Отзыв оппонента Поповой (Дальний магнитный порядок и метамагнитные превращения в редкоземельных франциситах Cu3RE(SeO3)2O2Cl)

OT3bIBo @ ~ q ~ a . J I b ~ o or non o H e H T a K.@.-M.H.pa6o~y 3axapo~aI I o ~ o BE.A.o ~ ~H aAkIccepTaqkIoHHym~ O H C T ~ H T U H ~B J I ~ A u M u ~ o B u =< <IA~a J I b H U i iM ~ ~ H U T H ~IIOPRAOICI ~ ~UMeTaMarHUTHbIeIIpeBpameHUHBpeAIC03eMeJIbHbIX $ ~ ~ H ~ U C U CT ~UX~ R E ( S ~ O ~ ) ~ npeACTaBJIeHHyIOO~C~H,H a COkICKaHkIe y Y e H 0 f i C T e n e H H KaHAkIAaTa @ H ~ H K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ T H Y ~HCaKyK~IXno CneqHa.JIbHOCTkI 01.04.09 - @ k I 3 k I ~ aHH3KkIX T e M n e p a T y pA H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~pa6o~aH O H 3axapo~aH~K.B.nocBxmeHa @ ~ H ~ ~ M ~ H T u ~ H o ~ ~~ a y Y H 0 f i rrpo6ne~e @OPMHPOB~H~IIIKBaHTOBbIXHkI3KOpa3MepHbIXkIOCHOBHbIX@ ~ ~ C T ~ H P O B ~ H H MaTHeTkIKaX.~IXHCCJIeAOBaHkIK) HkI3KOPa3MePHbIX MareTkIKOBCOCTOIIHH~~BkIHTepec06ycnosne~TeM,KYTO B 3THXCOeAkIHeHkIIIX pea.JIH3yK)TCII OCHOBHbIe COCTOIIHkIII, H e kIMeK)lL(kIe aHa.JIOrOB BK J I ~ C C H Y ~ C K O@~ k~I 3 k I ~ e .HaB03MOXHOCTbYCTaHOBJIeHHIIAa.JIbHerOMarHkITHOrO nOpIIAKa B 3THX CkICTeMaX CYmeCTBeHHO BJIHXK)T @ J I y ~ T y a q k ~ k I@pycTpaqm k~ a~k130~ponk111.

k I 3 y ~ e ~ ~ eM a r H m H o r o n a p a M e T p a nopRAKa,KawOrOPeIIIeHkIeHOBOrOC e ~ e f i c T B a ~ 0 e ~ k I H e H H fIIpenCTaBJIReTiKOTOPO~~II03BOJIIIeTco6oiiY M Y ~ H T ~ nOHHMaHkIe3aAaYy,xBJIe~kIfi,lTpOkICXOnRmkIX B HH3KOPa3MePHbIX MarHeTHKaX T[PH HH3KHX T e M n e p a T y p a X .B~ H C C ~ P T ~ ~ H O pa6o~eH H O ~ ~HCCJIenOBaHbI C B O ~ ~ C TCJIOkICTbIXB~~0enkIHeHHfiC U ~ R E ( S ~ O ~ ) ~(REO ~=CY,~La - Lu)coc ~ p y ~ ~ y p o Mi iH H e p m a@pa~q~Ac ~K~TaY. ~ ~ ~ pa6o~b1H O C To n~p e n e n R e T c R@yHna~eHTa.JIbHlUlHH@OPM~~HII 0C ~ H H O B O ~ ~IIOnCHCTeMe,TeM, YTO BMarHkITHbIXnO3BOJIRK)maR~ e fnonTIyYeHaiB~~HMO~~~~CTB~IIIXYCTaHOBHTbMeXaHkI3MbI~ O P M H P O B ~ H H I HeKOJIJIHHeaPHbIXIMarHkITHbIX CTPyKTyP kI MeTaMarHkITHbIXI I p e B p a m e H H f i B HH3KOpa3MepHbIX kI @ ~ ~ C T ~ H P O B ~ HKHa r~OIMXe MarHeTHKaXCOC T ~ Y K T Y ~ O@~ P~ ~ H ~ H C H T ~ .O M H M O @ ~ H ~ ~ M ~ H T ~ .

J I kIHTepeCa~ H o ~ oHCCJIenOBaHkIII AkICCepTaHTa BeCbMa aKTya.JIbHb1 AJIX IIOHCKa HOBbIX peIIIeHHfiB O~JI~CT3E~I e p r 0 ~ 6 e p e X e ~ k IK0MnbK)TepHbIXR,H TeJIeKOMMYHkIKaqHOHHbIX~ex~onor~fi.Bo ~ ~ o p or in ia B ellapaI'Pa@OB. n e p B b 1 f iAaHn ~ l ~ e p a ~ y p0630~.~ b ~ i i BTOPMr n a B allapapa@ nOCBRII&3HC u - c o ~ e p ~ a q c~ ox enaparpaeeTaKXeer0onHcbIsamTcxMg)Hanpmepe c e ~ e i i c ~ s aH H ~ o @ T ~ . J I MeAH.~T~BOBTOPOMc ~ o i i c ~ sMaa H e p a n a @ p a ~ q ~C c~ ~~ B~i (aS e 0 ~ ) ~ 0 2aC l ,H3OCTpyKTypHbIX CHHTeTHYeCKHX aHa.JIOrOB Cp e ~ ~ 0 3 e ~ e J I b ~HOHb 1 f HJIHi~ a . J I O r e H aH a0630~C B O ~ ~ C T BMeTa.JIJIOOKCHAHbIX6 p o ~B.TpeTbeM3 a ~ e ~ 0 BHCMYTafiHallaparpa@e l l p H B e A e HC O ~ A H H ~ H HrAe~ ~ , C O C y q e C T B y I o T MeAHaR HpeAKO3eMeJIbHaSI M a r H H T H b I e llOACHCTeMb1 H a l l P H M e P eY, La - Tm).TpexOCO~~HHOCTIIMM ~ ~ H H T HCTpyKTyPbIO~~~ k ~ ~ ec ~ p~e fmi e ~ ~ o fKi aroMe~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ T c MAFCI UT ~H (TO~H ) ~(AC~=Zn,~COCTOHT 133c e ~ e f i c R~ E~2 aC U 0 4 (RE =C ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~CBkIAeTeJIbCTBYeT0~ClnpeAnonoxeHHeBo KOTOPOMIIsI~ofi rnaBe0 CTpyKTyPHOM @ ~ ~ O B O IMIepeXOAeBbIABkIranocbIIpeACTaBJIeHbIpaaee.Pe3YJIbTaTbIHeMarHkITHbIMkI peAK03eMeJIbHbIMkI kIOHaMkIEu,Lu.BOBCeXyKa3aHHbIXHCCJIeAOBaHkIIIHaMarHkIYeHHOCTkICOeAkIHeHkIsIXM ~ T ~ M ~ T H H T IHI e~p eIX~O~AeeCTPYKTyPbI kIIIpkI~ a 6 n I o ~ a e ~ cI IRe p e X O AHeemTeMIIepaTypaXnonxx -2,5 Tn.B@ P ~ H I J ~ I C ~ I T OCBC U ~ R E ( S ~ ~rAe~ )RE~ =~ Y,~ CLa,~ ,~ H T H @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~ COCTORHkIeH H T H O ~ npkI TeMIIepaTypaX3aBkICkIMOCTsIX11 POAa,&IsIB- 35 K.

Ha IIOJIeBbIXHkDKeTNH~~JIIOA~~TCIIkICCJIeAOBaHkIsIM~TH~ITHO~~k I 3 ~ e H e H k I f i IIpkI MeTaMarHkITHOM I I e p e X O A e ~ ~ I J IIpOBeAeHbII ~ IH ~ ~ ~ T P O H H RCCJIeAOBaHkIsI~ I ~IIB ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~AJIIIC TCB ~UI ~~ ~ Y( S ~ ~B ~pe3ynb~a~e) ~ ~ ~ C3THX~ . H C C J I ~ A O B ~~H~~I IJ~I ~OIIePBOIIPkIHIJHIIHbIePaCYeTMO ~ M ~ H H ~ I XIIOKa3aH0, YTO IIpkI MeTaMarHkITHOM I I e p e X O A e IIPOkICXOAkIT T P ~ H C @ O P M ~ I J ~ F I6I~ O A P ~ U ~ T O ~ H O ~ ~ ~ H T H @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~ H H T H O CTpYKTflbI~ ~~ - I I o ~ ~ ~ I I I ~ T o@Y ~HP ~P HIM~ ~THEITH~IOCTPYKTYPY.CTpyKTflaC O ~ J I a C y e T C RC AaHHbIMkIn p e ~ J I 0 l K e H H a s I MarHkITH2i.H3nP, rAe 0 6 ~ a p y l K e H 0 COCyqeCTBOBaHkIeJ I ~ I H ~ I ~ ~ , COOTBeTCTBylOLlJkIXCIIeKTpaslbHbIXBABYMAByxPa3JIkIYHbIMK ~ ~ I c T ~ J T J I o ~ J ~ ~ @ ~ I YII03kIIJHHM~cK~IMMeAkI.

Eb1JI BbIsIBJIeH B K J I W I I a p a M a r H e T k I 3 M aB ~ HQ J I ~ K B~MarHkITHyIoC U ~ E U ( S ~ O ~ ) ~&I2O~CBCeX~.BOCIIPkIkIMYkIBOCTb~ 0 e ~ k I H e H k IIIOCTpOeHbIfiMarHkITHbIe @a30~b1eAkIalJlaMMbI.B ruec~ofir J I a B eMarHkITHbIMkInepexomnepBoropeAK03eMeJIbHbIMkIBToporopoaa@P~HIJ~ICHTrkICTepe3kICaIIpeACTaBJIeHbI p e 3 y J I b T a T b I kICCJIeAOBaHkIsIBpoAa0 6 ~ a p y x e ~ b 1AOIIOJIHkITeJIbHbIeHOHaMkI.B CoeAmeHkItIxC U ~ R E ( S ~ O ~ )(RE~ O=~Nd,C ~ Sm),C ~ ~ Y b ( S e 0 ~ ) ~ H0a~k 1C6 oln.e e n o ~ p o 6 ~o on k I c a HC ~ ~ S m ( S e 0 ~ ) ~ 0 ~06HapylKeHH2i.HC1.HaTeMnepaTypaxpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIXClleKTpOCKOIIkIkI,@~~HIJHCEITOBCI I o J I e ~ o f i 3aBkICkIMOCTkIc~asasa ckIHaMarHkIYeHHOCTkIEIOHOB.IIepBOIIpkIHIJkIIIHbIePaCYeTbIHkI3KOTeMIIepaTypHOrOcmapk~e~b~fi@OPM~IIpkIIIeTJIkIHkI3KkIX~ o ~ ~ y p e ~ s k O~ AeHfOiE I O H H O ~ ~ ~ H ~ I ~ O T ~ O I I ~ I ~ IIIepeXOAHbIXAaHHbIe c n e K T p o c K o n m e c m xCJIOlKHaXH~ P H B O ~ I I T C I I AaHHbIeO ~ M ~ H H ~BI X~ ~ ~ I M O A ~ ~ ~kI C T B H ~ ~~ c c n e a o ~ a ~1103~ons11oqk1e~fi,@ ~ ~ O B O I~I eOpeXOAa.3m-BceonpeaenmbnpkIpoAy3KCIIepkIMeHTa.JIbHbIeAaHHbIeyKa3bIBaIoT,YTOIIpHHkI3KEMn e p e o p a e ~ ~ a q ~ o ~nepexoA~b~ii3KCIIePkIMeHTaJIbHbIXAaHHbIXTeMIIepaTypaXIIPOHCXOAHTpons.ocHosaHmiBToporoBbICKa3MBaeTCRHaCnkIH-aamasaIIpeAnOJIOXeHkIe,YToBC ~ ~ Y b ( S e 0 ~ ) T~a0K~x eC~l a 6 n I o ~ a ce n~ ac~~- n e p e o p ~ l e ~ ~ a q nepexoa,m ~ ~ b ~ iHOinepBoroBpoAa.( m a ~ a 7)3aKJIIoW3HkIkIllpkiBOARTCRV~@EIKEICBOAHbIeEiT~~JIHIJ~I,c @ o ~ ~ ~ ~ J I ~ I OCHOBHbIe~ o B ~ H ~Pe3YJIbTaTbIIEI BMBOAM.C p t 3 ~ 1 .

r~ a k I 6 o n e eB a X H b I X Pe3YJIbTaTOB A H C C ~ P T ~ I J H O H H Opa60~b1~~H~O~XOAEIMOOTMeTkITb CJIeAYIOwHe :-YCT~HOBJI~HO@ O ~ M H ~ O B ~ H H AaTIbHerO~MarHkITHOrOIIOpXAKaC U ~ R E ( S ~ O ~ ) 2~(REO~C= IY, Pr-Nd, Sm-Lu) n p H TN= 3 1 - 4 1 K.-BM a r H k I T O y I I O p ~ O s e H H O MCOCTORHHkI BO BCeX HCCJIeAOBaHHbIX @ ~ ~ H I J H C H T ~ XC U ~ R E ( S ~ ~(RE~ =) Y,~ ~Pr-Nd,~ C ~ Sm-Lu) 0 6 ~ a p y X e ~ bEiHAYIJHPOBaHHbIe1MarHkITHbIMIIOJIeMTeMnepaTypeHeemMeTaMarHkITHbIeIIpeBpaQeHkIR.YCT~HOBJI~HO,YTOnpkI@OPMMPY~TCX C K O I L I ~ H H ~@I ~~I P P O M ~ T H E I T HIIOPRAOK~I~~BHYTPElK ~ ~ o M ~ - c J I o ~I IBp,l l 3 T O M CJIOkI OPkIeHTkIPOBaHbI ~ H T H @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H ~ OTHOCkITeJIbHOITHOApyr Apyra,YTO A a e T pe3yJIbTkIpyIoKL(ee~ H T H @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~ COCTORHkIe.H H T H O ~BnoneMeTaMarHkITHOrO n e p e X O A a IIPOHCXOAkIT I I e P e B O P O T BHeIUHHM MarHkITHMM nOJIeMKawOrOBTOpOrOCJIOREIyCTaHaBJIkIBaeTCRHeKOJIJIkIHeapHOeCOCTORHkIe@~PP~IM~TH~ITHOTkIIIa.TO-C U ~ R E ( S ~ ~ (RE=~ ) ~ ~ Sm,~ C ~Yb)BnepeopkIeHTaskIoHHbIe@a3o~b1enepexoAb106HapyXeHb1BToporoHnepBoroCHHH-poAaCOOTBeTCTBeHHO, O ~ ~ C J I O B J I ~ HB H~ ~~ I ~~ I M O A ~ ~ ~IIOACkICTeMC T B ~ I ~ MpeAKO3eMeJIbHOrOk~ n e p e x o ~ ~ o Mr oe T a n n o B .B KaYeCTBe 3 a ~ e Y a H k I f Ki A ~ I C C ~ P T ~ I J ~ I O Hp aH6Oo~ ~~ eMOXHO1.

BcoeAmeHmC ~ ~ S m ( S e 0 ~ ) ~~0a~6Cn Il o ~ a e ~ccHxn b H o eIIoBeAeHkIe M ~ ~ H H T HBOCllpkIkIMYkIBOCTkI,O ~ ~FC,npHOTMeTkITb:TeMnepaTypaxHtmeTNpa3nHmeH ~ M ~ P ~ HBHP eOX~k I ~M a X(PEIC.6.7Hac~p.100). BAkICCepTaIJkIkI OTCYTCTBYeT 0 6 ' b R ~ H e ~ k 3I eT O r 0 HOBeAeHkIR.ZFCBkITeKcTekIHAyLl[kIPOBaHHbIMBHeLUHkIMHanOJIeM.OCHOBeM~THHTHO~~MOAeJIkICTPYKTYPbI @ ~ ~ H L ~ [ H C T H T O~ B~, ~ A J I o X ~ BH AkICCepTaqkIkI,H O ~ ~MOXHOllpOMOAeJIF.IpOBaTb IIOJIeByIoKOHCTaHTbI K I o p k I4. B3aBkICkIMOCTbHaMaTHkI9eHHOCTkI,6a1no 6b1OlTpeAeJIkIBC OT T e M n e p a T y p b I n p k I @ ~ I K C H P O B ~ H H O M3Ha9eHkIkI 0.TeKCTe AkICCepTaqkIkI e C T b H e K O T O p b I e HeTOrHOCTkI kI O n e 9 a T K k I .IIOAnkICkIKPHC.4.4I?HaCaMOMC U ~ B ~ ( S ~ O ~XOTR) ~ OB~ TeKCTeC ~ , perb64).

OTCYTCTBY~TBCTaBKaK pkIc.4.1PkICYHKeHAeT O,0yKa3aHOT ~ KB,COeAkIHeHkIeC ~ ~ B i ( S e 0 ~ ) ~( ~0 ~~ pB. r6 3 ,K O T O P O ~ ~rOBOPkITCR B TeKCTe H ac~p.62.Y K a 3 a ~ ~ b 3I aeM e r a H k I R H e BJIkIRIoT H a BbICOKyK) O q e H K y pa60Tb1,xapaKTepn o x e n a ~ ~Hf si aPe3yJIbTaTb1,~asIb~efiIIIkIxaHOCRT~ e r a ~ kno~ fCiT H J I I ~H a n K c a H m A k I c c e p T a q m .nOJIyYeHHbIeB AkICCepTaqkIkI,HCCJI~AOB~HH~~M O T T 6b1TbKBa3kIABYMePHbIXnOJIe3HbI AJIR@PYCT~HPOB~HH~IXM ~ T H ~ T H K O B . P e 3 y J I b T a ~ b 1 A E I C C ~ P T ~ ~ I I O H H Opa6o~b1~~MOTT661~bkICIIOJIb30BaHbI B HHCTkITYTaX kI J I ~ ~ O P ~ T O P ~ I X3aHHMaIoUJkIXCRX,npo6ne~a~k1CElJIbHOKOppeJIHPOBaHHbIX CkICTeM kI MarHkITHbIX R B J I ~ H H n~ p~k IHkI3KkIXT e M n e p a T y p a X , T a K H e KaK C a ~ K ~ - n e T e p 6 y p r ~ K k I Kf ir,n a ~ c K k I f i , Y p a J I b ~ K k I f i@ e ~ e p a n b ~ YHkIBepcHTeTbI,b~eIIHCTEIT~T @ H ~ ~ I ~ ~ C K nI IpXo 6 n e ~HM.K a n ~ q b ~~IHCTHTYT,0614eH @k13k1~k1HM.

A.M. npoxopo~aH ~ p .n.J.noHOBkl3He,aKTYaJIbHOCTM3KCIIepMMeHTaJIbHbIX pe3YJIbTaTOB,o6ae~yTeMbI,r ~ 1 y 6 BbIBOAOB,~~e3aKOHYeHHYK) HapHO-MCCJIeAOBaTenbCKYH)pe3yJIbTaTOB,lIpMBeAeHHbIXBAOCTOBepHOCTM~ ~ H A ~ M ~ H TM ~ J I ~ H o3axapo~a K.B.n p a ~ ~ ~ r e c ~~Ho~ Yf Mi M O C T MA a c c e P T a q M xco6ofiMAMCCePTaqMM,pa60~y.~npeAcTasmeTO C T O B ~ ~ H O ~ T ~0 6 e c n e ~ ~ s a e ~BbICOKHMcxYPOBHeM M ILIMPOKHM H ~ ~ O ~ 3KCIIepMMeHTaJIbHbIXO MMeTOAMK,B ~ ~ H M H OCOlTIaCOBaHHOCTbIO~ ~Pe3YJIbTaTOB,O C H O B H ~ Pe3YJIbTaTbII~MeTOAMK.HOJIpeHHbIXAMCCePTaqMMaT a m ePa3HbIXM33axapoBaK.B.o I I ~ ~ J I M K o B ~ HB~ I3 CTaTbSIX B BeAYIIJMX PeLl[eH3MpYeMbIX XCypHaJIaX M 3nepeYHXB MMAOJIOXeHbI7HaK O H @ ~ ~ ~ H ~M H C~ UXM n 0 3 ~ M a X .OTeYeCTBeHHMXM3apy6ex~b1xABTOP~~~LIOJIHOCTbIoP~TOTpWaeTcoAepxaHMe AMccepTaqm.C Y M T ~YTO,AMCCePTaqEZFI3axapoBa<<A~JIJ=HM~~M ~ ~ H H T H IIOpXAOK~ I ~ ~MK O H C T ~ H T HBHJ I~~ A M M M ~ O B M W ~MeTaMarHMTHMelTpeBpaIIJeHH5lBpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIX @ ~ ~ H ~ H C HCTU~~XR E ( S ~ O ~ ) ~ O ~YAOBJIeTBOpXeTCI)),BCeMT ~ ~ ~ o B ~ H E Z FBAK.IMABTOPpa60~b1,3axap0~KOHCT~HTUHBJI~AMMMPOBMY,s a c y x ~ s a e ~n p k n c y x q e H M xMaTeMaTMYeCKkIXHayKpeaoiicTeneHMlI0 CneIJMaJIbHOCTMKawwaTa01.04.09 -(PM~MKO-4 k 1 3 U ~ a HM3KMXTeMnepaTyp.-A o ~ ~ HK.T 4.-M.H.,E-mail:eapopova@hse.ruTen: 8 4 9 16)-476-6295E.A.

IIonosa.