Отзыв оппонента Пудонина (Эффект магнитоимпеданса в ферромагнитных микроструктурах и композитных средах)

o + H ~ H ~ J I ~ H oOIIlTOHeHTa~oH a AHCCePTa4HOHHyIOp a 6 o ~ ynBna-a ~ H ~ 0n fa pi H c b 1AHMHPOBH~I< < ~ + + ~ I cMTa r n w r o z l M n e A a n c a B @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H E I T HMUICPOCTP~IC~IXT y p a X U ICOMII03UTHbIX C p e A a X > > , IIpeACTaBJIeHHyIO H a COHCKaHHe Y Y ~ H OCTeIIe~HH AOKTOpa + H ~ H K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ T H ~ H~ aCyKK ~IIOI XCIIeuHaJIbHOCTH0 1.04.11- ~E I ~ H KMarHHTHbIX X B J I ~ H H ~ ~& ~ c c ~ ~ T ~ ~ I ~pa6o~ao H H n~ a~ ~I H ~ 0 A.B.f iIIOCBcIqeHa~ H MH arHmomMneAaHca(MH)13~ e ~ s o npoas e p x H o c T H o r op a 3 p a 6 0 ~ ~KOHueIIeHMneAaHca B4eppo-MaTHHTHbIX IIpOBOAaX, M H O ~ O C J I O ~ ~ H C~ TI Xp y K T Y p a X H KOMII03HTHbIX M a T e p H a J I a X C+ ~ P P O M ~ T H E I T H ~ I MIIpOBOAaMH.E~JIeHHXMklT a ~ x eB p a 6 o ~ ep a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a ~ bMeXaHH3MbI1YCH-OTHOUIeHHX H M O A E . I + H K ~ ~ I ? EMI4IXaPaKTePHCTHK B Pa3JIHYHbIX YaC-TOTHbIX A H a I I a 3 0 H a X AncI I I ~ H M ~ H ~BHBbICOKOYyBCTBHTeJIbHbIXH ~ ~CeHCOpaX, HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHbIX H yIIPaBJIReMbIX KOMII03HTHbIX C p e A a X .BH a C T O c I q e e BpeMcI IIPOBOAXTCX HHTeHCHBHbIe HCCJIeAOBaHHcI, H a I I p a B J I e H -H b I e H a HCCJIeAOBaHHcI + ~ H A ~ M ~ H T ~ J I ~C HBO~ ~I ~xC T MHKPOMaTHHTHbIXBCHCTeM Cq e J I b I O C03AaHHcI HOBOrO IIOKOJIeHHX pa3JIHYHbIX I I P H ~ O P O B CIIHHTPOHHKH.Oco6oeMeCTO 3aHHMaIOT HCCJIeAOBaHHcI MarHHTHbIX CHCTeM, KOTOPbIe M O X H O EICIIOJIb30B a T b B KaYeCTBe CeHCOPOBc~epxcna6b1xMarHHTHbIXPOMHbIM IIpHKJIaAHbIM IIOTeHqHaJIOM TaKHX CHCTeM.H b I e CTPyKTYPbI 3 a H H M a I O T0c06oeIIoJIefi.BMeCTO, IIOCKOJIbKYTO 06ycnosne~oO r -3TOM MarHHTOHMIIeAaHCHCCJIeAOBaHHR 3aBHCHMO-CTH KOMIIJIeKCHOTO BbICOKOYaCTOTHOrO COIIPOTHBJIeHHcI OT MarHHTHOTO IIOJIX CBHAeTeJIbCTByIOT06OYeHb6 0 n b m ~ xH3MeHeHHcIXHMlleAaHCa H asaCTOTaX BHeKOTOPbIX MarHHTOMcITKHX CTPYKTYPaX, KOTOPbIe MOrYT AOCTHraTbnee.

K p o ~ eTOrO,qHXMH~+@KT,B03MOXHOCTb M H H H a T I O P H 3 a q H H MaTepHaJIOB,600%H06~apy~~sam3 H a s H T e J I b H O PaCLLIHPcIeT I I p H K n a ~ ~ o If IiO T e H q H a J I 3THXMH-CHCTeM, B KOTOPbIX H 3 M e H e H H e H M I I e A a H C a COCTaBJIReT AeCcITKH IIpOqeHTOB.3THM I I P H 9 H H a MTYaJIbHbIMEI.pa60~b1,IIpeACTaBJIeHHbIe60-noB A ~ H H OA H~ C~C e p T a q H H , XBJIcIIOTCX aK-BA H C C ~ P T ~ ~ H O Hpa6o~eH O ~ ~ IIOCTaBJIeHbI H YCIIeXLIHO P e I I I e H b I 3aAaYH, C p e -AH KOTOPbIX MOXHO BbIAeJIHTb CJIeAYEOmHe: TeOPeTHYeCKHH 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOHCCJIeAOBaHbI CTaTHYeCKHe H AHHaMHYeCKHe IIpOqeCCbI HaMaTHHYHBaHHRHbIX MHKPOIIPOBOAaX C K o J I b q e ~ o f i A O M ~ H H OC~T ~P Y K T Y P O ~ ~~;~mec~~a n fn aip a T a ~ m s s a~ e ~ s o pn oas e p x H o c T H o r oH H T H ~ I Xn p o B o A a xMOP@-a 3 p a 6 0 ~Maa T~e M a -HMneAaHca B@eppo~ar-c r e n m ~ o s ~ a n b ~Mo f~ i~ H H T Ha O~ ~~ 3~ 0 ~ p o n mnepfHi n p o ~ s ~ o n b -HbIX YaCTOTaX H B T P ~ X C J I O ~ ~ HIIJIeHKaX~IXT H n a ( P ~ P P o M ~ ~ H ~ T E I K / ~ JMIe -~ ~ AT ~ J I J I / @ ~ ~ ~ o M ~ ~CHYYeTOM~ T H K IIJIaHapHbIX reOMeTpHYeCKHX p a 3 M e p O B .RBHJIOCb Hp a 3 p a 6 0 ~ ~3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIXaBepXHOCTHOTO HMIIeAaHCa.B~XH~IMMeTOAOB OIIpeAeJIeHHR M a T P H q b IT a ~ x e6b1no TeOpeTHYeCKHno-HCCJIeAOBaHO H 3KCIIepH-MeHTaJIbHO IIOATBepXAeHO C y ~ e C T B O B a H H e pa3JIHYHbIX MeXaHH3MOB aCHMMeTPHYHOTOMH.

M H T ~ P ~ C HRBJIReTCR~IMH TeOpeTHYeCKOe H 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOe HC-CJIeAOBaHHR H3MeHeHHR ~ @ @ ~ K T H B HAOH ~~ ~J I ~ K T P H Y ~ c KIIPOHHqaeMOCTHo~~KOMIIO3HqHOHHbIX C p e A C @ ~ ~ ~ O M ~ ~ H H T IIpOBOAaMHH ~ I M HIIOA A ~ ~ ~ C T B HBHerUHHX~ M@ ~ K T O P O B( M ~ ~ H H T H OIIOJIR~ O H MeXaHHYeCKOrO H ~ ~ ~ P I I X ~ H E I FBI )I.

I O A O ~ H ~KOMIXII03HTHbIX M a T e p H a J I a X -3 T O PeIIIeTKH H e I I p e p b I B H b I X IIapaJIJIeJIbHbIXAOB ( I I J I ~ ~ M o H H C~HI ~C T ~ M ~ IH) KOPOTKHeIIPOBO-IIpOBOAa ( p e 3 0 ~ a ~ c ~ bC1HeC T ~ M ~ I )M O X e T P e a J I H 3 0 B a T b C R aHOMaJIbHaR YaCTOTHaR AHCIIePCHR ~ @ @ ~ K T M B HIIPOHHO~~qaeMocTH.H e o 6 x o ~ H ~OTMeTHTb,oYTO ~ O J I ~ L I I H H C T B TeOPeTHYeCKHXOH 3KCIIePHMeHTaJIbHbIX p e 3 y J I b T a T O B , IIpeACTaBJIeHHbIX B A H C C e p T a q H H n a ~ H ~ 0X.B.,f iRBJIREOTCRHOBbIMH.3 ~ e MOXHO~ bBbIAeJIHTb CJIeAYEOmMe HOBbIe pe3yJIbTaTb1, IIOJIyYeHHbIe BAsccepTaqss:- pa3pa60TKaT e O p H H qHPKyJIRPHbIX IIPOqeCCOB HaMarHHYHBaHHFI B IJHJIHHAPHYe-CKHX @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H ~ T CHKX P~YX~ O B OA~O~ M ~ H H OC ~T P~ Y K T Y P O ~I~I p H B O ~ A ~ ~ ~ C T OPBHHTOrOHaJIbHbIX MarHHTHbIX I I o J I e g , YTO II03BOJIHJIO OIIPeAeJIHTb H 3 M e H e H H e UHPKyn R p H o r 0 M a r H H T H O r O IIOTOKa IIOA A ~ ~ ~ C T B BHH~e UMH e r O OCeBOrO M a r H H T H O r O IIOJIR H KOJIHYeCTBeHHO O ~ ~ X C H HH T~ ~~ J I E O A ~H3MeHeHHR~ M ~ I ~HMIIeAaHCa B MHOrOAOMeHHbIX ~ M O P @ H ~ IIIpOBOAaX;X-BBeAeH T e H 3 0 P IIOBePXHOCTHOrO HMIIeAaHCa AJIX rHPOTPOIIHbIX @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H H T -HbIX CTPYKTYP HAOB H IIJIeHOK.p a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a~~H ~ J I H T H W ~ CMeTOAK H ~ ~ er0Te~3opH M n e A a H C aBbIYHCJIeHElII AJIR ITPOBO-IIO3BOJIIIeT YYeCTb BKJIaA IIePeKpeCTHblX AHHa-MElYeCKHX n p O q e C C O B HaMarHHYHBaHBR B H 3 M e p I I e M b I e CElrHaJIbI HanpXXeHkfII.I I O ~ T O M Yo Y e H b60JIbLLIEle H ~ M ~ H ~ H H MI Zn e A a H c an p o ~ c x Bo pe3ynb~a~e~~~ne-P e O p H e H T a q H H C T ~ T H Y ~ C K HaMarHHYeHHOCTBO~BO BHeLLIHeM MaTHEZTHOM IIOJIe HH e o ~ ~ c J I o B .

~ I ~YCJIOBHBMHH~I@~PPOM~I'HHp eT3 0HH aOH C~aO. Ta ~ x eCAeJIaHBbIBOA0 TOM, YTO O ~ M ~ H BH~ ~ I I M~ O A ~ ~ ~ C THBeI BJIHIIIOTIRH a BeJIHYHHY 3 @ @ e K ~ NlkI;a-AJIX a H a J I H 3 a H3MePFIeMbIX BeJIElYBH HCnOJIb30BaH 0 6 0 6 ~ e ~ ~ b 1 Tj j ~: H ~ O P H38~ I ~ ~KOHOM^. P m p a G o ~ a ~Mae T o A m a o n p e A e n e H H c IB c e x KoMnoHeHT~ e ~ s o nosepxpaHocTHoro HMneAaHca.- HHTepeCHbIep e 3 y J I b T a T b I IIOJIyYeHbI AJIII HeAHarOHaJIbHOrO HMIIeAaHCa, K O T O P ~ I ~ ~M O X e T ElCIIOJIb30BaTbCII AJIX BeKTOPHOrO AeTeKTElPOBaHHR MarHHTHOrO IIOJIR.MeTHM, YTO H a 3 B a H B e ( ( H ~ A E ~ ~ T o H ~ JElMIIeAaHC))I ~ H ~ I ~ ~ IIOIIBElJIOCb IIOCJIe~ ~ H H H 6Ob ~1 n. ~BbIIIBJIeHbI I I P e H M y Q e C T B a H e A H a r O H a J I b H O r OB ~ I X O A H OCHrHaJI~~MOXeT6 b 1 ~ baHTElCElMMeTPHYHbIMOT-p a 6 0 ~J , B .MI/3.

n 0 K a 3 a ~ 0 ,YTOOTHOCHTeJIbHO BHeUIHerOIIOJIII, YTO A a e T B03MOXHOCTb OIIpeAeJIeHHII BeJIBYElHbI H HaIIpaBJIeHHII BHeLLIHerOnOJIII.K ~ o MTOrO,~~ e ~ H a r o ~ a J I b ~ElMneAaHCb1fiIIO3BOJIIIeT YBeJIElqHTb B ~ I X O A H O ~ ~CHrHaJr C I I O M O ~ b I Op e 3 0 H a H C H O r O B O ~ ~ Y X A ~ H E ITOX , eCTbYBeJIHYHTb YYBCTBH-TeJIbHOCTb BbIXOAHOrO HaIIPSIXeHHX, YTO YJIyYLIIaeT XaPaKTePHCTHKH LLIyMa.-HccneAosaHCKHH-CJIOXMHB TOHKHXnnemax, KOTOP~IEonpeAenHeTcx~~BHCHMOCT~IOOT MarHHTHbIX C B O ~ ~ C T BB.

CJIyYae HeOAHOPOAHbIX CTPYKTyP ( T P ~ X -C J I O ~ ~CHCTeM,H ~ I X B KOTOPbIX A B a MarHHTHbIX CJIOII MarHHTOMIIrKOI'O MaTHeTHKa,pa3AeJIeHbIBbICOKOIlPOBOAIIQHM CJIOeMCU,AgOYeHb 6 0 ~ 1 b ~ 1 k i eH ~ M ~ H ~ H HHMIZn e A a H c a AJIR n n e H o KHJIHcAu),YAaeTCII IIOJIYYBTbC~~MHKPOHH~IMpamepaHMH.O~OCHOB~HHEl OAOCTOBePHOCTbCT~HayYHbIX Pe3YJIbTaTOB H BbIBOAOB,IIO-JIyYeHHbIX H C @ O ~ M ~ J I H ~ O B ~ H HB~ IAXH C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ H O pa6o~e,H H O ~ ~IIOATBepXAaeTCIIKOPPeKTHOCTbK)IIOCTaBJIeHHbIX 3 a A a Y HCCJIeAOBaHHII, IIpHBJIeYeHHeMCTPOrHXTeOpeTHYeCKHX MeTOAOB, A ~ M O H C T P ~XOpOLLIerO~ H ~ ~ ~ COrJIaCHII TeOpeTHYeCKHX H3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIX AaHHbIX.K p o ~ eTOrO,AOCTOBepHOCTb IIOJIyYeHHbIX pe3yJIb-TaTOB O ~ ~ C I I ~ Y E I B ~ ~XOPOIIIHMTCIICOrJIaCHeM C 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIMI.I AaHHbIMHIIO HCCJIeAOBaHHXM MarHHTOHMIIeAaHCa, IIOJrYYeHHbIMH P a 3 H b I M H aBTOpaMH.Pa60~b1a B T O p aH M e I o T 60JIbILIyIO IIPaKTHYeCKYIO H HaYYHYIO 3HaYHMOCTb.T ~ KB03MOXHOCTb,PerHCTPauHHT e M n e p a T y p a x HMeeTHCIlOJIb3OBaHHeHbIe6onbruoeCBePXMaJIbIX MarHHTHbIX IIoJIefi I I p H KOMHaTHbIXs ~ a ~ eT a~K ~KaKe ,H enpaKTmecKoeT P Y A O ~ M K OH~ ~~0p0rofiK P H O T ~ H H OTeXHOJIOrHH.~~I\/M 3JIeMeHTbI0~06b1fiH H T e p e CMOrYT IIPeACTaBJIXTb~ p e 6 y e ~ c XMHHH~TIOP-AJIX TaKHX n p H J I o X e -~ H f i ,KaK KOHTPOJIb TpaHClTOpTa MarHHTHbIX HaHO-MapKepOB, K O r A a H ~ O ~ X O A H M OIIPOBOAHTb P e r H C T p a u H I O IIPOCTPaHCTBeHHOrO P a C I I p e A e J I e H H X MarHHTHbIXIL'II/IH a CBepXBbICOKHX YaCTOTaX M O X e TBCTpaHBaeMbIX ~ ~ C I I ~ O B O ACeHCOpOB.H~IX6 b 1 ~ bHClTOJIb30BaHIIoJIefi.AJIX p a 3 p a 6 0 ~ ~ HT a ~ x eI I p e A J I O X e H H b I eMHOTOCJIO~~H~I~CHCTeMbI MOrYT HCIIOJIb30BaTbCX AJIX C03AaHHX YnPaBJIXeMbIX HHAYKTOPOB.K p o ~ eTOrO, pa6o~aHeCOMHeHHOH M e e T @ Y H A ~ M ~ H T ~ J I 3~HHa YOe ~H H e AJIXHCCJIeAOBaHHX BbICOKOYaCTOTHOrO M a r H H T H O r O T p a H C I I O p T a , AHHaMHYeCKHX IIpOQeCCOB I I e p e M a r H H Y H B a H H X IIpOBOAXwHX MHKPOCTPYKTYP, 3JIeKTPOAHHaMHKH M e T a M a T e p H a J I O B C @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H ~ I T H3JIeMeHTaMH.~IM~IK ~ KH n106a~H a y Y H a x pa6o~a,n p e A c T a s n e H H a xA.B.