.1,3.2, 3.3 EI 3.5 nPEICYTCTBYIoT ApYrEIe MEIHEIMYMbI, KOTOPbIe B nkICCePTauEIEI H e 06cy~nam~c11.5.npEI OIIEICaHEIEI 3KCnepEIMeHTa no H ~ ~ J I I ~ ~ c~ ~HyEn eI ~I e~~f iE I c KB ~~ X O ~ ~ @ C O H O B C K E I Xnepexonax H a ocHose T1-223 n o s m He onacaHbI neTann ~ K C I I ~ ~ E I M ~HeH TonncaHo,~.s ~ EIoK a KEI3MePIIJIOCb. He CKa3aH0, o6pa3eq- KpHCTaJIJI EIJIH IIOJIEIKpEICTanJI. He O ~ ~ R C H ~ HnOseMyO,AJIEIHy KOHTaKTa HYXHO BbIWiCJIHTb, a H e EI3MePEITb He3aBBCBMO.

BooGwe, 3KCIIePEIMeHTbI II0H ~ ~ J I I ~ A J~IerHeTOEBICIK~EIX OC~EIJIJIIIIJEI~~IIBJIRIoTCR ~ a ~ 1 6 0 n cenea 6 b 1 ~MeCTOM nEICCePTauHEI. B3KCIIepEIMeHTe ~a6n1onae~c116onbmoe sEIcno O C O ~ ~ H H O C T a~ ~ EIX~,HHTepIIpeTa~HR HaBII3bIBaeTCII aBTOPOM 6e3 O ~ C Y X ~ ~ H EHPYrEIXIIIBO3MOXWMX IIPH9HH. H ~ nOKa3aTeJIbCTBTTOrO,TO TO - nereToBcKne MOAM. Cornac~xc oxnnae~ofi~ K B E I ~ E I C T ~ H T H O (Pac.5.12)CT~I~HeT.~ T E 3aMe9aHEIR,IOAHaKO, OTHOCIITCII K HOCRT CKOpee K HenOCTaTOsHO K ~ E I T E I ~ H oMaHepe~~a T a m e aMeIoT xapamep n o x e n a ~ ~ f i P ~ ~ B H T B I IY M ~ ~ R I O T06wefi n o n o x ~ ~ ~ e n b ~oqeHKuofinnccepTaum,E I ~ J I O X ~ H E IPR ~ ~ Y J I ~ T ~ BT nnccepTaum,OBn c c n e n o ~ a ~ ~aBTopa.fiOHEI H eIIpenc~a~JIIIIowefico6ofi 3KCIIepEIMeHTaJlbHOeEICCJIenOBaHEIe,IIOCBXQeHHOeaKTyaJlbHbIMHaIIpaBJIeHEIIIM B ~ E I ~ E IKOHneHCEIPOBaHHOTOK ~COCTOIIHEIII. Pe3yJIb~a~b1pa60~b1MOrYT 6 b 1 ~ bEICIIOJIb30BaHbI B BenYQEIX HaYsHbIX qeHTpaX, TaKEIX K a K ~ E I ~ E I ~ ~ EIHCTEITYTc K B ~ ~ EIM.n.H.JIe6ene~aPAH, Ban EIM.

n. JI. Kanaqb~PAH, BHCTEITYT~ E I ~ E I K EMI E I K ~ O C T ~ ~PAH,K T ~ ~I/IHCTBTYT~ E I ~ E I K MeTWJIOBEIYPO PAH, Ka3a~c~EIfiOenepEiJIb~bIfiYHEIBePCHTeT, MOCKOBCKE~ H ~ H K O - T ~ X H H EIHCTEITYT,~ ~ C K ~ MOCKOBCKH~~BHCTBTYT CTaJlEI EI CIIJIaBOB, H O B O C B ~ B P C K~ O C Y ~ ~ ~ C T BY~HHHHB ~~ I~ ~C ~HHaqEIo~anb~bIfiT~T,E I c c J I ~ ~ o B ~ T ~ J I qeHTp~ c K E I(~(K~ YP~~TOBCK3arcnmse~ae. A~ccep~aqarrKym6a~mc~oroCeprerrBJI~AHMH~oBH.I~c t M ~ o r o w e n e s mCBepXtIpOBOAHMOCTb AOIIHpOBaHHbIX KyIIpaTOB)), XBJIReTCX 3aKOINeHHbIM HaJTJ3bIM H C C J I e A O ~ e M .noJIy4eHHbIep e 3 y J I b T a T b I OTJIHWIOTCR H O B E I ~ H OH~ ~ AOCTOBePHOCTbIO,aBTOPOMOCHOBHbIeBbIBOAbI H 3aKJIIOqeHHR, B OCHOBHOM, O ~ O C H O B ~ H ~AI B.

~ o p e @ e p aCOOTBeTCTBYeT~OCHOBHOMYCOAePXEiHHIO A H C C e P T q H H .AHCC~~T~~HOpa6o~aH H ~ RO T B e r a e TIIpHCyXAeHHRYreHbIX~ ~ e I I e H e i i ) ) , YTBepXAeHHOrOP o c c ~ i i c ~ o@i ie ~ e p a q H HOT 24COHCKaHHeyseH0iiCTeneHHK y m 6 a ~ m c ~Cepreii~i3T ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H H (R( ~MO J I O X ~ H H H 0C ~ H T S I ~ P2013RKaHAHAaTanOCTaHOBJIeHHeMr. N~842,IIpeA'bRBJIReMbIM@ H ~ E I K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ ~H~ Ca Kp noH XC n e q m m H o c - n iI I O A ~ EB.M.I C ~n y ~ a n o yAOCTOBepRH3:~a~ ~ ~ B H T ~ J I ~K AHCCepTaqHRM H a@ E I ~ H K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ T E I ~ ~ CHKaEy IKX,B n a A a ~ a p o B ~ ss a, c n y x ~ s a en p~H c y x A e H u r rIIOpRAKea eeaBTOp,yseaoii c T e n e s H KaHm,qaTa01.04.09 - O H ~ HH HK~ K~H XT e M n e p a T y p ..