Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Структура и свойства катионных полиэлектролитов и комплексов на их основе)

OT3bIBoiblllll4arbEoro offIoEelrra Ea AlrccepralllloHEyo pa6orylleperrsxo I4roPr IoPreeuva"CTp),(Typa Ii cBoficrBa l(arllol lr,rx noJtll3ireKTponl'IToB It (oMlrJretcoe ua nx ocuooe",rrpeacTaBlrerGoi Ha col'cl{aHue yqeEoi cre[eHx (aE,qlraaTa !bI]3llKo-MaTeMaTliqec(llx say( IIocneqna,'rrnocrn 02.00.06 nucorouolerylEpHr,Ie coeAulreHEPa6ora flepeBB(o I4ropa lOpreruva flocBttqeEa xq {elit,loIli.{poarHaMurrec(lrx I-l (oEabopMaqnoHllbrx xapaKrepltcTll( .l rHeiHErxri fpaoT nojruMepsbxoqrornoi wtrI 6o(oB6rx uencx'Ma(poMoJre(yn, Eecyurlx 3apqxeHEble (aTlIoIlHr'Ie lppanraeurr,I aOTAeJlbHoe BHItMeuIie yAeneqoMoJIeKyntpEbIx,IBf{eEuIo ltllTepflonl'IS.reKTpoJlllrtl6D(I(oMrIJreKcoB Ha ocEoBe(arroHEBrx noIMMepoB It aEuolrHo 3aptxelrHbrx 6l-rojroruqec('ix Ma(poMone(yr AHK.AKTyanLEocrb nccJle,4oBaHl-it norllgrelclpojlllroB, a ral(xe ibyHklltioEajrbH6x rIoJlI-IMepEbrxclcTeM Ea ux ocHoBe Ee BEI36IBalsr coMdeElrfi.

IlonltgneloponqT6l rIpeacTaBJItIoT coooil o6mrpH6driracc Mzr(poMone(yj1, ItMeIoI[tx orpoMllblft npal(Tl'qec(Ili(EoTeEqtajriBcJre,ucTBIiIe sTofoo6racrtM opfalHlrqecKofr LlMaKpoMone(yJltpHofi xuMIrIl, xriMllll raTepuulJloB, arunliTnqecxot xl4Mr'll]r a Ta(xe 0u3n(eBHIlMal]Ile rlajrBorocoo6rqec'rBaIrtxoallrctBbrco(oMonekympEbrx co€anserMia ralo(e(arrroErrbre MeraKp[rarbr,cooTBeTcTByIotquMHa BblcoKoM )?oBse. flpeacTtlBreHHble B paboTeJrIrHeiHEIe IIoJIII3TEreBI'iMI'IHU(fl3l4),xapal(TepH6lMlt IIpeACTaBUTeiItMI'I [O.]IIrSJIe(TpOJlttTOB, ItCnOJIb3yeMLIX B(h)'Hl(llllor.rarr,Horo cy6crparaMarep!.rana u/uJru ire(apcrB Bf naBaxnprco3aEtEnl-'AelrtOrCr(arIeCTBectjcreM FanpaBneHHot AocraBn reHersqec(oro(rerKy, nro xopouo oro6paxelroBo BBeaeEuIlu coorBercrByror{nxaltcceprall{ll.ycrrn[raBTopa6unu c$oxycr-rporau6l rra aera,'IblroM Ilq.reulrlt rtlapoal'IuttMliqec(oroloBeaeEt-t9 (aTrroglrbrx [oDiSneI(TpoJrItToBo[pe,4eJrrrouux xapa(TeprrcTn(rIIOCTaBJIeHHbIX 3aAaqulrpo(ofoI'LcBoEcTBaOqeH(e ocHoBIibD( Mojre(yttpllErx [apaMeTpoB,to[[Mepllbrx Mone(yl]B pacTBopax.Ant peln€sEtiC! B fiCnorh3oBaErll',IMeToaoB 3l{cK]Ilo3l,logltzulnp[MeIrtJICt KoMnJIeKCIrBri IOAXOA, 3aKrIOqaIOUIcrreKTpa gTaHAapTrrbD< xljMlt(o-agatqTl,IqecK[xxpoMarorpaibss, Macc-c[eKTpoMerpu,titAepI{o-MarHurHBIi pe3oHztHc.

a rzll(xe (Jlaccuqec(Ilx Ita,'IIrTepHaT[BHbX DtApO,{XHaMtIr{€Ck[X MeTOAOBaIIaUl[3aBIICKO3UMEIp'Iq, aHaJItTItqeC(OeyrBTparleHTplo].flrpoBarste, [3oTepMr.rqecrat at-rQQy3nt Ir acc[MeTpn.rEoe SpaK[ioErrpoBar eIIOTOKE.IIPfiE3YITCEVI NOIISNEIOPOJII'TIIbD< I{OMIUIE(COB ,4OIIO.'IHIITEJIbIIO UCNOJII,3OBAIACLaroMHo-cr.rroBarr Mrjl(poc(oflut, renE-SneKTpoabop$,Kyrrb'rypaMuBin vitfo.np,dMeld.e]cLrea Ta(xe?KcrIep[MeETHcKreTortHBrMnB3ariMoaorrolsrl()rqllx asaj irr.rqeckr.rx Meroa[l( rro3Bo.[[rorrojryifrTb (oJfrirecTBeuuyo nuQopvauurc06ocrioBtlErx MoJre(yJrrpsbrxncTp]'roypHBlxTa(, 6u,ra paccv*rraarr a6colrorrlr're MoJIlpHEle MaccBl Ilpa3Mep6!, oflpeaejleHr,l 3ltaqeillit paBEoBecEot xecT(ocTlt lr .4I'IaMeTparapaMerpax o6Bel<ToB:fr.rapo,{lnaMuqecK'erronriMepB6x Mzr(poMoJle(yni onpeaeneEa npel4MyqecrBeflEzul I(oHoopMalllit Me!(poMone(ynBpacrBope.

Ha ocHoBzlHlIL ,{alHHblx Ii3 Bllcl(o3liMerplillecK[x 3(cnep{MeEToB ycraHoBne[o BJIl,tHrIeo-(oErreBhrxfpynfi karI,toEIIErx METaKpIlJIaroBrrolrxMepacIra repMo,q]-IEaMEqecKlii xapa(Tep B3atlMoAeicrBl'ltpacrBoptreJreM. l4cc,rrcI,oRafi:,z,t fiEuefiHorofl3l4, Eaxoatr[erorrupoI<oenpa(Tnqec(oe [p[MeHeEIre, BbltBtitll cylqecTBerrHoe HecooTBeTcTBIie peaJlhlrbrx MojltpltbD( Maccc TeopeT[qec(aMr'I u/uttu gKa\eldusuu Macc, npeqocaaBJleEHbrx IlpoIt3BoaI'ITeneMBnepoue 6r,ru oflpe.{enenLl KoulbopMauuouHr,Ie xapameprjcrll(t rrrueirlbl-\ [I3I4'fionliMepaCtrcreMar['recKnft agajlu3 rIoJrr'r9JIe(TpoJIIjtrHBx I(oMrIJIeI(coB Ea ocIIoBe MoAenhEoi ctlcreM6lAHMI3I{no3Bonlin aBTopy nojlyqlrrb Kolraqec'rBeHH}'ro nibopMauuro o crpy(Type u cocraBerIoJlrDneKTpoJII,ITItIiX (OMItre(COBIlCOIIOCTaBrrh AaHEbIe C 6IlOnoaI'qeC(Oi aml,lBHocT6m3TlxCI:lCTEM.Alrccepraqut u3roxeHa Ea 94 crpanuqax It cocroll't It3 BBeAeEIrt, Tpex ocsoBEix rraB,3a(JlloqeElir n cnI-IcI(a JMTepaT}?61.

Bo BBeaeEEU paCCMOTpeqa arTy€!II6EOCT6 npeACTaBneEHOtTeM6I IICCJIeAOBaITI'j OTIUCaEbI UeII,IIr3a4aqll, EayqEat IroBIt3Ira pa6oTLI, MeToaororDtuccreaoBarHrir, csopMynlpoBa.sbl ocEoBdble rolrot(e1tl'It, Bl,IHoctlMbIe Ha 3aquTy.fraBa IBKffoqaer nmeparypHBri o63op, orpaxaroquii allatlt3 coBpeMeHEoro cocrotHt'lt l4ccreaoBzlHl'ltBa ra(xe reoperuqec(yo qacrb, rlocBtlll€Elryo noApo6EoMy ofiucasllrcsKCrreprMeHTaJr6E!,D( U TeOpeTUqeC(tX MeToAoB, rIpIrMeHteMbIx B .{IrccepTarlfitj. f,raea 2,uaHEoft o6nacrn,nocBtl[eHa onl,Iczlltl[o Meroalt( [ocraHoBl{4 ll ycJloBxi 9(c[epuMelfoB, B ToM qlicre coAepxlrrnr$opuaunro 06 l,lcxoAHr,lx o6pasuax u cnoco6ax nx noJryqeHlrt. fnaBa 3 Blclllo'Iaer B ce6tpa3Aejlbl, OTEOCtlqlIeCt EeIIOCpeACTBeIISOkr'3) Iegttm KOHKp9IHLIX IIOJIiMepgBD<CITCTeMT UcoaepxrrT Bce ocHoBrrbre 3I(c[epI-rMerITzrJIbEHe p$yJrLTaTEIJ nonrrellrGle B xoae BHTIoJTHeHI{'pa6orLr, I-Ix o6pa6orxyrI nocJre.ryloqlifietllaurll3.

AocroBepllocrr, p$ynr,TaroB Ee BhI36IBaercoMHeH!fi, noc(or6(y arBTopoM rrpoBe.{eHo rrIIareJILEoe co[ocrnBreE[e pe3ynbraroB, nojlyrieHHLlxu3 pa3nrrrrH6D( 31(clrepriMeETajr6rr6rx MeronriK, apyr c apyroM, a Tal(xe c nliTepmypEbMlr anHHBIM[.flo uroraMpa6orEr coopMynnpoBar$r o6oqroBasr*,re Br,rBo,(6Ma(lrloqeHlt.B (aqecrBe 3aMeqallni no ariccepraqu[ MorGo orMernrB cnea)'roqee:.Bflpn rBy'reEnri (arrjoEEbrxrrpuclrc'rBl!MeraKpri.lraroB rrccrreaoBarrrr npoBo,{rlJlrlcr, B BoArrErx pacrBopa,\Hr.r3KoMoreKyrqpHoi conti (NaCl), a raKxe(NaOH). B ro xeBpeMJr6y,4er cltnrso 3aBucer6npt ao6agaenq[ cll'rrHoro ocEosaHlrr(oEoopMarlsr (arnoEn6D( Mzr(poMone(yIr, coAepxauux aMHuofpyflnBrJor rrx creresr [poros[poBaunrr,coorBercrBerrno,pacrBopa.

nasnbrfi Bonpoc coBep errrio He KoMMeqr[pyErcr aBTopoM pa6or6r.or lpoour pH. B pa6oreDpeacrtlBlleHbr pe3yJlr,Tarr,l [cc]IeaoBaElrt I(arI'IoHrIbD< MeraI(pI{IIaroB Mero,uoMacclrMgrplquoro QparoluouzporanuafloJryqeHrrbrx pe3ynbTaToBcBrloroKe,aaBHLIMLIr3BToM lMcJIe BLrIIoJIHerro cottocraBteltteCKOpOCTHOi CeAUM€HTaIIn['i3}(Cru O3l',OHlloixpouarorpa$uu. B ro xe BpeMt B pa6ore orcyrcrByer (al{at-nrt6o uut[opuaqur 06 orulcaEl'uaaHEoro MeToaa (accuuerprwroe $parquoHupoBall re B noTo(e).B rnaBe, flocBtlqeqEoi riccreaoBaHalo TIoJIII9IIeKTpoJIIITHLD( KoMIrreKcoB, aBTop npoBoAI'ITaHa,'rr3 cocraBa (oEeqH6rx (oM[reKcoB, Taldte oqegxu npoBoAl't.irltchItpaHl'IIIe.

Kyaa 60:reeEnTepecEr,rM MorJrIi 6I'IT6 AaHIrEle O (OllrqecTBe l{cxo/Ill6rx lrna3Mrla. 0opNrHp]'rou[x r{oMnnekc,(orop61e Heo6xoat MbI.artyAa.rEofi TpaHc$erunur r.nerryABTop EefiocreaoBareneH B rlpeacraBjreElu pe3yjrbraroB: Tz!(, B oarillx ra6ruqax &'ltI{aiAerIIIr-rx xapzrKTeptcrr-r( lpltBoatrct [orperunocrlt (EanpltMep' s ra6ruqe I Ha crp. 49), Eo flpnpaccMoTpentlt Tex xe xapa(TeplicTr'lk aplToi flonuMepHoi cacTeMbl BeJIuq],H6I norpeulliocTet{ Henpe,4crao:renu (ra6nrl\a2 ua aT .32).TaKxe cneAyer orMerltrb II36EIToqIIyo aoqEocrb rlpg olpeAeJrel ll Ee(oropED(xapamep4cTtiK, na[pEMep, 3EaqeHlrt (bpqK[toHEoro oTllotllesl]l! It cBt3arlHoro c HIiM.coorBercrB)'rolqero Ko3(bstjIIIteETa AUoib]3IrIr.

B OAnIiX ra6Jlrtqax aetHuble napzMErp6lqeMor{pe.4enerrbr c roqHocTblo ao coT6D<, B TO BpeMJI (aI( B Apyr[x c ToqlrocT6ro ao aectT6]x.o6ycnoBreHo 3To pa3rl?t Me nplt [crloJr['3oBagltrl o.{Eoro a roro xe rloaxoAa npu rIoJD IeHuIi 3Tl,x.qalrrI6Ix?.Pa6ora coaepxr.tr 3aMerHoe (oJll,lqecrBo Eeroqrocrefi, o6ycroBreHH6tx, cKopee Bcero,rie(oTopoi HeBqnMmejtblrocTbloaBTOpa.OaHa(o c,qeraHEHe 3zMeirarHlI,l B 3EaqI4TeJIbIrofi creneEl'cHr.rxaroT Br,rcoroisarlrloiIloctr Qopllamnufixapa(Tepus€Ilelllrocrt-l altccepTaut[.Auccepra[rir fipeAcraBnter co6oi 3zt(oEqelrH]'loItIIorurI€cK[ uerbE]'Ior.rcclreaoBarenEc(yro pa6ory sa a(Tyarl'E)'ro reMy. Ha)"Ilrble pBynLTarEI,xMe1oT CyrqecTBeHrroe 3ltaqeHrle Kar( aJIt ifr-rsrrr.r[oryreqHl'IeEayqEoaBTopoM,orrcorouole(yjl-ttplr6x coeIrFesl'lii, rax ullrcMexE6rx o6racr€i trayKr, 3aIIItMaIolI[xcq liccreAoBalrleM rloAo6urx uolexynapur,x o6r,emooBhrBoalr rl 3ar<rrroqerrrlr pa6orbr rloJllrocrr,Io o6ocnoBaqbl OcsoBElIe peynbrarbl orly6rn(oBatublrreTr,rpex peIIeH3apyeMLIx 3apy6exHbD<BtqryHalax, a Ta(xe [3roxeHbl Ha Me)IqyEapoaEbrx ItpoccriftcKnx KollibepeHqrirx.

Arrope$epar u ony6nn(oBaElrEle pa6ortl B rlonnoi Mepe orp,lliKarorco,{epxzrH[e arrccepTaqur. Ta.KnM o6pa3oM, arccepTaqnoEqEu pa6oTa flepeBq3Ko ]4.IO. oTBe'IaeT'rpe6oBaHnrM II. 9"floroxeHnr o llopt$(e Ilpllcyxrellntnay'ruo-r<ramr[uraufioqHofi pa60Tofi,cyqecTBeHEoe 3rraqeHne aJrrlltturlyqeIrBIXcreleHeilr BAKB (oTopoi coaepxxrct pelllelllt€P<D,rsrsercs3a,qa.I, uMeloll[fiaucoxovoleKyjltpRBfx coealHeH[fi.

A[ccepTaulrosHacpa6ora nMeer 6$ycnoBEyo EafrF)'ro rroBl-€Ity mBiDrKrIoe[paKT[qecKoe 3HaqeHEe, a €e aBTop,IIepeBBKo l4rop6 IOpEeBEq, 3€lcjlyxtBaer qptcy)t(4euruI eMy yseHoi crerleEtr xau4iAara 0l'I3l{r(oMareMarrqec(trx EayK rlo clleqszt'IblrocTtr 02.00.06 "BrrcorortaonexyrtpE$e coea!trtellE ".O(bnq[ar6Hbtri onnoEellrAMr|poBa AntrHa IIpEaroBHa(AIIAUAAT IbIB'KO-MATEMATFIECIMX HAYK,crapEi$ayqG'fr corpyAHnr na6oparopunMOJIeKynrpEoi orcI,Ir(tr noJrEMepoBOeaep&.rEgoro rocyaapcr'neanoro 6ro4xernoroyrlpexreurltI4ricrlryra Br,Ico(oMoreKyllfpHr,D(Pocq{icKof aK44eM[Bcoe,ryrHeHEfi199004, r.

Ca.Er(T-Ilerep6lpr, Eo.nruofi np., g.ror: +7(812)328-853rra]'I<trHayK3ll, e-mail: aliram.new@gnail.com@,AMtrpoBa AntrEa\k:,ffI{p[aroBHa.