Отзыв оппонента Звездина (Магнитные свойства и локальные состояния ионов Fe в магнитных сверхрешетках на основе Fe-Co-Mo)

O @ H ~ H ~ J I ~ H O I -OOn n o H e H T aH a A H c c e p T a q H I O C e ~ H ~ o Bepb~i iAne~ceeB~b1( ( M ~ T H M TCHB ~O I~~~ C T HB ~ JIOKaJIbHbIe COCTORHHR HOHOB Fe BCBepXpeIIIeTKaX H a OCHOBe Fe/Co/Mo>>, IIpeACTaBJIeHHyEo H ayYe~0fiCTeIIeHHCIIeqHaJIbHOCTHKaHAHAaTaM ~ ~ H ~ T H ~ I XCOHCKaHHe@ H ~ H K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ T H Y ~ C KHHaXyKIIO0 1.04.1 1 - @ H ~ E I MarHHTHbIXK~RBJI~HHG~ H c c ~ ~ T ~ L ( H o HpHa~6xo ~ aC~ H H HB.A.O~IIHT~P~CHOE13OTHOCHTCR K~ M C T P O P ~ ~ B E I B ~ I O I I ( ~O~~ ~J IC~RC T H@ H ~ H K H - MaTHeTH3MHaHOpa3MePHbIXPa60~aIIOCBRII(eHa 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOMy HCCJIeAOBaHHIO MarHHTHbIXCBepXpeIIIeTOK H a OCHOBe Fe/Co/Mo, CHHTe3 KOTOPbIX OCYII(eCTBJIIIJICR MeTOAOMKaTOAHOrO PaCIIbIJIeHHR B Pa3Pme C OCqHJIJIHpyIOII(HMH3JIeKTpOHaMH.YaCTHq.O K ~ ~ ~ J I YTOO C ~AaHHaR,MeTOAHKaKJIaCTepHbIX 0 6 p a 3 0 s a ~ ~ iCi MaJIbIMHaHOCTPYKTYPHbIXC B O ~ ~ C T B KaK~,IIpaBHJIO,MaTepHaJIOB TaKOrOYaCTHOCTH,BMaTepHaJIOBXeCBR3HRBJIReTCRYHHKaJIbHbIMKOJIHYeCTBOMIIpeACTaBJIRIOTpa3HTeJIbHO~CCTI~~~OB~HI~IIaTOMOB.HHTepeC,OTJIHYaIOTCRHCTOYHHKOMIIOCKOJIbKyHXO ~ ~ ~ M HC ~B OI ~ X~CTBOTCOCTaBa.

~ c c J I ~ ~ o B ~ HTaKHXHHO ~ ~ ~ K TaKTyaJIbHb1O BC B03MOXHOCTbIOC I I H H O B O ~3JIeKTPOHHKe.~HXIIpaKTHYeCKOrOB pa6o~e3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOKOJIIlYeCTBOMarHHTHbIXKOMIIOHeHT,YTOCBepXpeIIIeTOKII03BOJIHJIOHCCJIeAOBaJIOCbC pa3JIHYHbIMHYCTaHOBHTbIIpHMeHeHEvIOCHOBHbIe,BB6onb111oeTOJIII(HHaME3CJIOeB3aKOHOMePHOCTHHXMarHHTHOrO IIOBeAeHHR H B ~ ~ H M O ~ ~ ~ ~ CMTe XBAHy RaTOMaMH B CJIORX, M e m yCJIORMHHBH H T ~ ~ @ ~ E c ~@x o, P M H P ~ I O I I ( H ~ OllTHMaJIbHbIeXaPaKTePHCTHKH HCCJIeAyeMbIX HaHOCTPYKTYPHbIX CBepXpeIIIeTOK.c~oiic~sMa arHaTHbIxcBepxpemeToK:~ e p a B ~ o M e p ~ b 1POCTfiHaMarHHYeHHOCTHcTyneHsaTbIeC60nbru~e~ @ @ ~ K T H B Hg~- @I ~~ K T O PKOTOPbIe~I,neTnHllOBbILIIeHHeMMarHHTHbIeHeo6b1~~b1er~c~epe311ca,TeMIIepaTypbI,O ~ ~ R C H X I O T C XAHCCePTaHTOMB03MOXHbIM @ O P M H P O B ~ H I I ~ MKOMlTJIeKCHbIX C O ~ A H H ~ H HOHOBH~~KPHlTTOHOM.AKTY~JI~HOH CHayYHaRT~3HaYHMOCTbTeMbIFeHCO CpeIJe~3Hpye~oiiAHCCepTaqHH HeCOMHeHHbI.a H c c e p ~ a q H RCOCTOHT ~3 B s e A e H m , T p e x m a B , ~ ~ K J I ~ Y ~ aH Hc nRHcKan H T e p a T y pbI.BoBseAeHmonpeaenem1 qenaH 3 a ~ a r 1~~c c n e g o s a ~ ~n pi Hi ,B o A a T c xO q e H K a aKTyaJIbHOCTH H ~ ~ ~ K T H Y ~3HaYHMOCTHc K o ~ ~pa6o~b1,C @ O ~ M ~ J I H ~ O B ~ H ~ IIIOJIOXeHHX, BbIHOCHMbIe H a 3aWHTY.n e p ~ a X rJIaBaO ~ C T O I I T ~ J I ~ H0630~~ I ~ ~ TeOPeTHYeCKHXCOAePXHTI.Ipa6o.r IIO T e M e AHCCepTaqHH.B ~ o p a a rnasanocsxWeHaonHcaHmoMeToAoBC H H T ~ ~EI ~3KCIIePHMeHTaTIbHOTO HCCJIeAOBaHHB 06pa3q0~ M a r H H T H b I X CBepXpeIlIeTOK.P ~ C C M O TI I ~p O~q eHC C~b II HaIIMJIeHHX MarHHTHbIX CBepXpeIlIeTOK, B p e 3 y J I b T a T e3KCIIepHMeHTaTIbHbIXKOTOPbIX B03MOXHO @ O P M ~ I P O B ~ H EKI n~a C T e p O B C MaTIbIM KOJIHYeCTBOM aTOMOB,a TaKXeKOOPAHHaqHOHHbIX C O ~ A E I H ~ HKOMIIOHeHTH~~CBepXpeuIeTOK C P ~ ~ O Y H MKr, K O T O P ~ ICOAePXHTCX~~B IIOJIyzIaeMbIX 06pa3qax B KOJIHYeCTBe A 0 10a~.%.B ~ p e ~ b e f ir J I a B e I I p H B e A e H M p e 3 y J I b T a T b I 3KCIIepHMeHTllJIbHbIXH c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H CTPYKTYPHbIX~~H MarHHTHbIX C B O ~ ~ C T BHCCJIeAyeMbIX 06pa3q0~.ra30MO K ~ ~ ~ T I OYTOC ~ IIOBePXHOCTb,H M e e T OCTPOBKOBYIO C T P y K T y P y C p a 3 M e p a M HOCTPOBKOB A 0MarHHTHbIX250HM H B ~ I C O T O A~ ~0C B O ~ ~ C T BBbIXBHJIHHaMarHHYeHHOCTHMarHHTHbIXCBePXPeIlIeTOKHeMarHHTHbIXCJIOeB.OT TOJIWHHXapaKTepOMO ~ M ~ H H O ~BO~ ~ H M O ~ ~ ~ ~ CnoT B THHXIIyIIOCpeACTBOMPKKHAeJIOKaTIH3OBaHHbIXMeXAyH H T ~ ~ @ ~ ~ ~ H ~ H o H ~H @~ I@M~ HK T ~ M3JIeKTPOHHbIXHIIPOBOAHMOCTH3aBHCHMOCTbCO, YTO 0 6 y c n o ~ n e ~ oBOJIH,IIPHBOAXILI(HMHKKBaHTOBMX XM B CTPYKTYPe.

n 0 J I y Y e ~ b 1HaMarHIIYeHHOCTH HaCbIWeHHX II KOHCTaHTbI ~ @ @ ~ K T H B H O ~ ~M ~ ~ H H T H OaHH30TPOIIHH~ ~CyIzl[eCTBOBaHHeMHYTO@~PPOM~TH~ITH~IMEIHeMOHOTOHHa5lFeMo,KOCBeHHOrO3JIeKTpOHOBTa~xe06~apyXeHa@OPMHPOBZ~HHIO COOTBeTCTByIOWHXCJIOeBHHTerpaJIOBCIIOHT~HHHaMarHHYeHHOCTHO~~OT TOJIWHH CJIOeB6 0 n b m ~ e3HaYeHHXB ~ A ~ H HCCJIeAOBaHHXH ~ I ~OCqHJIJIXqHOHHYIO 3aBHCHMOCTb C I I O H T ~ H H O ~ ~o ~ ~ X C H X ~ T C XOCqHJIJIXqHOHHbIMCJIOXMH1 0 ~ ~~@ .OAJIXC O C T O R H H ~ ~CHCCJI~AOB~HHRCIIeKTpOB 3nPHeKOTOPbIXO ~ P ~ ~ O oB ~ ,~ c J I o B J I ~ H H ~ I ~06pa3qax.~ @ @ ~ K T M B H ~gI XI I o H H X ~ H H O ~Pa3MePHOCTbIO~BbIXBHJIH6onbmme3HaYeHHXB@~KTOPOB, YTO a B T O p CBX3bIBaeT C HaTIHYHeM BbICOKOCIIHHOBbIX C O C T O X H H ~ ~HOHOBFeMOMeHTaHCO, aT a K X e CyWeCTBOBaHHeM 3HaYHTeJIbHOTO O P ~ H T ~ T I ~ H O ~ O3JIeKTpOHOBBHHX.H ~ X ~ P ~ K TAJIR~PH@~~ ~I ~~ OT e M I I e p a T y p H b I e 3aBHCHMOCTH HaMarHHYeHHOCTH H CIIeKTpbIM ~ ~ H ~ T H K3m O ~ ~ X C H X I O T C XBO3MOXHMM CIIHHOBbIM KPOCCOBePOM.B~ ~ K J I I O Y ~ H H nHH c c e p T a q mnpmeAeHbIocHoBHbIepe3ynb~a~b1HBbIBOAbI IIpOBeAeHHOrO aBTOPOM HCCJIeAOBaHHR.BceIIpeACTaBJIeHHbIe Bpa6o~eHayzIHbIep e 3 y J I b T a T b I XBJIXIOTCR HOBMMH.A O C T O B ~ ~ H OnOJIy.IeHHbIXCT~6onbmoro ~ a 6 o p a B3aHMOJ(OIIOJIHIIIoIIJHXTaKXe0 6 e c n e ~ e ~ aHClTOJIb30BaHHeMpe3yJIbTaTOBCpaBHeHHeM pe3yJIbTaTOBMeTOAHK,a3KCIIepHMeHTZUIbHbIMHH3KCIIepHMeHTZUIbHbIXC H3BeCTHbIMHTeOPeTHYeCKHMH AaHHbIMH.H a ~ ~ a HOBH3HarrH IIpHKJIaAHOe 3 H a Y e H H e ~ ~ H C C ~ P T ~ ~ H Opa6o~b1H H O ~ ~C ~ H H HB.A.O ~ ~H e BbI3bIBaIOT COMHeHWI.

M a ~ e p H a nA H C C e p T a q H H H3JIOXeHnOCJIeAOBaTeJIbH0,npeAcTaBneHb1XOPOIlIHMB YAO~HOMII3bIKOM.Anrr~ K c I I ~ ~ H M ~ H T Z U I p~e 3Hy ~J I Ib T~aTbInoHHMaHmBHAe,I I O A ~ O ~ H Oo n H c a H b 1 HllpOaHZUIH3HpOBaHbI.no g ~ c c e p ~ a q ~ op~a 6~oo~ieMOXHOic A e n a T b cneaymqme ~ ~ M ~ Y ~ H H I I :1.B ~ p e ~ b e irnaseiHapymaeTcrr nocneAosaTenbHarr H y M e p a q mPHCYHKOB.Anx2.IIOATBepXAeHHIIKOMnJIeKCHbIX C O ~ A H H ~ HHOHOBH~~llpOBeCTHAOlIOJIHHTeJIbHbIeFerIpeAnoJIoXeHmCO CH0@OPMHPOB~HHHKPHIITOHOM XOPOILIOHCCJIeAOBaHHII,HalTpHMep6b1j-10 6b1HCCJIeAOBaHHFI@ O T O ~ J I ~ K T P O HCIIeKTPOB.H~IX3.n p HPaCCMOTPeHHH3mMOAeJIbHbIx ClIeKTpOB, KOTOPbIe MOrJIHCIIeKTpOB6b1 A a T bHeIIpOBeAeHbIPaCYeTbIH H C l l o p ~ a q H ~0o I I a p a M e T P a XKPHCTZUIJIHYeCKOrO IIOJIII.c ~ e J I a H H b 1 e 3aMeYaHH2,n p e ~ c ~ a ~ n e ~~~t oi ci ci eKOHeYHO,HeCHHXaIOTBbICOKYIOOqeHKyB qenoM AHccepTaqmn 0 p a X a m ~H e TOJIbKO H H T e p e C H b I ep ~ a q k ~ o ~ pa6o~b1.~ o i ilTPOH3BOAHT O Y e H b CHJIbHOe BneYaTJIeHHe.CBOECTB~HCCJIeAyeMbIXo6ae~n p o ~ e n a ~ ~pa60~b1.3oiinonaram,06HapyXeHHb1eMaTepHZUIOB,TOHOHKoJIoccZUI~H~I~xopom~iis a ~ e nAnrr A O K T O P C K O ~ ~AaccepTaqm.~ ~ J I o X ~ HB HA H~C CI e~P T a q H H p e 3 y J I b T a T b I AOWIaAbIBZUIHCb H a P O C C H ~ ~ C K H XH MeXAYHaPOAHbIX K O H @ P ~ H ~ H H X .

O C H O B HPe3YJIbTaTbI~I~O I I Y ~ J I H K O B ~BH ~ Ip e q e H 3 H p y e M b I X XypHZUIaX.A B T O P ~ ~n p >a B~H J~IbH~0 THAOCTaTOYHO nOJIHOoTpaxaeT coAepxaHHe AHccepTaqm.CYMMHPYIIBCe BbIILIeCKa3aHHOe, MOXHOAHCCepTaqHOHHaIIp a 6 o ~ a C ~ H H H O ~ B.A.~YBepeHHO3aKJIIOYHTb,IIBJIIIeTCRYTO3aKOHYeHHbIMHCCJIeAOBaHHeM, COAepXaIIJHM PIIA HOBbIX HaYYHbIX p e 3 y J I b T a T O B H BHOCIIUHMBKJIaA B ~ H ~ H KMarHHTHbIXYI I B J I ~ H H ~A~ .~ c c e p ~ a qlIOm CBO&Hay.IH0fiHI I ~ ~ K T H Y ~ C3HaYHMOCTHKO~~COOTBeTCTBYeTl l o n o x e ~ o~ ~ n o p r r A K enpHcymAeHmy.IeHbIxBCeMaKTyWIbHOCTH,T~~~OB~HHIIMc ~ e n e ~ e i BAKiPO,HaysHb16 COTPYAHkIKkiO@ PAH,AOKTOP 4 ~ 3 ~ ~ 0 - M ~ T ~ HayK,M~TH~~CKHXnpo4eccoprJI.l l o ~ n ~ c3se3jqk1~abA.K.Yre~b1ficeKpeTapb;/@no:3~e3fll-T~A~a~onkIii~OHCT~HTHHOBHYY Y ~ HCTeIIeHb:~RAOKTOP $ H ~ .

- M ~HayKT.n o s ~ o ~ b raApec:ii1 1999 1, M o c ~ s ayn., Bas~nosa,3 8, ~ e o p e ~ k ~ s e oTAenc~k~gTeae&o~:+7(499)135-02-47, +7 499 503 83 3 5&pec s a e m p o ~ ~ oIiIiO Y T :~zI~: e z d i n @ , ~ m a i l . ~ ~ mH ~ H M ~ H o B OpraHH3aqHH:~HH~@e~epliJIb~oerOCyAapCTBeHHOe ~ I ~ A X ~ TFpexAeHMe Haym HHCTI~TYT06qeii 4k13k1~k1HM. A.M. llpoxoposaY g e ~ o es s a ~ ~npo4eccope:AOJIXHOCT~:l7I.H.C. IdO@ PAHH O ~.