Отзыв оппонента Москвина (Магнитные, магнитоупругие и спектроскопические свойства соединений с 4F- и 3D-ионами чистых, замещенных и разбавленных составов), страница 2

~ H c J I ~ H HP a~CIs e~T b I H SUIaJIH3 HMeIOmHXCR B J I H T e p a T y p e 3KCIIePHMeHTaTIbHbIX ASUIHbIX,pmeIIOJryYeHHbIX pa3HbIMH rPYIIIIaMH H BCJIyYaeB C CYmeCTBeHHbIMH OTJIHYEZIIMH, II03BOJIHJIHa p r y M e H T H p O B a H H 0 H A ~ H T H ( # ~ H ~ H P OHB 3aTeM~ T ~ OIIHCaTbaBTOPOMTeOPeTHYeCKSUIKOJIHseCTBeHHOMY(#lepp060paToB.BMOAeJIbOIIHCSUIHIOY~~AHT~JI~HIIpOAeMOHCTpHpOBaJIaOR-FeC B O ~ ~ C T B JIerKOOCHbIXMWHHTHbIXCJIyYae S m F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4YYeCTb aHH30TPOIIHIO~ m 6 o n e AOCTOBepHbIeeASUIHbIe.

P ~ ~ B H T S U IOIIHCmHe 3KcnepHMeHTaHIIPHMeHHMOCTbKJIeTKOIIJIOCKOCTHbIXno~pe60sa~10AonOJIHHTeJIbHOO ~ M ~ H H OB~~O~ H M O A ~ ~ ~ C T BB HHRo.F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 y Y e T6oneeCJIoxHoroBHAa raMHJIbTOHHiuIa KPHCTaJIJIHseCKOrO I I O M (B C 2 C H M M ~ T ~ HOIIpaBAaH,H)IIOCKOJIbKy YAaJIOCbAOCTHYbIIpHHqHIIHaJIbHOJryYUIerOCOrJIaCHRC&IX3KCIIepHMeHTOM.X P O M O ~ O ~ ~ T O3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIeBAaHHbIe H a HeOPHeHTEiPOBSUIHOMo6pa3qeMaJIOH3yYeHHbIXNdCr3(B03)4HeIIO3BOJIHJIH AHCCepTSUITy AOCTHTHYTb KOJIHYeCTBeHHOrO OIIHCSUIEZII KPHBbIX HaMaI'HHYHBSUIEZII, OAHaKOT e M I I e p a T y p H b I e 3aBHCHMOCTH BOCIIPHHM9HBOCTH H aHOMaJIHR ~ O I T K HOIIHCSUIbI BeCbMa XOPOUIO.&IX JIerKOOCHbIXBTb H Dy)IIpeACKa3SUIbI R p K u e aHOMaJIHH B(#leppo60pa~ax.s e ~ B e p ~ 0 fr Ji I a B e PaCCMOTpeHbI MarHHTHbIe C B O ~ ~ C T pBa ~3 6 a B J I e H H b 1 ~ (#lepp060paToB.OCHOBHSUI s a C T b pe3YJIbTaTOB I I p H B e A e H a AJIR0.45, 0.25).c e ~ e f i c ~P r~x Ya1 - x F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4O T J I E I Y E I T ~ J I ~ H OO~ C~ O ~ ~ H H O C T ~ IPOr x Y 1 - x F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4A ~ M H A OA.A.B~(X =RBJUIeTCRo ~ H ~ ~ Y X ~ H H YmOBSUISUIC T p y I c T y p a M ~ ~ H H T HIIOACElCTeMbIO ~ ~IIpH X =UeJIb0 6 n a c ~HH3KkM~0 6 y c n o s n e ~ ~ b 1 e C ~ H H - ( # l n o n - n e p e x o ~ a ~ ~~, H ~ J I O ~ ~ H ~ 0I 6M ~Ha p y m e ~ ~ bB 1 ~TeMnepaTyp,JIerKOOCHbIXXPOMO~O~~TO(RB =0.75, 0.67, 0.55,3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHO0.67-0.45.

A M ~ E I ~ E ~ O ~ HHCCJIeAOBaTb B eAHHOM IIOAXOAe 6 o n b r u o f i MaCCHB 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIXAaHHbIX AJUI BCeX COCTaBOB (X =0.75-0.25)H AOCTHrb COTJIaCHR OIIpeAeJIeHHbIX aKTyaJIbHbIXI I a p a M e T p O B H e TOJIbKO M e X A y BCeMH ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ B J I ~ COCTaBaMH,H H ~ I M HHO H C AaHHbIMH AJIH sHCTbIXCOCTaBOB (X =1 H 0) 6 ~ n AOCTHrHyTaaH IIIHPOKO IIPOHJIJIIOCTpHPOBaHa.O T M ~I I~p eY~ J I o X e H H b 1 f iB a p H a H T o~%RcH~HEZIIIIpHpOAbI A B ~ x c T ~ I I ~ H ~aHOMaJIHH~ T O ~ ~ H a K P H B O ~HaMaTHHYHBaHHR~BAOJIbOCH C.P a c s e ~B yrno~oii+meHnpeanonoxemie ee Tpa~c(#lop~aqmc POCTOM nom~O~BOJIHJI3TameH H T e p I I p e T H p O B a T b A a H H b I e CTJTIeHYaTbIe aHOMaJIHH.aHOMaJIHHHH a TeMIIepaTypHbIX3WHCHMOCTXXO ~ ' ~ R C H ~H HOIIHCaHbI~ ICTyIIeHYaTbIeHaMX'HHYeHHOCTHM a r H H T H O r O IIOJM. A J M JJPYrHX p a 3 6 a B J I e ~ ~ b I @X e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o BCo m a ~ op a c s e TA ~ H H ~ I Xn o K a HeT,nosBonun3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHOrO HCCJIeAOBaHUII RBJMeTCX~ M T o ~rJIaBeIIpHBeAeHbIYTOH e r 0 B03MOXHOPrxYl m x F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 .HCCJIeJJOBaHkIIICBO~~CTBMal-HHTOJTIPpHXYTO B CHJIY MaJIOCTH B K J I m a@epp060pa~0~B w I m p e J J ~ 0 3 e ~ e J I b ~ oIIOJJCHCTeMbIfiMarHHTOCTPHKuHIo3HaYeHHXXT ~ ~ J I ~ Hnnx~ I~ a ~ 6 0 n e~eK@eppo6opa~DyxY1 - ~ F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4H AJMpe3yJIbTaTbI@epp060pa~0~.A H C C ~ P T ~ H T O MOTMeYeHO,PmHbIXR = Tb H Dy 3KCIIepHMeHTaJIbHbIXnpeAcKmaTb,0 6 ~ a p y X H ~aHOMaTIUH,baHaJIOrHYHbIe 0 6 H a p ) 9 K e ~ ~ b I MBBIIpHXeJIe3~0gIIOJJCHCTeMbIBXBJMeTCX OIIpeJJeJM€OrrlHM HP a C Y e T H ~ M ~ H ~ HMYJIbTHIIOJIbHbIXH GMOMeHTOB R - H O H ~BO BHeUIHeM MX'HHTHOM IIOJIe OIIpeAeJMeTpe3yJIb~HpJWrrlHfiBHAH ~ ~ J I K ) J J ~ ~ M MWHHTOCTPHKuHH.O~~MarHHTOCTPHKuHH JIerKOOCHbIXC M ~ H O3~H a K a B@epp060pa~0~H HeMOHOTOHHOeJIeTKOIIJIOCKOCTHbIX~HoM~JIHGB CJIyrIae JIerKOOCHbIXO I I H C ~ H ~ I RPKHeIIOBeJJeHHe M W H H T O C T P H W H H CO@eppo60pa~ax.~ o K ~ L U I O YTO,@epp060pa~0~AOCTaTOYHOCKaYKUAJMOIIHCaHkIIIJJaHHbIXyrIeCTb MOMeHTbI BTOPOrO IIOpRAKa,aAJM JIerKOIIJIOCKOCTHbIX@epp060pa~0~H ~ O ~ X O J J H MyrIeCTbOewe HoIIpe~eJIe~b13HaYeHEIIIK O ~ @ @ E I ~ H ~ H TBO BJ I k i H e f i ~ b I X K O M ~ H H ~ & U I XMYJIbTHIIOJIbHbIX MOMeHTOB,H ~ O ~ X O A H M ~ I AJM~KOJIHseCTBeHHOMOMeHTbI Y e T B e p T O r O I I O p m K a .O ~ H C ~ H E .

~ T MX'HHTOCTPHK~HH.~ ~ ~ A H T ~ JIIpOAeMOHCTpHpOBaHO, YTO o ~ H ~ P ) ~ K ~C MH eHH a~ 3 H a K a MarHHTOCTPBKqHH C POCTOM IIOJM B@eppo60pa~axC RMOMeHTOB.=NdHHo,O ~ ~ C J I O B J IH~ 3HM~e H e H H e M 3 H a K a HSIEI~OJI~IIIHXMYJIbTHIIOJIbHbIXhmor~mmCMeHa 3HaKaHoFe3(B03)4IIOKEL3aH0,Ha n p H M e p eMX'HHTOC'rpHWHH n p e A C K a 3 a H a B E r F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 .YTO P a C Y e T T e M I I e p a T y p H b I X ~ ~ B M C M M OMYJIbTHIIOJIbHbIXCT~~~MOMeHTOBHOHa TOJIbMUII XOPOUIO BOCIIPOH3BOJJHT O ~ H ~ P Y X ~ HHHH ~X eI ~T =100 KaHOMSUIIIH TeIIJIOBOrOPaCUIHpeHUII, B TOM s H C J I e H I I p H CIIHH-IIepeOpHeHTaJJHOHHOM IIepeXOJJe B ~ J I E ~T~=H5 K.L U ~ C rJIaBaT ~ I I O C B R a e H a TeOpeTHYeCKOMy HCCJIeAOBaHlGO@epp060pa~0~CnposeAeHaKOHKYPHPJWaHMH6onbmmIIOJIe H6e3BbIBOJJbIHTeopeTHsecKmMX'HHTHbIX C B O ~ ~ C T3Ba M e w e H H b I XR ' , ~ - F ~ o ~ M ~ H H ~ I MB~SIEIMOJJ~~~CTBUIIMH.H,&~CC~PTSLHTOMpa6o~anoneTaJIbHoMy H ~ ~ V ~ Hn oHs eIA ~e H m B MX'HHTHOMIIOJM MWHHTHbIX MOMeHTOB C M ~ U I L U I H Op~ e~ J J ~ 0 3 e ~ e J I b ~ oHf i X e J I e 3 H b I X IIOACHCTeM,Pe3YJIbTaTbIK O T O P O ~ ~ IIOJJKpeIIJIeHbIMHOrOYHCJIeHHbIMHPHCYHKaMH,CXeMaMH 0 p H e ~ ~ a J J H fMarHHTHbIXiMOMeHTOB U IIPHBeAeHHbIMH B TeKCTe JJaHHbIMH.OTMeTHTbAJMT ~ ~ J I H ~ ~H~O~XOAHpe3ynb~a~b1H C C J I ~ J J O B ~ HCM~~M~ & C T B ~N d ~ - ~ D y ~ F e 3 ( B 0 3(X) 4 = 0.05, 0.1, 0.15, 0.25, 0.4),HeKOTOPbIXCOCTaBOBI I e p e o p H e ~ ~ a J J E i o ~ IIepeXOJJ~b~K P H B ~ I X H ~ M X ' H H Y H B ~ H H R .nonpeAeneHHbrxBKOTOPOrOOIIHCaHO ~ H ~ P Y X ~ H H ~ Ic GI I o H T ~ H H ~ I ~ ~CIIHH-H 3 a C J I y X H B m a H e BHHMaHHe AByXCTJTIeHYaTbIeo ~ m a ~ oTO,npeAnonoxeHmiBenHYHHbI ~ K T ~ ~ J I ~ nHa p~ aIMXe T p o B B c e x COCT~BOB,~ ~ ~ J I H ~ ~ J ~J H~ JH I O B OM~~ ~~ H H T H OC ~T ~P Y K T ~ ~ I , n y m eCOrJIaCyIOTCR CO 3HaYeHHRMH B YHCTbIX COCTaBaX (IIpH X =COCTORHHH.KaKHBcnyrIae caHOMaJIHH H a0 H I),Y e M I I p H P a C Y e T e B JIerKOOCHOMp a 3 6 a B J I e ~ ~ b I MP r x Y l - x F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4BKaYeCTBeIIpHYHHbI4n s y x c T y n e H s a T o r o x a p a K T e p a c K a s K a H a M a r H H s e H H o c T H B N d 1 - ~ D y ~ F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4n p e n n o n o X e H 0C K ~ .

I K O O ~ ~ ~H 3~MHe HO e~H H eymo~ofi @ m b ~BnpoMexyTo9HymAH~ ~CO- lM' 0~u RMWHHTHbIX MOMeHTOB H P H I I e p e X O n e OT ~ a 9 t U b H o f iyrnoBym@my3 a c n p ~ s a e ~BHHMaHHXc n m - n e p e o p ~ e ~ ~ a q ~ onepexona~ ~ o r o TSR ~3n o 6 a s n e ~ ~n eer K o n n o c K o c T H o r oTSRCBII3aH~ a K 0 f POCTiTeMnepaTypbIKOHCTaTHPOBaTb,9TOBKJIma OTnJIII COCTaBaB ~ H C T O MHoFe3(BO3)4,N d - ~ O A C H C Tno~ MM~HI e. H H I oaBTOpa,C H 3 M e H e H H e M OCHOBHOrO HH3KOTeMIIepaTypHOTO COCTOIIHHXI I p e n n ~ X e H H b ~ f nHCCepTaHTOMiHCCJIenOBaHHbIX 3aMeIIJeHHbIX1, HHnerKoocHoro B nerKonnocKocTHoeno 9 K, c 5 KP ~ ~ I O M H PMYHORr O s H C J I e H H b I eC JIerKOOCHOrO H a Y m O B O e .0@non-@my.BOO ~ ~ R C H ~ HO H~ ~ H ~ P ~ ~ H HH3MeHeHWIO ~ Oc o c T o a H H e B H o o .

~ N ~ o . ~ F ~ ~ ( KB OO T~O) P~ ~, B b I p o c n aHeCMOTpX H a3 a ~ enepexon~H TonbKoH a TenJIOeMKOCTH OHHCaHa H ,QJM sHCTbIX COCTaBOB C X =Ndo.75Dyo.zsFe3(B03)4.TeMnepaTypbIYrJIa OTKnOHeHHIIp e 3 y J I b T a T b I A ~ H H OrJIaBbI~ ~MOXHOBaPHaHTnpOqeCCaHaMWHHsHBaHHIIJT'n0~0fiM ~ ~ H H T H CTPYKTYPbIO ~ ~@ e p p 0 6 0 p a ~ o B C peaJIH3aIJHefin03BOJIHJI B AeTaIDIX n p O a H t U H 3 H P O B a T b n O B e n e H H e MarHHTHbIX MOMeHTOBR " ~H F ~ - ~ O A C H HC T ~ Mn O C T a T O s H 0 YCneIIIHO O n H C a T b O ~ H ~ ~ Y X ~a HHO MH U~HIH ~MarHHTHbIX XapaKTepHCTHK.B cenb~ofir J I a B enapaMarHHTHbnraBTOpOMnpHP a C C M O T p e H b I M W H H T H b I e H MaTHHT03JIeKTpH9eCKHe~ J I W M O - H ~ ~ U J I O ~ O ~n a~p Ta MOe TBp .b 1 K p m x t U n H s e c K o r oCPaBHeHHHC3KCnePHMeHTtUbHbIMHMarHHTHbIMHXaPaKTePHCTHKklnonaonpeneneHb1XaPaKTePHCTHKaMH( H ~ M ~ T H H ~ ~ H HHOCBOTC~I I P H H M ~ H B O C T ~ )H H a OCHOBe AaHHbIX 0 PaCIIJenJIeHHXX 3 H e p r e T H s e C K H Xy p 0 B ~ e f i OCHOBHOrO M y J I b T H n J I e T a R - H o H ~ .

H e o 6 x o n 1 . 1 ~ 0COBnWeHHePaCCsHTaHHbIXXapaKTePHCTHKHccnenosaHHbIx ~ O ~ ~ T OP aB c. s e ~s @nOJIXXnpenCKa3tUTmAb(B03)4,HtUHsHeCOTMeTHTb B q e J I O M O s e H b XOpOIIIee3KCnepHMeHTtUbHbIMI.InJIIIKZiXnOrOH3@ e ~3 ~e ae ~ a B~ cpenmxaH c H n b H b r x (no 200 Tn) M a r H H T H b r xa ~ o ~ a n u fHi aMarHHTHbIXXapaKTepHCTHKaXHoA13(B03)4HCBII3aHHbIX C ~ @ @ ~ K T O MKpOCCOBepa ( B ~ ~ E I M O ~ ~ ~ ~ CHTH BXHHH~XM3 H e p r e T H Y e c K mypo~aefi R-HOH~).n p e n c ~ m a ~ ~Hoa neH Y H eTenJIOeMKOCTH H o A b ( B 0 3 ) 4HnosegeHHeBnoneaHoManHHLlIorr~kl HaHaIIIJIO CBOe 3 K C n e p H M e H T t U b H O e n O n T B e p w e H H e .

n p e n n o X e H H b 1 ~~ ~ M H A O B ~A.A.I M M e T O n H H T e p n p e T a q H H M ~ ~ H H T O ~ J I ~ K T ~nOJIIIPH3aqHH,W Y ~ C K O ~O~CHOB~HHH~a I~~ee K o p p e n x q H H c ~ a r ~ ~ ~ o c T p ~n mo ~~me miBin ,o n H eXopomHeHTennOBbIe,CpaBHHBmMmHTHbIe,MWHHT03JIeKTpHYeCKIIe,p a c u e n n e ~ ~HHXHHXxy p o ~ ~ eo fc Hi o B H o r o~ O ~ ~ T O CAeJItUB ,BbIBOA00 6 ~ a p p e ~ ~ b 3HaYeHkFII1epeAKO3eMenbHbIXIIOnCHCTeM0 6 o c ~ o s a ~IIpHYHHbIbMynbTHnneTa~ O J I ~ I U O M BJIHIIHHHR-HOH~,HccnegosaHHbnrH3MeHeHkIIIB3aMeIIJeHHOMTmA12,5Sc0,5(B03)4,H 3 M e H e H H e M W H H T H O ~ a~H H 3 0 T p O n H H ,noCBO~~CTBH~Bn a ~ ~ ornasefiKPHCTaTLnHYeCKOTOnoIIOJIIIHaP~CLUU@POBK~BKnwOB~ J I K ) M O ~ O ~ H~ 0Tl -~~ N d ~ A l 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4YMeHbILIeHHII 0 6 H a p p e H H o f i nOJIIIpH3aIJHH,nOJLRpH3aIJHHMarHHTOJTIpJT'HeM ~ ~ T H T O ~ J I ~ K T ~ E I Y n~OCJ IKI IOp H~3~m H H .CBII3aB HX C y B e n H Y e H H e M M W H H T H O ~aHH30TpOIIHH.~HCCJIeAOBaHWIpe3ynb~a~b1.ABTOP,a ~ a n ~ 3 ~ p y aCpaBHeHHIoO T M ~ Ya K~T yHU b~H O C T bcno3~on~naHoAb(B03)4,3KCnepHMeHTtUbHOrOnOCKOnbKy B H e M npOH30IIIJIOCpleCTBeHHOeCpaBHeHHIo C T m A l 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 H OXHnaeTCX C p l e C T B e H H O e5H3MeHeHHe(BO~MOXHOPOCT)H~ M O ~ O ~ (~H oT, T Om ) AB1 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4IIOJE3PH3mHH.n p e ~ ~ ~ a 3 Z l HIIOBeAeHHe0B > 9 TJI.B MarHHTHbIX I I O mB nocnen~eii ~ o c b ~ o ir in a B eAHccepTmmnpHBeAeHb1M a r H E I T o y I I p y r H X C B O ~ ~ C TaB n m ~ o 6 0 p a ~EI o~~~~~~~~~0~YTO n o B e A e H l i ecnoneM HIIOlIIIPkI3mHHpe3ynb~a~b1uccneno~amii60pa~aT m A l 2 , s S c o , s ( B 0 3 ) 4 .~ e ~ n e p a ~ y pHo~iHi ~ o J I ~ I U E I MX ynbTMnonbHbIxno~a3ZlH0,MoMeHToBHaXOAEITCX B IIOJIHOM KaYeCTBeHHOM COrJIaCUH C 3aBEICHMOCTXMEI MaTHEITOCTPHwEIH.K O ~ @ @ E ~ ~ U ~ H TBO B J I E I H ~ ~ ~ H ~ IKx O M ~ H H ~ H X XAaHHbIXB03MOXHOCTb KOJIHYeCTBeHHOMYJIbTHIIOJIbHbIXBOCIIPOH3BeCTH 3KCIIepEIMeHT.AJE3R-EIOHOBno~6opMOMeHTOBaJII0~060pa~aH0A13(B03)4OIIEICaHbI O C O ~ ~ H H O C T MaTHEITOCTPHwHHHB T p e X HaIIpaBJIeHEIXX: HeMOHOTOHHOe IIOBeAeHEIe AJEIHaIIpaBJIeHHX IIOJE3 BllC, ~OJIF,III~H BeJIEIYHHa MaTHEITOCTPEImEIEI I I p H HZUIpaBJIeHEIH M a r H H T H O r OnomB6 a 3 ~ c ~ oIIJIOCKOCTEIfiB((a,bH pa3~b1ii3 H a KBJla H B(lb.