Отзыв официального оппонента (Воздействие высокотемпературной импульсной плазмы на физико-механические свойства композиционных структур)

OT3hiBO<}_lHJ~Ha.TihHOrO OIIIIOHeHTa Ha .IJ:HCCepTaU:HIOEpHCKHHa AneKcaH.n:pa AneKcaH.n:poBHqa«Bo3.n:eilcTBHe BhiCOKOTeMnepaTypHoil HMIIYJihCHOH IIJia3Mhi HacpH3HKO-MexaHHqecKHe CBOHCTBa KOMII03HU:HOHHhiX CTPYKTyp»,npe.IJ:CTaBJieHHYIO Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTeiieHH KaH.IJ:H.IJ:aTa TeXHHqeCKHX HayKIIO CIIeU:Ha.TihHOCTH01.04.07- «<l>H3HKa KOH.IJ:eHCHpOBaHHOrO COCT051HH51»AKTyaJihHOCTh H36pauuoii TeMhl.HaCT051~eeBBpeM51BeCbMaBa:>KHOHnpo6neMoilB<}lH3HKeKOH.IJ:eHCHpOBaHHOrO COCT051HH51 51BJI51eTC51 pa.n:HaU:HOHHa51 CTOHKOCTh MaTepHa.TIOBnepBOH CTeHKH Hy.n:ep)KaHHeMIIJia3Mhi.)KeCTKHX ycJIOBH51XH30TOIIOB(T51P).IJ:HBepTOpa TepM051.IJ:epHoro peaKTOpaMaTepHa.TihiB03.IJ:eHCTBH51BO.IJ:Opo.n:aHreJIH51,3THXKOHCTPYKU:HHIIOTOKOBC MarHHTHhiM.IJ:OJI)I(Hhipa6oTaThBHOHH3HpyiO~HX H3JiyqeHHH (HOHhlBhiCOK03HepreTHqecKHeHeHTpOHbi),aTaK)KeTepMOU:HKJIHqeCKHX Harpy30K, o6ycJIOBJieHHhiX U:HKJIHqHOCThiO pe)KHMa ropeHH51IIJia3Mhi.200,5HaH60Jihnme TeiiJIOBhieHarpy3KHBnpou:ecceropeHH51nna3Mhi .n:oMBTIM 2 O)KH.IJ:aiOTC51 Ha npHeMHhie nnacTHHhi .IJ:HBepTopa, Ha nepByiO cTeHKYMBTIM 2.ITpH3TOM <}lniOeHc HeilTpOHHoro noToKa MO)KeT .n:ocTHraTh BeCbMa6oJihiiiHX 3HaqeHHH (.n:o1028H/M 2).

MaTepHa.Tihi,o6pa~eHHhieK IIJia3Me BT51P,6y.IJ:yT IIO.IJ:BepraTbC51 HHTeHCHBHOMy B03.IJ:eHCTBHIO HOHOB H30TOIIOB BO.IJ:Opo.n:a HreJIH51, a TaK)Ke pacnhiJieHHhiX aTOMOB MaTepHa.TIOB KOMIIOHeHTOB KOHCTPYKU:HH,KOHTaKTHpyiO~HX C IIJia3MOH,IIIHpOKOMHHTepBa.Tie3HeprHH.C HenpepbiBHhiM 3HepreTHqecKHMKpHTHqeCKHMBOIIpOCOM.IJ:JI51CIIeKTpOM Bocy~eCTBJieHH51ynpaBJI51eMOH TepM051.IJ:epHOH peaKU:HH 51BJI51eTC51 qHCTOTa IIJia3Mhl OT IIpHMeCeH,H3nyqeHHe Ha KOTOphiX cnoco6Ho oxna.n:HTh ee HH)Ke nopora ropeHH51.

Cne.n:yeTOC060OTMeTHTh,qTo.IJ:JI51peaKTOpOBCMarHHTHhiMy.n:ep)KaHHeMIIJia3Mhl,pa6oTaiO~HX B U:HKJIHqecKOM pe)KHMe, xapaKTepHbiM BH.IJ:OM B03.IJ:eHCTBH51 HaMaTepHa.Tihl nepBOH CTeHKH H .IJ:HBepTopa 51BJI5110TC51 CpbiBhl IIJia3Mhi, .IJ:OCTHraiO~Heno ou:eHKaM y.n:enhHOHMO~HOCTH.n:o10MBTicM2, qTo MO)KeT Bhi3BaTh CHJihHhieJIOKa.TihHhie OIIJiaBJieHH51 IIOBepXHOCTH, pacTpeCKHBaHHe, KHIIeHHe H HCIIapeHHeMaTepHa.Tia. TaKHe BH.IJ:bl IIOBpe)K.IJ:eHHH, B KOHeqHOM HTOre, MoryT IIpHBeCTH Kyxy.n:IIIeHHIO 3KcnnyaTaU:HOHHhiX CBOHCTB H .n:a)Ke BhiBO.IJ:Y Y3JIOB peaKTopa H3CTpO.H.BCB.H311 C Bbiiiiei13JIO)I(eHHbiM pe3KO B03pacTaeT 11HTepec K 11MI1TaiJ,110HHbiM11CCJie,n:oBaHI1.HMMaTep11aJiblB03,n:eiicTBI1.HT5IP,o6paiiJ,eHHbieKTepMO.H,n:epHOHl1Jla3MblHaKaH,n:l1,n:aTHbieB OC06eHHOCTI1 3TO OTHOCI1TC.H K 11M11TaiJ,I111 CpbiBa l1Jla3Mbl HaHell:3JieMeHTbiKOHCTPYKIJ,I111.B,n:aHHOMacrreKTeBeCbMarrepcrreKTI1BHbiM rrpe,n:CTaBJI.HeTC.H 11Cl10Jib30BaHI1e .II:JI.H 11MI1TaiJ,I10HHbiX 11CllbiTaHI1HycTaHOBOKTl1lla«f1Jia3MeHHbiHBbiCOKOTeMrrepaTypHOHITJIOTHOH<)JoKyc»;l1Jla3MblBrrapaMeTpbirrpou,eccereHep11pyeMOHpa60TblTaKoroTl1llaycTaHOBOK 6JII13KI1 K 0)1(11.II:aeMbiM rrapaMeTpaM CpbiBa ITJia3Mbl Ha rrepByiO CTeHKY11 .II:11BepTopTJIP.JilcrroJib30BaHI1e ycTaHoBoK Tl1rra «llia3MeHHbiH <)JoKyc» B CB.H311C He06biLIHOCTbiO YCJIOBI1H B03,n:eHCTBI1.H (11HTeHCI1BHOe aTOMHOe rrepeMeiiii1BaHI1eo6JiyLiaeMbiX KOMI103111J,I1H B COBOKYITHOCTI1 C MOI.IJ,HOH y,n:apHOH BOJIHOH) MO)I(eTOKa3aTbC.H TaK)I(e rrepcrreKTI1BHbiM .II:JI.H llOJiyLieHI1.H BbiCOKOa,n:re3110HHbiX I1pOLIHbiXl10Kpb1TI1H, a TaK)I(e, LITO y)l( COBCeM He06biLIHO, .II:JI.H C03,n:aHI1.H HOBbiX CITJiaBOB,COCTO.HI.IJ,I1X113KOMITOHeHTB3ai1MHOHepaCTBOpllMbiXB06biLIHbiXYCJIOBM.HX.HacTO.HI.IJ,a.H pa6oTa rrocB.HI.IJ,eHa 11CCJie,n:oBaHI1IO BbiiiierrepeLII1CJieHHbiX Ba)I(HbiX, arropoii 11 COBCeM He 11CCJie,n:OBaHHbiX, rrpou,eCCOB, l103TOMY ee 3KTY3JibHOCTbHBJIHeTCH HeCOMHeHHOH.HayqnaH HOBH3Ha.Bpa6oTerrp11HIJ,I1ITI1aJibHOrroJiyLieH p.H,n: HOBbiX,Ba)I(HbiX,HayLIHbiXaBHeKoTopbiX cJiyLia.Hx ITI10HepcKI1Xpe3yJibTaToB.AHaJII1311PY.H11xHayLIHYIOHOBI13HY He06XO.II:11MO rrpe)l(,n:e BCero OTMeTI1Tb Hai160Jiee 3HaLII1Mbie .II:OCTI1)1(eHI1.H:1.aTOMOBf1p11HIJ,I11111aJibHOITJieHKI1llOJiyLieHbi11HOBbiMITO.II:JIO)I(KI1,BbiCOKOa,n:re3110HHbieMeTO.II:OMYCI1JieHHOe(11HTeHCI1BHOerrpOXO.II:.HI.IJ,eHBbiCOKOllpOLIHbierrepeMeiiii1BaHI1ey,n:apHOHITJieHOLIHbieBOJIHOH)l10Kpb1T11.HHa,n:I13JieKTp11LieCKI1X rro,n:JIO)I(Kax, 11CCJie,n:oBaHbi 11x CTPYKTypa, 3JieMeHTHbiH cocTaB11<jJI1311KO-MexaHI1LiecKI1ecBoiicTBa( orrTI1LieCKI1e,3JieKTp11LieCKI1e,M11KpOTBep,n:OCTb, a,n:re311.H ).2.3KCI1ep11MeHTaJibHO,C11Cl10Jib30BaHI1eMMeTO,n:ape3ep<)Jop,n:OBCKOrOo6paTHOrO pacce.HHI1.H, rrpo,n:eMOHCTp11pOBaHO, LITO B 3aBI1CI1MOCTI1 OT rrapaMeTpOBl1Jia3MeHHOrO o6JiyLieHI1.H 11 Bl1,n:a BHe,n:p.HeMbiX 11p11 l1Jia3MeHHOH 11MITJiaHTaiJ,1111aTOMOBMO)I(HOrroJiyLiaTbKOMIT0311IJ,I10HHbieCTPYKTYPbicoCJIOeBbiMpacrrpe,n:eJieHI1eM no rJiy611He Jier11pyiOI.IJ,I1X 3JieMeHTOB.3.I1po,n:eMoHcrp11poBaHo,l1Jia3MeHHOr Oo6JiyLieHI1.H11LITOMeH.H.H pe)I(I1Mbi BbiCOK03HepreTI1LiecKorol10Crpa,n:l1aiJ,I10HHOrO2OT)I(11ra,MO)I(HOllOJiyLiaTbCTPYKTYPbirrneHKa-rro.n;nmKKa(HarrpHMepeKOMII03MIJ;MMTMTaH-cTeKJIO)cpa3JIMqHbiM TMIIOM 3JieKTpOIIpOBO)J;HOCTM (.ZJ;H3JieKTpWieCKMH, MeTaJIJIMqecKHH) .4.BrrepBbieB03)J;eHCTBM51Bcrreu;m]:mqecKMX.n;eiiTepHeBOHcBepxrny6oKoropacqeTHbiM,(HaIIJia3Mblrrop51.ZJ;OKo6Hapy)J(eH3cpcpeKT)J;aJibHO)J;eHCTBM51rrocpaBHeHMIO.n;eHTepH51MIIpHMeCHOrOTa,W);Zr, Nb,KOHCTPYKIJ;MOHHbie MaTepHaJibi (Ti,MeXaHM3MBbiCOK03HepreTwiecKoroBemrqMHbi),IIpOHMKHOBeHM51cpH3MqecKMHycnoBM51XHa6JIIO.ZJ;aeMOrO 51BJieHM51,cTeopeTMqecKMBO.ZJ;Opo.n;aBrrpe.n;Jio)J(eH a.n;eKBaTHbiHCB513aHHbiHC B03)J;eHCTBMeMMOIJJ;HbiX y.n;apHbiX BOJIH M pa.n;MaiJ;MOHHO-YCMJieHHOH .ZJ;H<pcpy3MeH ra30BbiX aTOMOBB o6nyqaeMOH MMIIIeHM.5.

CMCIIOJib30BaHMeM BbiCOK03HepreTMqecKOrO MMIIYJibCHOrO IIJia3MeHHOrOB03)J;eHCTBM51o6biqHbiXIIOJiyqeHblycnoBM51X)J;OCTOBepHbiHCIIJiaBblM3KOMIIOHeHTOBcpH3MqecKMHTepMO)J;MHaMMqecKM(Nb-Cu,MeXaHII3M,W-Cu,HeCMeiiiMBaeMbiXW-Ag);o6o51CWIIOIJJ;MHBrrpe.n;no)J(eH.n;aHHbiHpe3yJibTaTrrpou;eccaMM 6aJIJIMCTMqecKOrO, He.ZJ;Hcpcpy3MOHHOrO aTOMHOrO rrepeMeiiiMBaHM51.,li;OCTOBepHOCThnorMqHoIIOJiyqeHHbiX B )J;MCCepTaiJ;MM .ZJ;aHHbiX, IIO)J;TBep)l(JJ;eHHa51BbiCTpoeHHOHpa3H006pa3HbiXCTPYKTypoH:COBpeMeHHbiXM3MepHTeJibHbiXIIpH6opoBMeTO.ZJ;OB)J;JI51co6oi! 3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHbiXMccne.n;oBaHMH,aHaJIM3a,IIOJiyqeHM51XOpOIIIOMCIIOJib30BaHMeMBbiCOKoqyBCTBMTeJibHbiXCOrJiaCYIQIII;MXC51pe3yJibTaTOB M rrpaKTMqecKOHMe)l(JJ;ypeaJIM3aiJ;IIeH, HeBbl3biBaeT COMHeHMH.CTeneubo6ocuoBauuocTupeKoMeu~au,uii,HayqHbieCcpOpMyJIHpOBaHHbieIIO)J;XO)J;OMBrrono)J(eHM51,)J;MCCepTaiJ;MM,BbiBO.ZJ;bi)J;OCTaTOqHO3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHbiMM )J;aHHbiMM,Krrpe.ZJ;CTaBJieHM51MBhiBO~OBuc<J>OpMyJiupoBaHuhiX B ~uccepTau,uu.OcHOBHbieIIOJiyqeHHbiMMnoJio~euuii,uayqnhiXM3JIO)J(eHMIOcpH3MKMMaTepHanoBe.n;eHM51.MaTepHana,peKoMeH.n;au;MM,IIOJIHOTaK)l(eo60CHOBaHblIIOCJie)J;OBaTeJibHbiMCOOTBeTCTBYIOTKOH.ZJ;eHCHpOBaHHOrOPe3yJibTaTbi,aMCOCT051HM51rronyqeHHbieMaBTopoM,COBpeMeHHbiMpa.n;MaiJ;MOHHOrOBocrrpoH3BO.ZJ;MMbi,rronyqeHbi c MCIIOJib30BaHMeM BbiCOKoqyBcTBMTeJibHbiX MeTO.ZJ;OB Mccne.n;oBaHM51.

BCB513M C BbiCOKOH CTeiieHbiO )J;OCTOBepHOCTII IIOJiyqeHHbiX B pa6oTe pe3yJibTaTOB,060CHOBaHHOCTbHayqHbiXIIOJIO)J(eHMH,BbiBO)J;OBMpeKOMeH.ZJ;aiJ;MH,ccpopMynHpoBaHHbiX B .n;MccepTaiJ;MM, Ha Moil B3rJI51.ZJ;, He Bbi3biBaeT COMHeHMH. BIJ;eJIOM,)J;MCCepTaiJ;MOHHa513aKJIIOqeHM51,BbiBO)J;bipa6oTaOTJIMqaeTC51M peKOMeH)J;aiJ;MM,3BHyTpeHHMMC)J;eJiaHHbieHae)J;MHCTBOM;OCHOBe pe3yJibTaTOBI1pOBe,n:eHHhiXMCCJie.LJ:OBaHMH,Hayt:IHOo60CHOBaHhlM51BJI51IOTC51CJie.LJ:CTBMeMITOJiyqeHHhiX HOBbiX 3KCrrepHMeHTaJibHhiX ,n:aHHhiX.llpaKTH"IJeCKaH 3H3"1JHMOCTh pa60Tbl.I1paKTMqecKa51 3HaqMMOCTh pe3yJII>TaTOB MHororpaHHa.

B3aKJIIOqaeTC51BrronyqeHMMHOBhiXCITJiaBOBqacTHOCTM, oHa(HH06MH-Me,n:h,BOJib<}:>paM-Me.LJ:h,BOJib<}:>paM-Cepe6po ), KOTOpbie HeB03MO)KH0 ITOJiyqMTh 06hiqHhiMM TepMHqecKMMMMeTO.LJ:aMM B CB513M C OTCYTCTBMeM B3aMMHOH paCTBOpHMOCTM KOMITOHeHT OB BHOpMaJihHhiXycJIOBM51X.,[(aHHhiHpe3yJihTaTMO)KeT51BMThC51OCHOBOH.LJ:JI51pa3BMTM51 HayqHO-TeXHMqecKOfO HarrpaBJieHM51 I10JiyqeHM51 He M3BeCTHhlX paHeecrrnaBoB c B03MO)I(HhiMM yHMKaJihHhiMM CBOHCTBaMM ( coqeTaiOI.IJ;MX, HarrpHMep,TyrorrnaBKOCThBOJih<}:>paMarrpaKTMqecKMMacrreKTOMMBhiCOKYIOpa60ThlTerrnorrpoBO.LJ:HOCTh51BJI51eTC51Me,n:H).,n:eMOHCTpall,M51Ba)I(HhiMI10JiyqeHM51CMCI10Jih30BaHMeM BhiCOK03HepreTMqecKOH ITJIOTHOH I1Jia3Mhl BhiCOKOa,n:re3MOHHhiXrrpoqHhiXIToMMMOMeTaJIJIMqecKMXBhiCOKMXITOKpbiTMHMexaHMqecKMXCBOHCTB,pacrrpe,n:eJieHM51O.LJ:HOpO.LJ:HOCTbiO3JieMeHToB;KpoMe3JieMeHTOBMToro,,n:aHHhieBBO.LJ:MMhiXB03MO)I(HOrrepeMeHHoroHa )J.H3JieKTpHqecKMXxapaKTeparroKphiTM51I1Jia3MeHHOHrronyqeHMeITO.LJ:JIO)I(KaX.OTJIMqaiOTC51MMITJiaHTaiJ,MeHcnoeBoropacrrpe,n:en eHM513JieKTporrpoBO.LJ:HOCTM.HaKoHeiJ,,06Hapy)KeHHhiH B pa6oTe 3<}:><}:>eKT CBepxrny6oKOfO I1pOHMKHOBeHM51 M30T OI10BBO.LJ:Opo,n:a Bo6JiyqeHHbieBhiCOKOTeMrrepaTypHOHI1Jla3MOHKOHCTpyKIJ,MOHHbieMaTepHaJihl, paCCMaTpHBaeMhie B KaqecTBe rrepcrreKTMBHhiX .LJ:JI51 MCI10Jih30BaHM51 BT5IP (BOJib<}:>paM, ll,HpKOHMH, HM06MH, HMKeJib M ,n:p.), Heo6XO.LJ:MMO yqMThiBaTh rrpHrrporH03HpOBaHMM HX pa60TOCI10C06HOCTM B HaTypHbiX YCJIOBM51X,ITOCKOJihKYpacnmpeHMe o6JiaCTM, OKKYI1HpOBaHHOH fa30BhiMM aTOMaMM, MO)KeT ITOBJieqb 3aco6oi1p51.LJ:He)KeJiaTeJihHhiXo6oeMHhiX3<}:><}:>eKTOB(ycMneHMera3oBoropacrryxaHM51, rrpOBOll,HpOBaHMe BO.LJ:OpO.LJ:HOH M pa,n:MaiJ,MOHHO-CTMMYJIHpOBaHHOHxpyrrKOCTMMBhiiTOJIHeHMMrro.n:roTOBKy.TexHMqecKMX,n:p.

).XoTenocbpa6oThiHM6om6hiTaK)I(eOTMeTMTh,rrpo,n:eMOHCTpHpoBanrrpe,n:JIO)I(eHMHe3ayp51.LJ:HYIOpeanM30BaHycoBepllleHCTBOBaHMHqToCJIO)I(HOHp51.LJ:,n:MccepTaHTrrpHKOHCTPYKTopcKyiOrrpHcrroco6neHMHKOHCTPYKIJ,MMMy cTaHOBKM«I1na3MeHHhiH <}:>oKyc» IT<I>-4 KOMrrJieKca «TIOnhrraH>>, qTo rro3BOJIMJIO rrpoBeCTMyHMKaJihHhie3KcrrepHMeHThi,BhiCOKOI1pOqHhiXITOKpbiTMH,BqacTHOCTMaTaK)I(enorronyqeHMIOCITJiaBOBM3o,n:Hopo,n:HhiXHeCMelllMBaiOI.U;MXC51XMMMqecKMX 3 JieMeHTOB, B CB513M C qeM 6biJIM ITOJiyqeHbl rraTeHT Ha I10Jie3HYIOMO.LJ:eJib M crrpaBKa 0rrpaKTMqecKOM BHe,n:peHMM4OT <l>M3MqecKOfO MHCTMTyTa11M.IT.