Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Развитие методического обеспечения учетных процедур XIII-XIV вв. (на примере подлинных бухгалтерских книг средневековых компаний))

lt'i'lli',liirili'i'l:1,'i, i,'r r i.'iiiiiir.t{.r'i? l .'a,ir.rLtia)iiii;]n!;1ri ' . '' lr,I'€reh,{ oJoxcdeJreJx,(ggttvgspboLrvrdorcpr wrrlH€rroYorrccr4/ti., :,,t.!: i t{t r-r.wrHerNr4Hs'ii,l'i!.'ii!lwrqHrrr4xdeqcorrre[',( eH vrvrlcod g rr4Jelforc I4Jhorr I4I4HoxKodx €HrJr..riin1i,r-]i,ii, ,,r, ,'{rer'f 'ft'toxcdeuf€Jx{9 ol ed,{redoJl4lfeH v xlqHHecl{ro vr4rr4stBd oJoHHoI4IIor[ose Fr4frHeYHersxlqHH€ckIuorralrens*ids.z 'soxuHhorcl4os deu etutrcHe xrrofi s ruz oHorsJcolnfcoorr4verrceH,ftnro>tcder{erxr(g'r4r4Jouovorenr 4onrer,r('firuoxcer'radorcz x €doJs€ eznetnedgoqoHnerued:oc YvrHaaodrznrdoQ exore x rcenlnrcoHJo v xaavxde xr4xcHrqrrar;vr sK:??r4lnBHP;dx'I'soxes AIX-111X rsrHer,{r(xoY ersHHzriVou eH rcreedr4rroeHrrreecr(141I'V, giaherdecczV a erenr( uudo:nu eraHenr(e14 'uudol,;cu errqro oJosoxosoJoHryI4lzHpggq:Iioxicl4,'\ii;.iii,t,i,eH HesoHco rer'r( gzxcderrerx,(gurirHHor redao3BllHusotsorccu oJoH Hol{[urdeccuts rswer srcoHq ffefrxy,EXIIJCT4J€JC'renr( 4zxcderrerxfg- zl'00'g0 uJcoHsrezfieuc oIIiii'it,.7:..:,r,,i'xA€H xl4xcohl4l loHoxe eJ.;eYuYrrcx kIHexeJc uoHerrr( er4H€xcl4oc eHL i.,ij'i-i.i.:i9 E' T,EZ'ZI7 ['''-:-:i:l-t_,,.

.',1.:_.,,Jreaoc IarrHHor4[rerdeccpr V s o{fHHersercVedil,((.gg- 111y drftetrodu xrsHreF,( rl4Heherlcego oJoxcenzvorenr er4rgar€d>AIXii ri:r:r 1 ii*,r;rj-ierar4gorrKBxl4tr\lItitlA,ft.rer euenrerdy €HrIie€cfJAJoru[urdaccuE €H BrueHorr[o oJoHqrrurrlru{oslq€Io<<rerzcdeauHKr.rrsHHosrcdeVf cor 4zxcrdr(9dere11-ruH€Yr4HEtaoEEdgoJ)oremcrsalz,:zweYxedr,f, ruonsueresore dgo woHJexVor grroHHesJcdeV,(cor ruonrredeVe6 udu9E T,EZ'ZIT,resoc KrsunozlrerdecczV gY€H oHesoHco euH€soVerccr4{'1i;)!ltF$n€HlJrzdo^i:iliir'llitorg'zr4derrreJxfg goxc4exodseJI4hIZIIJO LI ZICOHdEI IOHOXBT iIJI4grIqArrreBc.(trAl 'IAl.v eroged 4eoac gIsHH,aodurr{nrdo{c .4uttuvHehlo}Iod:r rr :.,-,;r;.ii,r,"1j.;:!11,,."r,.tpY.l,lf3,,..6HIlnelroron xrsHr^,{eH rrrroHnusoHJogo snererJ,rqrNeJ'r roHrrreec{W '14I'Vr4JcoHir[€frxeFonnedger49uoii.itrr?#Heho{IrxetsrereYc rerrostor eoHH€t€)rcemrqg '4zueaoverrccr4s edr(redeJr4rr goHh,(eu HonVodent'[xenlyvtdolrcu rrueds eelnrorcen guuY ynsesoHco ezxogr(rr eerfog retnore{dex reHdesorcov,tresoH rcrer(dznrdoQ.ersrrHradrVedlXVEYI4JOIIszxsodzrxeddoxYCLOEfIT4US€H€ICCOgloiiiit ;e otoHr'{en oroHHerredsoc urarrueou c orormodu.,,.iLrL!iii,clqnienc'scro{fdureduderuz 4eH{} i0)il}cr* l liil i}.s orh 'woJ s'zHeweds vnarcemodu-liT*?QF$,;i"YrH?t!{torr4r{nxenHoy1jJr4orJoc enrreec(tr41i1.tyvqmr4rr xrqHrrHor 'zuHevx,(rrgllI{xQozmo BtI4Ir€H€ I{oxI{HhoJcI4 rzxfirc ex{x€J BHO 'r4xr4HHerlredsocrrJrrrrrrrv'rs.zHeIro.r.;l,lil-.:i,'itliri,gt.1'IsHoocorc I4rlso 14 LrwaLrHefIo €VJecs oH oyereV xrsdorox rravvrrzJcoHXoI rtos ,ererrr(I ifif,lli rllii'.

:xlqHqr€Hurzdo rznevsoc rrqrro oxqroxc orrrxeQerde oxsuorc!,#,gl3yen,1:i4rereVonreH oJeif+,K:q}"uor{}, Ii.,}}l Jq ljt,,ir.r *i:f;j .ri.. ,i,-erer'K vudo;nu orn 're€srsrexov onsrerzvegr( doray,YprYorce\,prt"XlAgirerx{g orosodzru eunesoverccu €H nersedreH oH 'rquedrcl"' lj.Li)1llr i-tr jzwexrnreijr4em€H'ueaznedro eH Ho fxsroxcoil'rzzQudrozdorcz FoHrer,( uoxcKzccodsreHszdr rez(Yerc rxeodl Jore .uzderrerx,(9weI'rHertsr '' Ilus.Hqrexzsr(lou4oaYjlj:i;'i1:j,ii,i",'iruHevxo det, vyouderr-zzfiorroa€ oJe err€Je oJemr4eHx€s^er4Her,K*rrl),ii':iiirrll.'ll'r,. I1i6rOtiicj[sedueH'erer'f oroxcder,rerxr(g uudo.rcu rqrroxm Koxcuegr{x erxeodllltuu'';1:l'ir:\lciroiresretesoYerccz oJomirrog o{irJceh goltioces vcreyual edorse €rog€d,Ir'tr';,'irogcjox'JoJererHlforrcos pIHeleJc goHsrorrrh€Ht s rufrerdecczY renre,{duanetred'u :vlcElrgo 4oJ€ s xorogedeedil.t:i.'1,1:--l:.):.ri,:ixrsHr'r(eH xrirHHesJcoheJo qJcoHhoreJcoyeHl.;'il1),i(..1I {j,i-i"..t-1,.t1.,t,..-'i.t1i1i)ilfi-.;r'i(i'l''rr4H€soverrccrrQ.4l1pI-rgn4l4d[IiiJiil ir'.,1i: '-lewer ou r4r4+€droradorcr4 KoHrehr( Kouneruedqoc1l ',:,'i:.lo,uH€-xdeVoc xnllor€srsdxced omor€slsxder'czxrcH<rr€drx€'rNeJ;.ri.t!i,1:riir)ii.'lr\^ic eJcews 'v soJx€derde'soVfdrxr4xcohr4doJcrrxr4xcohzdoJcrr osJcohuro).i.eq.mqrog.xI4H zved3 'xBxrqrr woxcHerrcu vr woxcs,{frH€dQ 'I^roxcHtrq]ferp\:: il.ia."t 1(Iltro)rccfden vxr'rHhorcr4 xr{ffiofthorffxs 'Hufizeouottoxo oH€s€>lf'ltoxc4tutttrH€00€vvv^:.,.;::i!,.,'rsVozdox ouxcehr4doJcr4jeflHox a NoHHef[eNoII 'IsdKredeJHIrilpoggdii i 7,t" t,',,\excr4rrcg.1setqtteedrij ;lI 'ri';HoHHeVtu 'x€xlqttr xlrlHhzifted €H rsdfrederzr 4oHh^€H weqgovrr4heHa Hoh/(sl4 hroHBlr€ecfnt 'ltt'V sor€IzdeJBr r xrqHsvxde owuruoll.',n'vvHeHil4dll Z BuHo)KesK Jo€gl4xfrceg: : ,;oH€Io[c/(seq V,(dr ruodoJse vra;;vHLrdu[edu Knroreou 'woreuderew NrirJcoduoHt\-iil:lf;!j i::li:l l\., i'::::.:qiloJO oc qJBJog€d IqsoJoJ elsHehf eHJoHI IeH 'Kt'eYet, orfxcsller€sovellccz,.,::.{l.,t,l:,iernNoricfonredx 'soxeg o>IqroxceH €H c€H Jo xl4rrlroJcJo (exlqtr woHH€drcogvj;i.l[1:l:i.'11eHsoJHeI IFxoV..\.:Lii1,,i:eI4H€soYe]f.oLI'oxoneKorre€h{sr4sHr4HeHrou xr4xogfrrJI4 I4rcoaI4hIN,(Vs 'rzuendeJ Je,(gedJ r4w€suxde c erog€d/ u 'rsrrer4derelrr erqHsr4xd€.)i':riil,i'i4"1{i,rlvtraluoYeIIclz s IsH)Korc oxqlfo)Ic€H (Jor€Hs Hxr4dorcr4 orqHqrreHor4cce+odlflir:1.;,r'i1] i.j , !"'I4xl4HhoJcl4ogdeil elqHqlrexzH{ eH rcJe€dl4xoj l,;xeYostqs' xraoscsHrIIeecKtrN't\l'V oJh'qJI4JorrJo eH rrqrreH r4€rsc 4or€ g'44Y+q\1 Hl4Heu'\tox VHoQ vcvrrfvlHoHHosV soxoJcr4 rr4H€soVe[ccr4 vrrYr ''l ' 1",14 ltlqII4HeIri ^il..-ij;:,-jI€HteUCI4h IArOJrIr4r<rrNzrheHq'lrZUeUruOX Xr4XCHrqrI€Jr4 SOVHOQ XISHSHXd€xltHsrexl4Hz( oxqrroxceH IqHehfsl4 I IodoJsV 'H)rr4HhoJcr4 (errHd,ftederHr)ii;r ! ti.3 I.jil.'ti ir;i.vr9nynzfl.o;a',;;.!:t...1r\il.;'..,.x€J'(errHauxde) ersHhuadeilxexHrrr4x(rrcoilenrreecr(141i'l'IAI-V .

wr:tsle8oYerrccr4 Uo€reg HoHHor4frer,rrdoQng 'aoxr4HhoJcr4 xrsl^lefesroilcr4.r ) i'j.*.i,i\." .., . ,^rrB_+Qocy.oJ?rrjgr rlrr4H€rroYe:ilccv xrDrcohndoJcr4 woJHewerfe r rHmr4oHy(€g:ill iii::'iii,'i,,!, 1)r:"r reJcr4c xrirHJeh^ xr4HHed vvt-r4ated r4xrrJorr 4orlovow xrirHHeodJcouorqlfioworr c r4r4Horrrrnrtr v x€Jr4Hx xr4)rcdeJlf€Jxrg a Uecvr]et HzH€sodzreVowsJcoHrrrc 'razderllerxfg 4o.JcodilsrrcJ.o€horrx€r Bvoxvou oJoHH€trs wercr4c xrrHJehrBu'Lwstpd Vozdeuiryurrroh.*sueco.onoduxr4HH€d yr4Hvssdr4HounxH{Q er.rreun€xowa FrirHHerrodvwdoQc'aorxeQ xuxcer'rldoJcl4 oruHeso[errccz)r Vox,trloil 4r4xcdorse Hox{o[Vedu wereJ€xcl4oc t4IIe[ HoHHerrs€Jcou KI4He)KZrcoVIIIX c - exos esY reesrsJ€sxo:r.Y',Arx.orr4xexr4Hhor." xrcHgnxde xrsudumgoii,:.

i: i,''l:.1 \,,r I t,,;I,li1.1,1i,ii'ri.i'rit,li'lirrri-j'',;,ll:,lr"i._.1',11i,i,,1,t,",'..il.;,';i.;.,r)iij:i . inwr 'xtrqreJc tl s :I4l4ccod rax{eudgoHzhl r rrr4HesogodrQ{ ,, ISojro)I.r,.ix4Fqrryd.osJollsoVf 'xvvtteYttr 14 xertaHd(x xrsHr.r(en xrswe,(dzsuened xztnfVes s.].''.1,]ii.;il.i'l:HalggTjllPf{9 rlrerexcl4ocr4LrnerdeccraVrqrersr{sed ersHr.,(eH orsHsoHco'(3urpe14 lenuuv uorlprcossy BurlunoccyItp,ti{p.+tV),,-ep,n4 oroxcderlreJx,(g I{eroresoverccz zrztrez[occ€ Koxcuexrader,rryfll{i.+,Ilgg?,99,o11- 4ouvoden,(vxey4 '(ecueroJuoJ Ieuor}eure1u1 ,fto1sr11 Eurlunoccy),fuo1Srg Sutlunoccv htolrend,(x foruer(evuerdo 'zzlrnedeQnoxHonvodeur(VNey41'(suetro1st11 Eununoccvj.,.--.go sse-rEuoJ plro4\) erer,f oroxcdeurerx,(g soxzdorcv,.eccedrn,ox wosodntrAl :wosJcetngooc lrrsuF'(en tnrrssodzrN xrqHHBHrudtt e'cuh worsi'ef;ol4dell oJeHJeIrI{JrrI oI4HoheJ."1': l i , r;.f+53,?,T,,9,,1s xr[[rHedeQnox xrsHa.(eH xrsH[odenr(vxewso+..lrs ,(sed xl4xcehrrrxedu r4 xr4xcehuredoer xrsHsoHco zzfiegodne9o quneYeac uu\terdecczV 6 'drc €H xrqHHersercVe du uutteaoHco €H sJZHeno' .

. , ...re,(Verc rzHesoverccr4 sorersrfsed srcoHdesorco[,91,,1,T,13*-4;Torrgrr.:,, ,r,,r,,ur,ri,:),t:.')'.:.:.$,.,,,,$9Fo"t"ti'i''unfiurdeccuV s xlcHHuaodurfndo{c 64urruVueruoxed.lluuevsorou xrsHr.fuH urcondesorco[ cHotrorJ {!r''l'''ii:i r::.1tr..,tr,,t,',,:1.,;,'rzHegoVolfccrl oronneVesodx gorersrr(eed.r;i,.itij; ,iiii,i4t'IJcoHHegoHcogo I4HorreJc I4oxoclqso VoarsssrerreEcrerrorrrox ore ocg'zr4HBrIr rox xr4xcHrsrIa lkr.xlqsoxosenVedc erer''{ oroxcderrerxr(gra zHelned€r eHs 4rzneyx{c----rr KeJcoHHegocottl;j\'i;i.l tl^)reexcz(IroV eH dorse htor€ ud11 'erer',(T,1T55,.",,qP1ooroxcderrelxfgnrc.outnz(cvuHeYua oJoHHoIAIedsoc 14 vuulated.t.l , tiiii,qonrenr( rvHroJcocvtt;,1ttE{eui,; :',.).'i.lt,;; ;,ii .

^ 1,.XIsHL{ tZ.!rr4 xeJ-nxnefiorri[tullr.rr4rorrovororroe x€uere xrsHHereVeduorraVoxca 'ererr,{ oJosoxesenVedc aoVorewnrodoJae xrqwer(esroucu 'goluerufrde unrercra3, ,' ,,,' , ,,,,4oIrhK€H.euwteec(I4l.141.Vr4JcoHJcosocodgotro lodarcsrereYzsc ogJcqroJrorcgo oJe 14 soregodx reu rsdr{rederurs oJh 'qr€texcoxeuilcwudot'nuororsJcoHHedesKc oHx(otrAl 'uude;;uetxr(g goaoxeseHVedcrrrneaoVe:rtl,cv errnxegr(deez "oH 'woI4HBHt'14'rrrsHF'r(eHl{rsnsrer(rxevezxc4zccod rrJceHJooc Jerrroaro11c edorae ogJcwoxgHtrer(dudrcnolteYK:ae9'orfircsreresoVerccu t,:eydumced oxsror oH rsd,(rederurr HoHHedrcoHr4iii;'li.ir,.K"qI,?"._,?hl+QedrTVi,j}r{iri_;:,i.j..?,1"\' -r..,.Lr gorcodrr ,,([Nenr rrere 4tsur,orfxenrodrtt*r9,fr4,3'9#nSrtlii?-r.-.9rslN14E 'rzderrerxfo€IreIIu Iazderrerxr(g goaoxeseHVedc vr4lrtre:€ftd euere NonneV/Z,EI-062) rluerle^eJ oddrpg ressotr l ererixfgwoHrrr€Hocde11e{oc 'xlqusev '('-t-t v8T,r-8Lzi p}esses ec olr}uoc r4r.rHpx}\rg}}fri.r1:qr.; ,iql). *"orog vol oroxxodg-H€J exdendr eH soduxH€g xraxcKzruedorQi-,.j:)lt\lilr'rov xlsHszxde utuuBHe osoHco €H '(68-01 'drc) rrer€xor doray .I'dftrelrodIf 14Uacvxeg'goVotew xlqHHogrcernr(c oJe I4I4HeIfgrIqsi':,,,r"r':ir'uvt$,rcJ'pli4osoxosesVedcit:iiV^;""uAotifos erer'r( oroxcdeurerxr(g yur;uam,d kr>rLrrNaHkrye1r4rfgHewlqHhoJ€rcov s)vrrr4sy (aourenl(uov xrsHa uxde r4wyr4H1sodrar'trrzrzdo I4I uqHHercl4hoJoHrrxrsrueevxosodrocv soxHr(czd"rrexc'Isrdzdereru elqHHer',trio11 'soxesgr{H€xr^ro) xtrxcHrarrenLlit1qF,AIX-IIXoxcderlferxfg xedrczred a wereF.c ox Kecr{[€t xrirHr er,K uu\rcrr4J€r rercr4c:P,",."f]s ced ..'uuYrxr{druroxed ou ,ftoged orr(murog rr4Hrorrqs doraytr'riii;r.ii''r:''1:uunerdercuv aorerslf,,( ed uHe[gon runrr{u11'i"lil:ril-'", :tj,i ' {i,i,luit.l "i1,.1 {,,' ,.i.

ij'llllIiiil'\iiI ii'|{l1', ; ;'r,^''src oHdeaorc oV orf ur.oreredrueVosrss w r trl4Hexororl;esrOonr'urgfll oxx€J'"i ;l . rr'.nrrsHrrreHcoy uuyterdeccilvrorevzdu gorersrr(eed'Uu\rcxuttg(tt xrsHrrfeH vr ererzderenrorongl4xdezznegoEerccz worresVeduen €H lroHH€aoHco ,uvt\ter;rretrrfrde'iii.'ilIL,'.eriezdeter,rr oronnerrr(avr srcoHdumgo ,l,toeudgor rr4xeJ.r,i;ili:)r'.iit,H..arttr-tt-ttjr, ..r."'f'ezHeneudll',uttut'KttorlKrlHexoror::;ncl,-rqit : ,:,lqJcoHHearcelngo Yeut'Kes rexodram rcqJr4r rox€Hto irJcoHxor rrosi,\-t:nzlerdeccuY I4IAIKLIHexo[ox zrurlHgoHco c oJh 'qlzr,orrrxee oHXoI Ir'"": l.. '\,'ii,lAurrex4119r(u oruao dKu fwes,go 'exzrelror e)Kx€r B 'utnetreyedu ee ee fi rsHudrc4emP4; xvudotmY(e xrsHF'feHs Kunerufrcrsa r4JcoHHerrctrhoJoHr r ollerersrfaed s xrsHHer'frol'aoVoarqs eznetngogo'aoxrauhoJcr4..,,,, ,.r$F,BsoVelfccz.-i l'i'xlsHszxde orznesoVerccl4 ou Vfdr vprHJorroJoHr r ror€xedro edorse zrafiexrargr(11;.tdorg ,; ecuelcs Jo qo,/K "q,,; ,,€ v,,"r"^rio""nro",'xuuneytra xrsHr-,r(BH xr:rHxegKdee.4zneaoVelfccI4 xrsHHoz[terdecczV gorersrr(aed zzlexurgfu/rIJ[ .