Отзыв оппонента (Разработка методики выявления и компенсации нелинейных динамических процессов в сетях среднего напряжения электротехнических комплексов)

OT3bIBoQr,rquanbHoro orrnoHeHTa Ha rvcceprarlLroHHyrop a6oryBeprapa Banlec IIyuc Aapona<<Paspa6orKa MeroAIt KIr BbIfl BJreH vs kr KoM rr eH c aryrala uel unefi nsrxAUHaMUTTeCKIIX IIpOUeCCOB B CeTsX CpeAHefOHa[pflr(eHuq3JIeKTpOTeXHItTIeCKIIX KOM TTJIeKCOB>>,npeAcraBneHHylo Ha coucKaHpre yueuofi creneHrr KaHAr4Aara rexHr,rqecKr.rx HayKIIo cneIII4€uIbHocrH 05.09.03- 3nexrporexHr4qecKr4eKoMrrJreKcbr r{ cr4creMbrAxryalrsocrr reulr Ancceprauuorinofi pa6orrrPacupe4eJIIaTeJIbHbIe 3neKTpuqecKr4ecerrrHarrp.rrxeHr4eMo6ecnequBaror HenocpeAcrBeHHoe rrr4TaHr4e norpe6urelefi14635xBrro3ToMy orHoc.rrrc.f,K oAHoMy I43 Ba)KHefiurzx 3JIeMeHTon aH$pacrpyKryp coBpeMeHHoro o6rqecrna,ero Hafiexuocm v 6e:onacnocrb.orlpeAenf,IolqlaMI4HAyKTLIBHrIe [epeHarlptr)KeHr4rrepexoAHble rpoqeccblHaKaIrJIrrBaHr4e(Oln)npu rpo3oBbrx pa3prAax,MHoro.rr4oJreHHbreQeppope3oHaHcHbrerIpH Bc{KI4x poAa neuonuo$€BHbrx pexzMax,4e$exruoit uzottr^guu B eervr, crapeHr4e o6opy4oeaHufl,pacnpeAeJleHl,It 3neKTpl4r-Iecrofi 3Hepu4r4 cnoco6crByror3neKTpI4rIpcKrIXcerefipocry3neKTporexHl4qecKkrx KoMrrJreKcoBcr4creMarlapuiruocrucpelHeroKJraccaHanpfl)KeHux.

Pezyrlbrarbl o6o6rqeru4-f, orrblTa 3Kcnnyararlavr rroKa3brBaror, r{ToeaNHefiuzNa acrIeKToM noBbIIueHr.Ir HalexHocrrrpacnpereJll{TeJlbHblx 3neKTpuqecKr4xr4ccneAoBalr.lzeyclonufieQ$exrunHblx MeproSynrqraoHr4poBaHrzrqcerefi Poccuu u MercuxllBo3Hr4KHOBeHr4f,seppop*oHaHcausBJr_{ercspa:pa6orxarpeAorBparrleHr,rro $eppope3oHaHcHbrx -rrBJrenufr.llo:roMyTeMa AI4ccepraIIZoHHoro I4ccneAoBaHr4fl., HanpaBJreHHafl.

ua paspa6orKy MeroAr4KHrloBbItBJIeHI4roI{KoMIIeHcarJvrkr Qeppope:oHaHcHbrx nepexoAHbrx npoqeccoB Bcertx cpeAHero HanptxeHLrfl, flBrrflercrBecbMa aKTyanbuoi,tuI4Meer HayrlHyror4oco6eHsocrl4 pa3Br4rnx Qeppope3oHaHcHbrx rrpoqeccoBBnpaKTI{r{ecKyIO 3Har{I4MOCTb.OBI{3HApaooTe. 3aKnroqaeTc{ B cneAyrouleMI) Hccne4oBaHbl:Cerqx; AOKa3aHO, rrTOKOMIIeHCHpOBaHHbIX3Haqr,rreJrbHbre paccTpor4KrrKOMIIeHCaIILII{ MOfyT Bbr3BaTb Hacbr[IeHr{e CepAeqHr.rKa(AfP), ilpr4BoArrqero2)Ayfofac{ruefopeaKTopaK pa3Br.rrr{rc S eppope:oHaHca;o6ocHoBaHa crpyKrypa cxeMbl 3aMerrleHvrfl, certrnplr HenorHoSa:Huxpe)KXMax, yrorlHeHbl rpaHHIIbr cyqecrBoBaHr4.s Qeppope:oHaHcHbrxserennficucIIoJIb3oBaHaeM S asonrrx rpaeKToprafi u ueroAoB HeJrr4Hefr uofi A]/IHaMIHKLT;'atpa:pa6oraHbr 6rox-cxeMa u aJrropr4rM QyurquoHnpoBaHr4r ycrpoficrna3)o6Hapyxenvrfl kr KoMlreHcaqzra Qeppope3oHaHcHbrx nepexoAHbrx npoqeccoB Hao c H oBe yrrp aBn.rr eMorop e3r4 crr4BHoro3a3 eMJr e Hprfl HefiTp arru.TerreHb o6ocHorroATBep)KAaeTcr:1)rcoppexrHblM npIaMeHeHr4eM B3neKTp OTOXHI,IKI4 I4 MeToAO B2)MaTeM aTurlecKorOpa6ore ocHoBHbrxM OAenIzIp OBaHvfl;co[ocraBI4TeJIbHbIMI4 Bbrrrr4cJrr4TeJrbHbrMr4 gKcnepzMeHTaMr4cnequaJrlt3l4poBaHHbIX KoMrrbrorepHbrx npofpaMMnoJlHoMacuna6nyro orlblTHyro [poBepKynpv3aKoHoBATP/EMPT,Ha6aseilporxeArrrr4xMoAenupoBaHuyr rpoqeacoBB3neKTpr4rlecKux ceT.rrx B pa3nzrrHblx cTpaHax;3)urzporcofi anpo6aqHeft pe3ynbraroB r4ccneAoBaHLrfl Mex4yHapoAHbrx,Bcepoccuficxux z perr{oHaJrbHbrx Hayr{Ho-rexHnqecxrax ronsepeHqzfx.flolyueunue B Auaaeprar\uuBbrBoAbr .qocraroqHo o6ocHosaHrr, ape3ynbTaTbr fBJrffoTcr HoBbrMr4.3Ha.{uNaocrl nory.reHHrx pegymraronAr-s reopuu unpaxruxr,r3aKJIIOqaeTCf, B TOM, rITOl)Hoertfi aJlropl,rrM Anfl o6HapyNeHr4r Lr ycrpaHeHr{f,npoueccoB B 3neKTp[qecKr{x cer.rrx oneKTporexHraqecKr4xrlpeAno)KeHQeppopeaoHaHcHblxKOMTTJTeKCOBCpeAHefo KJracca Hanpflx eHvrfl;2) pa:pa6oraHrrpeKoMeHAarJHLrrro nu6opyBerr4r{r4Hbr colporr4BJreHgtpe3l4cropa Anfl eQQexrunHoro rIoAaBJIeHr4fl Seppope:oHaHcHbrx npoqeccoBKOMrreHCr{poBaHHbrx r,r HeKoMneHcr4poBaHHbIX CeT{X;B3) paspa6oraHbrMeroAHqecKHe peKoMeHAarJzlvr AJII ycrpamenkrfl.QeppopesoHaHcHblx npoqeccoBpa3Br4Tr4fl.B cerqx cpeAHeroyclonufiHanpxlKeHu.flMercurH.npeArssr.f,eN,IbrM Auccepraull-sNa Ha coHcKaHue yqeHofi creueHz KaHAHAara HayxB 4ucceprar\kru craBtrrcr, uenb no pa3pa6orxe,'Bbr{BJreHr,rrorexHurqecKl,Ix petue:nufi.

novr KoMneHcarlnu Qeppope3oHaHcHbix nepexoAHblx [poqeccoBHaocHoBe aHarrkr3a Sasoeux xapaKTepr,rcrr4K eervr, Mepolpr4rrzfi no ycrpaHeHnro HXnocle4creuft, paspa6orr<e peKoMeH.4auuir. rro ycrpaHeHr,rro ycnonufi$eppopeaoHaHcalrqpasBkrrr4fl,cerefi cpeAHefo HanprxeHra.s Mexcuru.Bo BBeAeHurr o6ocHoeaHaaKry€LnbHocrb err6paHHofi reMrrAl4cceprar{rzoHHoro HccJreAoBaHvrs,, cSoprraynlrpoBaHaBbrreKaroqr4e HX Hee 3aAaqr.r LrccJre[oBaHV\rIeJIb pa6orsro6rexr H npeAMerunccJreAoBaHr4s,,HAy.tHafl. HOBLI3Ha pa6Orrr, CQOprvrynr{poBaHhr ocHoBHbre noJroxreHra.f,, BbrHocr4MbreHa 3aIIII,ITy, rrpeAcTaBJreHbr [paKTr.rqecKa.fl 3Har{r4MocTbvpa6omr, [pr4BeAeHbr cBeAeHr,rr rro anpo6aqurape3ynbraroBpeaJrr43arJkrfl,pe3ynbraroBpa6ourkI[y0nuKauH.sM.B uepnofi rJraBeAl{cceprarlr4r4 npoBeAeH aHaJrkrrurqecxufi o6sopcyulecTBytoulefo cocTotHII{ Bonpoca IIo aHanr43y cyl]IecTByrcrqux np[Hr{r4rroBcpeAcrB 6opr6srcSeppope:oHaHcoM.

lloxasaHo,ocyulecTBrreHr4fl HenocpeAcTBeHHbrxrrror4BBHAy HeBo3MoxHocrHHaTypHbrx r43MepeHr4r{,aHaJwr3Seppope:oHaHcHblx [poqeccoB cJreAyer [poBoAr4Tb o r4crroJrb3oBaHueM MeroAoBHelasefiuofi AI{HaMHKI4 pr coBpeMeHHbrx Bbrqr4cJrr4TeJrbHbrx cpeAcrB,rro3BoJr.[roqr4x rronyqnrb MoAeJrI4, 6rusKrae K pe€urbHbrM. Ha ocHoBe[poBeAeHHoro aHaJwr3a aBTopoM c$opnryru4poBaH BbrBoAoHeo6xo4lrMocrr4u ueponpr'rrrzfi Anfl yMeHbrxeHr4tpncKa ro{BreHl4q QeppopesoHaHcHbrx nepeHanpqxeHrafi B cerrx cpeAHeroHanpDKeHIr{ Mexcuru. 3Aecr xe BbrrroJrHeHa rrocraHoBKa saqarr.pa:pa6orrvI MeroAl,Iqecrnx peKoMeHAaguirtAr4CCepTarIr4OHHOfO r,rCCJIe,qOB aHr.Ifl .Bo nropofi rJraBe paccMorpeHbr MareMarnrrecKue noAXoAbI K aHanv3yrepexoAHbrx npoqeccoB B oneKTpuqecKnx cerqx ilpu SeppopesoHaHcHblxrBreHr4-sx. AnropoM rroKa3anrr oco6eHHocrrr Seppope:oHaHcHblx cereft.

flyrevKoMrbrorepHoro MoAenr4poBaHus.BrporpaMMe ATP/EMTP cMoAenI4poBaHbIKprIBbIe HaMafHHrlprBaHvrfl,, TIHAyKTI4BHOCTI4, eMKOCTH I4 HaIrpDKeHVfl I4CTOT{HIKafiLrralJvrs,,c rroMorrlbro KoTopbrx1,$eppope:bHaHcav Aarb orIeHKy e$SerrunHocrr4 Mep [oAaBneHI4t kr.OfI|I. HanpeAynpex,4eHr4rMo)KHo onpeAeJrHTb fpaHrIIIbI cyulecTBoBaHuflocHoBaHr4r4 BbrrroJrHeHHoroAHATIU3A BO3MOXHbIXpexlrMoB QeppopesoHaHca olpeAeneHo, r{To cra6uttttocrb 3JreKTpr4rrecKoit ceruMoxHo olrl{cblBarbHacbIIIIeHnr.[PcrroMorrlbro $a:onrrx xapaKTepr4crr4K.B 3aBr{cr4Mocrr4or Saau3aMbrKaHufl ?r oararorrHoro MarHr{THororroToKa MafHI4ToIIpoBoAa peaKTopa aBTopoM rroKa3aHo,HacbIIrIeHI4t Bo3pacraer3aMbIKaHI,I-aHac3eMJrro.llpu zccJreAoBaHHHqTor4HTeHcr4BHocTbpo_croM paccrpofiKr4 KoM[eHcaq:r^u eMKocrHbrx roKoBllpra 3ToMBeJrrrKa Bepo.srHocrbBo3Hr4KHoBeHvrs.1Qeppope3oHaHcHbrx [epexoAHbrx npoqeccoB r43-3a HacbrrrleHlrfl.

MatHvrTorrpoBoAaAyrofacsulefo peaKTopa.B rperrefirJraBe BbrrroJrHeH aHrurr43 oco6euuocrefi xoscrpyKrlr,rr{ cerefiMexcur<u 14 vrx xapaKTepvrcrtrK,ararcKe Bo3Mo)KHbrx SeppopesoHaHcHbrxnpoqeccoB, Bo3HHKalo[]I4x n rpex@a:Hbrxcerrx MercHKH. AeropoM rroKa3aHo,r{ro B Mercuxe I4cnoJlb3yerc{ pex(rzM rnyxo3a3eMJreHHofi nefirpanu99% cerefi cpeAHefo Hanpr)r(eHwx) w pexrrM(npralaepHo3a3eMJreHux uefirpatm (npuMepHo1% cereft cpeAHero HaupxxeHrzx).

lloxasaHo, qronprzMeHeHr4ernlxo3a3euleriHofi lFlefitpatm He I4cKlroqaer rorBreHH.f, Seppope:oHaHcHbrxxole6aHzfi nrtcoxl4x aMnJlvrryl npr4 HenorHoQasuux pexr{Max. llpr,r 3ToM Ha3AopoBbIXSa:axnpoIzIcxoAIIT HaJroxeHr4eBbrc[rzxfapMoHr4rrecKuxcocraBJlf,Iolqux qacrorbr. YcranoereHo, rrro An.rr r4cKnroqeHu.s Seppope:oHaHcaneo6xo4urrlo paspa6arblBarb Mepbr 3arrlr{TbrKoMIIeHcaIIIIZu ycrpoficrnatrnfl BbrqBreHurvr@iln.

Taxue pelueHzr o6ssareruHu npn HarwrqwLr OIIHB3neKTpHrrecKHX ceTf,x.B .rerneprofir.nase pa:pa6oraHbr €urroprrrMbr 14 rrpvrHut4nbl flocrpoeHl,ItycrpoficrB Anr [o,uaBJleHrzx $eppope3oHaHcHbrx repeHarrp.rrxeHufi, octioBaHHbIXHaI4crloJrb3oBaHvrkrSa:onrrx rpaexropnfi KaK AocroBepHoro Merola Antonp eAene Hufl. vr prccJreAoB aHufl Seppopes oHaHca. Pac.-rerHo-3Kclepr4MeHTaJrbHbrMnyreM aBTopoM ycraHoBneHo, r{To paspa6oraHHbre a,Tfopr4TM 14 rrpvrHL\vrrcxeMa ycrpoftcrBa Bbr.rrBJreHr4fl14,-*t nKoM[eHcarJr4v QeppopeeoHaHcHblx [poqeccoB HaocHoBe I{crroJlb3oBaHKfl. ynpaBnteMofo pe3r4cTopa B HevTpurv ceTr,r no3BoJlrroTycnelxHo peIxHTb 3a4aqy noBbrrrreHr{.fl HaAexHoarn pa6oru cerefi cpeAHeroHanpr)KeHrr.rl.B nqrofr rJIaBe paspa6oraHrr MeroAnrrecKr4e peKoMeHAaryr4r4 rroycrpaHeHr,rrc ycronufi pa3Burkrfl SeppopesoHaHca [nfl cerefi cpeAHeroHarlptxeHl{q Mexcuxlr.

llora3aHo, r{To npr4MeHeHHe paspa6oraHHbrxMeroAI,IqecKI4x peKoMeHAaL\vV ro BblsBreHrrlo, [peAorBparr{eHr4ro 14 [oAaBneHuroSeppopesoHaHcHbrx qereHnfi rro3BoJrr,rr cyruecrBeHHo rroBbrcr4Tb HaAexHocrb3neKTpocHa6xeHuq 3neKTp03Heprerzqecxofi arrcreMbr Mexczr<r,r, o6ecner{HTb3KcnnyaraurloHHble xapaKTepr4crrrKr4Lrcerefi HacIIoJIb3 oBaHrIeM rrepeAoBblx TexHr4rIecKI4x p eureuufiBcoBpeMeHHoM ypoBHe c.3aKrroqeHnn npuBoAtrTcs ocHoBHbre pe3ynbrarbr Lr BbrBoAbr rroAr4ccepraqraouuofi pa6ore.B flpnlonceHllqx [pI4BeAeHbrHecI4MMeTpr4Lr14c[paBorrHbre AaHHbreyAenbHbIM eMKOCTHbTM TOKaMOCHOBHbTX TT4IIOB[oOrrop BO3AyIXHbTXnu;auitt Mexcuxtz 14 Meponplzrrvrfl 4rr5. yMeHbrueHr4r pvraKaQeppopesoHaHcHbrx sereHuficrerreHr4rrorBJreHr4-s.Pesylrrarbl Al{ccepraul4oHHoror,rccJreAoBaHnr ony6ruxoBaHbr norxprrrofirlerrarH, o6cyNganr4:b Ha MeN4yHapoAHbrx, Bcepoccuficxux Lr pefnoHaJrbHbrxHayrrHo-TexHHqecKux xoH$epeHIII4{x.IIer{arHbIX pa6or, B ToM rIHcJIe,4nx ny6nuKar\Lrw.lloreMe Arrccepraqrzu ony6Jrr,rKoBaHo 132 pa6orsl B v3laHr4f,x, peKoMeHAoBaHHrix BAKluccepragux cocronT Lr3 BBeAeHHt, rrflTtr fJIaB, 3aKJIIor{eHrr-q,6u6tuorpaSuuecxoro cnr4cKa u3 100 Har4MeHoBalauit.

O6urufi o6reuAl4cceprarlr4ra cocraBr.f,er 160 crpaHwJ, 59 pr4cyHKoB,2 ra6xug.fiucceptaryux xopotuo crpyKTypvrpoBaHq Marepr4ar r{3Jro)KeH rcHoxopotuo oSopunen. Co4epxaHvreAr4cceprarlr4r4HB uenoM coorBercrByercoAepx{aHzro pa6or, ony6ruroBaHHblx no reMaruKe iluaaeprarlr4r4. Ha varepuaJrbr,ApyrI,IX aBTopoB, HcrroJlb3oBaHHbrx B Al4cceprar\vrvr) r4Merorct ccbIJIKH.lloeceNaIJIaBaM npl{BeAeHbr COOTBeTCTByTOqUe BbrBOAbr, OTpaXa}Oqr4e nOnyr{eHHbreHayrIHbIevnpaKTIzIqecKI4e pe3ynbTarbl.c$opuynupoBaHHbre aBTopoM,aarope $ellop ar6rrrz BnoJrHe AocrurHyrbr.