Отзыв оппонента Попова (Магнитные, магнитоупругие и спектроскопические свойства соединений с 4F- и 3D-ионами чистых, замещенных и разбавленных составов)

OT3bIBo @ ~ u ~ a n b ~o on nrooH e H T a A.@.-M.H. A.M. I l o n o ~ aH a A H c c e p T a u H o H H y I o P ~ ~ O TA.A. f l e M H ~ 0 B a( ( M ~ ~ H E I TM aHr H~HIT~OY, I I P Y r H e H CIIeKTPOCKOIIHFIeCKHe CBOI%CTB~C O ~ , I J H H ~ HCE4fI ~ ~H ~ ~ - H O H ~ MFIHCTbIX,EI3 a M e m e H H b I X H p a 3 6 a B J I e H H b 1 ~COCTaBOB)),npeaCTaBJIeHHymHaCOMCKaHMeyqeH0fiMaTeMaTMYeCKMX HaYK n O CneuMaJlbHOCTMCTeneHH,IJOKTOpaMCCJIeAOBaHMIoMarHEITHbIX,COBpeMeHHbIX MarHeTEIKOB CMarHHTOYIIPYrHX M4f3dEI@EI~EIKO-0 1.04.11 - @ M ~ E I KMarHHTHbIX~A E I C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ Mp aO6Ho ~Ha~A.A.R A ~ M H A OIBI O~C B I I u e H aYRB.TIeHHI%.~eopeTHFIecK0MyCIIeKTPOCKOIIHFIeCKEIXCBOGCTBEIOHaMH: peAKO3eMeJIbHbIX @ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ O B ,a n m ~ 0 6 0 p a ~ O B ,X ~ O M O ~ O ~ ~ THO B r i U I J I 0 6 0 p a ~ O ~ .

~ E I P O K ~ RB03MOXHOCTbC ~ M ~ I % C T B~~ O ~ ~ Tw O3 (BB 0 3 ) 4(M = Fe,Al, Ga, Cr) 0 6 e c n e r ~ s a eH~ 6onbruoe p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 ~@e H ~ H F I ~ C K H CBOGCTB,XHB a p b H p O B a H H R COCTaBOM HCCJIeAyeMOrOB03MOXHOCTEIY ~ P ~ B ~ ~ H HHMH.RYCT~HOBJI~HM~@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ 0K~ KJIaCCy M Y J I ~ T H @ ~ P P O H K O B ~ ~ H ~ P Y K ~ H E I ~MarHHTO3JIeKTPHFIeCKOrO 3 @ @ e ~ B~ aa J I I O M 0 6 0 p a ~ a x IIpHBeJIO KAOnOJIHEITeJIbHbIenpHHaAJIeXHOCTHrEIraHTCKOr0Pe3KOMY POCTY H H T e p e C a MHOrOFIEICJIeHHbIX HaYFIHbIX KOJIJIeKTHBOB K AaHHbIMM ~ T ~ P M ~ J I ~ M .~ O B ~ I U I ~ H H ~EII ~HT~~P~CM a r H H T 0 3 J l e K T P M q e C KMMM ~ ~ H M T O ~ J ~ ~ K T P E I ~ ~Cpe,IJaMCKMM0 6 y c n o ~ n e ~B,FIaCTHOCTH,KIIOTP~~HOCTIIMEIC O B ~ ~ M ~ HTL'XHMKM,H O ~ ~ B b l ~ B ~ ~ a I o K~ MaTePEIaJIaMe f iT P ~ ~ O B ~ HCOBMeCTMMOCTEIM RC COBPeMeHHblMM TeXHOJIOTMRMEI, q T O BbI3bIBaeT H ~ O ~ X O A E I M O C6oneeT~HOHMMaHMR@ M ~ M ~ ~ C K H nXP O u e C C O B ,MarHHT03JIeKTPEIFIeCKEIXH3j'qeHEIeIIPOTeKaIOmHXMaTepEIaJIOBBHHX.my60~0r0~ O M H M O 3TOr0,HeCOMHeHHOIIpeACTaBJIReT6 o n b r u o f i EIHTepeC EI C H ~ Y F I H o ~TOFIKEI~3PeHHII, T a K KaK IIPH 3TOM B03HEIKaeTH ~ o ~ x o A M M O C TBbIIICHeHEIII~BOnPOCOB, H M e I O m H X nPHHlJHIIHa.JIbHOe@ M ~ M K M MarHEITHbIXnpo6ne~aRBJI~HEII%.BbIRBJIeHHIIMarHEITO3JIeKTPHFIeCKEIXKTaKEIMBOIIPOCaM,MEIKPOCKOIIHFIeCKHXCBOI%CTBB3HaqeHEIII AJIRFIaCTHOCTH,MeXaHH3MOBOTHOCEITCII@OPMHPOB~HEIRM Y J I ~ T E I @ ~ P P O E I K O B .

n 0 ~ 0 6 ~ b 1 e BOIIPOCbIO C O ~ ~ H HBOa X H b I B CJIyFIae C O ~ A H H ~ H H I %C ,O A e p X a m H X HOHbI C OTJIHFIHbIM OT HyJIR( ~ nOJIHOCTbIOe~ ~ M O P O X ~ H H ~ OI PM~ E) I T ~ . T I ~ H ~ I M MOMeHTOM, K KaKOBbIM OTHOCIITCIIpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIeHOHbI,IIOCKOJIbKYM H O ~ O O ~ P ~ ~ MYHMKanbHblX~3THCOeAHHeHHIIMarHMTHblX,o~H~PYXEIB~IOTM ~ ~ H H T O ~ ~ P Y ~ H HXb I ~ l ' H M 7 0 ~ ! l t ' K 7 ' P M ~ e C K M XC B O ~ ~ C T B~. O ~ T O M )T' e M a A M C C ~ P T ~ ~ M O Hp Ha 6O0~~~b 1A.A.A ~ M M A ORBnReTCR,B~0 1.04.11--HeCOMHeHHO, a ~ T y a J I b ~ 0 fHi COOTBeTCTByeT CnelJEIanbHOCTH@ H ~ M MarHMTHbIXK ~RBJle~kifi.~ ~ H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ pH aO6 oH ~HaA.A.~ R~ ~ M E I A OCOCTOHTB ~H 3 BBeAeHHII, BOCbMHr;IaB,3aKJIIOFIeHHR,CnHCKaO I I Y ~ J I E I K O B ~ H H ~ pa6o.rIXHCIIHCKanmeparypbr.

P a 6 o ~ a~ 3 n o x e ~H aa 370 crpaaauax, B K n m s a R 1721 a 6 n ~ EIu CnEICOK J I M T e p a T y p b I E13 287 H ~ H M ~ H O B ~ H H ~ ~ .B0 BBeAeHEIH O ~ O C H O B ~aKTyaJIbHOCTbH~T e M b I HCCJIeAOBaHEIR,UenMM3aAaFII4,YKa3aHaHaYFIHaRHOBEI3HaEI~JEITEIPY~MO~~pacyaKa,HpaKTEIFIeCKaR27OIIpeAeJIeHbI3HaqEIMOCTbA H C C ~ ~ T ~ U Hc H@,nepBaIIo p ~ y n ~ p os ~a ma ~~ bm~a e ~ nbo~n eo x e H m .r J I a B a AMCCepTaIJHH IIpeACTaBJIReT ~0601%0 6 3 0 ~J I I l T e p a T y p b lBO ~ J I ~ C T3KCllePHMeHTaJIbHbIXMH TeOPeTHFIeCKEIX H C C J I ~ A O B ~ H I ~peAKO3eMeJIbHbIXI%~ O ~ ~ TRM:(B03)4.O Bn p ~ ~ e f l e ~A ba Hl H b l e 0 K ~ E I C T ~ J T J I H ~ ~ CTPYKTYPeCKO~M 0HaslMqMMCTPj'KTj'PHOrO@ a 3 0 ~ 0 r 0 nepeXOAa1B@eppo6opa~axCTRXeJIbIMHpefiKO3eMeJIbHbIMEIHOHaMH.MaTHMT03JIeKTPEIYeCKEIX,~PO~H~JIEI~EIPOB' ~AHaH~HI bIeMarHMTOynPYrHX,0MarHEITHbIX,CIIeKTPOCKOnEIYeCKEIXMApyrMxC B O ~ ~ C T B~~ OX ~ ~ T O B .BoB T O P O ~ r~n a B eXapaKTepEICTMK~ 3 n o x e ~T eao p e T M q e c K a c rM o A e n b p a c r e T a MccnefiyeMbIxp e A K O 3 e M e J l b H b I X ~ O ~ ~ TR OM 3B( B 0 3 ) 4qEICTbIX,3aMeWeHHbIX Mp a 3 6 a B n e ~ ~ bCOCTaBOB.1 ~A a H H b 1 f i IIOAXOA OCHOBaH H a a I I p 0 6 ~ p o ~ a ~ M~ o Af ein Mnoncr AJIR p e ~ ~ 0 3 e ~ e n b ~ oEIOHaroEIII~H~~MX~HEIEIM O n e K y J I R p H O r O IIOJIH.

Ancr P a C s e T a MaTHEITHbIX, M ~ ~ H M T O Y I I P Y ~ EXapaKTePEICTEIKIXM 3 @ + e K ~ a3 e e ~ a M~ Can O n b 3 0 B a n C X raMEIJIbTOHEIaH B K J I I O ~ ~ HraMEInbTOHEIaHb1~ ~ M ~ ~~ p ~ c 7 a s r s r ~ r e c r c ononclro(,qncl D3 M C2 C M M M ~ T P MO~K~p y x e H M c r p e ~ ~ o 3 e ~ e n b ~ o r oKpEIcTannkirecKoroHoH~),B ~ ~ E I M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B EOI F~I M, ~ H H O T OB ~ ~ E I M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B EEI I F I3eeMaHOBCKOrO~ P MHaXOXAeHMEI M a r H E I T H b I X M O M e H T O Bp e ~ ~ o 3 e ~ e n b EI~ ox fe in e 3 ~ 0 f in o A c M c T e M perrranacb c a M o c o r n a c o B a H H a c r 3 a ~ a r aM ~ T H M T o Y I I ~ ~ ~TaMEIJIbTOHEIaH.EI~~O n p e A e J I e H H R HX Be-TIEIsHH M O P E I ~ H T ~ I J MH a~ O~ CHOBe BbInEICaHHbIX raMHnbTOHEIaHOBrlPMYCJIOBEIEIMEIHEIMyMaT e P M O A M H a M E I Y e C K O ~ O IIOTeHUEIaJIa,3aIIEICaHHOTOBP a M K a X C T ~ H ~ ~ P T TH~ OPM~O~ A M H ~ M M Y ~ C TeOPEIEIK O ~ ~ B O ~ M Y L I J ~ H MAncr~ ~ .

OnMCaHEIRMarHHTOyIIpyrHXC B O ~ ~ C T BMCnOJIb30Ba.JICFI3aIIHca~Hb1fi BMynbTMnOnbHOMn p ~ 1 6 n ~ x e~ ~a r mH H~T 0 y I I p y r M f ir a M M n b T 0 H H a H p e n ~ 0 3 e ~ e n b ~ IIOACMCTeMbIofiAncrBbIpaxeHMcrPaCUHpeHMe.MarHmTocTpHKUmT e ~ n e p a ~ y p H b ~H eEIMarHmoynpyroroIIOneBbIeBKnaAa3aBHCHMOCTMBf-dTennoBoeMYJIbTMnOJIbHbIXM O M e H T O B p e A K O 3 e M e n b H b I X EIOHOB PaCCYMTbIBaJIMCb H a C n e K T p e H@YHKIJMFIX, @ O P M I ? P Y ~ M ~ I XK p H C T a n J I H s e C K M M I I O n e M ,EIBOnHOBbIXB ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~ C T( nBp H ~ MH~JIMYMMM ) 3et?MaHOBCKEIM B ~ ~ M M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B M ~ M .TarcxeBTOPOF~r n a B e 0 6 c y x n a e ~ c c l o n M c a H M e K p M c T a ; I n M r e c K o r o noncr A J ~ R6 o p a ~ o sC ABYMH p e A K 0 3 e M e n b H b l M M nOACEICTeMaMEI.

AEICC~PT~HTOMBO3aMeueHHbIXdpr) M e H T M P O B a H OnapaMeTpoBMOHOBBnPt?AnOXeHOEICnOJIb30BaTbBpaC9eTaXe ~ H ~ b 1 f Hi a 6 0 pnoncr Ancr P ~ ~ ~ E I Y HT ~H In oXB p e ~ ~ o 3 e ~ e n b ~ b r x6 o p a ~ e . M ~ B ~ C T H O9, T O O C H O B H b I e I I a p a M e T p b In p M 3 a n ~ c B~ T ~ H ~ O P H ~ I OXn e p a T o p a x B PRAYKpMcTannMrecKoro3aMeLIJeHHOMKpucTannHrecKorononcr@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o B H e CMJIbHO OTnMYaIoTCR OT H O H a K EIOHy, I I O 3 T O M y B K a s e C T B en p ~ 6 n ~ x e ~ ancp erA C T a B n c I e T C 2 B e C b M a p a 3 Y M H b I M M C n O J I b 3 0 B a H H en p e A n o x e H H o r o a B T o p o M nonxona Ancr o n E I c a H m c r K p a c T a n n M s e c K o r o noncr B3aMeLIJeHHbIX 6opa~ax.M H T ~ P ~ C HnPeACTaBJIFIeTCFI~IMI I p e ~ n o X C e H H b ~ af Bi T O p O M y ~ ~ o L I J ~ H HHO,~ IK ~a K~nepBOr0,IIOKa3aJIM p a C Y e T b 1 , A O C T a T O 9 H O ~ @ @ ~ K T E I B CHI I~OIC~O~~H H T e P I I P e T L ? 4 M H n O n e B b I X HT e M n e p a T y P H b I X ~ ~ B E I C H M O CMT~~ ~~ H~ M T O ~ ~ ~ K T P IIOJIFIPH3aIJMEI.M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~M ~ B ~ C T H O ,YrOJJIclBoparos RM?(BOq)jMMeeTMeCTOM C ~ O J I ~ ~ ~Ya RHMaTHMT03neKTpMYeCKMXCBO~CTB.npeAJIOXEIn3KCnepEIMeHTaJIbHbIeCPaBHMTbKOppeJlXIJMXp a C C 9 E I T a H H b l M H M3MeHeHEIFIMH C I I O n e MMarHRTOynpyrHXH~ b 1 f i@ ~ K T , A M C C e p T a H T ,3aBHCHMOCTHIIOnFIPM3a~MMC~ e M I I e p a ~ y p 0 fT ie X MYJIbTMnOJIbHbIXMOMeHTOB, K O T O P b I e n03BOnSIH3T Y C n e u I H O O n H C a T b MaTHHTOCTPEIKIJEIH3.B ~ p e ~ b er fn ia B eC ABYMR MarHEITHbIMM IIOACMCTeMaMEI: @ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o B(CX P O M O ~ O P ~ T O B (BNdCr?(BO3)4).6oparosR = Y, Ps, Sm, Tb, Ho, Es)MCCJIeAOBaHO H O B e n e H M e M a r H M T H b I X X a p a K T e p M C T M KOCHOBHOMAnzl3KCnePMMeHTaJIbHOHccnegoBaHHoroM c n o n b 3 y e ~ b 1 f i ~ e o p e ~ ~ s e c ~nonxogk i f i ,qocTaToYHoy6e~~~enb~n p o A e M o H c T p M p o B ~ n P H M e H M M 0 C T b K K O n H 9 e C T B e H H O M Y OIIMCaHEIH3 HOBeAeHEItI2MarHMTHbIXC B O ~ ~ C T BHn e p e o p ~ e ~ ~ a w i o ~O F ~ ~ ( B OB~ KOTOPOM)~,~ b l~ f ~i P ~ X O A , 6b1npeZLTIH3yeTCR C I I O H T ~ H H ~CIIMHI~~MCIIOJIb30BaHTaMHJIbTOHMaHKPMCTitrIJIMZIeCKOTO IIOJIlrI M B B ~ I C O K O T ~ M ~ ~(D3),~ ~ I?T B~ H~ HH~ OK O~ T~~ M I I ~ P ~ T Y P H O ~(C2) CMMMeTPHRXJIOKZUIbHOTO OKPYXeHHlrI H O H a TOnbMMR.CJeJlL?Tb9TOBbIBOA,KOnH9eCTBeHHOeB 0 3 M O X H O TOJIbKO IIpM Y r e T eOnHCaHMeTOIIO~BOJTHJIOa B T O p yXaPaKTePMCTMKHoFe3(B03)4JIo~aJIb~ofiC B M M e T P H H C2.Y ~ T B ~ ~r JTI a B~ a R I I O C B X w e H a MarHMTHbIM C B O ~ ~ C T B ~ Mp a 3 6 a ~ J I e ~ ~ b 1@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ 0O~ C.

H O B Hp e~3 yIJ~I b T a T b I H BbIBOAbI CAeJIaHbI H a I I p M M e p e c e ~ e f i c ~ ~ aPr,Y I - , F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 , A n % K o T o p o r o n p ~o n p e ~ e n e ~ ~ oc iT ie n e a n p a 3 6 a s n e ~ ~ ~peZUIH3yeTCR YrJIOBaR MarHMTHaR CTpyKTj'pa. , @ X C C ~ ~ T ~ H T , HCIIOJIb3yR a K T y a J I b H b I exapanep I I ~ ~B nRT0fiA C K ~ ~ B~OH~ M OR X H ~ IaX~ o ~ a n aMf ai x c T e n e H M B b r p a x e w H o c T m .rJIaBehlaTHMTOynpyrMXIIpMBeAeHbIpe3yJIbTaTbITeOpeTM9eCKOrOMCCJIeAOBaHMRC B O ~ ~ C T B@epp060pa~0~.~ ~ O A ~ M O H C T ~ H ~ O B9 T~OH OCKaVKM,@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ aI I~p B CIIHHB B 6 a 3 ~ ~ ~ IIJIOCKOCTH0fik1)~7bTMnOJIbHb1X MOMeHTOB peAKO3eMeJIbHbIX MOHOB B@JToII-II~~~xoAB ~ noneBAOJIbT P B T O H & ~ I ~ H OOCH~~o ~ ~ c ~ o B ~ H B ~ I O 0T6 ~ a p y ~ e H H b l eMaTHMTOCTPHK~HM.BeJIHqMHbIABTOPOMYCTaHOBJIeHO,YTO KBaAPYIIOJIbHOrO I I ~ H ~ J I M X ~ H M RAOCTaTOZIHO A n R OIlMCaHMR MarHHTOCTpMKlJHH @ e p p 0 6 0 p a T o B CJJIR @ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o BCR = Sm, Nd, HO M ErlIp0~0.TIb~ofiCKaYKOBR=Pr, TbBDy, aH ~ O ~ X O A MyMY e T MOMeHTOB H e TOJIbKOsroporo, HO M Y e r B e p T o r o n o p R n K o B .B L L I e c ~ o f i r,TaBe n p e J C T a B J I e H b 1p e 3 y n b T a T b I T e O p e T H s e C K O r O MCCJIeAOBaHMRMarHMTHbIXCOCTaBOBC B O ~ C T B 3aMeUeHHbIXp e ~ K 0 3 e ~ e J I b H o f~ iO A C M C T ~ M OK~O~ ~.@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o B COM Y ~ C T B OIIHCaHMe~HHO~C M ~ W ~ H H O ~MarHHTHbIX M APYl?MX@ H ~ M ~ ~ C K CMB XO~~CTBMarHHTOYnOPRAOYeHHbIX MarHeTMKOB C K O H K Y P H p Y M u H M HBKJIaJaMMX e ~ I e 3 ~ 0 f iMC M ~ U I ~ H H Op ~e ~~ ~ 0 3 e ~ e J I b ~IIOACMCTeMo f iH ~ ~ ~ O C T 3Oa ~Ga Y e f i .