Неофициальный отзыв 2 (Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов)
Описание файла
Файл "Неофициальный отзыв 2" внутри архива находится в папке "Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов". PDF-файл из архива "Разработка научно-методологических основ создания перспективных высокотемпературных энергетических комплексов", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой докторскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени доктора технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OrsrreHa aBropeSepar Al{ccepra.quouuofi pa6orrr Poraresa Au4pex HurolaeBr.ua Ha reMy<Pa^:paSorKa HayqHo-MeroAorofl,IqecKurx ocHoB ao31a:aarfl rrepcneKTr{BHbrx BbrcoKoTeMneparypHblx gHeprerl4qecKl4x KoMnJreKcoB)), [peAcraBJreHHofiua coucKaHr{eyveuofr creneHl4 AoKTopa. rexHI4rIecKrIX HayK no cneqr4aJrbHocrrnvr 05.14.01 - 3Hepferl4qecKze cl4creMbl 14 KoMnJIeKcbr, 05.04.12 -TypSoMarrrr,rHbr rz noudusapoBaHHbrerypSoycraHoBKr,rCo:4anue [epcneKTI4BHbIX BbrcoKoreMneparypHbrx gHepreraqecKr4x KoMrrJreKcoB Anf relronofi z aroMHofi eneprertrKLr Ha 6ase uaporyp6uHHux rexHoJrorufi uaopfaHuqecKoM, tAepHoM 14 BoAopoAHoM TorrJrzBe, HaxoA_ruleecr B rIeHTpe BHr4MaHr.{rruzpoeofi sHeprerl4qecrofi HayKa, Bo3MoxHo roJrbKo Ha nyrr4 rroBbrrueHr4r HarraJrbHbrx[apaMerpoB TepMoAlaHav'lz.l'ecKoro rlr4Kna. Kaxue-ru6o suaqzMbre npoABr4)KeHr4q BgroM HalpaBJIeHrrI4 HeBo3Mo)ItHbI 5e: npoeeAeHr4.rr r4ccneAoB auuit, rroAroraBrrlrBaroUII4X HayrIHbIe rI MeTOAOJIOU4qeCKI4e OCHOBbI CTpaTefI4r4 B peIXeHUII4 KOMIIJIeKCa B3aI4MocB-f,3aHurx npo6JreM: eHeprerrrqecKoft e$SercrrrBHocrr4, pa:paSorKr{ HoBbrx KoHcrpyKrILIoHHbIX Marepl4anoB H 3aIrlr4THbIX noKpbrrufi, ocnoeuu-s rexHororufi H3roroBIreHLrfl v3 Hvrx oJIeMeHTos renroo6MeHHoro o6opy4oeaervrs, coBeplreHcrBoBaHnr rerlJIoBrIX cxeM 14 KoHcrpyKTI4BHbIX peureHufr, rIoAXoAoB 14 rrpr{Hrlr4rroB KoHcrpyrzpoBaHr4rrHoBoro o6opy4onaHr4fl, o5ecne.IeHl4fl ero 3Kclnyaraqzouuofi ua4dxnocru.
Bce ernacrIeKTbI npo6neuu o6osuaqeHbr poccuficxoit rexHoJrorv.recKofi nnarQopuofi <3xonorl4tlecKvr rtverafl Te[JIoBa.fl 3HeprerlrKa BbrcoKofi eS$exruBHocrr4> ra $e4epalruofiqeleeofi npofpaMMofi <I4ccneAoBaHI{.rI u pazpa6orKr4 rro rrprzopr4rerHbrM HarrpaBneHH.tlM pa3Bvrrufl HayrlHo-TexHoJrorurrecKoro KoMIIJIeKca Poccuu>. IIp" oroM rrpr4xoIJ4-refl yr{I4TbIBaTb, trTO rrepexoA Ha r4ciloJrb3oBaHr4e BbrcoKoTeMneparypHbrx napaMeTpoB [apa Ha yronbHbrx gHeproSnor<ax Bcrperlaer nperurrcrBr{-rl KaK TexHr4rrecKoro xapaKTepa, oBfl3aHHble flpexAe Bcefo c ua4eNuocTbro KoHcTpyKrIr4oHHbrx MaTepHanoBAn.[ [aponeperpeBanerreit, naponpoBoAoB, cryneHefi BbrcoKoro AaBneHLrfl rypduur,r,TAK V 3KOHOM\lrreOKOfO trIrAHA Vr3-3A IIOBbrrrreHI4f, CTOI4MOCTI4 TaKI4X SHepfeTr4qeCKr4XKoMrIJIeKcon.
A B aroMHofi enepreu{Ke cAep}Kl4BaroqrzM $arropoir,r rBJrrrrorc.f, rpeSoBaHLrfl 6 es onacH o crLr, o SycnoueHHbre yp oBHeM orp aHr4rrzB aroullrx [ap aMerpoB rr ep uofr eneprerr4rrecKofi ycrauoerz.B ce.ssu c Bbrrrrerr3Jrolr(eHHbrM HarrpaBJreHHocrb r4ccneAoBa:auft ua pa:paSorKy r4HayrrHoe oSocHosaHl{e rexHrrrlecKl{x peureuufi, B eoBoKyrrHocrl4 oSecue.rnBarouluxco3AaHI4e B nepcleKTl4Be BbICOKOTeMnepaTypHbIX sHepfeTr4rrecKr{x KoMrrJreKcoB HoBoro noKorrenvrfl. Ha ocHoBe naporyp6uuHofi TexHoJrorr4r4 c roBbrrrreHH;rMu TexHrrKooItoHoMHrrecKI{Mrr rloKa3arelrfllr:z, oSycrouvrBaer HecoMHeHHyro ar(TyaJrbHocrL,reMbl AnccepraquoHnofi pa6orrr. 3Aecr cneAyer orMerr{rb, qro c$oprvrynvpoBaHlaflIlenb oxBaTbrBaeT rrpaKTr{qecKu Becb KoMfrJreKc BonpocoB no soprtrupoBaHr4ro rtolxoAoB K oSocnosaHllro cocrana o6opyAoBaHr4q r,r errSopy napaMerpoB Ans nepcneKTuBHbIX BbICOI(OTeMIIepaTypI{bIX gHepfeTr4qeOK}rx KOMIIIeKCOBCACrOJrb3OBaHneM KaK Cy-rIIecrByIoUZX, TaK Lr HoBbrx rexHI{LIecKr4x perxeuafi.
KoppeKTHo IIocraBrIeHFIbIe 3a[aqv Al4cceprarluoHHoro r4ccJreAoBarlr4tr flBrrlrvrcb neo6xo4uMbrM ycnoBrzeM nonyqeHrr-f, pe3yJlbraroB, odraAarorql4x nprr3HaKaMrr Hay.ruofi HoBrr3Hbr I4 rrpar(ruqecrcofi3HaquMocTI{.Hayvnan HoBLI3Ha pa6oru.qocrarorrHo rIoJrHo oxapaKTeprz3oBaHa e aeropedreprre v 3aKJrroqaero-s: rtperr<Ae Bcero n paspa6oraHHoM KoMrrJreKce r,rHHoBarluoHrrbrxTexHI4rIecKI4x pellleHl4fi, 3arII4xIdHHbIX lrlec']tblo IIareHTaMr4 PO14 Boflnouarclrrl4x Honltfr xoncrpyKTlzBHlrfi o6lzx 3Heprerr4r{ecKr4x KoMrrJreKcoB Ha ocHoBe naporyp6rzHHbIX TexHolorafi; B HayqHorra o6ocuoBaHLruAannofi coBoKynHocrr4 perueHzfi c ror{Kl43peHl4's rexHl4rlecxoft eos\4o)KHocrlr I{ gKoHoMuqecrofr qenecoo6pa3Hocrr4ux peanv-3ar\r4u; e Honofr MeroAonorl4l{ npoeKTIzpoBErHLnr rexHruecr(r4x peruenufino BbrcoKoTeMrleparypHblM gHellferI4r{ecKl4M KoMIrrIeKcaM, r{cronb3yrouefi co.reraHHe pacqerHbIX Ir 3Kc[epI4MeHTaJIb[Ibrx MeroAoB rrccJreAonanui,t, ycoBepueHc.rBoBaHHyrcMeroAI4Ky pa^:pa6orKlz re[JIoHalpt]KeHIlbIX oxJra)r(AaeMbrx 4eralefi BbrooKoreMneparypurtx ryp6r4H Ha ocHoBe olrepex{alou1efr nepz$nrcaquu MareMarr4rrecKr4x riro4erefi; npaspa6orKe anropl4TMoB u pacrrerHblx MoAerefi rclroqeBbrx sJreMeHToB npororrHoftqaarr4 [nfl Ixl{poKoro KJIacca ryp6ovaruzrH, a rapKe B p-flAeApyrrzx nprrHrlrz[r{aJrr,Ho HoBbIX floJloxeuzfi 4nx SopukrpoBaHnr crpyKlyprr rz errSopa pa6our4x rrapaMerpoBBbr-coKoreMrreparypHbrx 3Heprerl4rrecKrzx r(oMrr[eKcon.
Or4elbHo cJre,qyer orMerrrrb pe3ynbrarbl ro Brv-sHI4IO [apaMerpoB napa Ha rexHr4Ko-SKOHOMr4rreaKr4e [oKa3are lru LLcrpyKTypy rel]noBblx oxeM SHepferI{r{ecKHX,KOMrrJreKcoB, a raKxe no r4crroJrb3oBaHr4roSynr<qzoHallbHo-croLlMocrHoro aHanl43a AJi.[ Bbr.trBJreHr4.s ycnoBufi 4ocrux eHLrflMaKcI4MaJIbHoro ypoBHx eSQeru4BHocrI4 npeAno)KeHHbrx n pa6ore peruenzfinpr{ Mr4Hr4MaJrbHbrx 3aTpaTax.flpa rcruvecKaqaq u Mocrb pe3ynbraroB paSorrr recHo yBfl3aHan anrop eQ epare c KDKAbIM rono)KeHl4eM HayqHoft HoezsHrL fraeHbrM coAep)KaHr4eM, orrpeAeJrrrotULrM npaKTI4rIecKyIo UeHHocrb paSoru, flBlrfleras, roKa3aHHa-s Bo3MolKHocrbpeaJrLr3ar\krv Ha rIpaKTIrKe nepc[eKTlzBHbrx rexHoJroruit c 14 crroJlr3oBaHr{eM paspa6oraHHr,rx3HHayrrHo-MeroAonorl{qecKl'Ix ocHoB I{ HoBbIX TexHrIrIecKZX pettreuzft.
Eonrrlroe npaKTl4r{ecKoe 3HalIeHI4e rrMelor nupa6oraHHble IvIeroAbI I4 MoAerrr4 orIeHKr4 cror4Mocrlrco3 naHvrfl o 6 opy4oe aHut{ H oB oro tIoKoJI eHr4 fl u B rlenoM Bbrc o KoreM[eparypHbrx oHepf e TI4qecKI4x KoMIIJleKcon. C vx I4cIIoJIb3oBaHI4eM MoxtHo olleHrrBarb Brrr4flHte IloBbIXHayr{Ho-TexHIzIIecKI4x pelxeHuit 4ltt sHepreTl4rlecKI4x KoMrrJreKcoB Ha rzxQunaucoBbre14krHB e CTLIIIT4 OHHbre IIOKa3 aTeJIr4.TeoperuuecKafl 3HaqnMocrr padorbr cocrozr B ToM, rrro nonyireHHbre Ar4c_cepraHToM pe3ynbrarbl AorlonH.flrcr u yrny6rrror npeAcraBrreHzfl o BrruflHvrv \apaMerpoB napa Ha rexHI{Ko-SKOHOMI4r{eCKr{e rroKa3arerrv v Ha crpyKTypy rerr.troBbrxcxeM' Ha Bo3MolItHbIe BaptraHTL,I KoHarpyKTaBHofo o6laxa ocHoBHoro o5opy4 oBaHLrflpeuIeHI'It BbIcOKOTeMnepaTypHbIX SHepreTr4r{eCKr4X KOMTTJTeKCOB LIB I{enoM o TeopeTI4qecKIzX noAXoAaX K AocTI4XeHI4Io MaKcLIMaJIbHoro ypoBH.{e$$er<Tr4 B HO CTrI Trpr.l }./LTHI4}''4I!{3 aI\VU 3 aTp aT.14KOMIIOHOBOTIHLIe{ocro nepHocrt, u o6ocuoBaHHocrb nonyr{eHHbrx pe3ynbraroB Aocrr4raerc-s BpaSore I4clIoJIb3oBaHIreM coBpeMeHHbIX MeroAoB pelueHr4f, TefInorexHrrLIecKZX 3anaq14 M eTOAOB MareMarl{qe cKof o M oAenl4p oBaHr4.q, c orleraHneM MareM arr4qe cKof o M one nLIp o BaHr4 x u $uzutecKo f o gKclepr4MeHTa.Anpodaqvfl u onydnurcoBaHue pe3ynbraroB, ocHoBHbrx rroJroxegzfr 14 BbrBoAoB npoBeAeHbl B Aocraror{HoM o6rdue: ony6lzroBaHo 58 uayvuux pa5or, B roMrII4cJIe 76 C/IarcfrB HayqHbIX r(ypHanax,BKJrroqeunrx B leper{eHr BAK MraHo6p.n ayKuP@ 4n.a ony6nzroBaHvrflpe3yJlrraroB Ar{cceprar-lzoHHr;rx r4ccJre gonauurt,13 crarefiB xypHaJlax, I4HAeKczpyeMbIX MexAyHapoAHr,rMu 6azaytuAaHHbrx Scopus n Web ofScience,6 nareuroe ua zgo6pereHl4t; cAenaHo 16 4oxna4oB Ha 15-ru rpeAcraBr4renbnux xou$epeHqr4-rrx, r43 Koropux 10 sapy6eNurrx.Cym ilo anrope$eParY, rvcceprarJr4fl npeAcraBJr.rrer co5ofisaeepurdnnyroKpynHylo HayrIH o -14 coneAoB arerlb cKylo pad ory Ha aKryanbHyro reMy, p e3ynbrarbrKo ropofi o6ria4aror nay"rHofi HosusHofi, rtpaKTl4rlecrofr r4 Teoperz.{ecKofi 3Harrr4x4ocrbro"Buecre c reM rro aBTopesepary zMerorc_s 3aMeqaHr{_s z Bonpocbr:1.
He upznereHbl xapaKTepncrLrr<v ycraHoBoK rn.rr r4ccneroB aH:afl MoneJrbHbrxodpa:qoe 3neMeHToB HoBoro oSopy4oe aH:zfl. npr4MeHr.rreJrbHo K npeAJro)KeHHbrM TexHHr{eCKI4M peIXeHI4.flM H I4CIIOIb3OBaBIIIUXafl B 3KC[epZMeHTaX cpeACTBuswepe]Fiuitvto6pa6orr<r4 ilonyqaeMbrx pe3ynbraroB.2' O nepcneKTl4BHocru npeAnoxeusofi KoHcrpyKrusnofi cxeMbr rouo.1rofi KaMepbl fopI43oHTaJIbHOfO I{CTIOJIHeHI4fl HeAOCTaTOqHO Cy,4r4Tb ronbKo no pe3yJrbraraMMoAenupoBalJnfl aopoAr4HaMI{KI4.
B'racrHocru, paSorocnocoSHocrb xoJro4Hbrx BopoHOK, paClOJIolKeHHbIX flo AnI{He TO[IKI4, 3ABlZrAl1rT I,I oT TeMilepaTypHblx ycnoBr4fi,onpe-Aentrcrqnx orcyrcrBLleI{ BO3MO}r(HOCTb fpaHynapoBaHvrfllttnaKa.3 . Orcyrcrnyel onl4c aHkre I,Icnonb3yeMbrx MareMarrrqecKqx vo4erefi .OrNle'IeHHble HeAocrarKl{ He eHr4}Kalor IloJlo)Kzreruuofi oueHKr4 npo4erauuofipa6orrt vr He Blrr4rror Ha o6ocnoeaHHocrb rJraBHbrx pe3ynbraroB r4 BbrBoAoBAr4ccep'|AI\LII4, KOTOpbIe I{MOIOT CyUIeCTBeHHOe 3Har{eHI4egHepfeTLIqeCKOfiAn{ pa3BLITLItOrpaanv Pocczu.ITTJIaKOBAlg.VTfl CTeHllpe4crauleHH€tt Aaccepraul4oHHa.rr paSora rroJrHocrbro coorBercrByer rpedoBaHI{-gM n.
9 <llonoxeHr4-s o npzcyxAeHr4r4 y.lenrx crenenefi), rpeA:brrBn{eMbrMKAoKTopcKI4M Azccepralln-qM Ha cor4cKaHne yvenofi crerreHr{ AoKTopa rexHr4r{ecKr4xHayK, a ed aerop, Poralee An4pefi Hrar<onaesr4q,3aery)KrrBaer npl4cynrA eHufleuy yvenofi creueHl'I AoKropa rexHIrqecKZX HayK rro cnerlr4arbHocr-svr 05.14.01 OneprerzrIecKI4e clrcreMbl rr KoMnJlexcrr, 05 .04.I2- Typ6onaarrrrHbr rz r<olr6zuhpoBaHHbre ryp6oycrauonxz.3anopvu Aneroau4p CepreeBr4r{, AoKTop rexHur{ecKr4x HayK, upoQeccop, pyKoBoArrrenb Hayvuo-odpa3oBarenbHoro rIeHTpa Zu>xeHepuofi urxonbr sHepferr4Ktr, OfAOy BO <HaqproHaJrbHbrft zccneloearenrcrcufi Tolrcrzft rloJrr4TexHI,r.recKrafi yHlrBepcr{TCT)),634050, Pocczx, r. Tovcx,E-mail : zav orin@tpu.ruren.
B (3822) 563910.llolnzcr3anp-r. Ileuuua,4ou30.Bep-'IrcV.reHrrfiO <Haqzonalrsr,rfrr4ccneAoyHr4BepcnoJII4TeXHlarleCrclr'frO.A. AHaur,enac;3 A{. ^aOt.
