Отзыв оппонента Арутюнова К.Ю. (Многощелевая сверхпроводимость допированных купратов)

OT3bIBp a 6 0 ~ yK y n b 6 a s H ~ c ~ o CepreiiroBJI~AHMH~oBHY~o @ a q a m b s o r o onnoHeHTa H a A a c c e p T a q a o H H pc t M ~ o r o u e n e ~CBepXIIpOBOAHMOCTbmAOIIHpOBaHHbIxKyIIpaTOB)), n p e A C T a B J I e H H y I O H a COHCKaHHey s e H 0 f i CTeIIeHH K a H A H A a T a @ H ~ H K o - M ~ T ~ M ~ T H Y ~ c KHHa yxK IIO CIIeqHaJIbHOCTH0 1.04.09 - @H ~ H K ~HHSKHX T e M n e p a T y pA H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ H pa60raO H H ~ KR ~ J I ~ ~ ~ ~ H H c KB.A.o ~ o IIOCBRmeHa3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOMyHCCJIeAOBaHHIO O C O ~ ~ H H O CMTH~o ~r o~~ e J I e B o r oC B e p X I I p O B O A R m e r O COCTORHHR, 3JIeKTPOMaTHHTHbIXCBO~~CTBA X O ~ ~ @ C O H O B C K H XKOHTaKTOB H JIeTelTOBCKHX MOD Bo6pa3qax~ y n p a ~ o ~ H g B a 2 C Ca U, .~~~ ~ ~ + ~ + ~ ( O A H O C J IPTYTHOrOO ~ B O O KyIIpaTaHg- 120 1, ABJ'XCJIOeBOrOKynpaTaHg- 1212 a T p e x c n o e B o r o1 C u n O 2 n + 4 + (C~YHcJIoMCUO~H~T~~B~COTPTyTHoro KynpaTa13); 3)A01)KyIIpaTOB:PTYTHbIXPTYTHOrOHg- 1223);2) B H C M ~ T O B ~ I~X y n p a ~ o ~ B i 2 S r 2 C a ~ -HTPHeBbIXHTaJIJIHeBbIXK ~ I I ~ ~ T o B Y B ~ ~ C U ~ O ~ - xI M UYHCJIOM~~ H A P ~ ~ B C HK O ~ ~~C p~a 3 J-I H s~H bC~ ~ ~C U~~ ~ +- I I ~J I O~C K O C TC~ ~IIOMOmbIOT Y H H ~ J I ~ HcOII~K~ T ~ o c K o I I H H .

C O A H O ~CTOPOHbI, CBePXIIPOBOAHMOCTb - @ ~ H , Q ~ M ~ H T ~ . J I RBJIeHHe,~Ho~IIO3BOJIRIOWee H ~ ~ J I I O A KBaHTOBbIe~ T ~3 @ @ e ~ ~ bH1a MaKPOCKOIIllseCKOM YPOBHe,aC~ p y r 0 f i-C B e p X I I p O B O A R m H e 3JIeMeHTbI HaXOART IIIHpOKOe I I p H M e H e H H e B p a 3 J I H s H b I X O ~ J I ~ C T X HXapOAHOrO~ 0 3 R f i C T ~ aB. ~ I c o K o T ~ M I I ~ ~ ~ CBepXIIpOBOAHMOCTbT ~ ~ H ~ RIIpeACTaBJIReT 0 ~ 0 6 b 1 i i H H T e p e C KaK AJIRIIpaKTHYeCKHX3aAaY,COTORHHR.I/ICXOARTaKHCTOYKH3PeHHR$ ~ H A ~ M ~ H T ~ J I@~HH ~oH~K~H KOHAeHCHpOBaHHOrO113 BbIIIIeCKa3aHHOT0, T e M a A H C C ~ P T ~ ~ H O H Hpa60~b1O~~IIpeACTaBJIReTCR B e C b M aa~~yaJIbH0fi.OCHOBHOUeJIbIO~~QeJIeBOMpa60Tb16b1noIIOJIyseHHeHOBO^^~ K c I I ~ ~ H M ~ H T ~ HJ HI ~@HOO~ ~M~ ~ ~ 0HHIIapaMeTpeCBepXIIpOBO~~erOCOCTORHHR KyIIpaTOB.

AJIR nOHHMaHHR RBJIeHHRBTCnaTaKXeH~O~XOAHMOAeTaJIbHOe H3yYeHHeC B O ~ ~ C T B~ J I ~ K T P O H H OH~ ~ @ O H O H H O ~ ~IIOACHCTeM,YCTaHOBJIeHHe CHMMeTPHH CIIapHBaHHR. n 0 C J I e ~ H e e ~p e 6 y eOT~3KCIIepUMeHTlUIbHbIXBbICOKOrO p a 3 p e I U e H U R , KaK IIO 3 H e p r H H , TaK H IIO KBa3HHMIIyJIbCy.CIIeKTpOCKOIIHR,HCIIOJIb30BaHHaRBA H C C ~ P T ~ ~ H O H H pOa ~6 0~T e ,MeTOAOBA H A ~ ~ ~ BH CT yKH H~e JXIbHaRU3MepReTOAHOYaCTHYHyIOIIJIOTHOCTb C O C T O H H U ~C~ X O P O I I I ~TOYHOCTbIO~~IIO 3 H e p n l H . 3 T H CIIeKTpOCKOIIHYeCKHe MeTOAbI AaIOTu ~ @ o p ~ a q o~ rsemismeoc~epxnpo~onsmefimem, ee~HH~OT~OIIHHs,IIOHHMaHHRpa3JIHsHbIXI I p H p O A b I CBepXIIpOBOAHMOCTHHIIpOBepKHTeOpeTMYeCKHXBTCn.-'~ o~ e o 6 x o g a ~AJIRoMusmw Insiiruie of Eiedmnm arc Malh~rnadcjNatlor~alRosearch Unhersly Higlw ktzoul ol Eccmomics (HSFI3 1 Ta!linshaya Mosmw 1234%, Russ~alei : * 7 (495) T I 2 9592 '45173 f a r -7 :495) 91 6 3829 emai!: mien@llse N miern lhse,rU~0AeJIefi5~ H c c ~ ~ T COCTOHT~ ~ ~ H HR3 BBeAeHHR,rJIaB, OCHOBHbIX p e 3 y J I b T a T O B Pi BbIBOAOB, 3aKJIIO9eHHRH CIIHCKa J I H T e p a T y p b I .BO B B e n e H H H o 6 0 c ~ o ~ aKTyaJIbHOCTba~a3aAa9HH c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H ~H~ A a HI I ~ ~ K T H ~ ~ c UeHHOCTH.K o ~ ~~ b 1 6 p a ~ ~ T0 efMi b I A H C C e P T a u H H , C @ O P M Y J I H P O B ~ H ~ I~ a y 9 ~ 0 fHOBH3HbIiaHaJIH3O I I H C ~ I B ~ ~ T C RCTPYKTYpap a 6 o ~IIOo I I ~ ~ J I H K o B ~ H H I~IIe x9 a T H b I XIIOJIy9eHHbIXAHCCePTauHHT e M e AHCCepTauHH - BCerO4pe3yJIbTaTOBHIIpHBeAeH8 Te3HCOBCTaTbH HEIHXCIIHCOKH TPYJOB~ o ~ @ e p e ~ u H f i .n e p ~ raJ I~a B a RBJIReTCR O ~ ~ O P H OB~ ~~ e,f ia B T O pB ~ I C O K O T ~ M I I ~ ~CBePXIIPOBOAHMOCTEIH~ T ~ ~ H O ~ ~pa3JIH9HbIeaCIIeKTbI3TOr03aTw09HOrOH 3 J I O X I m OCHOBHbIe IIpeACTaBJIeHHR 0CYQeCTByIoWEIXRBJIeHHR.Oco6oeMOAeJIRX,BHHMaHHeOIIHCbIBaIOUEIXYAeJIeHOOTKpbITHIoB ~ I C O K O T ~ M I I ~CBepXIIpOBOAEIMOCTH~ ~ T ~ ~ H O ~ ~B C e p O B O n O p O A e HpEI BbICOKOM AaBJIeHHH, KOTOPOeIIOKa3bIBaeT, 9 T O A a X e B IIpOCTbIX COeAEIHeHHRX B 0 3 M O X H a CBePXIIPOBOAHMOCTb C @ O H O H H ~ I MMeXaHH3MOM CIIapHBaHHR 3JIeKTpOHOB.B ~ o p mr J I a B aAHCCepTauHEI C O n e p X H T OIIHCaHEIe TeXHHKH IIpHrOTOBJIeHHR TyHHeJIbHbIXdI(V)/dV-KOHTaKTOB H MeTOAHKH H 3 ~ e p e ~ HI(V)fiHBBTCII - 06pa3uax.

B p a 6 o ~ eHCIIOJIb3OBaJIaCbI I O M O U b I O K P H O r e H H O r O CKOJIaI(V)HdI(.V)/dV-TeMIIepaTypbIHKOHTaKTOB3aIIEICbIBaTbR(T),T e X H H K a IIpHrOTOBJIeHHR TyHHeJIbHbIX KOHTaKTOB C0 6 p a 3 ~ 0(breakjunction)~XapaKTepHCTHKII03BOJIRJIaIIPOBOAEITbX a p a K T e p H C T H K KOHTaKTOB H a M H K P O T p e U H H eHMOAYJIRuHOHHaR MeTOAHKa H 3 ~ e p e H H f iM E I K P o T P ~ ~ H H ~ . I / ~ ~ M ~ P YCTaHOBKaHT~JI~H~RHa~ H @ P o B o ~@~ O P M ~ 3aBHCEIMOCTHBBOJIbTaMIIepHbIeI(V)XapaKTepEiCTEIKEICOIIPOTHBJIeHHRnll@@epe~UEIa.JIb~yIoII~oBoAHMocT~~~~)/~V~T~O~ I P ~ X K O H T ~ KCXeMe.T H O ~ ~~~ B H C H M O C T HI(V) CHHMa.JIHCb@HKCHPOB~HHOTOIIpOH3BOAHJIaCbTOKa.Cd I ( V ) / d V - x a p a ~ ~ e p ~CBePXIIPOBOAXUHXc~~~3aIIHcbIIOMOabIO~ ~ I C T ~ O A ~ ~ ~ C TaBTOMaTH9eCKOrOB Y I ~ ~ ~ ~ OI I e p e M e H H O r O TOKa ( M O A ~ J I R ~ H O H HM~ ~I T~O~ A).

TIIOJIyYaTbBbICOKOKa9eCTBeHHbIeHaIIpRXeHHIO.BOJIbTaMIIepHbIeM ~ M ~ ~ ~IIPOBOAHJIHCbH H RI/~ccJI~~oB~JIHKaKc ~ IIOJIHKpHCTa.JIJIb1MOHOKPHCTaJIJIbI BbICOKOrO K a 9 e C T B aBa ~ mMeTOAHKa(- AJIRHaKOHTaKTOBHaC Y ~ ~ ~ ~ M O H H ~ ~WCe JKI e ~B mRCBepXIIpOBOnHMOCTH.~ H @ ~ O B O ~MOCTaOHIIpOH3BOnHbIeTOKaIIOH BHCMYTOBbIXKyIIpaTOB),TaK HTaJIJIHeBbIX EI HTPHeBbIX KJTIpaTOB.HCCJIeAOBaHHRaHnpeeBCKOr0OTPaXeHHRB06pa3uax P T Y T H ~ I X~ y n p a ~ o ~ H g B a ~CCUa~, O- ~~ , + ~Hg+~1: 20 1 ( o A H o c J I o ~ B ~ R@ma), Hg- 12 12 (n~yxcnoe~arr@ma)aHApeeBCKHXKOHTaKTOBC p a 3 J I H 9 ~ 0 f i C T e I I e H b I o AOIIEIpOBaHHR.B C J I y 9 a e PTYTHbIX~ p e ~ b e fr Ji I a B e IIPHBOARTCR p e 3 y J I b T a T b IIIoJIHKpIlcTanJIHrecKHxMeTOAOMYHHKaJIbHa H A a e T B03MOXHOCTbXapaKTepHCTHKHo6pa3uaxOTBHTpexcnoesmMHKPOTpeuHHeCTpyIcTypaBHa4a3a Hg- 1223.

Y C T ~ H O B ~ ~s H~ oO y,o6pmqaxBAXC J I y Y a e TpeXCJIOeBOrO P T y T H O r O K y I I p a T aHg- 1223 MHKPOKOHTaKTa@a3Hg-1201COOTBeTCTByeTHg-1223HaBAXHHg-1212OAHOU~JI~BO~~IIIapBHHCKOrOIIORBJIRIOTCR A B e He3aBHCHMbIe c y 6 r a p ~ o ~ H 9 e c ~ EU ei JeI e B b I e CTPYKTYPbI,C O O T B e T C T B y I o U H e C y U e C T B e H H O p a 3 J I H 9 a I o U H M C R IIO B e J I H 9 H H e C B e p X I I p O B O A R ~ H MI I J ~ J I R M . ~ ~ ~ B ~ RC T p y K T y p a COOTBeTCTByeT6 o n b ~ ~ oWeJIHfiAopZ49 M ~ BB.

T O P ~CTPYKTYPaHu e n ~A 1 p = 1 2 M ~ B B. pa6o~en p e A n a r a e T c HCOOTBeTCTByeT ~ a J I 0 f i0 6 5 H c ~ e ~ H~e T O ~HOBneHm: p a 3 n H m e B ypoBHeC U O ~ - ~ J I O C K OKOTOpOeC T ~ ~ ~npHBOAIIT,AOnIIpOBaHHR BHYTPeHHHX II BHeLUHHXK B03HHKHOBeHHWA B ~ x ~ ~ J I CBepXnpOBOAHMOCTH.~ B O ~ ~Ha BAXaHApeeBCKHXSCS-KOHT~KTOBH a MIIKPOTpeuHHeHg-1201 6b1na o 6 ~ a p y x e ~ b3KBHAIICTaHTHbIe1OC4HJIJIHqHH ~ O J I ~ L UaMIIJIHTyAblO ~ ~B 3aueJIe~ofio 6 n a c ~ a c ~ e u e ~ ~ ABTOPOMii.npeAnaraeTcxCyIueCTBOBaHHeHeynpyrHXMHOrOKPaTHbIX~ T H X O C ~ H J I J I H ~ H-~ ~o ~ L H c H ~ H I I ~n p u p o A b IaHApeeBCKHX(POHOHOBH 3 J I ) T e H H e M HePaBHOBeCHbIX OIITHYeCKHXB OAHOCJIOeBOM PTyTHOM K y I I p a T e0 ~ p a X e ~ I I fBiSCS -C 3 ~ e p n l e f i , 6 J I H 3 ~ 0 ? f K MOAeKOHTaKTe6apmBCBa-0nJIOCKOCTHX.BY ~ T B ~ P T O ~m~a B eCBepXnpOBOAHHKHAIICCepTaqHHBi2Sr2Can-lC~n02n+4+6HgBazCa,.~C U ~ O ~ ~ +HBJIXIOTCH~ + & ,~JIOKII,CBepXnpOBOAHuHeHHTepKaJIHpOBaHHbIXOsKHCJIOpOAaBHnpHpOAHbIMHCoAepxaWHeIKaJIbqIIeM,qeHTpaJIbHYl0-PaCCMaTpHBaIOTCHT12Ba2Can-lC~n02n+4+6,CBepXpeLUeTKaMHOAHyHJIHTHna60nbmeKynpaTHbIeKOTOpbIe,S-I-S-I..

.,Cu02-KaKrAeS -IIJIocKocT~~~,cIIeficep0~ H r p a e TKJIIoYeByWpOJIbB06pa30~a~~B pa6o~eC B e p X I I p O B O A H u H X C B O ~ ~ C T BCu02 - ~ J I O K O B , KaK H B C J I y s a e P T y T H b I X K y n p a T O B .O ~ H ~ ~ Y X ~ YTOH O ,BAX a H A p e e B C K H X KOHTaKTOB B AOnHPOBaHHbIXAeMOHCTPHPWTH(cneficepb1). B B ~ A ~ HAOIIOJIHHTeJIbHOrOH~H30JIXTOPbIYaCTbCJIOHCTbIeC~~T~PMOHHY~CKYWCTPYKTYPY,Bi-220 1, Bi-22 12THIIllYHJ'IOAJIHHTI-22 120 ~ ~ 0 u e J I e ~ o f iCBepXnpOBOAHMOCTH. ~ H ~ Y ~ HUeJIII,H Hn 0 J I ) T e ~ H o f i ~ H A ~ ~ ~ B CC K~ O~ ?K~ T ~ O C KHOT~Y HH H~ ~~ J ~I ~ H O ~ ~c n e ~ ~ p o c ~ o n aceoisin,a A a I o T B npeaenax 3 ~ c n e p ~ ~ e ~ ~ an onr pbe r~r roa ofciT u .BBAXC J I y Y a e TpeXCJIOeBbIX K y I I p a T O BHaHOKOHTaKTOBBi-2223Bi-2223TI-2223HHTI-2223C H T y a q H H KaYeCTBeHHO MeHHeTCX.HaLUapBHHOBCKOrO T H n a H ~ ~ J I W A ~ I O T CAHB e (HJIH TPH)He3aBHCHMbIX C ~ ~ T ~ P M O H H Y ~ C KWeJIeBbIXHXCTPYKTYPbI, KOTOPbIe COOTBeTCTBYIOT pa3JIHYHbIMBeJIHYHHe C B e p X n p O B O A 5 I ~ H MWeJIXM.

n p e ~ J I a r a e ~ 0Oe ~ ~ H C H ~3H~0H6O~ C O ~ ~ H H O C T HAeHTHYHOHPTYTHbIMBTCIICOeAHHeHHXM: p a 3 J I H Y H e B C T e n e H H A n H p O B a H H H BHYTpeHHHX H BHeLUHHXCUO~nnoc~oc~eii.BIIHTo?~ m a B e A H C C e p T a q H HHpHBeAeHbIHCCJIeaOBaHHHKOHTaKTOBMOHOKPHCTaJIJIOBY B a 2 C ~ 3 0 ~H - T~ 1 2 B a ~ C a ~ C u ~ On O~M~O- w~b cI O ~ H A P ~ ~ B C HK TO Y~ H~ H ~ J I ~ H CneKTPOCKOIIIIH.O~~3aBHCHMOCTH T O K a OT H a n p H X e H I I XMHKpOTpeWHHeBAOnHpOBaHHbIXI(V)Hnep~o?f~ P O H ~ B O A H OTOKa?~MOHOKpIICTaJIJIaXIIO H a I I p H X e H H WCBepXnpOBOAHIIKOBdI/dVHaHaT12Ba2Ca2Cu3010-sIIY B ~ ~ C U ~ OH a, -X a~p a K T e p H C T H K a X aHApeeBCKIIX KOHTaKTOB O ~ H ~ P Y X ~ HeCKOJIbKOHOHe3aBHCIIMbIXC ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M O H H Y ~ CTPYKTYP,C K H XCBepXnpOBOAHHKOB.AOnOJIHHTeJIbHaRIIJIa3MOHOB.CBHAeTeJIbCTBYuEIX0B n o ~ u e n e ~ o t oi 6 n a c ~ BAX~TOHKmCTPYKTypa,T a ~ x eHCCJIeAOBaHbIKOTOPYIOaBTOpMHOTOueJIeBOM3THXXapaKTepeAaHHbIX0 6 p a 3 ~ 0 ~6bma 0 6 ~ a p y x e ~ aO ~ L X C H ~ ~3 ~TF i c c H e f i JIerreTTOBCKHX3 J I e K T p O M a r H H T H b I e C B O ~ ~ C TAXO~~(PCOHOBCKHXB~KOHTaKTOB H aMHKpOTpeQEIHeB(SIS-TH~) H 3 F e H b IAXO~~@COHOBCKOM P e X H M eT12Ba2Ca2Cu3010-s,B<DHcK~.3aBHCHMOCTH KPHTHYeCKOrO TOKa OT M a r H H T H O r O IIOJISI H r e O M e T p H Y e C K H e p e 3 0 H a H C b IO n p e ~ e J I e H a@ ~ H A ~ M ~ H T U ~ YaCTOTaHEMp e 3 0 H a H C O B H CKOPOCTbABTOPIIOJIYYHJIHHX.CBHX~~T~.O T M ~ Y~Ya a 6 o n e e3 H a Y H M b I e H 3PIIA HOBbIX H O P H r H H U b H b I X pe3yJIbTaTOB.K ~ a a 6 o n e eB a X H b I Mp e 3 y J I b T a T a M A I I C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ ~ p~ aO6 oH~Hb 1OK y~ n~ b 6 a ~ a ~ c ~ C.o r B.o CJIeAyeTOTHeCTH:1)~ I c c J I ~ A o B ~ H ~H H~ A P ~ ~ B C HK OT ~Y ~H H ~ J I ~ H OCIIeKTPOCKOnHH~~BbICOKOTeMIIepaTYPHbIXCBepXIIpOBOAHHKOB B i 2 S r 2 C a n - l C ~ n 0 2 n + 4 + 6 H, g B a 2 C a n - l C ~ n 0 2 n + 2H+ ~T12Ba2Can-1Cun02,,+4+6Cn=l, 2,3.2) CnoMowbma ~ n p e e ~ c ~con fe Ki T p o c K o n m onpegeneme c s e p x n p o ~ o ~ ~ r qweei ni H yAOIIHpOBaHHbIxIIOJIHKpHCTUJIHYeCKHX(Tc=120*5 K).Y C T ~ H O B J I ~ H OYTO,YonTmanbHo06pa340~PTYTHbIX K J T I ~ ~ T o B120H 1~ -(Tc=93f2 K)HHg- 1212~ J I H ~ K HKXOnTHMUbHOMYAOIIHPOBaHIIH) IIOJIHKPHCTUJIHYeCKllX0 6 p a 3 ~ 0 ~PTYTHbIX K Y I I ~ ~ T O120B H1 ~ -( o ~ ~ o c n o e ~@ma)mHg- 1212H(~BJXCJIO~BZM@=a),CBepXnpOBOAHMOCTb H M e e T O A H O Q ~ J I ~ BXOa p~a~K T e p .3.