Отзыв ведущей организации (Повышение управляемости фазоповоротных устройств с тиристорными коммутаторами)

AKUi,i0 i-.tFPH0t il btlliiil Tsil,,i-'lay...{ii0rii*E*il*.qsH0iiTexht,l{t-rilKi4i,TceTftsflt4Fi0tiriitSHrr',4[Itr.lrir;uSliepfeTfiqecK0i,ici4CTerdbt*UilHTti'??Kaurapr;iioeLilocee1152Ci Pi,ri:ci,ls,nK.3, r h/ocxs;r.,-i e i r,," --l(4 9 5 'ii2 l l ti -{1.{} ,6;urc:+ / { ri i i i :)7?l 13-{ 18;, ,nlc- p}ower . r i. ie-ni ai ii;nfcti ' ntc-pi l i vf;r,rLlv,rv,twi 0 6 7 7 4 r i f i 1 ! 1 9r4, ,l H i t 7 7 2 8 5 8 { ] 1KSi)l 0c K n c r) i 6 5 0 2 1 6 0i . l i - P Ht l7, / 2 4 i J 1 0 0 1yTBEPIKAATOHay.rHufipyronoAurenbOCK EOC)rrfi Aesrenb HayKnPOIO.f. IIIarapxHw2016 r.OT3bIBBe4yqefi opraHusarrr4r4o Ar{cceprarlproHHofi pa6ore(De4oponofiMaprrn Llropennrr(fIOBbI IIIE HIIE YIIPABJTflEMO CTII O A3OIIOB OPOT HbIX YC T POIZCrNC TIIPUCTOPHbIMIT KOMMYTATOPAMIb,[peAcraBlessofiHa collcKaHvreyuenofi crerreHr4KaHALrAararexHlrqecKrrx HayKro cneulraJrbHocrz 05.09 .I2 <<CuloBar oneKTpoHr.rKa)- oAHo I{3 rIepcrIeKTuBHbD(ycrpoficrn FACTS, rro3BoJurroqeeperynr,rpoBarb [oroKr.rO|IyaKTrIBHofiuouuocrpl,tlocpeAcrBoM u3MeHeHufl yrna cABrrra cr4creMbrBeKTopon o4uofi Uenu rroorHollreHrIro K cl,IcreMe BeKTopoB Ha[ptxenufiFACTSflBJUIrorcflperynupoBaHllflrloBblrlreHre4pyrofi qerrra.

OcnonHrnrvr gapra'uaMlrrexHoJrorlrge$SerruBHocrlryrpaBneHlrrHarIpDKeHr,Ifl vr o6ecueqeHr{e crarurrecrofiI'IcnolrgoBaHl{e OIIynoroKar\dr{MorrlHocrrr,14 .uprHaM[.recrofi ycrofiuBocr]r.ocyqecrBJrflerct c uenblo yMeHbrx elar4fl,KarrprrurlrbHbrxr{ sKcrrJryararl[oHHbD(9KOHOMI{rIeCKLrX 3aTpaT.B HacrotlqeecyqecrByrorBBeAeHHhre B oKcnnyaraunrorlepeKnlo'rarerefi,o6ecueqllBaerBpeMt BeAercq MHolKecrBo paspa6oroK, cBr3aHHhx c OIIy.ycrpoficrnaHa ocHoBe 3neKTpoMexaHrlrrecKrrxoAHaKo LIx [pLIMeHeHue B KarrecrBe KoMMyrupyroqnxxelaeurrfirIpLIMeHeHlIe B crpyKrypeypoBeHb cKopocrrrOIIyB MupegneMeHToB He14 HaAelKHocrLr [epeKJrrorreHr,rfl. Hanporzn,6ucrpo4eficrnylolquxupu6oponcurosofieneKrpoH1aKrlrrlo3BoJlter [paKTurrecKu MrHoBeHHo nogAeficrBoBarb Ha rrpoueccbr B sHeprocr4creMax vrKaqecrBeHHo ynyqlultTb xapaKTepLIcTr.rKLrraKlrx ycrpoficrn,HarrpLrMep,yBen[qlrrbAr,rcKperHocrbyrna Sasonoro cABI{ra.

flonauuo ororo, nonyrpoBoAHlrKoBbre npu6opsl o6laAarorLI3MeHeHH.flloBbrrxeHHofi rra,4exHocrBro IIo cpaBHeHr,rrcc gneKTpoMexaHr,rqecK[MrrflepeKrroqarer.ruu. BcBt3I,Ic gTxMorreHBgOOeKTI,IBHEIMI,IHcrpyMeHToMrBJrrercr @ITV c rr.rpr.rcropHbrMRoMrryraropoM(Tn.cyllectoyrorcnoco6rr y[paBJreHrrr @rIY c TK, oAHaxo oHrr o6na4aror prgoM HeAocrarKoB,KOTOpBTeHe IO3BOJUTTOTO6eCne.rurt rroJrHyro ]rfipaBJrreMocrEKoMMrraropa, a 3To, B CBOrOoqepeAb, cKtr3brBaercr na 6rrcrpo4eficrnuu.lannatAr,rcceprarlrroHHaapa6o:ra nocBrtrIeHarroBlrrrreHxroynpaBJrreMocrrrOIIY c TK, .rro r,ronpeAeJrqer ee arcryanbrrocrE.Cogepxauxe a[ccepraqr{onlrofiru6panuofipa6oru.Bo nae,qenr,ruo6ocnosrnagrcraKTyaJrEHocr6TeMarprRr4,Qoprr.rynupyercr rleJrb r{ 3a,uarm pa6or6r, HoB}BHa ri rrpaK114qecKilt3HarII'IMocTbnpoBeAeHlrbrx r,rccle4onanr,rfi, a raKx(eprrBeAeHblrroJro)KeHl{t, BbrHocrlMbreHa3arqr.rry.BnepnofirJraBe oflrrcbrBauorcr pa3Hhre rr.rnbl @fIV,[pr.rBeleHa ruraccuQr,rraqr.rr[oJI)mpoBoAHrIKosErxO[IY.

Ilpr,r nocranonre npo6nerrrarr.rxfiEccJre,qoBaur{soco6oe Bgr,rMulgueaBTopyAeJrter HeAocrarKaMpalree [3BecrHbD(Bapr]arrroByrrpzlBJreHlrr@IIY c TK. flora:ano, yrocyulecrByloq[e BapI,IaHTbIynpaBJrenm He qBJrrK)TcrAocraroqHo e(fipexrunnrrur,r, nocKoJrlxy ogr,r3aBI'Ictr or cocTotHl,It gHeprocficreMbr, Koropoe Moxer r,r3MeHr,rrr,crB rrpo[3BoJrEnrfr uorraeurBpeMeHn'rlosToMy cyqecrB)'Ior orlpeAeJreHHBreorpaHurreHnr no yflpaBJrreMocrr,r..{a:ree anropnprrBoAr,rr nosrrft cuoco6 ynpaBJreH[r, aJrroprrrM y4paBneHrar, pearM3yro4rfi npe4loxermrrftcnoco6, a raxxe 14MrrrarlrloHuyro MoAeJrbclrcreMbr )mpaBJrerrr, peaJrr,r3yroqrc noruft a,rropr,rru.,{auur,rficnoco6 nepexnovenusTKBBoAnr BpeMennyro 3aAepnmy rra [epeKrroqegueueo6xo4zrurrx rlneq rllpucropHhD( MocroB B MoMeHTcrraAaroKa B Mocre K nynro.

Taxr.ru o6paaorr,r,o6ecneqr,IBaErcs HyJreBar ror(oBar\aw4no3BoJuruqarrupr{cmpaMBoccraraBJrr.rBarb3arllIpalol4ue cBoficrBa. flo npomecrnur.r nayru @fIY Ha4exHo BKJrroqaETcrB rroBoe coororHr.re.Taxa.f,roronar [ay3a BBo,4r,rrcrrprrx,er 3a BpeMr oAHoro neperu[oqeEr.(r- [ocJreroBareJrb6oAJrtrax4ofi Qarrr TK. Aaropou EccneAoBagr,rrrroKa3aHo,rrro B rrpouecce fiepeK]rrorreHrrrrpexOa3 BHoBOeCOCTOtrHrre,oIIy c TK oxaaunasrc.r B HecKoJrbxrrxcneqr,rQr,rvecrn<pexr{Max pa6orbr,roropue rpedyor uccJreAoBaHur.Bropar uara nocBtlqeua arraJlr,ITl4rrecKoMyonucaur,rro cneqr-r(fr.rvecrlrx pexrnron pa6orn(DITV, nosnuraroqrrx nprr peaJrr3arryfir [peAro)KeHHoro cnoco6a y[paBJreHr,rr TK.AnamrgnpoBoAI'ITct Ha AByxMzlffI,IHnofi uoAenn 3ueprocricreMbr. Analtrr,rqecroeo[ucagr{e c.ueJlanoNOAPO6TTOC BPEMCHHINMI,IU BEKTOPHEIMI,IAI,IATPAMMAMI,I,I,IJIJIIOCTPI{PYIOqIIMI,I rrPOqECC6I B KAXAOMI43 ycragoBr.tBrrurxcr cneqr,r(pravecKr.rxpexriMoB pa6orrr OIfV.

W slrl< cJreAyer, .rro na {a:axTl'rpllcropHoro KoMM)"Tarop4a GoorBercrBeHHo,r{ Ha r4pr,rcropax [orBJrrrorcr llepeEarrp')IteHur.3areu arrop npoBoAllr npoBep(y AaHHbrx,[onyqeHHBrx Ha arraJrr.rrr{qecroftrrro4enu c noMotrFropIMHTaIIuoHHoroMoAenupoBaHut e Matlab&Simulink,MaKerHoM o6pasqe. lanuuea raKxe 3KcrreprlMeHTarrbHoHa Susu.recKoMrloK€r3blBaror xopouyrcI{MI{TaIIuoHHIIM MoAenvpoBaHI,IeMB [peAenaxcxoAuMocrb:B cnyqae cpaBHeHr{s c5 oA, a B cnyqae c gKcrreprlMenT€urbHbrMr.rAaHHbIMIIt- B npeAenax 9 %. Paspa6oraHHble anaJrurkrqecKpreMoAen[ rro3BoJurrorpaccq[Tarb roKr{kr }lanpfl)KeHllt Bo Bcex BerBtx H y3nax cxeMbr Ha Bcex STarrax[epeKnrorreHrrr KoMMyraTopa.B rperrefi uane rpoBoAplTcq [oApo6noe r4ccneAoBaHr,recnequ$uqecKnx pex{HMon pa6oruHa ocHoBe pa3pa6oranuofiO|Iyanallrlrrr4qecrcoftMoAenrr.

llpnne4enuxoeQSzuLIeHToB rrepeHarlp.axeHkI-e kr rreperpy3Krr rro roKyBrpaSlrKpr 3aBracuuocrefiJrvrnvrv 3neKTpolepeAarrr.r vrHenocpeAcrBeHHoB rI4pI,IcropHoMKoMMyrarope or yrna perynerpoBanus,OIIyLr or yrna SasonorocABLIra MelKAy LIcroqHrIKaMLr3AC AByxMarTrunnofi MoAen[ gHeprocrrcreMbr. floxasauo, qro BIrr4lrukr3neKTporepeAaqrl He Bo3HLrKaerHeAorrycrrrMbrx [epeHarrprxenufiB TKOAuaroOnypaccqI,ITaHhI rnflBo3HI{KaIor flepeHarrp-sxeHlrfl Ha rrrpprcropax.xaxAofiSasuTKE rreperpy3oK no roKy.3rnrepeHarrp-flxeHlrtc rroMorrlbro aHaJrkrrvrqecKlrxcoorHorrr e:eIuit.

llorcasaHrrronyqeHHble eKcrlepuMeHT€rrrbHoHa QusnvecKoM MaKere BpeMeHHbreAuarpitMurr pa6oru (DIIY cTK s pexrlMe peulnbHoro BpeMeHn)qro rro3BoJrrer cAenarb BbrBoA: 1) o rou, rrro rrpeAnoxennufianropurM yrIpaBJIeHpItrIo3BoJUIerperuIlTb rrocraBJreHHhreB Aucceprar\Hkr npo6levru u o6ecnerrlrrbronyroyrpaBnteMocrbrkIpllcropHbrMKoMMyraropoMOfIy,2)oKparKoBpeMeHHocrr4npe6unanug OIIV B crleqllSuvecrux pe)fl.rMax, a3HarrLtr,o 6ucrpoAeficrsupr. llora3aHo, rrro oAHolepeKnlorreHlae MoxHo ocyilIecrBltrb 3a rrepuoA ceTeBofo HalpflxeHrar.

llouzuofJIaBe paccMorpeH pex[v3Toro, n rperrefi3&rrIrrrHoro orKrroqeHlrs [o cHcreMe yrrpaBnelJus. npv Bo3HI,rKHoBeHHLrBHeIIrHero K3 B lrvrlaurkroneKTponepeAaqv. B oroM pexr,rMe raprce AeMoHcrpr4pyercr [paKTurrecKiurrroJre3Hocrb co3Aannofi anurnrprqe cro fi Mo.rlen[.B uerneprofirJIaBe noKa3aHa MeroAr,rKa pacrrera HaAexHocrLr TK OlIy,yqrdrhrBaroq€urcuoco6 ylpaBneHrrt TK, a rarcKe MeroAprKa eu6opa KoJrrrqecrBa rr{pracropoB B TlrptrcropHoMKoMMyrarope. flocleAufl.flKoporKrIXsaNarrraHzfi BMeroAI{Ka [ocrpoeHac yrreroM rroKinareleftIrurHkrkr oneKTpo[epeAaqu,araKnteHaAexHo crv\ BHerrrHrrxBBeAeHHoro ilolpaBoqHororos$SraqlleHTa Ha HeKoHTponHpyeMbIeycnoBrdq pa6orrr, cBr3aHHbrec HeAerepMlrHkrpoBaHHbrMr.r[epexoAHbIMH rlpoueccaMla B gHeprocerkr.

BKoHue rJraBhr aBTopoM pa6orurrpoBoAlrrcflcpaBHeHLIeKorllqecrBa rI,IpLIcroPoB, ueo6xoAllMoro rrprd I{crroJrb3oBaHLrupaHee I,r3BecrHoro krrlpeAnoxeHHoro B AaHHoM AHcceprarILroHHoMr{ccneAoBaHLrvcnoco6a yrpaBneHr.rr TK OIIy.floxaganoyBenI{rreHLIe KoJluqecrBa rprpricropoBB cnfraepeiurlr3arllru HoBorocnoco6ayrIpaBneHI,It B 1,3 pa3a. OAuaxo 9To BrIoJrHe rrplreMneMuur rrJrara ga nonlrqeHrre nomrofiyrrpaBJureMocrr,rLr BbrcoKoro 6 rrcpp o4efi crnzr.KoHrcperHoeJrrrqHoe yqacrlle3aKJlloqaerct B paspa6orreaneaJrururqecKplxnno4elefi,rllpllcroponpa6oruaBToparpeAnoxeHHoroB rroJryrreHrr[pe3yJrbraroBcnoco6a yrpaBneHlrrTKAucceprauuupaspa6orreOlIy,a raKlKe MeroAprK pacrrera HaAexHocrr,I kr nu6opaKoJrLrqecrBaTK.

.{uccepraIIroHHEUI pa6ora 1azupyercr Ha pe3ynbrarax HarypHbrx rrccJreAosaHzfi[peAno]KeHHoroflpe4cranJreHHble€lJrropr,rrMa yrrpaBneH:afle rrpoBeAeHHbxOe4oponofiM.VI.B Anccepra'qr'ztpr laccneAoBanprfl, AocroBepHbr, BbrBoAbr kr peKoMeHraq71pro6ocHoeaHhr.Hay.urafl HoBrr3Ha noJryrleHHbrx p e3yJrbraroB HccJreAonanufi 3aKrroqaercq:1) B paspa6orKe croco6a u anropllrMa yrrpaBneHprsTK OlIy,IronHyro ylpaBnteMocrbxoropufiro3Borqer o6ecnerrlrrbu 6ucrpoAeficrnLre B rrpe.{enax ileplroAa cereBoro Harrpfl}Kenprfl,.2) B paspa6oraHHblx aHaJil4TrrqecKprxMoAenrx cnequQraqecKr{x pe}KLrMoBpa6orrr,OilyB KoropbrxoKul3blBaerct B npoqecce [epeKrrorreHur rro [peAnoxeHHoMy irJrropr,rrMyynpaBJreHr.rr.ff panruqecKafl 3Haqr{Mocrb pa6oru 3aKnroqaercr:l) B paspa6orrecl{creMhl yrlpaBneHkrfl.,rlo3BoJurroueft peirnu3oBarb rrpeAnox{ennufi arrroplrrMyrlpaBnenuq TK OlIy,KoppeKrnas, pa6ora noArBepxAena aKroM o BHeApenvru rro AoroBopy cMnHo6pHayKI,I Poccuu, a raKxe n paspa6orKe rrMr,rraur{onuofi MoAenu crrcreMbr yrrpaBneHr4tHoBbrMcnoco6oM Anr rccneAoBartvs.

pa6oru OIIy.2) B uccneAoBanvrn cneqnSuqecKLIx pelKrMoB pa6orur OlIy,rlpeAnox(eHHoro cnoco6a yrpaBneHrflTK OITy. llp"Bo3HuKaroqrdx rrpr pe4nr3arluuIiIcroJIb3oBa:nvrrrylre cyrqecrByroquxcnoco6oB yrlpaBn e:ulas.TaKLrxcueqv SuqecKr.rx pelg,rMoB He Bo3HLrK€uro.3) B parpa6orKe MeroApIKpacqera HaAelrHocrvrv nrr6opa KoJrurrecrBarprpucropoB n TK cfreroMfloKa3arelefi Hane]KHocrr,r.Ily6"unrcaularavaupo6aqurp$yJrbraroBpa6oru.OcsoBHbrepe3ynbrarbrArccepraUl'IoHHofi pa6orH ouy6nLIKoBaHhI B 14 uayuHbrx rpyAax (4 craru4 B perleH3lrpyeMbrxxypHarlax LI3 rlepeqns BAK PO) u anpo6upoBaHbl Ha 7 MexAyHapoAHbrx HafrHo-TexHLrqecKHXronQepeHrlurx.3apre.raH*rfl rro ArrcceprarluoHHofi padore1) I4cuonb3yeMiul B Allcceprar\vrkr MeroApIKa nccne$oBalkrfl pe)Kr4Monpa6orrr OIIVgHeproclrcreMbl IEEE c 10-ro reHeparopaMl,I n 39 ruHH€tMLrrr[poKoc TK B cxeMepacrpocrpaHeHa BsneKTporexHrlrlecKoMcoo6qecrBe LI coorBercrByer ypoBHro Me)KAyHapoAHbrxr{ccneAosa1uir.CouacHocBeAeHrIsM krs [vccepraql,Il4, nu6op orrrprMaJrbnoro Mecra ycraHoBKtr OnycrIcreMbl ocyulecrBJreH npo$ulbHbIMLI crequantrcraMrr OAO (3HI4H)HecuorpsHa ro, qro 9To He flBrsercterofiB paMKax rpoeKra.JILIqHofi pa6orofi anropa, Irrfl, nyq111ero Boc11purrr4tAklccepraul{oHHbrx vccneAoBaHkrir,,qenecoo6pasHo rrplrBecru o6ocHoealns, nu6opaMecraycraHoBru OIIY.2) B pa6ore no4po6uo LlccJreAoB€ulacbroJrbKo oAHa rorroJroruq OIIVc TK.