ГДЗ-Русский-язык-8-класс-Бархударов-2000 (8 класс - Бархударов)

>hfZrgyyjZ[hlZihjmkkdhfmyaudmaZ deZkkd mq_[gbdm ©JmkkdbcyauddeZkkª;Zjom^Zjh\ K=b ^j F©Ijhk\_s_gb_ª]mq_[ghijZdlbq_kdh_ihkh[b_ , Jmkkdbc yaud Lukyq_e_lby kha^Z\Ze gZjh^ wlh ]b[dh_iurgh_g_bkq_jiZ_fh[h]Zlh_mfgh_ihwlbq_kdh_b ljm^h\h_hjm^b_ k\h_c khpbZevghc `bagb k\h_c fukeb k\hbo qm\kl\ k\hbogZ^_`^k\h_]h]g_\Zk\h_]h\_ebdh]h[m^ms_]h:GLheklhc,, I_j_^ \Zfb ]jhfZ^Z ± jmkkdbc yaud GZkeZ`^_gv_ ]em[hdh_ah\_l\ZkgZkeZ`^_gv_ih]jmablvky\h\kxg_baf_jbfhklv_]hb baeh\blvqm^gu_aZdhgu_]hG<=h]hevH[sZyfukevl_dklh\± \_ebqb_jmkkdh]hyaudZGhqvxyjdh[jh^beih[_j_]mkghiihe_\h]hijh`_dlhjZGhcqvxkeh]ZG ± >g@± kh]ea\l\H ± >h@± ]eZkgm^Q ± >q¶@± kh]e]emofy]dV ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZX ± >c¶@kh]ea\fy]d± >m@]eZkg[_am^[md\a\mdh\,;jh^beqlh^_eZe"± ]eZ]heGn± [jh^blv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j_f_gb\ _^qbke_\ fm`j,,,Kghiqlh^_eZe"[jh^beIhe_\h]hihe_kmnnnbdkZevguckihkh[Ghqvx kmsyjdh gZj_q[jh^be ]eihij_^e[_j_]m kmskghi kmsihe_\h]h ijbeijh`_dlhjZkmsIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkljZkijhkljYaudh\Zykbkl_fZJZa^_egZmdbh yaud_Yaudh\u__^bgbpu=jZnbdZNhg_lbdZA\mdbHjnh]jZnby Keh\hh[jZah\Zgb_ AgZqbfu_qZklbkeh\ZKihkh[ukeh\hh[jZah\ZgbyE_dkbdheh]byKeh\ZNjZa_heh]byNjZa_heh]bq_kdbch[hjhlFhjnheh]byQZklbj_qbb bonhjfuImgdlmZpby KbglZdkbkKeh\hkhq_lZgb_OIjhklh_ij_^eh`_gb_> @Keh`gh_ij_^eh`_gb_>@b >@Iha^gyy hk_gv=jZqbme_l_ebE_kh[gZ`bekyiheyhimkl_ebLhevdhg_k`ZlZihehkdZh^gZ=jmklgmx ^mfmgZ\h^blhgZG:G_djZkh\Iha^gyy± [md\a\mdh\ihke_^gyyY ± a\mdZcZHk_gv± [md\a\mdZdjhf_v=jmklgmx± [md\a\mdh\X ihke_]eZkghc± a\mdZcmGb\uk`Zlujhsb]heuHl\h^ulmfZg b kujhklvDhe_khfaZkbgb ]hjuKhegp_ lboh_kdZlbehkvK?k_gbgK`Zlu± [md\a\mdh\LmfZg± [md\a\mdh\Khegp_± [md\a\mdh\Jbnfmme_l_ebhimkl_eb h[jZam_lkhq_lZgb_a\mdh\>l¶we¶u@h^gZhgZ >gZ@]heu]hju >euju@kujhklvkdZlbehkv >Zkl¶Zk¶@=eZkgu_>Z@>h@>m@>w@>u@>b@L\_j^u_>i@>n@>d@>l@>k@>o@>r@>p@A\mdbKh]eZkgu_=emob_>i@>n@>d@>l@>r@>k@>o@>p@>q@>s@Fy]db_>i¶@>n¶@>d¶@>l¶@>k¶@>o¶@>q¶@>s¶@A\hgdb_>[@>\@>]@>^@>`@>a@>c@>e@>f@>g@>j@L\_j^u_>[@>\@>]@>^@>`@>a@>e@>f@>g@>j@Fy]db_>[¶@>\¶@>]¶@>^¶@>c¶@>a¶@>e¶@>f¶@>j¶@>g¶@ M]hevm]he>ee¶@ ahjvdbahjdb>j¶j@ jZ^jhl>Zh@ jZ^jy^>jj¶@ jh\jz\>jj¶@ [jZl[jh^>Zh@ jy^y^>j¶c¶@ dex\dexq>nq¶@ RmjZXjZ>rc¶@ `_kl_kl>`c¶@ghqmxldhqmxl>gd@dmzlihzl>dmiZ@A\mdh\ [hevr_ q_f [md\ y^ XjZ _kl ghqmxl dhqmxl dm_lih_l;md\uvyx_z kem`Zl^eyh[hagZq_gbyfy]dhklbij_^u^msbokh]eZkguo@_e_agh^hjh`gucjZat_a^\hjhgv_ ]g_a^hh[tzf rZjZ\v_lky gZ^ djur_c [vxlky h kdZeu g_h[tylguc ijhklhj \_jgu_ ^jmavyrvxl dhklxfiv_l \h^mi_kljucrZjnihkeZlvdmjv_jZhlkh_^bgblv ijh\h^ ij_^ty\blv ^hdmf_glu ih^t_oZlv d [_j_]m qvblhke_^u kheh\vbgu_ lj_eb \vxsb_ky jZkl_gby jZamqb\Zlv i_kgbh[yaZl_evgh_ mkeh\b_ ij_^tx[be_cgZy ih^]hlh\dZ kwdhghfblvkj_^kl\ZIjZ\beh jZa^_ebl_evguc l\_j^uc b fy]dbc agZdb T ibr_lkyihke_ijbklZ\dbi_j_^dhjg_fV ± \ dhjg_JZa^_ebl_evgu_T bV mdZau\ZxlgZgZebqb_i_j_^]eZkgufa\mdZ>c¶@ J_^dh_ y\e_gb_ ± f_ldh_ keh\h [jhkdbc p\_l ± ^_jadbc hl\_lab]aZ] fhegbb± ijb]hjh^guc\hdaZeQm^_kguci_caZ`± q_klgucihklmihd\eZklguc\a]ey^± hiZkgucih\hjhl]mklu_j_kgbpu jh\_kgbdb kugZ ± gZrb k\_jklgbdb IeZlblv aZ d\Zjlbjm ±kiehlblv jy^u ihk\_lblv nhgZj_f ± ihk\ylblv \ k\hb ieZgu ^jm`_kdZydhfiZgby± m[hjhqgZydZfiZgby<u^_e_ggu_[md\uh[hagZqZxlh^bgZdh\u_a\mdbIjZ\beZ[_am^Zjgmx]eZkgmx\ dhjg_keh\Zfh`ghijh\_jblvih^h[jZ\ h^ghdhj_ggh_ keh\h \ dhlhjhf gZ wlm ]eZkgmx iZ^Z_lm^Zj_gb_g_ykgmxbebg_ijhbaghkbfmxkh]eZkgmx\ dhjg_keh\Zfh`gh ijh\_jblv ih^h[jZ\ h^ghdhj_ggh_ keh\h \ dhlhjhf ihke_wlhckh]eZkghcklhbl]eZkgZyG_ijh\_jy_fu_ \hdaZe ± ijb\hdaZevguc j_kgbpu ± j_kgbqdZjh\_kgbdb ± jh\_kgbpZ k\_jklgbdb ± k\_jklgbpZ dhfiZgby ± dhfiZg_ckdbcdZfiZgbyKeh\hkhq_lZgbyjh\_kgbdfZfu[uebk\_jklgbdZfbKdbgmehdZnlZg a_e_guce_lhHlk\bkl_eb`Z\hjhgdb\keZklvHk_gv\ rm[m `_elmxh^_lZIhe_kZfk f_l_edhxijhreZkvQlh[\hreZjZqbl_evghcohaycdhc< kg_`gu_e_kgu_l_j_fZS_]heboZ\ [_ehcjZae_lZcd_±JmkkdZyjmfygZyabfZ>D_^jbgIjZ\beh gZibkZgb_ [_am^Zjguo ]eZkguo \ dhjg_ keh\Z ijh\_jy_lkym^Zj_gb_f<u^_e_ggu_keh\Zmihlj_[e_gu\ i_j_ghkghfagZq_gbbdZnlZgrm[Z± ebkl\Zl_j_fZ± e_k@_elmx ± ke<hreZ¶ ± ke` ± >`@± kh]ea\l\\ ± >\@± kh]ea\l\z ± >h@± ]em^h ± >Z@± ]e[_am^e ± >e@± kh]ea\l\r ± >r@± kh]e]emol\l ± >l@± kh]e]emol\e ± >e@± kh]ea\l\m ± >m@± ]e[_am^Z ± >Z@± ]em^x ± >c¶@± kh]ea\fy]d[md\a\± >m@± ]e[_am^[md\a\Baebrgyyjhkdhrv]jm[Zyeh`vijZ\^b\Zyj_qv[_kdhjuklgZy ihfhsv [_j_qv \j_fy m\e_qvky kihjlhf qblZ_rv dgb]m eh\brv ju[m dmiZ_rvky \ fhj_ hlj_`v oe_[Z kt_rv kmi gZagZqvl_^_`mjguoEh`v± keh]J_qv± keh]e ± >e@± kh]ea\l\j ± >j¶@± kh]ea\fy]dh ± >h@± ]em^_ ± >w@± ]em^` ± >r@± kh]e]emol\q ± >q¶@± kh]e]emofy]dv ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZv ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZ[md\ua\mdZ[md\ua\mdZKt_rv± keh]k ± >k@± kh]e]emol\t ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZ_ ± >c¶@± kh]ea\fy]d± >w@± ]em^r ± >r@± kh]e]emol\v ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZ[md\a\V \\u^_e_gguokeh\ZoibrmlihijZ\beZfV ibr_lkyKms_kl\kdehg_gby^hqv< ]eZ]heZoih_rv[_j_qvGZj_qbygZR bQ gZkl_`vijhqvgZhlfZrv , DZijhgh\uc ieZs baysgZy \_sv ]hj_qv h[b^u jy^ g_m^Zq djmlhc \bjZ` e_]dZy ^jh`v ihqm\kl\h\Zlv nZevrv bkihegblv lmr q_jgZy lmrv fhjha `]mq jZa`_qv dhkl_j ij_^hkl_j_qvhlhrb[dbg_fgh]hjZa\e_qvkyZddmjZlghih^kljbqvkymclbijhqvm^ZjblvgZhlfZrvmiZklvgZ\agbqvg_[h\k_kiehrv\ lmqZo\aylvj_\Zgrg_gm`gZyjhkdhrv[_j_qvg_h[oh^bfu_\_sbgZkl_`vhldjulv ^\_jb ih^j_`vl_ \_ldb kbj_gb m\e_qvky ql_gb_f hdZaZlvi_j\mxihfhsvjZ^hklvg_h`b^Zgguo\klj_q,, Ey`_rv kiZlv ihjZgvr_ Z mljhf ihlbohgvdm \klZg_rv mfh_rvky ih[_`brv gZ j_qdm AZdbg_rv m^hqdm b h`b^Z_rv de_\ZQmlv aZ[m^_rvky aZ^j_fe_rv ± kfhljbrvZ q_j\ydZm`g_lH[b^gh ohlv ieZqv JZkk_j^brvky ihlhf \havf_rv b gZkZ^brv gh\mxijbfZgdmKgh\Z`^_rvMihlj_[e_gb_V ihke_rbiysboV ibr_lkyV g_ibr_lkyKms_kl\kdehg_gby^hqv Kms_kl\g_kdehg_gbybeb\hfgh`qbke_ieZsfgh]hlmq< ]eZ]heZoih_rv[_j_qvDjZldb_ijbeZ]Zl_evgu_iZomqGZj_qbygZR bQ gZkl_`v GZj_qbygZ@ djhf_gZkl_`v @_el__l ihki_\ZxsZy jh`v ;ukljh khog_l ljZ\ZIjhoh^blqZk ^jm]hcDhexqbfagh_fiur_lg_ih^\b`guc\ha^moBKLmj]_g_\Hkgh\ukhklhylbaijbklZ\dbdhjgyb kmnnbdkZ , JZa\_\Zxsbc ieZfy \_l_j jZa\b\Zlv kdhjhklv kfheblveu`baZdj_iblviZjmkZaZkdjbi_lvam[Zfbhl[hebijbf_jylvieZlv_ijbfbjylvijhlb\gbdh\h[t_^bgylvex^_c,, BaeZ]Zlv ijhkv[m \eh`blv ibkvfh \ dhg\_jl jZkiheh`_gb_dhfgZl hklhjh`gh_ ijbdhkgh\_gb_ dZkZlvky jmdhc klheZ kbevghm]hj_lv aZ]hj_euc kihjlkf_g aZjhkeb fh``_\_evgbdZ aZjZklbljZ\hcklZjrbc\hajZkl\ujhk \ ^_j_\g_\ujZs_ggZyjZkkZ^Zjhbkdekldb gh\h]h kl_j_lv aZibkv gZlbjZlv ihe jZkkl_eblv dh\_jaZibjZlv d\Zjlbjm [e_kl_lv hl jhku kh[bjZlv mjh`ZcaZf_j_lvgZf]gh\_gb_jZa`b]Zlvdhkl_j;md\uijhims_gu\ dhjg_keh\< i_j\hcqZklb[_am^ZjgZy]eZkgZy\ dhjg_keh\Z<h\lhjhcqZklbq_j_^mxsb_ky]eZkgu_\ dhjg_keh\ZAZdj_iblv± aZ[_`ZlvijbklZ\dZ± dhj_gv± kmnnbdkIZjmkZ± fhj_dhj_gvIjhkv[m± [hjv[Zdhj_gvkmnnbdkAZ]hj_euc± aZ[he_\rbcijbklZ\dZ± dhj_gv± kmnnbdkAZdj_iblv± aZ[_`Zlvdj_idbcmlheblvAZdj_iblviZjmkZh[t_^bgylvkbevghaZ]hj_euc , RzjkldZ r_jklv `zeluc `_elh\Zluc r_iq_l rzihlqzegq_eghdsz]hevs_]heylv^_rz\uc,, Gh`hgdZ gh`_gvdb eh^qhgdZ j_q_gvdZ \heqhghd i_lmrhd]hjhr_d djxqhd i_khq_d ohesh\uc dhq_\hc ghq_\dZ dhjqz\dZ\hafmszgguc jZah``zgguc dhiqzguc mqzguc ]hjyqh kihjblv]jhfq_ ]h\hjblv,,, KZjZgqhc \jZqhf dZjZg^Zrhf qm`hc [hevrh]h k\_`_]hi_qzlkl_j_`zl``zljZah``zlH ± , ?ihke_rbiysbo,;_am^Zj_gby± ?,,Ih^m^Zj_gb_f< dhjg_keh\Z± ,< kmnnbdkZob hdhgqZgbyo]eZ]heh\± ,< kmnnbdkZob hdhgqZgbyog_]eZ]heh\± H Ih^iju]gmlv ± iju]gmlv ijb]hjh^ ± ]hjh^ g_aZ\bkbfuc ±aZ\bkbfuc± ijbklZ\hqguckihkh[=blZjbkl ± ]blZjZ \_k_ggbc ± \_kgZ lZgp_\Zlv ± lZg_p ± kmnnbdkZevguckihkh[Khljm^gbd ± ljm^ ih^a_fguc ± a_fey \a]jmklgmlv ± ]jmklv ±ijbklZ\hqghkmnnbdkZevgucOe_[haZ\h^± oe_[aZ\h^keh`_gb_hkgh\k ihfhsvxkh_^bgbl_evghc]eZkghcF=M Fhkdh\kdbc =hkm^Zjkl\_gguc Mgb\_jkbl_l \ma \ukr__mq_[gh_aZ\_^_gb_± keh`_gb_khdjZs_gguohkgh\AZjieZlZ ± aZjZ[hlgZy ieZlZ kihjldem[ ± kihjlb\guc dem[ ±keh`_gb_qZkl_chkgh\keh\[_akh_^bgbl_evguo]eZkguo?klvlZd`_[_kkmnnbdkguckihkh[a_e_gv± a_e_gucb i_j_oh^h^ghcqZklbj_qb\ ^jm]mxjy^h\hc[h_pjy^h\hcbakhk_^g_cqZklb± ijbeZ]\ kms_kl\M^Zjgbdbhk_ggbckmnnbdkZevguckihkh[Ih^[_`Zlvg_m^ZqZijbklZ\hqguckihkh[JZat_oZlvkygZiZjgbdijbklZ\hqghkmnnbdkZevguc @_e_ah[_lhg Zlhfhoh^ keh`_gb_ hkgh\ k ihfhsvx kh_^]eZkghcH<_a^_oh^ime_f_lkeh`_gb_hkgh\k ihfhsvxkh_^]eZkghc?=heh\hdjm`bl_evguckeh`_gb_hkgh\k h^gh\j_f_ggufijbkh_^bg_gb_fkmnnbdkZIjbIjbdhkgmlvky g_ihegh_ ^_ckl\b_ ijbfhjv_ [ebahklv ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ ijbkh_^bg_gb_ ijb\b^_gb_ agZq_gb_ g_ykgh ijbemgblvky ijbkh_^bg_gb_ ijbaZ^mfZlvky g_ihegh_ ^_ckl\b_ ijb[j_`guc[ebahklvd [_j_]mijb\yaZgghklvijbkh_^bg_gb_Ij_Ij_fm^juc hq_gv ij_\hkoh^guc hq_gv ij_klmie_gb_ i_j_ij_djZkguchq_gvij_\hafhqvi_j_?keb ijbklZ\dZ h[hagZqZ_l ijbkh_^bg_gb_ ijb[eb`_gb_ [ebahklvbebg_ihegh_^_ckl\b_lhwlhijbklZ\dZijb?keb ijbklZ\dZ [ebadZ ih agZq_gbx d keh\m hq_gv beb d ijbklZ\d_i_j_ lhwlhijbklZ\dZij_qbdJ_aqbdkfZaqbdh[t_a^qbdjZkkdZaqbdi_j_[_`qbdih^ghkqbdjZd_lqbdi_j_ibkqbd± sbdQ_dZgsbdh[fZgsbd[he_evsbd]hgsbdH[s__ agZq_gb_ kmnnbdkh\ ± h[hagZq_gb_ ex^_c ih oZjZdl_jmboaZgylbcbeb^_ckl\bcIjZ\beh m kms_kl\bl_evguo h[hagZqZxsbo ex^_c ih oZjZdl_jm bo aZgylbc beb ^_ckl\bc ihke_ kh]eZkguo ^ l a k ` ibr_lkykmnnbdkqbdihke_^jm]bokh]eZkguosbd Z ijbklZ\db mkljZgblv [_kihjy^hd ij_^uklhjby jhfZgZ[_ahiZkguc i_j_oh^ k\_joqm\kl\bl_evgZy ie_gdZ k]j_klb k_ghjZkklZ\blv f_[_ev jZkkqblZlv klhbfhklv j_fhglZ bat_a^blv \kxkljZgmbkljZlblv^_gv]b[ kmnnbdku mklZeuc ]jmaqbd fheh^hc dZf_gsbd ebfhggucgZiblhd dh`ZgZy kmfdZ dexd\_gguc fhjk klZjbgguc dh\_j gbadh_ ihf_s_gb_ fZljhkkdbc lZg_p njZgpmakdbc yaud ^hdeZ^u\ZlvdhfZg^bjm mqZkl\h\Zlv \ khklyaZgbb q_kl\h\Zlv ih[_^bl_e_c qm\kl\h\ZlvjZ^hklv\ ijbklZ\db b kmnnbdku \ufulv ih^hdhggbd [_ah[eZqguc^_gvgZkl_ggucdZe_g^ZjvijbfhjkdbciZjd]kh_^bgbl_evgu_]eZkgu_H b?e_khkieZ\djZ_\_^a_jghojZgbebs_ a_fe_mkljhckl\h i_r_oh^guc k_evkdhohayckl\_gguc nZ[jbqghaZ\h^kdhc `_elhdjueuc `_elhdjZkguc ]hem[h\Zlhk_jucg_f_pdhjmkkdbck\_lehkbgbcIj_^uklhjby± bklhjbyijbklZ\hqguc;_kihjy^hd ± ihjy^hdijbklZ\hqguc=jmaqbd ± ]jmakmnnbdkZevgucNjZgpmakdbc± njZgpmakmnnbdkZevguc Ijba_feblvky ijbkh_^bg_gb_ \ kl_ib ijbhldjulv ^\_jvg_ihegh_ ^_ckl\b_ ij_j\Zlv i_j_]h\hju i_j_ ijbkh_^bgblvkyd [_k_^_ ijbkh_^bg_gb_ijbaZ^mfZlvkygZ^dgb]hcg_ihegh_^_ckl\b_ ij_\ukblv i_j_ ghjfm ijb\hdaZevgZy iehsZ^v [ebahklvd \hdaZemij_kf_rgh_hq_gvijbdexq_gb_ij_h^he_lvij_iylkl\b_ij_g_[j_]ZlvhiZkghklvxi_j_^Zlvijb\_lh[tykgblvijbqbgmhiha^Zgbyij_h[jZah\Zgb_i_j_a_feb?keb ijbklZ\dZ h[hagZqZ_l ijbkh_^bg_gb_ ijb[eb`_gb_ [ebahklvbebg_ihegh_^_ckl\b_lhwlhijbklZ\dZijb?keb ijbklZ\dZ [ebadZ ih agZq_gbx d keh\m hq_gv beb d ijbklZ\d_i_j_lhwlhijbklZ\dZij_ AZk_^Zgb_ ij_ab^bmfZ mdZa ij_ab^_glZ ijbhjbl_l \ jZkkfhlj_gbb \hijhkZbf_lvijb\be_]bb GZb[he__ baf_gqb\uf \ yaud_ y\ey_lky keh\Zjguc khklZ\Keh\Zjguc khklZ\ yaudZ [uklj__ \k_]h j_Z]bjm_l gZ \k_ baf_g_gby\ ijhba\h^kl\_b \^jm]bokn_jZoh[s_kl\_gghc`bagb<<<bgh]jZ^h\J_Z]bjm_l± hl\_qZ_lhlau\Z_lkyKn_ju± h[eZklbmqZkldbk_]f_glu<ukdZaZggmx \ l_dkl_ fukev ih^l\_j`^Z_l ihy\e_gb_ \ gZr_fyaud_ gh\uo keh\ ± dhfivxl_j dehgbjh\Zgb_ ]_ggZy bg`_g_jbyk_j\_j^hf_gb l^GZmqgucklbevldbkihevam_l ki_pbZevgu_keh\Z\ujZ`Z_lj_amevlZlubkke_^h\Zl_evkdhc^_yl_evghklbGbq_]hg_kdZaZeZju[dZebrvo\hklhfih\h^_ie_kgmeZb mreZ \ ]em[hdh_fhj_=em[hdh_ fheqZgb_pZjkl\h\Zeh djm]hfIjhr_e ^h`^v ^Z _s_ kh rd\Zehf b hk\_`be Zlfhkn_jm GZjZa\blb_ dZ`^h]h q_eh\_dZ bf__l \ebygb_ \ky h[s_kl\_ggZy Zlfhkn_jZ\ dhlhjhc_fmkm`^_gh`blv=em[hdh_ fhj_ ± keh\h ]em[hdbc \ agZq_gbb ©ijhly`_gguc beb^Ze_dhjZkiheh`_gguc\ gZijZ\e_gbbk\_jom\gbaª=em[hdh_ fheqZgb_ ± keh\h ]em[hdbc \ agZq_gbb ©^hklb]rbciheghluk\h_]hijhy\e_gby\ukr_]hij_^_eZª:lfhkn_jZ± ]Zahh[jZagZyh[hehqdZhdjm`ZxsZyA_fexb g_dhlhju_^jm]b_ieZg_luH[s_kl\_ggZyZlfhkn_jZ± hdjm`Zxsb_mkeh\byh[klZgh\dZKeh\Z dhlhju_ bf_xl g_kdhevdh e_dkbq_kdbo agZq_gbc gZau\Zxlkyfgh]hagZqgufbgZijbf_j]j_[_gv± wlhb ij_^f_l^eyjZkq_ku\Zgby\hehkb \_jrbgZ]hjub \_jo\hegub fykbklucgZjhklgZ]heh\_m i_lmoZLbrbgZg_[hb kl_ivB \hl\ wlhc[_kij_^_evghckl_ibex^bkha^Zebdhkfh^jhf< ghqvk gZZij_ey]fug_kiZeb< qZkZgZqZebkvaZdexqbl_evgu_ijh\_jdb\k_o kbkl_fdhjZ[eyLhqgh ih ]jZnbdm ihy\ey_lky Z\lh[mk k dhkfhgZ\lZfb b ijb[eb`Z_lkyihqlbd kZfhcjZd_l_ghkbl_exXjbc:e_dk__\bqih^oh^bld ]jmii_jmdh\h^bl_e_cbih^g_kyjmdmd ]_jfhre_fm^hdeZ^u\Z_l± Lh\Zjbs ij_^k_^Zl_ev =hkm^Zjkl\_gghc dhfbkkbb klZjrbce_cl_gZgl=Z]Zjbgd ihe_lmgZi_j\hf\ fbj_dhkfbq_kdhfdhjZ[e_©<hklhdª]hlh\Ih:B\Zgh\m< l_dkl_]h\hjblkyh i_j\hfihe_l_q_eh\_dZ\ dhkfhkGh\u_ keh\Z dhlhju_ ihy\eyxlky \ yaud_ gZau\Zxlky g_heh]bafZfbL_dklhlghkblkyd im[ebpbklbq_kdhfmklbexKl_iv± keh]k ± >k@± kh]e]emol\l ± >l¶@± kh]e]emofy]d_ ± >w@± ]eZkgm^i ± >i¶@± kh]e]emofy]dv ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mda\mdZ[md\Ghqv± keh]g ± >g@± kh]ea\l\h ± >h@± ]eZkgm^q ± >q¶@± kh]e]emofy]dv ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZa\mdZ[md\u JZa \ gZqZe_ hk_gb DbjbeZ I_ljh\bq kh[bjZeky \ hlt_a`__ihe_ GZdZgmg_ [ue hl^Zg ijbdZa ikZjyf b klj_fygguf [ulv ]hlh\ufb d iylb qZkZf mljZ IZeZldZ b dmogy hlijZ\e_gu [ueb \i_j_^gZf_klh]^_DbjbeZI_ljh\bq^he`_g[ueh[_^ZlvOhaybgb ]hklbihrebgZikZjguc^\hj]^_[he__iylbkhl]hgqbob [hjauo`beb\^h\hevkl\_b l_ie_ijhkeZ\eyys_^jhklvDbjbeZI_ljh\bqZgZk\h_f kh[Zqv_f yaud_ Lml `_ gZoh^beky b eZaZj_l ^ey [hevguo kh[Zdih^ ijbkfhljhf rlZ[e_dZjy Lbfhrdb DbjbeZ I_ljh\bq ]hj^beky kbf ij_djZkguf aZ\_^_gb_f b gbdh]^Z g_ mimkdZe kemqZy iho\ZklZlvkyhguf i_j_^k\hbfb]hklyfbbadhbodZ`^uchkfZljb\Ze_]hihdjZcg_cf_j_m`_\ ^\Z^pZlucjZa:KImrdbgG_evay ih^h[jZlv kbghgbfu d l_f keh\Zf dhlhju_ h[hagZqZxllZdb_ ij_^f_lu b ihgylby dhlhju_ m`_ g_ ijbkmlkl\mxl \ `bagbkh\j_f_gguo ex^_c l_ kh\k_f mklZj_eb Wlh lZdb_ keh\Z dZdhlt_a`__ihe_klj_fyggu_ikZjbikZjguc^\hjFh`ghih^h[jZlvkbghgbfueZaZj_l± [hevgbpZrlZ[e_dZjv±\jZq\_l_jbgZjkbf± wlbfhguf± bfdhbo± dhlhjuo IZ\_e =Z\jbeh\bq gZr lj_lbc rlmjfZg aZklmibe gZ \ZolmHd_Zg hg agZ_l emqr_ q_f y k\hx mebpm B qmlv eb g_ gZ dZ`^mxlhqdmhd_ZgZ mg_]hijbiZk_gZbklhjby± <hllml± hgluq_ldZjZg^Zrhf\ dZjlm± \ ijhrehf]h^m\ueh\bebh]jhfgmxZdmemLZd\hlwlZZdmeZba\_jgmeZkvb ijh]ehlbeZ\_^jhk dZjlhrdhc<k_ohohqmlZ ih\ZjgZrqmlvg_j_\zlDZjlhrdm^\ZqZkZqbklbeZ hgZ_z ± ohib \fhf_glkehiZeZ: \hllmlih^h[jZeb ju[ZdZiZimZkZ \ iZjrb\_gvdhc eh^qhgd_ Rlhjf jZau]jZekygm_]hb ihlZsbeh\ hldjuluchd_ZgIhDGbdbl_gdhL_dklhlghkblkyd im[ebpbklbq_kdhfmklbexk we_f_glZfbjZa]h\hjgh]hLuq_l± mdZau\Z_lohohqml± kf_xlkyj_\_l± ieZq_lohi± jZakehiZeZ± kt_eZju[ZdiZimZk± lma_f_piZjrb\_gvdZy± mleZyihlZsbeh± ihg_kehOheh^fhjhaklm`Zh[s__± oheh^gZyih]h^ZjZaebqby±kl_i_gv oheh^Z ohl_lv klj_fblvky `Z`^Zlv h[s__ ± `_eZlvqlheb[hjZaebqby± [hevrZybebf_gvrZykl_i_gv`_eZgby \_`eb\uc ex[_aguc ^_ebdZlguc h[s__ ± \hkiblZgghklvjZaebqby ± jZagu_ klhjhgu \ujZ`_gby \hkiblZgghklb hrb[dZhiehrghklv ijhfZo h[s__ ± g_ijZ\bevgh_ ^_ckl\b_ jZaebqby ±g_ijZ\bevgh_ ^_ckl\b_ \ jZaguo dZq_kl\Zo \eZ`guc fhdjuckujhch[s__± ijhiblZgguc\h^hcjZaebqby± [hevrZybebf_gvrZykl_i_gv\eZ`ghklbaZ]hj_lvky\kiuogmlvaZiueZlvh[s__± ihjZ`_gb_ h]g_f jZaebqby ± jZaebqgZy ijbjh^Z \hagbdgh\_gby\ha]hjZgby\_k_ggbc\_rgbch[s__± \j_fy]h^Z\_kgZjZaebqby ± [he__ beb f_g__ ebl_jZlmjgh ^mfZlv fukeblv jZafureylv h[s__ ± fukebl_evguc ijhp_kk jZaebqby ± jZagZy kl_i_gv]em[bgufukebl_evgh]hijhp_kkZGZmebp_r_efhdjuckg_]?kebghkm kh[Zdb\eZ`gucb oheh^gucwlhagZqblqlhhgZa^hjh\Z<kxhk_gvklhyeZkujZyb ijhfha]eZyih]h^ZLy`zeZyb kbevgZyju[Z[jhkbeZkvih^[_j_]Y gZqZe\u\h^blv_z gZqbklmx\h^mIZmkl± LbrbgdjbqZeqlhhg\u\_^_lgZ qbklmx \h^m \k_o o\Zklmgh\ b aZagZ_d Hk__\Z >_eZcl_ dZdohlbl_DhgklZglbg:e_dk__\bqy mfu\Zxjmdb<u[m^_l_hl\_qZlvaZ \kz Kl_iZgh\ ± B\Zg Bevbq klZe mfu\Zlvky Hg k hl^uohfmfuejmdbebph\uqbklbeam[uEL<u\_klbgZqbklmx\h^m± jZah[eZqblvh[fZgjZkdmkblvY mfu\Zxjmdb± i_j_klZlvijbgbfZlvmqZklb_\ dZdhfeb[hf_jhijbylbb\uclbbab]juhlkljZgblvkyNjZa_heh]baf ± wlh mklhcqb\h_ khq_lZgb_ keh\ bkihevam_fh_^ey gZa\Zgby hl^_evguo ij_^f_lh\ ijbagZdh\ ^_ckl\bc E_dkbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_ bf__l njZa_heh]baf \ p_ehf gZijbf_j [blv [Zdemrb± ©[_a^_evgbqZlvªNjZa_heh]baf\ ij_^eh`_gbby\ey_lkyh^gbfqe_ghfij_^eh`_gby NjZa_heh]bafu bkihevamxlky \ h[u^_gghc j_qb \ om^h`_kl\_gguo ijhba\_^_gbyo \ im[ebpbklbd_ Hgb ijb^Zxl \ukdZau\Zgbx\ujZabl_evghklvkem`Zlkj_^kl\hfkha^Zgbyh[jZaghklbK_j^p_m g_]hklmqZehlZddZd[m^lhhgijh[_`Ze\h\_kv^mo jZa]h\hjguc klbev g_kdhevdh \zjkl E L GZ aZ\h^_ EmdZrbgm ihgjZ\behkv k i_j\h]h \a]ey^Z jZa]h\hjguc klbev IZg H^gh aZjm[b k_[_ gZ ghkm jZa]h\hjguc klbev \u^_j`db l_[_gZ^hih[hevr_IhiIh^hjh]_\ <zr_gkdmxhgbaZ]h\hjbebhkha^Z\r_fky iheh`_gbb b hq_gv [ukljhgZrebh[sbcyauddgb`guc klbev Rhe Bamp_e_\rbo[jz\_ggZkdhjmxjmdmjZa]h\hjguc klbev kdhehlbeb ba[zgdm ihdjueb _z lzkhf L AZ^meoheh^guc\_l_jjZa\_jaebkvoey[bg_[_kgu_dgb`gucklbevj_dbaZlhibeb em]Z b ^hjh]b Q KemqZc ^hklZ\be fg_ \hafh`ghklvhl^Zlvihke_^gbc^he]dgb`gucklbevk\h_fmlh\ZjbsmLDgb`guc klbev ± \haghkblv ^h g_[_k i_lv ^bnbjZf[u kuiZlvdZdba jh]Zbah[beby_]hZobee_kh\ZiylZJZa]h\hjguc klbev ± aZdZ^uqguc ^jm] f_^\_`vy mkem]Z \lZilu\Zlv\ ]jyavahehlu_jmdb\h^blvaZghkEhfZlv]heh\mgZ^aZ^Zq_cjZ[hlZlvkimklyjmdZ\Z ljm^blvky g_ ihdeZ^Zy jmd kh\k_f miZklv ^mohf ^_eZlv ba fmob kehgZmf_lv ^_j`Zlv yaud aZ am[Zfb\uclb ba k_[y kh[jZlvky gZ kdhjmxjmdm ^_eZlv kdj_iyk_j^p_ihklZ\blv\ lmibdL_fZaZsblujh^ghca_febdjZkghcihehkhcijhoh^blq_j_agZrb[uebgu;h[qbgkdbcb >h[qbgkdbchdZaZeb]hjh^gbq_fm f_^\_`vx mkem]m ;hevrmx jhev \ ijhba\_^_gbyo gZjh^gh]hl\hjq_kl\Z b]jZxl ihklhyggu_ wibl_lu Iheyjgu_ klZgpbb \g_keb[hevrhc\deZ^\ hk\h_gb_:jdlbdb <u gbdh]^Z g_ \b^_eb dZd kbgbqdZ ieyr_l" KgZqZeZ y kZf^mfZeqlhlZdh_[u\Z_llhevdh\ kdZad_H^gZ`^u hdheh \hkvfb qZkh\ mljZ \ur_e y gZ mebpm b hklZgh\bekym djuevpZ:odZdh_g_h[udgh\_gghyjdh_\ukhdh_[uehg_[h gZ^ ]heh\hc Y ihex[h\Zekyg_[hfb \^jm]mkeurZem^b\bl_evgmx ilbqvx i_k_gdm >h]Z^Zeky qlh ihzl kbgbpZdmag_qbd =^_ `_hgZ" Y hdbgme \a]ey^hf \ukhdb_ lhihey b m\b^_e ilbqdm gZ ^ebgghf]hehfkmdmGhg_khreZebhgZk mfZ"KbgbqdZiju]ZeZ\^hevkmqdZ ih\hjZqb\ZeZkv \ \ha^mo_ djm]hf Lhevdh o\hkl f_evdZe B\kz\j_fygZi_\ZeZ©PuibpuibpuibpuibªIhGGbdhgh\mKZfhklhyl_evgu_ qZklb j_qb Bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ ± kbgbqdZ g_[h Bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ ± yjdh_ \ukhdh_ Bfy qbkebl_evgh_ ± \hkvfb F_klhbf_gb_ ± \u y kZf =eZ]he± ieyr_l^mfZeGZj_qb_± kgZqZeZh^gZ`^uKem`_[gu_ qZklb j_qb Ij_^eh]± \gZgZ^Khxa± bgh QZklbpZ± ebg_<u^_e_ggufrjbnlhf\ l_dkl_h[hagZq_guf_`^hf_lbyF_`^hf_lb_± hkh[ZyqZklvj_qbdhlhjZy\ujZ`Z_lghg_gZau\Z_l jZaebqgu_ qm\kl\Z b ih[m`^_gby F_`^hf_lby g_ \oh^yl gb \kZfhklhyl_evgu_ gb \ kem`_[gu_ qZklb j_qb F_`^hf_lby g_ baf_gyxlkyb g_y\eyxlkyqe_gZfbij_^eh`_gby,Ieyr_lqlh^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]heGN± ieykZlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qbke_\ ebp_,,,KbgbqdZqlh^_eZ_l"ieyr_l,< kdZad_\ q_f"± kms_kl\Gn± kdZadZ,,Ihkl± g_h^mrgZjbp`jh^kdeG_ihkl± \ ij_^eiZ^_`_\ _^qbke_,,,;u\Z_l]^_"\ kdZad_,M^b\bl_evgmxi_k_gdm± ijbeZ]Gn± m^b\bl_evguc,,Ihkl± dZq_kl\G_ihkl± \ _^qbke_\ `jh^_\ \bgiZ^_`_,,,I_k_gdmdZdmx"m^b\bl_evgmxImrdbgkdZyIkdh\sbgZImrdbgkdbc ijbeZ] fma_caZih\_^gbd kms_kl\ gZ Ikdh\sbg_ kms_kl\ ± i_j\uc f_fhjbZevguc ijbeZ] imrdbgkdbcijbeZ]fma_ckms_kl\\ gZr_ckljZg_kms_kl\Hg[uehkgh\Zg[he__k_fb^_kylbe_lkms_kl\lhfmgZaZ^fZjlZkms_kl\]h^Zkms_kl\FboZceh\kdh_ ijbeZ] Ljb]hjkdh_ ijbeZ] K\ylu_ ijbeZ]gug_ Imrdbgkdb_ ijbeZ] =hju kms_kl\ ku]jZeb h]jhfgmxijbeZ]jhevkms_kl\\ `bagbkms_kl\b l\hjq_kl\_kms_kl\ihwlZkms_kl\Fgh]h_bagZibkZggh]hImrdbgufkms_kl\ihlhf\ I_l_j[mj]_kms_kl\Fhkd\_kms_kl\;he^bghkms_kl\[uehaZ^mfZgha^_kv\ ikdh\kdhfijbeZ]m_^bg_gbb kms_kl\Imrdbg kms_kl\ gbdh]^Z g_ [ue \eZ^_evp_f kms_kl\ FboZceh\kdh]h kms_kl\ g_ [ue dj_ihklgbdhfihf_sbdhf kms_kl\ Gh hg dj_idh ex[be ©k\hx ^_j_\_gvdm kms_kl\ gZ IZjgZk_ kms_kl\ª f_qlZe [jhkblv ©k\bgkdbc ijbeZ] I_l_j[mj]kms_kl\ª gZ\k_]^Z ihk_eblvky gZ Ikdh\sbg_ kms_kl\ b `blvkj_^bjh^ghcijbeZ]ijbjh^ukms_kl\b ijhklh]hijbeZ]gZjh^Zkms_kl\F_qlZfkms_kl\ImrdbgZkms_kl\g_km`^_gh[uehk[ulvkyG_aZ^he]h^hkf_jlbkms_kl\dZd[uij_^qm\kl\myk\hc dhg_p kms_kl\ Imrdbg kms_kl\ dmibe k_[_ dehqhd kms_kl\ a_feb kms_kl\ \ ^_j_\g_ kms_kl\ K\ylh]hjv_ kms_kl\ ]^_ b aZ\_sZe ihohjhgblv k\hz ©[_kqm\kl\_ggh_ ijbeZ]l_ehkms_kl\ªIhK=_cq_gdh,< `bagb\ q_f"± kms_kl\Gn± `bagv,,Ihkl± g_h^mrgZjbp`jh^kdeG_ihkl± \ ij_^eiZ^_`_\ _^qbke_,,,Ku]jZebjhev\ q_f"\ `bagb,Dehqhdqlh"± kms_kl\Gn± dehqhd,,Ihkl± g_h^mrgZjbpfm`jh^kdeG_ihkl± \ \bgiZ^_`_\ _^qbke_,,,Dmibeqlh"dehqhd,< ^_j_\g_]^_"± kms_kl\Gn± ^_j_\gy,,Ihkl± g_h^mrgZjbp`jh^kdeG_ihkl± \ ij_^eiZ^_`_\ _^qbke_,,,Dmibe]^_"\ ^_j_\g_,Fma_cdZdhcihkq_lm"i_j\uc± qbkeblGn± i_j\uc,,Ihkl± ihjy^dh\h_ijhklh_G_ihkl± \ bf_giZ^_`_\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,Fma_cdZdhc"i_j\ucH[sb_fhjnheh]bq_kdb_ijbagZdb± ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_kh]eZkm_lkyk kms_kl\bl_evguf\ iZ^_`_qbke_b jh^_ Y ebqgh_ m\ezdky ij_ke_^h\Zgb_f ^bdbo dZ[Zgh\ b aZ[em^beky AZ e_khf gbq_]h hljbpZl g_ [ueh \b^gh Y ebqgh_ g_kdhevdh g_hij_^_e jZa \uklj_ebe \ \ha^mo gh g_ ihemqbe gbdZdbohljbpZlhl\_lguokb]gZeh\<^jm]ihkeurZekylj_kdkmqv_\bqvzlh g_hij_^_e ij_ju\bklh_ ^uoZgb_ DZdhclh g_hij_^_ea\_jv[_`Zefg_ebqgh_gZ\klj_qmD_fhlghkbl[uhgebqgh_fh] hdZaZlvky " Y ebqgh_ ohl_e klj_eylv gh \bglh\dZ aZp_ibeZkvaZebZguY ebqgh_\kdjbdgmeg_k\hbf]hehkhfb \wlhlmdZaZlfhf_gl ihqm\kl\h\Ze dZd `b\hlgh_ ebagmeh f_gy <ha\jZlbeZkvfhy ijbly`Zl kh[ZdZ HgZ ebqgh_ hklhjh`gh \ayeZ am[Zfb fhxijbly`Zljmdmb klZeZlbohgvdh\ba`Zlv;_akh[Zdby ebqgh_gbaZ qlh hljbp g_ gZrze [u ljhim dhlhjZy hlghkbl \u\_eZ f_gyebqgh_gZ^hjh]mIh<D:jk_gv_\m,IhkeurZekyqlhk^_eZe"± ]eZ]heGn± ihkeurZlvky,,Ihkl± kh\\b^g_i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,Lj_kdqlhk^_eZe"ihkeurZeky,<kdjbdgmeqlhk^_eZe"± ]eZ]heGn± \kdjbdgmlv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,Y qlhk^_eZe"\kdjbdgme Fg_ ijboh^behkv jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv k j_[ylZfb aZ^mfZ\rbfbklZlv nbabdZfb G_dhlhju_ ba gbo kqblZebqlh ih nbabd_ hgb^he`gubf_lv©iylvªwlh]eZ\gh_Ih^jm]bf`_ij_^f_lZffh`ghmqblvkydZdijb^zlkyG_^mfZxqlhwlhijZ\bevgh_j_r_gb_Djmigu_mqzgu_gbdh]^Zg_[uebmadbfbki_pbZebklZfbIhdZ\umqbl_kv \ rdhe_ ihklZjZcl_kv hij_^_eblv dZdZy h[eZklv gZmdb \Zk\k_jvza bgl_j_km_l KlZ\vl_ hiulu kZfhklhyl_evgh ZgZebabjmcl_j_rZcl_ aZ^Zqb mqbl_kv qblZlv ki_pbZevgu_ dgb]b jZkrbjyxsb_ b^hihegyxsb_ rdhevguc mq_[gbd <ujZ[Zlu\Zcl_ \ k_[_ mf_gb_ khkj_^hlhqblvky gZ lhf q_f \u aZgbfZ_l_kv ijbmqZcl_kv gZklhcqb\h^h[b\Zlvkyp_ebg_kljZrbl_kvg_m^Zq:dZ^BDDbdhbg<h \lhjhc qZklb l_dklZ [hevrbgkl\h ]eZ]heh\ mihlj_[e_gu \ih\_ebl_evghfgZdehg_gbb,KqblZebqlh^_eZeb"± ]eZ]heGn± kqblZlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\hfgh`qbke_,,,G_dhlhju_bagboqlh^_eZeb"kqblZeb,G_^mfZxqlh^_eZx"± ]eZ]heGn± ^mfZlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qbke_\ f ebp_,,,Y qlh^_eZx"g_^mfZx,Mqbl_kvqlh^_eZ_l_"± ]eZ]heGn± mqblvky,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\hfgh`qbke_\hf ebp_,,,<uqlh^_eZ_l_"mqbl_kv,Bgl_j_km_lqlh^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]heGn± bgl_j_kh\Zlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qbke_\ f ebp_,,,H[eZklvgZmdbqlh^_eZ_l"bgl_j_km_lJmdbih[hjxl,kijh^gh]hZ agZgb_ih[hj_l,kijlukyqb GZ^h fgh]h mqblvky ,, kij qlh[ fgh]h agZlv , kij >gzfjZgvr_ihk__rv,kijg_^_e_cjZgvr_ih`gzrv,kijDhgv\uj\_lky,kij± ^h]hgbrv,,kijZ kdZaZggh]hg_\hjhlbrv ,, kij G_ m^_j`Zeky ,, kij aZ ]jb\m aZ o\hkl g_ m^_j`brvky,,kijIjZ\^Z]eZaZdhe_l,kijDe_\_lZqlhm]hevg_h[h``_l,kijlZdaZfZjZ_l,kij,Ih[hjxlqlhk^_eZxl" ± ]eZ]heGN± ih[hjhlv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ [m^\j\hfgh`qbke_\ f ebp_,,,Jmdbqlhk^_eZxl"ih[hjxl< [_am^ hdhgqZgbyo ]eZ]heh\ \ , kijy`_gbb ibr_lky ? \h ,,kijy`_gbb± B GZr kZfhezl h[]hgy_l dhkydb i_j_ezlguo ilbp <gbam [e_klbl j_dZ K _z klZjh]h jmkeZ aZjhkr_]h ijbqZklb_ dmklZjgbdhfih^gbfZxlkyklZb]mk_cb mlhdbkim]ZgguoijbqZklb_ijb[eb`_gb_f kZfhezlZ K^_eZ\ ^__ijbqZklb_ jZa\hjhl fu kgb`Z_fky gZjZkqbs_gghcijbqZklb_ihkj_^be_kZiehsZ^d_Dhkgm\rbkv ^__ijbqZklb_ a_feb kZfhezl dZlblky ih mlhilZgghfmijbqZklb_em]mGZe_kghfZwjh^jhf_jZkiheh`_gghfijbqZklb_ \ lZz`ghc ]emrb `b\zl klhjh`klZjbd <klj_qZy ^__ijbqZklb_ ijbe_l_\rbc ijbqZklb_ kZfhezl jZ^hklgh ijb\_lkl\m_lhgagZdhfuo?szg_\uoh^y^__ijbqZklb_badZ[bguezlqbddjbqblk\h_fmklZjhfmijbyl_ex©DZd`b\zrv^_^mrdZ"ªIhBKhdheh\mFbdblh\m<gbam gZj_q [e_klbl ]eZ] j_dZ kms_kl\ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkdeijhkljZkijhklj,JZkiheh`_gghf± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_GZZwjh^jhf_dZdhf"jZkiheh`_gghfGn± jZkiheh`_gguc,,Ihkl± kljZ^Zlijhr\j_fykh\\b^G_ihkl± \ ij_^eh`iZ^_`_\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,GZZwjh^jhf_dZdhf"jZkiheh`_gghf,Ijbe_l_\rbc± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_KZfhe_ldZdhc"ijbe_l_\rbcGn± ijbe_l_\rbc,,Ihkl± ^_ckl\ijhr\j_fykh\\b^G_ihkl± \ \bgiZ^_`_\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,KZfhe_ldZdhc"ijbe_l_\rbc,Dhkgm\rbkv± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ^__ijbqZklb_DZlblkydZd"dhkgm\rbkvGn± dhkgmlvky,,Kh\\b^g_baf,,,DZlblkydZd"dhkgm\rbkv,<klj_qZy± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ^__ijbqZklb_Ijb\_lkl\m_ldZd"\klj_qZyGn± \klj_qZlv,,G_kh\\b^g_baf,,,Ijb\_lkl\m_ldZd"\klj_qZy Keh\hkhq_lZgby k gZj_qbyfb h[hagZqZxsbfb ijbagZd^_ckl\by_]h\j_fyf_klhb ^jjZ[hlZlv^hl_fgZgZj_qb_ijbclb aZk\_leh gZj_qb_ k\_jgmlv \ijZ\h gZj_qb_ keurZlvky ke_\ZgZj_qb_ ihklmiblv ihlh\Zjbs_kdb gZj_qb_ kihjblv ]hjyqhgZj_qb_Keh\hkhq_lZgbyk gZj_qbyfbh[hagZqZxsbfbijbagZd^jm]h]hijbagZdZ ihmlj_gg_fm gZj_qb_ k\_`bcih\kx^mgZj_qb_ba\_klgucihabfg_fmgZj_qb_oheh^ghqmlvqmlvgZj_qb_lzieuc Keh\hkhq_lZgby k gZj_qbyfb h[hagZqZxsbfb ijbagZd ij_^f_lZfZdZjhguihnehlkdbgZj_qb_rdheZgZijhlb\gZj_qb_>hjh]b_j_[ylZHq_gv ljm^gh ibkZlv h[ hq_\b^guo \_sZo <u \_^v \k_ kZfbij_djZkgh agZ_l_ qlh h[jZah\Zgb_ g_h[oh^bfh \ gZklhys__ \j_fy^ey\kydhcijhn_kkbb< wlhf kfuke_ f_gy hq_gv h]hjqbeh qlh \u gZibkZeb \ k\hzfibkvf_ ©ohq_fª \f_klh ©ohlbfª Wlh ihdZau\Z_l qlh \u j_[ylZhq_gvfZehqblZ_l_QblZcl_ih[hevr_± \_^vwlhlZdbgl_j_kgh± bihfgbl_qlhh[jZah\Zgb_\Zfgm`ghg_^eyrdheuZ ^eykZfbok_[y b qlh [ulv h[jZah\Zgguf kh\k_f g_ kdmqgh Z gZh[hjhl ± bgl_j_kgh]efukevK gZbemqrbfbih`_eZgbyfbEEZg^Zm=eZ]heuohl_lvb [_`Zlv± jZaghkijy]Z_fu_l_hgbbaf_gyxlkyg_lhevdhihi_j\hfmghb qZklbqghih\lhjhfmkijy`_gbx,H[± ij_^eh]IbkZlvh[hq_\b^guo\_sZoij_^eiZ^_`,,Ijhklg_ijhba\g_baf,< ± ij_^eh]G_h[oh^bfh\ gZklhys__\j_fy\bgiZ^_`,,Ijhklg_ijhba\g_baf,>ey± ij_^eh]G_h[oh^bfh^eyijhn_kkbbjh^iZ^_`,,G_baf,< ± ij_^eh]H]hjqbeh\ kfuke_ij_^eiZ^_`,,Ijhklg_ijhba\g_baf,K ± ij_^eh]K ih`_eZgbyfbl\hjbliZ^_`,,Ijhklg_ijhba\g_bafh q_f",Qlh± khxa>± @qlh± ,,Ih^qbgblijhklg_ijhba\g_baf,B ± khxa,,Khqbgblijhklg_ijhba\g_baf,: ± khxaZ,,Khqbgblijhkl g_ijhba\g_baf,<_^v± qZklbpZ>hiagZq_gb_± mkbe_gb_,,Fh^ZevgZyg_baf,G_± qZklbpZH[s__agZq_gb_± hljbpZgb_,,HljbpZlg_bafGZ^\hj_[ueZ f_l_ev\_l_j \ueklZ\gb ljykebky b klmqZebkh_^bg_guijbihfhsbbglhgZpbbKdhjh\ ^hf_\kz mlboehb aZkgmeh FZrZ hdmlZeZkv rZevxgZ^_eZ lzieucdZihl\ayeZ \jmdmrdZlmedmk\hxb \ureZ gZaZ^g__djuevphF_l_ev g_mlboZeZ \_l_j ^me gZ\klj_qm dZd [m^lh kbeykv hklZgh\blv fheh^mxij_klmigbpm b ± ijb ihfhsb bglhgZpbb b ± ijb ihfhsbih^qbgblkhxaZ<eZ^bfbj _oZe ihe_fi_j_k_q_gguf]em[hdbfb h\jZ]Zfb F_l_ev g_ mlboZeZ g_[h g_ ijhykgyehkv kh_^bg_guijb ihfhsb bglhgZpbb FZehihfZem ^_j_\vy gZqZeb j_^_lv b<eZ^bfbj \u_oZe ba e_km ijb ihfhsb khqbgbl khxaZ ;uehm`_k\_lehdZd^hklb]eb hgb @Z^jbgZijbihfhsbih^qbgblkhxaZ Yfsbd ijh_oZe fbfh lh]h f_klZ ]^_ \u_a`Zeb gZ^hjh]mblZdbf h[jZahf hqmlbebkv fu \ g_agZdhfhc klhjhg_ ijb ihfhsbih^qbgbl_evguo b khqbgbl_evguo khxah\ ;mjy g_ mlboZeZ ym\b^_e h]hgzd b \_e_e _oZlv lm^Z kh_^bg_gu ijb ihfhsb bglhgZpbb >_gv ijhrze [eZ]hihemqgh gh \ ghqv FZrZ aZg_fh]eZijbihfhsbkhqbgbl_evgh]hkhxaZ:KImrdbgY \_e_e_oZlvd dhf_g^Zglmb q_j_afbgmlmdb[bldZhklZgh\beZkvi_j_^^_j_\ygguf^hfbdhfY \ur_ebadb[bldbb lj_[h\Zeqlh[hl\_ebf_gyd gZqZevgbdmQlh[ml_rblv[_^gh]hKZ\_evbqZy ^Ze_fmkeh\h\ij_^v[_a_]hkh]eZkbyg_jZkiheZ]Zlvgbh^ghxdhi_cdhxR\Z[jbgih^hrzedhfg_k ih^ghkhfghy \lhjbqgh hl g_]h hl\hjhlbeky Ijb h[udgh\_gghc k\h_c kf_leb\hklbhgdhg_qgh^h]Z^ZekyqlhIm]Zqz\[uebfg_^h\he_gH^bgbaklZjrbgih^Ze_fm>Im]Zqz\m@f_rhdk f_^gufb^_gv]Zfbb hgklZebof_lZlvijb]hjrgyfbK_j^p_fhzaZguehdh]^ZhdZaZebkvfu\ ^Z\gh agZdhfhcdhfgZl_:KImrdbg>@gh>@± keh`ghkhqbgzggh_ij_^eh`_gb_k khxahfgh>@qlh± keh`ghih^qbgzggh_ij_^eh`_gb_k khxahfqlh>@b>@± keh`ghkhqbgzggh_ij_^eh`_gb_k khxahfb>@dh]^Z± keh`ghih^qbgzggh_ij_^eh`_gb_k khxahfdh]^Z>_lb\u[_af_gygbdZdhcl_e_]jZffug_ihemqZeb"Hl\_qZcl_fmqbl_eb<hl]^_fhyih]b[_ev<hldlhdhg_qghk\_^zlf_gy\ fh]bem>Zi_j_klZgvl_\u]m^_lv b jZkkdZ`bl_lhedhfdZd[ueh^_eh:=Zc^Zj< wlhfl_dkl_ hljZ`_guijbagZdbjZa]h\hjgh]hklbeyIh]b[_ev ± kf_jlv k\_klb \ fh]bem ± m[blv ]m^_lv ± rmf_lvlhedhf± ih^jh[ghh[klhyl_evgh< f_klZo]^_^\b`_gb_ j_]mebjm_lkyi_r_oh^u h[yaZgujmdh\h^kl\h\Zlvkykb]gZeZfbk\_lhnhjZbebj_]mebjh\sbdZ< f_klZo ]^_ ^\b`_gb_ g_ j_]mebjm_lky i_r_oh^u fh]ml i_j_oh^blv ijh_a`mx qZklv lhevdh ihke_ lh]h dZd hgb hp_gyl jZkklhygb_ ^h ijb[eb`Zxsboky ljZgkihjlguo kj_^kl\ b bo kdhjhklv bm[_^ylkyqlhg_kha^Z^ml ihf_obo^\b`_gbxL_dklhlghkblkyd hnbpbZevgh^_eh\hfmklbexld_]hp_ev± i_j_^ZqZlhqghcbgnhjfZpbbL_dklgZibkZg\ h^ghfba`Zgjh\hnbpbZevgh^_eh\h]h klbey ± bgkljmdpby L_dkl oZjZdl_jbam_lky ij_^_evghclhqghklvx\ujZ`_gbcbkdexqZxs_cjZagh_lhedh\Zgb_ Hd_ZgZfb gZau\Zxl djmigu_ ihembahebjh\Zggu_ qZklb Fbjh\h]h hd_ZgZ h[hkh[e_ggu_ ^jm] hl ^jm]Z fZl_jbdZfb Ke_^h\Zl_evghdZ`^uchd_Zgh]jZgbq_g[_j_]ZfbfZl_jbdh\b dZdhclhmkeh\ghc ebgb_c ij_^ihqlbl_evgh ih djZlqZcr_fm jZkklhygbxf_`^m fZl_jbdZfb < lZdbo]jZgbpZohd_Zgij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hcg_dhlhjh__^bgkl\h± dhfiZdlgmxfZkkm\h^ub ]jmiimhd_Zgbq_kdbo\iZ^bg DZd b fZl_jbdb ljb gZb[he__ djmiguo hd_ZgZ h[eZ^Zxl[hevrbfjZaghh[jZab_fnbabdh]_h]jZnbq_kdbomkeh\bc>;h]^Zgh\Klbevl_dklZ± gZmqguc,BfyXjby=Z]ZjbgZgZ\k_]^Z\hreh\ \_dZHghagZf_gm_lkh[hc gZqZeh gh\hc wju ± wju hk\h_gby q_eh\_dhf dhkfbq_kdh]hijhkljZgkl\ZIh^\b]_]hhebp_l\hjy_l\kzemqr__qlhkha^Zghq_eh\_q_kdbfjZamfhfk ^j_\gbo\j_fzg^hgZrbo^g_cih^\b]wlhldZdijbgylh]h\hjblv\ibkZg\ bklhjbxahehlufb [md\Zfb=Lblh\,, Fu \klmiZ_f \ \_d \ dhlhjhf agZgby [m^ml b]jZlv hij_^_eyxsmxjhev\ km^v[_q_eh\_dZ;_aagZgbcg_evay[m^_ljZ[hlZlvMq_gb_ ± \hl qlh gm`gh fheh^hfm q_eh\_dm k kZfh]h fZeh]h\hajZklZ Mqblvky gm`gh \k_]^Z >h dhgpZ `bagb g_ lhevdh mqbebgh b mqbebkv \k_ djmig_crb_ mqzgu_ KZfh_ [eZ]hijbylgh_ \j_fy^eymq_gby± fheh^hklvBf_ggh\ fheh^hklbmfq_eh\_dZgZb[he__\hkijbbfqb\Mf_cl_g_l_jylv\j_f_gbgZimklydb;_j_]bl_k_[y^eymq_gby^eyijbh[j_l_gbyihe_aguoagZgbcb gZ\udh\IhklZjZcl_kv \ dZ`^hf ij_^f_l_ gZclb jZ^hklv ijbh[j_l_gbygh\h]hMqbl_kvex[blvmqblvky>EboZqz\Wlb l_dklu hlghkylky d im[ebpbklbq_kdhfm klbex ?]h p_ev ±\ha^_ckl\b_ gZ kemrZl_ey A^_kv rbjhdh bkihevamxlky ihfbfhg_cljZevguo lhj`_kl\_ggu_ keh\Z wfhpbhgZevgh hdjZr_ggu_keh\Z\hkdebpZgbyh[jZs_gbyd qblZl_ex , K_cqZk `_ \hae_ \oh^ghc ^\_jb >\ dZ[bg_l_ : I Q_oh\Z@gZijZ\h± rdZnk dgb]ZfbGZdZfbg_g_kdhevdh[_a^_emr_db ij_djZkgh k^_eZggZy fh^_ev iZjmkghc romgu GZ kl_gZo ihjlj_luLheklh]h=jb]hjh\bqZLmj]_g_\ZGZhl^_evghffZe_gvdhfklhebd_ gZ \__jhh[jZaghc ih^klZ\d_ fgh`_kl\h nhlh]jZnbc Zjlbklh\ bibkZl_e_c:BDmijbghibkZgb_,,GZ^jm]hc^_gv\ gZagZq_ggh_\j_fyy klhyem`_aZkdbj^Zfbh`b^Zyk\h_]hijhlb\gbdZ<kdhj_b hgy\beky©GZkfh]mlaZklZlv± kdZaZe hg fg_ ± gZ^h[gh ihki_rblvª Fu kgyeb fmg^bju hklZebkv\ h^gbodZfaheZob h[gZ`bebriZ]b:KImrdbgih\_kl\h\Zgb_om^h`_kl\_ggucklbev,,, :lfhkn_jguc \ha^mo djhf_ ZahlZ b dbkehjh^Z kh^_j`bl_sz hq_gvg_[hevrh_dhebq_kl\hm]e_dbkehlug_kdhevdh^_kylblukyqguoWlZm]e_dbkehlZkhklhblbam]e_jh^Zb dbkehjh^ZKe_^h\Zl_evgh wlhl [_kp\_lguc ]Za gbq_f ih \b^m g_ hlebqZxsbcky hl\ha^moZ kh^_j`bl qZklbpu m]ey D : Lbfbjya_\ jZkkm`^_gb_gZmqgucklbev G_gm`guo ijhn_kkbc g_l Ij_^klZ\vl_ qlh aZ\ljZ aZ ijbeZ\dZfb fZ]Zabgh\ \^jm] g_ hdZ`_lky gb h^gh]h ijh^Z\pZ bebkdZ`_f \k_ fZrbgu ebrZlky \h^bl_e_c BlZd \k_]h h^ghc^\mfyijhn_kkbyfb klZg_l f_gvr_ Z dZdb_ g_ijbylgu_ ihke_^kl\by wlh\uah\_lgZkdhevdhhkeh`gblkyb aZljm^gblkygZrZ`bagvIh\_jvl_qlhlZd`_h[klhbl^_ehb kex[ufb^jm]bfbijhn_kkbyfb?kebhgb_klvagZqblihy\bebkvhgbih^\ebygb_fg_h[oh^bfhklbKlZeh [ulv g_aZf_gbfu gm`gu ex^yf b ^he`gu j_]meyjgh ihihegylvky k\_`bfb kbeZfb Ihqzlgh [ulv b lhdZj_f b \h^bl_e_fljZf\Zyb ih\Zjhfb fhglZ`gbdhf\ukhlgbdhfQlh[uijbgylvijZ\bevgh_j_r_gb_gm`ghmf_lvhjb_glbjh\Zlvky\ lhfjZaghh[jZabbijhn_kkbcdhlhju_kh\j_f_ggZyijhfure_gghklvk_evkdh_ohayckl\hb kn_jZh[kem`b\Zgbyij_^eZ]ZxlxghrZfb ^_\mrdZf \klmiZxsbf \ `bagv DZd kdZaZe ihwl ©<k_ jZ[hlu ohjhrb\u[bjZcgZ\dmkªIhdgb]_©Imlz\dZ\ `bagvªHkgh\gZyfukevl_dklZ± \Z`ghklvb gm`ghklv\k_okms_kl\mxsboijhn_kkbc ImkluggZy ^hjh]Z \hreZ \ e_kZ Ju`Zy hk_gv fqZeZkv ihklhjhgZf E_kZ [ueb aZj`Z\e_gu bo ihdju\ZeZ `_elZy ie_k_gvhibkZgb_FZrbgZkhgghrmjrZeZihdj_fgbklhc^hjh]_khgghrmf_e\_l_j\ jZ^bZlhj_^j_fZebiZkkZ`bjuih\_kl\h\Zgb_Kd\hav^j_fhlmfum\b^_ebgZk_\_j_]jy^mdjZkguo]hj ihdjuluofhjsbgZfbGZ]hjZog_[uehgb _^bghcljZ\bgdbdZd[m^lhka_febkgyeb\_kzeucjZklbl_evgucihdjh\hibkZgb_FZrbgZ dZlbeZkv b _z jZ\ghf_jgh_ ^\b`_gb_ \uau\Zeh ijhklu_b kihdhcgu_fukeb<kyijb\e_dZl_evghklva_febaZdexq_gZ\`b\hlghf b jZklbl_evghf fbj_ B lhl b ^jm]hc fbj bamq_gu gZfbihqlb\ kh\_jr_gkl\_gh\k_]^Zhlkhijbdhkgh\_gbyk gbfbhklZzlkyhsms_gb_aZ]Z^dbAZ]Z^hqgub ihlhfmij_djZkgulzfgu_qZsbe_kh\]em[bgufhj_caZ]Z^hq_gdjbdilbpub lj_kdehigm\r_chll_iehlu^j_\_kghcihqdbJZa]Z^ZggZyaZ]Z^dZg_m[b\Z_l\heg_gby\ua\Zggh]h aj_ebs_f a_feb Q_f [hevr_ fu agZ_f l_f kbevg__`_eZgb_`blvjZkkm`^_gb_DIZmklh\kdbc<u^_e_ggu_keh\Zmihlj_[e_gu\ i_j_ghkghfagZq_gbb , Y jZgh gZqZe aZ^mfu\Zlvky gZ^ l_f qlh f_gy hdjm`Z_lI_j_ezluklj_dha`bagvih^\h^gh]hpZjkl\Zj_qdb<Zeh\u\ dhlhjhc \h^bebkv gZjy^gu_ djZkghizjdb b ahehlu_ ebgb aZdhgu j_qguo l_q_gbc aZklZ\ey\rbo djm`blvky \h^h\hjhlu b af__\b^gh ba\b\Zlvky ^ebggu_ ijy^b \h^hjhke_c ± \kz[uehlZdqm^_kghiheghlZbgkl\_ggh]hagZq_gby:GNhjfhah\,, Fgh]h_ _sz fh`gh gZibkZlv h F_szjkdhf djZ_ Fh`gh gZibkZlv qlh wlhl djZc hq_gv [h]Zl Gh y gZjhqgh g_ ibrm h[ wlhfG_m`_ebfu^he`guex[blvk\hxa_fexlhevdhaZlhqlhhgZ[h]ZlZ"G_lhevdhaZwlhfuex[bf jh^gu_f_klZFuex[bfbo_szbaZ lh qlh ^Z`_ g_[h]Zlu_ hgb ^ey gZk ij_djZkgu Y ex[ex F_szjkdbcdjZcaZlhqlhhgij_djZk_gohly\kyij_e_klv_]hjZkdju\Z_lky g_ kjZam Z hq_gv f_^e_ggh ihkl_i_ggh Ih D = IZmklh\kdhfmLbij_qb± jZkkm`^_gb_ Ba[jZlv \ ij_ab^bmf kh[jZgby ijb\be_]bb fgh]h^_lgufk_fvyf \klj_qZ k \_l_jZgZfb \hcgu b ljm^Z gZrb jh\_kgbdb bk\_jklgbdb ij_ke_^h\Zlv k\hb bgl_j_ku [m^msZy ijhn_kkby ohjhrZyki_pbZevghklvk\h_\j_f_gguckb]gZe< bgklblml_ f_gy h[mqZxl fh_c [m^ms_c ijhn_kkbb Y [m^mbg`_g_jhf± wlhohjhrZyki_pbZevghklv,Ij_ke_^h\Zlvqlh^_eZlv"± ]eZ]heGn± ij_ke_^h\Zlv,,G_kh\\b^i_j_o,kij\ g_hijnhjf_,,,Qlh^_eZlv"ij_ke_^h\Zlv,K \_l_jZgZfbk d_f"± kms_kl\Gn± \_l_jZg,,Ihkl± h^mrgZjbpfm`jh^kdeG_ihkl± \ l\hjbliZ^_`_\hfgh`qbke_,,,<klj_qZk d_f"k \_l_jZgZfb,;m^msZy± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_Ijhn_kkbydZdZy"[m^msZyGn± [m^msbc,,Ihkl± ^_ckl\blgZkl\j_fyg_kh\\b^G_ihkl± \ bf_gbliZ^_`_\ _^qbke_\ `_gjh^_,,,Ijhn_kkbydZdZy"[m^msZy,GZrb± f_klhbf_gb_Jh\_kgbdbqvb"gZrbGn± gZr,,Ihkl± ijbly`Zl_evgh_G_ihkl± \ bf_gbliZ^\hfgh`qbke_,,,Jh\_kgbdbqvb"gZrbGZ^_`gucijbeZ]Zl^jm]kms_kl\blljm^h\hcijbeZ]ZlklZ`kms_kl\blih^ebggucijbeZ]Zl^hdmf_glkms_kl\bl Hq_gv gZj_qb_ bgl_j_kguc ijbeZ]Zl ih\_k_gg_fm gZj_qb_k\_`bcijbeZ]Zl Ihkljhblv ]eZ]he ihebdebgbdm kms_kl\bl ij_h^he_lv]eZ\gh_± ]eZ]heljm^ghklbkms_kl\bl=eZ\gh_keh\h± ij_^f_l;_lhggu_ijbeZ]hihjukms_kl\bl^_j_\yggZyijbeZ]i_j_]hjh^dZ kms_kl\bl lZeZgleb\Zy ijbeZ] iv_kZ kms_kl\bl]_gbZevguc ijbeZ] mqzguc kms_kl\bl hlqZyggZy ijbqZklb_ojZ[jhklv kms_kl\bl ih_a^dZ kms_kl\bl \ ]hju kms_kl\bl kij_^eh]hf=eZ\gh_keh\h± ijbagZd<_kvfZgZj_qb_bkdmkgucijbeZ]qj_a\uqZcghgZj_qb_m\e_dZl_evgucijbeZ]hlqZygghgZj_qb_kf_eucijbeZ]=eZ\gh_keh\h± ^_ckl\b_Ih^]hlh\blv ]eZ]he ^hdeZ^ kms_kl\bl dmiblv ]eZ]he [jhrxjmkms_kl\blq_jlblv]eZ]helmrvxkms_kl\bljZkkdZau\Zlv ]eZ]he h iml_r_kl\bb kms_kl\bl k ij_^eh]hf ih^t_oZlv]eZ]hed ha_jmkms_kl\blk ij_^eh]hfih^gbfZlvky]eZ]hebaaZ e_kZ kms_kl\bl k ij_^eh]hf ihdZaZlvky ]eZ]he baaZ ]hj kms_kl\blk ij_^eh]hfRbjhdb_[jxdbhq_gvdjZkb\uc[ulvkf_eufIjbeZ]kmsDjZkb\h_ieZlv_kbgbc`Zd_l[e_klysbcmki_oGh\ZyfZrbgZKmskms\ jiIb^`Zd [jZlZ ihjln_ev hlpZ i_kgy kljhbl_e_c ]g_a^h hjeZL_ljZ^v^jm]Z=ekms\ \iKfhlj_lv l_e_nbevf qblZlv jhfZg ieZ\blv f_lZee Ex[blvijbjh^m=ekms\ l\iJm[blvlhihjhfibkZlvdZjZg^Zrhfjbkh\ZlvdjZkdZfbMijZ\eylvih\hadhcGZj_q]e;ukljh [_`Zlv ohjhrh ieZ\Zlv k_j^blh \hjqZlv FjZqgh \u]ey^_lvGZj_qgZj_qIhhk_gg_fmiZkfmjghhq_gvl_fghKh\k_fiehohKmskms\ jik ij_^ebaGblvbadZijhgZdh\jbdbaihjhehgZL_klhbafmdb=ekms\ ^Zli:ieh^bjh\Zlv ZjlbklZf \hajZ`Zlv ^hdeZ^qbdm AZieZlblv ijh^Z\pm=egZj_q<ha\jZlblvky aZl_fgh ijb_oZlv k_]h^gy \klZlv kihaZjZgdmH^_lvky[ukljh=ekms\ l\iMijZ\eylv dhjZ[ezf jmdh\h^blv [jb]Z^hc dhfZg^h\Zlv wkdZ^jhcJmdh\h^blvjZ[hqbfbGZj_qkms;ebadhhl[_j_]Zihe_agh^eya^hjh\vyKujhhl^h`^yL_e_nhg^bj_dlhjZjmqdZmqbl_eykf_jlvg_]h^yy<ua\Zlv k_dj_lZjy ijh]gZlv kh[Zdm ijhqblZlv ]Za_lm Zi_qZlZlvkmj]mqhf\uj_aZlvgh`gbpZfbm[blvgh`hfKl_exsbckylmfZgdjZkguc neZ] gh\uc kZjZnZg ;ZgdZ baih^ djZkdb [mluedZ ebfhgZ^Z\_^jh\h^u<ha\jZlblvkybaaZ^h`^yhlieulvhl[_j_]Zmclbhlhl\_lkl\_gghklbIj_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkmskms\ jik ij_^ebaFhehdhba^_j_\gbjm[bgbaDZbjZ\Zj_gv_badem[gbdb>_ckl\b_b ij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^bl]ekms\ \iM\Z`Zlvjh^bl_e_c[_j_qve_kiblvfhehdh>_ckl\b_b _]hijbagZd]egZj_qMclbjZgh`^Zlv^he]hkdZaZlvk]hjyqZIjbagZdb ijbqbgZ_]h\hagbdgh\_gbyijbeZ]kms\ jikij_^ehl fhdjuchljhkuAZkl_gqb\uchlijbjh^ukeZ^dbchlkZoZjZ[_euchlkg_]ZE_kghcaZiZo± aZiZoe_kZ[jhgah\ZyklZlmy± klZlmyba[jhgau fjZfhjguc iZfylgbd ± iZfylgbd ba fjZfhjZ [Zkk_cg ^ey ieZ\Zgby ± ieZ\Zl_evguc [Zkk_cg dhklxf ^ey lj_gbjh\db ± lj_gbjh\hqguc dhklxf jZkkdZau\Zlv k m\e_q_gb_f ± m\e_q_gghjZkkdZau\Zlv^_j`Zlvkyk ^hklhbgkl\hf± ^hklhcgh^_j`ZlvkyiZjdijb fhj_ ± ijbfhjkdbc iZjd ]hklbgbpZ ijb \hdaZe_ ± ijb\hdaZevgZy]hklbgbpZb^lbihe_f± b^lbihihex_oZlv[_j_]hf± _oZlvih[_j_]m@bl_evFhkd\u± fhkdh\kdbc`bl_evdhjh[dZbadZjlhgZ± dZjlhggZydhjh[dZ HieZlblv jZkoh^u ]eZ]kms_kl\ mieZlblv aZ ijh_a^]eZ]kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf ^h[blvky ijbagZgby ]eZ]kms_kl\aZkem`blv iho\Zeu ]eZ]kms_kl\ m^hklhblvky \gbfZgby]eZ]kms_kl\ h[km`^Zlv klZlvx ]eZ]kms_kl\ h[km`^_gb_klZlvb kms_kl\kms_kl\ ih^_eblvky hiulhf ]eZ]kms_kl\dj_idbc dhn_ ijbeZ]kms_kl\ [eZ]h^Zj_g ^jm]m djZld ijbeZ]kms_kl\hlqzlh jZ[hl_kms_kl\kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfhlau\ h dgb]_ kms_kl\kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf j_p_gaby gZ klZlvxkms_kl\kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf m^hklh_g gZ]jZ^u djZldijbqkms_kl\^hklhbgm\Z`_gbydjZldijbeZ]kms_kl\Zk ]eZ\gufkeh\hfkms_kl\bl_evgufaZl_fk ijbeZ]Zl_evguf b qbkebl_evguf \_dh\u_ ljZ^bpbb ljZ^bpbhggu_ \klj_qbgZrb kh\j_f_ggbdb b^_Zeu fheh^z`b bklbgguc ^jm] mdZau\Z_lgZ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd lhqguc jZkqzl ba\_klguc k ^_lkl\Zhq_gv\gbfZl_evgucmdZau\Z_lgZijbagZdijbagZdZh[s_kl\_gghihe_aguc`bag_gghg_h[oh^bfuc^hklhcgucm\Z`_gbydjZcg_aZkl_gqb\uc\lhjhcbamqZklgbdh\lj_lbcke_\Z[ k ]eZ\guf keh\hf ± ]eZ]hehf mqZkl\h\Zlv \ ihoh^_ q_kl\h\Zlv \_l_jZgh\ mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuc hghi_j_oh^bl \_jghjZkkqblZlvmdZau\Z_lgZ^_ckl\b_b _]hijbagZd\k ]eZ\gufkeh\hf± gZj_qb_fQj_a\uqZcghijbylghjZghmljhf GbgZ gZijZ\beZkv d \hjhlZf GZ kljhcdm \t_a`Zeb ly`_eu_kZfhk\Zeu M \hjhl Gbgm hklZgh\be ^_^mrdZ \ dhjhldhf ib^`Zd_Hg hl^Ze q_klv b \bgh\Zlh ijh]h\hjbe qlh ihklhjhggbf \oh^blvg_evay G_fgh]h h[b^_\rbkv GbgZ h[tykgbeZ qlh hgZ g_ ihklhjhggyyb ihdZaZeZ^biehfQ_j_aiheqZkZ_c^Zebjhah\uclZehgqbdb hgZ\hreZgZkljhbl_evgmxiehsZ^dm<ukhdh \ g_[h moh^be kljhcguc f_lZeebq_kdbc dZjdZk khklhysbc ba ]hjbahglZevguo klZevguo [Zehd b \_jlbdZevguo dhehgg=j_fy klZevgufb dmah\Zfb \ jZagu_ klhjhgu _oZeb kZfhk\Zeu ki_kdhf[_lhghfdhgl_cg_jZfb]jmah\bdbk `_e_ah[_lhggufbieblZfbb qm]mggufbljm[ZfbIhK:glhgh\mGZijZ\beZkv d \hjhlZf mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b _]h ijbagZdly`_eu_kZfhk\ZeumdZau\Z_lgZij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdgZkljhcdm\t_a`ZebmdZau\Z_lgZ^_ckl\b_b _]hijbagZd\t_a`Zeb kZfhk\Zeu mdZau\Z_l gZ ij_^f_l b _]h ^_ckl\b_ ^_^mrdZ \ ib^`Zd_mdZau\Z_l gZ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd \ dhjhldhf ib^`Zd_ mdZau\Z_l gZ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd hklZgh\be m \hjhl mdZau\Z_l gZ^_ckl\b_ b _]h ijbagZd hklZgh\be Gbgm mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ bij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^blL_dkljZa^_e_ggZZ[aZpZld\ dZ`^hfbagbogZqbgZ_lkygh\ZyfukevHiulgucaZ\bkijbeZ]gZklZ\gbd]eZ\gi_j\ZyaZ\bk qbkebl klbi_g^by ]eZ\g [Z[mrdbgu aZ\bk ijbeZ] kh\_lu ]eZ\g gZr_ aZ\bk f_klhbf [m^ms__ ]eZ\g Ijb baf_g_gbb]eZ\gh]hkeh\ZaZ\bkbfh_keh\hlh`_baf_gy_lkyAZihegblv]eZ\gZgd_lmaZ\bkkms_kl\^mfZlv]eZ\gh[m^ms_f aZ\bk ijbq k ij_^eh]hf kh]eZkblvky ]eZ\g k gbff_klhbf k ij_^eh]hf aZ\bk ba\_klguc ]eZ\g ajbl_eyf aZ\bkkms_kl\Ijbbaf_g_gbb]eZ\gh]hkeh\ZaZ\bkbfh_keh\hg_baf_gy_lky GZklhcqb\h aZ\bk gZj_q m[_`^Zlv ]eZ\g agZlv ]eZ\ggZbamklv aZ\bk gZj_q hq_gv aZ\bk gZj_q gZklhcqb\uc]eZ\g ihe_lg_fm aZ\bk gZj_q `Zjdbc ]eZ\g Ijb baf_g_gbb ]eZ\gh]hkeh\ZaZ\bkbfh_keh\hg_baf_gy_lkyIh^gbfZlvneZ]aZ\bkkms_kl\k\yavhdhgqZgb_f`blvgZ\afhjv_aZ\bkkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfk\yavij_^eh]hfb hdhgqZgb_f b^lbihZee__aZ\bkkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfk\yavij_^eh]hfb hdhgqZgb_fjZ[hlZlvgZwe_dljhklZgpbbaZ\bkkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfk\yavij_^eh]hfb hdhgqZgb_fijhoh^blvih\ha\ur_gghklb aZ\bk kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf k\yav ij_^eh]hf b hdhgqZgb_f aZi_qZlZlv kmj]mqhf aZ\bk kms_kl\ k\yav hdhgqZgb_fk^_eZlvgZki_oaZ\bkgZj_qb_k\yavihkfukemh^_lvkyihabfg_fm aZ\bk gZj_qb_ k\yav ih kfukem b]jZlv gZ jhye_ aZ\bk kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf k\yav ij_^eh]hf b hdhgqZgb_f ijbdZaZlv \_jgmlvky aZ\bk ]eZ]he k\yav ih kfukem h[tykgylv g_lhjhiykv aZ\bk ^__ijbqZklb_ k\yav ih kfukem wlbf aZ\bkf_klhbf e_lhf k\yav hdhgqZgb_f k i_j\uf aZ\bk qbkeblih_a^hf k\yav ij_^eh]hf b hdhgqZgb_f magZlv h ijhbkr_kl\bbaZ\bk kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf k\yav ij_^eh]hf b hdhgqZgb_f[mrmxs__aZ\bkijbqZklb_fhj_k\yavhdhgqZgb_fLmjbklkdbcaZ\bkijbeZ]ihoh^kh]eZkh\Zgb_± \ lmjbklkdhfaZ\bkijbeZ]ihoh^_kh]eZkh\Zgb_i_j\ZyaZ\bkqbkebl]jmiiZ kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ± i_j\mx aZ\bkqbkebl ]jmiim kh]eZkh\Zgb_gZraZ\bkf_klhbfdhee_dlb\kh]eZkh\Zgb_± gZr_fmaZ\bkf_klhbfdhee_dlb\mkh]eZkh\Zgb_dZ`^ucaZ\bkf_klhbf^_gv kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ± k dZ`^uf aZ\bkf_klhbf ^gzf kh]eZkh\Zgb_jZa\b\Zlvkihkh[ghklbaZ\bkkms_kl\blmijZ\e_gb_± jZa\blhc aZ\bkijbqZklb_ j_[zghd kh]eZkh\Zgb_ \ha\jZlblvky baihoh^ZaZ\bkkms_kl\blk ij_^eh]hfmijZ\e_gb_± \ha\jZlblvky^hfhc aZ\bkgZj_qb_ ijbfudZgb_ mfgh`blv gZ ^\Z aZ\bkqbkebl k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ ± m\_ebqblv \^\h_ aZ\bkgZj_qb_ijbfudZgb_gbq_faZ\bkf_klhbfg_m\e_dZlvkymijZ\e_gb_ ± gbqmlv aZ\bkgZj_qb_ g_ m^b\blvky ijbfudZgb_]meylv [_k_^my aZ\bk^__ijbqZklb_ ijbfudZgb_ m_oZlv \ hlimkd aZ\bkkms_kl\bl k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_± m_oZlve_qblvkyaZ\bk]eZ]heijbfudZgb_jZ[hlZlv\ l_q_gb_f_kypZaZ\bkkms_kl\bl k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ jmdh\h^blv ohjhf aZ\bkkms_kl\bl mijZ\e_gb_ ± jmdh\h^bl_ev ohjZ aZ\bkkms_kl\blmijZ\e_gb_ [_k_^h\Zlv k ^jmavyfb aZ\bkkms_kl\bl k ij_^eh]hfmijZ\e_gb_[_k_^ZgZ_^bg_aZ\bkgZj_qb_ijbfudZgb_< dZq_kl\_aZ\bkbfuokeh\ijbkh]eZkh\Zgbbfh]ml[ulvijbeZ]Zl_evgu_qbkebl_evgu_ijbqZklbyf_klhbf_gby< dZq_kl\_ aZ\bkbfuo keh\ ijb mijZ\e_gbb fh]ml [ulv kms_kl\bl_evgu_qbkebl_evgu_f_klhbf_gbydZdk ij_^eh]hflZdb [_ag_]h< dZq_kl\_ aZ\bkbfuo keh\ ijb ijbfudZgbb fh]ml [ulv ]eZ]heu^__ijbqZklbygZj_qbyGh\ZyaZ\bkijbeZ]jZ[hlZ]eZ\gkms_kl\± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ JZ[hlZlv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he ihgh\hfm aZ\bk gZj_qb_ ±ijbfudZgb_ Mqblv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he jZ[hlZlv aZ\bk ]eZ]he ±ijbfudZgb_ Ih\hjhl ]eZ\g kms_kl\ gZ iehsZ^v aZ\bk kms_kl\ kij_^e ± mijZ\e_gb_ Ih\hjhl ]eZ\g kms_kl\ gZe_\h aZ\bkgZj_qb_ ± ijbfudZgb_ E_\uc aZ\bk ijbeZ] ih\hjhl ]eZ\gkms_kl\± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ GZklhcqb\h_ aZ\bk ijbqZklb_ lj_[h\Zgb_ ]eZ\g kms_kl\ ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ GZklhcqb\h aZ\bk gZj_qb_ lj_[h\Zlv]eZ\g ]eZ]he ± ijbfudZgb_GZklhylv]eZ\g]eZ]hegZk\hzfaZ\bkf_klhbfk ij_^e± mijZ\e_gb_AbfgyyaZ\bkijbeZ]^hjh]Z]eZ\gkms_kl\± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ihabfg_fm aZ\bk gZj_qb_ oheh^guc ]eZ\g ijbeZ] ±ijbfudZgb_ m_oZlv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he abfhc aZ\bk gZj_qb_ ±ijbfudZgb_ Ihklhyggh aZ\bk gZj_qb_ aZ[hlblvky ]eZ\g ]eZ]he ±ijbfudZgb_ ihklhyggu_ aZ\bk ijbeZ] aZ[hlu ]eZ\g kms_kl\ ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ijhy\blv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he aZ[hlm aZ\bkkms_kl\± mijZ\e_gb_ Ihklmiblv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he kijZ\_^eb\h aZ\bk gZj_qb_ ±ijbfudZgb_ kijZ\_^eb\h_ aZ\bk ijbeZ] j_r_gb_ ]eZ\g kms_kl\ ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ lj_[h\Zlv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he kijZ\_^eb\hklbaZ\bkkms_kl\± mijZ\e_gb_< dZq_kl\_aZ\bkbfuokeh\ijbkh]eZkh\Zgbbfh]ml[ulvijbeZ]Zl_evgu_qbkebl_evgu_ijbqZklbyf_klhbf_gby< dZq_kl\_ aZ\bkbfuo keh\ ijb mijZ\e_gbb fh]ml [ulv kms_kl\bl_evgu_ qbkebl_evgu_ f_klhbf_gby dZd k ij_^eh]hf lZd b [_ag_]h< dZq_kl\_aZ\bkbfuokeh\ijbijbfudZgbbfh]ml[ulvgn ]eZ]heZ^__ijbqZklbygZj_qbyKh]eZkh\Zgb_KljhcgZy aZ\bk [_j_aZ ]eZ\g ihkljh_gguc aZ\bk ^hf]eZ\g\lhjhcaZ\bkghf_j]eZ\ggZrbaZ\bk^_lb]eZ\gMijZ\e_gb_Ex[blv]eZ\gijbjh^m aZ\bk\klj_qZlv]eZ\gl_[yaZ\bkIjbfudZgb_OhjhrhaZ\bk\b^_lv]eZ\g`blv]eZ\gex[yaZ\bkohl_lv]eZ\g`blvaZ\bk, De_lqZluc ijbe aZ\bk rZjn kms ]eZ\g ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ rZjn kms ]eZ\g \ de_ldm kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_gZ^_lv ]e ]eZ\g rZjn kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_ kh\_jrblv]e ]eZ\g iju`hd kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_ iju`hd kms]eZ\g k ljZfiebgZ kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_ \_jblv ]e]eZ\g ex^yf kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_ \_jZ kms ]eZ\g \ex^_c kms aZ\bk ± mijZ\e_gb_ k_juc ijbe aZ\bk ib^`Zdkms]eZ\g± kh]eZkh\Zgb_k_jucijbe]eZ\ghliuebkmsaZ\bk± mijZ\e_gb_\ha\jZs_gb_kms]eZ\gghqvxkmsaZ\bk ± ijbfudZgb_ \ha\jZsZlvky ]e ]eZ\g ghqvx kms aZ\bk± ijbfudZgb_iha^ghgZj_qaZ\bkghqvxkms]eZ\g±ijbfudZgb_ ojZ[juc ijbe aZ\bk q_eh\_d kms ]eZ\g ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ hlqZyggh gZj_q aZ\bk ojZ[juc ijbe ]eZ\g ±ijbfudZgb_ihabfg_fmgZj_qaZ\bkoheh^gucijbe]eZ\g± ijbfudZgb_ ihabfg_fm gZj_q aZ\bk oheh^gh gZj_q]eZ\g± ijbfudZgb_,,Ljb]eZ\gl_ljZ^baZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_± lj_oaZ\bkl_ljZ^_c ]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_ q_luj_ ]eZ\g dZjZg^ZrZ aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ ± q_lujvfy aZ\bk dZjZg^ZrZfb ]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_^\h_]eZ\g^_l_caZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_± ^\mfyaZ\bk^_lvfb ]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_ \hk_fv ]eZ\g kihjlkf_gh\ aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ ± k \hk_fvx aZ\bk kihjlkf_gZfb ]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_iylv^_kyl]eZ\gjm[e_caZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_± k iylvx^_kylvxaZ\bkjm[eyfb]eZ\gkh]eZkh\Zgb_ =jhfdbf r_ihlhf ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ rhjho ^_j_\v_\ ± mijZ\e_gb_koh^blvaZ[Z]Z`hf± mijZ\e_gb_ihcfZlv f_^\_`hgdZ± mijZ\e_gb_ ju[heh\guc djxqhd ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ohesh\uc f_rhd ±kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ghq_\dZ \ e_km ± mijZ\e_gb_ ahehq_gh_ dhevph ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ljb rhnzjZ ± mijZ\e_gb_ ]hjyqh kihjblv ± ijbfudZgb_ y]h^u dju`h\gbdZ ± mijZ\e_gb_ gh\h_ rhkk_ ± ijbfudZgb_\kdbiyq_ggh_fhehdh± kh]eZkh\Zgb_GZibkZgb_ keh\ k ijhims_ggufb [md\Zfb hkgh\Zgh gZ ijZ\be_gZibkZgby [md\ h_ ihke_ rbiysbo Hgh k\yaZgh kh ke_^mxsbfbagZqbfufbqZklyfbkeh\Zdhj_gvb kmnnbdkH ± , ?ihke_rbiysbo,;_am^Zj_gby± ?,,Ih^m^Zj_gb_f< dhjg_keh\Z± ,< kmnnbdkZob hdhgqZgbyo]eZ]heh\± , < kmnnbdkZob hdhgqZgbyog_]eZ]heh\± HJu[heh\guc ± ju[Z eh\blvg keh`_gb_ hkgh\ k h^gh\j_f_ggufijbkh_^bg_gb_fkmnnbdkZAhehq_guc± ahehlblvkmnnbdkZevguc=hjyqh± ]hjyqbckmnnbdkZevguc,;_kihdhblvky]eZ\gh ^hq_jb\ IiaZ\bklj_\h`blvky]eZ\gaZ[jZlZ\ <iaZ\bkij_^mij_^blv]eZ\gh[hiZkghklb\ IiaZ\bkij_^hkl_j_qv]eZ\ghlhrb[db\ JiaZ\bk,,M\_j_gghklv]eZ\g\ mki_o_\ IiaZ\bk\_jZ]eZ\g\ih[_^m\ <iaZ\bk\_jghklv]eZ\g^he]m\ >iaZ\bkex[h\v]eZ\gd Jh^bg_\ >iaZ\bkij_^Zgghklv]eZ\gJh^bg_\ >iaZ\bkaZ[hlZ]eZ\gh lh\Zjbs_\ Ii aZ\bk\gbfZgb_ ]eZ\g d ex^yf \ >i aZ\bk ^hklhbg ]eZ\g \gbfZgby\JiaZ\bkm^hklh_g]eZ\ggZ]jZ^u\ JiaZ\bkIh\b^ehbay[ehd± mijZ\e_gb_kmik nZkhevx± mijZ\e_gb_dbk_ev ba dexd\u ± mijZ\e_gb_ rdZn ^ey dgb] ± mijZ\e_gb_ \h^Zba jh^gbdZ ± mijZ\e_gb_ lbrbgZ ghqb ± mijZ\e_gb_ =jZffZlbq_kdh_agZq_gb_± mdZau\ZxlgZij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdY[ehqgh_ ih\b^eh ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ nZkhe_\uc kmi ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ dexd\_gguc dbk_ev ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ dgb`guc rdZn± kh]eZkh\Zgb_jh^gbdh\Zy\h^Z± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ghqgZylbrbgZ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_< wlbokeh\hkhq_lZgbyoijbagZd\ujZ`_g[he__dhgdj_lgh < jZa^mfv_ aZ\bk b^lb ]eZ\g mijZ\e_gb_ b^lb]eZ\g ih iehsZ^b aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ Bgnhjfbjh\Zlv]eZ\gh[hldjulbb aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_h[hldjulbb]eZ\g\uklZ\db aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ Ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv ]eZ\g \ ieZg_lZjbbaZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv]eZ\ggZe_dpbbaZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ Mihjgh aZ\bk lj_gbjh\Zlvky ]eZ\g ijbfudZgb_ lj_gbjh\Zlvky ]eZ\g \ l_q_gb_ hk_gb aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ Ih^hclb ]eZ\g d mkZ^v[_ aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ d ^_j_\_gkdhcaZ\bk mkZ^v[_ ]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_ JZkkdZau\Zlv ]eZ\g hkem`[_ aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ h kem`[_ ]eZ\g \ Zjfbb aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ F_qlZlv ]eZ\g h ih_a^d_ aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ hih_a^d_ ]eZ\g \ AZiheyjv_ aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_<g_aZighaZ\bk hklZgh\blvky ]eZ\g ijbfudZgb_ hklZgh\blvky ]eZ\g \g_^hmf_gv_aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_QmlvaZ\bk\b^g_lvky]eZ\gijbfudZgb_ \b^g_lvky ]eZ\g \ ih^g_[_kv_ aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_G_h`b^ZgghaZ\bkihy\blvky]eZ\gijbfudZgb_ihy\blvky ]eZ\g \ hl^Ze_gbb aZ\bk mijZ\e_gb_ F_^e_gghaZ\bk himkdZlvky ]eZ\g ijbfudZgb_ himkdZlvky ]eZ\g gZiZjZrxl_aZ\bkmijZ\e_gb_ Ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv gZ ij_^\u[hjghf fblbg]_ kemrZlv \uklmie_gb_dZg^b^ZlZijhbag_klb\a\hegh\Zggmxj_qvijh\_klb\u[hju^_e_]ZlZ \klj_lblvky k gZrbf ^_imlZlhf ]hehkh\Zlv aZ ba[jZggbdh\gZjh^ZLboh gZj_q aZ\bk kimklbeky ]eZ] ]eZ\g± ^_ckl\b_b_]hijbagZdijbkh_^bg_gb_>j_fe_l ]eZ] ]eZ\g gZ^ fhj_f kms aZ\bk ± ^_ckl\b_ b_]hh[t_dlmijZ\e_gb_IheyjgZy ijbe aZ\bk ghqv kms ]eZ\g ± ij_^f_l b _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_< lzfghcijbeaZ\bkimqbg_kms]eZ\g± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Yjdb_ijbeaZ\bka\_a^ukms]eZ\g± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_K \urbgukmsaZ\bkevzlky]eZ]]eZ\g± ^_ckl\b_b _]hf_klh mijZ\e_gb_=hem[h\Zlh_ ijbe aZ\bk kbygb_ kms ]eZ\g ± ij_^f_l b_]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Fzjl\Zy ijbe aZ\bk lbrbgZ kms ]eZ\g ± ij_^f_l b _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Ih\bkeZ ]eZ] ]eZ\g gZ^ fhj_f kms aZ\bk ± ^_ckl\b_ b_]hf_klhmijZ\e_gb_AZklu\rbfijbqaZ\bkfhj_fkms]eZ\g± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Kbg_\ZlucijbeaZ\bkhlk\_lkms]eZ\g± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_HaZjy_l]eZ]]eZ\g]eZ^vkmsaZ\bk± ij_^f_lb _]hh[t_dlmijZ\e_gb_<h^gmx ijbe aZ\bk ]eZ^v kms ]eZ\g ± ij_^f_l b _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Kbg_\Zluc± kbgbckmnnbdkZevguc=eZ^v± ]eZ^dbc[_kkmnnbdkguc <_jghklv gZjh^guf ljZ^bpbyf ij_^Zgghklv ^_em bklbggZyojZ[jhklv ih^ebggh_ [_kkljZrb_ lZeZgleb\uc kdmevilhj ]_gbZevgh_ijhba\_^_gb_bklbgghgZjh^guciZfylgbdih]b[rbfh[_ebkdba]jZgblZIh^ebggh_ijbeaZ\bk[_kkljZrb_kms]eZ\g± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_Bklbggh gZj_q aZ\bk gZjh^guc ijbe ]eZ\g ± ijbagZdijbagZdZijbfudZgb_H[_ebkdkms]eZ\gba]jZgblZkmsaZ\bk± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdmijZ\e_gb_ AgZ_l_ eb \u mdjZbgkdmx ghqv" \hijhkbl ij_^e H \u g_agZ_l_ mdjZbgkdhc ghqb ih\_kl\ \hkdebp ij_^eh` <kfhljbl_kv\ g_z ih[m^ ij_^e K k_j_^bgu g_[Z ]ey^bl f_kyp ih\_kl\ij_^e G_h[tylguc g_[_kguc k\h^ jZa^Zeky jZa^\bgmeky _sz g_h[tylg__ih\_kl\ij_^e=hjblb ^urblhgih\_kl\ij_^e< dhgp_ij_^eh`_gbyklZ\ylkylhqdZ\hijhkbl_evgucb \hkdebpZl_evgucagZdb<hkdebpZl_evgu_ ij_^eh`_gby ^hihegbl_evgh \ujZ`Zxl wfhpbb qm\kl\Z ]h\hjys_]h beb ibrms_]h b ijhbaghkylky k hkh[hcbglhgZpb_c\hkdebpZgby,Ex[ex baty\blgZdel_[yI_ljZl\hj_gv_Ex[ex baty\blgZdel\hckljh]bckljhcguc\b^<eZ^bfbjb ibkZe[u mkeh\ggZdeh^u>ZHev]Zg_qblZeZ baty\blgZdeboRmfbrmfb ih\_eblgZdeihkemrgh_\_ljbeh<hegmcky ih\_eblgZdeih^hfghcM]jxfuchd_Zgih[m^blDZdhcibkZl_evgugq_ \ fh^_"\hijhkbl;_edZlZf`b\zl baty\blgZdejmqgZy>ZaZl_cgbpZdZdZyDlhlZf"\hijhkblQ_cdhgv\h\_kvhihjIh]jhaghciehsZ^bg_kzlkybaty\blgZde" \hijhkbl:KImrdbg,, Ijb_a`Zc ih\_eblgZde lu d gZfih[m^bl Y [u kh]eZkbeky mkeh\ggZde k \Zr_c ijhkv[hc Lu [u ihrze mkeh\ggZde d \jZqmih[m^bl ;_kihdhcgh j_yeb baty\blgZdeeZklhqdbL\hj_gb_± ijhba\_^_gb_jZ[hlZ<_ljbeh± iZjmkGugq_± l_i_jvk_cqZkG_k_lky± [_`blkdZq_l,Ijb_a`Zcqlh^_eZc"]eZ]heGn± ijb_a`Zlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ ih\_eblgZde\ _^qbke_\hebp_,,,Luqlh^_eZc" ijb_a`ZcB^ml\ baty\blgZde\ gZkl\j_f_gbkihjlkf_guDlhjZa]h\Zjb\Z_l \ baty\blgZde \ gZkl\j" <u g_ rmfbl_ \ ih\_eblgZde Lu [u d gZf aZrze \ mkeh\ghf gZde Dm^Z fuih_^_f \ baty\blgZde \ [m^\j" Ieh\pu lj_gbjh\Zebkv \baty\blgZde\ ijhr\j\ [Zkk_cg_ Y gZ ^gyo aZghq_\Ze gZ kl_ighf ha_j_ih\_kl\ Hgh ihqlbkiehrvaZjhkeh\ukhdbf dZfurhfih\_kl\GZk_j_^bg_[e_kl_eZmadZy ihehkZ qbklhc \h^u ih\_kl\ F_^e_ggh ]ZkeZ aZjy ih\_kl\ < kihdhcghc \h^_ hljZ`Zebkv i_j\u_ a\za^u ih\_kl\Kdhj_c [u ijhreZ ghqv ih\_kl\ \hkdebp I_j_^ jZkk\_lhf lj_\h`guc mlbguc djbd aZklZ\be f_gy hqgmlvky ih\_kl\ Hlq_]h[_kihdhbebkv mldb" \hijhkbl Dlh fh] bo ihlj_\h`blv" \hijhkbl DZdZylh l_gv f_evdgmeZ i_j_^ fhbfb ]eZaZfbqvblh djuevy_^\Z g_ aZ^_eb f_gy ih ebpm ih\_kl\ Kh\Z ih\_kl\ \hkdebp<hl dlh ]m[bl ilbp ih ghqZf ih\_kl\ \hkdebp ;_j_]bkv ghqgZyobsgbpZih[m^bl\hkdebpIhGGbdhgh\m,IjhreZ[uqlhk^_eZeZ"± ]eZ]Gn± ijhclb,,Ihkl± kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ mkeh\ggZde\ _^qbke_\ `_gj,,,Ghqvqlhk^_eZeZ[u"ijhreZ[u,=m[blqlh^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]Gn± ]m[blv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qbke_\ ebp_,,,Dlhqlh^_eZ_l"]m[bl,;_j_]bkvqlh^_eZc"± ]eZ]Gn± [_j_qvky,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ ih\_eblgZde\ _^qbke_\hebp_,,,Qlh^_eZc"[_j_]bkv<_l_j g_r_ehogzl]eZ\gqe_gZLbrbgZ]eZ\gqe_gLjh_i Iha^gyy ghqv ]eZ\gqe_g _klv \lhjhklqe_gu Fhj_rmfbl aZ hdghf ]eZ\gqe_gZ _klv \lhjhklqe_gu IZmkl L_fg_eh ]eZ\gqe_g Fheh^hc f_kyp ih\bk lhgdbf jh]hf gZ^^Zevg_cjhs_c]eZ\gqe_gZ_klv\lhjhklqe_guIZmkl , <kihfbgZ_lky fg_ jZggyy ih]h`Zy hk_gv^\mkhkljZkij IjhoeZ^gmx lbrbgm mljZ gZjmrZ_l kulh_ d\holZgv_^jha^h\^\mkhkljZkij< ihj_^_\r_f kZ^m^Ze_dh \b^gZ ^hjh]Z d rZeZrm ^\mkhkl jZkij <kx^m keZ\gh iZog_l y[ehdZfbh^ghkhkl jZkij >h \_q_jZ \ kZ^m lheiblky gZjh^ ^\mkhkljZkij L_fg__l h^ghkhkl g_jZkij ;h^jh b^zrv ^hfhch^ghkhkl jZkij Woh jZkdZlblky ih ]hjbahglm ^Ze_dh^Ze_dh^\mkhkljZkijB:;mgbg,, Ih^gyeky \_l_j ^\mkhkl g_jZkij < h^gm fbgmlm ieZfyh[o\Zlbeh \_kv ^hf ^\mkhkljZkijDjZkguc ^uf \bekygZ^djh\e_x^\mkhkljZkijKlzdeZ lj_sZeb^\mkhklg_jZkijBkdjuihe_l_eb h]g_gghc f_l_evx ^\mkhkl jZkij I H^gZ`^u yrze ih^hjh]_ba]hjh^Z ^\mkhkljZkij<_q_j_ehh^ghkhklg_jZkij DZa Hl aZkuoZxsbo ebklv_\ iZoeh hk_gvx h^ghkhkljZkijIZmklIha^gyy hk_gvh^ghkhkljZkij=jZqb me_l_eb^\mkhklg_jZkijG,,, Ghqv h^ghkhkl g_jZkij FZrbgZ ljh]Z_lky ^\mkhklg_jZkij >he]h [e_klbl \ l_fghl_ djZkguc nhgZjbd ^\mkhkljZkij Kh[jZ\rb_ky jZkoh^ylky ih ^hfZf ^\mkhkl jZkij Dm^Z \u _^_l_ ]jZ`^Zgbg" ^\mkhkl jZkij FZjlugh\ kgyeljm[dm^he]h jZa]h\Zjb\Ze ihl_e_nhgm^\mkhkljZkijGhqvxk\_`bc[_euc imrhd ihdjue klZjuc gZkl^\mkhkljZkij<H\_qdbg<_kv± keh]\ ± >\¶@± kh]ea\fy]d_ ± >w@± ]eZkgm^k ± >k¶@± kh]e]emofy]dv ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZ[md\ua\mdZ Eu`gbdb lj_gbjmxlky <u lj_gbjmcl_kv eu`gbdbh[jZs_gb_ J_[ylZ ijbreb \ fma_c J_[ylZ \u ijboh^bl_\ fma_c h[jZs_gb_:]jhghfhkfhlj_ej`Zgh_ ihe_Dhehkblkyj`Zgh_ihe_H[jZs_gb_ g_ \eby_l gZ jZkijhkljZg_gghklv ij_^eh`_gby hgh\eby_lgZ_]hhkeh`g_gghklvY ibrm wlbkljhdb\ ^_j_\g_± kh]eZkh\Zgb_\ ebp_b qbke_KheB ghlu _klvb bgkljmf_glu _klv± g_kh]eZkh\ZguDj?klv gZ<he]_mlzk ± g_kh]eZkh\ZguI_kgy;mjy f]ehxg_[hdjh_l ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ \ ebp_ b qbke_ I @mjZ\ev ghkhf klmdklmd ih lZj_ed_ ± g_ kh]eZkh\Zgu Ijbr\ Ijb[j_`guc ljhklgbd keZ[h aZrmfbl ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_ \ ebp_ b qbke_ L LZlvygZiju] \ ^jm]b_k_gb± g_kh]eZkh\ZguI Ijm^ m`_aZklue ± kh]eZkh\Zgb_\ jh^_b qbke_IY f_klhbf ibrm ]eZ] wlb f_klhbf kljhdb kms \ ij_^eh] ^_j_\g_ kms Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhkl ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj,AZrmfblqlhk^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]Gn± aZrmf_lv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^g_i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ [m^\j\ _^qbke_\ ebp_,,,Ljhklgbdqlhk^_eZ_l"aZrmfbl,AZklueqlhk^_eZe"± ]eZ]Gn± aZklulv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^qbke_\ fm`jh^_,,,Ijm^qlhk^_eZe"aZklue, EbkbpZ \b^bl kujebkbpmkuj ie_gbeDjK jZa[hjhf \u[bjZc ^jma_c Dh]^Z dhjuklv k_[y ebqbghc ^jm`[u djh_lhgZ k_[_ ebrv yfm jh_l Dj Fbgmc gZk ims_ \k_o i_qZe_c b[Zjkdbc]g_\b [ZjkdZyex[h\v=jAZh[eZdZhjze gZ\_joDZ\dZakdbo]hjih^gyekyDjFu [Zkg_cgbdh]hh[b^_lvg_ohl_ebDjQm^_g>g_ijijblbohcih]h^_dh]^Zfqbl kd\have_kZb ]hjuihegu_\h^uk\hb=G_ e_gbl_kv d ibkvf_pmijbibkZlvqlhgZ^h L\Zj^ FheqZebg \Zf gZkdmqbe [u _^\Z eb dh]^Z [ khrebkv dhjhq_k gbf=jDhjuklv± \u]h^ZEbqbgZ± \b^fZkdZI < i_j\uo qbkeZo Z\]mklZ \ kj_^g_c ihehk_ Jhkkbb ihki_\Z_l[jmkgbdZj_ZevgucnZdl<b^_ebeb\uwlhlfZe_gvdbc\_qgha_ezguc dmklZjgbq_d" \hafh`guc nZdl ?]h \_d ^hklb]Z_l [he__ e_lj_ZevgucnZdlIh[u\Zcl_e_lhf\ e_kmb ihkfhljbl_gZwlh]h^he]h`bl_ey`_eZl_evgucnZdlDZ`^uc hohlgh gZ[jZe [u [jmkgbdb ih[hevr_ `_eZl_evgucnZdlGhh[jZsZcl_kvk y]h^gbdhfhklhjh`gh`_eZl_evgucnZdl;_j_]bl_wlhqm^_kgh_jZkl_gb_`_eZl_evgucnZdlHghohjhrhkem`blex^yfj_ZevgucnZdlIh>Am_\mDZ`^uchohlgh gZ[jZe[u [jmkgbdb ih[hevr_Ih^\b]iZiZgbgp_\fZy] G_aZ[u\Z_fuc^_gv<i_j\u_\ bklhjbbbamq_gby:jdlbdb gZ ^j_cnmxsb_ ev^u \ jZchg_ K_\_jgh]h ihexkZ himkdZ_lky q_lujzofhlhjguc kZfhezl GZ _]h [hjlmgZoh^ylkyq_luj_[m^msboabfh\sbdZ± q_luj_bkke_^h\Zl_ey< ijh^he`_gb_ ^_\ylb f_kyp_\ gZ ev^bg_ ^he`gu [ueb `blv bjZ[hlZlv gZqZevgbd iheyjghc klZgpbb B\Zg >fbljb_\bq IZiZgbg[bheh] Izlj I_ljh\bq Rbjrh\ Zkljhghf b fZ]gblheh] ?\]_gbcDhgklZglbgh\bq Nz^hjh\ b jZ^bkl Wjgkl L_h^hjh\bq Dj_gd_ev <wlhf^j_cn_klZ\r_fe_]_g^Zjguf[ueh\kzebr_gbye_^_gysbcoheh^ g_bklh\kl\h imj]b jbkd b g_ba\_klghklv Gm`gu [ueb h]jhfgh_ fm`_kl\h mihjkl\h bkdexqbl_evgZy ij_^Zgghklv ex[bfhfm ^_em qlh[u ex^b hklZ\rb_ky gZ ev^bg_ fh]eb ij_h^he_lv \k_ljm^ghklb b ^h[blvky mki_oZ Q_l\_jh hl\Z`guo abfh\sbdh\ [e_klys_\uihegbebihklZ\e_ggu_aZ^Zqb< n_\jZe_ ]h^Z wdki_^bpbx kgyeb kh ev^bgu K l_o ihj \jmkkdhfyaud_ihy\behkvgh\h_keh\h± iZiZgbgpu;he__ ihem\_dZ ijhreh k lh]h fhf_glZ dh]^Z IZiZgbg b _]h^jmavy gZqZeb k\hc bklhjbq_kdbc ^j_cn AZ wlh \j_fygZev^ZoK_\_jgh]h E_^h\blh]h hd_ZgZ [ueh hj]Zgbah\Zgh [he__ ^\Z^pZlb^j_cnmxsbo klZgpbc gh g_ ihf_jd \ iZfylb gZjh^Z ih^\b] iZiZgbgp_\Klbevl_dklZ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbcLjm^ghklb± ljm^guckmnnbdkZevguckihkh[Kgy¶eb± keh]Zk ± >k@± kh]e]emol\g ± >g¶@± kh]ea\fy]dy ± >Z@± ]eZkgm^Zjge ± >e¶@kh]ea\fy]db ± >b@± ]eZkg[_am^[md\a\mdh\,>j_cnmxsb_± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_Ev^udZdb_"^j_cnmxsb_Gn± ^j_cnmxsbc,,Ihkl± ^_ckl\gZkl\jg_kh\\b^G_ihkl± \ bfiZ^\hfgh`q,,,Ev^udZdb_"^j_cnmxsb_,Q_luj_± qbkebl_evgh_GZoh^ylkykdhevdh"q_luj_bkke_^h\Zl_eyGn± q_luj_,,Ihkl± dhebq_kl\ijhklp_eh_G_ihkl± \ Bi,,,GZoh^ylkydlh"q_luj_bkke_^h\Zl_ey,GZrbjhdhcmebp_klhye ]jmah\bdEx^bjZ[hlZebkihdhcghkihjh fheqZeb\h: \klhjhgd_klhyebxghrZb ^_\mrdZb jZa]h\Zjb\Zebm\e_q_ggh b [_aaZ\_lghih\_kl\h\Zgb_>_\mrdZ \ jhah\hc dhnl_ b \ `_eluolmneyogZ[hkmgh]m[ueZdjmigZy ihegZy jmkZy k lzfgufb fZlh\h ih[ezkdb\Zxsbfb dZdfbg^Zebgu]eZaZfbqmlvdhkh\ZlufbHllh]hqlhhgZqmlvdhkbeZhgZkfhlj_eZgZxghrmg_fgh]hk[hdmhibkZgb_,, XghrZ [ue ^ebgguc g_kdeZ^guc kmlmeh\Zluc \ kbg_c aZklbjZgghcdhkh\hjhld_k dhjhldbfb^ey_]h^ebgguojmdjmdZ\Zfbih^ihykZgguc madbf j_f_rdhf \ k_juo \ dhjbqg_\mx ihehkdmdhjhldh\Zluo [jxdZo b \ lZihqdZo gZ [hkm gh]m >ebggu_ ijyfu_lzfgu_ \hehku g_ kemrZebkv _]h dh]^Z hg ]h\hjbeiZ^Zeb gZ eh[gZmrbb hglhb ^_ehaZdb^u\Zeboj_adbf^\b`_gb_f]heh\uEbph _]h ijbgZ^e_`Zeh d lhfm lbim [e_^guo ebpdhlhju_ ihqlb g_[_jzlaZ]ZjD lhfm`_xghrZ[uey\ghaZkl_gqb\Gh\ \ujZ`_gbb_]hebpZ[uehklhevdhijbjh^gh]hxfhjZb \lh`_\j_fyaZlZzggh]h \hl\hl ]hlh\h]h \kiuogmlv \^hogh\_gbyqlh wlh \hegh\Zeh ^_\mrdmhgZkfhlj_eZ_fm \ ebphg_hlju\ZykvhibkZgb_Kihjh± [ukljhkeZ`_ggh^jm`ghFheqZeb\h± lboh[_krmfghg_jZa]h\Zjb\ZyJZa]h\Zjb\Zeb± [_k_^h\Zebh[sZebkvM\e_q_ggh± k bgl_j_khfkZfhaZ[\_ggh>ebggu_± dhjhldb_L_fgu_± k\_leu_J_adbf± ieZ\gufIh:NZ^__\mGZ ij_^eh]rbjhdhc ijbemebp_ kmsklhye ]eZ]]jmah\bdkmsIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijDhjhldh\Zluo± dhjhldbckmnnbdkZevguckihkh[AZlZ_ggh]h± aZlZblvkmnnbdkZevguckihkh[K[hdm± [hdijbklZ\hqghkmnnbdkZevguckihkh[ ;_kdhjuklguc ± `Z^guc ^hklhbgkl\Z ± g_^hklZldb Zdlb\guc± iZkkb\guc\_k_eblvky± lhkdh\Zlvhldjh\_gguc± kdjulguc kdjhfghklv ± aZagZckl\h jZkk_yggh ± khkj_^hlhq_ggh kkhjblvky± fbjblvkyh^h[jylv± ihjbpZlvijbe_`guc± e_gb\uc<k_ wlbZglhgbfuh[t_^bg_gul_fhcq_eh\_q_kdbodZq_kl\;_kdhjuklguc q_eh\_d `Z^guc ^h ^_g_] \uy\e_ggu_g_^hklZldb jZ[hlu mdjZrZxsb_ _]h ^hklhbgkl\Z jZkk_yggh kemrZlv khkj_^hlhq_gghjZ[hlZlv K\b^_l_evkl\h ]eZ\g kh\j_f_ggbdh\ aZ\bkbf mijZ\e_gb_ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdfhbaZ\bkbfjh\_kgbdb]eZ\gkh]eZkh\Zgb_ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd h[s_kl\_ggu_ aZ\bkbfb^_Zeu]eZ\gkh]eZkh\Zgb_ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdfm`_kl\_gghaZ\bkbf^_j`Zlvky]eZ\gijbfudZgb_^_ckl\b_b _]hijbagZd kb]gZe ]eZ\g h[ hiZkghklb aZ\bkbf mijZ\e_gb_ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd j_]mebjh\Zlv ]eZ\g ^\b`_gb_ aZ\bkbfijbfudZgb_^_ckl\b_b ij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^blih^ebgghaZ\bkbfkf_euc]eZ\gijbfudZgb_ijbagZdijbagZdZ\jmqblv ]eZ\g Zll_klZl aZ\bkbf ijbfudZgb_ ^_ckl\b_ bij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuc hgh i_j_oh^bl ihq_lguc aZ\bkbf ^biehf]eZ\g kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ij_^f_l b _]h ijbagZd ihemqZlv ]eZ\gklbi_g^bx aZ\bkbf ijbfudZgb_ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuchghi_j_oh^bl Dhfm ihjmqbeb ijb]eZkblv bg`_g_jZ DmavfbgZ gZ \_q_j\klj_qb k \_l_jZgZfb aZ\h^Z" Bg`_g_jZ DmavfbgZ ihjmqbeb ijb]eZkblv <heh^_ b Bjbg_ < dhgp_ Dh]h ihjmqbeb ijb]eZkblv<heh^_ b Bjbg_ gZ \_q_j \klj_qb k \_l_jZgZfb aZ\h^Z" <heh^_ bBjbg_ihjmqbebijb]eZkblvbg`_g_jZDmavfbgZ\ dhgp_Dm^Zihjmqbeb ijb]eZkblv <heh^_ b Bjbg_ bg`_g_jZ DmavfbgZ" <heh^_b Bjbg_ ihjmqbebijb]eZkblvbg`_g_jZDmavfbgZgZ\_q_j\klj_qbk \_l_jZgZfbaZ\h^Z\ dhgp_ Gm`gu_ pblZlu y ih^[bjZe ^he]h h[jZlguc ± Y ^he]hih^[bjZe gm`gu_ pblZlu ijyfhc Hg \gbfZl_evgh i_j_qblZekhqbg_gb_ ijyfhc± Khqbg_gb_hgi_j_qblZe\gbfZl_evghh[jZlgucFuohjhrhjZ[hlZeb\ kZ^mijyfhc± < kZ^mfujZ[hlZebohjhrhh[jZlguc;Z[mrdZ ihkZ^beZ gZ ^Zq_ jhfZrdb b fZj]Zjbldbijyfhc ±JhfZrdbb fZj]ZjbldbihkZ^beZgZ^Zq_[Z[mrdZh[jZlgucFuaZibkZebkv\ k_gly[j_ \ rdhemieZ\Zgby± FuaZibkZebkv \ rdhem ieZ\Zgby \ k_gly[j_ <u [m^_l_ mqZkl\h\Zlv \eu`ghf djhkk_ \ yg\Zj_ ± < yg\Zj_\u[m^_l_mqZkl\h\Zlv\ eu`ghfdjhkk_Khj_\gh\Zgbydhgvdh[_`p_\khklhylky\ Lme_ \h\j_fydZgbdme± Khj_\gh\Zgbydhgvdh[_`p_\\h\j_fydZgbdmekhklhylky\ Lme_Fu[m^_fjZ[hlZlvgZkZ^h\hfmqZkld_ohjhrh<k_]^Zgm`ghkemrZlvh[tykg_gbymqbl_ey\gbfZl_evghLu^he`_g \uihegylvaZ^Zgb_ijZ\bevgh , < m]em klhye rdZn k ihkm^hc gZ kl_g_ \bk_e ^biehfhnbp_jkdbcaZkl_dehfb \jZfd_hdhehg_]hdjZkh\Zebkvem[hq:KImrdbggu_dZjlbgdbhibkZgb_,,M ^\_jby klhedgmekyk q_eh\_dhf\ukhdh]hjhklZhq_gvlheklufb ]jmagufEbph_]hjy[h_b imoeh_\ujZ`Zehe_gvb [hevr_gbq_]h djhohlgu_ ]eZadb lZd b kebiZebkv b ]m[u ehkgbebkv dZdihke_kgZhibkZgb_BKLmj]_g_\,,,< wlmfbgmlmfyl_`gbdbgZ[_`ZebgZgZkb \hj\Zebkv\ dj_ihklv;ZjZ[Zgmfhed]Zjgbahg[jhkbejm`vyf_gykrb[ebk gh]gh y \klZe \f_kl_ k fyl_`gbdZfb \hrze\ dj_ihklv ih\_kl\h\Zgb_:KImrdbg:\lhdhehggZaZ^_j`ZeZkvgZi_j_\Ze_GZi_j_\Ze_Z\lhdhehggZ aZ^_j`ZeZkv GZ i_j_\Ze_ aZ^_j`ZeZkv Z\lhdhehggZ Mljhf]_heh]b\ureb\ ]hju=_heh]b\ureb\ ]hjumljhfMljhf \ ]hju \ureb ]_heh]b <_jlhezl ^hklZ\be f_^bdZf_glu<_jlhezlf_^bdZf_glu^hklZ\beF_^bdZf_glu^hklZ\be\_jlhe_lBglhgZpbyij_^eh`_gby[he__gZijy`zggZylh]^Zdh]^Zeh]bq_kdh_ m^Zj_gb_ iZ^Z_l gZ keh\h klhys__ \ k_j_^bg_ beb \ dhgp_ij_^eh`_gby,DZ\dZa ih^hfghxH^bg\ \urbg_KlhxgZ^kg_]Zfb m djZyklj_fgbguHjzek hl^Zezgghcih^gy\rbkv\_jrbguIZjblg_ih^\b`ghkhfghcgZjZ\g_,,=Zkg_l^_gvAZdhkh]hjhfJZaeb\Z_lky aZdZlA\hgdbcf_kyp \uc^_lkdhjhIh]meylvihdjurZfoZlKdhjha\za^u lbobfk\_lhfMiZ^mlgZ^ghj_dbY ijhsZxkvk lzieuf e_lhf;_ai_qZebb lhkdb:KImrdbgFBkZdh\kdbcQm^_g >g_ijijblbohcih]h^_=HdZdZykljZggZy[ueZ wlZ ghqv ;mg <kz baf_gbehkv djm]hf baf_gbehkv gZ]eZaZob g_aZf_lghLhqghdhe^h\kl\h k\_jrbehkvKPY e_[z^qbdhf jZ[hlZxe_k gZ[_j_]\ulZkdb\ZxDZaB \hlm`_g_magZlvdhjy\uokmqv_\H`bebaZa_e_g_eb \_l\bIjbr\IhklZgh\dZ eh]bq_kdh]h m^Zj_gby khijh\h`^Z_lky baf_g_gb_fihjy^dZkeh\\ l_okemqZyodh]^Zgm`ghih^q_jdgmlvg_h[uqghklvwfhpbhgZevghklv ijhbkoh^ys_]h beb i_j_^Zlv hkh[_gghklb jZa]h\hjghcj_qb Kgh\Z ihey ihey G_l djZy wlhfm fh]mq_fm ijhklhjm ;_kdjZcghklv ihe_c \ kl_ighc q_jgha_fghc ahg_ ihjZ`Z_l g_ lhevdhq_eh\_dZ \i_j\u_ m\b^_\r_]h ihey Wlhl ijhklhj m^b\ey_l b lh]hdlh \ ihe_ \klj_qZ_l b ijh\h`Z_l dZ`^mx \_kgm M^b\ey_l ihlhfmqlhj_^dh\klj_qZxlkyex^b[_afZrbgIhjZabl_evgZ kbeZ fZrbgu \ gZr_ \j_fy Ex^b mijZ\eyxlfZrbgZfb b kZfb ih^qbgyxlky jblfm l_ogbdb JZa\_ lhevdh gZkdehgZogZ^yjhfgZh]hjh^Zom\b^bl_hl^_evgu_]jmiiuex^_cgZjmqghcjZ[hl_Z lZd± \_a^_fZrbgZfZrbgZIh=Ljh_ihevkdhfmIhey¶ ± keh]Zi >i@± kh]e]emol\_j^iZjgh >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^e >e¶@± kh]ea\hgdfy]dg_iZjgy >Z@± ]eZkgm^Zjg[md\ua\mdZ;_kdjZcghklv± [_kdjZcgbckmnnbdkZevguc,M^b\ey_lqlh^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]Gn± m^b\eylv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\blgZde\ gZkl\j_f \ _^qbke_\ ebp_,,,Ijhklhjqlh^_eZ_l"m^b\ey_l,M\b^bl_qlhk^_eZ_l_"± ]eZ]Gn± m\b^_lv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± < baty\blgZde\ [m^\j_f\hfgh`qbke_\hebp_,,,<uqlhk^_eZ_l_"m\b^bl_,<j_fyqlh"± kms_kl\Gn± \j_fy,,Ihkl± g_h^mrgZjbpkjjh^gZfyG_ihkl± \ <i,,,IhjZabl_evgZdh]^Z"\ gZr_\j_fy;bh]jZnby± hibkZgb_qv_ceb[h`bagbb ^_yl_evghklb[b[ebh]jZnby ± i_j_qbke_gb_ b hibkZgb_ dgb] b ^jm]bo i_qZlguo ba^Zgbc kibkhd ebl_jZlmju ih dZdhfmeb[h \hijhkm Keh\Z [bh]jZnby b [b[ebh]jZnby \dexqZxl\ k\hckhklZ\qZklb]j_q_kdbokeh\[bh [bhk ± ©`bagvª [b[ebh [b[ebh ± ©dgb]Zª ]jZn ]jZnh ±©ibrmªJZchggZy[b[ebhl_dZbamqZlv[bheh]bx^\hcdZih]_h]jZnbbIh^ebgguc^hdmf_glgZrdZg^b^Zl\uklmie_gb_gZfblbg]_\klj_qZlv^_e_]ZpbxgZjh^gu_^_imlZlujZkihjy`_gb_^bj_dlhjZ h[yaZgghklb ]jZ`^Zg Zll_klZl aj_ehklb jZ[hlZlv ih ki_pbZevghklb< bgklblml_ijbgbfZeblhevdhih^ebggu_^hdmf_gluK_]h^gy ]jmiiZklm^_glh\ih_^_l\ Zwjhihjl\klj_qZlv^_e_]ZpbxIhemq_gb_Zll_klZlZaj_ehklbhq_gv\Z`gh^eydZ`^h]hq_eh\_dZIh^ebgguc aZ\bkbf ijbe ^hdmf_gl ]eZ\g kms ± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_GZr f_klhbf aZ\bkbf dZg^b^Zl ]eZ\g kms ± ij_^f_l b_]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_<uklmie_gb_ ]eZ\g kms gZ fblbg]_ aZ\bkbf kms kij_^e± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdmijZ\e_gb_<klj_qZlv]eZ\g]eZ]he^_e_]ZpbxaZ\bkbfkms± ^_ckl\b_b ij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^bl ijbfudZgb_GZjh^gu_ aZ\bkbf ijbeZ] ^_imlZlu ]eZ\g kms ± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdkh]eZkh\Zgb_JZkihjy`_gb_ ]eZ\g kms ^bj_dlhjZ aZ\bkbf kms ±ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdmijZ\e_gb_H[yaZgghklb]eZ\gkms]jZ`^ZgaZ\bkbfkms± ij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdmijZ\e_gb_:ll_klZl ]eZ\g kms aj_ehklb aZ\bkbf kms ± ij_^f_l b_]hijbagZdmijZ\e_gb_JZ[hlZlv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he ih ki_pbZevghklb aZ\bkbf kms kij_^e± ^_ckl\b_b ij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^blijbfudZgb_ E_[_^b kms klZ^hf e_l_eb ba oheh^ghc klhjhgu \ lzieu_a_feb Hgb f_klhbf e_l_eb q_j_a fhjy H^bg fheh^hc e_[_^vkms_kl\k qbkeble_l_e ihaZ^b\k_oKbeukms_kl\_]hhkeZ[_ebEGLheklhc Ih_a^ kms_kl\ fqZeky \ g_ykgmx ^Zev b y f_klhbf\kihfgbe abfgxxghqv\ ]hjZoIZmkl<k_f_klhbfijblboeb G_kdhevdh q_eh\_d f_klhbfkms_kl\ h]eygmehkv Bgu_ f_klhbf \a^jh]gmeb >jm]b_ f_klhbf hlhreb \ klhjhgm F = JZa\_\Zebkv ^\Z ihedh\uo agZf_gb qbkeblkms_kl\ih^gylu_\ukhdh:GLFuk lh\Zjbs_f f_klhbfkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf \u_oZeb ^h aZdZlZ khegpZ Rhe LZgpmxsb_ ijbqZklb_l_kgbebkv b lhedZeb ^jm] ^jm]Z D <hl jZa^Zehky ©Zmª f_`^hf_l\^Ze_d_GLZf]^_kZ^behkv khegp_kms_kl\blh[hagZqbeky keZ[uc jmfyg_p kms_kl\bl aZjb Rmdr ;ue m`_ ihe^_gv kms_kl\bl dh]^Z fu f_klhbf \ha\jZlbebkv \Kl_iZgqbdh\h>hkl>hfhl^uoZkms_kl\blkms_kl\blklhye gZ[m]j_ihjhkr_f]mklufhkbggbdhfb klZjufb_eyfbIZmkl ;hevrbgkl\h agZdhfuo j_[yl kms_kl\bl kms_kl\bl m`_jZat_oZehkv ih ^ZqZf : = ;Zelbckdh_ fhj_ ijbeZ]kms_kl\bl]em[hdh\^Zzlky \ fZl_jbd?\jhiuGF Ih_a^ kms_kl\ fqZeky \ g_ykgmx ^Zev b y f_klhbf\kihfgbe abfgxxghqv\ ]hjZo> @b > @ <k_ f_klhbf ijblboeb G_kdhevdh q_eh\_d f_klhbfkms_kl\ h]eygmehkv Bgu_ f_klhbf \a^jh]gmeb >jm]b_f_klhbfhlhreb \ klhjhgm> @> @> @> @ ;ue m`_ihe^_gvkms_kl\bldh]^Zfu f_klhbf\ha\jZlbebkv \ Kl_iZgqbdh\h> @dh]^Z ;hevrbgkl\h agZdhfuo j_[yl kms_kl\bl kms_kl\bl m`_jZat_oZehkv ih^ZqZf> @<_ebdZyHl_q_kl\_ggZy\hcgZ gbdh]^Zg_[m^_laZ[ulZjmkkdbfgZjh^hfJhkkbckdZyN_^_jZpby ± h^ghbakZfuo[hevrbo]hkm^Zjkl\fbjZ@_e_agZy^hjh]Z lygmeZkvih[_kdjZcg_ckl_ib^hkZfuo]hjIheh\bgZ^hfZ [ueZaZgylZgZrbfbkhk_^yfbGZklhygd_klhyehg_kdhevdhZ\lhfh[be_cQZklvajbl_e_c [ueZ\ [mn_l_b g_\b^_eZgZqZeZij_^klZ\e_gbyFuk lh\Zjbs_f ^_eZ_fmjhdb \f_kl_H^bgba]bfgZklh\ miZek [jmkv_\b ih\j_^bejmdm:gxlbgu]eZadbih^Zj_ggu_fheh^ufq_eh\_dhfklhyeb\ djZkb\hc\Za_Hdhehkhlgbq_eh\_d kh[jZehkvgZfblbg]\hae_a^Zgbykm^ZKlZcdZ\hjh[v_\gZohoeb\rbkvkb^_eZgZ^_j_\_, L_dlh hiha^Ze g_m\b^_ebi_j\h]h^_ckl\byiv_ku±Hiha^Z\rb_ g_m\b^_ebi_j\h]h^_ckl\byiv_kuL_dlhijbkmlkl\h\ZegZj_i_lbpbb]hjyqhiha^jZ\bebj_`bkkzjZ± Ijbkmlkl\h\Z\rb_gZj_i_lbpbb]hjyqhiha^jZ\bebj_`bkkzjZL_dlhgZoh^beky \ l_Zlj_ Zieh^bjh\Zeb ZjlbklZf ± GZoh^b\rb_ky \ l_Zlj_Zieh^bjh\ZebZjlbklZf,, L_ dlh [ue gZ ^_`mjkl\_ \gbfZl_evgh ijh\_jyeb \oh^gu_ [be_lu ± >_`mjgu_ \gbfZl_evgh ijh\_jyeb \oh^gu_ [be_luLhldlh_^_l\_johf[ukljh^hklZ\blibkvfhZ^j_kZlm± <_joh\hc[ukljh^hklZ\blibkvfhZ^j_kZlm@be klZjbd kh k\h_x klZjmohc m kZfh]hkbg_]h fhjyIDhf_g^ZglrZk ^hq_jvx m^ZebebkvI;Z[mrdZk \gmqdhc ijbrebd gbf \_q_jhf Ijbr\ GbdheZc k >_gbkh\uf oh^beb ih aZeZfELKlZjbddj_klvygbg k [ZljZdhf rze ih^\_q_je_kdhfDjIh^e_`Zs__ \ujZ`_gh kbglZdkbq_kdb g_^_ebfuf keh\hkhq_lZgb_f \ lhf kemqZ_ dh]^Z kdZam_fh_ klhbl \h fgh`_kl\_gghf qbke_kfij_^eh` GZr rhnzj ± ih`behc aZ]hj_euc fm`qbgZ dlh" kms_kl\bl Hg f_^e_ggh \_^zl qlh ^_eZ_l" ]eZ]he Z\lh[mk ih ]hjghc^hjh]_ GZ x]haZiZ^_ \ha\urZxlky qlh ^_eZxl" ]eZ]he [_eu_\_jrbguWev[jmkZIhijhbkoh`^_gbxWev[jmk ± ihlmorbc\medZgqlh" kms_kl\bl Dhglmju kg_`gh]h \_ebdZgZ ijZ\bevgu b djZkb\u dZdh\u"djZldijbeZ] DhgqbeZkv baty\blgZde e_lgyy lzieZy ghqv> @ AZgbfZ_lky baty\blgZde gZ^ e_khf mlj_ggyy aZjy> @ Kdhjh\ahc^zl baty\blgZde h[kmrbl baty\blgZde jhkm lzieh_ khegurdh> @;m^_ljZ^h\Zlvky baty\blgZde\ky ijbjh^Z> @KF Fu dj_idh ijb\yaZeb baty\blgZde gZrb iZeZldb> @BgZq_bo[ukhj\Ze mkeh\gh_gZde\_l_j> @:jk,Ijhr_^r_]h\j_f_gb Ih mljZf gZ^ iheyfb jZkklbeZeky nhjfZ baty\blgZdeijhr\j_fy ]mklhc iZj Fu \b^_eb nhjfZ baty\blgZdeijhr\j_fy gZ djurZo bafhjhav LZye nhjfZ baty\blgZdeijhr\j_fyfhdjuckg_],,Ih\_ebl_evgh]hgZdehg_gbyJZa[_jbl_kvnhjfZih\_eblgZde\ wlhcaZ^Zq_JZkkfhljbnhjfZ ih\_eblgZde \gbfZl_evgh q_jlz` Ih^]hlh\vl_kv nhjfZih\_eblgZded kZfhklhyl_evghcjZ[hl_,,,Mkeh\gh]hgZdehg_gby ;_a lj_gbjh\db y g_ \uihegbe [u nhjfZ mkeh\ggZde ghjfihieZ\ZgbxKoh^be[u nhjfZmkeh\ggZdeluihke_rdheu\[b[ebhl_dm=eZ]heu \ mkeh\ghf gZdehg_gbb baf_gyxlky ih qbkeZf b \_^bgkl\_gghfqbke_± ihjh^Zf=eZ]heu \ ih\_ebl_evghf gZdehg_gbb mihlj_[eyxlky h[uqgh \nhjf_ ]h ebpZ g_ baf_gyxlky ih \j_f_gZf Nhjfu ih\_ebl_evgh]h gZdehg_gby h[jZamxlky hl hkgh\u gZklhys_]h beb [m^ms_]hijhklh]h \j_f_gbk ihfhsvxkmnnbdkZb bebgme_\h]hkmnnbdkZ Hev]Z klZ\bl ]eZ]he gZkl\j_fy aZ\ljZd gZ klhe Yih^h`^m ]eZ]he [m^\j_fy l_[y m j_qdb <u dh]^Z \_jgzl_kv]eZ]he [m^\j_fy" AZ \hjhlZfb ihkeurZeky ]eZ]heijhr\j_fy rmf fZrbgu DZebldZ i_j_^ ^hfhf k lj_kdhf jZkiZogmeZkv ]eZ]he ijhr\j_fy Lu [u k[_]ZeZ ]eZ]hemkegZdehggZdheh^_paZ\h^hc<u gZg_zg_k_j^bl_kv]eZ]heih\_eblgZdehgIhq_fm\u fg_g_ibr_l_ ]eZ]hegZkl\j_fy"Ohly [u \u gZk ih`Ze_eb ]eZ]he mkegZde\ agZq_gbb ih\_e YehrZ^_cdhjfblv[m^m ]eZ]he[m^\j_fyK ljm^hfih^t_oZeb]eZ]he ijhr\j_fy hgb d djuevpm klhjh`db hl dhlhjh]h d e_km\_eZ ]eZ]heijhr\j_fyljhibgdZ:=Zc^ZjKdZam_fu_kh]eZkh\Zguk ih^e_`Zsbfb\ [m^ms_fb gZklhys_f\j_f_gb\ ebp_b qbke_Z \ijhr_^r_f± \ jh^_b qbke_?keb kdZam_fh_]eZ]he klhbl \ nhjf_ ih\_ebl_evgh]h gZdehg_gbylhhgkh]eZkm_lkyk ih^e_`Zsbf\ qbke_Z _keb\ nhjf_mkeh\gh]h± ihjh^Zfb qbkeZf,JZkiZogmeZkvqlhk^_eZeZ"± ]eZ]heGn± jZkiZogmlvky,,Ihkl± kh\\b^i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^qbke_\ `_gjh^_,,,DZebldZqlhk^_eZeZ"jZkiZogmeZkv,G_k_j^bl_kvqlh^_eZcl_"± ]eZ]heGn± k_j^blvky,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ ih\_eblgZde\hfgh`qbke_,,,<uqlh^_eZcl_"g_k_j^bl_kv <hdjm] f_gy ijhklbjZebkv ]eZ]he i_qZevgu_ imklugbi_j_k_q_ggu_ohefZfbb h\jZ]ZfbIjhkgm\rbkvihmljm^h\hevghiha^ghy m\b^_e ]eZ]heqlh[mjy mlboeZ ]eZ]he> _^__ijh[hjhl_ @qlh J_dZ _sz g_ aZfzjaeZ ]eZ]he b_z k\bgph\u_\hegu ]jmklghq_jg_eb ]eZ]he\ h^ghh[jZaguo[_j_]Zoihdjuluo[_eufkg_]hf> @b> @ijbqh[hjhl_@G_h`b^Zggu_ijhbkr_kl\bybf_\rb_\Z`gh_\ebygb_gZ\kxfhx`bagv^Zeb ]eZ]he \^jm] fh_c ^mr_ kbevgh_ b [eZ]h_ ihljyk_gb_ Y\a[_`Ze ]eZ]he ih fZe_gvdhc e_klgbp_ dhlhjZy \_eZ ]eZ]he \k\_lebpm b \ i_j\uc jZa hljh^m \hrze ]eZ]he \ dhfgZlm FZjvbB\Zgh\gu GZdhg_p fu \u_oZeb ]eZ]he ba dj_ihklguo \hjhl bgZ\_d]eZ]hehklZ\beb ;_eh]hjkdmxdj_ihklv:KImrdbg,I_j_k_q_ggu_± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_ImklugbdZdb_"i_j_k_q_ggu_Gn± i_j_k_q_gguc,,Ihkl± kljZ^Zlijhr\j_fykh\\b^G_ihkl± \ bf_gbliZ^_`_\hfgh`qbke_,,,ImklugbdZdb_"i_j_k_q_ggu_,Ihdjuluo± hkh[nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_< [_j_]ZodZdbo"ihdjuluoGn± ihdjuluc,,Ihkl± kljZ^Zlijhr\j_fykh\\b^G_ihkl± \ ij_^eiZ^_`_\hfgh`qbke_,,,< [_j_]ZodZdbo"ihdjuluo E_k ojZgbl gZkl\j_fy ihq\_ggmx \eZ]m kfy]qZ_lgZkl\j_fydebfZlhklZgZ\eb\Z_l gZkl\j_fykmob_b `Zjdb_\_lju h[hagZq_gb_ ihklhyggh]h ^_ckl\by IZmkl <hey b ljm^q_eh\_dZ^b\gu_^b\ul\hjyl gZkl\j_fyh[hagZq_gb_ihklhyggh]h ^_ckl\by G DZly \g_aZigh \kihfgbeZ i_kqZgmx ^hjh`dmIh ^hjh`d_ b^zl gZkl\j_fy hgZ kZfZ ± DZly Ih^ lmn_evdZfbojmklbl gZkl\j_fy i_khd <hehku lj_ie_l gZkl\j_fy \_l_jhdijb^Zgb_`b\hklbjZkkdZamh ijhrehf:GLLjm^± keh]l >l@± kh]e]emol\j >j@± kh]ea\hgdl\m >m@± ]eZkgm^Zjg^ >l@± kh]e]emol\[md\ua\mdZG_gZ^h^Z\Zlvimkluoh[_sZgbc± G_gZ^hgZijZkghh[_sZlvDhfZg^bj ^Ze ijbdZa h gZklmie_gbb ± DhfZg^bj ijbdZaZe gZklmiZlv>_\mrdZ hl^Z\ZeZij_^ihql_gb_fheh^hfmb djZkb\hfmxghr_\kbg_fdhklxf_± >_\mrdZij_^ihqeZfheh^h]hb djZkb\h]hxghrm\ kbg_fdhklxf_>bj_dlhj \g_k ij_^eh`_gb_ baf_gblv ]jZnbd jZ[hlu ± >bj_dlhjij_^eh`bebaf_gblv]jZnbdjZ[hluGZrZZjfbyh^_j`ZeZih[_^mgZ^ \jZ]hf± GZrZZjfbyih[_^beZ\jZ]ZHl mklZehklb hg gZqZe de_\Zlv ghkhf ± Hl mklZehklb hg gZqZeaZkuiZlvFZevqbrdb \k_]^Z aZ^bjZeb ghk i_j_^ h^ghdeZkkgbpZfb ±FZevqbrdb\k_]^Zij_ajbl_evghkfhlj_ebgZh^ghdeZkkgbpHl g_m^Zqb hg kh\k_f ih\_kbe ghk ± Hl g_m^Zqb hg kh\k_f aZ]jmklbe Ih^jm]Z dZ`^Zy lml lboh lhed ih^jm]m Dj Fu h[ZgZ]gmebkv^ZjZahfb o\Zlv af_xGHl_plhfhc_fmb ihex[bkvL , Khegp_ e_`Zeh g_kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy gZ aZims_gghcdemf[_ k p\_lZfb b gZ ljZ\ygbklhc em`Zcd_ Dhjbqg_\Zy [Z[hqdZkb^_eZ g_kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy gZ p\_ld_ b lh jZkimkdZeZ g_kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy lh k^\b]ZeZ g_kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy djueurdb A_feygu_ iqzeu fhogZlu_ lzfgu_ k [_eufb rbjhdbfbimrbklufb ihehkdZfb \hdjm] [jxrdZ kgh\Zeb g_kh\\b^ijhr\j_fy k p\_ldZ gZ p\_lhd keZ^dh ]m^_eb g_kh\\b^ijhr\j_fy : NZ^__\ ± hibkZgb_ >_ckl\by ijhbkoh^yl h^gh\j_f_ggh,, EbaZ\_lZ B\Zgh\gZ \klZeZ kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy \ugmeZkh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy ba dhfh^Z dexq \jmqbeZ kh\\b^ijhr\j_fy _]h =_jfZggm b ^ZeZ kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy _fm ih^jh[gh_ gZklZ\e_gb_ =_jfZgg ih`Ze kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy _z oheh^gmx [_ahl\_lgmx jmdm ihp_eh\Ze kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy __ gZdehgzggmx ]heh\m b \ur_e kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy : K Imrdbg± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_>_ckl\byke_^mxl^jm]aZ^jm]hf,,, Gh dh \k_fm ijb\udZ_l g_kh\\b^ gZkl\j_fy q_eh\_d B=_jZkbf ijb\ud kh\\b^ ijhr\j_fy gZdhg_p d ]hjh^kdhfm `blvxBKLmj]_g_\± jZkkm`^_gb_,< fZ_aZp\_eb lxeviZgu± < fZ_gZqZebbaty\blgZdeijhr\j_fyh[hagZqZ_lgZqZeh^_ckl\byp\_klblxeviZgu G_^Z\gh hlp\_eb lxeviZgu ± G_^Z\gh dhgqbeb baty\blgZde ijhr\j_fy h[hagZqZ_l dhg_p ^_ckl\by p\_klb lxeviZguM`_bxgvZ lxeviZgup\_lml± M`_bxgvZ lxeviZguijh^he`Zxl baty\blgZde gZkl\j_fy h[hagZqZ_l ijh^he`bl_evghklv^_ckl\byp\_klb,,Ku]jZe[u y k_cqZkk lh[hciZjlbx\ rZofZlu± Y ohqm baty\blgZde gZkl\j_fy h[hagZqZ_l `_eZl_evghklv ^_ckl\by ku]jZlv k lh[hciZjlbx\ rZofZlu,,, GbdZd g_ gZc^zl Hey k\hx l_ljZ^v ± Hey gbdZd g_ fh`_lbaty\blgZdegZkl\j_fyh[hagZqZ_l\hafh`ghklv^_ckl\bygZclb k\hxl_ljZ^v Hgb gZqgml ]hlh\blvky d dhgn_j_gpbb khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ± Hgb [m^ml ]hlh\blvky ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_± khklZ\gZynhjfZ[m^ms_]h\j_f_gbd dhgn_j_gpbb Hg ijh^he`Z_l aZgbfZlvky khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_± Hg [m^_l aZgbfZlvky ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ± khklZ\gZynhjfZ[m^ms_]h\j_f_gb Fheh^hc >m[jh\kdbc ohl_e aZgylvky ^_eZfb I <eZ^bfbjgZqbgZe kbevgh[_kihdhblvky I>_\hqdZi_j_klZeZieZdZlv Dhj< wlmghqv^he]hg_fh]mkgmlv >bfdZ:=K \hdaZeZ@_gyg_mki_eZihkeZlv l_e_]jZffmhlpm: = HgZ mf_eZ \h^blv fZrbgu ljZdlhju K :gl Y[ue ]hlh\ex[blv \_kvfbjEDbjbeej_rbegZ\_klblv fZlvN_^<u^he`guljm^blvky LH[hagZq_gby± kh\kihfh]Zl_evgufb]eZ]heZfb± k khq_lZgbyfb]eZ]heZk\yadb[ulv k djZldbfbijbeZ]Zl_evgufbY [uejZ^bo\b^_lvY [m^mjZ^ bo\b^_lvY jZ^ bo\b^_lvY [ue[ujZ^ bo\b^_lvLu[uejZ^ bo\b^_lvLu[m^_rvjZ^ bo\b^_lvLujZ^ bo\b^_lvLu[ue[ujZ^ bo\b^_lvFu[uebjZ^u bo\b^_lvFu[m^_fjZ^u bo\b^_lvFujZ^u bo\b^_lvFu[ueb[ujZ^u bo\b^_lv;jZl[uejZ^ bo\b^_lv;jZl[m^_ljZ^ bo\b^_lv;jZljZ^ bo\b^_lv;jZl[ue[ujZ^ bo\b^_lvK_kljZ[ueZjZ^Z bo\b^_lvK_kljZ[m^_ljZ^Z bo\b^_lvK_kljZjZ^Z bo\b^_lvK_kljZ[ueZ[ujZ^Z bo\b^_lv;jZlvy[uebjZ^u bo\b^_lv;jZlvy[m^mljZ^u bo\b^_lv;jZlvyjZ^u bo\b^_lv;jZlvy[ueb[ujZ^u bo\b^_lv< wlbokemqZyok ih^e_`Zsbfkh]eZkm_lkyb ]eZ]hek\yadZ[ulvb djZldZynhjfZijbeZ]Zl_evgh]h\ qbke_b jh^_KdZam_fu_kh]eZkh\Zguk ih^e_`Zsbfb\ [m^ms_fb gZklhys_f\j_f_gb\ ebp_b qbke_Z \ijhr_^r_f± \ jh^_b qbke_?keb kdZam_fh_]eZ]he klhbl \ nhjf_ ih\_ebl_evgh]h gZdehg_gbylhhgkh]eZkm_lkyk ih^e_`Zsbf\ qbke_Z _keb\ nhjf_mkeh\gh]h± ihjh^Zfb qbkeZf Q_eh\_d ^he`_g ljm^blvky djZldijbeZ] gn]eZ]heZkhklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ : = FujZ^u \_kvbat_a^blvkhklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ djZldijbeZ] gn]eZ]heZ fbjI < h^bghq_kl\_ kihkh[_g `blv khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ djZldijbeZ] gn]eZ]heZ g_ \kydbc Dj Lb]j ijb[eb`Zeky ]eZ]ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_Hg^he`_g[ueijhclbkhklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_djZldijbeZ][ulvgn]eZ]heZ[ebadh hl gZk :jk DZaZdb ijbgyebkv jZa\vxqb\Zlv khklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_]eZ]gn]eZ]heZehrZ^_c:jkKdZam_fu_kh]eZkmxlkyk ih^e_`Zsbf\ jh^_b qbke_K_kljZgZf_j_gZijb_oZlv d gZf\h\j_fyhlimkdZHl^uoZxsb_ h[yaZgu lhqgh \uihegylv \k_ jZkihjy`_gby Z^fbgbkljZpbbDhgvdh[_`pu]hlh\umqZkl\h\Zlv \ jhau]jur_h[eZklgh]hi_j\_gkl\Zbaf_gbehkvagZq_gb_ij_^eh`_gbyY ^he`_g[ue ijbagZlvk\hbhrb[db ± Y g_fh]g_ijbagZlvk\hbohrb[hdHgg_fh] g_agZlvh \Zr_f\ha\jZs_gbbHgg_fh]g_kh]eZkblvkyk gZfbMl\_j`^_gb_ \ujZ`Z_lky [he__ kbevgh \ ij_^eh`_gbyo k ^\hcgufhljbpZgb_fY ^he`gZ[ueZm_oZlv^hfhc± Y g_fh]eZg_m_oZlv^hfhcGZr deZkk ^he`_g [ue ih_oZlv gZ wdkdmjkbx ± GZr deZkk g_fh]g_ih_oZlvgZwdkdmjkbx,JZ[hqb_gZr_]haZ\h^Zfh]mlijh\h^blvk\hchlimkdgZ[_j_]m fhjy FZkl_j ohq_l ih\ukblv k\hx d\ZebnbdZpbxDZiblZgdhfZg^ufh`_lg_^himklblvb]jhdZd khj_\gh\Zgbyf,, >jmavy fhb gm kihjblv ± >jmavy fhb gZqZeb kihjblvB klZebhgbkf_ylvkyFugZqZebieykZlvohohlZlv,,,Hg fZkl_j dhjabgu ie_klb ± Hgohjhrh mf__l dhjabguie_klb B\Zg Dmavfbq hq_gv ex[be ihrmlblv K_fzg I_ljh\bqhq_gvex[beih]h\hjblv < wlh \j_fy [ZlxrdZ gZgye ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ^ey f_gy njZgpmaZ fhkv_ ;hij_ dhlhjh]h \uibkZeb ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_baFhkd\u> @dhlhjh]hFu `bebijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_^mrZ\ ^mrm> @OhlyihdhgljZdlm h[yaZg hg [ue f_gymqblv khklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_ihnjZgpmakdbihg_f_pdbb \k_fgZmdZfghhg ij_^ihqze gZkdhjh\umqblvky hl f_gy dh_dZd [helZlv khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ihjmkkdbY j_rbekyk^_eZlv khklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_ ba g_z >]_h]jZnbq_kdhc dZjlu@ af_c bihevamykv kghf ;hij_ijbgyeky ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ aZ jZ[hlm GZdhg_p [ZlxrdZ h[ty\be ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_qlhgZf_j_gibkZlvkhklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ kh fghc d [m^ms_fm fh_fm gZqZevgbdm b ihlj_[h\Ze ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ i_jZ b [mfZ]b:KImrdbgDhgljZdl^h]h\hjQ_eh\_d^he`_g k ^_lkl\Zkhrdheu ihfgblvgZdZdhca_fe_hgjh^bekyHg^he`_gihfgblvqlhm g_]h_klvh[yaZgghklbi_j_^wlhc\_ebdhcdjZkb\_cr_ca_fezc\ fbj_dhlhjmxah\ml Jh^bghc ?keb _c [m^_l m]jh`Zlv kf_jl_evgZy hiZkghklv hg ^he`_g\klZlv gZ _z aZsblm b klhylv _keb gm`gh gZkf_jlv Hg ^he`_gihfgblvb qlblv ^_eZk\hboij_^dh\dhlhju_g_`Ze_eb `bagbaZsbsZyjh^gmxkljZgmjh^ghcyaudjh^ghc^hfGLbohgh\=eZ\gZyfukevl_dklZ± ex[h\vd Jh^bg_Klbevl_dklZ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc>_j_\vyih`_el_eb ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_± >_j_\vygZqZeb`_el_lv khklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_A_e_g_eZijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_habfv± Habfv[ueZa_ezghc ]jZffZlbq_kdh_agZq_gb_\ujZ`Z_lky]eZ]hehfk\yadhcZ hkgh\gh_e_dkbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_ ± bf_g_f ijbeZ]Zl_evguf Ih hdhgqZgbbdmjkh\ k_kljZ [m^_l jmdh\h^blv khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ohjh\uf djm`dhf ± Ih hdhgqZgbb dmjkh\ k_kljZ [m^_l jmdh\h^bl_evgbp_c ]jZffZlbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_\ujZ`Z_lky]eZ]hehfk\yadhcZ hkgh\gh_e_dkbq_kdh_agZq_gb_± bf_g_fkms_kl\bl_evgufohjh\h]hdjm`dZ F_l_ev [ueZ kljZrgZy khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ GZ^\hj_[ueZ ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_f_l_ev\_l_j\ueijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_IGZgZ_a^gbd_[ueZ ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ k_jZy dmjldZ k f_oh\uf \hjhlgbdhf D Dhklxf kh\k_f gh\uc khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ ± gme_\Zyk\yadZ GZdZgmg_ ijZa^gbdZ [m^_l ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_dZjgZ\ZeBeexfbgZpby[m^_ldjZkb\hckhklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_ <_l_j dZaZeky lzieuf ± <_l_j [ue lzieuf Hgb kqblZebkv^jmavyfb± Hgb[ueb^jmavyfbHggZau\Zekyfhbflh\Zjbs_f ± Hg [ue fhbf lh\Zjbs_f Hl kg_]Z \kz klZeh [_euf ±Hlkg_]Z\kz[ueh[_euf<h\lhjhfkemqZ_k ]eZ]hehfk\yadhc[ulv± dhgklZlZpbynZdlZdZd [ueh \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb Z \ i_j\uo kemqZyo ± [hevrZy bebf_gvrZykl_i_gvm\_j_gghklb <^Zeb ihdZaZeky ^ufhd ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ih_a^Z Eh^dZ ihdZaZeZkv fg_ g_gZ^z`ghc khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_Hgy\bekyijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_[_aij_^mij_`^_gby ?]h ijb_a^ y\beky ^ey f_gy kxjijbahf khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_Dexqhl^\_jbhdZaZeky ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_\ dZjfZg_dhf[bg_ahgZGh\Zyfh^_evkZfhezlZhdZaZeZkv agZqbl_evghemqr_ khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_klZjhcKxjijba± g_h`b^Zgghklvih^Zjhd,,Ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_D_f [u y gb klZe y [m^m ex[blv k\hx ijhn_kkbx ?]h ]eZaZfy\behkv \b^_gb_ GZ mebp_ [ue fhjha JZ[hlZ ^_eZeZkv hq_gv [ukljhKhklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_Kg_]klZe[_e__b qbs_?]hijb_a^y\beky^eyf_gyiheghcg_h`b^Zgghklvx Gh\uc a\md [ue m`_ ]jhfq_ Hl h]hjq_gby hg ^_eZeky\k_ae__b ae__K_kljZijbreZ bardheu]jmklgZy ]eZ]ijbeZ]HgZkb^_eZ aZ klhehf [e_^gZy ]eZ]ijbeZ] J_[ylZ ijb[_`Zeb gZf_klh ijhbkr_kl\by i_j\u_ ]eZ]qbkebl Ih hdhgqZgbb bgklblmlZ Nz^hj ^he`_g [ue \ha\jZlblvky \ k_eh Z]jhghfhfdjijbe[ue]eZ]kms_kl\ Hev]Z GbdheZ_\gZ _sz k ^_lkl\Zklj_fbeZkv klZlv \jZqhf ]eZ]klZlvkms_kl\ Ijb [hevr_fklZjZgbb=_ggZ^bcfh][uemqr_k^Zlv fh][uijbeZ]]eZ]\uimkdgu_wdaZf_gu,, GZ khj_\gh\Zgbyo gZrb kihjlkf_gu ijbreb \lhjufb Hl_pijb_oZe k jZ[hlu h]hjqzgguf Fhc [jZl f_qlZ_l [ulv Z\bZdhgkljmdlhjhf?keb[ug_\hcgZy fh][uklZlvf_oZgbdhf >h[jZy jZ[hlZ ± \k_fm gZqZeh kms_kl\ gme_\Zy k\yadZ Ih_e A_fey \_ebdZ b ij_djZkgZ djZldijbeZ] gme_\Zyk\yadZ Q GZlZevy :e_dk__\gZ [ueZ ]eZ]hek\yadZ fheh^uf\jZqhf kms_kl\ NZ^ <hklhqgZy qZklv g_[Z [ueZ ]eZ]hek\yadZ l_fg__ ijbeZ] aZiZ^ghc IZmkl <ha^mo klZgh\blky]eZ]hek\yadZ keZs_ ijbeZ] N_^ FZjd [ue ]eZ]hek\yadZe_l^\Z^pZlbk_fb kms_kl\qbkebl=hgqIjb\klj_q_k N_^_c y [ue ]eZ]hek\yadZ gZklhjh`_ djZldijbq IZmkl JZa]h\hjqZkhlqZkm^_eZeky ]eZ]hek\yadZ rmfg__ ijbeZ]IY[ue ]eZ]hek\yadZ ]em[hdh hkdhj[ezg djZldijbqZklb_ keh\Zfb]\Zj^_ckdh]hhnbp_jZI ;hij_ \ hl_q_kl\_ k\hzf [ue iZjbdfZo_jhf ihlhf \Ijmkkbb khe^Zlhf I KlZjbd [ue dh]^Zlh gZqZevgbdhf djmighc `_e_agh^hjh`ghc klZgpbb <_j Hl_p [ue \jZq ijblhffgh]h bgl_j_kh\Zeky kZgblZjb_c <_j FZfZ [ueZ ^hfhk_^dZ bg_ex[beZ\u_a`Zlv bak\h_]h^hfZ<_j Mebpu imkluggu NhgZjb g_ aZ``_gu JZkkdZau[ueb hq_gv g_bgl_j_kgu djZld ijbeZ] khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ JZ[hlZ g_ aZdhgq_gZ H[jZah\ZgZ dhfbkkby ihhj]ZgbaZpbb gh\h]h^g_]h \_q_jZ < l_Zlj_ ^_lb [uebg_k^_j`Zggu djZld ijbe khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ ]jhfdhkf_yebkv i_j_]h\Zjb\Zebkv HgZ [ueZ g_ mfgZ djZld ijbeZ]khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_Z hq_gvobljZ djZldijbeZ]ijZ\hibkZgb_G? k djZldbfbijbeZ]Zl_evgufbb ijbqZklbyfbG_ k djZldbfb ijbqZklbyfb \k_]^Z ibr_lky hl^_evgh Z k djZldbfb ijbeZ]Zl_evgufb g_ ibr_lkylZd`_dZdk ihegufbijbeZ]Zl_evgufb ijZ\hibkZgb_ G b GG \ djZldbo ijbqZklbyo b ijbeZ]Zl_evguo< djZldboijbqZklbyo\k_]^Zibr_lkyh^gZ[md\ZGZ \djZldboijbeZ]Zl_evguo klhevdh `_ [md\ GG kdhevdh \ khhl\_lkl\mxsboiheguoijbeZ]Zl_evguo , Dgb]m beexkljbjh\Ze ba\_klguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd ±Dgb]Z beexkljbjh\ZgZ ba\_klguf jmkkdbf om^h`gbdhf LmqbjZa\_ye ih^gy\rbcky \_l_j ± Lmqb jZa\_yguih^gy\rbfky\_ljhf Gh\u_ ^hfZ ihkljhbe `bebsguc dhhi_jZlb\ ± Gh\u_ ^hfZ ihkljh_gu`bebsgufdhhi_jZlb\hf< djZldboijbqZklbyo\k_]^Zibr_lkyh^gZ[md\ZG \kmnnbdk_,, G_kdhevdha^Zgbc[uehjZajmr_ghmjZ]Zghf± MjZ]Zg jZajmrbeg_kdhevdha^Zgbc>_j_\vy[uebih\Ze_gu[mj_c± >_j_\vy ih\ZebeZ [mjy Kg_`gu_ lmqb [ueb ijbg_k_gu pbdehghf ±Pbdehgijbg_kkg_`gu_lmqbGh\h_ieZlv_[ueh_chq_gvd ebpm± ?chq_gvrehoZjZdl_jgh^eyjZa]h\hjghcj_qbgh\h_ieZlv_± HgZ[ueZohjhrZ\gh\hf ieZlv_ Y g_ ijbrze \h\j_fy b lh\Zjbs [ue gZ f_gy \h[b^_± Y g_ijbrze\h\j_fyb lh\Zjbs[uegZf_gyh[b`_g± Yg_ ijbrze \h\j_fy b lh\Zjbs h[b^_eky oZjZdl_jgh ^ey jZa]h\hjghc j_qb gZ f_gy Wlhl jZkkdZa fg_ kh\k_f g_ ih ^mr_ ± WlhljZkkdZafg_kh\k_fg_gjZ\blkyoZjZdl_jgh^eyjZa]h\hjghcj_qb± WlhljZkkdZag_ohjhr IhehkZ o\hcguo e_kh\ y\ey_lky ]eZ]hek\yadZ h^gbf bakZfuo [hevrbo ijbjh^guo ihykh\ qbkeblkms_kl\k ij_^e khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_gZr_ckljZguHl DZj_ebb ^h MjZeZ lZc]Z kl_e_lky baty\blgZdehg ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ih jZ\gbg_ Z aZ ?gbk__f ^h Lboh]h hd_ZgZhgZ b^zl baty\blgZdehg ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ih \ha\ur_gghklb< aZiZ^ghcqZklblZc]bdebfZll_ie__ijbeZ]gme_\Zy k\yadZ khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ >h MjZeZ jZklml baty\blgZdehg ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ khkgZ k _evx <AZiZ^ghc Kb[bjb jZkijhkljZg_gZ khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_gme_\Zyk\yadZdjZlijbqZklb__ev\i_j_f_`dmk ibolhcb kb[bjkdbf d_^jhf AZ ?gbk__f abfu fZehkg_`gu khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_ gme_\Zy k\yadZ djZlijbeZ] Z fhjhau hq_gv kbevgukhklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_gme_\Zy k\yadZdjZlijbeZ]A_fey hllZb\Z_l baty\blgZdehg ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_lhevdh kgZjm`b =eZ\guf ^_j_\hf kms_kl\ \ <hklhqghc Kb[bjby\ey_lky ]eZ]hek\yadZ khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ ebkl\_ggbpZ Ebkl\_ggbqgu_ e_kZ klhyl ]eZ]hek\yadZ abfhc ]heu_ ijhajZqgu_ijbeZ]khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_HgbdZ`mlky]eZ]hek\yadZ qzjghck_lvxkms_kl\khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_gZ[_ehfnhg_kg_]ZIhGFboZceh\mKlbev l_dklZ ebl_jZlmjghom^h`_kl\_gguc k we_f_glZfb gZmqgh]hklbey< ij_^eh]aZiZ^ghc ijbeZ]qZklb kms_kl\lZc]b kms_kl\debfZl kms_kl\l_ie__ ijbeZ]Ih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijhklj> @>hij_^eh]MjZeZ kms_kl\jZklml ]eZ]hekhkgZkms_kl\kij_^eh]_evx kms_kl\Ih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijhklj> @ <k_ wlh f_gy fmqbeh KlZjbd m]jxfh kb^_e gZ h[emqd_ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ Y g_ fh] g_ ijbagZlvky k_[_«Y g_ij_f_gghohl_e k gbf ihfbjblvky« khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ >hjh`gu_ jZafure_gbyfhb[uebg_hq_gvijbylguIjhb]jurfhcihlh]^Zrgbfp_gZf[ueg_fZeh\Z`_gkhklZ\gh_bf_ggh_ , Wlh [ue ]eZ]hek\yadZ ]hkih^bg e_l ljb^pZlb kms_kl\qbkebl g_fZeh]h jhklZ ijbeZ]kms_kl\ ie_qbklucijbeZ]k h]jhfghcdmjqZ\hx]heh\hc ijbeZ]kms_kl\khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_Ebph m g_]h[ueh]eZ]hek\yadZfykbklh_b jmfygh_ khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ ijbeZ] ghk rbjhdbcijbeZ]b kiexs_gguc ijbqZklb_khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_kdZam_fh_gme_\Zyk\yadZ]eZaZ fZe_gvdb_ ijbeZ]aZieu\rb_ijbqb gZkf_reb\u_ ijbeZ] dZd [m^lh [_kij_ju\gh ih^fb]b\Zxsb_ khxaijbqZklb_ khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ gme_\Zy k\yadZNF>hklh_\kdbcIhjlj_l,,Ih]h^Z klhyeZ ]eZ]hek\yadZij_djZkgZy ijbeZ]khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ [_eu_ djm]eu_ h[eZdZ \ukhdh b lboh g_kebkvbaty\blgZdehg ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ gZ^ gZfb ykghhljZ`Zykv \ \h^_ ljhklgbd rmrmdZe baty\blgZdehg ijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ djm]hf ijm^ f_klZfb dZd klZev k\_jdZebaty\blgZdehg ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ gZ khegp_BKLmj]_g_\I_caZ`,,,Wlh[ue ]eZ]hek\yadZkljZgguc ijbeZ]khklZ\gh_bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ q_eh\_d Ihemh[jZah\Zgguc hq_gv g_]emiuc hgj_rbl_evghij_abjZe baty\blgZdehgijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_ \k_o b dZ`^h]h g_ bf_e ]eZ]hek\yadZ gbdZdbo ijZ\be kms_kl\khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ kf_yeky baty\blgZdehgijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ gZ^h \k_fb b d klZjhklb k^_eZeky]eZ]hek\yadZ ahe jZa^jZ`bl_e_g b [_a`Zehkl_g djZld ijbeZ]khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ N F >hklh_\kdbc OZjZdl_jbklbdZ KdZam_fh_ ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ ± Y `^m Hg ih[_`ZeKhegp_\klZehKhklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_± Y f_qlZxihe_l_lvgZemgmGZmebp_klZehl_fg_lv KhklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ ± ;m^m jZ^ <Zk \b^_lv Y ohqm[ulvmqbl_e_fY y\eyxkvij_^klZ\bl_e_fnbjfuIjhklh_ b khklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgu_ kdZam_fu_ h[t_^bgy_l lh qlhwlh]eZ\gucqe_gij_^eh`_gbydhlhjuch[uqghkh]eZkm_lkyk ih^e_`Zsbf b bf__l agZq_gb_ \ujZ`_ggh_ \ \hijhkZo qlh ^_eZ_lij_^f_l"qlhk gbfijhbkoh^bl"dZdh\hg"QlhhglZdh_"dlhhglZdhc" b l^ : jZaebqZ_l bo lh qlh \ khklZ\ghf ]eZ]hevghf kdZam_fhf e_dkbq_kdh_ b ]jZffZlbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_ \ujZ`_gu \ jZaguokeh\ZoZ \ijhklhf]eZ]hevghfkdZam_fhf± \ h^ghfkeh\_,KhehlqZ± ba\bebklZyg_]em[hdZyj_dZQm^_kgh_ ^_ehe_kZE_k± wlhkZfuc\_jgucgZrihfhsgbd \ [hjv[_aZmjh`ZcKeZ^dh\ZlucaZiZo\h^yguoebebckf_rZgk aZiZohfkfheu>\Z^pZlve_l± kh\_jr_gghgbqlh`guckjhd \ `bagbgZjh^h\DIZmklh\kdbc,,FhzaZgylb_± wlgh]jZnby bamq_gb_ `bagbjmkkdboex^_cIj`@bagvij_djZkgZb m^b\bl_evgZFZydJ_q_\ZydmevlmjZ q_eh\_dZ ± wlh a_jdZeh _]h ^moh\ghc `bagb Kmohfe Ihgylv ± agZqbl ijhklblv Hkgh\ghc fhlb\ fh_c `bagb ± k^_eZlvqlhgb[m^vihe_agh_ ^eyex^_cPbhedh\kdbc,,, Hev]Z ± klZjrZy k_kljZ <bdlhjZ HgZ jZ[hlgbpZ l_dklbevghcnZ[jbdbAehcyaudqlhklj_eZIh_eQl_gb_± \hlemqr__mq_gb_ I Keh\h g_ klj_eZ ^Z hklj__ klj_eu Ih_e Ke_iZyg_gZ\bklv± iehohckh\_lqbdIh_eL\hbj_qb[m^lhhkljucgh`EEZkdh\h_keh\hqlh \_k_ggbc^_gvIh_e AgZgb_± hjm^b_Z g_p_evELDgb]Z± wlh bklhqgbd agZgbc< l_dkl_\u^_e_gukhklZ\gu_bf_ggu_kdZam_fu_,Q_eh\_dex[ysbcb mf_xsbcqblZlv± kqZkleb\ucq_eh\_dHghdjm`_gfgh`_kl\hfmfguo^h[juob \_jguo^jma_c>jmavywlb± dgb]bH]jhfguc fbj aZfZgqb\uc b jZaghh[jZaguc \ju\Z_lky d gZfkhkljZgbpex[bfuodgb]Qlhkdjulh\ gbo"QblZcl_ g_ lhjhiykv qlh[u g_ ihl_jylv gb h^ghc dZieb ^jZ]hp_ggh]hkh^_j`Zgbydgb]Q_eh\_d]ehlZxsbcdgb]bihoh`gZiml_r_kl\_ggbdZ agZdhfys_]hky kh kljZghc ba hdgZ \Z]hgZ AZklZ\eycl_ k_[y qblZlv f_^e_ggh aZihfbgZy h[^mfu\Zy ij_^klZ\eyykZfh]hk_[y\ ]ms_l_okh[ulbcb lhch[klZgh\dbdZdbfbgZiheg_gZ dgb]Z Lhevdh lh]^Z i_j_^ \Zfb ^h dhgpZ hldjh_lky kha^ZggucibkZl_e_f[hevrhcb ij_djZkgucfbjQblZcl_ Imklv g_ [m^_l gb h^gh]h ^gy dh]^Z [u \u g_ ijhqebohly[uh^ghckljZgbpubagh\hcdgb]bIhDIZmklh\kdhfm,,Ql_gb_± wlhhdhrdh\ fbj\Z`g_crbcbgkljmf_glmq_gbyMf_lvqblZlv± wlhhagZqZ_l[ulvqmldbfd kfukemb djZkhl_keh\Z d _]h lhgqZcrbf hll_gdZf DjZkhlZ keh\Z yjq_ \k_]h \hiehs_gZ\ ihwabb<:KmohfebgkdbcI_j\ucb \lhjhcl_dkluh[t_^bg_guh[s_cfukevx\Z`ghklbbg_h[oh^bfhklbql_gbyHg f_klhbf hdjm`_g djZldijbqZklb_ fgh`_kl\hf kms_kl\bl mfguo ijbeZ] ^h[juo ijbeZ] b khxa \_jguo ijbeZ]^jma_c kms_kl\bl Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhkl ^\mkhkl jZkijhkeh`gg_h^ghjhij_^_e_gbyfb> hijb hij@>jmavy kms_kl\bl wlb f_klhbf ± dgb]b kms_kl\bl Ih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkij> @Qlh f_klhbfkdjulh djZldijbqZklb_\ ij_^eh]gbo f_klhbf"\hijhkblg_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijihegh_g_hkeh`g> @"QblZcl_± qblZlvkmnnbdkZevgucIbkZl_e_f± ibkZlvkmnnbdkZevgucIhoh¶` ± keh]ZI ± >i@± kh]e]emol\_j^H ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^O ± >o@± kh]e]emol\_j^H ± >h@± ]eZkgm^@ ± >r@± kh]e]emol\_j^[md\ a\mdh\,LhgqZcrbf± ijbeZ]Hll_gdZfdZdbf"lhgqZcrbfgn± lhgdbc,, Ihkl ± dZq_kl\ G_ihkl ± ij_\hkokl_i_gv \ > i \hfgh`qbke_,,,Hll_gdZfdZdbf"lhgqZcrbf,:e_dkZg^jK_j]__\bqImrdbg± \_ebqZcrZy]hj^hklvgZr_c ebl_jZlmju Kh\j_f_ggbdb gZau\Zxl _]h khegp_f jmkkdhc ihwabbIh\_klv©DZiblZgkdZy^hqdZª± h^ghbaaZf_qZl_evguoijhba\_^_gbcihwlZHgZgZibkZgZ\ ]h^mHkgh\Zih\_klbImrdbgZ± dZjlbgugZjh^ghc\hcguih^jmdh\h^kl\hfIm]Zqz\Z,, H[jZaghklv y\ey_lky hlebqbl_evghc q_jlhc om^h`_kl\_gghcebl_jZlmjuKha^Zlvom^h`_kl\_ggh_ijhba\_^_gb_± wlhagZqblgZjbkh\Zlv p_ehklgmx dZjlbgm`bagbL\hjq_kdbc\ufuk_eihfh]Z_lihwlmh`b\blvkh[ulby^Zezdh]hijhreh]h H[jZa_p We_\Zlhjhf gZau\Z_lky hkh[h_ f_oZgbabjh\Zggh_a_jghojZgbebs_ [hevrbojZaf_jh\We_\Zlhj± wlhhkh[h_f_oZgbabjh\Zggh_a_jghojZgbebs_[hevrbojZaf_jh\We_\Zlhjij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc g_ qlh bgh_ dZd hkh[h_ f_oZgbabjh\Zggh_ a_jghojZgbebs_[hevrbojZaf_jh\ Dhg\_c_jhf gZau\Z_lky mkljhckl\h ^ey g_ij_ju\gh]h i_j_f_s_gby h[jZ[Zlu\Z_fh]h ba^_eby hl h^gh]h jZ[hq_]h d ^jm]hfmDhg\_c_j± wlhmkljhckl\h^eyg_ij_ju\gh]hi_j_f_s_gbyh[jZ[Zlu\Z_fh]h ba^_eby hl h^gh]h jZ[hq_]h d ^jm]hfm Dhg\_c_j ij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hcg_qlhbgh_dZdmkljhckl\h^eyg_ij_ju\gh]hi_j_f_s_gby h[jZ[Zlu\Z_fh]h ba^_eby hl h^gh]h jZ[hq_]h d ^jm]hfm Dhgl_cg_jhf gZau\Z_lky hkh[Zy lZjZ ^ey i_j_\hadb ]jmah\ [_amiZdh\db Dhgl_cg_j ± wlh hkh[Zy lZjZ ^ey i_j_\hadb ]jmah\ [_amiZdh\db Dhgl_cg_j ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc g_ qlh bgh_ dZd hkh[mxlZjm^eyi_j_\hadb]jmah\[_amiZdh\dbWdkdZ\ZlhjhfgZau\Z_lky fZrbgZ ba\e_dZxsZy a_fex WdkdZ\Zlhj ± wlh fZrbgZ ba\e_dZxsZy a_fex WdkdZ\Zlhj ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc g_ qlh bgh_ dZdfZrbgmba\e_dZxsmxa_fex<klj_qZk >_jkmQZkh\ \ ^_kylv \_q_jZ y aZdjue l_ljZ^v ez] d h]gx Kl\heu ^_j_\v_\dZaZebkv^ebgghcdhehggZ^hcmoh^b\r_c\]em[ve_kZ<^jm] ehrZ^b ih^gyeb ]heh\u b gZklhjh`beb mrb Fu klZebijbkemrb\Zlvkyghdjm]hf[ueZlbrbgZK\_jom ihkuiZebkv f_edb_ dZfgb Q_j_a g_kdhevdh fbgml dgZr_fmh]gxih^hrzeq_eh\_diha^hjh\Zekyk gZfbAZl_fhgihklZ\bed ^_j_\mk\hzjm`vzkgyekhkibgudhlhfdmb ih^k_ed dhkljmWlh [ue q_eh\_d g_\ukhdh]h jhklZ dhj_gZkluc =jm^v m g_]h[ueZ \uimdeZy jmdb dj_idb_ fmkdmebklu_ gh]b g_fgh]h djb\u_AZ]hj_eh_ebph_]h[uehlbibqgh^eyf_klguo`bl_e_cG_[hevrb_l_fghjmku_ \hehku hdZcfeyeb \_jogxx ]m[m Z fZe_gvdZy ju`Zy[hjh^dZ mdjZrZeZ ih^[hjh^hd gh \k_]h aZf_qZl_evg__ [ueb _]h]eZaZ Hgb dZaZebkv l_fghk_jufb gh g_ dZjbfb < gbo kd\habebj_rbl_evghklvb ijyfhlZoZjZdl_jZIh<D:jk_gv_\mIh^[hjh^hd± [hjh^ZijbklZ\hqghkmnnbdkZevguckihkh[< l_dkl_ \klj_qZxlky khklZ\gu_ ]eZ]hevgu_ b bf_ggu_ kdZam_fu_b ijhklu_]eZ]hevgu_kdZam_fu_ :\bZihqlZ ± wlh ihqlZ ^hklZ\ey_fZy k ihfhsvx kZfhe_lZh[jZah\Zghhlkeh\ZihqlZkeh`_gb_f^\mohkgh\:d\ZeZg]bkl± wlhq_eh\_dieZ\Zxsbck Zd\ZeZg]hfh[jZah\Zghhlkeh\ZZd\ZeZg]kmnnbdkZevgufkihkh[hf:\bZihqlZ[ueZ^hklZ\e_gZ\h\j_fy:d\ZeZg]bklK_j]__\[ueemqrbf\ gZr_cdhfZg^_LZeZglj_`bkk_jZj_i_lbpbyiv_kukp_gbq_kdh_bkdmkkl\h ihjZablv ajbl_e_c ]hlh\blvkyd dhgn_j_gpbbdhg]j_kk[bheh]h\ ijZa^gbqgZy beexfbgZpby dZjgZ\ZevgZy ghqv mjZ]Zgguc \_l_j \hiehszgguc aZfuk_e klZjZl_evgh bkihegblv [hevrbgkl\hijbkmlkl\mxsboba[bjZl_evgZydhfiZgbyLZeZgl ]eZ\g kms_kl\ j_`bkk_jZ aZ\bkbf kms_kl\ mijZ\e_gb_mdZau\Z_lgZij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdKp_gbq_kdh_aZ\bkbfijbeZ]bkdmkkl\h]eZ\gkms_kl\kh]eZkh\Zgb_mdZau\Z_lgZij_^f_lb _]hijbagZdIhjZablv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he ajbl_e_c aZ\bkbf kms_kl\ mijZ\e_gb_ mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuc hghi_j_oh^blKlZjZl_evgh aZ\bkbf gZj_qb_ bkihegblv ]eZ\g ]eZ]he ±ijbfudZgb_mdZau\Z_lgZ^_ckl\b_b _]hijbagZd >\_jv aZkdjbi_eZ b e_kgbd rZ]gme q_j_a ihjh] Y ihkfhlj_e gZg_]hf_klhbfk ij_^eh]hfJ_^dhfg_f_klhbfkemqZehkv\b^_lv lZdh]hfheh^pZ kms_kl\Baih^fhdjhcjm[Zrdb\uimdeh\uklZ\eyebkv _]hfh]mqb_ furpuLHlijZ\blv ]eZ\g qlh" l_e_]jZffm aZ\bkbfmdZau\Z_lgZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuc hgh i_j_oh^bl mijZ\e_gb_ex[h\Zlvky ]eZ\g q_f" i_caZ`_f aZ\bkbf mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuc hgh i_j_oh^bl mijZ\e_gb_ jZa`_qv]eZ\g qlh" dhklzj aZ\bkbf mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_lgZ dhlhjuc hgh i_j_oh^bl mijZ\e_gb_ jZkkdZaZlv ]eZ\g hq_f"h \klj_q_aZ\bkbfmdZau\Z_lgZ^_ckl\b_b ij_^f_lgZdhlhjuchghi_j_oh^blmijZ\e_gb_\klj_lblv]eZ\gdh]h"^jm]ZaZ\bkbf mdZau\Z_l gZ ^_ckl\b_ b ij_^f_l gZ dhlhjuchghi_j_oh^blmijZ\e_gb_Mljhfy hlijZ\bel_e_]jZffmY ex[h\Zekyi_caZ`_f ^hkZfh]h\_q_jZ <_q_jhf fu j_rbeb jZa`_qv dhkl_j Y ohl_e \k_f jZkkdZaZlvh gZr_c\klj_q_Fg_g_l_ji_ehkvihkdhj__\klj_lblv^jm]Z IZjhoh^ [m^bl ]hjh^ ieZqmsbf ]m^dhf IZmkl GZk\klj_lbeijb\_leb\uc[jblucklZjbdIZmklB ihg_keZ\i_jz^i_ohlZ k\hz jh^bfh_ mjZ L\Zj^ FZlmrdZ \ ke_aZo gZdZau\ZeZfg_ [_j_qv k\hz a^hjh\v_ I< dZjlhgd_m QmdZ ojZgbebkvljbp\_lguo agZqdZ :=[@b\m]hj`mkvkugZfbL\Zj^;ZeZ]mjm kfhljyl\ jhlkeh\h eh\yl`Z^ghL\Zj^Fukh[bjZebkv\_jgmlvky ^_ckl\b_h^gh]hb lh]h`_ebpZ ^hfhc d \_q_jm ± K_kljZ ijhkbeZ gZk \_jgmlvky ^_ckl\byjZaguo ebp ^hfhc d \_q_jm E_lhf y ijh^he`Ze ihk_sZlv ^_ckl\b_h^gh]hb lh]h`_ebpZieZ\Zl_evguc[Zkk_cg± <jZqkh\_lh\Zefg_ ihk_sZlv ^_ckl\by jZaguo ebp ieZ\Zl_evguc [Zkk_cg Mq_gbdb gZqZeb kh[bjZlv ^_ckl\b_ h^gh]h b lh]h `_ ebpZ fZl_jbZeu ^ey khqbg_gby ± Mqbl_ev j_dhf_g^h\Ze mq_gbdZf kh[bjZlv^_ckl\byjZaguoebpfZl_jbZeu^eykhqbg_gbyFuj_]meyjghqblZ_f@xey<_jgZIhdZ`bl_gZdZjl_DZ\dZakdb_ ]hju Fgh]b_ kljZgu fbjZ \_^ml lhj]h\ex k Gh\hcA_eZg^b_c WdkdmjkZglu ijb_oZ\rb_ \ Fhkd\m ihk_lbeb FZg_`gmxijhsZ^v H[eZdh aZdjueh khegp_ Dhjgb ^_j_\v_\ iblZxl ebklvy =hjh^kdb_ mebpu mdjZrZxl fgh]hwlZ`gu_ ^hfZ E_kZkhojZgyxlj_dbJ_]meyjguch[f_g\_s_kl\ ih^^_j`b\Z_lkms_kl\h\Zgb_hj]Zgbafh\We_dljh\hau aZf_gbebiZjh\hauLjhee_c[mk h[h]gZe ljZf\ZcLhihev i_j_jhkdezgIhjy^hdkeh\\ ^ZgguokemqZyob]jZ_lkfukehjZaebqbl_evgmxjhevH[jZa_p>hklZgvl_baoheh^bevgbdZfhehdh ± >hklZgvl_baoheh^bevgbdZfhehdZIjbrebl_gZfgh\u_ihqlh\u_fZjdb± Ijbrebl_gZfgh\uoihqlh\uo fZjhd G_ aZ[m^vl_ dmiblv \ fZ]Zabg_ dhgn_lu ± G_aZ[m^vl_dmiblv\ fZ]Zabg_dhgn_lIhkdhj__ijbg_kbl_[Z[mrd_qZc± Ihkdhj__ijbg_kbl_[Z[mrd_qZxGZe_cl_\ \Zggm\h^m±GZe_cl_\ \Zggm\h^u Kh[jZgb_ g_ ijbgyeh h[hkgh\Zggh]h j_r_gby Fu g_kfh]eb bkihegblv k\h_]h h[_sZgby :l_ev_ g_ ijbgbfZ_l gh\uoaZdZah\Mq_gbdg_ihgyemkeh\byaZ^ZqbB]jZlv]eZ\gmxjhev \ iv_k_[m^_lgh\ucZdlzjOhjhrZynbabq_kdZy ih^]hlh\dZ b]jZ_l [hevrmx jhev \ ^hklb`_gbb kihjlb\guo mki_oh\ Hl^uoZxsb_ ex[h\Zebkv \b^hf kg_`guo ]hjJZkkdZaqbd g_ ih^Ze \b^Z qlh gZr \hijhk _fm g_ ihgjZ\beky Lhedh\uc keh\Zjv ihfh]Z_l ihgylv agZq_gby keh\Z AZdZeb\Zgb_hj]ZgbafZbf__l[hevrh_agZq_gb_ ^eya^hjh\vy@bjguf rjbnlhf \u^_e_gu njZa_heh]bq_kdb_ h[hjhlukdZam_fu_B]jZ_l[hevrmxjhev± fgh]hagZqblhq_gv\Z`_gG_ih^Ze\b^Z± g_h[jZlbe\gbfZgbyijhb]ghjbjh\ZeBf__l [hevrh_ agZq_gb_ ± hq_gv \Z`gh b]jZ_l [hevrmx jhevfgh]hagZqbl Fu hq_gv lj_\h`bebkv aZ gZrbo \he_c[hebklh\ <k_hkh[_ggh[_kihdhbebkvaZdZiblZgZ Fu[ueb[ujZ^uij_^hkl_j_qv bohl \hafh`guo hrb[hdGhkZfbb]jhdb[uebihegum\_j_gghklb\ mki_o_<_jZ\ ih[_^m hq_gvihfh]eZbfI_j\_gkl\h [ueh aZ\hz\Zgh dhfZg^hc \iheg_ aZkem`_ggh Lj_g_j [uem^hklh_gki_pbZevghcgZ]jZ^uKeh\Zk ijhims_ggufb[md\Zfb^ZgugZijZ\behgZibkZgbyGb GG \ kmnnbdkZojZaebqguoqZkl_cj_qb ?klv \ hk_gb i_j\hgZqZevghc ijbeZ] dhjhldZy ijbeZ] gh ^b\gZy ijbeZ] ihjZ Lxlq Gh ^Ze_dh _sz ^h i_j\uo qbkebl abfgbo ijbeZ] [mjv ± b evzlky qbklZy ijbeZ] blzieZy ijbeZ]eZamjv gZhl^uoZxs__ ijbqZklb_ihe_Lxlq@bjgufrjbnlhf\u^_e_guhij_^_e_gby>Zggu_hij_^_e_gbyhl\_qZxlgZ\hijhkuDZdZy"DZdh_"DZdb_"DZdhc" Hgb hlghkylky d kms_kl\bl_evguf \u^_e_gu dmjkb\hf bk\yaZguk gbfbihkihkh[mkh]eZkh\Zgby,K ]hjuhldju\Zekyqm^_kguc\b^± <b^k ]hju[ueqm^_kguc<_kvf_kypklhyeZg_gZklgZy ih]h^Z± <_kvf_kypih]h^Z[ueZ g_gZklgZy Fu `b\zf \ i_j\hf hl iehsZ^b ^hf_ ± GZr^hf i_j\uc hl iehsZ^b Klhyeb ih]h`b_ ^gb ± >gb ih]h`b_ >h\h^u dhfbkkbb [ueb hq_gv m[_^bl_evgu_ ± Dhfbkkby ij_^klZ\beZm[_^bl_evgu_Zj]mf_glu,, AZ ihehlghf madhdhe_cdb g_ijhoh^bfuf qZklhdhehf klhblfheh^hc khkgyd G_ijhoh^bfuf hg dZ`_lky lhevdh ba^Ze_dZ IZmklGZ[u\r_c ijbqZklb_kh]eZkh\Zgb_hdjZbg_gZr_]h f_klhbf kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ]hjh^Z kha^Zg ^ey ^_l_c kihjlb\guc ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_ dhfie_dk < p_glj_ _]h ihkljh_gh g_\ukhdh_ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_ dmihehh[jZagh_ ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_a^Zgb_ ba kl_deZ kms_kl\ b [_lhgZ kms_kl\ mijZ\e_gb_ Wlhabfgbc ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_[Zkk_cg^eyieZ\Zgby kms_kl\blkij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ Ke_\Z gZoh^blky nml[hevgh_ ijbeZ]kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ihe_ k [_]h\hc ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_ ^hjh`dhcG_ih^Zezdmmkljh_gu iehsZ^db^ey[Zkd_l[heZb \he_c[heZ kms_kl\blk ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ _klv ^\Z jZkiheh`_gguo ijbqZklb_kh]eZkh\Zgb_jy^hfl_ggbkguo ijbeZ]kh]eZkh\Zgb_dhjlZ>ey aZgylbc ez]dhc ijbeZ] kh]eZkh\Zgb_ Zle_lbdhc hl\_^_gZl_jjblhjby kijZ\Z gZj_qb_ijbfudZgb_ K mljZ ^h \_q_jZ \ ]hjh^d_ fgh]h j_[yl jZagh]h \hajZklZ ijbeZ]kms_kl\bl mijZ\e_gb_ Bo f_qlZ k_jvzagh aZgbfZlvky kihjlhf ]eZ]he kms_kl\blmijZ\e_gb_klZeZj_ZevghklvxKljZ^Zl_evgu_ ijbqZklby ijhr_^r_]h \j_f_gb ih^q_jdgmluh^ghc q_jlhc< ij_^eh] p_glj_ kms_kl\bl _]h f_klhbf ihkljh_ghdjijbqZklb_g_\ukhdh_ ijbeZ]dmihehh[jZagh_ijbeZ]a^Zgb_kms_kl\bl ba ij_^eh] kl_deZ kms_kl\bl b khxa [_lhgZ kms_kl\bl Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhkl ^\mkhkl jZkij hkeh`g h^ghjh^gufbg_kh]eZkhij_^_e_gbyfb> « hijb hij@>ey ij_^eh] aZgylbc kms_kl\bl ez]dhc ijbeZ] Zle_lbdhckms_kl\blhl\_^_gZdjijbqZklb_l_jjblhjby kms_kl\blkijZ\ZgZj_qIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkij> @Bo f_klhbf f_qlZ kms_kl\bl k_jvzagh gZj_q aZgbfZlvky]eZ]he kihjlhf kms_kl\bl klZeZ ]eZ]he j_Zevghklvx kms_kl\blIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkij> @H[jZa_pGZ\bljbg_klhyeZojmklZevgZy\ZaZ± GZ\bljbg_klhyeZ\ZaZba]hjgh]hojmklZeyRhnzjh^_l\ dh`Zgmx dmjldm± Rhnzjh^_l\ dmjldmbadh`b< dbhkd_[ue[hevrhc\u[hjbeexkljbjh\Zgguo `mjgZeh\±< dbhkd_[ue[hevrhc\u[hj`mjgZeh\k beexkljZpbyfb:\lhfh[bevgZy klhygdZgZoh^beZkvg_^Ze_dhhl\hdaZeZ± KlhygdZZ\lhfh[be_c gZoh^beZkv g_^Ze_dh hl\hdaZeZQ_j_aljbqZkZihdZaZebkv]hjgu_ \_jrbgu± Q_j_aljbqZkZihdZaZebkv\_jrbgu]hjDgb]b\ [b[ebhl_d_\u^Z\ZeZ\ukhdZyq_jgh]eZaZy ^_\mrdZ± Dgb]b\ [b[ebhl_d_\u^Z\ZeZ\ukhdZy^_\mrdZk q_jgufb]eZaZfb< klZdZg_ k [_kp\_lghc`b^dhklvxjZkl\hj_ghg_fgh]h\bgh]jZ^gh]h kZoZjZ \ ^jm]hf klZdZg_ gZoh^blky yjdhkbgyy `b^dhklv Y ijbeb\Zx \ wlm kbgxx `b^dhklv [_kp\_lguc jZkl\hj bai_j\h]h klZdZgZ b ke_]dZ ih^h]j_\Zx hgZ gZqbgZ_l fmlblvky ijbgbfZ_l ]jyagha_e_gh\Zluc p\_l h[jZam_lky kgZqZeZ `_eluc [mjucZ ihlhfyjdhdjZkguchkZ^hdKlbevl_dklZ± gZmqguc@_¶eluc± keh]Z` ± >`@± kh]eZkga\l\_ ± >h@± ]eZkgm^Zjge ± >e@± kh]eZkga\l\l ± >l@± kh]eZkg]emol\u ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^Zjgc ± >c@± kh]eZkga\l\[md\a\mdh\,Bai_j\h]h± qbkeblBaklZdZgZdZdh]h"i_j\h]hGn± i_j\uc,,Ihkl± ihjy^dh\h_ijhklh_G_ihkl± \ jh^iZ^,,,BaklZdZgZdZdh]h"i_j\h]hKeblghibrmlkykeh`gu_ijbeZ]Zl_evgu__kebhgbh[jZah\Zguhlkeh`guokms_kl\bl_evguoibrmsbokykeblghl_ieh\hahllZdbokeh\hkhq_lZgbc\ dhlhjuoh^ghkeh\hk\yaZghk ^jm]bfihkihkh[mih^qbg_gby[_ehkg_`guc± [_euckg_]K ^_nbkhfibrmlkykeh`gu_ijbeZ]Zl_evgu__kebhgbh[jZah\Zgu Hl bf_g kms_kl\bl_evguo ibrmsboky k ^_nbkhf x]h\hklhqguchllZdbokhq_lZgbckeh\dhlhju_k\yaZguihkihkh[mkhqbg_gbydZdjZ\ghijZ\gu_ihgylbyrZofZlghrZr_qgZyhlrZofZlubrZrdb_kebh[hagZqZxlhll_gdbp\_lh\ yjdhdjZkguc <ha^mo _sz g_ klZ\rbc aghcguf ijbylgh hk\_`Z_l]jm^v Khe Khegp_ _sz g_ \hr_^r__ \ kbem ]j__l [_j_`gh beZkdh\h Khe G_kdhr_ggu_ em]Z ^mrbklu IZmkl G_ ljhgmlZy ^Z`_ r_e_klhf _^bgkl\_ggh]h kmoh]h ebklZ lbrbgZ ijhklbjZeZkv \ em]Zo IZmkl Kihjuc ^h`^v evzlky hl\_kgh kbevghHg\k_]^Zijb[eb`Z_lkyk gZ[_]Zxsbf rmfhfIZmklIjbqZklguch[hjhl\u^_ey_lkyaZiylufb\ lhfkemqZ_dh]^Zhgklhblihke_hij_^_ey_fh]hkeh\ZG?k ijbqZklbyfbibr_lkyjZa^_evgh\ kemqZyo?kebijbqZklb_djZldh_g_gZibkZgZ?kebm ijbqZklby_klvaZ\bkbfh_keh\h_s_g_gZibkZggZy ?keb \ ij_^eh`_gbb _klvijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_k khxahfZ g_mklZ\rbcZ hl^hogm\rbc< hklZevguo kemqZyo g_ k ijbqZklbyfb ibr_lky keblgh dh]^Z[_aG?g_mihlj_[ey_lky Ij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ ex[_agu_ qblZl_eb q_eh\_dZ ihegh]h\ukhdh]he_lk_fb^_kylbk ebphfgZihfbgZxsbfg_kdhevdhebphDjueh\Zk ykguf b mfguf\ahjhfih^gZ\bkr_c[jh\vxk \Z`ghchkZgdhc f_jghc j_qvx f_^ebl_evghc ihoh^dhc \hl \Zf H\kygbdh\Ghkbehgijhklhjguckbgbc kxjlmdk ^ebggufbjmdZ\ZfbaZklz]gmluc ^h\_jom r_edh\uc ebeh\uc ieZlhd gZ r__ yjdh \uqbs_ggu_kZih]bk dbklyfbJmdbm g_]h[uebij_djZkgu_fy]db_b[_eu_hgqZklh\ l_q_gb_jZa]h\hjZ[jZekyaZim]h\bpuk\h_]h kxjlmdZ H\kygbdh\ k\h_x \Z`ghklvx b g_ih^\b`ghklvx kfurezghklvx b e_gvx k\hbf ijyfh^mrb_f b mihjkl\hf gZihfbgZe fg_jmkkdbo [hyj ^hi_ljh\kdbo \j_fzg <k_ khk_^b _]h qj_a\uqZcghm\Z`Zebb ihqblZebaZq_klvagZlvkyk gbfBKLmj]_g_\L_dklhlghkblkyd om^h`_kl\_gghfmklbex GZrb f_klhbf mq_gbdb e_lhf hl^uoZeb gZ kihjlb\ghcijbeZ] [Za_ Mq_gbdb klZjrbo deZkkh\ ijbeZ] kms_kl\bl hl^uoZeb e_lhf gZ kihjlb\ghc ijbeZ] [Za_ Mq_gbdbklZjr_deZkkgbdbkms_kl\ble_lhfhl^uoZebgZkihjlb\ghc ijbeZ][Za_GZrb mq_gbdb kh]eZkh\Zgb_ gZ kihjlb\ghc [Za_ kh]eZkh\Zgb_ klZjrbo deZkkh\ kh]eZkh\Zgb_ mq_gbdbklZjr_deZkkgbdbkh]eZkh\Zgb_;_eu_qZcdbju[heh\u i_j_ghkgagZq_gb_k djbdhfghkbebkv gZ^ >hghf Rhe <ukhdh klhbl khegp_ gZ g_[_ ]hjyqhi_q_l a_fexfZlmrdm i_j_ghkgagZq_gb_ Dhevp <vzlky mebpZaf_y i_j_ghkgagZq_gb_FZyd<gmdrhnzjbaaZjmeydeZgy_lky ^_^m L\Zj^ @_gsbgZ\jZq ba ^hfZ hl^uoZ \ukemrZeZK_fzgZ IZmkl ;jh^yl \_ljukdhfhjhob i_j_ghkgagZq_gb_aZ^_\Zxl ijh\h^Z BkZd B i_eb ^_\hqdbih^jhkldb gZ [_j_]mk\h_cj_dbL\Zj^GZ^<he]hcj_dhcjZkie_kdZeZ]ZjfhgvkZjZlh\kdb_ kljZ^Zgvy Kmjd Ihrze [mdkbj ©Dhq_]Zjª k q_lujvfy[Zj`Zfbg_nlygdZfbIZmklKlZjbgguc\Zevk©Hk_ggbckhgªb]jZ_l]ZjfhgbklBkZdKlZjbgguc ijbeZ] \Zevk kms_kl\bl ©Hk_ggbc ijbeZ] khgkms_kl\blª b]jZ_l ]eZ]he ]Zjfhgbkl kms_kl\blih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkij> @ibrmlkyk ^_nbkhf< kdZqdZomqZkl\h\ZebdhgbdjZkZ\puM \hjhlkdeZ^Zklhyeklhjh`klZjbdGZ[_j_]mj_db\ujhkaZ\h^]b]Zglibrmlky[_a^_nbkZ< kdZqdZo mqZkl\h\Zeb djZkZ\pu dhgb M \hjhl kdeZ^Z klhyeklZjbd klhjh`GZ[_j_]mj_db\ujhk]b]Zgl aZ\h^DjZkZ\pu± djZkb\u_klZjbd± klZjuc]b]Zgl± [hevrhcF_`^mijbeh`_gb_fb hij_^_ey_fufkms_kl\bl_evgufihklZ\e_g ^_nbk \ lhf kemqZ_ _keb hij_^_ey_fh_ keh\h klhbl i_j_^ ijbeh`_gb_f @mjgZe ©Ijbjh^Zª klZe i_j\uf `mjgZehf dhlhjuc jZkkfZljb\Ze\hijhkuwdheh]bbIh`b\hibkghc^hebg_ijhl_dZeZ j_dZ:fmjBg`_g_jI_ljh\Z [ueZ emqrbf ki_pbZebklhf \ k\h_ch[eZklb<jZqB\Zgh\Z _oZeZ \ [hevgbpmb hq_gv[hyeZkvhiha^Zlv GZ n_klb\Ze_ \uklmiZeb klm^_gluZjfyg_ Hgb gZ jmkkdhfyaud_^_deZfbjh\Zebklbohl\hj_gbyihwlZImrdbgZHlju\hd ba jhfZgZ E G Lheklh]h ©<hcgZ b fbjª h kjZ`_gbb ih^ :mkl_jebp_fijhqzeij_ih^Z\Zl_evebl_jZlmju:jlbkl]hjh^kdh]hl_ZljZ ki_e Zjbx ba hi_ju ©LjZ\bZlZª dhfihablhjZ <_j^b :gkZf[ev gZjh^guo bgkljmf_glh\ bkihegbe jmkkdmx i_kgx ©<h ihe_[_j_aZklhyeZª<he]Zljm`_gbpZ=eZ\ghc mebp_c Jhkkbb ah\ml wlm m^b\bl_evgmx j_dm \_ebqZxl<he]hcfZlmrdhcL_qzlj_dZ<he]Z ihqlbq_j_a\kxkljZgmk k_\_jZgZx]ihdZg_khevxlky_z \h^uk khezgufbdZkibckdbfbK_]h^gy <he]Z ± j_dZljm`_gbpZ Fgh]h gZ g_c aZ\h^h\]b]Zglh\Dlhl_i_jvg_agZ_lfZjdm©<:Aª"Ba_]h\hjhlih\k_fmk\_lm jZat_a`Zxlky fbeebhgu gh\uo dhfnhjlZ[_evguo e_]dh\uoZ\lhfh[be_cGZdhg\_c_jguoebgbyoaZ\h^ZjZ[hlZ_lfgh]hfZkl_jh\kZfhc\ukhdhcd\ZebnbdZpbbKlbev l_dklZ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc^Zggucl_dklkem`bl^ey\ha^_ckl\by gZ qblZl_ey \ p_eyo ijhiZ]Zg^u ijhkeZ\e_gby hl_q_kl\_gghc ijhfure_gghklb J_Zebam_lky \ \b^_ im[ebpbklbq_kdhcklZlvb hq_jdZ Bf_xl f_klh lhj`_kl\_ggu_ wfhpbhgZevgh hdjZr_ggu_keh\Zjblhjbq_kdb_\hijhku Keh\h ^_\ba ba njZgp ya i_j\hgZqZevgh ± ©gZ^ibkv gZ]_j[_ beb sbl_ª bf__l e_dkbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_ ©djZldh_ baj_q_gb_beb keh\h \ dhlhjhf \ujZ`Z_lky jmdh\h^ysZy b^_y ih\_^_gby beb^_yl_evghklbdh]heb[hªgZijbf_j >_\ba kf_euo ©;hjhlvkyb bkdZlv gZclbb g_k^Z\ZlvkyªDZ\Kbf\he ba]j_qya©agZdijbf_lZªh[hagZqZ_l©ij_^f_lkem`Zsbc mkeh\guf gZbf_gh\Zgb_f dZdh]heb[h ihgylby b^_bª gZijbf_j=hem[v± kbf\he fbjZHebfibckdbc FbrdZ klZe kbf\hehf hebfibZ^u ijhoh^b\r_c\ Fhkd\_>_\bahf kj_^g_\_dh\h]hjupZjkdh]hhj^_gZ[ueZnjZaZ©Ih[_^Zbebkf_jlvª EZg^rZnlu AZiZ^ghc Kb[bjb jZaghh[jZagu_ \he`kdb_i_caZ`b hdZaZlv ihkeZf ]hkl_ijbbfkl\h jZ^mrgh \klj_lblv ]hkl_c \ujZablv ]em[hdmx ijbagZl_evghklv bkdj_gg_ ih[eZ]h^ZjblvaZihfhsvljm`_gbdbihe_cb h]hjh^h\n_klb\ZevaZjm[_`guodbghnbevfh\ ZgkZf[ev mdjZbgkdbo [Zygbklh\ dhg_qgZy hklZgh\dZljZf\Zy ^\b`_gb_ klhebqguo ljhee_c[mkh\ djZkhqgu_ \bljbgufZ]Zabgh\BaaZ fblbg]h\ ijhoh^ysbo k_]h^gy \ Fhkd\_ ^\b`_gb_ klhebqguoljhee_c[mkh\[uehaZljm^g_ghFhkdh\kdb_ ij_^ijbgbfZl_eb \ujZabeb ]em[hdmx ijbagZl_evghklvfwjmFhkd\uXjbxEm`dh\maZhdZaZggmxih^^_j`dm GZ aZj_ h[klhyl \hckdh ^\bgmehkv \i_jz^ h[klhylI Dhklzj URSHe `Zjdh h[klhyl k lj_kdhf h[klhyl Q K_fzg B\Zgh\ kem`be klhjh`_f gZ `_e_aghc ^hjh]_ h[klhylHgjZ[hlZeg_ihdeZ^Zyjmd h[klhylF=LZdhcieykdbygbdh]^Z h[klhylg_\b^u\Ze\ihke_^kl\bbh[klhylDhj >\bgmehkv ]eZ] dm^Z" \i_jz^ gZj_q ijbfudZgb_ ^\bgmehkv ]eZ] dh]^Z" gZ aZj_ kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ =hj_e ]eZ] dZd" `Zjdh gZj_q ijbfudZgb_ ]hj_e ]eZ]dZd" k lj_kdhf kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ Kem`be]eZ] ]^_" gZ `_e_aghc ^hjh]_kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfmijZ\e_gb_ JZ[hlZe ]eZ] dZd" g_ ihdeZ^Zy jmd ^__ijbqh[hjhlijbfudZgb_G_\b^u\Ze]eZ]dh]^Z"gbdh]^ZgZj_qijbfudZgb_ g_ \b^u\Ze ]eZ] dh]^Z" \ihke_^kl\bb gZj_q ijbfudZgb_K_fzg kms B\Zgh\ kms kem`be ]eZ] klhjh`_f kms gZij_^eh] `_e_aghc ijbeZ] ^hjh]_ kms Ih\_kl\ g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijhklj> @Fhj_jZau]jZehkvdZd"g_gZrmldmkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_h[jZaZ ^_ckl\by <kx ghqv dZd ^he]h" kms_kl\f_klhbf mijZ\e_gb_ \j_f_gb \hegu g_ i_j_klZ\ZydZd"^__ijbqijbfudZgb_h[jZaZ^_ckl\byk ]jhohlhf dZd"kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ h[jZaZ ^_ckl\by h[jmrb\Zebkv dm^Z"f_klZ gZ [_j_] kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ < KZjZlh\ dm^Z" kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_f_klZl_iehoh^ ^he`_g [ue ijbclb dh]^Z" \_q_jhf gZj_q ijbfudZgb_ \j_f_gb gh ihq_fmlh ihq_fm" gZj_q ijbfudZgb_ijbqbguhiZa^u\ZeFuihg_\he_ hlq_]h"gZj_qijbfudZgb_ijbqbgu aZghq_\Zeb ]^_" gZ ijbklZgb kms_kl\ kij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_f_klZ < l_q_gb_ kmlhd dh]^Z" kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_\j_f_gb ]hjyqZy \h^Z g_ reZihq_fm" baaZ Z\Zjbb kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ijbqbgu ]^_" \ dhl_evghc kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_f_klZ:\Zjby[ueZij_^hl\jZs_gZihq_fm"[eZ]h^ZjygZoh^qb\hklb kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_ ijbqbgu ^_`mjgh]h< kemqZ_^h`^y ijbdZdhfmkeh\bb"kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_mkeh\by wdkdmjkby hlf_gy_lky GZ ghqe_]aZq_f" kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_p_eb lmjbklu jZkiheh`bebkv ]^_" m ha_jZ kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf mijZ\e_gb_f_klZHgb^he]hdZd"gZj_qijbfudZgb_h[jZaZ^_ckl\by jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb g_kfhljy gZ qlh" g_kfhljy gZ mklZehklvkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfmijZ\e_gb_mklmibl_evgh_agZq_gb_Hebfibckdb_b]juKh\j_f_ggh_ hebfibckdh_ e_lhkqbke_gb_ \_^zlky k ]h^Zgh Hebfibckdb_ b]ju kms_kl\mxl ba^Z\gZ Hgb gZqZebkv \ >j_\g_c=j_pbb\ ]h^m^hgZr_cwju Lh]^Z b]juijh\h^bebkv\l_q_gb_e_lgbo f_kyp_\ \ ]hjh^_ HebfibyIh[_^bl_evihemqZe\gZ]jZ^m \_ghd ba \_l\_c fZkebgu b gZ jh^bg_ _fm mkljZb\ZeZkvlhj`_kl\_ggZy\klj_qZ<ihke_^kl\bb klZeb ijh\h^blvky b abfgb_ Hebfibckdb_ b]jugZau\Z_fu_;_eufbhebfibZ^ZfbBokqzl\_^zlkyk ]h^Z< gZr_ckljZg_ Hebfibckdb_b]ju\i_j\u_ [uebijh\_^_gu\ ]h^m Wlh [ueb ;;,, e_lgb_ Hebfibckdb_ b]ju dhlhju_ hldjuebkvbxey\ Fhkd\_Kh\k_odhglbg_glh\ ijb_oZeb\ klhebpm mqZklgbdbb ]hklbHebfibZ^u Ijb fZe_cr_c m^Zq_ mkeh\by kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hfhgg_h[udgh\_gghh[h^jyeky>hkl < kemqZ_ gZiZ^_gby mkeh\by kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf aZibjZcl_\hjhlZ^Z\u\h^bl_khe^ZlI BaaZ rmfZ ijbqbgu kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf iZ^Zxs_]h^h`^ygbq_]hg_[uehkeurghLIeZ\Zgb_ihj_d_[uehhiZkgh \ke_^kl\b_ [ukljhlu ijbqbgu kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf l_q_gby:j_K]hjyqZ ijbqbgugZj_qb_hgg_h[jZlbe\gbfZgbygZmrb[KZgblZjgucih_a^hlijZ\eyeky\ HfkdgZj_fhgl p_ebkms_kl\k ij_^eh]hfIZg Ihke_ fblbg]Z \j_f_gb kms_kl\k ij_^eh]hf Q_j_iZgh\ijb]eZkbe Njheh\Z d k_[_ ihm`bgZlv G Gbd < ijh^he`_gb_^gy \j_f_gb kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf i_j_[u\Zeh \ fh_c ob`bg_[he__ khjhdZ q_eh\_d ba jZaguo ^_j_\_gv FFZd < l_q_gb_\k_]h iml_r_kl\by \j_f_gb kms_kl\ k ij_^eh]hf jZ[hlu [ueh\^h\hevIj`M[_^blvky\ihke_^kl\bb<ke_^kl\b_[he_agb\ l_q_gb_ghqb\ ijh^he`_gb_g_^_eb<heh^ygZqZemqblvky \ jh^ghfk_e_Jmdh\h^bl_evihoh^ZjZaj_rbegZfbkdmiZlvkyFu\urebba^mrghcdhfgZlugZdjuevph hk\_`blvky h[klhyl p_eb Lj_g_j ij_^eh`be kihjlkf_gZfy\blvky gZaZgylbymljhfFuj_rbeb \k_fdeZkkhfihclb gZdhgp_jl M]jh`Zxs_ gZj_q jhdhq_l fhj_ K rmfhf kms_kl\ kij_^eh]hfdZlylky]jhagu_\Zeu>m_lhq_gv gZj_qoheh^guc\_l_jGZqzjghfdZdlmrvkjZ\gblh[hjhlg_[_g_f_evdZ_lgb h^gZa\za^hqdZG_mfhedZygb gZfb]^__ijbqh[hjhlie_sml\hegu <^Zeb `_el_xl dZd [e_^gu_ iylgZ kjZ\gbl h[hjhl h]gbnhgZj_c<uc^yaZ\hjhlZ^__ijbqh[hjhlfuih\_jgmeb\ijZ\hb ih[j_ebg_ki_rZ^__ijbqihfy]dhciuevghc^hjh]_QG_ qZklbpZ mfhedZy ^__ijbq gb qZklbpZ gZ ij_^eh] fb]kms_kl\blie_sml ]eZ]\hegukms_kl\blih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijhkljhkeh`gh[hkh[eh[klhyl_evkl\hf\ujZ`^__ijbqh[hjhlhf>_^__ijh[hjhl_ @G?b GBG_kem`bl^eyhljbpZgbyG_ibr_lkykeblghkhkeh\Zfbdhlhju_[_aG?g_mihlj_[eyxlky g_^hq_l b kh \k_fb ^jm]bfb keh\Zfb djhf_ gb`_baeh`_gguokemqZ_\G?ibr_lkyhl^_evghdh]^Z_klvbebih^jZamf_\Z_lkyijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_k khxahfZ G_ijZ\^ZZ eh`v G? ibr_lky hl^_evgh hl ]eZ]heh\ ^__ijbqZklbc djZldboijbqZklbcb iheguoijbqZklbck aZ\bkbfufbkeh\ZfbG?ibr_lkyhl^_evgh_keb_klvkeh\Zkh\k_fg_\h\k_g_gbqmlvg_b l^kh\k_fg_[hevrhcGb mihlj_[ey_lky \ ij_^eh`_gbyo ]^_ m`_ _klv hljbpZgb_ g_g_lg_evay^eylh]hqlh[umkbeblvwlhhljbpZgb_G_lgb a\_a^hqdb I_j_^ kdZam_fuf \ ijb^Zlhqguo ij_^eh`_gbyo ^ey mkbe_gbyiheh`bl_evgh]h agZq_gby Dm^Z GB ihkfhljb \kx^m dbibl jZ[hlZGB ibr_lkylZd`_\ hl^_evguo\ujZ`_gbyogb ju[Zgb fykh , Ijbe_l_\ gZ f_klh ]mkb rmfgh himkdZxlky gZ \h^m:dk =jhohl [eb`g_]h [hy _sz hk_gvx ih^gye f_^\_^y ba [_jeh]b gZjmrb\ _]h abfgxx kiyqdm Ihe AZ Fhkd\hcj_dhcZe_y \klZe jZkk\_l S DZd iZjmk qZcdZ lZf [_e__l \ \ukhl_N_l Jmq_zd ih\hjZqb\Ze gZijZ\h b kljmbeky \^hev [hevrh]hh\jZ]Zkeb\Zykvk ^jm]bfbjh^gbdZfbKheKg_]m djuevpZdZdi_khdau[mqbc?_HimkdZxlky± kZ^ylkyjh^gbd± jmq_cDZd gZj_q iZjmk kms_kl\ qZcdZ kms_kl\ lZf gZj_q [_e__l ]eZ]he \ ij_^eh] \ukhl_ kms_kl\ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkdeijhkl^\mkhkljZkijhkljhkeh`gh[hkh[eh[klhyl_evkl\hf\ujZ`kjZ\gblh[hjhlhf>_kjZ\gblh[hjhl_ @Kg_] kms_kl\ m ij_^eh] djuevpZ kms_kl\ dZd gZj_q i_khd kms_kl\ au[mqbc ijbeZ] ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhkl ^\mkhkljZkijhklj> @<^hev± keh]< ± >\@± kh]ea\hgdl\_j^> ± >^@± kh]ea\hgdl\_j^H ± >h@± ]eZkgm^ZjgE ± >e¶@± kh]ea\hgdfy]dV ± g_h[hagZqZ_la\mdZa\mdZ[md\,, B jZaebqZe y dZd mahj gZ g_c am[pu ^Ze_dbo ]hj Ihjhc \ms_ebb rZdZe djbqZe b ieZdZe dZd ^bly« Y kZf dZd a\_jv [ueqm`^ex^_cb iheab ijylZekydZdaf_c>hogmebkhggu_p\_lubdZdhgbgZ\klj_qm^gxy ih^gye]heh\mfhxFE_jfhglh\©Fpujbª<_kgZgZklmibeZ\ wlhf]h^mjZggyy^jm`gZybdZd\k_]^Z\Ihe_kv_g_h`b^ZggZyIh[_`Zebih^_j_\_gkdbfmebpZf[mjeb\u_dhjbqg_\u_k\_jdZxsb_jmq_cdbk_j^blhi_gykv\hdjm]\klj_qguodZf_gv_\ b [ukljh \_jly s_idb b ]mkbguc imo \ h]jhfguo em`Zo\h^u hljZabehkv ]hem[h_ g_[h k ieu\msbfb ih g_fm djm]eufblhqgh djmlysbfbky [_eufb h[eZdZfb k djur ihkuiZebkv qZklu_a\hgdb_ dZieb <hjh[vb klZyfb h[kuiZ\rb_ ijb^hjh`gu_ \_leudjbqZeb lZd ]jhfdh b \ha[m`^zggh qlh gbq_]h g_evay [ueh jZkkeurZlvaZbodjbdhfIh:DmijbgmKlbevl_dklZ± om^h`_kl\_ggucGZ^hfgh]himl_r_kl\h\Zlv± g_h[yaZl_evgh©gh]Zfbªi_j__a`Zyk f_klZgZ f_klhbah^ghckljZgu\ ^jm]mxgh©iml_r_kl\h\Zlvªihdgb]Zfk ihfhsvxdgb]k ihfhsvxfma__\B i_j\h_ ©iml_r_kl\b_ª dhlhjh_ q_eh\_d ^he`_g kh\_jrZlv ±wlh ©iml_r_kl\b_ª ih k\h_c kljZg_ AgZdhfkl\h k bklhjb_c k\h_ckljZgu k _z iZfylgbdZfb k _z dmevlmjgufb ^hklb`_gbyfb ± wlh\k_]^ZjZ^hklvg_kdhgqZ_fh]hhldjulbygh\h]h\ agZdhfhfjZ^hklvmagZ\Zgby ijb\uqgh]h \ gh\hfAgZdhfkl\hb hagZdhfe_gb_^jm]bo_keblugZklhysbciZljbhl± [_j_`gh_hlghr_gb_d k\h_cklZjbg_d k\h_cbklhjbbb[hk\hykljZgZihfbfhbaf_j_gby\ ijhkljZgkl\_bf__l_szb ©q_l\zjlh_baf_j_gb_ª± \h\j_f_gb?keb\uex[bl_k\hxkljZgm\ug_fh`_l_g_ex[blvk\h_cbklhjbbg_fh`_l_g_[_j_qviZfylgbdh\ijhreh]h >KEboZqz\Klbev l_dklZ ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc ^Zgguc l_dkl kem`bl ^ey \ha^_ckl\bygZqblZl_ey\ p_eyoijbau\ZbamqZlvbklhjbx[ulviZljbhlhfJ_Zebam_lky\ \b^_im[ebpbklbq_kdhcklZlvbhq_jdZBf_xlf_klhlhj`_kl\_ggu_wfhpbhgZevghhdjZr_ggu_keh\Zih\lhju<h \lhjhf Z[aZp_ lbj_ klZ\blky f_`^m ih^e_`Zsbf b kdZam_fufi_j_^keh\hfWLHLbij_qb± jZkkm`^_gb_< dZ`^hfgh\hfZ[aZp_\ujZ`Z_lkygh\ZyfukevKemrZlvdhgp_jl hi_jZdhfihablhjZ;hjh^bgZ hiha^ZlvbaaZZ\ZjbbhlijZ\blvZ\lhfZrbgm\ j_fhgl]Za_lgucdbhkddjZkhqghhnhjfe_ggZy\bljbgZa^Zgbykh\j_f_gghcZjobl_dlmjuj_klZ\jbjh\ZlvklZjbggmxdZjlbgmkbf\he ^jm`[uFhb jh^bl_eb \ wlb \uoh^gu_ ih_oZeb \ l_Zlj kemrZlv h[klhyldhgp_jl ^hiheg_gb_Ih jZ^bh i_j_^Z\Zeb hi_jm ^hiheg_gb_ dhfihablhjZ hij_^_e_gb_;hjh^bgZ hij_^_e_gb_BaaZ Z\Zjbb h[klhyl kemqb\r_cky gZ ^hjh]_ ij_ih^Z\Zl_evhiha^Ze kdZam_fh_gZe_dpbxGZi_j_\Ze_dZjZ\Zg aZ^_j`ZekyLygmeh \_q_jg_cijhoeZ^hc h^ghkhkl jZkijhklj IjbkZ`b\Z_fky d dhkljm h^ghkhkl jZkijhklj =mklhc lmfZg h^ghkhkl jZkijhklj Bafhjhkvh^ghkhklg_jZkijhklj >h`^v ]hgbl k ]hj\_l_jIh=N_^hk__\m <u ihc^zl_ baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph gZ klZ^bhg"^\mkhkl J_[ylZ kjhqgh \ha\jZlbl_ ih\_eblgZde ebph \[b[ebhl_dmoj_klhfZlbbh^ghkhkl ?^m baty\blgZdegZkl\j ebph \h >\hj_p kihjlZ h^ghkhkl Lu <Zey ih_^_rv baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph kh fghc" ^\mkhkl ;_`bf ih\_eblgZde kdhj_c h^_\Zlvky h^ghkhkl J_[ylZ g_ hiZa^u\Zcl_ih\_eblgZdeebphgZaZgylbydjm`dZh^ghkhklHij_^_ezgghebqgu_ij_^eh`_gby AZ\ljZ b^m ]eZ]\ baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph k jZ^bklhf bijh\h^gbdhf \ ]hju Q_j_a ^\Z qZkZ kgh\Z [m^m ]h\hjblv ]eZ]\baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph k \jZqhf K q_]h ^_gv gZqbgZlv [m^_f ]eZ]\ baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph " >Z\Zc k_]h^gy hkfhljbf]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZde k_\_jgu_ kdehgu Ihq_fm g_ b^zrv hl^uoZlv ]eZ]\ baty\blgZdegZkl\jebph"G_aZ[m^v k_]h^gykhh[sblv ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZdeebph\ rlZ[h kh[ulbyo\q_jZrg_]h^gyIh=N_^hk__\m Ex[ex l_[y I_ljZ l\hj_gv_ ex[ex ]eZ]\ baty\blgZdegZkl\j ebph l\hc kljh]bc kljhcguc \b^ hij_^ebqgh_DjZkmcky]jZ^I_ljh\b klhc ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZdeebphg_dhe_[bfhdZdJhkkbyhij_^ebqgh_ ;ueZm`ZkgZyihjZh[ g_c k\_`h \hkihfbgZgv_ H[ g_c ^jmavy fhb ^ey \Zk gZqgm]eZ]\ baty\blgZde[m^\j ebph k\hz ih\_kl\h\Zgv_ hij_^ebqgh_ Fhc ^jm] hlqbag_ ihk\ylbf ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZde ebph^mrbij_djZkgu_ihju\uhij_^ebqgh_JZkkdZ`m ]eZ]\baty\blgZde[m^\jebphl_[_kdZadmhij_^ebqgh_dhlhjmx\j_[yq_kl\_jZkkdZau\ZeZfg_klZjZydZefuqdZKdZ`b ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZdeebphhij_^ebqgh_ [jZl_pdZdmx^_\mrdm ^_j`brvlu m k_[y ih^ dZjZmehf IhdZ`bdZ ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZde ebphfg_ _z hij_^ebqgh_ Ihlhf h[jZlbeky hg >Im]Zqz\@ d FZjv_B\Zgh\g_ b kdZaZe _c eZkdh\h ©<uoh^b ]eZ]\ ih\_eblgZde ebphdjZkgZy^_\bpZ^Zjmx ]eZ]\ baty\blgZdegZkl\jebphl_[_\hexhij_^ebqgh_ª Dh]^ZehrZ^bljhgmebkvlhhg>Im]Zqz\@_szjZa\ukmgmekybadb[bldbb aZdjbqZefg_ªIjhsZc\Zr_[eZ]hjh^b_ :\hkv m\b^bfky ]eZ]\ baty\blgZde[m^\j ebphdh]^Zgb[m^vhij_^ebqgh_ª:KImrdbg IhagZdhfbfky k gh\uf dhfie_dkhf ]bfgZklbq_kdbo mijZ`g_gbc± IhagZdhfvl_kvk gh\ufdhfie_dkhf]bfgZklbq_kdbomijZ`g_gbc<klZg_f\ h^gmr_j_g]m± <klZgvl_\ h^gmr_j_g]mIjb]hlh\bfkyd oh^v[_gZf_kl_± Ijb]hlh\vl_kvd oh^v[_gZf_kl_Ij_^eh`_gb_ \ujZ`Z_l lj_[h\Zgb_ \ kemqZ_ dh]^Z ]eZ]heklhbl\ nhjf_ih\_ebl_evgh]hgZdehg_gbyZ \kemqZ_dh]^Z]eZ]heklhbl\ nhjf_]hebpZfgh`_kl\_ggh]hqbkeZ± ijb]eZr_gb_d kh\f_klghfm^_ckl\bx HllZedb\Zgb_ hl hihju ± g_h[oh^bfh_ mkeh\b_ ^\b`_gbyGh\k_]^Zeb[u\Z_llZd"<havfbl_\ jmdbly`zemxiZedm<klZgvl_gZez^;jhkvl_iZedm\i_jz^Qlhijhbahc^zl"<uihdZlbl_kvgZaZ^Gh\_^v\ub g_^mfZebhllZedb\Zlvkygh]hchlhev^ZFujZkkfhlj_eby\e_gb_hl^ZqbIhE>EZg^Zm:BDblZc]hjh^kdhfm,IhdZlbl_kvqlhk^_eZ_l_"± ]eZ]heGn± ihdZlblvky,,Ihkl± kh\\b^g_i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ [m^\j\hfgh`qbke_\hebp_,,,<uqlhk^_eZ_l_"ihdZlbl_kv,G_^mfZebqlh^_eZeb"± ]eZ]heGn± ^mfZlv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^g_i_j_o,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\hfgh`qbke_,,,<uqlh^_eZeb"g_^mfZebhlllZedb\Zlvky,JZkkfhlj_ebqlhk^_eZeb"± ]eZ]heGn± jZkkfhlj_lv,,Ihkl± kh\\b^i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\hfgh`qbke_,,,Fuqlhk^_eZeb"jZkkfhlj_ebNhjfu ih\_ebl_evgh]h gZdehg_gby h[jZamxlky hl hkgh\u gZklhys_]h beb [m^ms_]h ijhklh]h \j_f_gb k ihfhsvx kmnnbdkZ B bebgme_\h]h kmnnbdkZ =eZ]heu \ ih\_ebl_evghf gZdehg_gbb \ _^bgkl\_gghfqbke_bf_xlgme_\h_hdhgqZgb_Z \hfgh`_kl\_gghfL?A^_kv hij_^_ezgghebqgu_ ij_^eh`_gby \ujZ`Zxl ih[m`^_gb_d ^_ckl\bx@bl_ebk_eZ]hlh\ylkyd k_\m± < ^_j_\gyob kzeZo]hlh\ylky ]eZ] \ baty\blgZde gZkl\j ebph d k_\mh^ghkhkl KZ^h\gbdb hdZiu\Zxl ^_j_\vy ± < kZ^Zo hdZiu\Zxl ]eZ] \ baty\blgZdegZkl\jebph^_j_\vyh^ghkhkl:]jhghfuijh\_jbeb \koh`_klv k_fyg ± GZ hiulghf mqZkld_ ijh\_jbeb ]eZ] \baty\blgZdeijhr\jfgh`qbkeh\koh`_klvk_fygh^ghkhkl < iZeZl_ _sz ^he]h \kihfbgZeb ijhr\j_fyfgh`qbkeh _]h jZkkdZau X=_jfGZ[Zedhg_khk_^g_c^ZqbaZ`]eb ijhr\j_fyfgh`qbkehk\_lIZmkl<_^mlgZkl\jebph fgh`qbkeh dh fg_ dhgy I <uklmie_gb_ gZr_]h ohjZ[m^mlljZgkebjh\Zlv [m^\j_fyebphfgh`qbkehihjZ^bhH[jZa_p< ^hf_rmfyl^_lb± < ^hf_rmfyl GZ iehsZ^b kljhbl_eb \ha\h^yl a^Zgb_ gh\h]h l_ZljZ ± GZiehsZ^b \ha\h^yl a^Zgb_ gh\h]h l_ZljZ Iheyjgbdb ijbkeZeb \ahhiZjd ^\mo [_euo f_^\_^_c ± < ahhiZjd ijbkeZeb ^\mo [_euof_^\_^_c GZ aZ\h^_ jZ[hqb_ ba]hlh\eyxl ih^rbigbdb ± GZ aZ\h^_ba]hlh\eyxlih^rbigbdb< bgklblml_gZmqgu_khljm^gbdbijh\_^ml jy^ wdki_jbf_glh\ ± < bgklblml_ ijh\_^ml jy^ wdki_jbf_glh\Wdki_jbf_gl± hiul>ey lh]h qlh[u ij_\jZlblv ^\mkhklZ\gu_ ij_^eh`_gby \ kbghgbfbqgu_ h^ghkhklZ\gu_ g_hij_^_ezgghebqgu_ gm`gh m[jZlvih^e_`Zs__ Ij_^eh`_gby ijb wlhf klZgh\ylky g_dhgdj_lgufbfukeylkyg_hij_^_e_gghGZfiha\hgbebb kdZaZebh lhfqlhfu\ub]jZeb<h^\hj_]jhfdhklmqZebIhmljZfgZf\k_]^Zi_j_^ZxlihqlmGZk\k_]^Zah\mld h[_^m\h\j_fy Mfgmx ]heh\m ihqblZxl gZkl\j_fy ebphfgh`qbkeh kfheh^mg_hij_^ebqgh_ >_eh keh\hf g_ aZf_gbrv baty\blgZde[m^\j_fyebphhij_^ebqgh_Ihke_^_eZ aZ kh\_lhf g_ oh^yl gZkl\j_fy ebph fgh`qbkeh g_hij_^ebqgh_ Klhc ih\_eblgZde ebph aZ ijZ\^m ]hjhc hij_^ebqgh_ KgZqZeZ ih^mfZc ih\_eblgZde ebph ihlhf]h\hjbih\_eblgZdeebphhij_^ebqgh_Kheh\vy[Zkgyfbg_ dhjfyl gZkl\j_fy ebph fgh`qbkeh g_hij_^ebqgh_IhkeEx[brvdZlZlvky± ex[bb kZghqdb\hablvI_j_klZgvh lhflm`blvq_fmg_evayihkh[blv;_jbayly\ ^hf± g_kb;h]Z\hg Ih ^hjh]_ a_jdZevgh [e_klys_c fbfh hlq_]h _^m djuevpZ ijhklh_ hij_^ebqgh_ L\Zj^ FZrbgu ihg_kebkv b \hl\u_a`Z_f gZ iehsZ^v hij_^ebqgh_ keh`gh_ :g^j__\ <kZfhf gZqZe_ f_kypZ m^Zjbeb mlj_ggbdb ijhklh_ Ihfgbl_" hij_^ebqgh_ijhklh_ IZmkl ;hevrZy [ueZ jZ^hklvdh]^ZjZkklmibebkv ihke_^gb_ ^_j_\vy keh`gh_ Khe Q_]h k_[_ g_ ohq_rv lh]h b ^jm]bf g_ ^_eZc keh`gh_ hij_^ebqgh_ Ih_e DZd\hedZgb dhjfbhij_^ebqgh_hg \kz\ e_k kfhljblkeh`gh_Ih_eQlh gZibkZgh i_jhflh]hg_\ujm[brv lhihjhfhij_^ebqgh_keh`gh_IhkeG?b GBG_kem`bl^eyhljbpZgby G_ ibr_lky keblgh kh keh\Zfb dhlhju_ [_a G? g_ mihlj_[eyxlkyg_^hq_lb kh\k_fb^jm]bfbkeh\Zfbdjhf_gb`_baeh`_gguokemqZ_\G?ibr_lkyhl^_evghdh]^Z_klvbebih^jZamf_\Z_lkyijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_k khxahfZ G_ijZ\^ZZ eh`v G? ibr_lky hl^_evgh hl ]eZ]heh\ ^__ijbqZklbc djZldboijbqZklbcb iheguoijbqZklbck aZ\bkbfufbkeh\ZfbG?ibr_lkyhl^_evgh_keb_klvkeh\Zkh\k_fg_\h\k_g_gbqmlvg_b l^kh\k_fg_[hevrhcGb mihlj_[ey_lky \ ij_^eh`_gbyo ]^_ m`_ _klv hljbpZgb_ g_g_l g_evay ^ey lh]h qlh[u mkbeblv wlh hljbpZgb_ G_l gb a\_a^hqdb I_j_^ kdZam_fuf \ ijb^Zlhqguo ij_^eh`_gbyo ^ey mkbe_gby iheh`bl_evgh]h agZq_gby Dm^Z GB ihkfhljb \kx^m dbibljZ[hlZ GB ibr_lky lZd`_ \ hl^_evguo \ujZ`_gbyogb ju[Z gbfykhGZf_klhju[Zedb\uh[uqghijb_a`Z_l_aZjZg__Ghqm_l_magZdhfuo Mljhf ijhkuiZ_l_kv \ qbklhc dhfgZl_ [_e_gvdh]h fZaZgh]h ^hfbdZ Khegp_ ke_ibl ]eZaZ @fmjbl_kv hl yjdh]h k\_lZ G_gZ^he]h kgh\Z aZkuiZ_l_ Ihlhf \klZ_l_ Ijbp_iey_l_ gZ kibgmjxdaZd IjhsZ_l_kv k ]hkl_ijbbfgufb ohay_\Zfb G_l_ji_eb\hrZ]Z_l_d ]mklufdZfurh\ufaZjhkeyfOZjZdl_j ih\_kl\h\Zgby y\ey_lky [he__ h[h[szgguf qblZl_evdZd[ukZfmqZkl\m_l\ bah[jZ`Z_fhf\h\lhjhfkemqZ_ihke_i_j_^_edb,Ke_iblqlh^_eZ_l"± ]eZ]heGn± ke_iblv,,Ihkl± g_kh\\b^i_j_o,,kijG_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qbke_\ ebp_,,,Khegp_qlh^_eZ_l"ke_ibl JZkkdZa <_q_j__l baty\blgZde gZkl\j_fy h^ghkhkl ± GZklmiZ_l \_q_j ^\mkhkl K mljZ [ue fhjha ^\mkhkl ± K mljZfhjhabeh baty\blgZde ijhr\j_fy h^ghkhkl Fg_ ohq_lkykiZlv baty\blgZde gZkl\j_fygn]eZ]heZ h^ghkhkl ± Y ohqmkiZlv^\mkhklF_gyk mljZagh[bl± F_gyk mljZagh[beh;Z[mrd_ \_kv ^_gv g_a^hjh\blky ± ;Z[mrd_ \_kv ^_gv g_a^hjh\behkvJZkk\_lZ_l± <kdhj_jZkk\_ehIeZgIhgylb_± [_aebqgu_ij_^eh`_gby<ujZ`_gb_kdZam_fh]h\ [_aebqghfij_^eh`_gbbZijhklh_]eZ]hevgh_kdZam_fh_[khklZ\gh_]eZ]hevgh_b bf_ggh_kdZam_fu_AgZq_gb_[_aebqguoij_^eh`_gbcMihlj_[e_gb_[_aebqguoij_^eh`_gbc;_aebqgu_ij_^eh`_gby K\_lZeh ]eZ] ijhr\j_fy L_fg__l ]eZ] gZkl\j_fy <kz [hevr_ aZghkbl ]eZ] gZkl\j_fy kg_]hf hdhrdh Ijh]j_f_eh ]eZ]ijhr\j_fy \^Zeb < ]hje_ m K_\Zklvygh\Z i_j_o\Zlbeh ]eZ]ijhr\j_fyOheh^gh gZj_qb_GZk_e_l_fghgZj_qb_ b lboh gZj_qb_ JZ^hklgh \b^_lv gZj_qb_gn]eZ]heZ^jm`gu_\koh^uFh`gh[uehjZaebqblv fh`gh [uehgn]eZ]heZ kZfuc ^Zevgbc dmj]Zg \ kl_ib >he]hfg_ g_ kiZehkv ]eZ]ijhr\j_fy G_q_]h \Zf f_rZlvky g_q_]hgn]eZ]heZ g_ \ k\hz ^_eh IhjZ [u _oZlv ihjZ[ugn]eZ]heZgZZwjh^jhfKm`^_gh gZfjZaemqblvkykm`^_ghgn]eZ]heZH^ghkhklij_^eh`_gby B^m g_ lhjhiykvhij_^_e_gghebqgh_ < wlh \j_fy iha\hgbeb \ ^\_jvg_hij_^_e_gghebqgh_>\mkhklij_^eh`_gbyKg_`gh_ihe_ k aZklu\rbfb\hegZfbgZklZ\^jm] ihjhah\_ehhloheh^gh]hkhegpZ<;_eGZklmiZ_l ij_^ijZa^gbqguc \_q_j;mg Dehqhd g_[Z dZd e_glZ kbg__l gZ^ \Zr_c ]heh\hx I Ghqvxi_j_iZe ^h`^vRmdrK_eh imklugghH[jZa_p < ohjhrmx e_lgxxih]h^mj_[ylZg_kb^yl^hfZ± < ohjhrmxe_lgxxih]h^mj_[ylZfg_kb^blky^hfZ Y k_]h^gy \kx ghqv g_ kiZe ± Fg_ k_]h^gy \kxghqvg_kiZehkv Lh\Zjbs g_ \_jbe \ mki_o gZr_c ih_a^db ± Lh\Zjbsm g_\_jbehkv \ mki_o gZr_c ih_a^db Y ohqm gZmqblvky ohjhrh b]jZlv \ rZofZlu ± Fg_ [u ohl_ehkv gZmqblvky ohjhrh b]jZlv \rZofZlu Hg k_]h^gy g_a^hjh\ ± ?fm k_]h^gy g_a^hjh\blky J_[ylZ g_ohlylm_a`Zlv bakihjlb\gh]heZ]_jy± J_[ylZfg_ohl_ehkvm_a`Zlv bakihjlb\gh]heZ]_jy;_aebqgu_ ij_^eh`_gby f_g__ dhgdj_lgu_ \ gbo ]h\hjblky h^_ckl\bbk [hevr_cbebf_gvr_ckl_i_gvxm\_j_gghklbH[jZa_p<haqbdhklhjh`ghk\h^blk ]hjuehrZ^v± < \h^_m f_gyk\h^blgh]b=^_lh\^Zeblboha\_g_edhehdhevqbd± < ]heh\_m f_gya\_g_ehhlm^ZjZKg_] \_kghc ihkl_i_ggh l_fg__l b lZ_l ± Abfhc gZ mebp_ jZghl_fg__l>_^\h^\hj_m`_p_eucqZkdhe_l^jh\Z± M f_gy\ [hdmdhe_l , H[jZa_p GZ kh[jZgbb ]h\hjbeb h[ memqr_gbb ljm^h\hc^bkpbiebgu ± GZ kh[jZgbb ]h\hjbehkv h[ memqr_gbb ljm^h\hc^bkpbiebguH ijhr_^r_fpbdehg_fgh]hibkZeb± H ijhr_^r_fpbdehg_ fgh]h ibkZehkv < qblZevg_ g_ jZaj_rZeb ]jhfdh jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv± < qblZevg_g_jZaj_rZehkv]jhfdhjZa]h\Zjb\Zlv,, H[jZa_p Fg_ ihjmqbebih^]hlh\blv^hdeZ^± Fg_[uehihjmq_ghih^]hlh\blv^hdeZ^ < [hevgbpZo baaZ wib^_fbb ]jbiiZ aZij_sZxl gZ\_sZlv[hevguo± < [hevgbpZobaaZwib^_fbb]jbiiZ[uehaZij_s_ghgZ\_sZlv [hevguo J_rbeb mklZgh\blv dZjZglbg ± ;ueh j_r_ghmklZgh\blvdZjZglbgIjbdZaZeb\k_fghkblvfZje_\u_ih\yadb±;uehijbdZaZgh\k_fghkblvfZje_\u_ih\yadbH[jZa_p<h^ZaZebeZdhleh\Zg± <h^hcaZebebdhleh\Zg±<h^hcaZebehdhleh\Zg I_khd aZkuiZe demf[m ± I_kdhf aZkuiZeb demf[m ± I_kdhfaZkuiZeh demf[m H]hgv \u`_] ljZ\m ± H]g_f \u`]eb ljZ\m ±H]g_f\u`]ehljZ\m<aju\jZa^jh[bekdZem± <aju\hfjZa^jh[bebkdZem± <aju\hfjZa^jh[behkdZemJZaebqbywlboij_^eh`_gbc\ lhfqlhhgb klZgh\ylkyhli_j\h]hd lj_lv_fm \k_ [he__ g_dhgdj_lgufb [_a hij_^_e_ggh]h ebpZ kh\_jrZxs_]h^_ckl\b_,H[jZa_p>ufsbie_l]eZaZ± Hl^ufZsbie_l]eZaZ I_j_p ``_l yaud ± Hl i_jpZ ``_l yaud H`h] klygme dh`m± Hlh`h]Zklygmehdh`m,,H[jZa_pDZl_jklj_fbl_evghgzkkyd [_j_]m± DZl_jklj_fbl_evghg_kehd [_j_]m <hegu [bebkv h kdZeu ± <hegu [beh h kdZeu ;Zc^ZjdZm^ZjbeZkvh dZf_gv± ;Zc^Zjdmm^Zjbehh dZf_gv,,,H[jZa_p< i_qd_qlhlh]m^bl± < i_qd_]m^blBas_e_c ^m_l\_l_j± Bas_e_c^m_l< ljZ\_qlhlhrmjrbl± < ljZ\_rmjrbl<^Zeb]j_f_e]jhf± <^Zeb]j_f_eh,9H[jZa_pM f_gy[uebl_ljZ^bb dZjZg^Zrb± M f_gyg_[uehl_ljZ^_cb dZjZg^Zr_c GZ jugd_ [ueb ihfb^hju Zi_evkbgu fZg^Zjbgu y[ehdb ±GZ jugd_ g_ [ueh ihfb^hjh\ Zi_evkbgh\ fZg^Zjbgh\ y[ehd <hdjm]^hfZa_ezgu_gZkZ`^_gby± <hdjm]^hfZg_la_ezguogZkZ`^_gbcH[jZa_pFh`gh± L_[_fh`ghaZgbfZlvkyieZ\Zgb_f>_lyfgm`gh^urZlvk\_`bf\ha^mohfMqbl_eyfg_evaydjbqZlvgZmq_gbdh\Fhbfjh^bl_eyfg_dh]^Zijh\_jylvm f_gymjhdbG_\hafh`ghkdZaZlv]^_gZc^_rvZ ]^_ihl_jy_rvFg_ihjZb^lb\ rdhem,H[jZa_pY kdmqZx± Fg_kdmqghLu]jmklbrv± L_[_]jmklghFh]my \hclb"± Fh`ghfg_\hclb",, H[jZa_p DhfgZlZ qbklZy k\_leZy ± < dhfgZl_ qbklhk\_leh>hfijhklhjgucmxlguc± < ^hf_ijhklhjghmxlgh<Z]hg k\h[h^guc m^h[guc ± < \Z]hg_ k\h[h^gh m^h[gh <uklZ\dZ[m^_lbgl_j_kghc± GZ\uklZ\d_[m^_lbgl_j_kgh H[jZa_p P\_klb ± G_ p\_klb p\_lZf iha^g_c hk_gvx >hieulv ± Lhevdh [u^hieulv^h[_j_]ZIhkljhblvky± Ihkljhblvky\ ^\_r_j_g]b >h]gZlv ± G_ ^h]gZlv moh^ys_]h ih_a^Z HiZa^u\Zlv ±HiZa^u\Zlv kljh]h \hkij_sZ_lky M\b^_lv ± Emqr_ h^bg jZam\b^_lvq_fklhjZamkeurZlvIh[u\ZlvgZx]_± G_ih[u\Zlvfg_gZx]_\ wlhf]h^mDmiblvnml[hevgucfyq± Lhevdh[udmiblv nml[hevguc fyq G_ hlklZ\Zlv ± G_ hlklZ\Zlv hl gZijZ\eyxs_]hH[jZa_pLug_kfh`_rvj_rblvwlh]hmjZ\g_gby± L_[_g_j_rblvwlh]hmjZ\g_gby<ug_kfh`_l_m_oZlvk_]h^gy± L_[_g_m_oZlvk_]h^gyLu^he`_g\ ij_gbyo\uklmiZlvi_j\uf± L_[_gm`gh\uklmiblv\ ij_gbyoi_j\uf Ihke_ kh[jZgby y [u ohl_e ih]h\hjblv k lh[hc ± Ihke_ kh[jZgbyfg_gZ^hih]h\hjblvk lh[hcK\_leh gZmebp_b \b^_g kZ^ gZkd\havL\Zj^I_qvgZdZebeZkv ^hdjZkgZb \iZeZld_klZeh g_\ughkbfh`Zjdh=NIv_f qZck fz^hfaZ[hevrbfgh\ufklhehfgZdjulufqbklhcohesh\hckdZl_jlvxKFQmlv[j_a`behkvdh]^ZgZkjZa[m^beb DZd gZf k k_kljbp_c g_ ohl_ehkv \klZ\Zlv :dk Hlpmfh_fm aZohl_ehkv magZlv hlq_]h ihl_deZ gZrZ eh^dZ :dk FZlv ]h\hjbeZ ^he]h b lZd ohjhrh dZd b \ dgb`dZo g_ ibrml:dk GZ g_[_ gZqbgZeh k_j_lv b ih \h^_ aZdem[beky ez]dbciZjhdE_kdLmqgZ g_[_g_[uehghb khegp_ g_\u]ey^u\ZehE_kdGb]^_g_^urblky\hevg_c jh^guoem]h\jh^guoihe_cG Dh]^Z kh\k_f jZkk\_eh >_jkm jZa[m^be gZk :jk Kh^gh]h djZy g_[h hqbklbehkv ]hem[_eh b [ebadh ]^_lh [ueh khegurdh Rmdr Ki_eZ [u ju[dZ i_k_gdm ^Z ]hehkZ g_lIhkeQlhijbiZkzrvlhb gZklheihg_kzrvIhke;m^vk \_kzehc i_kg_c ^jm`_g k ]jmklvx g_aZq_f ^jm`blv L\Zj^ =jhaZ [ueZh[eh`gZyb ]j_f_eh kjZamkh\k_oklhjhgIZmkl ;eZ]h^Zjy lhfm qlh e_lh [ueh `Zjdh_ b kmoh_ ihgZ^h[behkviheb\ZlvdZ`^h_^_j_\hQGZkd\hav± keh]ZG ± >g@± kh]ea\l\: ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^K ± >F@± kh]e]emol\D ± >d@± kh]e]emol\< ± >\@± kh]ea\l\H ± >h@± ]eZkgm^A ± >F¶@± kh]e]emofy]dV ± g_h[haga\mdZ[a\Ihl_deZ± ]eZ]Qlhk^_eZeZ"ihl_deZGn± ihl_qvIhkl ± kh\\ g_i_j_o , kij g_ihkl ± \ baty\ gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^q\ `jEh^dZqlhk^_eZeZ"ihl_deZ<hevg_c± gZj_q>urblkydZd"\hevg__Gn± \hevghDZq_kl\gZH?h[jZaZ^_ckl\by\ kjZ\gblkl_i_gbg_baf>urblky dZd"\hevg_cB^zfl_\_jog_cljhihc<ujh_lkg_]hhqbklbl_evljZgr_x\hl b _^_rv \ wlhc ljZgr__ dZd \ dhjul_ LZfm`\ijZ\h\e_\hg_k\_jgzrvIhke_^gb_^\Zij_^e± h[h[s_gghebqgagZq_gb_< iheyol_fg_ehIZjd^Z\ghaZdjuebLmlkg_]ZgZf_lZ_lf_ljZgZljbKf_jdZ_lky;_aex^ghA\za^ghImklugghG_[u\Zlv_fm\ ]hklbghcL_fgh;_aex^gh,AZdjueb± ]eZ]Qlhk^_eZeb"aZdjuebGn± aZdju\Zlv,, Ihkl ± kh\ \ i_j_o , kij g_ihkl ± \ baty\ gZde ijhr\jfgq,,,Qlhk^_eZeb"aZdjuebKx`_l± wlhjy^k\yaZgguof_`^mkh[hcb ihke_^h\Zl_evghjZa\b\Zxsbokykh[ulbckhklZ\eyxsbokh^_j`Zgb_ijhba\_^_gbyWdkihabpby± wlh\klmibl_evgZyqZklvebl_jZlmjgh]hijhba\_^_gbykh^_j`ZsZyfhlb\udhlhju_jZa\b\Zxlky\ ^Zevg_cr_fAZ\yadhc gZau\Zxl gZqZeh bkoh^guc imgdl kx`_lZ ijhba\_^_gbyDmevfbgZpby± wlhlhqdZgZb\ukr_]hgZijy`_gbykx`_lZJZa\yadhc gZau\Zxl aZ\_jr_gb_ aZdexqbl_evgmx qZklv ijhba\_^_gby JZgg__ abfg__ mljh < dhfgZl_ k\_`h ba nhjlhqdb lyg_lijhoeZ^hc BaaZ aZ^_jgmluo rlhj e_gb\h ijh[b\Z_lky i_j\uc emqbd khegpZ GZ kl_g_ b]jZxl kheg_qgu_ aZcqbdb Gh y g_ ki_rm\kdZdb\Zlvk ihkl_ebK_]h^gy\hkdj_k_gv_b fh`ghkiZlv^he]hK mljZ\ kZ^mihxlkd\hjpu<_kgZKh\k_fl_ieh;ZjlhI_j\h_abfg__mljh<kya_feymdjulZ[_eufimrbklufihdju\ZehfKdj_[bpdbcIylvqZkh\^gy;ebablky\_q_jLjh_i Yjdb_ ]hem[u_ ^gb Kbg__ fhj_ <_q_j [ue lbobc ez]dbcKFFZe_gvdbcjmq_zd<h^Zg_fgh]hdhjbqg_\ZlZyHgZg_ l_qzl Z khqblky ba foh\ hl ih^gh`by g_\ukhdbo [_jzahd b\hevob b [hehlghc ljZ\u J_dZfeZ^_g_p Q_j_a ljb ^_kyldZ rZ]h\i_j_k_qzl _z i_j\uc ^_j_\ygguc fhklhd I_kd Ghqv Ihkdjbiu\Z_l b ihkdjbiu\Z_l klZ\_gdZ Rmdr Dj_idh fhjhabl =NFhjhaOjmklblih^\Ze_gdZfbkg_]GHQbklu_kl_guh[blu_e_khfAZiZo\h^ub kfheuI_kdLj_lbcqZk^gyIZkfmjgh Q <hg jZ^m]Z <_k_eh `blv ;mg ;_a\_ljb_ b \kzg_[haZeblhdjZkdhcL<hlk_jucklZjuc^hfL_i_jvhgimklb ]emoG>mrgZyghqv;m^_l]jhaZ<hgb [e_kgmeh[e_^ghblj_\h`gh;me]GhqvlboZylboZyKg_]juoe=^_lh^Ze_dh\g_[_lyg_l\_kghc;me]AZfhjhadbIh^khoehY \ur_eijhclbkv d j_qd_ ;me] F_eh \_kv f_kyp \ n_\jZe_ ;I<h\kzf fg_ ohq_lky ^hclb ^h kZfhc kmlb \ jZ[hl_ \ ihbkdZo imlb \k_j^_qghckfml_;IAbfZih^oh^bld k_j_^bg_^hjh]bfhdgmlk djurl_qzlb khegp_]j__lkygZev^bg_;I Ikdh\kdZy a_fey gZau\gh_ F_edhe_kv_ gZau\gh_ <ZemgugZau\gh_=hem[u_ha_jpZevgZgZau\gh_Ihey khaj_\Zxs_cj`b gZau\gh_ Fh]mqb_ dZfgb hklZ\e_ggu_ e_^gbdZfb gZihfbgZxl<Zkg_ph\Zkmjh\uci_caZ`_]h[h]ZlujkdhcaZklZ\u<hbklbgmikdh\kdZya_fey± [h]ZlujkdZyaZklZ\Za_febjmkkdhcG_jZaJhkkby\klj_qZeZb ^hklhcghijh\h`ZeZ\jZ]h\RebgZwlhca_fe_ kmjh\u_ [hb b \ khjhd i_j\hf b \ khjhd q_l\zjlhf : \hl biZfylgbdb \hbgkdhckeZ\ugZau\gh_KDhgzgdh\JZgg__mljhLboZyj_dZ>Ze_dbchkljh\Iurgu_dmklu< bo]mklhcl_gbkb^blkhggucju[heh\E_lgbc\_q_jI_j_iheg_gguc klZ^bhg J_rZxsbc fZlq DhfZg^u ^\mo kljZg ]hlh\u d\klj_q_ <hl hdjZbgZ gZau\g <hl AZ\h^kdZy mebpZ gZau\g<hl ^hfbd ih^ lhe_\hc djur_c gZau\g =hj[ Dlh \Zk ijbkeZe">hklIjbfg_g_kf_ckb^_lvhij_^ebqg<klZgvhij_^ebqg KlmiZc hlkx^Z hij_^ebqg Q F_gy dehgbeh dhkgm [_aebqg Khe <^jm] qlhlh aZklZ\beh f_gy h]eygmlvkyKhe GZ f_gy g_ k_j^bl_kv hij_^ebqg IZmkl Ki_rbfgZah\dhkljZhij_^ebqg]^_`^zl gZkijb\Ze=NHg qZkZ^\Z klhye \ lzfguo k_gyo b `^Ze dh]^Z hlhijml ^\_jv g_hij_^ebqgQFg_\k_]^Zohjhrh b ijbylgh [_aedh]^Zihkb^brvfheqZgZ^lbohc\h^hchij_^ebqgKheZjgbpZ hklhjh`ghf_evdZeZ gZ^ lzfgufLjhrbgufem]hfb l_iehkmohiZoeh ^m[hf[_ae;mgKd\havlvfmijh[b\Z_lky yjdh_ieZfy dhkljZb gZ^mr_\gh\vk\_le__l [_ae=NFg_aZohl_ehkvihdehgblvkyfh]beZf ih]b[rbo lh\Zjbs_c [_ae dhfm g_ km`^_gh [ueh \_jgmlvky bawlboimklugguof_kl[_ae=N>@>@ ]^_bb>@ dh]^Z>@dh]^Z>@b >@>@b >@> @dhfm <hl fhj_ gZau\g \hl i_jfkdb_ ^j_fmqb_ f_klZ gZau\g I GZ ijb]hjd_ lh kujh lh `Zjdh N_l <uc^_f klh[hc ih[jh^blv \ emgghf kbygbb hij_^ebq N_l =emoZyiheghqvgZau\g<kzfheqblLxlq Kfhljbhij_^ebqdZd^gzf lmfZgbklh[_eh qmlv [j_a`bl \ g_[_ f_kyp k\_lhaZjgucLxlqQmlv[j_a`behnhgZjvihklZ\e_ggucgZa_fexhk\_sZelboh iZ^Z\rb_ kg_`bgdb F = < dmagbp_ fhehlklmqblf_evgbpm \ukljhyl kdhjh G R_e ghqvx kg_] ]mklhc b [_euc hlkg_]Z \ dhfgZl_ k\_leh [_ae L\Zj^ B^m b jZ^mxkv hij_^ebq E_]dh fg_ [_ae >h`^v ijhr_e L\Zj^ Jh`v jh`vgZau\g>hjh]Zihe_\Zy\_^zlg_\_^hfhdm^ZL\Zj^ K_j_^bgZ yg\Zjy gh gZ iheyo ihqlb kh\k_f g_l kg_]Z <hlgh\Zy ^\mowlZ`gZy rdheZZ jy^hf k g_c kljhyl >\hj_p dmevlmjuDh]^ZabfZ\ jZa]Zj_kf_jdZ_lkyhq_gvjZghG_[haZlygmehk\bgph\hk_jufb lmqZfb b ]mklh ihrze kg_] <kz kbevg__ ijb]j_\Zehkhegp_ b \ ^_j_\gyo b kzeZo aZdZgqb\Zeb ih^]hlh\dm d \_k_gg_ihe_\ufjZ[hlZf?keb\_q_jhfihc^zrv\ [b[ebhl_dmh[yaZl_evghijhqblZc ihke_^gbc ghf_j `mjgZeZ ©Kf_gZª Fheh^z`v ^he`gZklZlv gZke_^gbp_c emqrbo ljZ^bpbc ij_^r_kl\mxsbo ihdhe_gbclZdqlh_cg_h[oh^bfh\hkiblu\Zlv\ k_[_gZklhcqb\hklv\ ij_h^he_gbbljm^ghkl_c K ]eZ\guf qe_ghf ± ih^e_`Zsbf gZau\gu_ JZgg__ mljh<hlfhy^_j_\gyK ]eZ\guf qe_ghf ± kdZam_fuf hij_^_ezgghebqgu_ ]eZ]he \nhjf_]hbeb]hebpZ<b`mqm^gh_ijb\hev_Ihc^_rvkhfghc"G_hij_^_ezgghebqgu_ ]eZ]he \ nhjf_ e fg q gZkl b [m^\jb \nhjf_fgqijhr\j< ^\_jvihklmqZebkvQlhgh\_gvdh]hibrml\ ]Za_lZo";_aebqgu_ g_ fh`_l [ulv ih^e_`Zs_]h Kf_jdZehkv Fg_ g_a^hjh\blky ± =^_ \u ijhoh^beb ij_^^biehfgmx ijZdlbdm" ± kijhkbeGbgm]eZ\gucbg`_g_j± < YjhkeZ\e_± Qlh\Zfihjmqbeb"± L_ogbdm[_ahiZkghklbK:glhgh\< YjhkeZ\e_± Y ijhoh^beZij_^^biehfgmxijZdlbdm\ YjhkeZ\e_L_ogbdm[_ahiZkghklb± Fg_ihjmqbebl_ogbdm[_ahiZkghklb , FZevqbdb ijbmlboeb <b^gh [ueh qlh keh\Z IZ\eZ ijhba\_ebgZgbo]em[hdh_\i_qZle_gb_HgbklZebmdeZ^u\Zlvkyi_j_^h]gzfdZd[ukh[bjZykvkiZlv± Qlhwlh"± kijhkbe\^jm]Dhklyijbih^gy\]heh\m± Wlhdmebqdbe_lylihk\bklu\Zxl± Dm^Z` hgbe_lyl"± : lm^Z]^_]h\hjylabfug_[u\Z_lg_iheg± : jZa\__klvlZdZya_fey"± ?klvg_iheg± >Ze_dh"g_iheg± >Ze_dh^Ze_dhaZlzieufbfhjyfbDhkly\a^hogmeb aZdjue]eZaZBKLmj]_g_\,, Iehl ieue \^hev [_j_]Z Z eh^dZ ± _fm gZi_j_j_a _ij_^e± g_iheg?]hjmrdZ^he]hh]ey^u\Ze _]hZ hg ± ?]hjmrdm _ ij_^e ± g_iheg Q IjZ\^Z ijZ\^hc hklZzlky Z fhe\Zk_[_± fhe\hc_ ij_^e± g_ihegL\Zj^< lmabfmy ijb\yaZeky d k_klj_ ?c rze \hkvfhc ]h^ < gZr_c k_fv_ \k_ [ueb qzjgu_Z hgZ [_e_gvdZy_ ij_^e± g_ihegDZ\: dZdhgZ eh\dhohaycgbqZeZ \ k\hb k_fv e_l <ijhq_f ohayckl\h [ueh ijhklh_ \h^ghf m]em q_j^ZdZ e_`ZeZ dZjlhrdZ \ ^jm]hf ± k\zdeZ b dZimklZemd b khevg_ihegDZ\,©Hggbq_]hl_[_ijhDZlxg_]h\hjbe"ª± kijhkbeZEb^Z FZgy hl\_lbeZ ©Gbq_]hª ©=^_ `_ hgZ [m^_l `blv"ª ± kijhkbeFZdZjFZdZjh\bq©M f_gyª± kdZaZeZFZjvy<Zkbev_\gZIhGQmdh\kdhfm,, Fu lZd b g_ m\b^_ebkv ihlhfm qlh iehoh ^h]h\hjbebkv hf_kl_\klj_qbLh\Zjbsb`^Zebf_gym l_ZljZevguodZkkZ ybo±gZljhee_c[mkghchklZgh\d_< KiZkkdhfEmlh\bgh\_>h KiZkkdh]h g_^Ze_dh g_iheg ?^_f _sz fbgml ^\Z^pZlvhij_^ebqg Dbehf_ljh\uc klhe[ k pbnjhc gZau\g Ih\hjhlgZau\gG_kdhevdhih^tzfh\b kimkdh\gZau\gB \hliZjdgZau\g< ijhoeZ^ghcl_fghl_[_e__l^hfIjb]ey^_\rbkvjZaebqZ_f kl\heu^_j_\v_\^hjh`dmhij_^ebqgG_lhjhieb\h\u]jm`Z_f fZ]gblhnhgguc ysbd jxdaZdb b fhldb ijh\hehdb \ lmj]_g_\kdhfjh^h\hfiZjd_[m^_faZibku\Zlvkheh\v_\hij_^ebqgIZklmo lhevdhijh]gZeklZ^hZ mh]jZ^uiZjdZm`_q_luj_Z\lh[mkZg_ihegKlm^_glubaHjeZg_ihegIZjdba^Zebg_hlebqbrvhlkl_iguoi_j_e_kdh\h[h[sebqgK\hz]g_a^hKiZkkdh_Emlh\bgh\hibkZl_ev[_jz]kx^Z\ha\jZsZekyihke_kdblZgbca^_kvibkZehohlbekyg_ihegIh<I_kdh\m,HojZgmijbjh^u y kqblZx^_ehfk\ylufWlhkhojZg_gb_b mfgh`_gb_[h]Zlkl\Jh^bguIjbau\ h[ hojZg_ ijbjh^u e_kh\^he`_g[ulvh[jZs_gij_`^_\k_]h bf_ggh d fheh^z`b ?c `blv b ohayckl\h\Zlv gZ wlhc a_fe__c b mdjZrZlv _z Q_f jZgvr_ fheh^z`v ijbf_lky aZ wlh ^_eh l_f[hevr_ gZdhiblky a_ezgh]h ^h[jZ dh \j_f_gb _z \klmie_gby \ iheghijZ\gh_ gZke_^kl\h @b\h_ ^_j_\h _klv dZiblZe dhlhjuc fgh`blkyk dZ`^ufqZkhfJZa\_^_gb_e_kh\± wlhfm^jZyjZ[hlZ\ijhd\ [m^ms__K\hxex[h\vd Jh^bg_fZehlhevdh^_deZjbjh\Zlv_zdjhf_lh]hgZ^hij_l\hjylv\ `b\u_^_eZH]eygbkv\hdjm]k_[yfheh^hcq_eh\_d<kzqlhlu\b^brvkhldZgh keh`_gh ba ieZf_gghc ex[\b l\hbo ij_^dh\ l\hbo klZjrbokh]jZ`^Zgd Hl_q_kl\mEx[h\vd Jh^bg_gZ^h\hkiblu\Zlvk ex[\bd jh^ghcijbjh^_>hjh]b_ xgu_ ^jmavy >mfu h a_e_gb ± ^mfu h [m^ms_f <kzq_fm jZ^m_lky gZr ]eZa _klv h]jhfgZy dhibedZ ij_^dh\ Ij__fkl\_gghklv± h^gZbahkgh\ijh]j_kkZB imklvi_j\u_^\Z^_j_\pZgZrdhevghf^\hj_beb\Zr_]h ^hfZ[m^mlihkZ`_gu\ q_klv\Zr_cex[bfhcJh^bgu;_j_]bl_b ohevl_wlb^_j_\pZqlh[u\ ihegmxkbemjZa\bebkvhgbih^\ZrbfhdghfIhEE_hgh\m=eZ\gZy fukev l_dklZ ± fheh^_`v ^he`gZ hojZgylv ijbjh^mKlbev± im[ebpbklbq_kdbcEZ[hjZlhjby± eZ[hjZgleZ[hjZlhjguceZ[hjZglkdbcFh]mqZy^_j`Z\Zh[s_q_eh\_q_kdb_b^_Zeukbf\hefbjZ^_\ba kf_euo ij_h[jZah\Zgb_ imklugb \hiehlblv \ `bagv [m^msb_ ihdhe_gbymqZkl\h\Zlv\ ^bkdmkkbbhkms_kl\blvwdki_jbf_glfZjrjmlihoh^ZljZkkZ]Zahijh\h^Z kljhbl_evkl\hfZ]bkljZebq_klgu_ljm`_gbdb>_j`Z\Z ± kljZgZ ]hkm^Zjkl\h ;m^msb_ ± ke_^mxsb_ ]jy^msb_>bkdmkkby± ^bkimlkihj;_euc ]hem[v ± kbf\he fbjZ Wlb ^_jadb_ ieZgu fh`gh \hiehlblv\ `bagvLjZkkZ]Zahijh\h^Zijhc^_lq_j_alZc]mKbevgh kljZ^Zxl hl ]heh^Z b oheh^Z i_\qb_ ilbpu K_j^h[hevgu_]hjh`Zg_mkljZb\Zxl^eygbo[_kieZlgu_klheh\u_\ kZ^Zob ijyfhm k_[ygZhdgZoH^gb\u\_rb\ZxlbahdgZdmkhqdboe_[ZbkZeZgZgblhqd_>jm]b_\uklZ\eyxl\ kZ^memdhrdbk a_jghf b oe_[hfEZahj_\db qb`bq_qzldbp_eufbklZcdZfbihk_sZxlwlb[_kieZlgu_klheh\u_<;bZgdbFukeb fhbfhzbfyljm^u [m^mlijbgZ^e_`ZlvJhkkbb= Hl q_]h aZ\bkbl kZfhkhojZg_gb_ kZfhh[gh\e_gb_ b kZfhhqbs_gb_ gZpbhgZevgh]hyaudZ"Fg_dZ`_lkyqlhhl kZfh]h h[s_kl\Zhl_]hgjZ\kl\_ggh]hkhklhygby<;_eHg >Imrdbg@bamfbl_evgh k [e_klysbf xfhjhf baeh`be ]b[dbf a\hgdbf yaudhffm^ju_ kdZadb jmkkdh]h gZjh^Z Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl ihegh_ jZkijhklj hkeh`g h[hkh[e h[klhyl F = <gzfdZd[m^lh\ e_dkbdhg_aZdexqbehkv\kz[h]Zlkl\hkbeZ b ]b[dhklv gZr_]hyaudZ=Hlghkbl_kv d jh^ghfmyaudm[_j_`ghbex[h\gh ^mfZcl_ h gzf bamqZcl_ _]h ex[bl_ _]h Em] Hgb>agZdb ij_ibgZgby@ kms_kl\mxl qlh[u \u^_eblv fukev ijb\_klbkeh\Z \ ijZ\bevgh_ khhlghr_gb_ b ^Zlv njZa_ ez]dhklv b ijZ\bevgh_a\mqZgb_IZmkl KZfhklhyl_evgu_ qZklb j_qb ± wlh bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ bfy qbkebl_evgh_ f_klhbf_gb_ ]eZ]he gZj_qb_ ijbqZklb_ b ^__ijbqZklb_ Kem`_[gu_ qZklb j_qb ± wlh ij_^eh] khxa b qZklbpZ Ih^e_`Zs__ b kdZam_fh_ ± wlh]eZ\gu_qe_guij_^eh`_gby >hiheg_gb_ hij_^_e_gb_ b h[klhyl_evkl\h ± \lhjhkl_i_ggu_ qe_gu ij_^eh`_gby AgZqbfu_ qZklb keh\Z ± wlh hkgh\Zb hdhgqZgb_dhj_gvkmnnbdk b ijbklZ\dZ <kz k_ju_ dZjb_ kbgb_ ]eZadb kf_rZebkv dZd \ ihe_p\_lu G K qZkm ghqb gZ ^\hj_ ih^gyeky mihjguc hk_ggbc^h`^v D Keurblky k^_j`Zgguc g_ykguc rzihl ghqb L ;uehlboh_e_lg__ mljhLAZj_dhcih^gbfZebkv^m[h\u_ibolh\u_e_kZI_j\<ukhdb_f_lZeebq_kdb_fZqlub^mlq_j_alZc]mGFGZijb]hjd_\b^guijyfu_rbjhdb_mebpuGFKmohc]hjyqbc\_l_jgzkjZkdZezgguc\ha^moRhe<^jm]lj_\h`gh_dhgkdh_j`Zgb_jZa^Zehkv\hlvf_NZ^Fheh^hcg_`gucf_kyp e_`ZegZkbg_fiheh]_ghqbIZmkl Lhihj a\mqZe ]emr_ b ]emr_ khqgu_ [_eu_ s_idb e_l_ebgZ jhkbklmx ljZ\m b ez]dbc lj_kd ihkeurZeky baaZ m^Zjh\EL <hdjm] lygmeZkv iehkdZy mgueZy kl_iv IhkeurZekya\hgdbc dZdhclh meu[Zxsbky ]hehk G_[hevrb_ qbklh ih^f_l_ggu_ ^\hjbdb [ueb h]hjh`_gu a_feygufb aZ[hjZfbIjb[eb`ZekykmfjZqguc]jmklguc\_q_jKljZgbpu[uebbkibkZgudZjZg^ZrhfhkljufZddmjZlgufihq_jdhf<hklhqgZyklhjhgZg_[ZjZ\ghf_jghk\_le_eZkeh\gh_z ihlbohgvdm jZa[Z\eyeb ijhajZqghc jh^gbdh\hc \h^hc <hegu f_edhchkljhciuebrebh^gZaZ^jm]hcBaih^a_feblhjqZeh[hevrh_[_lhggh_ dhe_kh <_l_j ]gZe ih ihex rbjhdb_ ahehlbklu_ \heguWevaZklZeZi_j_ebklu\Zlvk\hxdjhohlgmxaZibkgmxdgb`dmKgh\ZihlygmeZkvkl_ivb kgh\ZaZa\mqZe\ mrZoh^ghh[jZaguckl_ighcklj_dhlkeh`gK:glhgh\,H^ghjh^gufbhij_^_e_gbyfb< gZr_ckljZg_[ukljhjZa\b\Z_lky Z\lhfh[bevguc j_qghc \ha^mrguc ljZgkihjl >eyfhsguo k\_jokdhjhklguo dhfnhjlZ[_evguo eZcg_jh\ g_ kljZrgZgbdZdZy ih]h^Z Kh\j_f_ggu_ j_Zdlb\gu_ kZfhezlu y\eyxlkym^h[guf[ukljufgh^hjh]bfkj_^kl\hfkhh[s_gby,, G_h^ghjh^gufb hij_^_e_gbyfb Ihkljh_gZ ]hjh^kdZy l_e_nhggZy klZgpby KlZjh_ djZkgh_ dbjibqgh_ a^Zgb_ \uoh^bl \i_j_mehd L_e_nhggZy klZgpby bf__l ijyfmx k\yav k ijb]hjh^gufbgZk_ezggufbimgdlZfb,Fg_ohjhrhiZfylgu^_lkdb_kdblZgbyihi_s_jZfDjufZQlhhkh[_gghaZf_qZl_evgh\ i_s_jZo± wlhbom[jZgkl\hlhba^ebgguo \ukhdbo dhehgg lh ba ^ebgguo k\_rb\Zxsboky k\_jomkhkme_d]bjeyg^ aZgZ\_k_c;_eu_`zelu_djZkgu_fbg_jZeuk\hbfbhleh`_gbyfbihdju\Zxlkl_gui_s_j:?N_jkfZg,, Khegp_ k_ehAZiZ^iueZep_eufih`Zjhfyjdhimjimjguobh]g_gghahehluodjZkhdg_fgh]h\ur_wlb]hjyqb_lhgZi_j_oh^beb \ ^ufghdjZkgu_ `zelu_ b hjZg`_\u_ hll_gdb b lhevdh ba\bebklu_ djZy ijbohleb\uo h[eZdh\ hleb\Zeb jZkieZ\e_gguf k_j_[jhf _sz \ur_ kfm]ehjhah\h_ g_[h g_aZf_lgh i_j_oh^beh \g_`guca_e_gh\Zlucihqlb\ [bjxah\ucp\_l:BDmijbgucZ[aZp± gZmqghihimeyjgucklbevc ± om^h`_kl\_ggucDjZy ± keh]ZD ± >d@± kh]e]emol\J ± >j@± kh]ea\l\: ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^Y ± >c@± kh]ea\fy]d± >Z@± ]eZkgm^[a\ , K\_l fZe_gvdhc ghqghc eZfiu kdm^gh ijh[b\Z_lkykd\hav ]hem[hc Z[Z`mj Q KeurZebkv dhjhldb_ hlju\bklu_k\bkldb^Zezdh]hkheh\vyQ< khgghf aZklu\r_f\ha^mo_klhye fhghlhgguc rmf [_a dhlhjh]h g_ h[oh^blky kl_igZy e_lgyyghqvQIuevgZ^hjh]_[ueZ]em[hdZylhgdZyIZg< lzfgu_ hdgZ klmqZeb djmigu_ ^h`^_\u_ dZieb ;ueh oheh^gh qm\kl\h\ZeZkvj_adZyg_ijbylgZykujhklvQKhk_^fhcaZlygmelhgdbf]hehkhfaZmgu\gmx[mjeZpdmxi_kgxI,, Ihfgx jZgg__ k\_`__ lboh_ mljh Ihfgx [hevrhc \_kvahehlhcih^khorbcb ihj_^_\rbckZ^<h^Zih^ehabgZfbklZeZijhajZqgZy e_^ygZy b dZd [m^lh ly`zeZy < ykgmx ^Zev m[_]Zxlqzldh\b^gu_l_e_]jZngu_klhe[uHdgZ\ kZ^hldjulub hllm^Z\__l [h^jhc hk_gg_c ijhoeZ^hc DZ`^uc a\md ]medh jZa^Zzlky \imklhf kujhf b k\_`_f e_km >gb klhyl kbg_\Zlu_ iZkfmjgu_GZklmibeblmfZggu_kbau_kmf_jdbB:;mgbgKo_fu,>@ > @,,> @>@ Dhgvdh[_`pu nb]mjbklu eu`gbdb ]hlh\ylky d abfg_cHebfibZ^_ < l_ieu_^gby moh^be]meylvjZgh^Ze_dhb gZ^he]hIjm^hdZaZekyg_]em[hdbfZ f_edbfKhegp_ m`_kdjuehkvb ghqgu_l_gb[ukljhgZ^\b]Zebkvkh klhjhgu e_kZ keh`gh_ DZaZdb dhgqbeb k\hb aZgylby b kh[jZebkv d m`bgm\ ba[mijhklh_k h^ghjkdZaEmdZ[ukljh\uo\Zlbe jm`vzb ijbeh`bekyghg_mki_e\uklj_eblvijhklh_k h^ghjkdZa F_kypZ g_ [ueh gh a\za^u yjdh k\_lbeb \ lzfghf g_[_keh`gh_ K_j_[jbkluc lmfZg aZ[_e_e gZ^ \h^hc b fheh^u_hjeu ijhgabl_evgh aZk\bklZeb b aZoehiZeb djuevyfb keh`gh_ \h\lhjhc qZklb ± h^ghj kdZa J_adbc hlju\bkluc a\md \uklj_eZjZagzkky ih j_d_ b ]^_lh ^Ze_dh i_j_rze \ ]jhohl ijhklh_ k h^ghjkdZaEGLheklhc GZ^ fh_x ]heh\hc lj_\h`gh [bebkv ebklvy dezgZ gh g_k\_jdZeb hlemq_ckhegpZZ [e_^ghjbkh\Zebkv gZl_fghkbg_fnhg_DhjLzfgh_g_[hkfhljblk\_jomb [m^lh^urbl k\hbfbh]gyfbDhjQ_jg_xsZydhkZylmqZilbpaZkehgbeZb e_kb g_[hb kbg_xsmx^ZevK_jZnL_fghG_l h]g_c gb gZiZem[_gb gZfZqlZo gb djm]hf \ fhj_ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ h^ghkhkl[_aebqgh_jZkijhkljihegh_hkeh^ghjh^gh[klhylQP\_luemqr_\k_]hkh[bjZlvmljhf bebih^\_q_jIZmklYdmlkdZyehrZ^v g_ hkh[_ggh kbevgZ aZlh m^b\bl_evgh g_lj_[h\Zl_evgZDhj Klj_fbl_evgu_ \_lju ^Z ^bdb_ hjeu djm`bebkv gZ^ gZrbfb]heh\Zfb:=Djm]hf[uebigb^Zdhjy\u_kl\heu^Zihjhkev K :gl KeurZeky lhevdh m^Zeyxsbcky rmf Z\lhfZrbgu ^Z [_aaZ[hlgh_ \hjdh\Zgb_ ]hjebgdb Rhe Hk_gv ijbreZ\jZkiehob aZ\eZ^_eZa_fezckZ^Zfb b j_dZfb e_kZfb b \ha^mohfiheyfb b ilbpZfbIZmklJZ^hklghfheh^h [uehgZg_[_b gZa_fe_b \ k_j^p_ q_eh\_dZLDhggbpZi_ohlZ b Zjlbee_jby \b^g_xlkykh\k_oklhjhgihh[rbjghciheyg_EL H[jZa_p < ihoh^_ gZf ihlj_[h\Zebkv iZeZldZ b kiZevgucf_rhd ± < ihoh^_ gZf g_ ihlj_[h\Zebkv gb iZeZldZ gb kiZevgucf_rhd<_q_jhf\ dem[_y aZklZeb k\hbo^jma_cb agZdhfh]RrZofZlbklZ± <_q_jhf\ dem[_y g_aZklZegb k\hbo^jma_cgb agZdhfh]hrZofZlbklZB [b[ebhl_dZb qblZevgucaZejZ[hlZeb± Gb[b[ebhl_dZgb qblZevgucaZeg_jZ[hlZebY kfh]ihkfhlj_lvb lhedh\uckeh\Zjvb keh\ZjvbghkljZgguokeh\± Y g_kfh]ihkfhlj_lvgb lhedh\uckeh\Zjvgb keh\ZjvbghkljZgguokeh\GZfm^Zehkvihb]jZlvb \gZklhevgucl_ggbkb \ rZofZlu± GZfg_m^Zehkvihb]jZlvgb \gZklhevgucl_ggbkgb \rZofZluKo_fu gbgbgbgbgbgbgbgb Kljhbl_eb aZdhgqbeb k\hx jZ[hlm b aZ ^_eh \ayebkvrlmdZlmju b fZeyju AZ^ZqZ b ijbf_ju [ueb hq_gv bgl_j_kgufbb mjhd ijhe_l_e g_aZf_lghKijylZebkva\za^u b f_kyp aZlmqbb klZehkh\k_fl_fgh,Dh_]^_ijb^hjh]_ihiZ^Z_lkym]jxfZyjZdblZbebfheh^Zy [_jzadZ jZa^_ebl_evguc khxa BEB mdZau\Z_l gZ q_j_^h\Zgb_ELQ_eh\_dhklZ\rbcky\ e_kmh[udgh\_gghbebjZa]h\Zjb\Z_l kZf k kh[hc beb k\bklbl beb ihzl beb krb[Z_l iZedhckmob_ kmqvy jZa^_ebl_evguc khxa BEB \u[hj beb q_j_^h\Zgb_IZmkl Lh kijZ\Z lh ke_\Z lh ihaZ^b keurZeky ]me iZ^Zxsbo^_j_\v_\JZa^_ebl_evguckhxaLHLHq_j_^h\Zgb_ y\e_gbcIZmklIhkeurZeky]emohca\mdg_lhhlm^ZjZ\hqlhlhfy]dh_g_lhhllheqdZJZa^_ebl_evguckhxaG?LH± G?LH\u[hjbay\e_gbcGZ]>j_fZebg_lhevdhe_kZghb e_kgu_hazjZb e_gb\u_e_kgu_ j_db k ij_kghc \h^hc Kh_^bgbl_evgu_ khxau G? LHEVDH GH B ih\l khxa B h^gh\j_f_gghklv y\e_gbc IZmkl Lhevdh fhj_ \_l_j b ihjhc dZdZygb[m^v ilbpZ gZjmrZxl h[s__kihdhckl\b_Kh_^khxaBihke_^h\Zl_evghklvy\e_gbcFFZd,,HgZrvzlohjhrh^Zf_^e_gghIjhlb\bl_evguckhxa>: GH ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_ <hl ihrze hg \ e_k b aZ[em^bekyKh_^ khx B ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv <Zky iheh`be dgb]m \ rdZn^Z b aZ[ue ijh wlh Ijhlb\bl_evguc khxa >: B GH ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_ F_l_eb kg_]Z b lmfZgu ihdhjgu fhjham \k_]^Z G Keurblky lh rzihl lh hklhjh`guc r_e_kl =hgq H^gh ebrvh[eZqdh gZ gzf >g_[_@ g_ lh ieu\zl g_ lh lZ_l L GZ klZgpbbaZ`]ebkv[_eu_djZkgu_a_ezgu_h]hgvdb:j_DZaZdg_ohq_lhl^hogmlvgb \qbklhfihe_gb \^m[jZ\_gb ijb hiZkghci_j_ijZ\_ I Oehihl FZjlurd_ ihehg jhl qmj[Zg hgZ lh ihg_kzl lhlZdlhkyd_]hh[o\Zlbllhih\hehqbllhihdZlblDj>jh[ykvh fjZqgu_kdZeurmfylb i_gylky\ZeuIY ex[exwlba\za^gu_ghqbwlba\za^ub dezgub ijm^;mgE_kZem]Zihzfgu_jmqvbb j_dbjmkkdb_\_kghxohjhrbGKo_fu> blh lh@>@g_lh> g_lh@>@gb>gbgb@lh>@ >lh lhlh lh @b>_ _@ >bb@b> @ K_\_jguc E_^h\bluc hd_Zg ± wlh oZhk lhjhkh\ ^he]Zy iheyjgZyghqvb k\bj_iu_\vx]bH^gZdhbf_ggha^_kvh[blZ_l[_eucf_^\_^v Wlhl djmig_crbc gZ ieZg_l_ gZa_fguc obsgbd \kz [hevr_ ijb\e_dZ_l d k_[_ \gbfZgb_ g_ lhevdh iml_r_kl\_ggbdh\ gh bmqzguoahheh]h\ Bkke_^h\Zl_eb iulZxlky jZa]Z^Zlv k_dj_l m^b\bl_evghcijbkihkh[e_gghklb[_eh]hf_^\_^yd `bagb\ e_^yghcimklug_ < hlebqb_ hl k\h_]h [mjh]h kh[jZlZ [_euc f_^\_^v ^Z`_ g_\iZ^Z_l \ j_]meyjguc abfgbc khg g_ ijyq_lky hl g_\a]h^ Z [m^lhgZf_j_gghb^zlbfgZ\klj_qmHgkh\_jrZ_lg_ij_klZggu_dhq_\db[jh^bl kj_^b ^j_cnmxsbo ev^h\ dZd abfhc lZd b e_lhf Fh]mqbca\_jvh[eZ^Z_lihjZabl_evghckihkh[ghklvxhjb_glZpbbgZf_klghklbGbfgh]hf_kyqgh_hlkmlkl\b_khegpZgb l_fghlZiheyjghcghqbgb g_ij_ju\gu_i_j_f_s_gbyev^h\g_hklZgZ\eb\Zxl_]hi_j_^\b`_gbc ;_euo f_^\_^_c hklZehkv gZ a_fghf rZj_ g_fgh]hIhwlhfmg_lhevdhmqzguoghb \k_oaZsblgbdh\ijbjh^ug_fh`_lg_[_kihdhblvbokm^v[ZIhKFMki_gkdhfmL_dklhlghkblkyd gZmqghihimeyjghfmklbex,Ihegucf_kypk\_lbegZdZfurh\mxdjurmb [_eu_kl_gufh_]hgh\h]h`bebsZgZ^\hj_h[\_^zgghfh]jZ^hcba[meu`gbdZ klhyeZ ba[hqZkv ^jm]Zy eZqm`dZ f_g__ b ^j_\g__ i_j\hckhxa B k\yau\Z_l h^ghjh^gu_ qe_gu ;_j_] h[ju\hf kimkdZeky dfhjxihqlbm kZfuokl_g_zb \gbamk [_kij_ju\gufjhihlhfie_kdZebkv l_fghkbgb_ \hegu khxa B k\yau\Z_l ^\Z ijhkluo ij_^eh`_gby \ khklZ\_ keh`gh]h EmgZ lboh kfhlj_eZ gZ [_kihdhcgmxgh ihdhjgmx _c klbobx b y fh] jZaebqblv ijb k\_l_ _z ^Ze_dh hl[_j_]Z^\ZdhjZ[eykhxaB k\yau\Z_l^\Zijhkluoij_^eh`_gby\khklZ\_keh`gh]h,,LZdijhrehhdhehqZkZF_kypk\_lbe\ hdghb emq_]hb]jZeiha_feyghfmihemoZlukhxaB k\yau\Z_l ^\Zijhkluoij_^eh`_gby\ khklZ\_keh`gh]h<^jm]gZyjdhcihehk_i_j_k_dZxs_ciheijhf_evdgmeZ l_gv Y ijb\klZe b \a]eygme \ hdgh khxa B k\yau\Z_lh^ghjh^gu_qe_guFXE_jfhglh\I_j\ucZ[aZp± hibkZgb_\lhjhc± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_>@b >@b >@;_kihdhcgmxIha_feyghfm± ijbeZ]IhihemdZdhfm"a_feyghfmGn±a_feyghcIhkl± hlghkblg_ihkl± \ fj_^q>iIhihemdZdhfm"a_feyghfmI_j_k_dZxs_c ± hkh[Zy nhjfZ ]eZ]heZ ± ijbqZklb_ GZ ihehk_dZdhc" i_j_k_dZxs_cGn± i_j_k_dZxsbcIhkl± ^_ckl\g_kh\\gZkl\jg_ihkl± \ `j_^q>iGZihehk_dZdhc"i_j_k_dZxs_cihe Ih h^ghfm fu \oh^beb \ ibehlkdmx dZ[bgm dhjZ[ey HgZ[ueZ ijhklhjg__ dZ[bgu ezlqbdZ gZ kZfhezl_ GZoh^ykv \ dj_ke_dhkfhgZ\lfh]hkms_kl\eylv\k_hi_jZpbbihgZ[ex^_gbxb k\yabkA_fezcdhgljhebjh\Zlvihezlb ijbg_h[oh^bfhklbkZfhklhyl_evghmijZ\eylvdhjZ[ezfQ_]hlhevdhg_[ueh\ wlhcg_h[uqghcdZ[bg_B \kzg_kh\k_flZddZdgZkZfhezl_Ke_\Z jZaf_sZeky imevl ibehlZ GZ gzf gZoh^bebkv jmdhyldb bi_j_dexqZl_eb mijZ\eyxsb_ jZ[hlhc jZ^bhl_e_nhgghc kbkl_fuj_]mebjmxsb_ l_fi_jZlmjm \ dZ[bg_ Z lZd`_ \dexqZxsb_ jmqgh_mijZ\e_gb_ b lhjfhaghc ^\b]Zl_ev KijZ\Z jZaf_sZebkv jZ^bhijbzfgbd dhgl_cg_ju ^ey ijbzfZ ibsb b jmqdZ mijZ\e_gby hjb_glZpb_cdhjZ[eyIjyfhi_j_^dj_kehfdhkfhgZ\lZ± ijb[hjgZy^hkdZwe_dljhqZku Z lZd`_ ]eh[mk \jZs_gb_ dhlhjh]h kh\iZ^Zeh k ^\b`_gb_fdhjZ[eyihhj[bl_Gb`_ijb[hjghc^hkdb[ueZmklZgh\e_gZl_e_\babhggZydZf_jZ^eygZ[ex^_gbyaZdhkfhgZ\lhfk A_febX=Z]ZjbgLbi j_qb ± hibkZgb_ Ij_^eh`_gby \h f Z[aZp_ k\yaZgu ijbihfhsb gZj_qbc ke_\Z kijZ\Z ijyfh gb`_ Ijhn_kkbhgZevgu_keh\Z imevl jZ^bhl_e_nhggZy kbkl_fZ jmqgh_ mijZ\e_gb_ lhjfhaghc^\b]Zl_evijb[hjgZy^hkdZ>Zxsbc`bagvOe_[ ± qm^_kg_cr__ hldjulb_ q_eh\_q_kl\Z I_j\hfm [_aufygghfm oe_[hjh[m ex^b ^he`gu [ueb [u ihklZ\blv iZfylgbd ihlhfmqlh g_kfhljy gZ fgh]h\_dh\hc ijh]j_kk gbq_]h [he__ ihe_agh]h bg_h[oh^bfh]h ^ey q_eh\_dZ g_ ijb^mfZgh < gZrb ^gb ©^h[u\Zgb_ªoe_[ZgZkmsgh]h± ^_ehdZd[m^lh\_kvfZijhklh_AZrze\ [mehqgmxhdbgme\a]ey^hfoe_[gu_ihedb\u[jZegm`gh_aZieZlbe^_gv]b± b_rvgZa^hjh\v_GhlZdeb\kzijhklh"<_^vwlhlhevdhihlj_[bl_exoe_[^hklZzlkye_]dhL_f`_dlh_]hijhba\h^blhgklhblly`zeh]hljm^Z bkkmrZxsbo aZ[hlhc [_kkhgguo ghq_c gZijy`_gby \k_o nbabq_kdbob ^moh\guokbeWlZ [bl\Z [_kdjh\gZgh\^h\hev hjhr_gZkhezguf ihlhf oe_[hjh[h\ >ey gbo oe_[ g_ lhevdh dhg_qguc ijh^mdlghb ebqgZy ]hj^hklv^hklhbgkl\hjZ^hklv b [hevH^gZdhb^ey l_o dlh g_ iZr_l g_ k__l oe_[ ± hkgh\Z kms_kl\h\Zgby aZeh][eZ]h^_gkl\by \k_]h h[s_kl\Z \ p_ehf b dZ`^h]h q_eh\_dZ \ hl^_evghklb LZd fh`_f eb fu g_ `Ze_lv g_ [_j_qv [_a^mfgh [jhkZlv gZ\_l_jlhqlh^Zzl\k_fgZfa^hjh\v_b kbem[h]Zlkl\hb m\_j_gghklv\ aZ\ljZrg_f^g_"Oe_[± ^_eh`bagbdZ`^h]hbagZkb h[jZsZlvkykgbf^he`ghgZ<uIh<LdZq_gdhKlbev ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc p_ev ± \ha^_ckl\b_ gZ qblZl_ey gZ_]h m[_`^_gby kj_^kl\Z ± jblhjbq_kdb_ \hijhku wfhpbhgZevghhdjZr_ggu_keh\ZGbq_]h± f_klG_ijb^mfZghq_]h"gbq_]hGn± gbq_]hIhkl± hljbpg_ihkl± JiG_ijb^mfZghq_]h"gbq_]h Y ex[ex k\hx ijhn_kkbx Ex[ex b ^jm]hc g_ ohqm g_ij_^klZ\eyx <kydhfm q_eh\_dm y `_eZx lZdhc km^v[u ihlhfm qlh[_a ex[bfh]h ljm^Z `bagv g_ lh qlh g_iheghp_ggZ Z ijhklh g_`bagv;ulv a_fe_^_evp_f ± agZqbl [ulv [eZ]h^Zjguf hlpZf b ^_^ZfgZrbf aZ fm^jhklv aZ hiul dhlhjufb gZk gZ]jZ^beb \ bkdmkkl\_\ha^_eu\Zlv oe_[ ;ulv a_fe_^_evp_f ± wlh ]em[hdh ihgbfZlv bqm\kl\h\Zlv `bagv a_feb ihey mf_lv \ibkZlvky k\hbf ljm^hf \]Zjfhgbxijbjh^u;ulva_fe_^_evp_fk_cqZk± agZqbl\aylvgZk_[y hl\_lkl\_gghklv aZ ^hklZlhd ijh^mdlh\ iblZgby \ kljZg_ aZ \_^_gb_hljZkebgZhkgh\_kh\j_f_gghcgZmdbb l_ogbdbFBDe_ibdh\Hkgh\gZyfukevl_dklZ± [ulva_fe_^_evp_fihq_lghb hl\_lkl\_ggh Klbev ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc p_ev ± \ha^_ckl\b_ gZ qblZl_eymihlj_[eyxlkyih\lhjuwfhpbhgZevghhdjZr_ggu_keh\ZIjhn_kkby ± jZ[hlZ ki_pbZevghklv jh^ aZgylbc A_fe_^_e_p ±dj_klvygbgoe_[hiZr_p , Klhjhgu k\_lZ k_\_j x] \hklhd aZiZ^ IbkZl_ebihwlu ijhaZbdb ^jZfZlmj]b JZaf_ju klbohkeh`_gby yf[ ohj_c^Zdlbev,, FmaudZevgu_ bgkljmf_glu [ZjZ[Zg ljm[Z ]blZjZ kZdkhnhg Kihjlb\gu_ b]ju nml[he ohdd_c \h^gh_ iheh =_hf_ljbq_kdb_nb]mjudjm]d\Z^jZllj_m]hevgbd,AbfZqm\kl\h\ZeZkv\h\kzf\ dhjhldhf^g_aZiZo_kg_]Zb jZgh aZ`b]Z\rboky kb]gZevguo nhgZjyo IZmkl K hiulgufijh\h^gbdhf gZf g_ kljZrgh gbq_]h gb [jh^u q_j_a [mjgu_ j_dbgb kiehrgZylZc]Zgb i_j_\Zeu=NFmdZb oe_[gh_a_jghkhklhyl ]eZ\guf h[jZahf ba ljzo \_s_kl\ de_cdh\bgu djZofZeZ bfZkeZLbfGZdjZkgh\ZlhcljZ\_gZ[uebgdZo± \kx^m [e_kl_ebb \hegh\Zebkv [_kqbke_ggu_ gblb hk_ggbo iZmlbg L <kx^m\\_jom b \gbam ± i_eb `Z\hjhgdb Q Xgu_ ^_j_\vy \k_o ihjh^_ev b khkgZ hkbgZ b [_jzaZ ± jZklml ^jm`gh b l_kgh IZmkl <ijm^mjZa\_ebjZagmxju[mdZdlhdZjih\lheklheh[bdh\,, Gb \_jz\db gb djxqdb gb e_klgbpu ± gbqlh g_ihfh]Zeh^h[jZlvky ^h ^gZ i_s_ju =Za A_ezgZy ^hebgZ ]hju \ [_euorZidZo ± \kz [ueh aZeblh khegp_f Rmdr < q_eh\_d_ ^he`gh[ulv\kz ij_djZkghb ebphb h^_`^Zb ^mrZb fukebQDZ`^uc^_gv[uegZiheg_gmfhfkbehcq_eh\_q_kdhcl_iehlhc^jm`[hc ± \k_f l_f qlh fu gZau\Z_f kZfuf ij_djZkguf \ fbj_ IZmkl <kz wlh b ghqv b ^Zeb b ]hju b a\za^u b lmfZgu ±dZaZehkvfg_bkiheg_ggufg_\b^Zgghcij_e_klbDhj<_a^_gZiheyo b gZ e_kguo ijhk_dZo b gZ ^hjh`dZo ± iZj ih^gbfZeky hla_feb Ijbr\ B dZ`_lky \a^hogmeZ \ky a_fey ^hfZ b ex^bjhsbb iheyED<kydbcimklydih\hjhlrhkk_\_ldZgZ^aZ[hjhfk\_lnhgZj_c± \kz dZaZehkvagZqbl_evgufIZmklYaud± hjm^b_ fure_gbyH[jZsZlvkyk yaudhfdh_dZd± agZqblb fukeblvdh_dZdg_lhqghijb[ebabl_evghg_\_jgh:GL> @ >bbbb@>@ < dhjabg_ e_`Zeb jZagu_ njmdlu y[ehdb ]jmrb \bgh]jZ^ h[h[s ke ijb h^ghjh^guo ih^e_`Zsbo Y[ehdb ]jmrb\bgh]jZ^ Zi_evkbgu fZg^Zjbgu ± njmdlu khkl bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_Lj_kdZk_ev^viZelmk ± fhjkdb_ju[u gZr_]hK_\_jZkhklbf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_ Ba fhjkdhc ju[u lj_kdb k_ev^biZelmkZ ±ijb]hlh\eyxl fgh]h \dmkguo b iblZl_evguo [ex^ h[h[s keh\hijbh^ghjh^guo^hiheg_gbyoGZ ihed_ klhyeZ ihkm^Z dZkljxeb lZj_edb qZrdb DZkljxeblZj_edbqZrdb± kZfZyg_h[oh^bfZyihkm^ZBaaZlmfZgZg_[ueh\b^ghgbq_]hgb \i_j_^bb^ms_]h[mdkbjZ gb [_j_]Z Kihjlb\gZy Zj_gZ ieZ\Zl_evguc [Zkk_cgkihjlb\gu_iehsZ^db± \k_\uau\Zeh\hkobs_gb_ihk_lbl_e_cklZ^bhgZGZ\hdaZe_f_gygbdlhg_\klj_lbegb ^jmavygb jh^gu_ Y ih[u\Ze \kx^m \ fma_yo b l_ZljZo \ dZjlbgghc ]Ze_j__ b gZk_evkdhohayckl\_gghc \uklZ\d_ JZagu_ ZlljZdpbhgu dhfgZlZkf_oZdZjmk_evdZq_eb± ijb\e_dZxlihk_lbl_e_ciZjdZdmevlmju Khegp_ ih^gbfZ_lky baaZ h[eZdh\ b aZeb\Z_l e_k ihe_ bgZrbokimlgbdh\]j_xsbfk\_lhfQLmkdeh[_e_ekg_]aZghqvmki_\rbc aZihjhrblv b klZjmx ebkl\m b hklZldb dhkljZ b igb bmiZ\rb_^_j_\vyNhjf<b^gu[ueblhevdhkbemwlu^_j_\v_\^Zlzfgu_djurbkZjZ_\QKlZedb\Zebkv^jm]k ^jm]hflhjhieb\h[_]msb_ kljmb lh gujyeb \]em[v lh \ugujb\Zeb h[jZamy [m]hjKheGb[ebadbo[_j_]h\gb ^Zezdbo]hjgb ^Z`_\h^u± gbq_]hg_ [ueh \b^gh Khe <kz gZihfbgZeh _fm >=jb]hjbx@ ihemaZ[ulmx ij_`gxx `bagv b aZiZo h\qbg hl lmemiZ b ^hfZrgbc \b^ g_qbs_guo ehrZ^_c b dZdhcgb[m^v i_lmo \ keh[h^_ Rhe AZmgu\gZy i_kgy lh aZfbjZeZ lh hiylv ijhghkbeZkv\ klhyq_f^mrghf\ha^mo_ Q <i_j_^ba_e_g_ehg_lhha_jhg_lh[hehlh=ZaLhevdh lml y m\b^_e qlh \kx^m gZ kdehgZo kb^_eb fheqZeb\u_ ofmju_ obsgbdb rbjhdhie_qb_ [_jdmlu [_eho\hklu_ hjeZgu h]jhfgu_ ihqlb qzjgu_ ]jbnu Nhjf Kd\hjzgmrdZ ± g_[hevrZye_kgZyj_qdZA_e_gbjZaghcb p\_lZfb fZebggbdmb ^mrbklhcfyl_b djZib\_± \k_fm\hev]hlghjZklb\hae_Kd\hjzgmrdbKhebb >@ >gbgbgb@ >bbb@ >bbbb@E_\LheklhcLmj]_g_\>hklh_\kdbc± \k_wlb\_ebdb_ex^bJhkkbbijbagZ\ZebImrdbgZk\hbf^moh\gufjh^hgZqZevgbdhfFmaudZ bkihevah\ZeZ \ nhjf_ hi_j p_euc jy^ \_s_c ImrdbgZ©JmkeZg b Ex^fbeZª ©Ibdh\Zy ^ZfZª ©>m[jh\kdbcª ©?\]_gbcHg_]bgª ©Ahehlhc i_lmrhdª ©PZjv KZelZgª ©;hjbk =h^mgh\ª©Pu]Zguª ©FhpZjl b KZev_jbª ©Kdmihc jupZjvª ©:e_dhª ± \k_wlb hi_ju gZibkZgu gZ l_dkl ImrdbgZ djmig_crbfb dhfihablhjZfb Jhkkbb =ebgdhc QZcdh\kdbf Fmkhj]kdbf JbfkdbfDhjkZdh\ufJZofZgbgh\uf?]h ihwfu ©Pu]Zguª ©;jZlvyjZa[hcgbdbª ©DZ\dZakdbc ie_ggbdª ± \kz wlh deZkkbq_kdb_ h[jZapu jmkkdh]h keh\Z b klboZ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h^ghjijbeh`_gbyfbk h[h[skeb ^hiheg_gbyfbL\hjq_kl\h ImrdbgZ ± rbjhdbc hke_ibl_evguc ihlhd klboh\ bijhauF=hjvdbcHke_ibl_evgucBkihevah\ZeZ ± ]eZ]he FmaudZ qlh k^_eZeZ" bkihevah\ZeZG n± bkihevah\ZlvIhkl± kh\\i_j_o,kijg_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^q`jFmaudZqlhk^_eZeZ"bkihevah\ZeZGZibkZgu± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_Hi_judZdh\u"gZibkZguGn± gZibkZggucIhkl± kljZ^ijhr\jkh\\g_ihkl± djnhjfZfgqHi_judZdh\u"gZibkZguDjmig_crbfb ± ijbeZ] DhfihablhjZfb dZdbfb" djmig_crbfbGn± djmigucIhkl± dZq_kl\g_ihkl± \ ij_\hkokl_i_gb\hfgqLiDhfihablhjZfbdZdbfb"djmig_crbfbIZfylgbdImrdbgm\ ]hjh^_gZG_\_[uehldjul\ ]h^m:\lhjiZfylgbdZ± kdmevilhjFD:gbdmrbgIhwlbah[jZ`_g\^hogh\_gghqblZxsbfk\hbklbobL_dklhlghkblkyd im[ebpbklbq_kdhfmklbex< ]h^m \_ebdbc ]hjh^ gZ G_\_ lhj`_kl\_ggh hlf_qZe k\hze_lb_ < dZgmg ijZa^gbdZ gZ iehsZ^b Bkdmkkl\ khklhyehkv hldjulb_iZfylgbdZ:KImrdbgm:\lhj wlh]h aZf_qZl_evgh]h ijhba\_^_gby ± ba\_klguc jmkkdbckdmevilhjFD:gbdmrbgOm^h`gbdihdZaZeImrdbgZm\e_qzgghlj_i_lgh b kljZklgh qblZxsbf k\hb klbob Fu \b^bf `b\hc hkljuc \a]ey^ \ukhdbc eh[ ykgh hq_jq_ggmx ebgbx ]m[ Kljhcghklvebgbc nb]mju ke_]dZ ijbih^gylZy ]heh\Z hkh[_ggh `_kl ijZ\hcjmdbih\hjhldbklbiZevpu± \kzih^qzjdb\Z_l\^hogh\_gb_ihwlZKdmevilmjZmklZgh\e_gZgZihklZf_gl_badjZkgh]h]jZgblZIZfylgbd klhbl \ a_e_gb \hdjm] g_]h jZkiheh`_gu \_ebq_kl\_ggu_a^Zgby imrdbgkdhc wihob Jmkkdbc fma_c Fma_c wlgh]jZnbb FZeuchi_jgucl_ZljNbeZjfhgbyIhEKbfhg_gdhIeZg>b\gucm]hehdJhkkbbIhe_gh\kdbcfma_cmkZ^v[ZI_caZ`bIhe_gh\Z<k_fbjgZyba\_klghklvdZjlbgIhe_gh\ZIhe_gh\h ± ^b\guc m]hehd Kj_^g_c Jhkkbb Rbjhdb_ j_qgu_jZaeb\ub ahehlu_i_kqZgu_iey`biZebljZ hk_ggbodjZkhdb kljh]ZydjZkhlZe_kh\Ihe_gh\h aZf_lgh ba^Ze_dZ dh]^Z kd\havl_kguckljhc\ukhdbokhk_g ihdZ`_lky \^jm] hke_ibl_evgh [_euc hkh[gyd Ijhc^zl_ g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\ f_ljh\ ih Zee__ b \hli_j_^\Zfb]eZ\gZy^hklhijbf_qZl_evghklv wlbo f_kl ± Ihe_gh\kdbc fma_cmkZ^v[Z Fgh]he_llhfmgZaZ^ba\_klgucjmkkdbc`b\hibk_p<Zkbebc>fbljb_\bqIhe_gh\ f_qlZeh lhf\j_f_gbdh]^ZgZrgZjh^[m^_lagZlvk\hboom^h`gbdh\ B \hl l_i_jv khlgb lukyqb ex^_c jZagh]h \hajZklZ bijhn_kkbbfheh^uob klZjuob^ml bb^ml\ kha^ZggucIhe_gh\uffma_cqlh[uijbdhkgmlvkyd jh^gbdh\hcqbklhl_bkdmkkl\ZL\hjq_kl\h<>Ihe_gh\Zfgh]h]jZgghb ij_djZkghghhkh[_ggh ljh]Zxl _]h i_caZ`b K \_kgu ^h iha^g_c hk_gb [jh^be hg kfhev[_jlhfb jbkh\Zek gZlmjuHdmIhhqv_hdj_klgu_e_kZ<k_fbjghc ba\_klghklvx ihevamxlky dZjlbgu ©AhehlZy hk_gvª©JZaeb\ gZ Hd_ª ©Hk_gv \ :[jZfp_\_ª ©JZggbc kg_]ª Kdhevdh \gbojmkkdhcdjZkhlukdhevdhihwabbb ]em[hdhcijZ\^uIhK?f_evygh\mLbij_qb± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_DZjlhl_dZ± kh[jZgb_dZjlhq_dkhk\_^_gbyfbkijZ\hqgh]hoZjZdl_jZnbevfhl_dZ± kh[jZgb_nbevfh\>bkdhl_dZ[b[ebhl_dZnhghl_dZNbevfhl_dZ Fma_y dbgh [ueZ h[rbjghc gh mklZj_\r_c GZrZnbevfhl_dZ gZ ^gyo fh`_l ihihegblvky DZjlhl_dZ ^_lkdhc [b[ebhl_dbbf__lfgh`_kl\hjZa^_eh\L_i_jvdZjlhl_dZklZgh\blkym^h[g__AZoh^bl ebj_qvh kljhbl_evkl\_ dhjimkh\gh\uoaZ\h^h\bnZ[jbd beb h ijhdeZ^d_ rhkk_cguo ^hjh] b ebgbc we_dljhi_j_^Zqb]Zah b g_nl_ijh\h^h\bebh \ha\_^_gbbfhklh\l_e_\babhgguo[Zr_g b lZd g_h[oh^bfuo k_cqZk rdhe ^_lkdbo kZ^h\ b dhg_qgh`beuo ^hfh\ ± fu kjZam `_ \kihfbgZ_f l_o dlh \k_ wlh kha^ZzlFu\kihfbgZ_fk m\Z`_gb_f b gZ^_`^hc kljhbl_e_cIjhn_kkby wlZ hkh[Zy Kljhbl_eb \_a^_ b^ml i_j\ufb \k_]^ZgZqbgZy ©k gmeyª KlZe_\Zju b ldZqb \jZqb b mqbl_ey ijh^Z\pu bihjlgu_ ± \k_ijboh^ylm`_ke_^hfaZgbfbB gh\hkzeulh`_B jZ[hlZm kljhbl_e_chq_gvjZagZylZddZdkljhbl_ev± ijhn_kkby kh_^bgyxsZy \ k_[_ ^_kyldb ^jm]bo Wlh b dZf_gsbdb b fhglZ`gbdb b iehlgbdb b f_oZgbaZlhju kZfh]h rbjhdh]h ijhnbey\_^vgZkljhcdZoaZgylu^_kyldbkZfuojZaebqguof_oZgbafh\Kljhbl_ev± h^gZbakZfuoljm^guoijhn_kkbcghb h^gZbakZfuo[eZ]h^ZjguoLuaZdZgqb\Z_rv k\hxjZ[hlmb moh^brvZ ljm^l\hc i_j_ebluc \ [_lhg b dZf_gv hklZzlky B q_j_a fgh]h e_l lufh`_rvijbclb d ^hfmb^hljhgm\rbkv^hkl_gulziehchl\_k_gg_]hkhegpZk aZdhgghc]hj^hklvxih^mfZlv©Wlhk^_eZeyªB ^Z`_ lh]^Z dh]^Z l_[y g_ [m^_l gZ k\_l_ lh qlh lu ihkljhbe [m^_lklhylvgZa_fe_b kem`blv ex^yfIhL;jZldh\hcLbij_qb ± jZkkm`^_gb_ LjZgkihjl Z\lh[mk ljZf\Zc ljhee_c[mk FmaudZevgu_ bgkljmf_glu ]blZjZ kdjbidZ ibZgbgh LZgpu \Zevk fZamjdZ ihevdZ <b^u bkdmkkl\Z fmaudZ `b\hibkv Zjobl_dlmjZebl_jZlmjZY ijbh[j_e ijh_a^ghc gZ \k_ \b^u gZa_fgh]h ljZgkihjlZ Z\lh[mk ljZf\Zc ljhee_c[mk < dhgp_jl_ mqZkl\h\Zeb bkihegbl_eb gZjZaguo fmaudZevguo bgkljmf_glZo ]blZj_ kdjbid_ ibZgbgh <ohj_h]jZnbq_kdhf djm`d_ jZamqb\Zeb gZjh^gu_ lZgpu \Zevk fZamjdmihevdmGZmjhdZoom^h`_kl\_gghcdmevlmjufuagZdhfbfkyk jZaebqgufb \b^Zfb bkdmkkl\Z gZjh^h\ fbjZ fmaudhc `b\hibkvxZjobl_dlmjhcebl_jZlmjhcK_j]_cihagZdhfvkyk lh\ZjbsZfbihjZ[hl_<yq_keZ\<eZ^bfbjh\bq gZagZqvl_ ih`ZemcklZ kh[jZgb_ djm`dZ gZ kj_^m Lh\Zjbsb mkeh\vl_kv h \j_f_gb \klj_qb gZ \hdaZe_ Hlt_a`Zxsb_\ kihjlb\guceZ]_jv\havfbl_k kh[hclzieu_\_sbIj_^eh`_gby ih p_eb \ukdZau\Zgby ih[m^bl_evgu_ ]eZ]heukdZam_fu_\ nhjf_ih\_ebl_evgh]hgZdehg_gby Izlj dm^Z lu kijylZeky" <hijhk ijhklh_ ^\mkhkljZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h[jZs_gb_f L Lbfmj L_[y bs_ll\hc ^y^y : = Y \_jx l_[_ ^y^y Q L_[y ev \b`mfbeuc ^jm]" I Hlimklb f_gy jh^gZy gZ ijhklhj rbjhdbcIh[m^g_\hkdeijhklh_h^ghkhklhij_^ebqgjZkijhkljihegh_ hke h[jZs_gb_f G A^jZ\kl\mc khegp_ ^Z mljh \_kzeh_Gbd Hiylvy \Zrh xgu_^jmavyI,=hjh^gbqbcY ijb]eZkbe\Zk]hkih^Zk l_fqlh[ukhh[sblv \Zf ij_g_ijbylgh_ ba\_klb_ d gZf _^_l j_\bahj EmdZEmdbq AZq_f `_ :glhg :glhgh\bq hlq_]h wlh" AZq_f d gZf j_\bahj"=EbaZ<ukm^ZjvdZf_gvKm^Zjvez^=j,,M\Z`Z_fucB\ZgB\Zgh\bqgZk_jvzag_crbc<Zr\hijhkhagZq_gbb djZ_\_^_gby fh`_l [ulv ^Zg ebrv h^bg hl\_l djZ_\_^_gb_ ± ^_eh agZq_gb_ dhlhjh]h g_ fh`_l [ulv ij_m\_ebq_gh Fu^he`gu agZlv gZrm a_fex \kx ^h ihke_^g_]h ZlhfZ F = Hl\Zk fhb xgu_ ^jmavy lj_[mxlky ijbe_`Zgb_ mqz[Z ^Z ex[h\gh_\gbfZgb_d h[s_kl\_ggufp_gghklyfe_`Zsbf\ ihe_\Zr_]haj_gbyE_hg,,,Fhci_j\uc ^jm]fhc^jm][_kp_ggucB ykm^v[m[eZ]hkeh\beDh]^Zfhc^\hjm_^bg_ggucI_qZevgufkg_]hfaZg_k_ggucL\hcdhehdhevqbdh]eZkbeIh Kbgb_ ]hju DZ\dZaZ ijb\_lkl\mx \Zk E H i_j\uchheZg^urbaih^kg_]Zluijhkbrvkheg_qguoemq_cN_l<_l_jhihc \_l_j \hc gZ ijhklhj_ Y ^hjh]hx kdZahqghc fqmkv <kx hlhhfhjy l_[yb ^hfhjy\b`mymagZxl_[yJmkvL\Zj^De_gluhfhc hiZ\rbc dezg aZe_^_g_euc qlh klhbrv gZ]gm\rbkv ih^ f_hl_evx [_ehc" ?_ KiZkb[h fhy jh^gZy a_fey kiZkb[h fhc hlhqbc ^hf aZ \kz qlh hl `bagb agZx y qlh \ k_j^p_ ghrm k\hzfhhhL\Zj^Kl_ibijb\hevgu_]hjudjmlu_\h^u]em[hdbofhj_cbhazj± \kzlu\f_klbeZjh^gZyJhkkby\ k\hcg_h[tylguc[_kdjZcgbc ijhklhjBkZdIhwlbq_kdbc ijb_f± hebp_l\hj_gb_hFbeZyfZfZY [_kihdhxkvh l\hzfa^hjh\v_>hjh]hchDbjbee =_ggZ^b_\bq Mq_gbdb gZr_]h deZkkZ k_j^_qgh iha^jZ\eyhxl<Zkk r_klb^_kylbe_lb_f>hjh]Zy>ZrZy hq_gvihl_[_khhkdmqbeZkv M\Z`Z_fuclh\ZjbsIheydh\Ijhrm jZaj_rblvmq_gbdZf9,,,deZkkZaZgbfZlvkyihkm[[hlZf\ ]bfgZklbq_kdhfaZe_,DZdl\h_a^hjh\v_fhyex[bfZy[Z[mrdZ"M\Z`Z_fZy:eeZ :e_dk__\gZ =em[hdhm\Z`Z_fu_ qe_gu `xjb hebfibZ^u >hjh]ZyFZr_gvdZ,, Hc m` ]^_ \u ^h[ju_ fheh^pu" D l_[_ \ur_e y l_i_jv[ZkmjfZgkdbc kug ± \ur_e y gZkljZrguc[hcgZihke_^gbc[hcY kdZ`m l_[_ ijZ\hkeZ\guc pZjv y m[be _]h \hevghc \he_x« Ohjhrhl_[_^_lbgmrdZm^Zehc[h_pkugdmi_q_kdbcqlhhl\_l^_j`Ze lu ih kh\_klb M` \u [jZlpu fhb^jm]bdjh\gu_ihpZem_fky^Zh[gbf_fl_kvgZihke_^g__jZkklZ\Zgb_FE_jfhglh\©I_kgyijhpZjyB\ZgZ<Zkbev_\bqZ«ª\\J_r_gb_km^vb[ueh[_kkihjghJ_r_gb_km^vb[_kkihj\\gh[uehijZ\bevgufD fh_fmh]hjq_gbxhgg_ijbkemrZekydjZamfghfm kh\_lm D fh_fm h]hjq_gbx ijb[Z\behkv qm\kl\h ^hkZ\\^u <_q_j dZ`_lky [m^_l lzieuf L\hz ih\_^_gb_ fg_ dZ`_lkykljZgguf\\DZaZehkvlbobcghqghcqZkijb^Z\Ze[_k_^_hkh[mxij_\\e_klv g_\ukhdZy kl_i_gv m\_j_gghklb Dhj >_ckl\bl_evghdZfgb[u\ZxljZaebqghcl\zj^hklb[hevrZykl_i_gvm\_j_gghklb\\KZfuc fy]dbc dZf_gv ± lZevd N_jk GZdhg_plh gZ fhz kqZklv_ ^y^y b klZjbd Ydh\ k\_jgmeb d fZe_gvdhfm kd\_jm qm\kl\h\\: = Y g_ [m^m \Zk aZ^_j`b\Zlv Ihfh_fm ^_eh ykgh bklhqgbd fg_gby FK < \ha^mo_ iZoeh \h^hc ljZ\hc lmfZghf ±\\h^gbfkeh\hfiZoehjZggbfij_djZkgufe_lgbfmljhfaZf_qZgb_h kihkh[_hnhjfe_gbyfukebEL , JZamf__lky ih_a^ ijb^zl \h\j_fy Dhg_qgh `_ \h\j_fy dZgbdme fu ohjhrh hl^hogzf I_j_^ khj_\gh\Zgb_f [_kkihjghihkh\_lmcl_kvk \jZqhf,, Kheg_qgu_ ^gb \_jhylgh mklZgh\bebkv gZ^he]h J_dZih`Zemc \kdjh_lky jZgh <_kgZ gZ\_jgh_ [m^_l lzieZy b kmoZyGZx]_\hafh`ghm`_gZqZekydmiZevguck_ahg,,,;he_agvd g_kqZklvx hdZaZeZkvhq_gvhiZkghcM f_oZgbdZ d kqZklvx gZrebkv aZiZkgu_ ^_lZeb G_dhlhju_ ba mqZklgbdh\ djhkkZ d gZr_fm m^b\e_gbx ihq_fmlh g_ [ueb gZ lj_gbjh\d_,9 Ih khh[s_gbyf ]Za_l wdki_^bpby hldjueZ \ ]emohc kb[bjkdhclZc]_[hevrb_aZiZkug_nlb < k_gly[j_ihk\_^_gbyf=b^jhf_lp_gljZ h`b^Zxlky jZggb_ aZfhjhadb < wlhc g_rbjhdhcgh]em[hdhcj_d_ihkeh\ZfklZjh`beh\jZgvr_[uehfgh]hju[u KZfh_ ljm^gh_ ^ey f_gy ± jZ[hlZ gZ^ keh\hf Q_f y jmdh\\\h`mkvij_^ihqblZyh^ghkeh\h^jm]hfm"<hi_j\uokeh\h^he`gh\\k gZb[hevr_clhqghklvxhij_^_eylvfukev<h\lhjuohgh^he`gh\\[ulv fmaudZevgh\ujZabl_evgh <lj_lvbo ^he`gh bf_lv jZaf_jlj_[m_fucjblfbq_kdhcdhgkljmdpb_cnjZauDN_^bg<\h^gu_keh\Za^_kvhnhjfeyxlihjy^hd\ujZ`_gbyfukeb <hi_j\uo bkdmkkl\h nhjfbjm_l oZjZdl_j q_eh\_dZ \h\lhjuoijh[m`^Z_lex[h\vd ij_djZkghfmbgZdhg_p\hkiblu\Z_l]hlh\ghklv[hjhlvkyaZlhj`_kl\h^h[jZb ijZ\^uAZgylbykihjlhf \hi_j\uo aZdZeyxl hj]Zgbaf \h\lhjuo \hkiblu\Zxl \hex\lj_lvbo^bkpbiebgbjmxlq_eh\_dZNhjfbjm_l ± ]eZ] Bkdmkkl\h qlh ^_eZ_l" nhjfbjm_l G n ±nhjfbjh\ZlvIhkl± g_kh\\i_j_o,kijg_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^q\ f eBkdmkkl\hqlh^_eZ_l"nhjfbjm_l=hlh\ghklv , Wlh iZjZee_evgu_ ebgbbKe_^h\Zl_evghhgbg_i_j_k_dZxlky <\h^gh_ keh\h ]jZffZlbq_kdb g_ k\yaZgh k ^jm]bfbkeh\Zfb \ ij_^eh`_gbb LZdbf h[jZahf hgh g_ y\ey_lky qe_ghfij_^eh`_gby JZ[hlZy gZ^ bklhjbq_kdbf ijhba\_^_gb_f ibkZl_eb bamqZxl ijhreh_ klZjZxlky `b\h ij_^klZ\blv bklhjbq_kdb_dZjlbguH^gbfkeh\hf^eyom^h`_kl\_ggh]h\hkkha^Zgbyijhreh]hg_h[oh^bfhb gZmqgh_agZgb_b l\hjq_kdZynZglZaby,, G_m^ZqZ g_ kfmlbeZ [hdkzjZ GZijhlb\ hgZ aZklZ\beZ _]h_sz[hevr_gZijyqvkbeuLh\Zjbsg_h[b^_ekygZrmldm;he__lh]hhgkZfkf_yeky\f_kl_kh\k_fbNZglZaby± \hh[jZ`_gb_\u^mfdZ >ey q_]h ex^b qblZxl"_ Hq_\b^gh fh`gh \u^_eblv ljbijbqbgu ih[m`^Zxsb_ ex^_c d ql_gbx <hi_j\uo hgb qblZxl^ey h\eZ^_gby dZdhcgb[m^v ki_pbZevghklvx <h\lhjuo qblZxlqlh[u m^h\e_l\hjblv k\hb om^h`_kl\_ggu_ aZijhku ba ex[\b dij_djZkghfmGZdhg_pfuqblZ_fqlh[uihemqblvbgnhjfZpbxh[hdjm`Zxs_fgZkfbj_IjZ\^Zfh`_l[ulv_klvb _szh^gZijbqbgZ± ©m[blv\j_fyªDkh`Ze_gbx _klv _sz ex^b dhlhju_ g_ agZxl dm^Z k_[y ^_lv LZdbfh[jZahfql_gb_fh`_lijbghkblvh]jhfgmxihevamghfh`_lbg_ hklZ\blv aZf_lgh]h ke_^Z \ mf_ b k_j^p_ q_eh\_dZ <kz ^_eh \mf_gbbqblZlv©GZmdZb `bagvªDZdhcgb[m^v ± f_kl Ki_pbZevghklvx dZdhc" dZdhcgb[m^vG n± dZdhcgb[m^vIhkl± g_hij_^g_ihkl± \ `j_^qLiKi_pbZevghklvxdZdhc"dZdhcgb[m^vQlh[u± khxa>@qlh[uFhjnijbagih^qbgblijhklhcFg_dhg_qghe_lebrg__keh\h©dhg_qghª?fmdhg_qghg_ f_gvr_e_lYagZqbl`b\mm kZfhcj_dbebrg__keh\h©agZqblªHgkeurZe]m^hdl_iehoh^ZAgZqblg_^Ze_dhj_dZ<uy \b`mex[bl_ijbjh^mLDZd\ujZ`Zxlkyfhjydb \_l_j dj_iqZe Q >m[_qgy ± lZd gZau\ZeZkv gZrZ i_j\ZyklZgpby± gZoh^beZkv\ k_fgZ^pZlb\_jklZohl]hjh^ZQIl_gqbd miZe ba ]g_a^Z \_l_j kbevgh dZqZe [_jzau Zee_b b kb^_e g_ih^\b`gh Iml_r_kl\b_ gZ l_iehoh^_ ih <he]_ ± wlh [ueh \ ijhrehf]h^m± hklZ\behg_ba]eZ^bfucke_^\ fh_ciZfylbQ_j_ag_kdhevdhe_ly gZ^_xkvfg_m^Zklky_]hih\lhjblvA_ezgucfuklZd gZau\Z_lky h^gh ba djZkb\_crbo f_kl gZ ih[_j_`v_ Q_jgh]hfhjy gZoh^blky \[ebab ;Zlmfb <uklmie_gby ba\_klguo fmaudZglh\dZdkhh[sZxl]Za_luijhrebk [hevrbfmki_ohf\ jZaguo]hjh^ZofbjZIZjb`_Jbf_b KhnbbF_l_evy ^mfZxg_kdhjhmlbog_lGZrbrZofZlbklu^h[vxlkyy m\_j_g[hevrbomki_oh\gZhebfibZ^_A_fe_^_evpuDm[ZgbdZdkhh[sZxl]Za_lumki_rgh\_^ml\_k_ggb_ihe_\u_jZ[hluIjbyl_ebdZdfum`_kdZaZeb\ur_g_ihoh^beb^jm]gZ^jm]ZLFhbiuleb\u_ \hijhkuhq_\b^gh\klj_\h`beb^y^xIh\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl ihegh_ jZkijhklj hke \\ke:=<h\j_fy[he_agb± y wlhohjhrhihfgx± hl_p\_k_eh\habeky kh fghc F = ;mehqgbdb ± bo [ueh q_l\_jh ± ^_j`Zebkv \ klhjhg_ hl gZk F = Ih keh\Zf ihedh\gbdZ\ ^\modbehf_ljZo[uegZqZevgbd^b\babbdhlhjucijbf_l;ZeZrz\Zb ijh\h^bl _]h ih gZagZq_gbx E L GZ gZr_ kqZklv_ [mjZg g_aZ^_j`Zekymrze\]em[vfZl_jbdZ=N=e_[ijbrzek jZ[hluhgjZ[hlZegZibehjZf_mfuekyi_j_h^_ekyRmdrAZo\Zlu\Zxs__aj_ebs_± iZjgu_b]ju\ l_ggbk< gboijb\e_dZ_l\kz<hi_j\uoihqlb[hevrbgkl\hfyq_cijbgbfZ_lkyk ezlZ<h\lhjuo\iZjghcb]j_g_\hafh`ghih[_^blv[_aZlZdb=ZaMf_gb_fZkl_jkl\h b gZdhg_p bkdmkkl\h `b\ml \_jhylgh \ ij_^_eZo ex[h]hljm^Z<;_eH^gZ`^u± wlh[ueh\ dhgp_bxgy± ^hdlhjOh[hlh\ ijbrze ih dZdhfmlh ^_em d :g^j_x ?nbfuqm Q Klm^_gludhgk_j\ZlhjbbihklZ\beb©Ibdh\mx^Zfmªb GbgZ± wlh[ue_z ^_[xl± k_]h^gy\i_j\u_i_eZ]jZnbgxDZ\<Zfy ^mfZxly`_eh `blv ^hdlhj" E_kd >_ckl\bl_evgh lhevdh hldjulb_dZfiZgbb aZ^_j`Zeh Jhklh\Z b ihf_rZeh _fm ijb_oZlv E L BlZdgZqbgZ_lkyi_kgyh \_lj_Em],Hq_\b^ghh[s_gb_k ^_lvfbjZa\b\Z_l\ q_eh\_d_fgh]b_^h[ju_k\hckl\ZIZmklDZ`^ucjZaGZklygZoh^beZih^\h^hcgh\u_ bgl_j_kgu_ \_sblh\ufhdrmx\ \h^_ihju`_\rmx_eh\mx\_ldmhgZdZaZeZkvaZj`Z\e_gghclhebeh\uchloheh^Zb fzjl\ucebkl\h^yghc ebebb IZmkl GZ fhc \a]ey^ \g_rghklv wlh]h q_eh\_dZm^b\bl_evghkhhl\_lkl\h\ZeZ_]hki_pbZevghklbKhe,, Ih]h^Z y \Zf ^heh`m g_kl_jibfZy Hq_\b^gh klhjh`mdjueky hl g_ih]h^u b l_i_jv kiZe ]^_gb[m^v gZ dmog_ beb \hjZg`_j__ D \_ebdhfm fh_fm m^b\e_gbx ijhezldZ k\_jgmeZ gZgZrm^hjh]mb ijhe_l_eZfbfhf_gy\ \hjhlZN_ev^r_jFboZbeAZoZjh\bq± wlh[uehg± lbohdZreygmeb g_kf_eh\hrze\ dZ[bg_l N_ev^r_j g_ohly ljhgmeky k f_klZ _fm dZd [m^lh ohl_ehkv _szqlhlhkdZaZlvihrze\ i_j_^gxxb hklZgh\bekylZf\ jZa^mfv_:IQ_oh\< hjZg`_j__± kmsKiZe]^_"\ hjZg`_j__Gn± hjZg`_j_yIhkl± gZjbpg_h^mr`j_ kdeg_ihkl± \ _^qIiKiZe]^_"\ hjZg`_j__< jZa^mfv_± kmsHklZgh\bekydZd"\ jZa^mfv_Gn± jZa^mfv_Ihkl± gZjbpg_h^mrkjj_ kdeg_ihkl± \ _^q\ IiHklZgh\bekydZd"\ jZa^mfv_<kz\j_fyhgZ>fZlv@^mfZeZh qzflh± wlhy kjZammagZ\Zeih`b\uf^\b`_gbyfebpZ± b lhjZkkljZb\ZeZkvfheqZijhk_[ylhmeu[ZeZkvD kh`Ze_gbxfuhq_gvj_^dhlZdohjhrhijh\h^bf\j_fy<u^mfZ_l_fh`_l[ulvqlhh^gZ`^uhqgm\rbkvy klZe ihijZ\eylvky" Gbqmlv g_ [u\Zeh <jZq gZagZqbe f_gy gZj_gl]_g b \hl lml y ©ih^^Zeky [_^_ª dZd ex[beZ ]h\hjblv lzly >ZrZ<hi_j\uoj_gl]_gihdZaZeqlhgh]Zg_ijZ\bevghkjhkeZkv<h\lhjuoy^he`gh[ulvijhklm^beky<DZ\_jbg , GZklmibeh fheqZgb_ H^ghh[jZagZy lj_kdhlgy dmag_qbdh\^zj]Zgv_dhjhkl_eyb djbdi_j_i_eZg_gZjmrZebghqghclbrb\\\\gu Z gZijhlb\ ijb^Z\Zeb _c _sz [hevrmx fhghlhgghklv DZaZehkvlboha\mqZebqZjh\Zebkemog_ilbpug_gZk_dhfu_Z a\za^u]ey^_\rb_gZgZkk g_[ZI_j\uc gZjmrbe fheqZgb_ KZ\dZ Hg f_^e_ggh i_j_\ze ]eZaZ k\\qzjghc Dmlvdb gZ f_gy b kdZaZe ©<Zf [Zjbg y \b`m kdmqgh >Z\Zcl_m`bgZlvª:IQ_oh\,,IeZklbdh\u_eu`b± gh\bgdZ\ gZr_fabfg_fkihjlbg\_glZj_ Ij_bfms_kl\h bo \ kjZ\g_gbb k ljZ^bpbhggufb hq_\b^gh <h\\i_j\uoeu`bbaieZklbdZh[eZ^Zxl\ukhdbfbkihjlb\gh[_]h\ufb\\\\dZq_kl\Zfb \h\lhjuo^Zxlh]jhfgmxwdhghfbx^j_\_kbgugZdhg_phgbhq_gvbaysgugZ\b^=Za, ± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_ jZkkdZau\Z_lky h kh[ulbyo ghqvx ,, ± jZkkm`^_gb_ ^hdZau\Z_lky ij_bfms_kl\h ieZklbdh\uo eu` Ij_^eh`_gby\h\lhjhfl_dkl_k\yaZguijbihfhsb\\h^guo keh\Fhghlhgghklv± h^ghh[jZab_Lboh± g_keurgh[_aa\mqgh;m^mlk_]h^gyljZgkebjh\Zlvohdd_cgucfZlqihl_e_\bahjm" Dhg_qgh `_ [m^ml Khfg_\Zxkv qlh [m^ml JZamf__lky KemrZ_l_ eb \u jZ^bhi_j_^Zqb ©< fbj_ keh\ª"± >ZkemrZxDkh`Ze_gbx j_^dh G_m`_eb \Zf g_gjZ\blkykbfnhgbq_kdZyfmaudZ"G_lg_gjZ\blkyIhfg_gbxfZfuy _s_^hg__g_^hjhk >Za^jZ\kl\m_lkhegp_^Zkdjh_lkylvfZIG_lgbq_]h jZ^hklg__ ljm^Z G H B wlhl ]hehk gZdh\Ze_g ^Z kdjbif_oh\^Zrmf h]gyk ^ZezdhclhcihjugZqZevghc\ mrZog_fhedg_l m f_gy L\Zj^ F_klZ kh\k_f g_agZdhfu_ ;hevrbo ^hfh\g_l Z klhyl fZe_gvdb_ ^hfbdb < DZl >Z \hl lZd ex^b a^_kv`b\mlL\Zj^Hg[ueh fhj_l\hci_\_pI$[dZdoheh^gh \ ^hjh]_ Ih\_kl\ \hkde ijhklh_ h^ghkhkl [_aebqg jZkijhklj iheg hke f_`^hf_lb_f L\Zj^ G_l jZ^bh]jZffm yihkueZlvg_[m^m=hj[h,M\Z`Z_fuc<eZ^bfbjDeZ\^b_\bqdgb]m<Zrmy qblZek\\\_ebdbfgZkeZ`^_gb_fG_]h\hjyh _zgZmqghc p_gghklbdhg_qghg_khfg_gghc b djmighc m\e_q_g b hqZjh\Zg [ue _z bah[jZabl_evghx kbehx <Zf m^Zehkv h[t_^bgblv \ k_[_ ;j_fZb N_gbfhjZDm\\\\i_jZWlhih\_jvl_g_iehoZyiho\ZeZJZamf__lkyy [m^mhq_gvjZ^ihemqblv\lhjh_ba^Zgb_wlhcqm^_kghcdgb]b<_ebdh_ gZkeZ`^_gb_ ± [hevrh_ m^h\hevkl\b_ Qm^_kgZy ± m^b\bl_evgZyaZf_qZl_evgZyg_h[udgh\_ggZy mklgh >ey lh]h qlh[u h[gZjm`blv ijbkmlkl\b_ m]e_jh^Z \ m]e_dbkehl_ g_h[oh^bfh hlgylv m g_z dbkehjh^ Wlh]h fh`gh ^hklb]gmlv aZklZ\b\ dbkehjh^ kh_^bgblvky k dZdbfgb[m^v l_ehf h[eZ^Zxsbf _sz [hevrbf d g_fm kjh^kl\hf LZdh\ gZijbf_j f_lZeefZ]gbc ijh\hehdZ dhlhjh]h k]hjZ_l jZkijhkljZgyy hke_ibl_evguck\_l AZ`b]Zx ijh\hehdm b himkdZx _z \ kl_deyggmx [ZgdmaZdexqZxsmxh[udgh\_gguc\ha^moIjh\hehdZk]hjZ_lb gZ^ghiZ^Z_lkh\_jr_ggh[_eZyaheZWlhfZ]g_abykh_^bg_gb_f_lZeeZfZ]gbykdbkehjh^hfIh\lhjyxlhl`_hiulghgZwlhljZaih]jm`Zx]hjysmxijh\hehdm\ khkm^k m]e_dbkehlhcL_i_jvm`_hgZ\ugm`^_gZ^h[u\Zlv k_[_ dbkehjh^ hlgbfZy _]h m m]e_jh^Z b wlhl ihke_^gbc^he`_g h[gZjm`blvky B ^_ckl\bl_evgh gZ wlhl jZa ijh\hehdZ ]hjblg_lbohZ klj_kdhfdZd[uk p_eufjy^hffZe_gvdbo\aju\h\Z gZ kl_gdZo kl_deyggh]hkhkm^ZhkZ`^Z_lkyq_jgZydhihlvWlhhk\h[h^b\rbckym]e_jh^BlZd\ Zlfhkn_jghf\ha^mo_\ g_\b^bfhc^ey]eZaZnhjf_ihklhygghijbkmlkl\m_l]jhfZ^gucaZiZkm]e_jh^Z D:Lbfbjya_\Klbev l_dklZ ± gZmqguc \ gZmqghihimeyjghc jZagh\b^ghklb;hevrbgkl\h]eZ]heh\± \ nhjf_baty\bl_evgh]hgZdehg_gbyEZmj_ZlGh[_e_\kdhc ij_fbbq_kl\h\ZlveZmj_ZlZIh[ebahklb hl djmiguo ijhfure_gguo p_gljh\ kha^Zxlky]hjh^Zkimlgbdb Ih aZfukeZf Zjobl_dlhjh\ dZ`^uc lZdhc ]hjh^jZkkqblZggZg_kdhevdh^_kyldh\lukyq`bl_e_cH[uqghhgkljhblky \ f_klghklb k ohjhrbfb debfZlbq_kdbfb mkeh\byfb >hfZ \ha^\b]Zxlky \^Zeb hl nZ[jbd b aZ\h^h\ Ke_^h\Zl_evgh a_ezguc aZkehg hl^_ey_l `beu_ d\ZjlZeu hl ij_^ijbylbc LZdbo `beuod\ZjlZeh\ kljhbl_eb gZau\Zxl bo fbdjhjZchgZfb ijh_dlbjmxlg_kdhevdhQbkluc\ha^mokhegp_a_e_gvkhq_lZxlky\ gbok [hevrbfbm^h[kl\Zfb>\hj_pdmevlmjudbghl_Zljabfgb_kihjlb\gu_aZeuieZ\Zl_evgu_[Zkk_cguZ bgh]^Zb iey`b± \kzwlh[m^_lkihkh[kl\h\Zlvohjhr_fmhl^uom`bl_e_cIeZ\Zl_evgu_DZ`^uc± f_kl=hjh^dZdhc"dZ`^ucGn± dZ`^ucIhkl± hij_^g_ihkl± \ fj_^qBi=hjh^dZdhc"dZ`^ucIjh_dlbjmxl± ]eZ]Qlh^_eZxl"ijh_dlbjmxlGn± ijh_dlbjh\Zlv Ihkl ± g_kh\\ i_j_o , kij g_ihkl ± \ baty\gZde \gZkl\j\hfgqeQlh^_eZxl"ijh_dlbjmxlBgl_j_kgZy^bkdmkkby[mjgu_^_[ZluhkljZydmevfbgZpbyobfbq_kdZyeZ[hjZlhjbyhdheha_fgZyhj[blZhiulgucibehlijhklhjgZy dZ[bgZ ojZgblv ^hklhbgkl\h ]jZgblguc ihklZf_gl \ukhdbc iv_^_klZe ^hklhijbf_qZl_evgu_ f_klZ bkdmkkl\h l_ZljZ fhglbjh\Zlv ^_dhjZpbb j_i_lbjh\Zlv _`_^g_\gh l_e_\babhggZyljZgkeypby^_[xlZdljbkukbfnhgbq_kdbchjd_klj>bkdmkkby ± ^bkdmkkbhgguc dmevfbgZpby ± dmevfbgZpbhggucljZgkeypby± ljZgkeypbhgguc L_kgh lhjqZeb gZ ]jy^dZo _i_j_imlZggu_]hjhohf_ [mju_ebklvy L LjZ\Z _k]b[Z_fZy m^ZjZfb \_ljZ b ^h`^y_ eh`beZkvgZa_fexF= mklgh LbrbgZ ]jhfZ^guo dhfgZl _gZjmrZ_fZy lhevdh baj_^dZi_gb_f__^hghkb\rbfkybagb`g_]hwlZ`Z_gZ]hgyeZa_\hlmijbqZklgu_h[hjhluihke_hij_^_ey_fuokeh\Q Ebklvydezgh\ihoh`b_ gZ eZiu j_adh \u^_eyebkv gZ `zelhf i_kd_ Zee_c kh]ejZkijhij_^_e_gb_ihke_hij_^_ekeh\ZQ>gyq_j_aljbh]hebebkv ^hklmigu_ \k_f \_ljZf [m]ju ^h[Z\hqgh_ h[kl agZq_gb_ijbqbguRheOhaycdZih[jZgbeZ_z aZ jZggxxhk_ggxxijh]medm\j_^gmxih_z keh\Zf^eya^hjh\vyfheh^hc^_\mrdbkh]ejZkijhkljhij_^_e_gb_ihke_hij_^_ekeh\ZIP\_lgZyhk_gv\_q_j]h^Zfg_meu[Z_lkyk\_lehjZkijhkljijbeh`_gb_FZjrGZfblbg]Zofu]Za_lqbdbmagZzf fgh]hgh\hkl_cijbeh`_gb_hlghkblky d ebqg f_kl IZmkl GZ^j_dhcih\bk]mklhclmfZg[_euc kljZrguc ^\Z h^ghjh^g kh]e hij_^_e_gby ihke_ hij_^keh\Z =_jp : hg fyl_`guc ijhkbl [mjb dZd [m^lh \ [mjyo_klv ihdhc hlghk D ebqgf_klEMlhfezggucgh\ufb\i_qZle_gbyfb y aZkgme jZg__ h[udgh\_ggh]h d ebqg f_kl :dkGZg_[_aZ^mfqb\haZf_jebez]db_h[eZdZ_szjhah\u_hlaZdZlZjZkijhklkh]ehij_^_e_gb_ihke_hij_^keh\ZF=<_l_j kujhc oheh^guc ijhgbau\Zxsbc klmqbl \ hdgZ ljb h^ghjh^ghij_^_e_gbyihke_hij_^keh\ZQ =hjgZy p_iv _khklhysZy ba fgh`_kl\Z oj_[lh\_ lyg_lkygZfgh]hdbehf_ljh\Kg_]_g_lZxsbc^Z`_\ kZfh_`Zjdh_e_lh_ ihdju\Z_l \_jrbgu ]hj Kj_^b dZf_gguo ]eu[_gZ]jhfh`^_gguo^jm]gZ^jm]Z_ljm^ghgZclb^hjh]m_Ihdjulu_yjdbfb iylgZfb p\_lh\_ \ukhdh]hjgu_ em]Z hlqzleb\h \u^_eyxlkygZnhg_l_fgha_ezgh]he_kZGb`_\b^g__lky]hjh^_g_^Z\ghihkljh_gguc_ _\_kv aZebluc we_dljbq_kdbf k\_lhf_ <_l_j oheh^guc b j_adbc^m_lk ]hj\ ^hebgmGbadb_ b dhjy\u_ khkguijbkihkh[bebkv\u^_j`b\Zlv_]hihju\u KZgdlI_l_j[mj] djmig_crbc dmevlmjguc gZmqguc bijhfure_gguc p_glj gZr_c kljZgu jZkiheh`_g gZ [_j_]Zo j_dbG_\u Hg ]hjh^fma_c hkh[_ggh ^hjh] gZr_fm gZjh^m <k_fbjghc ba\_klghklvx ihevamxlky i_l_j[mj]kdb_ Zjobl_dlmjgu_ bkdmevilmjgu_iZfylgbdb± \u^Zxsb_kyijhba\_^_gbybkdmkkl\Z=hjh^fma_chghkh[_ggh^hjh]gZr_fmgZjh^m<hkobs_gguchgg_fh]\ufhe\blvgb keh\ZKhijh\h`^Z_fu_ hiulguf wdkdmjkh\h^hf fu hkfhlj_eb \k_ ^hklhijbf_qZl_evghklb]hjh^Z<a\hegh\Zggucy ^he]hg_fh]aZkgmlvKhk_^gbckZ^[ue[hevrhcb l_gbkluc± KZ^[hevrhcbl_gbkluc [ue ih khk_^kl\m hl gZk Abfgbc \ha^mo qbkluc fhjhaguc± Abfgbc\ha^moqbklucb fhjhagucijbylghhk\_`ZeebphWlh^_j_\h\ukhdh_b \_l\bklh_± Wlh^_j_\h\ukhdh_b \_l\bklh_ihkZ^be_s_fhcijZ^_^ < l_Zlj_ klZ\beb ©J_\bahjZª [_kkf_jlgmx dhf_^bx =h]heyY ijhqzedgb]mh F<Ehfhghkh\_\_ebdhfjmkkdhfmqzghfb ihwl_F<Ehfhghkh\± \_ebdbcjmkkdbcmq_gucihwlb j_nhjfZlhj \ h[eZklb klbohkeh`_gby F < Ehfhghkh\ \_ebdbcjmkkdbc mq_guc [ue _s_ b ihwlhf b j_nhjfZlhjhf \ h[eZklbklbohkeh`_gby D IZmklh\kdbc ± \u^Zxsbcky jmkkdbc ibkZl_evDIZmklh\kdbc\u^ZxsbckyjmkkdbcibkZl_evfgh]hibkZeh ijbjh^_;hjh^bg± ba\_klgucjmkkdbcdhfihablhj;hjh^bgba\_klgucjmkkdbcdhfihablhj[ue_s_b lZeZgleb\ufobfbdhf W Mki_gkdbc ± ihimeyjguc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev W Mki_gkdbcihimeyjguc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev kha^Ze kp_gZjbb fgh]bo fmevlnbevfh\<Zkg_ph\± lZeZgleb\ucjmkkdbcom^h`gbd<Zkg_ph\lZeZgleb\uc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd gZibkZe fgh]h dZjlbg gZ kdZahqgu_kx`_lu Gh\Zy fZ]bkljZev jh\gZy b ijyfZy iha\hebeZ fZrbgZfjZa\b\Zlv [hevrmx kdhjhklv < kmf_jdb wdki_^bpby \t_oZeZ \]hjgh_ ms_ev_ kujh_ b fjZqgh_ IeZfy dhkljZ hk\_sZeh kg_`gmxjZ\gbgmf_jl\mxb [_ahljZ^gmxIh^gbfZekyk_\_jguc\_l_j j_adbc b oheh^guc Fu mdjuebkv \ [j_a_glh\hc iZeZld_[hevrhcb m^h[ghcGZ^aZeb\hf_s_g_aZf_jarbfk djbdhfghkbebkvqZcdb <^hev ^hjh]b lygmebkv ihey ihdZ g_ aZk_yggu_ ir_gbp_c ;e_kl_eZ gZ khegp_ ljZ\Z g_ \ukhorZy ihke_ ^h`^y MjZ]Zgg_bklh\kl\h\Z\rbc\kxghqvih\Zebefgh]h^_j_\v_\ Hd_Zg ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc h]jhfguc j_a_j\mZj jZkoh^mxsbc k\hx \eZ]m gZ hjhr_gb_ kmrb >Z`_ \ jZchgZo jZkiheh`_gguo \ ]em[bg_fZl_jbdh\^hijhp_glh\\k_ohkZ^dh\khklhblba\h^ubkiZjb\r_ckyk fhjkdhcih\_joghklbIhih^kqzlZfmq_guodhebq_kl\hhkZ^dh\\uiZ^ZxsbogZkmrmgZr_cieZg_lujZ\ghdm[bq_kdbfdbehf_ljZf\h^uWlZ\h^Z jZkl\hjy_l fbg_jZeu kh^_j`Zsb_ky \ ihq\_b \ughkblbo\f_kl_k hkZ^dZfb\ hd_ZgKlbevl_dklZ± gZmqguc, JZkoh^mxsbc ± ijbq J_a_j\mZj dZdhc" jZkoh^mxsbc G n ±jZkoh^mxsbc,,Ihkl± ^_ckl\g_kh\\gZkl\jg_ihkl± \ fj_^q<i,,,J_a_j\mZjdZdhc"jZkoh^mxsbck\hx\eZ]mgZhjhr_gb_kmrb,JZkiheh`_gguo± ijbqJZchgZodZdbo"jZkiheh`_gguoGn±jZkiheh`_gguc,,Ihkl± kljZ^kh\\ijhr\jg_ihkl± \ fgqIi,,,JZchgZodZdbo"jZkiheh`_gguomklgh ;ZaZjh\ ih^gye ]heh\m b m\b^Ze IZ\eZ I_ljh\bqZ H^_luc \ ez]dbc de_lqZluc ib^`Zd b [_eu_ dZd kg_] iZglZehgu hg[ukljh rze ih ^hjh]_ ih^ furdhc hg gzk ysbd aZ\zjgmluc \ a_ezgh_ kmdgh L QZkZ ljb ^ebeZkv [_k_^Z g_lhjhieb\Zy jZaghh[jZagZy`b\ZyIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijihegh_hkeh`gh^ghjh[hkh[hij_^LDjZkb\Zy[hjaZykh[ZdZk]hem[uf hr_cgbdhf \[_`ZeZ \ ]hklbgmxklmqZ gh]lyfbihihemZ\ke_^ aZ g_x \hreZ ^_\mrdZ e_l \hk_fgZ^pZlb q_jgh\hehkZy bkfm]eZy k g_kdhevdh djm]euf gh ijbylguf ebphf k g_[hevrbfblzfgufb ]eZaZfb HgZ ^_j`ZeZ \ jmdZodhjabgmgZiheg_ggmxp\_lZfb L Kdhjh ihy\beZkv kZfZ H^bgph\Z \ ijhklhf mlj_gg_fieZlv_ L <hrze q_eh\_d e_l r_klb^_kylb [_eh\hehkuc bkfm]euc \ dhjbqg_\hf njZd_ k f_^gufb im]h\bpZfb b \ jhah\hfieZlhqd_gZr__LFZe_gvdbc ^hf\k_]h\ ljbdhfgZluklhyegZ]hj_Ih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijihegh_hkeh[hkh[e hij_^ IZmkl <hegZ ojmklZevgZy ly`zeZy ebaZeZih^gh`b_ kdZeu ;mg <Zj\ZjZ >fbljb_\gZ hdZaZeZkv `_gsbghc qmldhc b ^_ebdZlghc NZ^ <at_jhr_gguc g_fuluc G_`^Zgh\bf_e\b^^bdbcb kljZggucL<ukmgm\r__ky badZj_lu ebph GZlZrb kbyeh gZkf_reb\hc eZkdhx ELFheh^hfmq_eh\_dm \ex[ezgghfm g_\hafh`gh g_ ijh[helZlvky L L_jjblhjbZevgu_\h^u± ijbe_]ZxsZyd [_j_]mqZklvfhjybebhd_ZgZgZ dhlhjmx jZkijhkljZgy_lky km\_j_gbl_l ijb[j_`gh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\ZKeh\ZjvbghkljZgguokeh\>_ebdZlguc± [_j_`gucqmldbcsZ^ysbcqm\kl\Z^jm]boKo_fu>b @@>Lzieuf^mrbkluf\_q_jhf^jmavyih^oh^bebd <he]_Hgbm`_ \b^_eb [e_kd]hjh^kdbohdhg_]hjysbogZaZdZl__b ^ufiZjhoh^Z _ih^ufZ\rbcky ijyfh baaZ djur k_eZ_ ijbq h[ ihke_ hij_^ ke IueZxsb_ h[eZdZ ahehlbklu_ jhah\u_ p_ehc klZ_c ih^gyebkv gZ^ e_khf aZ]hj_ebkv ebdmxsbfb djZkdZfb `Zjilbph^ghjkh]ehijihke_hij_^keh\ZIhlhfhgbjZa^_ebebkvgZ^_kyldb h]g_gguoilbq_djZae_l_ebkv\ klhjhgub f_^e_gghihlmoebIZjhoh^ _ihdjuluc q_jgufb dem[Zfb ^ufZ_ ^Ze ihke_^gbc]m^hdojbieuc b ]mklhcijbqh[b h^ghjhijihke_hij_^keh\ZGZdhjf_lbobc`_gkdbc]hehkaZlygmei_kgxg_fgh]hi_qZevgmx]jmklgmx h^ghj hij ihke_ hij_^ keh\Z ;ukljh ijb[eb`ZekyijZ\uc [_j_] <he]b M`_ [Zrgb b kl_gu gb`_]hjh^kdh]h dj_feyklZeb \b^gu \ lzfghf g_[_ gZ^ \_gphf ]hju _i_j_lygmlhc lhgdbfihykdhf h]hgvdh\_ijbqh[ihke_hij_^keh\Z<hlb hlqbc^hfklZjbgguc jmkkdbc ]hjh^ _jZkdbgm\rbcky gZ^ rbjhdbf jZa^hev_f\_ebdhc jmkkdhc j_db_ jZkijhklj ijbeh`_gb_ b ijbq h[ ihke_hij_^keh\ZEx[bfucdjZcjh^gZyijbjh^Z± hgbfbe__\k_]hIh:GNhjfhah\m=zl_]h\hjbe©Ijbjh^Zg_^himkdZ_lrmlhdhgZ \k_]^Zk_jvzagZb kljh]ZhgZ\k_]^ZijZ\^ZªLheklhc[uedZdijbjh^Z[ueg_baf_ggh©k_jvza_gªb [_af_jgh©ijZ\^b\ª©=_jhcfh_cih\_klbdhlhjh]hy ex[ex\k_fbkbeZfb^mrbdhlhjh]hklZjZeky\hkijhba\_klb\h\k_cdjZkhl__]hb dhlhjuc\k_]^Z[ue_klvb [m^_lij_djZk_g± ijZ\^Zª< kfuke_ ijZ\^b\hklb m^b\bl_e_g [ue ^Z`_ yaud _]h ijhba\_^_gbc\u^_eyxsbcky\h\k_cjmkkdhcebl_jZlmj_hlkmlkl\b_f\kydbo [_ee_ljbklbq_kdbo djZkhl ]hlh\uo klbebklbq_kdbo ijbzfh\mkeh\ghkl_cihjZ`Zxsbckf_ehklvxgm`ghklvxlhqghcgZoh^qb\hklvxdZ`^h]hkeh\ZB:;mgbg mklghFgh]hiZfylguof_kl\ Fhkd\_^j_\g_cklhebp_k\yaZgh kbf_gZfb aZf_qZl_evguo ex^_c gZr_c Jh^bgu < p_glj_ klhebpumklZgh\e_giZfylgbd\_ebqZcr_fmjmkkdhfmihwlm:KImrdbgmG_^Ze_dh hlg_]hgZoh^blkyiZfylgbd<<FZydh\kdhfmgh\Zlhjmjmkkdhc ihwabb kha^Zgguc ihijh_dlm:IDb[Zevgbdh\Zba\_klgh]h kdmevilhjZ =h]he_\kdbc [mev\Zj b Ehfhghkh\kdbc ijhki_dlgZa\Zgu \ q_klv G < =h]hey b F < Ehfhghkh\Z agZqbl_evguo^_yl_e_c jmkkdhc dmevlmju Bfy I B QZcdh\kdh]h \k_fbjghba\_klgh]h dhfihablhjZ ghkbl Fhkdh\kdZy ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggZydhgk_j\Zlhjby Bf_g_f : < Km\hjh\Z e_]_g^Zjgh]h ihedh\h^pZgZa\ZgZh^gZbaiehsZ^_cklhebpu <heh^y K_fzgh\ dZd klm^_gl ]hjgh]h bgklblmlZ qZklh[u\Ze\ ]_heh]hjZa\_^hqguowdki_^bpbyoFhc^_^mrdZdZdmqZklgbd <_ebdhc Hl_q_kl\_gghc \hcgu [ue ijb]eZr_g i_j_^ >g_fIh[_^u gZdhgp_jl^ey\_l_jZgh\K_kljZdZdhlebqgbpZmqz[uijbgyeZmqZklb_\ ]hjh^kdhchebfibZ^_ijbqbg =_jZkbfm dZd hlebqghfm jZ[hlgbdm lml `_ ^Zeb \ jmdbdhkmLM`_g_jZa^hoh^beb^hf_gykemobh Yrd_Lmjd_dZdhemqr_fi_\p_\ hdhehld_LIhe_kv_khojZgbehkvm f_gy\ iZfylbdZdi_qZevgZyghg_fgh]haZ]Z^hqgZykljZgZIZmkl>m[ijbqbgdZdhq_gvdj_idh_^_j_\hijbf_gy_lky^eyba]hlh\e_gbyiZjd_lZijbqbgGZr kZ^ dZd ijhoh^ghc ^\hj Q DZd kljZklguc ex[bl_ev hohluy p_eufbg_^_eyfbg_[u\Ze^hfZKFEx[bl_ev Ihe_kv_± kmsKhojZgbehkvqlh"Ihe_kv_Gn± Ihe_kv_Ihkl± kh[kl\g_h^mrkjjkdelhevdh_^qg_ihkl± \ BiKhojZgbehkvqlh"Ihe_kv_,< ihe^_gvihe_lg_fm]hjyqbcb [_euchgbih^t_oZebd kmlmehfm hkh[gyqdm gZ h^ghc ba ijb\hdaZevguo mebp =hehkih^ihedh\gbdZ qzldbc b gZihjbkluc ijbly]b\Ze \gbfZgb_ =jb]hjbyDhr_\hcg_ihgbfZ\rbc[_kihdhcghckm_lgb[uem^b\ezgEz]hgvdbc\_l_jhdihb]ju\Ze]jb\hcgb jZamg_aZihl_\r_]hdhgy <a\hegh\Zgguc hg g_ fh] mkgmlv K`b]Z_fuc [_kihdhckl\hf hg mklj_fbeky \i_jz^ Ih ^hjh]_ \klj_lbeky wdki_^bpbb dZaZdnjhglh\bd _oZ\rbc k `_ghc gZ omlhj DZaZdb \ fhdjuobafZaZgguorbg_eyodbiylbebgZsblZodhl_edbk qZ_fGZaZjh\wlhlwg_j]bqgucdbimqbc]_g_jZekb^_ehi_jrbkvgZjmdmaZdju\eZ^hgvxeh[Jhkeucrbjhdhie_qbciZj_gvhg>khe^Zl@e_`Ze \hevgh hldbgm\ ]heh\m <Zffheh^ufmqblvkym gZkgZ^h dZd `bagv ijh\h^blv GZibkZgguc jmdhc Dhr_\h]h ez] gZklheebkl]jZnezghc[mfZ]b\uj\Zggucbamq_gbq_kdh]h[ehdghlZFRhehoh\Ijb\hdaZevguo,, GZrb ijZhlpu hkgh\Zl_eb jhkkbckdbo ^_j_\_gv b kze aZ[hlbebkv g_ lhevdh h[ m^h[kl\_ gh b h djZkhl_ Khe >_ckl\bl_evgh kj_^b rbjhdbo em]h\ lh ijhklh a_ezguo lh p\_lmsbo jZagufbp\_lZfbijhl_dZ_llboZyk\_leZyDhehdrZKheKdhevayih mlj_gg_fm kg_]m ^jm] fbeuc ij_^Z^bfky [_]m g_l_ji_eb\h]hdhgy b gZ\_klbf ihey imklu_ e_kZ g_^Z\gh klhev ]mklu_ b [_j_]fbeuc^eyf_gyIJ_[yq_kdbcdjbdih\lhjy_fucwohfk mljZb ^hghqb]j_fblihe_kZfGJh^bgZk_j_[jbklhc_eb± DZgZ^ZIjh^he`bl_evghklv`bagb wlh]h ^_j_\Z ± e_l Gh k_j_[jbklZy _ev \ujZs_ggZy \iblhfgbd_ih^]hjh^hfGZevqbdhf_szkh\k_ffheh^Z<ujZklbe wlm _ev kljh]mx b ]hj^mx klZjuc k_e_dpbhg_j B\ZgIhjnbjv_\bq Dh\lmg_gdh m^hklh_gguc aZ wlh =hkm^Zjkl\_gghcij_fbb G_ez]hd [ue _]h ljm^ GbdZd g_ \koh^beb k_f_gZ \ g_ijb\uqguo g_ ih^oh^ysbo ^ey gbo mkeh\byo Gh l_ji_gb_ b hiul k_e_dpbhg_jZ ih[_^beb Ihke_^gb_ljbdbeh]jZffZk_fyghklZ\rb_ky ihke_ ]b[_eb i_j\uo \koh^h\ hg \ukZ^be \ _eh\u_ hibedb Blukyqb dj_idbo \koh^h\ ihqm\kl\h\Z\rbo jh^gmx kj_^m ihlygmebkvd khegpmI_j\Zyba\ujZs_gguo\ iblhfgbd_k_j_[jbkluo_e_cm_oZeZgZ>g_ijh]wk?evDh\lmg_gdh\klZeZb mkl_gDj_feyb gZFZfZ_\hfdmj]Zg_b \hae_;j_klkdhcdj_ihklbIh<Q_jldh\mIjh^he`bl_evghklv Kljh]mx± ijbeZ]?evdZdmx"kljh]mxGn± kljh]bcIhkl± dZq_kl\g_ihkl± iheg\ `j_^q<i?evdZdmx"kljh]mxHklZ\rb_ky± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_Ljbdbeh]jZffZdZdb_"hklZ\rb_kyGn± hklZ\rbckyIhkl± ^_ckl\kh\\ijhr\jg_ihkl± \hfgq<iLjbdbeh]jZffZdZdb_"hklZ\rb_kyIhqm\kl\h\Z\rbo ± hkh[Zy nhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_<koh^h\dZdbo"ihqm\kl\h\Z\rboGn± ihqm\kl\h\Z\rbcIhkl± ^_ckl\kh\\ijhr\jg_ihkl± \hfgqJi<koh^h\ dZdbo"ihqm\kl\h\Z\rboFhj_± h]jhfgh_e_gb\h\a^uoZxs__m [_j_]Z± mkgmehb g_ih^\b`gh\ ^Zebh[eblhc]hem[ufkbygb_femguFy]dh_b k_j_[jbklh_ hgh kebehkv lZf k kbgbf x`guf g_[hf b dj_idh kiblhljZ`Zy \ k_[_ ijhajZqgmx ldZgv i_jbkluo h[eZdh\ g_ih^\b`guob g_kdju\Zxsbokh[hxahehluomahjh\a\_a^=hjuihjhkrb_^_j_\vyfb mjh^eb\h bah]gmlufb ghj^hklhf j_adbfb \afZoZfb ih^gyebk\hb\_jrbgu\ kbgxximklugxgZ^gbfb«K gbogZiurgu_a_e_gh\Zlu_]j_[gb\hegmiZebq_jgu_l_gbb h^_\Zxlbo«Fuk JZ]bfhf\ZjbfmombalhevdhqlhgZeh\e_gghcju[u« ± :ZeZZoZZd[Zj ± lboh\a^uoZ_lGZ^ujJZ]bfh]euklZjucdjufkdbcqZ[Zg\ukhdbck_^hckh``_ggucx`gufkhegp_fkmohcb fm^jucklZjbdF=hjvdbc©I_kgyh Khdhe_ªImrdbgkdb_f_klZ \Ikdh\kdhch[eZklb< dbehf_ljZo hl ]hjh^Z Ikdh\Z gZoh^blky Imrdbgkdbc ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguc aZih\_^gbd h[t_^bgb\rbc f_klZ l_kg_crbf h[jZahf k\yaZggu_ k `bagvx b l\hjq_kl\hf : K ImrdbgZ Q_j_a \kx`bagvihwlijhgzk]em[hdmxijb\yaZgghklvd wlhfmm]hedm jmkkdhca_febXghr_chgijb_a`Zekx^Z\ b ]h^Zoa^_kvijh\ze^\Z ]h^Z kkuedb kx^Z klj_fbeky \ ihke_^gb_ ]h^u `bagb Bf_gghh[wlbof_klZoImrdbgibkZe\ ]h^mIjb\_lkl\mxl_[yimkluggucm]hehdIjbxlkihdhckl\byljm^h\b \^hogh\_gvyP_gljhf aZih\_^gbdZ y\ey_lky FboZceh\kdh_ [u\r__ jh^h\h_bf_gb_ImrdbguoMkZ^v[Zk ]hkih^kdbf^hfhfb kem`[ZfbklhblgZ ohef_ gZ^ `b\hibkghc j_dhc Khjhlvx D mkZ^v[_ ijbfudZ_liZjd i_j_oh^ysbc \ \_dh\hc khkgh\uc [hj Z k [ZedhgZ jZkiheh`_ggh]h gZ k_\_jghc klhjhg_ ^hfZ hldju\Z_lky \_ebdhe_igZy iZghjZfZKhjhlbb rbjhdhc^hebguk ha_jhfJy^hf k ^hfhffma__f klhbl ^_j_\ygguc neb]_ezdagZf_gbluc^hfbdgygbihwlZ:jbguJh^bhgh\guIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijihegh_hkeh[hkh[jZkijijbeh`_gb_f<kyh[klZgh\dZ dhfgZl \hkdj_rZ_l h[jZa wlhc aZf_qZl_evghc jmkkdhc`_gsbgukZfh]h[ebadh]hb bkdj_gg_]h^jm]ZihwlZ\ ly`zeu_^eyg_]h]h^ukkuedbIj_^eh`_gby\ f Z[aZp_k\yaZguijbihfhsbkbghgbfh\f_klZm]hehdb gZj_qbca^_kvkx^ZH[t_^bgb\rbc± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_AZih\_^gbddZdhc"h[t_^bgb\rbcGn± h[t_^bgb\rbcIhkl± ^_ckl\kh\\ijhr\jg_ihkl± \ fj_^qBiAZih\_^gbddZdhc"h[t_^bgb\rbcf_klZL_kg_crbf± ijbeZ]H[jZahfdZdbf"l_kg_crbfGn± l_kgucIhkl± dZq_kl\g_ihkl± \ ij_\hkoklfj_^qLiH[jZahfdZdbf"l_kg_crbfD mkZ^v[_± kmsIjbfudZ_ld q_fm"d mkZ^v[_Gn± mkZ^v[ZIhkl± gZjbpg_h^mr`jkdeg_ihkl± \ _^q>iIjbfudZ_ld q_fm"d mkZ^v[_=jhagZyiZghjZfZ[mrmxs_]hfhjyjZa\_jgmeZkvi_j_^gZfb :evibgbklu ba^Zeb gZ[ex^Zeb iZghjZfm ^Ze_dbo \_jrbg ghbaaZg_ih]h^ug_fh]ebgZqZlv\hkoh`^_gb_ Hldjulb_ l_ZljZevgh]h k_ahgZ g_aZ[u\Z_fh_ \i_qZle_gb_hlb]juZdlzjh\ohjhrhih^]hlh\blvebl_jZlmjgucfhglZ`klZjZl_evghjZ[hlZlvgZ^jhevxhjb]bgZevgZyljZdlh\dZiv_kuj_`bkkzjhf Ex[bfh\uf ]_jhbq_kdbc nbgZe c kbfnhgbb RhklZdh\bqZfmaudZevgh_khijh\h`^_gb_jZ^bhki_dlZdey<i_qZle_gb_± \i_qZlZlvky\i_qZlebl_evgucIhhdhgqZgbbaZgylbcfu[m^_fjZ[hlZlvgZn_jf_± Fuhdhgqbf aZgylby b ihke_ wlh]h [m^_f jZ[hlZlv gZ n_jf_ _Hdhgqb\aZgylby_ fu [m^_f jZ[hlZlv gZ n_jf_ Ihke_ k^Zqb wdaZf_gh\fgh]b_ klm^_glu [m^ml jZ[hlZlv \ kljhchljy^Zo ± Fgh]b_ klm^_glu k^Z^ml wdaZf_gu Z ihlhf [m^ml jZ[hlZlv \ kljhchljy^Zo _K^Z\wdaZf_gu_fgh]b_klm^_glu[m^mljZ[hlZlv\ kljhchljy^ZoAZg_bf_gb_f^hfZgm`guodgb]y ^he`_g[ueaZgbfZlvky\ qblZevg_Yg_ gZr_e ^hfZ gm`guo dgb] b \ugm`^_g [ue aZgbfZlvky \ qblZevg__G_gZc^y^hfZgm`guodgb]_y \ugm`^_g[ueaZgbfZlvky\ qblZevg_, _H[h]gm\ \ukhdbc fuk_ iZjhoh^ \hrze \ aZeb\<_l_j dj_iqZe kbevg__ _aZdmlu\Zy ]hjh^ i_e_ghc fhjkdbo lmfZgh\_ GZ k_\_j_ _keZ[h f_jpZy_ ih^ufZebkv dZdb_lh [_e_kh\Zlu_ h[eZdZ>Ze_dh\ \urbg__\]ey^_\rbkv_fheh^hcq_eh\_djZaebqbeg_ykgu_hq_jlZgbyh[eZdZ<=Dhjhe_gdh,,<h^Zg_ohlyi_j_eb\ZeZkvq_j_ai_j_dZlDjmlY ]h\hjbeZ hgZreZfheqZRheJZ[hlZehgg_ihdeZ^ZyjmdF= IZgl_e_c Ijhdhnv_\bq kdj_iy k_j^p_ ^h\_jbe >Zjv_ [udh\RheQblZlvez`Z\j_^ghEz`ZgZ]hjyq_fi_kd_fukemrZebrmf ijb[hy Y ohjhrh agZe ]^_ gZ ihed_ e_`bl fhy ex[bfZydgb]Z b fh] \aylv _z g_ ]ey^y G_ ]ey^y gZ ^hkdm ljm^gh b]jZlv \rZofZlu GZ lj_gbjh\dZo ;hjah\ rmly ijh[_]Ze klhf_ljh\dm aZ k_dmg^ <_k_eh rmly b ih^kf_b\Zykv ^jm] gZ^ ^jm]hf fu g_aZf_lgh^hreb^heZ]_jyE_`Z gZ ]hjyq_f i_kd_ g_ ]ey^y gZ ^hkdm \_k_eh rmly b ih^kf_b\Zykv^jm]gZ^^jm]hfH[jZah\Zggu_hl^__ijbqZklbcgZj_qbyg_ bf_xlaZ\bkbfuokeh\, QbjdgmeZ kibqdZ gZ k_dmg^m hk\_lb\ jZa\_rZggu_k_lb k_gh klZjbdZ K_jZn Bgh]^Z ke_ihc [jZe ^m^dm b kh\_jr_gghaZ[u\Zekyih^[bjZyd k\h_fmgZkljh_gbxaZ^mfqb\u_f_eh^bb DhjF_kypahehlykvkimkdZekyd kl_ibELDZaZdbjZat_oZebkv g_ ^h]h\hjb\rbkv Rhe Hgb _sz ^he]h kb^_eb \]hjgbp_gZkmg^md_\ay\rbkvaZjmdbfheqZ^mfZyh k\hzfRhe,, B ohjhrh fg_ a^_kv hklZgh\blvky b ]ey^y \^Zev ihkemrZlv ih^h`^Zlv Rmfbl rmfbl \ukhdZy ir_gbpZ b _c dhgpZ bdjZy g_ \b^Zlv BkZd B ih^jm]b klZeb ]heh\m aZdbgm\ keh\gh^\_ hk_ggbo ^\_ e_kguo jy[bgu B aZi_eb jZahf klZx ijh\h`Zyqlh\k_]h^hjh`_klhjhgZjh^gZyIh\_kl\g_\hkdekeh`ghih^qkhklbao ijhkluokh_^ih^qkhxahfQLHBkZdB kheg_qguc ihlhd ijhj_aZ\ l_eh lmqb miZe ^ufykv gZ djbklZeebq_kdb_djmqb h]jhfguo e_^gbdh\ b \kiuogme b ih]Zk AZ[hehpdbc Kbg_y[e_smlg_[_kZIFug_hlju\Zykvke_^bebaZihezlhfieZgzjZM^Zey_lky aZlboZy i_kgy Jmq_c `mjqZ kljmblky ih dZfgyf IjhsZykv fu h[_sZeb ibkZlv ^jm] ^jm]m Y hldZaZeky [ueh hl ih_a^dbghih^mfZ\kh]eZkbeky IeZgzj djmlh \afue \\_jo b hibkZ\ [hevrhc djm] klZeieZ\ghkimkdZlvkyFZevqbrdbkfhlj_ebgZg_]haZ^jZ\]heh\ub fZoZeb \ke_^ Fhglzj ^he]h hkfZljb\Ze ijh\h^dm hlukdb\Zyih\j_`^_gb_bh[gZjm`b\f_klhjZaju\ZmkljZgbeg_bkijZ\ghklvHg]h\hjbe\k_\j_fymeu[ZykvKlZjbdrzeg_fgh]hijbojZfu\Zy >_\mrdZ kb^_eZ h q_flh aZ^mfZ\rbkv Ih_a^b^zlg_hklZgZ\eb\Zykvgb gZh^ghcklZgpbb G_ \u^_j`Z\ kebrdhf[ukljh]hl_fiZeu`gbdkhrzek^bklZgpbbG_aZdhgq_ggZyrZofZlgZyiZjlby[ueZi_j_g_k_gZgZke_^mxsbc^_gvaZf_gZg_\hafh`gZG_aZdhgqb\iZjlbx\q_jZ]jhkkf_ckl_ju k_]h^gy kh]eZkbebkv gZ gbqvx Fbebpbhg_j hrljZnh\Ze i_r_oh^Z g_ kh[ex^Z\r_]h ijZ\beZ ^hjh`gh]h ^\b`_gby aZf_gZ g_\hafh`gZ G_ mki_\ d ihke_^g_fm Z\lh[mkm iZkkZ`bju\ayeblZdkbI_j_g_k_gZ ^hjh`gh]h Ij_^qm\kl\my g_ijbylgmx \klj_qm \hjqZ b h]ey^u\ZykvDZrlZgdZ\hreZ\ fZe_gvdmxdhfgZlmk ]jyagufbh[hyfbb \kljZo_ ihiylbeZkv gZaZ^ Ijb]gm\ d a_fe_ r_x b ]heh\m jZklhiujb\djuevyb rbiyijyfhgZg_zrzek_juc]mkvG_kdhevdh\ klhjhg_hlg_]hgZfZljZkbd_e_`Ze[_eucdhlm\b^_\DZrlZgdmhg\kdhqbe \u]gme kibgm \ ^m]m aZ^jZe o\hkl \at_jhrbe r_jklv b lh`_aZrbi_e Kh[ZdZ bkim]ZeZkv g_ gZ rmldm gh g_ `_eZy \u^Z\Zlvk\h_]h kljZoZ ]jhfdh aZeZyeZ b [jhkbeZkv d dhlm Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h^ghj kdZa b^__ijbq h[ Dhl _sz kbevg__ \u]gme kibgm aZrbi_e b m^ZjbeDZrlZgdm eZihc ih ]heh\_ DZrlZgdZ hlkdhqbeZ ijbk_eZ gZ \k_q_luj_ eZiu b ijhly]b\Zy d dhlm fhj^m aZebeZkv ]jhfdbf\ba]eb\ufeZ_fIh:IQ_oh\m<hjqZ± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ^__ijbqZklb_<hreZdZd"\hjqZGn± \hjqZlvG_kh\\g_baf<hreZdZd"\hjqZIjb]gm\ ± hkh[Zy nhjfZ ]eZ]heZ ± ^__ijbqZklb_ R_e dZd"ijb]gm\Gn± ijb]gmlvKh\\g_bafR_edZd"ijb]gm\d a_fe_r_xb ]heh\mE_`Ze± ]eZ]Dhl qlh^_eZe"e_`ZeGn± e_`ZlvIhkl± g_kh\\g_i_j_o,,kijg_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j_^qfjDlhqlh^_eZe"e_`Ze G_kfhljy gZ m]h\hju jh^bl_e_c fu hlijZ\bebkv \ ihoh^ G_kfhljy gZ ihklb]rmx gZk g_m^Zqm fu mihjgh ijh^he`Zeblj_gbjh\Zlvky<hij_dbgZrbfij_^iheh`_gbyfwlZaZ^ZqZg_bf_eZj_r_gby < gh\h]h^gb_ ijZa^gbdb \ke_^kl\b_ g_hklhjh`gh]h h[jZs_gby k h]gzf kemqZ_lky fgh]h ih`Zjh\ Khklhygb_ [hevgh]h [eZ]h^Zjy ijZ\bevghfm e_q_gbx k_]h^gy memqrbehkv KZ\_eh\kdbc \hdaZe \ke_^kl\b_ j_fhglZ `_e_agh^hjh`guo iml_c \ wlb \uoh^gu_aZdjul Kjhdb k_\Z \\b^m h`b^Z_fh]h j_adh]h ihoheh^Zgby [uebi_j_g_k_guIhmebpZf]hjh^ZgZ\_ehkbi_^_fh`gh_a^blvk q_lujgZ^pZlb e_l ijb mkeh\bb kh[ex^_gby ijZ\be ^hjh`gh]h ^\b`_gbyFh`gh ijb gZebqbb ^hklZlhqgh]h dhebq_kl\Z \j_f_gb hlijZ\blvky \ djm]hk\_lgh_ iml_r_kl\b_ EZ[hjZlhjgmx jZ[hlm ih obfbbijb hlkmlkl\bb g_h[oh^bfuo ^ey ijh\_^_gby hiulZ mkeh\bc hlf_gbeb, Dh]^Z y ijb_oZe ^hfhc jZa^_eky b ih^mfZe h kg_ y m\b^_e qlh wlh kh\_jr_ggh g_\hafh`gh _KlZjZykv g_ rmf_lv_ y gZpuihqdZo ijhrze \ k\hx dhfgZlm b k_e gZ ihkl_ev G_l y [uekebrdhfkqZkleb\y g_fh]kiZlvIjblhffg_`Zjdh[ueh\ gZlhie_gguodhfgZlZob y_g_kgbfZyfmg^bjZ_ihlbohgvdm\ur_e\ i_j_^gxx gZ^_e rbg_ev hl\hjbe gZjm`gmx ^\_jv b \ur_e gZmebpmY ijhrzegZrimklugguci_j_mehdb \ur_egZ[hevrmxmebpm]^_ klZeb \klj_qZlvky i_r_oh^u b ehfh\u_ k ^jh\Zfb gZ kZgyo_^hklZ\Z\rboihehavyfb^hfhklh\hc_B ehrZ^b_jZ\ghf_jghihdZqb\Zxsb_ ih^ ]eygp_\blufb ^m]Zfb fhdjufb ]heh\Zfb_ b ihdjulu_jh]h`Zfbba\haqbdb_reziZ\rb_\ h]jhfguokZih]Zoih^e_\hah\_ b ^hfZ mebpu _dZaZ\rb_ky \ lmfZg_ hq_gv \ukhdbfb_ ± \kz[uehfg_hkh[_gghfbehb agZqbl_evghEGLheklhcLbij_qb± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_,, Fhj_ h]jhfgh_ _e_gb\h \a^uoZxs__ m [_j_]Z_ mkgmeh b g_ih^\b`gh\ ^Zeb_h[eblhc]hem[ufkbygb_femgu_Fy]dh_ b k_j_[jbklh_ hgh kebehkv lZf k x`guf g_[hf b dj_idh kibl _hljZ`Zy \k_[_ ijhajZqgmx ldZgv i_jbkluo h[eZdh\_ g_ih^\b`guo b _g_kdju\Zxsbokh[hcahehluomahjh\a\za^_=hju _ihjhkrb_^_j_\vyfb__mjh^eb\hbah]gmlufbghj^hklhf_j_adbfb \afZoZfb ih^gyeb k\hb \_jrbgu\ kbgxximklugxkmjh\u_dhglmjubohdjm]ebebkv_h^_lu_lziehcb eZkdh\hcf]ehcx`ghcghqb_F=hjvdbcLbil_dklZ ± hibkZgb_,,,DZd\kzijhr_^r__ykghb j_adhhlebehkv\ fh_ciZfylbGbh^ghcq_jlugb h^gh]hhll_gdZg_klzjeh\j_fyY ihfgxqlh\ ijh^he`_gb_ghqb_ij_^r_kl\mxs_cih_^bgdm_y g_ kiZe gb fbgmlu IbkZlv y g_ fh] ^he]h lZcgh_ [_kihdhckl\hfghx h\eZ^_eh K qZk y oh^be ih dhfgZl_ ihlhf k_e b hldjue jhfZg<Zevl_jZKdhllZ_e_`Zsbcm f_gygZklhe__Y qblZekgZqZeZkmkbeb_fihlhfaZ[ueky_m\e_qzgguc\her_[guf\ufukehf_GZdhg_p jZkk\_eh G_j\u fhb mkihdhbebkv Y ihkfhlj_eky \a_jdZeh lmkdeZy [e_^ghklv ihdju\ZeZ ebph fhz _ojZgb\r__ ke_^u[_kkhggbpu_ gh ]eZaZ _ohly hdjm`zggu_ l_gvx_ [ebklZeb ]hj^h bg_mfhebfhY hklZeky^h\he_gkh[hx_<_e_\ k_^eZlv ehrZ^_c_ y h^_eky b k[_`Ze \ dmiZevgx_Ih]jm`Zykv \ oheh^guc dbiylhd gZjaZgZ_ y qm\kl\h\Ze dZd l_e_kgu_b ^mr_\gu_kbeufhb\ha\jZsZebkvY \ur_eba\Zgguk\_`b[h^jdZd[m^lhkh[bjZekygZ[ZeIhke_wlh]h]h\hjbl_qlh^mrZg_aZ\bkblhll_eZFXE_jfhglh\Lbil_dklZ± ih\_kl\h\Zgb_k we_f_glZfbjZkkm`^_gbyIh_^bghd< qbklhf kbg_f g_[_ djm`bebkv ^\_ ilbpu kl_ighc hjze b `mjZ\ev Hjze iulZeky gZiZklv gZ `mjZ\ey klj_fykv \ae_l_lv \ur_g_]hZ `mjZ\ev\h\j_fyhle_lZy\ klhjhgmlh`_gZ[bjZe\ukhlm<hlhjzegZp_eb\rbkvk^_eZeklj_fbl_evguc[jhkhd\gba@mjZ\ev m\_jgm\rbkv hdZaZeky \ukhdh gZ^ hjehf Obsgbd gZ[jZ\\ukhlm ih\lhjbe k\hc fZgz\j gh kgh\Z g_ ^hklb]mki_oZGZdhg_phkeZ[_\rbc`mjZ\evjbgmekygZa_fexih^h]gm\djuevyIhqm\kl\h\Z\ l\zj^mx hihjm hg \klZe gZ k\hb ^ebggu_ gh]b bijb]hlh\bekyd \klj_q_k \jZ]hfHjze keh`b\ djuevy dZfg_f dbgmeky gZ `mjZ\ey Z lhl \ulygm\ r_x b jZkimklb\ djuevy k ]jhfdbf dmjeudZgv_f [jhkbeky gZ\jZ]Z<b^`mjZ\ey[uelZdbfm]jh`Zxsbfqlhhjzek_e\ klhjhg_Z ihlhfih[_`Zeijhqvb\afu\\ \ha^mokdjuekyaZkdehghf]hju mklgh< ]h^mZij_eyX:=Z]Zjbgkh\_jrbei_j\ucdhkfbq_kdbcihezlGZk_\_j_Jhkkbb\ ^_j_\g_Ohefh]hjujh^beky\_ebdbcjmkkdbcmqzgucb ihwlF<Ehfhghkh\G_^Ze_dhhlKZgdlI_l_j[mj]ZgZ[Zelbckdbo[_j_]ZoIzlj,aZeh`be]hjh^dj_ihklvDjhgrlZ^lJZghmljhf\ k_fvqZkh\ihjZ^bhi_j_^ZzlkynbaaZjy^dZ^eyrdhevgbdh\ mklghE_lhf\h\j_fydZgbdmefg_ohl_ehkv[uih_oZlvgZfhj_ GZ [_j_]m m kZfhc \h^u kh[jZebkv djbdeb\u_ qZcdb GZP\_lghf[mev\Zj_gZZj_g_pbjdZkhklhblkydjZkhqgh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_ <_q_jhf ihke_ jh^bl_evkdh]h kh[jZgby m gZk khklhyekyk_jv_agucjZa]h\hj;hlZgbdmlh_klvgZmdmh jZkl_gbyofugZqZebbamqZlv\r_klhfdeZkk_;bh]jZnbylh_klvhibkZgb_kh[kl\_gghc`bagbfh`_l[ulvgZibkZgZb \om^h`_kl\_gghfb \hnbpbZevgh^_eh\hfklbe_ Fgh]b_ ]Zau gZijbf_j dbkehjh^ e_]dh \aju\Zxlky Abfhc ^Z`_ \ kbevgu_ fhjhau g_ ij_djZsZe jZ[hlZlv ljZgkihjl <k_ `bl_eb ]hjh^Z ^Z`_ [hevgu_ ih[_`Zeb kfhlj_lv gZ^bdh\bggh_ aj_ebs_ Fg_ gjZ\blky ihwaby ^_\ylgZ^pZlh]h \_dZhkh[_ggh klbohl\hj_gby ImrdbgZ Ohjhrh e_lhf gZ x]_ hkh[_gghgZ[_j_]mQzjgh]hfhjy;_]_fhlbeb]biihihlZfh[blZ_l\k_]^Z\hae_\h^h_fh\ < ihe_ \ jhs_ \ \ha^mo_ pZjkl\h\Zeh [_afhe\b_ L <q_jZ y ijb_oZe \ Iylb]hjkd b gZgye d\Zjlbjm gZdjZx]hjh^ZgZkZfhf \ukhdhf f_kl_ m ih^gh`by FZrmdZ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkdeijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke mlhqgyxs h[kl E Ih_a^gzkkyfbfhkiysbo\hlvf_^_j_\_gvfbfhqzjguoe_kh\fbfhj_^dboklZgpbcHk_gvx\h\j_fyg_gZklvye_kbf__lhkh[_gghmgueuc\b^:jk< dhgp_ghy[jy\ ykguc^_gv\ keh[h^m y\bebkv ]hklb Dhj <^hev ^hebgu [eb`_ d k_\_jm kh\_jr_ggh ijZ\bevghc ebgb_c lyg_lky jy^ ]jhfZ^guo dmj]Zgh\Ij_`^_ \h \j_fy \hcgu wlb dmj]Zgu [ueb k\yaZgu ljZgr_yfb=beyjFhjydbkhojZgbeba^_kvgZ^jh`Zs_chl\aju\h\a_fe_\k_ k\hb ijb\uqdb Lhqgh k\ys_ggmx j_ebd\bx ghkbeb hgb ih^i_ohlghcrbg_evxk\hbihebgy\rb_aZklbjZggu_l_evgyrdb<AZdjmldbgPZjkl\h\Zeh <k_ibehluaZbkdexq_gb_fj_a_j\gh]hwdbiZ`Zkh[jZebkv gZ kh\_sZgb_ AZ\ljZ ihfbfh hq_j_^guo j_ckh\[m^_lims_gh g_kdhevdh ^hihegbl_evguo Fu hdhiZeb \k_ \ kZ^m djhf_njmdlh\uo ^_j_\v_\ <k_ g_ bkdexqZy mqZklgbdh\ dhgdmjkZ j_rZeb dhfm ijbkm^blv i_j\h_ f_klh =bfgZkl \uihegbe k\_jogZf_q_gghcijh]jZffu_s_g_kdhevdhmijZ`g_gbc<i_j_^bkj_^bk\_lZb l_g_clhkZ^ykvgZaZ^gb_eZidbbih^gbfZy lhjqdhf mrb lh ^_eZy dhjhldb_ iju`db ^\b]Zeky aZypijh[bjZykv gZ ahehlmx iheygm GZ aZiZ^_ aZ k_ehf k\_lZeh GZ\hklhd_ gZ kbahiuevghc lmq_ gZ^ oe_[Zfb klhyeb ^\_ a_e_ghnbhe_lh\u_ ^m]b <_l_j ^me \kz ihju\bkl__ kuiey [jua]bk yjdha_ezguo ^_j_\v_\ AZ kZ^hf ]^_lh gbadh ]j_f_e lm]hc ]jhf FZebgh\h_[_aemq_ckhegp_k_ehh]jhfgufdjm]hf\ kbamxkmomx fmlv aZ j_dhc aZ iheyfb m`_ ihdjulufb a\_gvyfb dhi_g Ijhlb\ ^\_jb m kl_gu klhye dhfh^djuluc\yaZghckdZl_jlvxKijZ\Z [ueh qmlv [_e_xs__ \ kmfjZd_ ihe_ ihdjulh_ dhigZfbIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijhkljihegh_hkeijbqh[hjhlZfbKe_\Zk lmkdehq_jg_xsboiZr_gk jZ\gbgu^melzieuc \_l_jhd <i_j_^b gZ^ lzfghc dZcfhc e_kZ ih^gbfZeky [hevrhc djZkguc FZjk Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhkljihegh_hkemlhqgyxsh[klB:;mgbgIhju\bkl__Lhjqdhf± gZj_qIh^gbfZydZd"lhjqdhfijbagZd^_ckl\byG_bafIh^gbfZydZd"lhjqdhfK\_lZeh± ]eZ]Qlh^_eZeh"k\_lZehGn± k\_lZlvIhkl ± g_kh\ \ g_i_j_o , kij [_aebqg g_ihkl ± \ baty\gZde\ ijhr\j\ _^qkjjQlh^_eZeh"k\_lZeh IZkfmjguc ^h`^eb\uc ^_gv gZau\g G_[h gZ^he]h aZ\hehdeh lmqZfb g_hijebqg b ^h`^x dhgpZ g_ ij_^\b^blky[_aeGZ^\hj_keydhlvfhdju_]ZedbZ \dhfgZlZokmf_jdbb lZdhc oheh^ gZau\g qlh ohlv i_qb lhib hij_^ebqg ©Jhah\ucqmehdªMljhKd\havev^ygu_djm`_\Zihdju\Zxsb_hdhggu_klzdeZijh[b\Z_lky \ ^_lkdmx yjdbc kheg_qguc k\_l <Zgy fZevqbd e_lr_klbkljb`_guck ghkhfihoh`bfgZim]h\bpmb _]hk_kljZGbgZq_lujzoe_lgyy^_\hqdZdm^jy\Zyimoe_gvdZyfZehjhkeZyg_ihe_lZf ijhkuiZxlky b q_j_a j_r_ldb djh\Zl_c ]ey^yl k_j^blh ^jm]gZ^jm]Z©Kh[ulb_ª>ZqgZyf_klghklvhdmlZggZyghqguffjZdhfGZ^_j_\_gkdhcdhehdhevg_[vzlqZk Ih\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_h^ghkhklg_hijebqgjZkijhkljihegh_ Ijbky`gu_ih\_j_ggu_Dhay\dbgb EZ_\ h[Z \ hlf_gghf gZkljh_gbb b ke_]dZ ihrZlu\Zykv \uoh^yl bae_kmb gZijZ\eyxlkyd ^ZqZf©AZ[em^rb_ªAghcgucb ^mrgucihe^_gvGZg_[_gb h[eZqdZ<u``_ggZykhegp_f ljZ\Z ]ey^bl mgueh [_agZ^z`gh ohlv b [m^_l ^h`^v ghm`_g_a_e_g_lv_c©?]_jvªLboZyZ\]mklh\kdZyghqvK iheyf_^e_gghih^gbfZ_lkylmfZgb fZlh\hc i_e_ghc aZklbeZ_l \kz ^hklmigh_ ^ey]eZaZHk\_szggucemghc wlhl lmfZg ^Zzl \i_qZle_gb_ lh kihdhcgh]h [_kij_^_evgh]hfhjy lh ]jhfZ^ghc [_ehc kl_gu < \ha^mo_ kujh b oheh^gh Mljh_sz^Ze_dh©Fzjl\h_l_ehª Ih^gh\h]h^gbc\_q_jG_eebfheh^Zyb ohjhr_gvdZy^hqvihf_sbdZ]_g_jZeZ^_gvb ghqvf_qlZxsZyh aZfm`_kl\_kb^blm k_[y\ dhfgZl_ b mlhfezggufb ihemaZdjulufb ]eZaZfb ]ey^bl \ a_jdZehHgZ[e_^gZgZijy`_gZb g_ih^\b`gZdZda_jdZeh©A_jdZehªH[s__ h[beb_ gZau\guo ij_^eh`_gbc qlh[u kjZam \\_klb qblZl_ey\ h[klZgh\dmG_^Ze_dh hl JyaZgbgZj_d_Hd__klvklZjbggh_k_ehDhgklZglbgh\hjh^bgZihwlZK_j]_y?k_gbgZ>hf ?k_gbguo l_i_jv a^_kv hldjul fma_c gZoh^blky \ kZfhfp_glj_ DhgklZglbgh\Z i_j_^ k_evkdhc iehsZ^vx Hdheh ^hfZ jZklzlihkZ`_ggucihwlhf\ ]h^mlhihev< i_j_^g_c m ^\_jb klhbl ^_j_\ygguc kmg^mqhd ]^_ ?k_gbg ojZgbe dgb]b ex[bfuo jmkkdbo ihwlh\ b ibkZl_e_c ImrdbgZ E_jfhglh\Z Dhevph\Z =h]hey < fZe_gvdhc k\_lehc ]hjgbp_ jZkiheh`_gghcaZi_j_]hjh^dhc± ^m[h\ucjZkdeZ^ghcklhek j_agufbgh`dZfbaZdhlhjufihwlex[bejZ[hlZlvijb_a`Zy\ DhgklZglbgh\hKijZ\Zhl^hfZ?k_gbguoaZk_evkdhciehsZ^vxkj_^b^_j_\v_\ \b^_g ^\mowlZ`guc ^hf ijbgZ^e_`Z\rbc g_dh]^Z f_klghc ihf_sbp_OhaycdZ_]hEb^byB\Zgh\gZDZrbgZihkem`beZ?k_gbgmijhh[jZahf]_jhbgbihwfu©:ggZKg_]bgZªA^_kv \ DhgklZglbgh\_ hkh[_ggh qm\kl\m_lky ih^ebggh \k_gZjh^gZy ex[h\v d ihwlm Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhkljihegh_hkemlhqgh[kl< l_dkl_ij_h[eZ^Z_lhibkZgb_k we_f_glZfbih\_kl\h\Zgby<k_gZjh^gZyGZoh^blky ± ]eZ]he >hf qlh ^_eZ_l" gZoh^blky G n ± gZoh^blvkyIhkl± g_kh\\g_i_j_o\ha\j,,kijg_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ gZkl\j\ _^qe>hfqlh^_eZ_l"gZoh^blky <hafh`gh h^gbf ba ijhlhlbih\ QZpdh]h ]_jhy [_kkf_jlghcdhf_^bb©=hj_hlmfZªihkem`be^jm]ImrdbgZQZZ^Z_\G_ijZ\ul_qblZl_ebdhlhju_^mfZxlqlhijhh[jZahfI_qhjbgZihkem`bekZfZ\lhj©=_jhygZr_]h\j_f_gbª GZibkZlv Z\lh[bh]jZnbx lsZl_evgh khklZ\eylv ijbfud [b[ebh]jZnbx aZgbfZlvky \ [bheh]bq_kdhf djm`d_kh]ekh[jZlv[hevrmxZm^blhjbxkh]egZagZqblv\ km[[hlmkh\_sZgb_ \ dZ[bg_l_ ^bj_dlhjZ ijh\_klb ijhnkhxagmx dhgn_j_gpbxkh]eih^]hlh\blvdhg]j_kkfbdjh[bheh]h\ba[jZggu_kt_a^hf`mjgZebklh\ij_^k_^Zl_evb ijZ\e_gb_Kh\_sZgb_ ± kh[jZgb_ ^ey ^_eh\h]h jZa]h\hjZ \gmljb dZdhceb[h hj]ZgbaZpbb Dhgn_j_gpby ± kh[jZgb_ ^ey h[f_gZ hiulhfij_^klZ\bl_e_cdZdhclhh^ghcijhn_kkbbbebjh^ZaZgylbcbajZaguof_klh[eZkl_c]hjh^h\kljZgKt_a^± lh`_qlhb dhgn_j_gpbygh^eyijbgylby\Z`guoj_r_gbcaZdhgh\Ih[_^ZWlh\_ebqZcr__kqZklv_^eykhe^ZlZ± khagZgb_lh]h qlh lu ihfh] k\h_fm gZjh^m ih[_^blv \jZ]Z hlklhylv k\h[h^mJh^bgu\_jgmlv_cfbjKhagZgb_lh]hqlhlu\uihegbek\hckhe^Zlkdbc^he]^he]ly`dbcb ij_djZkguc\ur_dhlhjh]hg_lgbq_]hgZa_fe_Ij_^Zgghklv b ex[h\v d k\h_fm gZjh^m d k\h_c hlqbag_ ijhy\bebkv \ [_kqbke_gguo ih^\b]Zo gZ ihe_ [jZgb =_jhyfb klZgh\bebkvfbeebhgu Khe^Zlu klhyeb gZkf_jlv gZ ihke_^gbo jm[_`Zo ]jm^vx[jhkZebkv gZZf[jZamju\jZ`_kdbo^hlh\ezlqbdbb lZgdbklug_aZ^mfu\ZykvrebgZlZjZg=_jhyfb[ueb\k_b l_dlhmklj_feyeky\ZlZdmkd\havkl_guh]gyb l_dlhih^kgZjy^Zfbkljhbefhklub lygmeijh\h^d dhfZg^gufimgdlZfKeZ\Z\ZfgZrbqm^_kgu_ex^b<_ebdZy Hl_q_kl\_ggZy \hcgZ [ueZ \k_gZjh^ghc B ih[_^Z gZ^\jZ]hf lh`_ [ueZ \k_gZjh^ghc :jfby b gZjh^ ijZa^gh\Zeb _z h^ghc^jm`ghck_fvzcB hlwlh]h_sziheg___sz[hevr_[uehgZr_khe^Zlkdh_kqZklv_DDJhdhkkh\kdbcGZ ihe_ [jZgb ± gZ ihe_ [hy \h_gguo ^_ckl\bc Klhyeb gZkf_jlv± kjZ`Zebkvg_`Ze_yk\h_c`bagbHkgh\gZyfukevl_dklZ± _^bgkl\hgZr_]hgZjh^Z\ [hjv[_aZhk\h[h`^_gb_Jh^bgu_]h]_jhbaf;_kqbke_gguoMklj_feyeky ± ]eZ] Dlh qlh ^_eZe" mklj_feyeky G n ± mklj_feylvkyIhkl± g_kh\\g_i_j_o\ha\j,kijg_ihkl± \ baty\gZde\ijhr\j\ fj_^qDlhqlh^_eZe"mklj_feyeky=jm^vx= ± >]@± kh]ea\l\J ± >j@± kh]ea\l\M ± >m@± ]eZkgm^> ± >^¶@± kh]ea\fy]dV ± g_h[haga\mdZX ± >c@± kh]ea\fy]d>m@± ]eZkg[_am^[a\>bZeh]iZfylgbdh\IZfylgbdb`_jl\Zf\hcgub ]_jhyfIh[_^uBofgh]h± m gZk\kljZg_ \ jZaguo dhgpZo fbjZ Bgh]^Z fg_ dZ`_lky qlh y keurmdZd \ lbrbg_ ghq_c dZf_ggufb b [jhgah\ufb ]hehkZfb hgb \_^mlkljh]mx b lhj`_kl\_ggmx [_k_^m f_`^m kh[hc i_j_debqdm keZ\ukdhj[bb ]hj_klbJh^bgZfZlv g_hlju\gh kfhljbl gZ gZ^]jh[by iZ\rbo ^_l_ck\hbo\ lbrbg_IbkdZjz\kdh]h[jZlkdh]hdeZ^[bsZ=b]Zglkdb_ ebdb khe^Zl i_j_ehfb\rbo oh^ \hcgu \ kjZ`_gbbgZ<he]_keh\ghijhjZklZxlkd\havkdehgukl_igh]hFZfZ_\Zdmj]ZgZlZfgZ^rbjvx\_ebdhcjmkkdhcj_dbY g_ agZx kdhevdh bo fhgmf_glh\ keZ\u b ih[_^u m gZk \kljZg_ b aZ _z ij_^_eZfb Ghkd\havrmfb [b_gb_lhj`_kl\mxs_c`bagb ^h qmldh]h moZ ^hoh^bl ohj bo ]hehkh\ gZihfbgZxsbo hijhrehfIhEMki_gkdhfmKlbev ± im[ebpbklbq_kdbc p_ev ± \ha^_ckl\b_ gZ qblZl_eykj_^kl\Z± wfhpbhgZevghhdjZr_ggu_keh\Zh[jZagu_\ujZ`_gby Ih^]hlh\dZd khqbg_gbx ?kebkeh\ZZ\lhjZg_jZaju\Zxlijyfmxj_qv :©Iª:©Iª:©I"ª©Iª± Z©Iª± Z©I"ª± Z,,?kebkeh\ZZ\lhjZjZaju\Zxlijyfmxj_qvI± Z± iªI"± Z± IªI± Z± Iª mklgh , FheqZgb_ gZjmrbe wlhl g_ba\_klguc ijhbag_ky gbadbfly`zeuf]hehkhfb k bghkljZggufZdp_glhfke_^mxsb_keh\Z©>h[juc ^_gv kbfiZlbqg_crbc Kl_iZg ;h]^Zgh\bqª ;me] BghkljZg_p hldbgmeky gZ kibgdm kdZf_cdb b kijhkbe ^Z`_ ijb\ba]gm\ hl ex[hiulkl\Z ©<u Zl_bklu"ª ;me] ©>Z fu Zl_bkluª ± meu[Zykv hl\_lbe ;_jebha Z ;_a^hfguc ih^mfZe jZkk_j^b\rbkv ©<hl ijbp_ibeky aZ]jZgbqguc ]mkvª ;me] <heh^y`fmjykvihkfhlj_egZk\hcihieZ\hdihlhfh]eygmekyb g_m\_j_ggh kijhkbe ©: qlh fh`_l ju[Z \ ^jm]hc [hqZ] mclb"ª DZa ©Ykgh_^_eh± aeh[ghhl\_lbeYrdZ± lZ khj\ZeZkvb \k_ojZkim]ZeZª DZa ©Y ^mfZx qlh a^_kv ^he`_g hklZlvky fZljhk @mojZc ± kdZaZe ?jfZq_gdh ih^oh^y d klhem ± <hi_j\uo@mojZcbaa^_rgbo f_kl \h\lhjuo hg ke_kZjv b fhglzj kfh`_l mkljhblvkyjZ[hlZlv gZ klZgpbb Ihfh_fm wlh kZfuc ih^oh^ysbc q_eh\_dªGH,,©Kdhjhfhkl± \_k_ehkdZaZeAm_\± Z lZfb AZ[hjv_Fh`gh kdZaZlv ijbrebª ©Ihc^zfl_ ih [_j_]m ± kdZaZe y ± fh`_l[ulv gZldgzfky gZ eh^dmª ©Klhc ± \^jm] kdZaZe =Zc^Zj ± QlhwlhlZdh_\hglZfaZdmklhf"ª©Qlhlu_klvaZq_eh\_d"± kijhkbe=Zc^Zj ± IjbagZ\Zckyª ©>Z \_^v wlh rdheZ ± jZ^hklgh kdZaZerhnzj± Lmlmqbl_evgbpZ`b\zlªDIZmklh\kdbc,,, ©: ihq_fm fg_ _oZlv \ijZ\h" ± kijhkbe yfsbd k g_m^h\hevkl\b_f± =^_lu\b^brv^hjh]m"ª©Ihfbemc[ZlxrdZIzlj:g^j_bq ± kdZaZe KZ\_evbq ± aZq_f _fm l\hc aZyqbc lmemi"ª ©Ijhrm g_ mfgbqZlv ± kdZaZe y k\h_fm ^y^vd_ ± K_cqZk g_kbkx^Z lmemiª©KemrZc<ZkbebkZ?]hjh\gZ± hl\_qZemjy^gbd±g_ ihf_klblv eb _]h [eZ]hjh^b_ d B\Zgm Ihe_`Z_\m"ª ©DZd <Zfm]h^gh± kdZaZeB\ZgB]gZlvbq± ^_eZcl_dZdjZamf__l_ª©Kf_eZebFZrZ"± hl\_qZeZ_z fZlv± G_lFZrZljmkboZª©GmfZlmrdZ ± \hajZabe B\Zg Dmavfbq± hklZ\Zckyih`ZemcdheblugZdj_ihklv gZrm gZ^__rvkyª ©IhkemrZcl_ B\Zg Dmavfbq ± kdZaZe y dhf_g^Zglm ± ^he] gZr ± aZsbsZlv dj_ihklv ^h ihke_^g_]hgZr_]h ba^uoZgbyª ©<hl y \Zk ± aZdjbqZe B\Zg Dmavfbq ± J_[ylZklj_eycª:KImrdbgIjb\ba]gm\jZ^hklghmqbl_evgbpZJZkk_j^b\rbkv± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ^__ijbqZklb_Ih^mfZedZd"jZkk_j^b\rbkvGn± jZkk_j^blvkyKh\\g_bafIh^mfZedZd"jZkk_j^b\rbkv©Ijboh^bl_\_q_jhf± ij_^eh`belj_g_j± \ ieZ\Zl_evguc [Zkk_cgª hij_^ebqg ©;hevghc qm\kl\m_l k_[y emqr_ ±kdZaZe ^_`mjguc \jZq ± l_i_jv `bagv _]h hq_\b^gh \g_ hiZkghklbª©<_l_jd mljmmlbog_l± khh[sbebihjZ^bhg_hijebqg± ih]h^Zmemqrblkyª©MqZklgbdbkhj_\gh\ZgbcgZau\g± jZa^ZeZkvdhfZg^Z± Kljhblvky[_aeª©Dm^Zb^zlwlhlZ\lh[mk"±kijhkbeb fum \h^bl_ey± GZfgm`gh\ p_glj]hjh^Z[_aeª MqZkl\h\Zlv \ ^bZeh]_ fhgheh] ]_jhy \ wibeh]_ jhfZgZ \ijheh]_iv_ku± DlhlZdhcwlhlIexrdbg"± kijhkbeQbqbdh\± Fhr_ggbd± hl\_qZeKh[Zd_\bq± LZdhckdjy]ZdZdh]h\hh[jZablvljm^gh< lxjvf_dheh^gbdbemqr_`b\mlq_fhg\k_oex^_ci_j_fhjbe]heh^hf± <ijZ\^m" ± ih^o\Zlbe k mqZklb_f Qbqbdh\ ± B \u ]h\hjbl_qlhm g_]hlhqghex^bmfbjZxl\ [hevrhfdhebq_kl\_"± DZdfmobfjml± G_m`_ebdZdfmob": iha\hevl_kijhkblvdZd^Ze_dh `b\zlhghl\Zk"± < iylb\_jklZo± < iylb \_jklZo ± \hkdebdgme Qbqbdh\ b ^Z`_ ihqm\kl\h\Zeg_[hevrh_k_j^_qgh_[b_gb_G<=h]hev mklghRhnzjlZdkbm\_jyeqlh^h\_a_lgZk^h\hdaZeZaZiylgZ^pZlv fbgml GbgZ kijhkbeZ ih^jm]m ihc^zl eb hgZ k_]h^gy \_q_jhfgZdhgp_jlDhey]h\hjbeqlh_]h[jZljZ[hlZ_lke_kZj_fbgkljmf_glZevsbdhf Mqbl_ev bklhjbb ij_^mij_^be gZk qlh gZ^h[ulvm fma_yjh\gh\ qZkh\ , Ih ml\_j`^_gbyf hq_\b^p_\ g_kqZklguc kemqZc ijhbahrze ih \bg_ i_r_oh^Z Ih khh[s_gbyf ]Za_l \_k_ggbc k_\b^zl mki_rgh Ih fg_gbx mqzguo j_db fh`gh ij_^hojZgblv hlaZ]jyag_gby,, <jZqb kqblZxl qlh dmj_gb_ hkh[_ggh \j_^gh ^ey ez]dbo Ki_pbZebkluml\_j`^Zxlqlhe_kgu_ih`ZjuqZs_\k_]h\hagbdZxlhlg_hklhjh`gh]hh[jZs_gbyk h]gzf,,, Ihfh_fm ohjhrZy dgb]Z ± gZklhysbc ijZa^gbd Y kqblZx qlh ohjhrZy dgb]Z ± gZklhysbc ijZa^gbd ©OhjhrZy dgb]Z ±gZklhysbc ijZa^gbdª ± kdZaZe y [jZlm Ih fg_gbx ikboheh]h\\gbfZl_evgh_ b [ukljh_ ql_gb_ ± hq_gv \Z`guc gZ\ud Ikboheh]bkqblZxl qlh \gbfZl_evgh_ b [ukljh_ ql_gb_ ± hq_gv \Z`guc gZ\ud Ikboheh]b ibrml ©<gbfZl_evgh_ b [ukljh_ ql_gb_ ± hq_gv\Z`gucgZ\udª Hg m^b\beky qlh y ijbr_e lZd jZgh Mqbl_ev h[jZ^h\ZekylhfmqlhfuijbrebgZkm[[hlgbd<blyihjZabekylhfmqlhy lZdfgh]hmki_eijhq_klvFZfZh]hjqbeZkvqlhfug_\ufuebihkm^m Im]Zqz\ kdZaZe =jbgz\m qlh lhl dj_idh i_j_^ gbf \bgh\Zl PZjv ]h\hjbl Dbjb[__\bqm qlh ihklZjZ_lky ihfhqv _]h]hjx =hjh^gbqbc khh[sZ_l qbgh\gbdZf qlh ijb]eZkbe boqlh[u khh[sblv ij_g_ijbylgh_ ba\_klb_ =_jhc jZkkdZaZ ©Ihke_[ZeZªB\Zg<Zkbev_\bqm\_jy_lqlh\ky_]h`bagvi_j_f_gbeZkvhlh^ghcghqbKhdhehl\_qZ_lM`mqlhagZ_lkqZklv_qlhojZ[jh[bekyF=hjvdbchq_gv[_j_`ghhlghkbekyd keh\mHgibkZe©Keh\h ± h^_`^Z \k_o nZdlh\ \k_o fuke_cª F =hjvdbc hq_gv[_j_`gh hlghkbeky d keh\m Hg gZau\Ze _]h ©h^_`^hc \k_o nZdlh\\k_ofuke_cª< i_j\hfij_^eh`_gbbbaj_q_gb_i_j_^Z_lkyiheghklvx ,F=hjvdbckqblZeqlhgm`ghmqblv©wdhghfbbb lhqghklb yaudZª ©KZfuc \_jguc ijbagZd bklbgu ± wlh ijhklhlZ bykghklvª ± ml\_j`^Ze E G Lheklhc E G Lheklhc gZau\Ze g_ykghklvkeh\Z©g_baf_ggufijbagZdhfg_ykghklbfukebª,, ©Kem`blv [u jZ^ ijbkem`b\Zlvky lhrghª ± hl\_qZ_l NZfmkh\mQZpdbc:KImrdbgkhdjmr_gghaZf_qZ_lKm^v[Zex^_cih\kx^mlZ`_=^_[eZ]hlZfm`_gZkljZ`_Bevijhk\_s_gv_bevlbjZg©Bklbgguc\dmkkhklhblg_\ [_ahlqzlghfhl\_j`_gbblZdh]hlh keh\Z lZdh]hlh h[hjhlZgh\ qm\kl\_khjZaf_jghklbb khh[jZaghklbª± lZdh\hfg_gb_\_ebdh]hjmkkdh]hibkZl_eyH k\h_fljZ]bq_kdhfh^bghq_kl\_]h\hjblFE_jfhglh\keh\Zo=ey`mgZ[m^msghklvk [hyagvx=ey`mgZijhreh_k lhkdhcBdZdij_klmigbdi_j_^dZagvxBsmdjm]hf^mrbjh^ghcG:G_djZkh\ijbau\Ze^_yl_e_cdmevlmjuK_cl_jZamfgh_^h[jh_\_qgh_K_cl_KiZkb[h\ZfkdZ`_lk_j^_qgh_JmkkdbcgZjh^NBLxlq_\ijhgbpZl_evghaZf_lbe©MfhfJhkkbxg_ihgylvªB\ZgB\Zguqhkfhlj_ef_gy\ ihke_^gbcjZab \_e_e\uibkZlv ba [hevgbpu Fu ijhklbebkv gh hg hklZ\be fg_ k\hc Z^j_k b\_e_e aZclb ©Lhevdh kfhljb g_ iha`_ ^\Z^pZlh]h ± \_k_eh kdZaZehg± : lh[jZl^hfZg_aZklZg_rvªK maehf\ jmdZoy \ur_eba[hevgbpubijhc^yd\ZjlZeijbk_egZlmf[mM f_gyaZdjm`beZkv]heh\Zghy agZeqlhg_miZ^mY ihijZ\bekyIjhsZc[hevgbpZA^jZ\kl\mcrdheZ< rdhe_ aZ wlb ihe]h^Z ijhbahreb [hevrb_ i_j_f_gu <hi_j\uohgZklZeZ\^\h_f_gvr_qZklvklZjrbodeZkkh\i_j_\_eb\^jm]b_ rdheu <h\lhjuo _z ihdjZkbeb b ih[_ebeb <lj_lvbo aZf_lghh`b\beZkvh[s_kl\_ggZy`bagvKeh\hf\ rdhe_klZeh\ lukyqmjZabgl_j_kg__Ih<DZ\_jbgm Bklbggh gZjh^gh_ ijhba\_^_gb_ eZmj_Zl dhgdmjkZ kdjbiZq_c \hiehlblv \ i_jkhgZ`Zo dhf_^bb kbfnhgbq_kdbc hjd_kljdhgp_jl klZjbgghc blZevygkdhc fmaudb nhevdehjguc ZgkZf[evjZau]jZggu_ \ ehl_j_x \_sb ijhy\blv ih^ebggh_ fm`_kl\h m\Z`Zlv q_eh\_q_kdh_ ^hklhbgkl\h g_ijbdhkgh\_gghklv q_eh\_q_kdhcebqghklb aZdj_ie_ggu_ \ dhgklblmpbb ijZ\Z b h[yaZgghklb ]jZ`^ZgbgZ ojZgblv j_ebd\bb <_ebdhc Hl_q_kl\_gghc \hcgu aZf_qZl_evgu_ iZfylgbdb Zjobl_dlmju ^hklhijbf_qZl_evghklb jh^gh]hdjZyGZrZmqbl_evgbpZk \hklhj]hf]h\hjbeZdZdb_\ I_l_j[mj]_aZf_qZl_evgu_ iZfylgbdb Zjobl_dlmju ©BamqZcl_ ^hklhijbf_qZl_evghklbjh^gh]hdjZyª± \hkdebdgmek_^h\eZkuc mq_guc MjZ]Zgguc \_l_j ijbekms kh]eZkh\Zgb_ `blv gZ\afhjv_ ]ekms mijZ\e_gb_ ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv gZ fblbg]_]ekms k ij_^e jZ[hlZlv \_kehf ]ekms ijbgbfZlv j_ahexpbx ]ekms ]jhfdh Zieh^bjh\Zlv gZj]eijbfudZgb_m_oZlve_qblvky]egn ]eijbfudijZ\bevghbgnhjfbjh\ZlvgZj]eijbfudjZ[hlZlvgZkljhcd_]ekmsk ij_^ejbkh\Zlv ieZdZl ]ekms gh\uc ^bj_dlhj ijbekms kh]e q_jlblv lmrvx ]ekms ihclb lj_gbjh\Zlvky ]e gn ]e ijbfud aZgbfZlvky kihjlhf ]ekms ijhlb\hiheh`gh_ fg_gb_ijbekmskh]e ;_kihdhblvky h kug_ ± lj_\h`blvky aZ kugZ ^hjh`blv\gbfZgb_f± p_gblv\gbfZgb_ih^_eblvky\i_qZle_gb_f± jZkkdZaZlv h \i_qZle_gbb ij_^mij_^blv h ijhkqzl_ ± ij_^hkl_j_qv hlijhkq_lZFZlv kbevgh [_kihdhbeZkv h kug_G_lj_\h`vkyaZkugZk gbfg_kemqblkygbq_]hkljZrgh]hY k_e gZdZfgbb klZekfhlj_lv \ fhj_<^jm]ke_\Zhlf_gyjZa^Zebkv ]jhfdb_ djbdb DZdb_lh ex^b m\b^_eb g_ba\_klgh_ `b\hlgh_@b\hlgh_ hdZaZehkv [hevrbfhkvfbgh]hfHg [ueihoh` gZh]jhfguc f_rhd HdjZkdZ _]h [ueZ dZdh]hlh kljZggh]h p\_lZIh\_kl\ g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijhkljiheg HgZ ihklhygghf_gyeZkvdZaZeZkv lhkbg_\Zlha_ezghclhba`_elZk_jhcIh<D:jk_gv_\m=jhfdb_ djbdb ijbekms kh]eZkh\Zgb_ jZa^Zebkv ke_\Z]egZj ijbfudZgb_ jZa^Zebkv \^jm] ]egZj ijbfudZgb_ke_\Zhlf_gygZjf_klijbfudZgb_ IjZ\^hih^h[b_ iheh`_gbc b ijZ\^Z ^bZeh]Z ± \hl gZklhysb_aZdhgu ljZ]_^bbIIhcfZlv _jrZbebhdmgy± wlhlZdh_[eZ`_gkl\hQE_k ± ij_djZkgh_\ujZ`_gb_kbeuijbjh^ub kZfucykguch[jZaqbd _z kh\_jr_gkl\ZIZmklGZau\gu_=mklhc a_ezguc _evgbd m ^hjh]b]em[hdb_imrbklu_kg_]Z<hlb \_q_j KZehg kZfhezlZ Lm ;_eu_ fy]db_ dj_keZ @mjgZeu b]Za_lugZjZaguoyaudZoHij_^_e_gghebqgu_;m^v keh\m k\h_fm ohaybg dj_idbc <_kzeh]h gjZ\Z g_ dmibrv<_k_e_cdjm`bl_kv^ZfuG_hij_^_e_gghebqgu_< GBBijh\_^mljy^wdki_jbf_glh\;_aebqgu_Km]jh[u gZf_eh \ur_ hdhg K ex[bfhc f_qlhx g_ ohq_lkyk_j^pmjZkklZlvkyG_jZklbljZ\_ihke_hk_gb Ghqv f_^e_ggh l_q_l [_a a\za^ [_a a\mdh\ [_a ^\b`_gbyK_jZnLZc]ZklhyeZ[_afhe\gZyb ihegZylZcguDhjB qbklb lbob yk_gk\h^g_[_k:DL;mjZgdjmlblr\ujy_lkg_]hfb\uk\bklu\Z_l b aZeb\Z_lky `mldbf \h_f Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h^ghj kdZa Rbrd Gbdhklzjgb lzieZyih^klbedZbakhkgh\uo\_lhdg_kiZkZebhlj_adh]hoheh^Z IZmkl Y lh aZkuiZx lh ijh[m`^Zxkv hldju\Zx ]eZaZIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_^\mkhkljZkijhkljihegh_hkeh^ghjkdZaIjbr\<_q_j_ehb lmqbg_lhjZkoh^bebkvg_lhaZoh^bebl_i_jvk ljzoklhjhg;mgJ_[zghd[uelhghdb keZ[ghoh^beb^Z`_[_]Zek\h[h^ghih\k_fm^hfmDhjL_q_l± ]eZ]Ghqvqlh^_eZ_l"l_q_lGn± l_qvIhkl ± g_kh\\ g_i_j_o , kij g_ihkl ± \ baty\gZde \gZkl\j\ e_^qGhqvqlh^_eZ_l"l_q_l;_afhe\gZy ± ijbeZ] KlhyeZ dZdZy" [_afhe\gZy G n ± [_afhe\gucIhkl± dZq_kl\g_ihkl± \ `j_^qBiLZc]Zqlh^_eZeZ"klhyeZ[_afhe\gZy;_]Ze± ]eZ]J_[_ghdqlh^_eZe"[_]ZeGn± [_]ZlvIhkl ± g_kh\\ g_i_j_o , kij g_ihkl ± \ baty\gZde \ijhr\j\ _^qfjJ_[_ghdqlh^_eZe"[_]ZeIh^klbedZ<kz iZoehdmklu ZdZpbbebklvy kbj_gbebklvy kfhjh^bgu p\_lu ljZ\u a_fey ;mg Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h^ghj ih^e_` K h[h[s keh\hf < ljZ\_\ dmklZo dbabeZ b ^bdh]h rbih\gbdZ\ \bgh]jZ^gbdZobgZ^_j_\vyo ± ih\kx^m aZeb\Zebkv pbdZ^uIh\_kl\g_\hkdeijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj ihegh_ hke h^ghj h[klhyl k h[h[skeh\hf D Kj_^b ilbp gZk_dhfuo \ kmohc ljZ\_ ± keh\hf\kx^m qm\kl\h\Zehkv ijb[eb`_gb_ \_kgu :jk Xgu_ ^_j_\pZ\k_o ihjh^ _ev b khkgZ hkbgZ b [_jzaZ ± jZklml ^jm`gh b l_kghIZmklIjb[eb`_gb_>hjh]Z\hreZ\ f_edbc e_kfzjl\ucoheh^guchlemgub jhku ;mg A\mdb fmaudb \_kzeu_ jZ^hklgu_ ^hghkbebkv k[hevrh]h iZjhoh^Z KlZgxd Fgh]h lj_sbg _gZiheg_gguo \h^hx_ h[jZah\Zehkv \ _jZajmrb\r_fky hl kheg_qguo emq_c_ ev^mKFFumlhfezggu_lhevdhd \hkvfbqZkZf\_jgmebkvk hohluIjbr\;hevrb_b g_mdex`b_gZa_fe_Zbklu[uebe_]dbbdjZkb\u \ g_[_ KP >hg_evay ^h\hevguc k\hbf \uklmie_gb_f ^_^ SmdZjv mklZeh himklbeky gZ kdZfvx Rhe F_edbc^h`^vij_^\_klgbdhk_gbdjhibla_fexF=>Zevr_ijhklbjZeZkv imklugy [_kdhg_qgu_ `_elu_ ijhklhju i_kdh\ GZ] MjZgg_]h ]jZqZjZa\_^qbdZ fgh]hoehihlLjh_iKh\j_fzg?jfZdZ jmkkdb_ ex^b h^_j`bfu_ kljZklvx ihagZgby ^\b]Zebkv gZ<hklhd >\b]Zebkv k Pgu]hem[db >_kgudjZkZ\bpu <he]bfZlmrdb =Za <ha\jZsZykv \ lZz`guc ]hjh^hd y ij_^\dmrZeh`b^Z\rb_ f_gy jZ^mrb_ b ]hkl_ijbbfkl\h :dbfh\gu fh_c d\Zjlbjghc ohaycdb = N D gZf kimkdZ_lky B\Zg B\Zgh\bq Lbrdbg Zkljhghf = N E_jfhglh\ijhaZbd ± wlh qm^h wlh lh dq_fm fu ^he`gu klj_fblvky : G L Hg om^h`gbd gbdh]^ZjZgvr_ g_ \b^_elZdh]hjZaghh[jZabydjZkhdIZmklGZ[m]j_[_jzaZk\_qdZ \ emgguo i_jvyok_j_[jZ?k>Z\u^h\ ^he]h [_`Ze_^_j`ZkvaZ]jy^mrdmkZg_c__iulZykvkh]j_lvgh]b_ihlhf \kdhqbe \ kZgbbijblZb\rbkvaZ^j_fZe Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkijhklj iheg hke h^ghjkdZa b ^__ijbq h[ Hg ijhkgmeky hl oheh^Z \ay\r_]h \ lbkdbk_j^p_ b hldju\ ]eZaZ kd\hav [e_smsb_ jZ^m`guf jZaghp\_lv_fke_abgdb m\b^_e oheh^gh_ khegp_ \_ebq_kl\_gguc ijhklhj [_afhe\ghckl_ibk\bgph\hk_jh_g_[hm djhfdb]hjbahglZb gZ[_ehcrZid_dmj]ZgZg_\^Ze_d_± j^ygh`zelmxk h]gbklufhleb\hfebkm EbkZ furdh\ZeZ HgZ klZgh\beZkv \ ^u[db ba\b\Zykv iju]ZeZ\\_jo b ijbiZ^Zy gZ i_j_^gb_ eZiu jueZ bfb hdmlu\Zykv kbyxs_c k_j_[jyghc iuevx Z o\hkl _z fy]dh b ieZ\gh kdhevagm\ eh`bekygZkg_]djZkgufyaudhfieZf_gbFRhehoh\<ay\r_]h± hkh[ZynhjfZ]eZ]heZ± ijbqZklb_Oheh^ZdZdh]h"\ay\r_]hGn± \ay\rbcIhkl± ^_ckl\kh\\ijhr\jg_ihkl± \ fj_^qJiOheh^ZdZdh]h"\ay\r_]h\ lbkdbk_j^p_Kdhevagm\ ± hkh[Zy nhjfZ ]eZ]heZ ± ^__ijbqZklb_ Eh`bekydZd"kdhevagm\Gn± kdhevagmlvKh\\g_bafEh`bekydZd"fy]dhb ieZ\ghkdhevagm\,GbadhgZ^kZfhcfZrbghcdjm`bebkvqZcdb<DZlEmqr_\k_]hgZ[ex^Zlvkd\hjpZjZghmljhf^h\hkoh^ZkhegpZZ^eywlh]hgZ^hb \klZ\ZlvihjZgvr_DK jZ[hlumreb\k_^Z`_^_`mjgucihklZgpbbGH,, Djhf_ q_lujzo km^h\ jmkkdhc wkdZ^ju gZ j_c^_ [ueh g_kdhevdh bghkljZgguo \h_gguo km^h\ KlZjrbc rlmjfZg ©DjZkZ\pZª± j_^dbc ^h[jydg_kfhljygZk\hckmjh\uc\b^Kmlhqgh_ieZ\Zgb_dhj\_lZ[eZ]h^Zjyihimlghfm\_ljm[u\Zehg_f_g__fbevDFKlZgxdh\bq>_`mjgucGbadh± gZj_qDjm`bebkvdZd"gbadhijbagZd^_ckl\byDZq_kl\g_bafDjm`bebkvdZd"gbadhIhjZgvr_ ± gZj_q <klZ\Zlv dh]^Z" ihjZgvr_ ijbagZd ^_ckl\byDZq_kl\kjZ\gblkl_i_gvg_baf<klZ\Zlvdh]^Z"ihjZgvr_< ;9,\_d_gZrbkhhl_q_kl\_ggbdbfZkl_jZqZkh\h]h^_eZklZeb kha^Z\Zlv qZku kh[kl\_gghc dhgkljmdpbb Bo wlbomf_evp_\gZJmkb [uehg_fZehHkh[_ggh yjdbc ke_^ \ jZa\blbb qZkh\h]h ^_eZ hklZ\be lZeZgleb\uc bah[j_lZl_evkZfhmqdZ B\Zg Dmeb[bg mjh`_g_p ]hjh^ZGb`g_]h Gh\]hjh^Z Ihfbfh [Zr_gguo qZkh\ b qZkh\ \ i_jklg_Dmeb[bg kdhgkljmbjh\Ze lZd gZau\Z_fuc ©ieZg_lgucª ijb[hjDjhf_qZkh\fbgmlb k_dmg^qZkuihdZau\Zebb f_kypub ^gbg_^_ebb \j_f_gZ]h^Zb nZauEmgu_AZljZlb\]h^ugZijy`_ggh]hljm^Z_bah[j_lZl_evkha^Zem^b\bl_evgu_qZku\ nhjf_ahehlh]hycpZ_ihjZ`Zxsb_k\hbfaZfukehfb keh`ghklvx f_oZgbafZ_ Hgb [vxl dZ`^uc qZk iheqZkZ b q_l\_jlvqZkZ<h\j_fy[hyhldju\Zxlky^\_jdb\hagbdZ_l^_dhjZpbydjhr_qgu_ nb]mjdb©Zjlbkluª jZau]ju\Zxl p_eh_ ij_^klZ\e_gb__khijh\h`^Zxs__ky fmaudhc_ Wlb qZku Dmeb[bgZ dZd [_kp_ggh_ijhba\_^_gb_ g_ lhevdh l_ogbdb gh b bkdmkkl\Z ojZgylky l_i_jv \WjfblZ`_Ih;JZ^q_gdh <hkvfh]h fZy lukyqZ \hk_fvkhl r_klv^_kyl ^_\ylh]h ]h^ZgZrZ wdki_^bpby gZijZ\beZkv ih k_\_jghfm [_j_]m ha_jZ OZgdZ \[Zkk_cgj_dbKbygow>m[b qzjgZy[_jzaZ± \hlij_h[eZ^Zxsb_ihjh^u^_j_\v_\jZklmsbo\ a^_rgboe_kZo<ijhq_f\klj_qZxlkyb^jm]b_^_j_\vydZdlhyk_gvdezgq_jzfmoZb lhihevb ZdZpbybZ[jbdhk< l_q_gb_ ljzo f_kyp_\ kljZgkl\h\Ze y ih e_kZf ]hjZf b ^hebgZf beb \ eh^d_ ih \h^_ Gbdh]^Z y g_ aZ[m^m ijh\_^_ggh]h a^_kv\j_f_gb>_gvaZ ^gzfijhoh^belh\ wdkdmjkbyolh\ i_j_^\b`_gbyo k f_klZ gZ f_klh Gb ]hju gb j_db gb [hehlZ ± gbqlh g_ hklZgZ\eb\Zeh gZk Y ihevah\Zeky ljhibgdZfb lhevdh ^ey i_j_oh^Z q_j_a]hjgu_i_j_\ZeuZ aZl_fh[udgh\_gghrzegZijyfbdih^hebg_dZdkZfhcj_dblZdb _z[hdh\uoijhlhdh\Ih^h[gu_oh`^_gbygZijyfbd dhg_qgh ^h\hevgh aZljm^gbl_evgu ^ey \vxqguo ehrZ^_cBf ijboh^blky beb i_j_ijZ\eylvky \[jh^ q_j_a [uklju_ j_db bebeZablv q_j_a djmlu_ ]hjgu_ hljh]b beb \yagmlv \ [hehlZo D kqZklvxf_klgu_ehrZ^bmf_xlkijZ\eylvkykh\k_fbg_\a]h^ZfbIhGFIj`_\Zevkdhfm DZaZehkvihke_^gbcemqkhegpZf_^ebemoh^blvbaba[uDhj G_agZdhf_p \b^bfh m^b\beky b gZ _]h ebp_ ihy\behkv\ujZ`_gb_ ^h\_jqb\hc jZ^hklb Dhj Fu j_rbeb ijh^he`ZlvgZrimlv[_aijh\h^gbdZghd \_ebdhcgZr_c^hkZ^_kh\k_fihl_jyebljhim:jkIhkeh\ZfgZrboijh\h^gbdh\j_dZqZklh\uoh^blba[_j_]h\b aZlhiey_le_k:jkYfbeuc^jm]jZkkdZaZe[u\Zfk kZfh]hgZqZeZghbklhjby^ebggZyb lZdZykeh`gZyQ$[dZdhcy gZqZejZkkdZaQ , ± KdZ`bdZ fg_ djZkZ\bpZ ± kijhkbe y ± qlh lu ^_eZeZk_]h^gygZdjh\e_"± : kfhlj_eZhldm^Z\_l_j^m_l± AZq_fl_[_"± Hldm^Z\_l_jhllm^Zb kqZklv_FXE_jfhglh\,,Lhj`_kl\_ggZyqZklvdhgqbeZkvb ]hkl_cijb]eZkbebd klhemJhfZrdZ^h]gZef_gy\ dhjb^hj_± IjZ\^Zij_djZkghijhrzex[be_cB\ZgZIZ\eh\bqZ"± >Zhq_gvohjhrh± < kZfhf ^_e_ `Zev qlh fu lZd j_^dh \klj_qZ_fky <kzlZdbklZju_lh\ZjbsbLu]^_kem`brv"± < ]jZ`^ZgkdhcZ\bZpbb± Wlh y \b`m ± kdZaZe hg b aZkf_yeky ± G_l ©]^_ª \ ^jm]hfkfuke_\ l_jjblhjbZevghf± GZDjZcg_fK_\_j_<DZ\_jbg Lzieuc fZckdbc \_q_j gZ^ G_\hc DZd k\h^ ]b]Zglkdhc jZdh\bgu hleb\Z_l g_`gufb djZkdZfb `_fqm`ghahehlh_ g_[h GZk_jhfdmihe_BkZZdbygZklzdeZog_h[hajbfhcgZ[_j_`ghcb]jZxlh]hgvdb aZdZlZ imjimjgu_ ihehku jZkl_dZxlky \ k_j_[jyghly`zehc \heg_ djZkZ\bpu G_\u H]jhfgZ b ij_djZkgZ i_jki_dlb\Z]hjh^Z Dlh kljhbe ^\_klb iylv^_kyl e_l wlhl fh]mqbc ]hjh^" DlhmdjZrZe_]h"DlhjZ[hlZeg_ihdeZ^Zyjmd"<_kv]_gbcjmkkdh]hgZjh^Z\ujZabekya^_kv\ \_ebdboljm^ZoE_gbg]jZ^g_bf__l^j_\g_cbklhjbbWlhfheh^hcgh\uc]hjh^Hg`b\zl\k_]h^\_klbiylv^_kyle_lGhhglZdfgh]hh[jZaghb [h]Zlhijh`bewlhdhjhldh_\j_fyB hg\_kvihehg[m^msbf GLbohgh\H]hgvdbH ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^= ± >]@± kh]ea\l\H ± >Z@± ]eZkg[_am^G ± >g¶@± kh]ea\fy]dV ± g_h[haga\mdZD ± >d¶@± kh]e]emofy]dB ± >b@± ]eZkgm^[a\>\_klb iylv^_kyl ± qbkebl Kljhbe kdhevdh" ^\_klb iylv^_kyle_lGn± ^\_klbiylv^_kylIhkl± dhebqkhklp_eh_g_ihkl± \ <iKljhbekdhevdh"^\_klbiylv^_kyle_l <hkiblu\Z_l q_eh\_dZ lh qlh kms_kl\m_l _sz ^h _]h jh`^_gby^hfb k_fvy[ebadb_b ^Zevgb_jh^kl\_ggbdbklZjrb_k\_jklgbdb <hkiblu\Z_l \ky `bagv \kz hdjm`Zxs__ <h feZ^_gq_kl\_\hkiblu\Zxl q_eh\_dZ \k_a\mdb\k_aZiZobb p\_lZ\kzih\_^_gb_hdjm`ZxsboI_kgbijbjh^Zb]juGZdhg_ph[jZah\Zgb_b rdheZQ_eh\_d nhjfbjm_lky \hkiblu\Z_lky \kz \j_fy f_gyykv ih^ \ebygb_f hdjm`Zxs_]h ihdZ m g_]h g_ ihy\ey_lky kihkh[ghklv e_iblvkZfh]hk_[yWlZkihkh[ghklvkZfhmkh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgbyy\ghk\yaZgZk djblbq_kdbfhlghr_gb_fd hdjm`Zxs_fmk jZaebq_gb_f^h[jZbaeZ ;u\Zxl ex^b lZd b g_ ijh[m^b\rb_ k\hx kh\_klv [u\Zxl blZdb_dZdE_\Lheklhcdhlhjuc\hkiblu\Zek_[y\kx`bagv^hkZfhckf_jlb< fheh^hf q_eh\_d_ gm`gh [m^blv ij_`^_ \k_]h wlm kihkh[ghklv<;_eh\L_dklijbgZ^e_`bld im[ebpbklbq_kdhfmklbexp_ev± ijbau\\ha^_ckl\b_kj_^kl\Z± wfhpbhgZevghhdjZr_ggu_keh\Zg_ihegu_ij_^eh`_gbyih\lhju mklghK_\_jgZy\_kgZ<_kgZ[_kkihjgh± kZfh_emqr__b kZfh_ihwlbq_kdh_\j_fy]h^Zh q_fibkZghb i_j_ibkZghihwlZfb\k_okljZgb gZjh^h\gh_^\Z eb ]^_gb[m^v \_kgZ lZd ohjhrZ dZd gZ ^Zezdhf ]emohf k_\_j_]^_hgZy\ey_lkyihjZabl_evgufdhgljZklhfkjZ\gbl_evghk kmjh\hcabfhc Ijblhf x`gZy \_kgZ gZklmiZ_l bkih^\hev Z gZ k_\_j_ hgZgZh[hjhlijhba\h^bl[ukljucb klj_fbl_evguci_j_\hjhl\ `bagbijbjh^u K ykgh]h ]hem[h]h g_[Z evxlky ihlhdb `b\hl\hjys_]hk\_lZ a_fey lhjhieb\h \u]hgy_l i_j\mx a_e_gv [e_^gu_ k_\_jgu_p\_lhqdbkf_ehijh[b\Zxlkyq_j_alhgdbckehclZxs_]hkg_]ZH^gbf keh\hf \ ijbjh^_ l\hjblky \_ebdZy lZcgZ h[gh\e_gby b dZ`_lky kZfuc \ha^mo p\_lzl b ex[h\gh ^urbl ij_bkihegyxsbfb_]hkbeZfbIjb[Z\vl_d wlhfmhk\_`zggmx]eygp_\blmxa_e_gvk_\_jgh]h e_kZ \_kzeuc ilbqbc ]Zf b ljm^h\mx \hagx dZdbfb h]eZrZxlkyb \h^Zb e_kb iheyb \ha^moY ex[ex wlhl \_ebdbc fhf_gl \ [_^ghc djZkdZfb b a\mdZfb`bagb k_\_jghc ijbjh^u dh]^Z kf_jlv b ihegh_ hp_i_g_gb_ abfukf_gyxlkydbimqbfbjZ^hklyfbdhjhldh]hk_\_jgh]he_lZ>FZfbgKb[bjydKmjh\Zy± k\bj_iZyaeZy@b\hl\hjysbc± p_e_[guce_q_[guc[eZ]h^ZlgucL\hjblvky± ijhbkoh^blvkh\_jrZlvky.