Неофициальный отзыв 9 (Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов)
Описание файла
Файл "Неофициальный отзыв 9" внутри архива находится в папке "Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов". PDF-файл из архива "Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой докторскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени доктора технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3bIBHa aBropeoepar Alrccepraqllll Poralena An4per Hraronaesrqa<Paspa6orKa HayqHo-MeToAonoruIqecKLIX OCITOB CO3AaHlIfl IIepcneKTI',IBHbXcorrcKaHue yrenofiBbrcoKoreMrreparypHbrx gHeprerurrecKrrx KoMIrJIeKcoB), rlpeAcraBnenuoft Hac]lcreMblcrerreHr,r AoKTopa rexHlrqecKr{x HayK rro cleqrlaJlbHocrf,M 05.i4.01 - SneprerraqecKl{er,rKoMrrJreKcrr pr 05.04 .12 -Typ6oMarr,rHblI,rrorra6uuupoBarrHbreryp6oycraHonruponr' Bflaepuat sHepreTl{Ka KaK B Mllpe, TaK }I e POcczu urpaeT upesnrruafiHo B4;KHyIopoccrnra Ha ,{onro aroMHbrx elercrpoctanqufi ilpuxoAllrcfl uopsAKa 19% nnrpa6orrr'Isnerrpu.recxofi gHeprru{. ocnony arounofi gHepreTI'IKI{ naruefi cTpaIIbIcocTaBJIf,IOTpeaKTopHbrMr{ ycraHoBKaIu}Iuaporyp6uHHbD( enepro6noKrr c BoAo-BoMHbrMrr sHepreruqecKllMr{rleplloA ao 2030MorrlHocrbrc 440,1000 u 1200 MBr. 3neprefl,r.recKafl crparerrrf, Poccnn Har'KaK 3arrpeArronaraer yBeJrrrqenue nrrpa6orKr{ gJreKTpoeHepruu Ha aroMHbrx sJIeKTpocraHIIrIf,xIIpOAJIeHI',Ifl CpOKacrreT ocyrqecTBJIeHI,It [poeKToB HOBOI.O CTpO]ITenbcTBa, TaK ]I 3a cIIeTgKcnJryaTalluu 4eficrnylorqllx Snepro6noKoB II peaJII{3aUI{u lporpaMMbl I'IHTencu(purarluu ltyBenr,rqeHur xos(hfuqfieHTa ]rcrroJrb3oBarrr4fl ycrttrronnennofi MorrtHocrll.tIToCrout orMer]rrb,atounofi gHeprerlrKrr Poccrau flpeArloJlararor yBeJI]IqeHLIe ycranonnennofilepcueKTl4Be Ao 2030 r'MorqHocTI,I A3C 6onee IIeM n 3 pasa.
Bso,U IIoBbx MolqHocTeft nnpoeKTa A3CrrperrMyurecrBeuHo 6yaer ocyrqecrBJrf,Tbcr 3a cqer coopyxeHlls snepro6noKoBrrJraHbr pazBkrrvrs.2006 sa 6age noAo-BoArHbrx gHeprerlllrrecKr{x peaKTopoB,cocraBJrr{eT rroprAKa 34-35o/o,vroTeITJIOBZItr sKOHOMI'IIIHOCTb KOTOpbD(o6ycnoBJleHo cpaBHVTeJIbHO HI{3KrIM ypOBHeM TeMrleparypblrrapa, reHepl,IpyeMolo rAepnofi napolpoll3soAsqefi yctanonrofi,orpanravennofiTexHoJIorI{qecK[MI,IBo3MoXHocTsMupeaKTopHblxycTaIIoBoKpaccMaTpl,IBaeMo|oTIIIIa.E,Ur,rnCrgeHHrM CIOCO6OU CyqeCTBeHHOfO nOBbIIIeHI'Lf,renlOnOfi3KOHOMIITIHOCTI1IA3CHaqaJlrnoft reuuepaTypbl.f,Br,reTcs IIoBbrrreHIIe napaNreTpoB feHepllpyeMofo napa.
llonnureHuerlpoMbrlrrJleHHbrx uacuna6axToJIbKo 3a crrer r,uepHoro roprcqero n 6nuxa.fimeft uepcnerrllBe BB CB.fl3lI C sTIIM IIepCIIeKTIIBHrIM CnOCO6Ou yBerrrlqeHra'f, renlOnOftsif(ferrunuocrn il eAran[qHofi MorqHocrrr eHeproycrarroBoK A3C .flBJl-f,erct rIp]rMeHeHI{enepelpeBa napa' TarrauBHerrrHero ro oTHoIleHI{Io K x4epnofi lapoflpo]I3noAslqeft ycTaHoBKeBbIcoKoTeMIIepaTypHbndo6paaonr, paCcMaTpI,IBaeMatr aBTopoM 3aAaqa nepexoAa r ru6pugnblMManOBepOtTHO.snepro6noKttM tBJlterca arryanruofi.B pa6ore [peAcraBneHbr HoBbre HafrHbre p$yJlbrarbr s o6flacrz]lccJreAoBaHl'I-f, TeflnoBbrxcxeM rn6pla4nrx aToMHhIx SnerrpoCranquft, 1ron1rtlegHble c [p]IMeHeHIIeM MeToAoBrlapa IIMareMar[rrecKoro MoAenr{poBarrvrfl,. YcranosleHo BJIII{HI'Ie [apaMerpoB rleperpeBaflorasano,crpyKrypbr renronoft cxeMr,r Ha eHepferlrqecKylo e$(ferrunnoctr ru6praanoft A3C'qropau[oHrurbHbrM Bapr4aHTOM peanrr3arl]ru lepefpeBa napa tBJrflerc.f,cqer rerrJrorbrefo ocyIqecrBJIeHI'IecropaH1as opranr4qecrofo roIrJII{Ba rIocJIe [aporeHeparopa3aAo 600"C cqTo3a III'IJIIIHApOM BbICOKOIO AaBJIeHu-f,'rrocJreAyloullM IIpOMexyTotil{bIM IIepeIpeBoM IO 620"cgrrepro6nora rlp]I AByKparHoM yBenuqeHl'Iu n'rou+rocru (crro3BoJrrer rloBbrcrrrb gKolroMrrqHocrbuounoc'tul 3a cqer cxulaHl'Ifl1000 ao 2000 MBr).
flpu erou nrrpa6orKa AoIIoJIHureJIbHofir{cKonaeMoro Torrn[Ba rrpo]rcxoAllT cKIIIuoprara50o/o, IITO COIOCTaBIIMO C IIOKa3aTeJItMI',InapaMeTpoBoKoHoMlIqHocTI,I eneprooloron ynbTpacBepxKp[Tl{qecKrxHaBbrfIoJrHeHbI TaKXe uccJIeAoBttHIIs, HarrpaBneHHbrerrpeAnaraeMor.o cuoco6a rroBbrlrreHll-f, MOUIHOCTIIvIlapa' Bpa6ore[paKTuqecKylo peanl'I3all]IlogKOHOMrIqHocTlr: ctfoprrluponanA3C v paspa6oranaKoHoTpyKrnnnrr[ o6nur KoTJra-raporeperpeBaTels lir:tr ru6pulnoftMoIIIHOCTbIO 2000 MBr, 6asupyroueircssaKOHCTpyKTrrBHrrfl cxeMa nrrcoroo6opornofi ryp6unupeurenuft' [peAJIOXeHHbD( coIIcKaTeJIeM - II[n]IHApeoAHOM r,r3 HOBbD( HalE[Ia-ta>(HI4IIeCKIIXHrr3Kofo.uaB,,eHns rroBbrrrreHgoftnponycrnofi cnoco6nocrrrc AByxbspycnoftlporoqnofi qacrrto'gHepIeTI',ItIecKIIx ycTaHOBOK'Baxnrnvr (faffiopou, olpeAeJIflIOIqI,IM KOHKypeHTOCIIOCO6nocrrrr,ncrqeneprerlIKe, rBJrrercs yAenbHaf, BeJIrIrIuHa KafI]ITaJIbHru< nflo]Keuuft']IB TOMB aTOMHOfiIlplIxoAstql{xc.f, Ha 1xBrycTaHoBJlennoft uorqHoCTI',I.Bgron'r IIJIIIHe pa:pa6oranHas aBTopoM[pofHO3I'IpOBaHI4tMeTOAOJIOIUT [poeKT]IpoEaIIIIfl' IIpeAIIOJIararcuat ocylqecTBneHllec floBbrilreHHblMrl [apaNleTpaMurrepcrreKTr4BHOFO gHepreTuqecKoro o6opy4onanl{.f,cTOHMOCTITnrrcoroft cTerleHblo nayuroftrrapa Ha pilIHIIX STaAI,IJIX paspa6orrul, 6eccuopno, O6nagaerHOBII3HbIvI nparru'recrOft3HaqI'IMoCTu.Bo6eCne'IeHI'Ie npar<ruuecroft peaJII'I3aIIWIMaTeMaTutIecKI',IX rUoAeneft oqeHKlIrrpeAnafaeuoft rraeroAoJrorr.rH BIIepBbIe palpa6oran KOMflJIeKCHa ocnosaHlll'I peanl'I3OBaHHOTO KOMnJIeKcaA3C c [p[MeHeHIleM paspa6orannmcuccneAoBar{r,rfi noragano, qTo llepexoA x ru6pu4nrna1 rBr ycranonnenHOfirroBbrx TexHuqecKux peureuufi o6ecnewmaeT CHIIXeHIIe cTOI4MOCTUcTor,rMocTlr HoBbD( pemenufiMolqnocrlr 6olee qelvl Hauo6opyaoBa1kIfl.80o/o.IIpoBeAeHHofo lIccJIeAoBaHI'It IIoATBepxAaeTcs ueroAlrqecxofi,II,oCrOnepuOcTb B6180A98pe3ynbTaToB' anpo6aqnefi nanpopa6OranHocTblo LI apryMeHTI'IpoBaHHoCTbIo rron1rtleHHbrxHayr{Hbrx Id3I.AHLrax'HayrHo-[paKT[qecKr,rx rontfepeHqrltx, uy6nuraqrasMl'I B BeAyIrIuxcneAyloq[e:flocue aHaJrrr3a anropeifepara B KarlecrBe 3aMeqaHIaft rvroxno BbIAeJI[TbIIpIIBeAeT K1.
flpurraeneHue AJr.f, rneperpeBa llapa KoTna-napolepefpeBaTeJul nel{s6exHoKoTopoe sa A3C r'I 6es roro cpaBHI'ITenbHocHlDKeHr4Io AaB.[eHns Ha BXoAe B [apoBylo ryp6uny,ne6onHloe, I{, KaKKOMrrJIeKCa. IrlecJreACTBI,Ie,gHepfeTIIqecKoIOK yMeHbIIIeHI{IO rellJlosofi SKOHOMIIqH0cTIIarropetfepara nercHo, rrporr3BoAr4JracbJII{ OqeHKa BIrVlSIHrLs'HaqaJIbHOrO AaBreHus6nora rr KaKOe AorronH}ITeJIbHOe COlporrIBJIeHue BHOC}tr rlapoilepefpeBarenb'ToIIJI]IBe' IIpIlBeAer KflpmraeueHl{e [eperpeBarefls' pa6oraroqefo Ha opraHI4qeCKoM3arparaM gHeprura Ans o6ecnerleHl{t co6crseHHbrx Hyx'u. I'1 npousnoArlJlacbHa 3KOHOMT{qHocrb2..rlorroJrHr,rreJrbHbrMJrr{ orIeHKa 3aTpaT rrp}r o[peAeJIeH]IU 9KOHOMIIIIHOCil4ru6pu,4Horo gHepf o6nolca'BbICOKOTeM[epaTypHbx3.
B anrope{epare He Harrulll oTpCIKeH[e BoIIpocbI MaIIeBpeIIHOCTI{eAunn-uroft MolqHocTbro 2000 MBr (e), KaK lI AaHHbD( o xapaKTepeggepreTurrecKrlxKoMIIJIeKcoBBO3AeftCTBr4fl r{X Ha pe}K[Mbrpa6orrr Ap)rr[x reHepaTopoB MoIqHOCT]r B gHepf.OCUCTeMe'OneprennvecKrre KoMrrJreKcbr croJrbBbrcoKHM ypoBHeM Ha,qexnocrlr,6onurofi Motunocrl[, rrpex,4e Bcero'uro6rt lrcKJrroqrrrbAOJIXIIbIo6lagarnBo3HtIKHoBeHI'Ie HeltrTarsoft cl/rryaryrkrlI TeMcaMbrM o6ecnequrr ycroftuunocm pa6our 9H€pIOCI4CTeMbI.yragannHe 3aMerrar{r{fl He HocsT IIpI4HIIu[]IaJIbHoIo xapaKTepa ra He Brrufior na o6rqyrokIoIIeHKy AIIcCepTaUuonnOft pa6Otrr' nruerorrleft BHyTpeHIIIorc nofIIKyI{qeuocrnuft 3aBepIIIeHHrrft xaparrep. Antope$epar HanLIcaH rpaMoTHbIM HafIHbIM 'f,3bIKoMrroJrONCrrTeJrbHyIoorpaxaer rBopqecKuft uo[xoAaBTopa K I'IccneAyeMbrM BorlpocaM'<Paspa6orra.{uccepraqrar Poraresa A.H.
IIa TeMyHayr{HO-MeTOAOJIoFI'IqecKHXOCHOBco3AaIIn'IIIepcIIeKTI{BHbD(BbIcoKoTeM[epaTypHbIxsHepleTuqecKllxKoMIIJIeKcoB))oTBeIIaeTBceMrpe6Onanranr,r flOnOxeHu.f,OIIp[Cy)KAeHLIu yqeHbrx creneueft, yrBepXAeIIHoro nocTaHoBJIeHIIeM842, a ee aBrop, Pora'uenflpasureurcrna Poccuftcrofi oelepaqnu or 24 cenrx6pr 2013 r.
NeTexHIIqecK]Ix HayKAn4peft Hnr<onaenuq, 3acly)KuBaeT flpucyxAeHl4fl yreuoft cTeIIeHI'I AOKTOparocflequaJrbHocrrM 05.14.01.-3nepreruqecKfie c]rcreMbr r,r KoMrIJreKcbr]r05.04.12-Typ6orrranlrubr I{ xou6uuupoBarrHbre ryp6oycranoBK}r'f nannrul naymufiAO dHI4I4A3C)corPYAHrIKAOKTOp rexHI{rIecK}IX HayK(-/r'A/4-rlaxoncxufiBna4nrr,rup Mnxaft lonraq2018 r.IIHCTI'ITyI IIoAXqllOnepnoe o6rqeCtno <BoepOccuftCxuft Halrtalo-"tcJleAoBaTeJlrCruft(BHI{I4A3C))eKcnnyararlur{ aroMHbD( erreKrpocrallqub (AO109507, r. Mocrn4 yn. (Deprancrcas, A'25T e:l^.: +7 (499)7 9 6-9 1 -33e-mail : vniiaes@vniiaes.rufloanucr r{axoecroro B.M. 3aBepffoPyrono4zreJlb yfipaBneHl{f, rlo pa6ore c repcoHafloM.
