Отзыв оппонента Свистова (Дальний магнитный порядок и метамагнитные превращения в редкоземельных франциситах Cu3RE(SeO3)2O2Cl)

A ~ c c e p ~ a L (K.B.m3axaposa n o c B x u e H a H c c n e A o s a H m oMarHHTHbIx CBO~~CTBHOBbIX H k l 3 K O p a 3 M e p H b I X @ ~ ~ C T ~ H P O B ~ HMaTHeTHKOB.H~IX~ c c J I ~ A o B ~ H I ~ ~3K30TIlYeCKHX M a r H I l T H b I X C O C T O H H E I ~TaKHX~MaTHeTHKOB,- O A H a H 3 AHHaMHYHOp a 3 B H B a I o u H X C R B H a C T O R u e e B p e M R TeMaTHK ~ H ~ H KT BHe p A O r O TeJIa.K.B. 3 a x a p o B a I I p O B e A e H b IB pa6o~eHCCJIeAOBaHHR M a r H H T H b I X C B O ~ ~ C TMarHeTHKOBBCE I C K ~ X ~ H HCOT ~PY~ K T Y P O ~K~ a r O M e H a I I p H M e p e CHHTe3HPOBaHHbIXpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIX @ ~ ~ H L ( H c H T o B ~.

K c I I ~ ~ H M ~ H T A~ aJHIH~b IHe IIpeACTaBJIeHHbIe~ I ~BA H c c e p T a U m i A n R ~ O J I ~ I I I H H C T Bc~o c T a B o B n o n y s e H b 1 B n e p s b I e .O ~ L ~ I C Tn ~c cMn eH~ o ~ a n axisin c I I o T c RC U ~ R E ( S ~ O ~ (RE=Y,La-Lu).)~O~C~K p aKepaMEisecKHeo6pa3qb1c ~ a n n a ~ e c ~C Ta pRy K T y p a TaKHX 0 6 p a 3 L ( 0 ~TaKOBa, YTO M a r H H T H b I e HOHbI M e A H CLl2+(S=1/2), P a C I I O J I O X e H H b I eB CJIOXX,0 6 p a 3 y I o T H C K a X e H H Y I o P e I I I e T K y K a r O M e . T a ~ ~ CJIOHl e p a 3 A e J I e H b I CJIORMH HOHOBH e M a r H H T H b I X HOHOB, YTO n03BOJIReT O X H A a T b , YTO O ~ M ~ H BH~ ~ EII M~ OA~~~CTBEIR60nbme, Y e M O ~ M ~ H H ~B ~ ~ H M o A ~ ~ ~ c TMBeHXRA y CIIHHaMH COCeAHHX I I J I o c K o c T ~ ~ ~T. a~axHepapXHRO ~ M ~ H HB~ I~ X~ H M O A ~ ~ ~II03BOJISIeTC T B H ~ ~O X H A a T b , YTO B 06pa3uax 3 T O r OM e X A y CIIHHaMH B IIJIOCKOCTRX CYUJeCTBeHHOI ~C e ~ e f i C T B a~ Y A Y TIIpO5IBJIRTbCR 3K30THYeCKHe C B O ~ ~ C TI IBP ~H C Y u H e ABYMePHbIMKarOMe MarHeTHKaM.B M ~ OO P~~ ~ K THCCJIeAOBaHHRO B6b1n CTHMYJIHPOBaHIIPeAIIIeCTByEoUJHMH HCCJIeAOBaHHRMH M a r H H T H b I X C B O ~ ~ C TPOACTBeHHOrOBMmepana@ p a ~ q a c aC~~a ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~ 0 ~ C l .4.

O~CYXA~IOTCIIPe3YJIbTaTbI KaJIOPHMeTPkIYeCKHX H OnTHYeCKHX~ c c n e ~ o ~BHCMYTOB~IXa ~ ~ f i @P~HUHCHTOBC ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~ 0 2 C l ,C ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~Ha0 ~~Be ~r .l T e p a ~ y p H3aBHCHMOCTH0fiTeIIJIOeMKOCTH@ p a a q s c a ~Ca ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~~ 0a ~6Cn lm ~ a aeH o~Mca .~n m c o o T s e T c T B y I o q a xCTpYKTYpHoMY ( P ~ ~ O B O Mnepexoay.YH a J I ~ l r ~Tl e~ K O GaHOMaJIHH HaXOAHTCXB COOTBeTCTBHH C pe3yJIbTaTaMEI E I c c J I ~ A o B ~ H HOnTEIYeCKHMEI~~MeTOAaMH.n p 0 B e ~ e H b 1H 3 M e P e H H X A H ~ J I ~ K T P H Y ~ C K llPOHHqaeMOCTkIOG06pa31.40~BHCMYTOBbIX ( P ~ ~ H ~ H C E I THaO Bo6pa3qe.4 p a ~ q ~ c Ca ~ ~a B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~~a06~nCml ~ a e p~ ec xs ~ aaH~o M a J I mA a s n e ~ ~ p m e c ~n op ofHi H q a e M o c T E I B pafio~e115 r p a A y c o B .5.

O~CYXA~IOTCIIpe3yJIbTaTbI MarHkITHbIX H KaJIOPkIMeTPHYeCKkJXMOHOKPHCTaJIJIHYeCKEIXH c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H G@ ~ ~ H ~ H C M TC OHeMarHEITHbIMHBPeAK03eMeJIbHbIMH EIOHaMEIH a n p H M e p e k I T P H e B O r 0 @ P ~ H I _ I E I C E ICT~ U~ Y ( S ~ ~T e~ ~)n~e p~a ~ yCp ~ b. ~ e3aBHCHMOCTkI BOCIIPHHMYHBOCTEI EI KPEIBbIe HaMarHHYkIBaHHX BHeIIIHeIIOXOXHe H a KPHBbIe, IIOJIyzIeHHbIe P a H e e H a MOHOKPHCTaJIJIHYeCKETXo6pa3qax BHCMYTOBOrO@P~H~HCHTAHOM~JIHII~.Ha T ~ M I I ~ ~ ~ T Y P H o ~ ~3aBHCHMOCTH TelTJIOeMKOCTEI, COOTBeTCTByIoqaX I I e p e X O f l y ByIIOp5IAOYeHHOe COCTORHHe T a K X e , KaK Pi B BHCMYTOBOM @ ~ ~ H ~ H c H T ~ ,lloc~poe~4 a 3 0 s a ~H-T ~ z a r p a B~ ~ a~ c c n e ~ o ~ aO ~~ J~I ~oCfTnonefiiHH T e M n e p a T y p .

M~TOAOMnopom~o~ofiH ~ G T P O H H OAH@P~KI_IEIH~~0 6 H a p y X e H 0 , YTO B OTCYTCTBHH M a r H H T H O r O IIOJIXp a 3 ~ b 1 s a e ~ c cr ry ~ e n a s e a n IIOJIR.e~B O S I H O B O ~BeKTOP CTPYKTYPbI YABOeH BAOJIb OCH <<C)>,T a K X e KaK EI B C J I F a eBEICMYTOBOrO @ P ~ H ~ ~ I C E TOI T ~ O. ~ C T O I I T ~ J I ~ C Tll03BOJIHJIOBOAEICCePTaHTYnpefinonoxmb, YTO C T p y K T y p a m p H e B o r o @ p a ~ q ~c ocB n~a A~a eaT coC T P Y K T YBHCMYTOBOTO.~O~~O ~ C Y X ~ ~ ~CIIeKTpbII O T C R3CP B 3TOMCOeAHHeHHH n O J I y Y e H H b I e B lTOJIRX MeHbIIIHX IIOJIR M e T a M a r H H T H O r OnepexoAa.

C n e ~ 3CP~ p B n a p a ~ a r ~ a ~o~6 on af ci ~T~e 1M n e p a T y p COCTOEIT E I ~AByX JIHHHfi. O A Hy 3~K a R , KOTOpaX BHAHa BO B c e f i H C C J I ~ ~ O B ~ HOH~ OJ I~~~C T HT e M n e p a T y p , a B T o p a R m H p o K a x , K o T o p a R ~ a 6 n m ~ a n a Tc obn b K o B 0 6 n a c ~ E IBbICOKkIX T e M n e p a T y p . ~ T AHB e JIHHEIH CBX3bIBaIOTCX AHCCePTaHTOM CHaJIHYHeM ABYX l l 0 3 H q H f i HOHOB MeAEI B C T p y K T y p e @ ~ ~ H ~ H c H T ~ .Amee B p a 6 o ~ eO ~ C ~ X A ~ I O T CMarHEITHbIeRC B O ~ ~ C TABPY~ rHX @ ~ ~ H ~ E I C H T O BC H e M a r H H T H b I M H peAK03eMeJIbHbIMH HOHaMH E U ~ ' Pi LU~'. K O M ~ ~ ~ K CMarHHTHbIX H KaJlOPHMeTPHYeCKEIX H C C J I ~ A O B ~ Hn03BOJIEIJIH~~AHCCePTaHTYnOCTpOHTb @X30Bb1e6.H-T A H a r p a M M b ITaKHX @ ~ ~ H ~ H C E I T O B .O ~ C ~ X A ~ I O TpCe 3Xy J I b T a T b I HCCJIeAOBaHHR @ P ~ H ~ H C H T OCBMarHHTHbIMHPr, Tm, Sm, Yb.

K p ~ s b r HaMaTHkIYkIBaHHX,e3aBHCEIMOCTH BOClTpHEIMYHBOCTH, a T a K X e T e M I I e p a T y p H b I epeJ(KO3eMeJIbHbIMH HOHaMHTeMnepaTypHbIe3aBHCHMOCTH TenJIOeMKOCTH kI3MepeHHbIe B p a 3 H b I X IIOJIRX H a@ ~ ~ H I @ ~ c H TC ~n xepB0finap0fi EIOHOB CXOAHbIC 3aBHCHMOCTIIMEIIIOJIyYeHHbIMH n p H HCCJIeAOBaHHH @ P ~ H ~ E I C H T OCB HeMaTHEITHbIMHpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIMH HOHaMH.@ a 3 0 ~ b 1 eH-T A k I a r p a M M b I .B p e 3 y J I b T a T e TaKHX H c c J I ~ A o B ~ H HllOCTPOeHbI~~3THX @ P ~ H ~ E I C E I T OOB~ H ~ P Y X ~ HYTOO,M ~ ~ H H T MOMeHTH ~ I ~ ~H e AOCTHraeT HaCbIIIJeHEIII BO BHeIIIHEIX IIOJIRX BnJIOTbAO30 T. Amee o n H c a H b 1 p e 3 y n b ~ a ~ b~1c c n e ~ o s ac a~M~a ip ai e B o r o EIH T T ~ ~ ~ B ~ B o@I ' ~o ~ H ~ H C C MH T~~ ~.H H CT BHO ~~~IC~TTaKHXB~@P~H~EICHTOBC y Q e C T B e H H O OTJIEIYaIoTCR OT C B O ~ ~ C T@B P ~ H ~ H C H T O BO, ~ C Y X A ~ H H ~P Ia XHee.An2 HHX H ~ ~ J I I O A ~ ~~To CI IRo J I H E I T ~ J I ~ H ~E II~~~K O T ~ M I I ~ ~ ~ T Y P H ~ I ~ ~M ~ T H E I T H@~XI~3 0~~ b 1 f iH e p e X O A .

TOT n e p e X O A COnpOBOXAaeTCRIIORBJIeHHeM A o I I o J I H H T ~ J I ~ H oaHOMaJIBH~~H a ~ e ~ l I e p a ~ y p H3aBBCHMOCTH0fiTeIIJIOeMKOCTH.P e 3 y J I b ~ a ~ bH1C C J I ~ A O B ~ Ha B T~O~p a O ~ ~ ~ J I E I K O BB ~3-xH ~HaYYHbIXIp e q e H 3 H p y e M b I X H3AaHHRX, BXOARUBX B n e p e Y e H bpa60~axBBAK, a T a K X e AOJIOXeHbIaBTOPOM H a P R A e OTeYeCTBeHHbIX H MeXAYHaPOAHbIX H a P H b I X @OPYMOB.H O B H ~B HAOCTOBePHOCTb.~B pa60~eHCCJIeAOBaH H O B ~ KJIaCCI ~ ~ @PYCTPEIPOB~HH~IXKBa3HABYMePHbIXMarHeTHKOB CO CIIHHOM S=1/2.

n O J I P e H b 1 OCHOBHbIe n a p a M e T p b I O ~ M ~ H H ~ I XB ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~3TBXC T BHOBbIXH ~ ~ CO~AHH~HHO~~~ H. ~ P Y XM e~T aHM a~r HIB T H b I eIIepeXOAbI B 3THX COeAHHeHHRX B l l p O q e C C e HaMaTHEIYHBaHHR. ~ ~ O B ~ A ~ H H O ~CHCTeMaTHYeCKOe HCCJIeAOBaHHe MarHBTHbIX C B O ~ ~ C TKepaMEIYeCKHXBO~~X~IJOBCHHTeTHYeCKHX @ ~ S I H ~ H C K E I T ORBJIRIOTCRBC Y u e C T B e H H b I M LUarOM B IIOHHMaHHHMarHEITHbIX CTPYKTYP P e a J I H 3 p U H X C R B TaKHX COeAHHeHHRX.

Y p e 3 ~ b 1 Y a f i H 0L U B p O ~ k i f i~ a 6 o p3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIX MeTOAHK, ~ T P H M ~ H R B I I I H ~ ~aBTOPOMcRBHCCJIeAOBaHHRX 3 T O r 0 KJIaCCa C O ~ ~ B H ~ HnO3BOJIHJIE I ~ ~ ,IIOJIYYHTb AOCTOBePHbIeA a H H b I e 0 M a r H H T H b I X C B O ~ ~ C T B3~TXO r 0 KJIaCCa M a r H e T H K O B H OIIpeAeJIHTb~ a a 6 o n e eH H T e p e C H b I eC @ y H ~ a ~ e H ~ a J I b HTOYKHofi3 p e H H R MaTepHaJIbI,MOHOKPHCTaJIJIbI KOTOPbIX MOrYTG ~ I IIepCIIeKTHBHbIT ~B 6yAyUe~.AEICC~~T~HTpa6o~anB TeCHOM COTPYAHHYeCTBeC TeOPeTHKaMH, YTO n03BOJIBJIO IIpOBeCTHc e p b e 3 ~ b 1 5T ~ O ~ ~ T H Y ~aHaJIEI3C K H ~HOJIJTeHHbIX~3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIX AaHHbIX.n O J I w e H H b 1 e AHCCePTaHTOM A a H H b I e BHOCRT ~ a X ~ b 1BKJIaAf iB IIOHHMaHHeMarHBTHbIX C O C T O R H I I ~ MarHeTHKOB~CO CIXHHOM~ ~ @ O ~ M H ~ O B ~PeLLIeTKaXH H ~ I XS=1/2 H a ABYMePHbIXK a r o ~ en.O J I y Y e H H b 1 e p e 3 y J I b T a T b I AOKJIaAbIBaJIHCbaBTOpOM H a HeCKOJIbKHX P O C C H ~ ~ C K H XEI M e X A y H a P O A H b I X K O H @ ~ P ~ H ~ H R X .H ~ K O T 3Oa M~e Y~a HIH~R,KOTOPbIe MOXHO CAeJIaTb IIO TeKCTY AHCCePTaqHH:1.

Ha PHC. 4.1 OTCYTCTBYeT BCTaBKa, 0 6 e u a H H a R B TeKCTe.2. Ha PEIC. 4.2 I I p H B e A e H b I T e M n e p a T y p H b I e 3aBHCHMOCTB TOJIbKO AJIR 0@ O H O H H O ~MOAbI.~B TeKCTe o ~ ~ ~ ~ H ~ I ~ ~ B E I C H AJIRMOCAByXT E IMOA.~ ~ 0 f i3. Ha PkIC. 4.4H e B e p H b I e n o A n a c H K PkICYHKY. ( C ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~ 0 2 C lC~~Bi(Se0~)~0~Br).4. C C ~ I J I KH ~a C O ~ C T B ~ H H YpWa 6 o ~ y[3] B AIICCepTaqIIEiCOOTBeTCTByeTPia ~ ~ o p e @ e pa aB T~OepIIPEIBOAIIT C O L I I H ~ K ~ M Hy. K X 3 a ~ b 1H e BCe aBTOPbI ZI H O M e p C T P a H I I q b IHesepeH.5.& ~ C C ~ ~ T I~I pHe ATI I O J I a r a e T , YTO CTPYKTYPa IITPkIeBOrO @ ~ ~ H ~ E I C I I T ~COBIIaAaeT CO C T ~ Y K T Y ~BIICMYTOBOTO.O~~B ~ e c C~Tee M ,KPIIBbIeHaMarHHYeHHOCTII 3THX MarHeTIIKOB CYweCTBeHHO Pa3JIIIYaIOTCR.BBZICMYTOBOM, BeJIIIYHHa MarHkITHOrO MOMeHTa IIOCJIe M e T a M a r H H T H O r OI I e p e X O A a COOTBeTCTByeTCOCTORHIIII,a B CJIyYae0.7 OT O X I I A a e M O r O3HaYeHIIR B H a C b I w e H H O MIITPkIeBOrO 3 T a BeJIIIYIIHa ~ J I E I ~K K1.~ B~POIITHO,3T0y K a 3 a H k I e H a TO, YTO B EITPHeBOM COeAkIHeHHH IIOAKOC MOMeHTOB BCOCeAHIIX q e I I O Y K a X OTCYTCTBYeT.M H KaXeTCR,~YTO Y T B e p X A e H I I ea ~ ~ o p e @ e poaTOM,~ e YTO c ~ p y ~ ~ 3y~p0ar oCOeAIIHeHIIX YCTaHOBJIeHa, CJIIIIIIKOM X e C T K O e .

BO~MOXHO,YTOAHccepTaHTa cAenaHHoe B@ ~ P P I I M ~ T H I I T H o@a3b1~~B HeKOTOPbIX COeAIIHeHIIRX C ~ M & C T B ~a p e a J I H 3 y e T C R HeIIOCpeACTBeHHO @ ~ ~ ~ o M ~( n a p a ~ a r ~ s@=a.~~a~)6. Ha @ a 3 0 ~ bAIIal-paMMaX1~IIOCTaBJIeHbI TOYKII, COOTBeTCTBYIOwIIe@P~HIJIIcIITOB HeT,~ H Z I T H ~ RaHOMa.JIHRM H a T e M I I e p a T y p H b I X 3aBIICIIMOCTRX TeIIJIOeMKOCTkI, II3MePeHHbIXOHMCOOTBeTCTBYIOT I I e p e X O A a M k13 H ~ Y I I O P R A O Y ~ H HBO ~ ~y n 0 p R A O Y e H H y I o @a3y.~ O Y ~ MH aY@ a 3 0 ~ bA1I ~I a r p a M M a X H e T TOYeKB P a 3 H b I X IIOJIRX.COOTBeTCTBJWqkIX aHOMaSIHRM H a IIOJIeBbIX 3aBIICIIMOCTIIX TeIIJIOeMKOCTkI,I I 3 M e P e H H b I M I I p H CKaHIIPOBaHEIII IIoJIR?7. npII o ~ c Y X A ~ H H IpIe 3 y J I b T a T O B T ~ M I I ~ P ~ T Y P H3aBIICHMOCTIIO~~M~THMTHO~~BOCIIPIIZIMYIIBOCTII AZICCePTaHT Y T B e p X A a e T , YTO ((HaAeHIIe 3HaYeHIIII113 nPII T e M n e p a T y p e T<TN y K a 3 b I B a e T H a~ H T Z I @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~C HJ I e~r KT oI fIi KOCbIo.)) BIIAHMO,3 T 0 YTBepXAeHIIeCIIpaBeAJIIIBO AJIR KOJIJIIIHeapHOrO ~ H T H @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~YTOH ~ CJIeAyeTT H K ~BOCIIPIlIIMYHBOCTII H a?O X I I A a T b AJIII HeKOJIJIIIHeapHOrO ~ H T I I @ ~ ~ ~ o M ~ ~C HM ~~ TT HI EI IKT H~ O ~ ~c ~ p y ~ ~ y pnopfei~ n a r a e ~ oafBiT o p o M n p H H~JIIIYHII O A H O O C H O ~ ~~HB~oTPoIIIIII?~ T I3aMeYaHkIR,IOAHaKO, OTHOCIITCII K HeAOCTaTOYHO KPIITEIYHO~~MaHepea T a K X e IIMeIoT X a p a K T e pI I o X e J I a ~ k i f iAJIX ~ a .