Отзыв ведущей организации (Разработка метода расчета и исследование рабочих процессов регуляторов давления с учетом аэродинамической составляющей нагрузки на регулирующий элемент)

AI(qI/OHEPHOE O6I]-IECTBO "HAYL4HO-NPOh3BOACTBEHHAfl" I-I E H TUKEAPAN b H O E KO H CT PY KTOPCKO E F IO P O AP MATYPOO14PMACT PO E HIAN"195027 Poccrs, Cauxr-flerep6yprnpocneKT [lJayl,lnua, n.411, nt,tT.ATeneQon (812) 6-11 1-000Qarc (812) 458-7-222als 33, CaHxr-flerep6ypr, 195A27e-mail: info@ckba.ruhttp://www.ckba.ruOrnen Ns 153OrYTBEPXAAIO'/&/Ne-3au. resepaJrrHoro Ar4peKropaHA NS{uper<rop no HafrHofi H sxcueprHofi pa6oreAO <Hayu4o.-_-npor43BoAcrBeHnar Qnpua<I-{enrpanbHoe KoHapMarypocrpoeHr4r)IO.V. TapacrenI orcrr6px 2015 r.ne4yrqefi opraHl43aIIuIl Ar<quonepHoe o6rqecrno '.iiFlbyvno-rpor.r3BoAcrBeHHatSzprraa <I-{enrpanbHoe KoHcrpyKropcKoe 6ropo apMarypocrpoeHr.rq))HaAI4ccepraIII4Io BacunbeBofi Beprr Arercau4poBHbr <Pa:pa6orKa MeToIa paaqera Lrpa6orrkrx npoqeccoB pefynrropoB AaBneHr4q c yrreroMI,ICCJIeAOBAHVTe-aspoAuHaMl4qecKof cocraBJlrloqefi Harpy3Kr,rHa perynr4pyroilIr4figJreMeHT),rlpe,4cTaBneHHyro Ha col4cKaHue yr{eHofi crelreHr,r KaHAr4AaTa rexHl4rrecKr4x HayK rroclerlr4aJrbHocrlr 05.04.06 <Baryyunar, KoMnpeccopHar rexHr,rKaLrnHeBMOCt4 CTeMbr)1.

AKTyAnbHOCTb l.vrc cEp TArlI4oHHof o r4cc rrB iloB AHr,rrrflneslaorr4ftpaBlrvrqecKrre czcreMbr rxlrpoKo npr4MeH-rrrorcrorpacn-f,x IJayKu14B pa3nrrr{HbrxTexHrrKz. IlocrotHHoe ycnoxHeHl4e, KaK caMr4x cr4creM, TaK vrlpol4cxoAf,Irlvx B HI4x TexHoJIorI4qecKI4x npoqeccon, o6yclaBJrlrBaeT, rroBbrrrreHHe[BblnlHEHllblE tlfiUlHtl0l]IF0{TmtilblE ASt0AblAO cHflO(qKEA)14HHp/c Nr 40702610500000003894 B Ollnilane 6aHKa7806026889 Knn 780601001 OTPH 1O2taO41773sOfnE (Ao) B caHrr-nerep6ypre r/c Ne 30101810200000000827 6l4K 044030s27AKU[4OHEpHOE O6llECTBO'HAyLIHO-nPOil3BOACTBEHHAfl O14PMA"uE HTPAIT b H O E KO H CT Py KTO PC KOE 5 tO PO AP MATyPO CTPO E H t/ F "UKWATpe6oBaHuit t< HaAexHocruycrpofrcrB,ve$SerrunHocrr4 pa6oru rrHeBMorr4ApaBnr4qecKr4xB cBt3I4 c qeM craHoBr4TcraKTyanrnofi 3a4arrar4x coBeprxeHcrBoBaHur.B 6omurzncrse cnyqaeB HaAe)KHocrbnHeBMorr4ApaBnr4tlecKrdx ckrcreMonpeAen-f,ercfl HaAelr{Hocrbro nxo4rrqefi B r4x cocran rpy6oupono4noft apMarypbr,r<oropoft orHocrrc.s perynqropbr AaBneHr4fl.

fraeHrr\4vrnpr4qvrHaMlr BbrxoAav3crpotpefynflTopoB AaBneHr,r{ rBr_f,roTcr BbrcoKrre 3HaKorrepeMeHHbre Halpy3KlrHepaBHoMepHoe pacnpeAeJreHze AaBrelllds.ycrpoficrBa-KJrarraHa.no Tapenr4 perynr4pyrouleFoKLr3JreMeHTa3rr,r o6crosreJrbcrBa MoryT rrpr4Becrr4 K noBbrrreHHoMyypoBHro rrryMa uyu6paryr4vrrpv pa6ore ycrpoficrBa) a raKxe K ero rroJroMKe.lucceprarlr4oHHa.rrpa6ora BaczmesofiB. A.nocB{rrleHa pacqerHo-sKorrepr4MeHTaJrbHoMy r4ccneAoBaHr4ro paooqux npoqeccoBB npoTorrHbrx rracTflxperynflTopoB AaBneHufl.

Vqer pa6ouzx npoqeccoB errle Ha craAVLr lpoeKTr,rpoBalc^prflno3Bor-f,er ycoBepueHcrBoBarb npoqeccr{ccJreAoBaHur.pa6o.rux ilpoqeccoBpaspa6orKr{ ycrpoficrn. O4uaro,vxkrx co3AaHr,rfl. llpe4naprlTenbHbref,BJr.rrrorctBA}KHbIM 3TATIOM HACTANVLIpeanv3arJvrfl flBrrflercfl. rpyAoeMKofi sa4avefi ncBfl3v co 3HarrureJrbHbrMvr 3arputaMrr KaK BpeMeHI4, TaK I4 pecypcoB. Paspa6orr<aMareMarrlrrecKrzxuo4erefi H MeroAoB pacrrera pa6otux npoqeccoB ycrpofictn,yrrurbrBaroqr{x HepaBHoMepHocrb pacnpeAeneHrlq Harpy3Kr4 Ha peryJlzpyrcqufigJr eMeHT, flBrrfl.er c s. aKTyaJrbH ofi uuNesepn ofi sa4a'refi,.2, C TEIIEFIb OE O CHOB AHHO C TI,1 HAYqHbIXIIO JIOX EHVIN,BbIB OAOBI{ PEKOMEHAATI4I2, COOPMynI4POBAHI IbIX B AI4CCEPTAUI,II4O6ocHosaHHocrb 14 AocroBepHocrb nonyrreHHbrx AaHHux o6ecneqzBaerc.anpr4MeHeHrreM cep:rra$zqr4poBaHHoro14 noBepeHHoro oKcnepI4MeHTaJIbHoroo6opy4onaHkrs, nepz$zqzpoBaHHoro nr4rleH3r4oHHoro rporpaMMHoro o6ecneqenzso8brAlrHElilrur3[80AblAI(LI14OHEPHOH OFI4HCTBO''HAYI.JHO.NPOil3BOACTBEHHAfl OIIPMA' UE HTPAN b H O E KO H CTPYKTO PC KO E 5 IO PO AP MATYPO ET P OEHIAF"LI,KHAvnoBTopf,eMocrblo pe3ynbraroB sKcnepr{MeHTa.

locroaepHocrbpaspa6orausoft MareMarl4qecrofi MoAenu rroArBepxAeHa corJracoBaHHocrbrope3yJlbraroB pacqerHhlx nccneAoBalc,uitAaHHbIMI4 aBTopa14cco6crseHHbrMr{ oKcnepr.rMeHTaJrbHbrMr4SKcrIepI4MeHTaJrbHbrMlr AaHHbrMr{, ony6lzroBaHHbrMq B HayrrHo-TexHr4rrecrofi lureparype.3. AOCTOBEPHOCTbBbrBHosv sHa [onyqeHHblxB ToM,14HOBI43HA HAYI{FIbIX IIOJIO)KEHI4N.oAoBPEKOMEHAAT@.r4B AI4 cceprarlLroHnofi pa6ore pe3ynbraroB 3aKrroqaerc{qro BnepBble npeAJloxeH MeroA pacqera pa6ovux lpoqeccoBBperynrropaxAaBJreIJufl, ylll4rblBarc:tr1uir.

xapaKrepl43yeMoe xoeS$uqr4eHToM roAbeMHofipacnpeAeJleHl4e4aueHzu B nporoqHofi .racrv,upa3pa6otaua MareMarr4rrecKatMoAenb pa6ouux [poqeccon. llpone4eHbr pacqerHo-reoperutrecKr4e r4ccneAonolyrleHHble pe3ynbrarbl co[ocraBJreHbrLIccneAoBauuit, ouy6luxoBaHHbIMI,IcaMocro.[TeJlbHo nonyqeHHbrMLIBcczlrrBaHv11,pe3yJrbraraMrr sKclepurMeHTaJrbHbrxHayqHo-Texnz.{ecrofi Jrr4TeparypeCpanneHzecOI4CKaTeJIeM.urpe3yJrbraroBTeoperlrqecKr4x r4 gKcrrepr4MeHT€urbHbrx krccJre4onauzfi IIOKa3arrO [paBoMepHocTbllclloJlb3oBarrnfl paspa6otaHHoro MeroAa pacqerauMareMarrz.recrofi MoAenzpaoorrr4x npoqeccoB.[ocronepHocrb [onyrreHHblx cor4cKareJreM pe3yJrbraroB noArBepxAeHaaKTaMr4 HX BHeApeHnfl Ha BeAyrrlr4x rrpeArrpvrflTkrflx oTpacnu.4.

OIEHKA COAEPXATJMAI{OOOP}/.TIETTJ.,A AI4CCEPTAIJI4VIflucceprauzoHHa{ pa6ora Baczmenofi B.A. cocror4TrJraB, 3aKJIIorIeHIz.a, cIII4cKa nzreparypbr r{r,r3 BBeAeHufl, Lrerbrpexnpr4no)KeHr,rr. O6rervr AncceprarJLrLlntr30BbttrfiHililtut ;itfflnH0crpo{lgtbftbtt 3[stl{blAKU14OHEPHOH O6II"IFCTBO''HAYLIHO.NPOT3BORCTBFHHAfiOYlPMALI E HTPAII b H O E KO H CT PY KTO P C KO E 5HC P O AP M ATY P O CT P O EH IA fl',UKffiAcocraBnter 124 crpaHzllbl MaIIrI4HoIIr4cHoro reKcra,BKJrroqa.rr4ra6twJstuznnrocrpaquft.

CnucoK nklTeparypbl BKJlroqaer 97 :rrauvreHoeaHzft oreqecrBeHHbrxsapy6exurrx LIcrorIHtIKoB. llpe4craureHbr aKTbr oAr435r,rBHeApeHr{r4 pe3ynbraroBccepraqzoHuofi pa6orrr.flo reueAzccepraqzz ony6Jrr,rKoBaHopeKoMeHAoBaHHbrxBo7pa6or, I43Hr4x3-s)KypHanax,BAK PO.ene4eHraz o6ocHoBaHa aKTyaJrbHocrb reMbr Ar,rccepTarJLrv\ ee HayqHatHOBr43Ha U npaKTr4lrecKaf, 3HaqI4MOCTb.B nepnofirJraBe npr,rBeAeHrro6qze cBeleHr4r o pefynrTopax AaBneHr4flprcyqecrBytoql4x MeroAax oIIeHKr4 r,rx pa6our4x xapaKTepr4crr,rK. B nureparypHoMoo3ope [peAcraBJIeHbI ocHoBHbIe MeroAbr r4ccJreAoBaHvrfl pa6ovzx [pordeccoB BnporoqHorr qacrr4 peryntropoB AaBJreHVfl. n pe3ynbrarbr r4ccneAoBasuit.

AHarrasI4CIIOJIb3OBaHHbIX LICTOTIHI4KOB IIO3BOJII4JI CAenaTbcylllecrBylolrlkIe MeroAbI Moryr6rrrrMareMarr4rlecKoro o6ecneqe Hr4fl14Bo nropofiBbIBoAbI O TOM,qTOycoBeprxeHcrBoBaHbr Ha 6ase conpeMeHHoroBbltrlrclr4TeJrbHbrx cpeAcrB.rJraBe npzBeAeHbr o6rqze cBeAeHr4so6 eranaxpaspa6orr<zMareMarl{'Iecrcofi MOAeJII{ c yrleroM aopoAr4Hauuqecr<ofi cocraBrqroulefi Harpy3KH Haperynl4pytoqzfi sJIeMeHr. Paspa6oraH anroprlTM pacqera, o[peleneHbr pacr{erHato6lacrsI4 ocHoBHbIeAonyqe:a:zfl, cocraBJreHa clrcreMa ypaBHeHzfi n o6rqeM Br{Ae,nrt6paHu MeroAbI perreHI4t, onpeAeJreHbr HaqarbHbre v rpaHr4r{HbreycJroBr4-rr,ycnoBr4f, oKoHqaHr4.s cqeTa.B rpemefi rJIaBe rIpI4BeAeHbI pe3ynbrarbrrr4 cJreHHo-Teoperr.rqecKr4xuccneAoBatruit.

C uovroqblo rIpeAJIo)KeHHoro MeroAa pacr{eraMoAeJrI{ nonyqeHa KaprI4Ha paclpeAerreHns.peryJltropa AaBJIeHnfl,r4MareMaua.recxofi4aueuufr B nporouuofiqacrr4VCCtTeAOBaHbI CTeneHb BJrkrflHLrfl crrJrbl TpeHI4r, AVaMerpoB4elurelblrofi AIo3bI, o6reua o6rerra perynr{poBaHtrfl kr r43MeHeHr4-s pacxoAauorpe6urena Ha xapaKrep 14 rrapaMerpbr pa6ovzx npoqeccoB.]Itr30BbtIlHEilltut MAlIfl B0cTt|lfiTEnbfl btr 3ff0AblAKU14OHEPHOE OEU{FCTBO "HAyLIHO-nPOil3BOACTBEHHAfl Ol/IPMA"uEHTPAn bH o E KO HCTPyKTOPC KO E 5Hl PO APMATvPOCTPO E Hl fr"LIKffiAPesynrrarbr colocraBJleHbr c gKcnepLrMeHTaJIbHbIMI4 AaHHrIMI4, npI{BeAeHHbIMI4HayqHo-TexHurr{ecKofi nvrreparype.PesylrrarblBcpaBHeHlafl IroK€I3€uIpI KaqecrBeHHoecoBrlaAeHr4e npoqeccoB, nonyqeHHblx pacqeTHo-TeopeTI{qecKI'IM14SKCnepI4MeHTanbHbIM nyTeM.npeAcraBJreHo orruIcaHlle gKcnepvMeHTaJlbHoro creHAaB .rerneprofi rrtaeeMeTOAI4KT4 npoBeAeHr4q 3KCrrepI4MeHTa,pacqerHo-Teoperr4qecKktxvra14TarcKe conocTaBJIeHIIe pe3yJIbTaToBSKcrrepr,rMeHTaJIbHbIX lrccJleAoBatrvtit, npoBeAeHHbIXaBTOpOM.Cpannenze pacqerHo-Teoperl,IqecKI'IXLr3KCnepLIMeHTaJIbHbIX AaHHbIXrro 3HarIeHI4IO [apaMeTpa, xapaKTepl43yroilIefono ero AnHTeJIbHocrI{.

PacxoxAeHI,Ie AnI,ITeJIbHocrI4ocyqecrBJrsJrocb aBTopoMuepexo4urrfi rrpoqecclepexoAHbrx rpoqeccoB cocraBr.f,er He 6onee 3I,7oA npl4 AoBepl{TemHoftBeporrHocrz P:0,95. llpzne4eHbr npeAnoJlaraeMble croco6u ynyuruennfl. TotIHocrI4pacrreToB.BunrenpuBeAeHHbre$anroprr nocnyxunllocHoBaHI4eM peKoMeHAoBarbpa^:pa6otaHHbre MeroA pacrrera r4 MareMarurrecKylo MoAeJIb Arr-f, BHeApeHVfl' na 3AOHnO (APKOH> u PKK <SHeprrax)) AJrfl aHanrvr3a pa6ourax rpoqeccoBIIacTI4 pefynf,TopoB AaBJIEHHf, V IIOBbIIIIEHI4qBnporoqnofiEQQCTTT NHOCTI4 IPOEKTHO-KoHcrpyKropcKr4x pa6or, raKxe pe3ynbrarrt pa6orrt BHeApeHbl n yve6nrtfi npoqeccsM|TV ravr. H.3.floAIa cceBaytv'aua, r{ro noATBepx{AeHo aKTaMI4 o BHeApeHI4lI'pr ar\r4v uMelorcqcneAyIoqH e 3 aMeq aHll-f, :- aBTopoM nopofi trclonb3yrorcq ycrapeBlxl4e repMI4HbI, tIpI4MeHqeMbIe paHeeBOTpaCnr4 apMaTypocTpoeHr4q,rrpl'I MeHeHI'Iq repMI4HOBB pf,AecnyqaeB oTcyTcTByeT oAHO3HaqHOCrb;tlttrAHilft{lrHr ll|num0clpotllt lbHblt 3rBo{blAKUT4OHEPHOE ObIqECTBO''HAYqHO-NPO[/3BO!CTBEHHAflOLIPMA.U E HTPAII b H O E KO H CTPY KTO PC KO E 5IO PO AP MATY POCTPO E HVl A'UK6A-I4Meer Mecro He6onb[roe KoJII4rrecrBo crLrJTucrLrrlecKzx HeroqHocrefr,OIIEIIATOK;- B pa3Aerc 4.3 orcyrcrBylor3HaqeHI4t norperuHocrefi 3Kcrrepr4MeHTa, rrroMofno 6u yrpacl'ITb SKclepHMeHT€rJrbHyro qacrb BbrnoJrHeHHofi pa6orrr.5.3AK JIIO rIE III4F, OCTBTMtIyHK TydIOJIOXEIfVIAOIIOP'AKETIPI,ICV)KNELfuI'-YIIEHbIXCOOTB ETAVIC CEPT AIn/tuI9CTEIIEHEIZ)[uccepraqux Bepbr Arexcau4poBHbr Bacumenofi <paspa6orrcaMeroAapacrlera vr uacile4oBaHl4e pa6ovux npoqeccoB perynrropoBAaBJreHr,rf, c yrreroMaopoAr4Hauzqecrofi cocraBn_rrroruefi Harpy3Kr{ Ha peryJrr4pyroqufi oJreMeHT))flBIrflercfl HayqHo-KnalzQuraqzouuofi pa6orofi rd 3acny)Kr4Baer noJro)KLrrelrHoftOUEHKI,I.Anrope$epar I4 ony6nzroBaHHble pa6omr AocraroqHo rroJrHo orpa)KarorcoAepxaHr4eAr4ccepT ar]'uv.,,{Hccepralll4 oHHat pa6ora B eprr Anercan4poBHbr B acumesofi coorsercrByercnerlr{ulnbHocrLr 05.04.06rIHeBMocI4creMbI)Al4cceprallutM,lpucyx{AeHnfl, eftau<Baryynanar, KoMnpeccopHarrpe6onaHLrflMBAK P@, npe4brBJrreMbrM KTexHuKaKaHAr4AarcKr4Mcol4cKarenb Bacunrena Bepa Alercan4poBHa 3acJrylrr4BaerUCTOVTOfi CreneHr4]Ka]P.AuA TarexHuqecKr,rx HavK.AKUT4OHEPHOE O6l{ECTBO "HAvtIHO-nPOl/3BOICTBEHHAfl O14PMA"H E HTPAfl b H O E KO H CT PY KTO PC KOE 5 IO PO AP M ATYPOCTPO E H 14 fl "L|,K6AOrgrre paccMorpeH 14 o6cyx4eu HaHayqHo-TexHLIqecKoM coBereArqzouepHoro o6uecrsa <Hay.rHo-npol43BoAcrBeHHa{ Qr.rpua <I{enrpanbHoeKoHcrpyKropcKoe 6ropo apMarypocrpoeHlrq> 14 orcrq6px 2015 roAa, uporonon312015.KaHAr,rAar rexHr,rqecKr'rx HayK,ne4yrqzft clequanucr orAeJIa3 KC n epTI43 bI, AI'Iaf H O CTVTKVI,r,r c rr brraH kr fi., rugp ar'Jr 14 q e c KLt xr4ccneAoB alnuit r4 pacqeroB apMarypblArqraonepHoro o6qecrea<Hayvno-[por{3BoAcrBeHHatQuprr,raKoHcrpyKTopcKoe ,46ropo apMarypocrpoeHr4r)) 6Aaeru9<I-{enrpa-nbHoeErena fpuropresHa lllrHaesaHa.ramHuK HayqHo-rrccJleAoBareJrbcKorooTAeJra gKCnepTI43bI, ALIa|HOCTI4KI4,r4crrbrr arrnit, ruyp awl I'I q e c KLIXauuit u pacqeroB apMarypblAxuuoHepHoro o6tllecrea<Hayuuo-rpol{3BoAcrBeHHaf, SIapua<I-{enrpanbHoe KoHcrpyKropcKoe6ropo apMarypocrpoeHl{.a))14ccJreAoBflo4nucz llun aesofi Ele Hrr fpzropreMapzna Vlt:r.,urru'tHa Culur'ulaaBHbr r4Cunur,unofi Map ran s l4nsum'I rrHbl3aBeprrc:Ha.ralrHzK orAeJIa KaApoRArquouepnoro o6rq<Hayvno-ttpor,r3BoA<I{eHrpanbHoe r(oHcrporcpo apMarypocrpoeHIO.A.

[lepervrenrbeBaJ\b.