Отзыв_оф._опп._ЕленеваЮЯ_Гуличева (Организационно-экономические механизмы и подходы к управлению процессом распространения знаний за рубеж)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв_оф._опп._ЕленеваЮЯ_Гуличева" внутри архива находится в следующих папках: Организационно-экономические механизмы и подходы к управлению процессом распространения знаний за рубеж, Отзывы оппонентов. PDF-файл из архива "Организационно-экономические механизмы и подходы к управлению процессом распространения знаний за рубеж", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "экономика" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве МГТУ им. Н.Э.Баумана. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с МГТУ им. Н.Э.Баумана, его также можно найти и в других разделах. Архив можно найти в разделе "остальное", в предмете "диссертации и авторефераты" в общих файлах, а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата экономических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
B ,l1;uccepTa",UOHHbIH COBeT ,l1;212.141.21<I>rJiOY BO «MOCKOBCKUHrocynapcrnenmatiTeXHUqeCKUHyaaeepcirrer UMeHU H.3. Baysrana»OT o4>uu uaJIbHOrO onnoneirra~.3.H., npoipeccopa EJIeHeBOHIOJIUU ilKOBJIeBHbIOT3bIBO<I>H"QHAJIbHOrOOnnOHEHTAna ,n;HccepTaU;HoHH)'IOpa60TY Tymrseaoa Enensr r eanansesnsrna TeMY: «OpraHH3aU;HoHHo-3KOHOMHqeCKHeMexaHH3MbI H nonxonsr Kyrrpaaneaaro nponeccov pacnpocrpaacaaanpencraanenayro3HaHHH sana COHCKaHHeyqeHOHpytiex»,creneaaxanzranara 3KOHOMHqeCKHXnayx rro CrreU;HallbHOCTH08.00.05 3KoHoMHKa H ynpasneaae(ynpaaneaneHapo,n;HbIMX035IHCTBOMHHHOBaU;H5IMH)AKTYallbHOCTb TeMbI ,UHccepTaUHoHHoro Hccne,UOBaHH5IHenb35I CKa3aTb, QTOresra nacceprauaaMOMeHTY onytinaxoaaasraficomoraoHOBa5I.
K HaCT05I:ru;eMYaaanoraxasre Hccne,n;OBaHH5Iy Hac B crpaneH sapy6e)J(oM, HO OHH KaCaIOTC5InH60 perHOHallbHbIX (BHYTpeHHHx ,n;n5Irocynapcrsa)np06JIeM, JIH60ornensasreocsemaiororztensaueCTOPOHbI opraHH3aU;HH npoueccarrJIaTHbIX 06pa30BaTenbHblxpacnpocrpaaeaaaAnexcanxosaHarrpaBJIeHH5I HHTerpaU;HH 06pa30BaHH5I,ycnyr.o6yqeHH5II1pHHU;HrrHallbHbIMH npe,n;ocTaBJIeHH5Isonpocaaananasa3HaHHH sa py6e)J( POCCHHCKHMHBY3aMH nOCB5I:ru;eHbIrpyzrsiA.M.,EeJI5IKOBaC.A.,KJI5IQKOT.JI. H np. Bonpocsi HHTerpaU;HHssrcurero 06pa30BaHH5I paccMaTPHBaIOTC5I B rry6JIHKaU;IDIX ArpoHOBHQa M.JI.,I1BaHoBa ~.I1.,PoranesaH.~.H zrp, <I>aKTopbI HHHOBaU;HOHHoro penrenaarrp06JIeM 06pa30BaHIDI orpaaceasr B pafioraxT.,U.
O,UHaKo, cymecrseaaoerrpo,n;OJI)J(aIO:ru;a5IC5IpediopvaEJIeHeBoH IG.R., CMHPHOBOHB.P. HKOJIHQeCTBOpa:mOrJIaCHH rro,UaHHoH TeMe H06pa30BaHH5I CBH,n;eTeJIbCTB)'IOT0 HecoMHeHHoHaKTYallbHOCTHTeMbI HCCJIe,n;OBaHH5IrYJIHQeBOH E.1.1CTeneHb 060CHOBaHHOCTHnOnO)l(eHHM, BbIBO,llOBH peKOMeH,llaUHM,CmOpMynHpoBaHHbIX B ,llHCCepTaUHHI1ccne,llOBaHHe,n,HCCepTaHTa OXBaTHnO npaKTUqeCKHCTOPOHbI 06pa30BaTenbHOrOnpoueccaHHOCTPaHu;eB,06~aIOIl(HXC~B POCCHH.scero,norHIIHOCTb,BBe,n,eHHH, npncnpasennaeoH3~eHHe060CHOBaHHHyxasananaycnosaaxPbIHOtIHbIXHamHXOfipautaernOCJIe,n,OBaTeJIbHOCTb HneransaoeBonpOCOB, HXKaK nnsHBOnpOCbIna cefiaBHHMaHHe,npexnenOCTaHOBKHCOOTBeTCTBYIOIl(He BbIBO,n,bI. Y)I(errpouecc(pacnpOCTPaHeHHeTeMbI,n,orOBopHO-ToprOBbIX OTHomeHHM) nperepnenBOHCCJIe,n,OBaHH~, aBTOppa3BHTHe3HaHHMHCTy,n,eHTOB,TaK H ,n,JUIy6e,n,HTenbHOCTbaKTyarrbHocTHTO, tITOBCePOCCHMCKHX BY30B BKaKBapHaHTHcnoco6CYll(eCTBeHHbIe c,n,BHrHB OCHOBHbIXHanpaBJIeH~XHX (BY30B) ,n,e~TeJIbHOCTH,oco6eHHO B MaTepHarrbHO-TeXHHtIeCKOM06eCnetIeHHHnpou;eCCOB 06~eHH~H <pHHaHCHpOBaHHH (KaK HaytIHOM, TaK Hnpeno,n,aBaTenbCKOM ,n,e~TeJIbHOCTH).B nacrosmeeCOTPy,n,HHtIeCTBa,Bpe~CYll(eCTBeHHO noasnnaercanpanoxeaaernerpynapOJIb Me)l(,n,YHapO.llHOrOrrpenonaaareneiiHaH60JIee3<p<peKTHBHO.K CO)l(arreHHIO, KaK CBH,n,eTenbCTBYIOTpe3YJIbTaTbI Me)l(,n,YHapo,n,HbIXpeMTHHrOB, POCCHMCKHeBy3bI 3aHHMaIOT CKpOMHbIe n03HUHH, H 3TO 3aTpy,llH~eTHX60Pb6y(KOHKypeHU;HIO)naMHPOBOM psnnce.Heo,n,HOKpaTHOYKa3bIBarrH PYKOBo,n,HTeJIHrocynapcrsaHa3TO06CTO~TeJIbCTBOB CBOHX BbIcTynJIeH~XHo<pHUHarrbHbIX peureaasx.I1CXO,ll~ H3 CJIO)l(HBmeMC~ CHTyaUHH, rYJIHtIeBOM E.r.xpyr6blJl C<pOpMHpOBaH3a,llatI H HaytIHbIX HHTepeCOB aucmeti mKOJIbI na 6JIH)I(aMmyIO nepcneKTHBY·Bee OHH orpaaceast B aBTope<pepaTe.,nHccepTaU;H~,3aKJIIOtIeHH~, cnncxapafioreMHoronOMHMO saeztenaa,nareperypu (155Ta6JIHU,cxesr,COCTOHT H3 rpexrnas,BbIBO,n,OBHHCTOtIHHKOB), a TaK)I(e npHJIO)l(eHH~.PHCYHKOB HnpyroroBKJIaCcH<pHKaUHoHHoroMaTepHarra.2I1epBIDIrJIaBa06pa30BaHH5.l»zmcceprauaaconepxorrrrapraepcrnaCYIIJ;eCTBYIOIIJ;HXrrp06JIeMC 3apy6e)l(HbIMHBbICIIIerOpsmxeBY3aMH, POJIH COBMeCTHbIX3HaHHH, a raxace (KaK 0606IIJ;eHHe) aHaJIH306pa30BaHH5.lHeroocofieaaocreirMe)l(,n;YHapo,n;HoH,n;e5.lTeJIbHOCTblOBY30B.
B TOM qHCJIe, BKpHTHKaMe)l(.rzyHapO,n;HOrO3HaHHH, aHaJIH3 aKa,n;eMHqecKoH M06HJlbHOCTH Bnporpaser na06pa30BaTeJIbHbIXacrrexrsrCBO,n;HbIHaHaJIH3 MeCTa H POJIH poccaricxoro06pa30BaHH5.l aa MHPOBOM psmxeYHHBepCHTeTaX H HX«TeOpeTHqeCKHeonpenenenasCYIIJ;eCTBYIOIIJ;HX MeTo,n;OBBynpasneaaanacceprauna npaseneaapeHTHHroBBY30B,HX<pOPMaJIbHOHorpaHHqeHHOCTH H 5.lBHOHHey6e,n;HTeJIbHOCTH.I1pe,n;JIO)l(eHH5.lasroparro COBepIIIeHCTBOBaHHIO :noHCHCTeMbI 3aCJIY)l(HBalOT BHHMaHH5.l. B qaCTHOCTH,naccepraar aaurna cnocof noxasarsJIH,n;epaMH B 06JIaCTH(Ta6JI.pacnpocrpaaenas1H Ta6JI.3HaHHH sa pyfieacBeJIHK06pHTaHH5.l, KaK rrpHH5.lTOCqHTaTb, a ABCTPaJIH5.l Hcnacxe3aHHMaeTnocroiiaoe,[(HHaMHKaqHCJIeHHOCTHsysax.paspafiorarspoccaacxaxHqTO HaCT05.lIIJ;HMH5.lBJI5.lIOTC5.lHeKanana.CIlIAHPOCCH5.lB 3TOMMeCTO, onepezcaa .5IrroHHIO H KHTaH.HHOCTPaHHbIXCBH,n;eTeJIbCTByeT06 aKTHBH3aU;HHnponeccapoccaacxax2),cTy,n;eHTOBpacnpocrpaneananpoexr,ziano YKa3aHHeCOrJIaCHO KOTOPOMY HenepsyioBY30B ,n;OJI)I(HbI BOHTH Braxace3HaHHH sa pyfiexc BPOCCHHCKHMrrpaBHTeJIbCTBOM B CB5.l3HC 3THMOCYIIJ;eCTBHTb3)(Ta6JI.COTHIO JIyqIIIHxMeHeenaraYHHBepcHTeToMMHpa.Bparry nepsocreneaasrx sanasr,CT05lIIJ;HXceroztasnaccepraarcnpasennaaonapacIIIHpeHH5.lMe)l(,ll;YHapo,n;HbIX KOHTaKTOB BYKa3bIBaeTnepenHe06xo,n;HMOCTbHarrpaBJIeHHIOnporpaxerrrOCB5.lIIJ;eH u;eJIbIHHH<p0pMaU;HH, aHaJIHTHqeCKHXnarrpasrep, npencraaneuaaaTa6JIHu;a6H pacrrpocTPaHeHHeMBHeMMHoroesponeacxaxBY30B.mrrepecaoaH cooTBeTcTBYIOIIJ;HX BbIBO,n;OB.TaK,BbI5.lBJI5.leT,n;OCTOHHCTBaMo,n;YJIbHOHCHCTeMbI 06yqeHH5.l rrpHMeHHTeJIbHO cOBMecTHoH 06pa3oBaTeJIbHoHrpexO,n;HO H3H THrrOBblX rrJIaHOB 06yqeHH5.l.
3TOMYnaparparp.nocrpoenaacYIIJ;eCTBeHHoro,n;e5.lTeJIbHOCTHBY30B.HarrpaBJIeHHH 3ToH ,n;e5.lTeJIbHOCTHCB5.l3aHOC pa3pa60TKoHCOBMeCTHblX 06pa30BaTeJIbHbIXBbICIIIeH IIIKOJIOH,1'13 Ta6JIHU;bI cneztyer,nporpasoreqTO U;HKJIbI (MO,n;YJIH)rrporpaMM3H)l;eHTH"llHbI, 06'beMbI xacon no Y"lle6HbIM nnaaaanpaxrasecxaCOBna)l;aIOT, a3Ha"llHT, He TPe6yIOT 60rrbIIlOM pa60TbI no nepecxorpy nporpaMM 06y-qeHH5I npa3aKrrlO"lleHHHnoroaoposIlpencraanserMe)l(,n;yBY3aMH.npaKTH"lleCKHM mrrepecpearrH30BaHHa5I rtporpaxoaa()l;BOMHbIX) )l;HnrrOMOB, opraHH30BaHHa5I no cornameamo(MOCKBa)H TeXHH"lleCKHM YHHBepCHTeTOM r.Me)l(,n;y Hl1Y «M311.»JIaneeHpaHTa(<1>HHrr5IH,n;H5I).zrsyx ,n;HnrrOMOB,POCCHMCKoroH esponeitcxoro, crynenrsrIloMHMO nonyseuaanonysarorzrsyx[(eHHbIM onsrr npmKHBaHH5I B ,n;pyroM CTPaHe, 6a30BOe 06pa30BaHHe BeBponeMCKOMBY3e, cnoco6CTByIOI.IJ;eeKapbepHOMY POCTYBbIllYCKHHKa.Y6e)l;HTerreH, na MOM ssrnsn, O,n;HHH3 BbIBO,n;OB,n;HccepTaHTa no ttepsojirnase,cornacnopearrsnsrk BKJIa,n;) YHHBepcHTeTa BKOTOPOMY «O[(eHKa (anao6I.IJ;eeneno nOBbIIIIeHM5I ypOBH5I H CTeneHH 06pa30BaHHOCTH B crpaae, ,n;OJl)KHaCTPOHTbC5I nay-rereOTpa)l(alOI.IJ;HX fioneeorpaaasennoro"lleM"llHCrra napaverpoa,HanorroBHHY)l;e5ITerrbHOcTb H ee pe3yrrbTaTHBHocTbBbIpa)l(alOI.IJ;MX HHenocpe,n;cTBeHHyIOBY30BCKyIO(3<p<peKTHBHOCTb)>>.0 nOKa3aTeJI5IX«pe3yrrbTaTHBHOCTHH 3<p<peKTHBHOCTH»cnenyer CKa3aTboco6o.
Brrpovex, BTOPa5Irnasa ,n;HccepTa[(HHHa"llHHaeTC5IHMeHHOC aroro.Bo BTOPOMrrraBe «CpaBHHTerrbHbIM aaanas HHHOBa[(HOHHOMopraaaaauaanpouecca pacnpocTPaHeHH5I 3HaHHM sa pyfiexc»npe,n;cTaBrreHbI pe3yrrbTaTbIaaanasa no opranasanaa BY30B, ,n;HHaMHKeYHHBepCHTeTCKOM,n;e5ITerrbHOcTHKaK BPOCCHH,TaK H aa py6e)l(OM. ,l1,aHaKOrrH"lleCTBeHHa5IH Ka"lleCTBeHHa5IO[(eHKa 3TOM)l;e5ITerrbHocTH. B Ta6rrH"llHOM<popMe rroxasana pafiora POCCHMCKMXHl1Y na <pOHeaHarrOrH"llHOMnesrensaocraIlepe"lleHbnaaoonee3apy6e)l(HbIX YHHBepcHTeToB.Ba)l(HbIX nOKa3aTerreM xaxec'raa06pa30BaTerrbHOM,n;e5ITerrbHOcTHBY30B rrpencrasneaB Tafinaue 8.noxasana Heo6xo,n;HMOCTbynaneananexoropux H3 3THX noxasarenea,,l1,HccepTaHT rroxasanaHC "lleM, Bnpnanane,aenssa He corrraCHTbC5I.
IlpHH[(HnHarrbHo pemeaa ,n;HccepTaHToM HnpooneaaBbI60pa nonxonaMHeHHIO aBTopa,K nonsezteaaro3,n;eCb HeYMecTHbI.HTorOB. Cpezmne BerrH"llHHbI, noCpaBHHBaTbHY)l(HO HeycrroBHbIecOBoKynHocTH nOKa3aTerreM, a HX HaryparrbHbIe BerrH"llHHbI no paH)I(HpOBaHHOMY4cnRCKY.3,necbnOKa3aTeJIeR.CYMeCTHee,CqRTaeT ,nRCCepTaHT, yqeT3TRM TO)l(ecnenyerOnbIT OueHKR xasecrsaBeCOMOCTRrrpezrcrasnenanpO,nyKURR qame npRMeH5IeTC5I B npOMbIIlIJIeHHOCTR.BO BTOPOR rnaseABTOP ,nRccepTaURR pa3pa60TaJIalillY(PRC.OT xanpos,2.1),R3COrJIaCRTbC5I,HeCMOTP5Iaa TO, qTO nO,n06HbIRAHaJIRTRKa npOueCCOB pacnpOCTPaHeHR5I 3HaHRRlillYxaxztoropy6e)l(opRrRHaJIbH)'lOcxesry9-11, 13).RHHoBaURoHHoRcpensrCB5I3aHbI R 3aBRC5IT, npexne scero,OT qRCJIeHHOCTR, yseasrx cTeneHeR R OnJIaTbI rpynaKa,npoBbIR nOTeHURaJI asropPOCCRRCKRMRB ,nOCTaTOqHOM 06'beMe (Ta6JI.npaoparerieB KOTOPOR acesanpeno,naBaTeJIeR.cnpaBe,nJIRBO Ha3BaJIa 5I,nPOMRHHoBaURoHHoRcpensrsysa.BnpasenaCOOTBeTCTBRRC o6meRBCRcTeMYTeMoR HayqHoroHayqHbleRRCCJIe,noBaHR5IfYJIRqeBa06pa30BaTeJIbHbIeYHRBepcRTeTaMR R RX COTPy,nHRKaMR B nponeccaxpy6e)l((PRC.
2.2).PRc.2.3.Tlpa06pa30BaHR5I3TOM06pa30BaTeJIbHORpacnpocrpaaeaas06pa30BaTeJIbHbIXno,nqepKRBaeTC5I,ofiecneaaeascropraHR3aURR,crarycu<l>OpMbI RqTOKOHTaKTbIycnyrcerenueCocymeCTBJI5IlOmRXRHOCTPaHHbIX OpraHR3aURR»RCnOJIb30BaHReM06pa30BaTeJIbH)'lOMe)l(,ny3HaHRRsanpe,ncTaBJIeHbI nalPOPMbIB03MO)l(HOCTb «OCBOeHR5IcrynearaxanporpaMMbIE.r.peaJIR3aURRKOMnJIeKCHORpecypcosHeCKOJIbKRX,ne5ITeJIbHOCTb, B TOM qRCJIeP<I>(<I>e,nepaJIbHbIR 3aKOHOT29,neKa6p5I2012r.NQ273-<1>3).rJIaBa3HaHRRsa3«MexaHR3Mpy6e)l(KaKBHRMaHR5I. 3,necb MHorolillYpeaJIR3aURR cTPaTerRRRHHOBaUROHHa5I nporpaseaa»cnopnoro,TO, nan qeM CTORT3a,nYMaTbC5I.POCCRR,nopacnoocrpaaemno3aCJIY)l(RBaeTHeonpe,neJIeHHOrO, He,noCKa3aHHOrO, HO ecrs RHapany,ne5ITeJIbHOCTRBcymecTBeHHble,nOCTORHCTBa RaBTOpC He,nOCTaTKaMR opraHR3aURRCOBepllIeHHOHaR60JIeeBa)l(Hble,nOCTR)l(eHR5IBbI,neJI5IlOmRe RXnpaR3BeCTHbIMRYHRBepCRTeTaMR.He,nOCTaTKOB,nOCTR)l(eHRR Rrrpeauyurecrn-cpaBHeHRRsenymaxHa3BaJIasenymaxC HaR60JIee60JIbllIe,O,nHaKO ,nOCTRrHYTble npeRMymecTBaBbICllIeR IlIKOJIbI He MeHee lPYH,naMeHTaJIbHbI, qeM BBY30BCKORcnpaBe,nJIRBOPOCCRRCKRX YHRBepCRTeTOB,3apy6e)l(HbIMRoco6oroqeMPOCCRRCKOR3apy6e)l(HbIXBY3ax,5H ,n;OCTHraIOTCHronasra,rornaKaK 60JIbIIIHHCTBO YKa3aHHbIX He,n;OCTaTKOBIIIHPOKO H3BeCTHbI H pafioranoFIX YCTpaHeHHIO Be,n;eTCHKaK na yposneOT,n;eJIbHbIXBY30B, TaK H aa npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOMypoaae.,lVuI ycneuraoapa60TbI, CBH3aHHOHC pacnpOCTPaHeHHeM 3HaHHH sapyfiez«,,n;HccepTaHTKJIaccmlmUHpoBaJIa Ba)l(HeHIIIHe <pyHKUHHHMY B 3TOM HanpaBJIeHHH(Ta6JI.
16). 3Ta KJIaCcH<pHKaUHHonpenensersupaoorxeero cTPaTerHH (ueJIeBOHKOMnJIeKCHOHnporpasoasr).fJIaBHOe 3BeHO B peurenaaHanpaBJIeHHH pacnpocTpaHeHHHnorosopaoti ueasrpeurenae(<nOJIe ,n;eHTeJIbHOCTH»aysa npa,n;JIHMHO)l(eCTBa sanaa sysa H, rrpezcne acero,3HaHHH sa pytiesc,BH,n;HT B npoexre(PHC. 3.2). Ha MOH B3rJIH,n;, 3TO yztaxaoePbIHOqHbIXoTHoIlleHHHBMaTeMaTHKasnecspaapafiorana6JIOK-cxeMY nporpaseorpyeasrx06pa30BaTeJIbHbleasroprozcecosepnrenoyCJIyrHYMecTHa. CC BbIXO,n;OM aansrcnrerocdiepeBH npaBHJIbHOe06pa30BaHHH.3TOH ueJIbIO znrccepraar,n;oroBopHoH uensr napacxeronMaKCHMaJIbHbIH 3KOHOMHqeCKHH(<pHHaHcoBbIH)pe3YJIbTaT.,n:aJIee zraccepraarpaccxrarpnsaer<pHHaHcHpoBaHHH asrcureroPemeaaen10.10.2002CJIO)l(HBIIIHeCHna06pa30BaHHH,BceronaaCOOTBeTCTBHH Cnp06JIeMbIH3BeCTHbIMAKKpe,n;HTaU;HoHHoHKOJIJIerHH MHHHcTepcTBa 06pa30BaHHH P<I> OTNQ 6-2001.TocyzrapcrseaaoroIlpezoreeCMeTHoe<pHHaHcHpoBaHHe BY30BH36IO,n;)I(eTa npaKTHqeCKH YCTynHJIO MeCTO BHe6IO,n;)I(eTHOH,n;eHTeJIbHOCTHBY30B, pa3BHBaeTcH H aafiapaerCHJIY HXnpezmpaaaaarenscsas,n;eHTeJIbHOCTb(Ta6JI.
