Отзыв официального оппонента, к.х.н., М.Г. Беренгартена (Комплексное оборудование и технологические процессы промышленного производства анолита и феррата)

oT3bIB OOTIUI4AIbHOTO OITTOHEHTAKaHAr4Aara xr{Mr.rqecKr4x HayK, flpoQeccopa (a$eApbr <Aunapar5,puoeo$opMrreHrle r{ aBToMarr.r3arlrrr rexHoJrorr4qecKr,rx nporr3BoAcrB<<MocxoscKr4 ft noJrrrrexHr4qecxzft yur,nepcn:rer>>(DfBOy BOEepeurapreHa Mnxan.na leopruern.raHa Ar{cceprarlr,rro Aparcveera EBreHrlq Ilurcoraegraqa<<Koun.nerccnoe o6opygonaHrre r{ TexHoJror[qecKne [poqeccbrrrpoMbrruJreHnoro [polr3BoAcrBa anoJrrrra u Qeppara>>, npeAcraBJreHHyloHa corrcKaHve yqeHor4 cTerreHrr KaHAaAaTa TexHr4rrecKr4x HayK no cneqrraJrbHocTr{05.02.13 - Marrunu, arperarbr n flpoqeccbr (uonzrpa$nvecKlre Lr y[aKoBoqHlreTexHoJrorur{ ra o6opy4oranr4e, xrr Mr{qecKaq npoM burrren nocru)(rexnzvecrue Hayxz)Arrya.nrnocu,TeMbIpa6ora Apaxveena E.H. nocssuena aKTyrurbHofi ragave'{lrccepraquourratpa,rpa6orru rr BHeApeHrrr B npoMbrrlneHHyro 9Kc[Jryararlr{ro KoMrureKcHoro3rreKTpoJrr43Horoarperara (K3A)lporr3BoAcrBa MeroAoM rrreu6pannoroxJropcoAepx(aIeroarroJrr{Tau $epparao6essapaxunanlrr r{ oqrrcrKr.r BoAbrr.rNr'ioAHoBpeMeHHorogJreKTpOJrr.I3aHaMeCTe6egonacnorofiorpe6reHu{:uairput AJrr gKoJror[qecxu 6egonacnorocroqHbrx BoA.llpousno4crno xJropcoAepxauero auoJrnra ra $eppara B pa*pa6oranHoMarperare MeroAoM naena6panuoro gneKTpoJILI3a o6ecnequnaetBbIcoKyIorrpou3BoArrreJrbHocrb, 6esonacHocm npolt3BoAcrBa r{ Ao3rrpoBaurlrr peareHToB 3acqeT3"rux [poqeccoB, Bo3MoxHocTb perynupoBaHl4tB 3aBacl,tMocTr{ oT TeKylqero pacxoAa peareHToB,aBToMaTr{3arlrrvtnpo'r3BoAtTenbHocTl,rKoMrraKruocrb u uacura6upyeMocrb o6opy4onaHurflocyqecray parpa6o:rannrre rrAJUrApyrrxlrccJreAoBaHHbre3aAaq.arperar I4 TexHoJlorutrBJr.f,IOTCt flpnMepaMlt aKTnBHO pa3BI{BaIOqerOCt B [OCJIe.{Hr{e rOALI HalpaBneHl4tpaspa6orxr,rvHTerpzpoBaHHbrx(coeverqexxrx) upoqeccor,rroBhrrlaroulux 9KoHoMnqecKylo, 9KoJloryFlecKyror,rcyqecrBeHHoTexHoJlorruecKyloe$Serruanocrl.O.unocmrufturur oqrrcrKa no4rr $epparoM Harplu Moxer paccMarpliBarbctcorpeuennofi TexuoJronrrr epBllqnoro xJIoplIpoBaHI4x u $norynxquucynrQaroru rpexBaJleHTHoro )KeJIe3a, nprl gToM xe o6pasyrorcs no6o'*nreKaK 3aMeHaTOKCHTIHbIeIIKaHIIepOfeHHbIe TZLIIO|eHLI3I{pOBaHHbIe OpraHI4qeCKIIe COeAI4HeHLI'.CosNaecrHoe HcrIoJIb3oBaHLIe aHoJrI4Tauu $epparaAnfl,o6e::apaxnBanLrfr rrr,rrbeBofiTexHnqecKofi BoAbI Iro3BoJILrT CHrr3LrTb ypoBeHb xnopr4poBa[r4fl BoAbrefo Ha o6pa6orrypacrBopoM non) IaeMoro gJIeKTponr43oM $eppara :aarpufl, a) cneAoBareJrbHo,oTK€BaTbCryMeHbrullTOT nepBr4rrHofoKOIUqeCTBOxnopupoBalP^ufl.cur,.vr3aMeHofio6pa:yroqkrxcs, ToKcprrrHbrx xJropopraHntrecKlrxcoe4unenufi.Orcyrcrnue oreqecrBeHHbrxusapy6exnux aHarrofoB orrpeAenreroprIfLIHarIbHocTb rIpe.{JIo)ICeHHbIX coHcKaTeJIeM TeXH}ITIecKLIX H TeXHOJIO|UqeCKT4Xperuenufi K3A Ans oAHoBpeMeHHoro npon3BoAcrBa aHoJruraraSeppara Harpu\ aIax ucrroJlb3oBaHrie B [poMbrrxnennofi BoAorroAroroBKe Lr BoAoorBeAeHLrLr B rleJrrxrroBbrrueHrrf, sSSerrnnHocrrl o6e:rapaxvrBaHus,kr orrucrKrr BoAhr LtCTOKOBorrpeAennor 6eaycnoBHyro aKTyttrrbHo crr pa6otrr.AHa.rus coAeprrannr pa6orrr,{uccepraq[oHHar pa6ora Aparueera E.H.

cocroprr rr3 BBeAeHvts., rrsrn rJIaB,3aKJrroqeHur, BbrBoAoB,clrrcKa nlrreparypbr H upuroxenufi. O6qnfi o6revpa6oru cocraBJrrer 192 crpaHlrrlbr MarrrlrHornrcHoro reKcra, BKJIIoqat 54 pucynra,27 ra6nurl, crrrrcoK Jrlrreparypbr u3Bo sneAenuu o6ocHoBaHa13 1 nazrraeHoBaHLIrl,2nputtoll(eHLIrl.aKTy€rJrbHocrb reMbl ALIccepraIILIoHHofi pa6orrr,BbrIroJrHeH aHaJrLr3 cocTorHrlf, upo6nervrrr, c$oprvryJll4poBaHblpa6orrr, HafrH€If,Ilenb krgallav^ulHoBLr3Ha vr [paKTuqecKuul 3HaqllMocrb, o6ocHosaHaAocroBepHocrb pe3yJrbraroB LrccJreAoBanaLrrvro6ocuoeaHHocrb ocHoBHbIxrroJroxeHuitpt BbrBoAoB, c$oprr,rylupoBaHbr ocHoBHbIe rIoJIox(eHLIs, BbIHoclIMbIe Ha3arqkrry.uepnofi rJraBe aBTop uo4po6Ho aHaJrrl3l{pyer ocHoBHbIeuccJreAoBareJrbcKlre pa6oru u [areHTHbre peruerrkrfl, Iro rexHoJrortltM orILIcrKI4nurresofi BoAbr Lr croKoB.

flpn 3ToM ocHoBHoe BHI4MaHkIe yAenterct reMBnoTeHIIUanbHoBo3Mo)KHbIM peIueHI4tM,Korophle AoDKHbr o6ecne.Iurr6esouacHbre Ant oKpy)Karoqefi cpegbr rr gKoHoMLrqecKLT orrpaBAaHHbre MeroAbr,TCXHOJIO|III{nIarresofipbrHKe14BoAbrafperaTbr.IIycrpofictBaCTOKOBAnfl,llpoana-rrn3l4poBaHbr rrpr,lMeHrreMbreAnfl oqr,rcrKr4peafeHTbr, MeToAbr 3neKTpoJrLr3a Lr cyqecTByrorlLre Haron)rrreHrf, xnopcoAepx(arqnx peareHTonraSepparon.Anrop paccMarpv Baer AocrolrHc rBa Lr HeAocrarKu cyqecrByro rqvx Mero.{oBc npr{MeHeHneM xJropcoAep)Karqux peareHTonneo6xoAnMocrHraHoBbrxpaspa6orrzo6esaapaxvrBanvrro BoAbr.

Co.reraHue$epparoB u [puxoALrr K BhrBoAy oKoMrrJreKcHhrxftepparnrrx texnororufi oqucrKr4OIILICTKOI4 XJIOPCOAEP)KAIIII,IMLI PCAfCHTAMU, B3.f,TbIXyMeHbruurb HefarlrBHoeBJrrr.rrHr4eperuenufi rocB MEHbIUIIX AO3AX, IIO3BOJIflETxJlopa Ha oKpylKaron{yrc cpeAy.He 6rrno BbrsBreHo [3BecrHbrx oreqecrBeHHbrx u aapy6exHblx rlpororllrroBKoMrrJreKcHbrx peruenui,tno o6essapaxorBaHr.rro BoAbrnaerra6paHHoro oneKTponu3a AnflronfreHlrrr4 croKoBc TIpLIMeHeHLIeMaHoJIkITa H Seppara.llpe4raraeurtfiaBTOpOM Ha OCHOBe aHaJrr43a JrprTepaTyphr KoMnJreKcHbII,I SIeKTpOJII,I3HbILI arpefaTfeppara vAJtfl oAHoBpeMeHHoro rtonf{eHusaHoJII{Ta Mo)Ker cylqecrBeHHorroBbrcrlrb e@Sercrr,rnHocrb npoqecca.O6ocnoeaHa rlenb Ar4cceprarlr4oHHoro uccneAoBannfl,vrpe6onannxKpaspa6arhrBaeMoMy gneKTpoJrLr3HoMyarpefary Lr napaMerpaM TexHoJIorHqecKI{xflpoqeccoB rrporl3BoAcrBa aHoJrLrra ueppara.SBo nropofi r.nane [pe,{craBneHo u o6ocuoBaHo KoHrlerrry€trlbHoe perreHLIeKOMIIJIeKCHO|O SJreKTpOJrr€HOfOalperaTa; HaOCHOBaHT4I4 TeOpeTUqeCKLIXrrpeAcraBneHraft paccqr,rraHbr ocHoBHbre rexHoflorlrqecKl{e [apaMerpbr rlpoqeccoBeJreKrpoirr,r3a aHonr4TaKOMTTOHOBOqHbTeLt Seppara:nurpr4fl; pa":pa6oraHrr rpI,IHIIurnarIbHbIe upelreHur MoAyneu arpefara.KouulexcHrrfigJreKTpoJrtrsHrrfiarperar BKJIIoqaer MoAyJII{ An{ rronf{envrfl.xrropcoAepx(arrlero aHoJrLrra (xroparop) 14 Seppara (Sepparop) vrerra6panHbrMsJreKTpOnI43OM U aBTOMaTI43I4pOBaHHyrc CI{CTeMy yHpaBJIeHLIt.BxJroparope ocHoBHbrM rrpoAyKToM .rrBJrf,ercr BoAHbrfi pacrBopoKcrlAaHToB,cMecr4B $epparope B pe3yJrbrare p€BnoxeHvrfl, pacxoAyeMoro cr€rrrbHoro3JreKrpoA a s 2UoA-nofi tr1enoquo6pa:yerca fi epp ar :r'utptrfl, Na2FeOa.Anropona BbrrroJrHeHbr pactrerbr kr no4o6panrr parlr4oHzurbHbre 3HaireHutKOHTIeHTpA\Vkr rrleJror[r, TeM[epaTypa SneKTpo rrvr3a, HanpDKeHvre Ha xnopaTopepISepparope, paccquraHbr 3HaqeHr{s BbrxoAa uo roKy Ans o6onx rr,ro4yne[.BruraBe HaTpeTbeIlocHoBaHLrkTsHeprorrorpe6nenur paspa6oraHbr cxeMHbreArrfl rrpolr3BoAcTBaQyHrquoHr4poBaHuflpacqeTa rrpor{3BoAuTeJrbHocTllr4 KoHcrpyKTr,rBHbreprpelxeHux nao4yneftkr Qepparon v onpeAeJIeHbI pe)KLIMbI prxB cocraBe K3A.

llpunegeurt cocraB rvro4ynefi K3A,aHoJrLrrarrapaMeTpbr TexHoJrofuqecKofo rrpoqecca rroJrrreld'ufl. aHoJrr.rra H Qeppara, cocTaBuporpaMMHo-an[apaTHafl. peann3a\krfl. cucTeMblLraBTOMaTU3?lpOBaHHOfOynpaBneHr{t upoqeccaM}I [poLI3Bo.qcTBa peaf eHToB.Paspa6oraH(to2S ru/cyrrcz)lrrr3roroBJreHK3Arpolr3BoAureJrbHocrbro Ao 1040 r/.r xroparpu eHepro3arparax Ao 3,0 rBr'.I/xr xrlopa u lo 420 r/u $eppara(ao 10 rr/cyrrcu) upu oHepro3arparax Ao 6 rBr'q/rr fieppara, ro3BoJlsrounfio6eaaapaxlrBarb ao 300 *tltac nnrresofi BoAbr (us pacvera Ao 3,5 rvr/n) u lo 2100*tltaccroqHhrx no4 (H: pacqera Ao 0,2 rrar/n). HecouneHHbIM AocroLIHcrBoMpaspa6oraHHoro KoMrrJreKcHoro arperara flBlrflercfl Bo3Moluocrb nonfrarbpeareHTbr 4rrx o6pa6orxz BoAbI Ha Mecre rlpuMeHeHvt.B .rerneprofiK3A Hao6tacru u BruraBe rrplrBeAeHbr pe3ynbrarbl ucrtrltart*titBoAoorrlrcrHbrx coopyx(eHlrrxBr.

,{sepxuncreHuxeropoAcKoitJleHuHrpaAcrofi o6lacru gKcrrepuMeHT€rrrbHbre uccneAoBantrfl o6esaapa>KvrBanvs.aHoJrtrroMuSepparorra :narpr4s. 3rcuepunreHT€trlbHonoATBep)KAeHae$SerrunHocrb Qeppara lrrurpufl. B orHorrrenuvr rraroreHHblx MtIKpoopraHI,t3MoBrrpuo6esaapaxLrBaHr4vr vrv, BoAbIuTOKCI,IIIHbIX XIIMLIIIECKLTX BCIIIECTB6rrrosbrx croKoB, a raK)Ke BorHoIueHLII,IY\ T')KCJIbIX METULIIJIOB IjPVT OKHCJIEHLII{T4KoaryJrrrlnu uM npoMbrruJreHHbrx croKoB.

,.{aHrr peKoMeHAar\vv rro ilpuMeHeHplloSeppara Harplrfl r4 TexHlrrrecKux cpeAcrB ero rron1^lenufl, An-f, rtpoMrrruleHnoffBO.4OTIOA|OTOBKLI U OqLICTKI{ CTOKOB.llorasana fiepcneKTr,rBuocrbAooqr4crKy $epparonrxropopraHr,rqecKr,tx:rra:rpvfl,coeAr4rreHr4r43aMeHhI AOOq?ICTKII CTOKOB rur[OXJrOpr4TOM Haxropa uB crourrrx BoAax Nfi c6poca vrx Bo6ecne.rzsarcuas orcyrcrBrrenoBepxHocrHLre ncrolrHr{KI4.B nsrofiruraBe npr4BeAeHBr peKoMeHAaqr4r4 rro BHeApeHnro [peAJroxeHHbrxTexHI,IqecKI4X peIUeHr,IUnOOIII4CTKe BOABII{eo4ocna6xenua, o6ocuoaana gKoHoMrrqecKaflCTOKOBurrpeAJraraeMbrx peurenufi. floxa3aHa BrrcoKarBCI4CTeMbI TOpOACKOTO3KoJroruqecKuure$$errunuocrret|$exrnnnocrbrIctIoJIb3oBaELrt$eppara H tpvtfl, rrporBJurcqero oAHoBpeMeHHo csoficrsav oKlrclrtrrerl'LrKOaryJrtHTa.B srrsoAax rro At4cceprarluu aBTop o6o6utraetAr.rcceprarluu, orMeqaer,MeTaJrJroBBCOqeTaHUr,ruro o6pa6orxaBoAbII{ croKoBocHoBH;Ie floro)KeHus(feppararr,ru uIeJIoqHhIXC XJrOpCOAepXaqI{Mt{ peareHTaMLI rIo3BOIteTornepB[qHoropesymtare croqHble BoAbI rrocJle rarofi o6pa6orKlrHe coAep)KarypoBeub xJIop[poBaHI,It IroAroroBJrennofi no4rr I,{JIII orKa:}arLcsxJroprrpoBaHr.rr.

BxJropav ero coeArrHenrafi, vroBOAOIOATOTOBKTTCIII,I3I'ITbcoorBercrByer coBpeMeHHhIM HopMaM KaqecrBar.r AOrryCKaeT CJILIB CTOqHbIX BOABeCTeCTBeHHbIe BOiqOeMbI.Paspa6orannuft aaropou vo6lrnrurrfi rortnrexcnrrft gJIeKTpoJIlt3HbIft arpera'rrro3BoJrrer r.rcrroJrb3oBarr ero rro Mecry npr{MeHeHI,IJI c srrcoroft srononauvecrofi,gKoJloruqecKofi rl rexnororr,r.recxofi e$$exrllBnocrblo.Hayuuan HoB[3Ha pa6omr cocrolrr B HafrHoM t4 oKc[epIrMeHTaIbHoMo6ocnogaur4r4 Kourleflqa[ LruTerp[poBaHHoro MoAyJIEHoro arperara AJIIoAHOBpeMeHHOTO flpOr{3BOACTBarrplrMerrreMbrxHarvreCre$eppata, amoItfi'fa LI4nr o6esrpexnBanuv BoAhI I4 croqHblxBoA,KoaryJItHTa,a raKx(e Haf{Hoo6ocnosauHoro no46opa napaMerpoB TexuoJloruqecKoro flpoqeccaTexHr.FrecKrrxLII{HoBbIxTexnoJlon4qecKv x perueurafi KoMlJIeKcHoro greKTpoJlla3Horoarperara rr ero Mo,ryJrefi, o6ecnevltranqux 3aAaHHyIo [poI'I3BoArITeJIbHocrb rroaHonnryr.r$eppary, gHepro- z pecypcoc6epexenlle rro cpaBHeHluo c I,I3BecrHbIMI,IAHdIOTAMI,I.O6ocnosaua Bo3Moxuocrb cHtI)KeHI'It KoHIIeHTpaIII4T'r npuuenreuofiB arperare Irlenoql4 nrIpHMeHeHus6o2paza(c 40% Ao 20o ) c oAHoBpeueuuofi Bo3Mo)KHocrbK)ree AeIITeBbIX naerra6paHAls ueu6paH Horo sJre KTponH3a.Bnepnue rroK€Bauo, qro gesunfuqr4pyroqaq cnoco6uocrr Seppara HarpvrflrlocpaBHeHI4K) C TpaAI{qrrOHHO r,rcnonByeMbrM xJropoM, MeHee rryBcTBuTeJrbHa Kxore6aHu.f,N,r reMrreparypbr,pH vcoAepxaHr{rr opraHHqecKHX BerrlecrBB4e:raH$rEqrEpyerr,rofi cpeAe.BunolHeHHat pa6ora Ha [paKTuKe rroKa3brBaer rurrpoKze Bo3Mo)r(HocrnI,IcnoJrb3oBanvrfl, coBMeIrIeHHhrx[poqeccoB B xllNau.recrofi TexHoJIortIu14pa:pa6oraHHoro na arofi ocHoBe o6opy4oaanurfl.flparrnvecKafl 3HaqrrMocrb pe3yJrbraroB pa6oruoupeAenflerct[poMbIIxneHHo rIpuMeHteMbIMI,I TeXHI{qeCKr,tMLr perxeHr,rrMr4 MoAynbHofogJleKTponptHoro arperara Ans o6eesapDKl{BaHr,rr BoAhr r,r croKoB, rrpoMbrruJreHHhrMoupo6onaHueM TexHHrIecKI,Ix cpeAcrB Arrs, nonf{eHr4-f, aHoJrura3KclepLIMeHT€LIIbHbIM o6ocnosaHr,reM 3KoJrorurrecrofieSSeruEnHocrr4urro HXBHeApeHrrro{eppara,gKoHoMuqecrofirrpeAnoxeHHbrx rexHurrecKr,rx peureHufi)peKoMeHAar\vrflMvruararur(eB rrpoqeccbr rrpoMhrruneHnofiBOAOTTOA|OTOBKIT Lr BOAOOTBeAeHTTT.HouE:na [peAnox(eHHbrx aBTopoM TexHnqecKrxvrexHoJroruqecKl{xperueHnfi rloArBepxAeHa ceMbro nareHraMr,r P@: J\b 113735Ns 2471891or15.03.2011; Jllb 142205oror 03.05.2011;05.12.2013; Ns160773Ns162651 or 09.11.15; Nb 165201 or 08.09.15; Ns 169435or08.09.15;or 04.07.20t6.[ocronepHocrb pe3yJrbraroB HccJreAonaHnfi ocnoBaHa Ha:- ucllonb3oBaHplllIiBMepe-HutcoBpeMeHHbrX MeTO.qOBLICCJTeAOBAIJLTflVtCpeACTBLI KOHTpOJI{ TeXHOIOTI4q€CKI4 X IIpOqeCCoB ;KoppeKTHoM I{crloJlb3oBankrvruoloxenufi TeopLrugneKTpoxvrMt4ytBpacqeTax ocHoBHhIX [apaMeTpoB TexHoJrorlrqecKr,rx [poqeccoB rrpor,r3BoAcTBaaHoJrura n Seppara :aar1l*rn;-gKcrrepr{MeHT€urbHoM rroATBep)KAeHI.dVT pacqeTHbrx [apaMeTpoBrrpoMbrrxneHHon [puMeHI4MoCTr{TexHoJrofraqecKux peureHrlfi;rrpeAno)KeHHbrxTeXHLIqeCKLIXvlV- Ha rrpoMbrruneHHoMTeXHOJIOTUqeCKLIX perueHIafiBnuomeHHaflolpo6oBaHr,rll pa3pa6oraHHbrx rexHr{rrecKr4xH.pa6ora nporuna aupo6arp.rro Ha pa3nr,rrrHbrx Me)KAyHapoAHbrxrou$epenqrrx.