Отзыв оппонента 2 (Многомодовые прямоугольные диэлектрические волноводы и резонаторы КВЧ диапазона)

OT3LIB Q«J)H:QHAJILHOrO OTITIOHEHTAua .LJ:HCcepTan;uro MHHKAP A MoxaMa.LJ: Caa.LJ:aJIJia«MHoroMo,n:oBnie np.HMoyronnHbie ,[(H3neKTpHqecKHe BonHOBO,[(bi 11 pe3oHaTopni KBq,[(Hana30Ha», npe,n:cTaBJieHH)'IO Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTeneHH KaH,[(H,[(aTa TeXHifqecKHXHayK no cneu:HanbHOCTH05.12.04-"Pa,n:HOTeXHHKa, B TOM q11cne CHCTeMbl II ycTpOHCTBa TeneBH,[(eHH.H"AKTyaJihHOCTh pa6oThl.BOllHOBO,[(bl(M:I1)J;B)(Mfl,lJ;P) TOllbKOMHoroMo,n:oBnie np.HMoyronnHble ,[(H3neKTpHqecKHeII MHOrOMO,[(OBble np.HMOyronnHbie ,[(H3neKTpHqeCKHe pe30HaTOpbice:H:qac CTanH HaxO,[(HTb npHMeHeHHe B TeXHHKe KBq, n03TOMy nOCTa-HOBKa 3a,n:aqlf C03,[(aHH.H ,[(H3neKTpHqecKOH 3neMeHTHOH 6a3nl(,z::(3E).HBn.HeTC.H CBOeBpe-MeHHOH.

KoMnneKc 3a,n:aq no Hccne,n:oBaHHIO MHoroMo,n:oBbiX np.HMoyronnHbi X ,n:H3neKvTpHqecKHX BOnHoBo,n:oB 11 pe3oHaTopoB, pemaeMbiH B pa6oTe MHHKapa M.C., aKTyaneH II Ba)KeH ,[(ll.H pa3pa60TKH II npoeKTHpOBaHH.H:QeJihiO pa60Thl -,z::(3E Ha 6a3e Mll,z::(B..HBn.HeTC.H KOMnneKCHOe ( TeopeTHqeCKOe, 3KCnepHMeHTanbHOeII MO,[(enbHOe) HCCne,[(OBaHHe cneKrpa THnOB BOnH BMll,z::(BII KOne6aHHH BMll,z::(PKBq ,n:Hana3oHa.)J;n.H ,n:ocTH)KeHH.H u:enH pa6oTni norpe6oBanocn:- o60CHOBaTb Bni6op 06beKTOB HCCne,n:oBaHHH: BOllHOBbiX .HBneHHH, MO,[(OBbiXpe)KHMOB, BH,[(OB 11 KOHCTPYKU:HH MHoroMO,[(OBbiX ,[(H3neKTpHqecKHX CTPYKTYP (,IJ;C);- H3yqHTb noBe,[(eHHe BbiClliHX THnOB BOnH Ha nnaBHO Heperyn.HpHbiX yqaCTKaXMll,z::(BII HX CHCTeM, oco6eHHO B o6naCT.HX B6nH3H KpHTifqecKHX ceqeHHH BbiClliHX Til-noB BOnH (BTB);- HCCne,n:oBaTbBTB B(H,z::(P)Mll,z::(BB03MO~OCTbII C03,[(aTb MeTO,[(HKY onpe,n:eneHH.H napaMeTpOBqepe3 Hccne,n:oBaHHe H3MepHTennHbiX ,[(H3neKTpHqecKHX pe3oHaTopoBCTO.Hqe:H: BOllHbl ( 0Tpe30K HCCne,n:yeMoro,z::(BMe)K,[(y nnOCKHMH OTpa)KaTen.HMH);- H3;nJHTb BllH.HHHe Ha H3Mep.HeMbie napaMeTpbiH,z::(PManniX OTKllOHeHHH reo-MeTpHH II napa.MeTpOB ero 6a30BbiX 3neMeHTOB: 3a30pOB Me)K,[(y OTpa)KaTen.HMH II TOpU:aMH CTep)KH.H,z::(B,,z::(B,HaKnOHa nnOCKOCTeH OTpa)KaTeneH OTHOCHTennHO HOpManH K OCRpa3BOpOTa CTep)KH.H,z::(BBOKpyr OCRPa60T3 HMeeT 06beM 154HH.H, cnMCKa nMTepaTypni II4-xH,z::(P.CTp.

0Ha COCTOHT 113 BBe,n:eHH.H, II.HTH rnaB, 3aKniOqenpHllO)KeHHH 06beMOM20CTp. Pa6oTa npoHnniOCTpH-2poBaHa 84 pHCYHKaMH (B T.q. 14 B rrpHJIO)I(eHH.srx). CrrHcoK JIHTepaTypoi BKmoqaeT 166Ha:HMeHOBaHHH, B TOM q:HcJieBo BBe,LJ;euuu7 aBTOpCKHX pa6oT.YKa3aHa aKTYaJihHOCTh pa6oThi, rrocTaBJieHbi :u:enH H rrpe,n:Jio)l(eHhiMeTO,I:(bi peiiieHH.si IlOCTaBJieHHbiX 3a,n:aq, orrpe,n:eJieHbl HOBH3Ha, rrpaKTHqecKa.si :QeHHOCTb pa60Tbi H IlOJIO)I(eHH.si, BbiHOCHMhie Ha 3aW:HTy.fiepBaH r JiaBapa60Tbi TIOCB.siiii;eHa aHaJIH3Y COBpeMeHHOrO COCTO.siHH.si B 06JiaC-TH ,I:(H3JieKrp:HqecKHX BOJIHOBO,I:(OB H ,I:(H3JieKTpHqecKOH 3JieMeHTHOH 6a3hl.BTopaH r JiaBaxapaKTepHCTHK MO,n:paccMaTpHBaeTc.sr perneH:He 3a,n:aqH Haxo)l(,n:eHH.si ,n:HcrrepcHOHHhiXMII,[(BrrorrepeqHhiMH pa3MepaMH.H orrpe,n:eneHH.sr Mo,n:oBoro cocTaBa BBCTBeHHhiX BOJIH ITJiaHapHOrOMII,[(Bc 3a,n:aHHhiMHHaqane orr:HcaHhi ,n:HcrrepcHOHHhie xapaKTepHCTHKH co6-,[(B ..z::I:anee IlOJiyqeHbl rrpH6JIH)I(eHHhie ,I:(HCilepCHOHHbiexapaKTepHCTHKH rrepBbiX ,n:ec.srTH THITOB BOJIHMII,[(B,a 3aTeM -qacTOTHbie 3aBHCHMO-CTH BHyTpeHHero H BHeiiiHero BOJIHOBbiX qHceJI, KOTOpbie OilHCbiBaiOT pacrrpe,n:eJieHH.siIlOJieH 3THX MO,n: BO BHyTpeHHeH H BHeiiiHeH o6JiaCT.siX ceqeHH.siHO.

llpe,n:JIO)I(eH MeTO,I:( HH)I(eHepHOH O:QeHKH qHcJia MO,n: BrneMIJ,[(BMIJ,[(BCOOT BeTCTBeH-C lPOpMaTaMH 60Jib-2.TpeTbH rJiaBarrocB.srrn:eHa BorrpocaM Hccne,n:oBaHH.sr ,n:Byx CB.sl3aHHbiXMII,ll,B.C,n:enaHa TaK)I(e rrorrhiTKa o:u:eHHTh TeopeTHqecKH H orrHcaTb Ha ypoBHe MHoroMo,n:oBbiX.siBJieHHH rrpo:u:eCChi, rrpOHCXO,I:(.siii(He B CHCTeMe ,n:Byx 6JIH3KOpaCITOJIO)I(eHHbiX,[(B.llpoBe,n:eH aHaJIHTHqecKHH pacqeT MaTpH:U:bi pacce.siHH.si ,I:(JI.si pa3JIHqHbiX MO,n:, IlOJiyqeHhi 3aBHCHMOCTH K03lPlPH:U:HeHTa CB.si3H oT paccTO.siHH.si Me)l(,n:yMII,[(B.l1ccne,n:o-BaHbl 3aBHCHMOCTH K03lPlPH:U:HeHTOB OTpa)l(eHH.si OT qaCTOTbi IlpH pa3JI:HqHbiX K03lPlPH:QHeHTaX CB.si3H (npH pa3JIHqHbiX paCCTO.siHH.siX Me)l(.n:y ITJiaCTHHaMH) ,I:(JI.sr ,n:Byx rrepBbiXMO,n:. llo,n:TBep)l(,n:eHhi rrpe,n:ITOJIO)I(eHH.si 0 TOM, qTO Heperyn.srpHOCTb THila CThiK CJia6o(Ha ypOBHe -60,n:n) BJIH.sieT Ha o6pa30BaH:He BOJIH BbiCIIIHX THilOB H BOJIH C OpTOrOHaJibHOH rron.srpH3a:QHeif.B 'leTBepToii r JiaBe paccMoTpeHhiMII,[(BHMII,.[(P .MeTo,n:hi 3KcrrepHMeHTaJihHhiX Hccne,n:oBaHHH.ll:JI.sr ,n:ocTH)I(eHH.sr :u:ene:H: aBTOp pa6oThi HCTIOJih30BaJI MeTo,n:hl lPH3H-qecKoro H BhJq:HcJIHTeJihHoro 3KcnepHMeHTOB .

.z::I:n.sr yTBep)l(,n:eHH.sr ,n:ocToBepHOCTH 6hiJIHnpoBe,n:eHhi o:u:eHKH rrorpernHOCTeif H3MepeHH.sr. PaccMoTpeHhl TPH lPM3HqecKHX 3Kcrre-3pHMeHTaJibHhiX ycTaHOBKH. IJOCTpOeHbl 3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHbie BbiqHCJIHTeJibHbie MO)J;eJIH, KOTOpbie 3KBHBaJieHTHbl <l>H3MeCKHM MO,n;emiM.B nHToii rJiaoerrpwBe.n;eHbi pe3yJibTaTbi <Pw3wqecKwx H qwcneHHbiX 3Kcrrepw-MeHTOB. IJpoBe)J;eH aHaJIH3 BJIIDIHH.si pa3JIHqHbiX <PaKTOpOB, TaKHX KaK 3a30pb1 Me)I()J;yMll,ZJ;BOTpa)l(aTeJI.siMH If CTep)I(HeM, yroJI HaKJIOHa OTpa)l(aTeJI.si, IIOBOpOTBOKpyr rrpo-)J;OJibHOM OCH OTHOCHTeJibHO B036y.D;HTeJI.si, Ha pe3yJibTaTbl 3KCIIepMMeHTOB. 3aMeqeHbl3aKOHOMepHOCTH He H3BeCTHbie paHee.B 33KJIIO'Ieuuu rrpHBe.n;eHbi BbiBO.D;bi no pa6oTe.BrrpHJIO)I(eHIDI BbiHeceHbi MaTepHanbi, wcrroJib30BaHHbie BHCCJie)J;OBaHHM 113 rJiaBbl5, a3rnaBe, pe3yJibTaTbiTaK)I(e 3a.siBKH Ha rraTeHTbl./(ocmoeepHOCmb U o60CH06QHHOCmb pe3yJibTaTOB pa60Tbl IIO)J;TBep)I()J;aeTC.si TeM,qTO 60JibiiiHHCTBO pe3yJibTaTOB IIO)J;TBep)I(.D;eHO 3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHO, C IIOMOII.J;biO .D;ByxHe3aBMCHMbiX 3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHbiX TeXHOJIOrHM,If OHM COrJiaCyiOTC.si C H3BeCTHbiMHTeopeTHqecKMMM If rrpaKTHqecKHMM pe3yJibTaTaMM.JlpaKmutteCKGJl 3HQ'-IUMOCmb pe3yllbmamoe ouccepmalf.UU1.

IlonyqeHbl rrapaMeTPbi BbiCIIIHX THIIOB BOJIH BMll,ZJ;B,Tpe6yeMbie )J;JI.si pa3pa60TKHMHoroMO.D;OBbiX .D;H3JieKTpwqecKHX CTPYKTyp H MHoroMO.D;OBbiX 3JieMeHTOB ,[(3:0.2. IJonyqeHbl HOBbie 3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHbie pe3yJibTaTbl IIO)J;TBep)I(.D;eHHbie <l>H31fqecKHMMBb~HCJIHTeJibHbiM 3KcrrepMMeHTOM.BqacTHOCTH,3aMeqeHaoco6eHHOCTbM3MeHeHHH .n;o6poTHOCTM rrpn M3MeHeHHM IIIHpMHbi 3a3opa Me)l(,n;y Topu;oMMII,ZJ;BBHOTpa)l(aTeJI.si C B036y)I(.D;a10II.J;HMH r:u;eJI.siMH.IJonyqeHblHOBbie3KCIIepHMeHTOB-COIIOCTaBJieHM.siH3yqeHbi:pe3yJibTaTOBBJIH.siHHeHape3yJibTaTOTKJIOHeHMM reoMeTpHH H rrapaMeTpoB 3JieMeHTOBIf TOpiJ;OM,ZJ;B,BbJqlfCJIHTeJibHbiXH,D;P:<l>H31fqecKOrOIf<l>M31fqeCKHX3KCIIepHMeHTa3a3opa Me)l(.n;y OTPa)l(aTeJI.siMHHaKJIOHa OTpa)l(aTeJieif; 3HaqeHIDI )J;H3JieKTpMqecKOM IIpOHHQaeMOCTM3JieMeHTa KperrneHH.si o6pa3u;aMII,ZJ;B;pa3BopoTa cTep)I(H.si,li;BBOKpyr rrpo.n;oJibHOMOCM.3a.MeiiQHUR I< OUCCepmal(UU1.3KCIIepHMeHTaJibHYIO qaCTb pa60Tbl MO)I(HO 6biJIO 6bi rrpe,n;cTaBHTb IIIHpe 3a cqeT COKpar:u;eHIDI MaTepnana rrepBbiX ,n;Byx rnaB.2.Ha HeKOTOpbiX rpa<l>HKax B aBTOpe<PepaTe If )J;HCCepTaQHH HMeeT MeCTO He COOTBeTCTBMe Ha)J;IIHCeM.

(HarrpHMep: pHC.9aBTOpe<l>epaTa IIpHCYTCTByeTB Ha)J;IIHCH CBepxypMCYHKa CTOMT TepMMH - «3epKaJIO», a B IIO)J;IIHCM IIO.D; pMCYHKOM «OTpa)l(aTeJib» ) .43.B pa6oTe M aBTope<):>epaTe MMeiOTCj{ oneqaTKM M nyHKTyau;MOHHI>Ie HeToqHoCTM.B u:enoM, npMBe.n;eHHI>Ie Bbiiiie 3aMeqaHMj{ He HOCj{T npMHU:MnMani>Horo xapaKTepaM He MeHj{IOT o6mero nonmKMTeni>Horo BneqaTneHlfj{ oT pa6oTI>I, pe3ynoTaTI>I KOTopo:H:MMeiOT Ba)I(HOe HayqHOe M npaKTMqeCKOe 3HaqeHMe.,[(MccepTa:QMOHHaj{ pa6oTaMHHKAPA MoxaMa,ZJ. Caa,ZJ.aJIJia«MHoroMo.n;o-Bble npj{MOyronbHbie .IJ:M3neKTpMqeCKMe BOnHOBO.IJ:bi M pe30HaTOpbi l(Bq .IJ:Mana30Ha»j{B~eTCj{ 3aKOHqeHHOM HayqHO-KBanM<):>MKa:QMOHHOM pa60TOM.

B pa6oTe Ha OCHOBaHMMBbiiiOnHeHHbiX MCCne.n;oBaHMM M3nO)I(eHbi HayqHo-060CHOBaHHbie MeTO.IJ:bi O:QeHKM qJICna MO.IJ: M MX xapaKTepMCTMK BMII.,Z:(BMMI1,l(PM TeXHMqeCKMe peiiieHMj{ .IJ:~ C03.IJ:aHlfj{nepcneKTMBHbiX l(Bq ycTpOHCTB pa3nMqHoro Ha3HaqeHlfj{.Pe3yni>TaTI>I Mccne.n;oBaHMM ony6nMKOBaHDI B )l(ypHanax (B TOM qMcne, YTBep)I(.IJ:eHHbiX BAK M npHpaBHeHHbiX K HMM), Heo.n;HoKpaTHO .n;oKna.n;oiBanMcb Ha HayqHO-TeXHMqecKMX KOH<):>epeH:Qlfj{X.

ABTOpe<):>epaT COOTBeTCTByeT co.n;ep)l(aHMIO .IJ:MCCepTa:QMM.Co.n;ep)l(aHMe pa6oTDIMHHKAPA M. C.«MHoroMO.IJ:OBI>Ie npj{Moyroni>HI>Ie .IJ:M-3neKTpMqecKMe BOnHOBO.IJ:bi M pe30HaTOpbi l(Bq .IJ:Mana30Ha» COOTBeTCTByeT Tpe6oBaHMj{M BAK no cneu;Mani>HOCTM05.12.04 -ycTpo:H:cTBa TeneBM.IJ:eHlfj{", a ee aBTop"Pa.n;MoTeXHMKa, B TOM qMcne cMcTeMI>I MMHHKAP A MoxaMa,ZJ. Caa,ZJ.aJIJia3acny)I(M-BaeT npMCY)I(.IJ:eHMj{ yqeHOM CTeneHM KaH.IJ:M.IJ:aTa TeXHMqecKMX HayK no YKa3aHHOM cneU:ManbHOCTM.Pj{60B EopMc AneKceeBMqIIo.n;nMch .n;ou;eHTa E.3aBepj{IQ<I>e.n;epanbHOe rocy.n;apcTBeHHoe 6IO.n;)l(eTHoe o6pa3oBaTeJibHOe yq:pe)I(.ZJ;eHHe BhiCIIIero rrpo<PeccHoHaJibHoro o6pa30BaHHSI «MocKOBCKHH rre.n;arorHqecKHH rocy.n;apCTBeHHhiH YHHBepcHTeT>>J1HCTHTYT <l>H3HKH, TeXHOJIOrHH H HH<l>OpMa~HOHHbiX CHCTeM119991 , PocciD!, r.

MocKBa, yJIHu;a Mana.R IlHporoscKa.R, 111http://xn--c 1arjr.xn--p Iai/ (Mnry.pQ>)alsemenov@mpgu.edu, r@mpgu.eduTeJI. +7-495-245-03-1 0 QJaKC. +7-499-245-77-58.