Отзыв на автореферат 9 (Развитие методического обеспечения учетных процедур XIII-XIV вв. (на примере подлинных бухгалтерских книг средневековых компаний))

B coser rro 3arrlr4Te AoK:topcKr4xAarcKrrx 4zccepraqufiLr KaHAr4-n2n.%2.36Bflerep 6yp rc rco rrafocyAapcTBeHHOMyHprBepcvrere, 19 I 123,r. Canrr-llerep6ypr,C aurcr-yn. r{afiroBcKoro, A. 62, aya. 501OT3bIBHa aBTopecpepar ALIccepraIlzn MycasJurHa<<PasBrdrueMeroAaqecKoro o6ecne.reHrrrApreua MzxafinoBnqa)rqerHbrx lpoqeAyp XIHa reMyII-XIVss.(.Ha npurraepe[oAnI{HHbrx 6yxranrepcKLD( KHkrr cpeAHeBeKoBbrx xoulanufi)>,rlpeAcraBrrerilrofi Ha collcKaHne f{euofi creueHLI KaHAr4Aara gKor{oMlrqecK}rx HayKIror crenu4€LtrbHocrpr 08.CtO.12- <<By>t:r.aJrrepcKuityter, craracrLrKa))PeQopunpoBaHLre 6yxra-rrrepcKoroy{era,p€r3Br.rrue MexrAyHapoAHbrx craH-AApTOB, Q'OBrgP[reHcTBOBaHUe )aqe'rHbrx MeroAkrK r,r nporleAyp 3aoTaBJlrror rroHoBoMY B:lrunllyrb Ha I4crorcn 6yxralrepwr4.

Cero4nx KaK HtrKorAa B4111Hoo6pa-TlITbct K Mcrcllpull craHoBlt:eHu;flupa3Bkrrus 6anancoBoro o6o6rqenutr, yBprAerbpeuleHlle ooEpeMeHHbIX npor6reM qepe3 npI,I3My MHoroBeKoeofi prcropr4r4.O4nrarvr .H3 IrpzopLITerHbIX HarlpaBneuuiiTepoKoro 'f{eTaI4cc.[eAOBaHLreu 6lxranrepcr<ofis AalrnefirueM p€r3Brlzz 6yxran-orr{erHocrpr cneAyer rrptr3HzlTb BcecropoHHeeero ocHoB, Irpe)KAe Bcero, -- yHurpaSz.recrzxll4zrpa$uqecKlrxf{erHhIX Iltpc}IleAyp. VqnThraafi Ba;KHocrb srofo HanpaBneaprfl, Akrcceprarl}roHHoelloc.|IeAoBarrae Mycasnxna A.M", ilpeAcraBJurerc-f, oqeHb cBoeBpr3MeHHhrM 14 aKTy€uIblIhrM.naKTy€urbHocrb sasnreHgofiKoropoe BbrloJrHeHo B paMKaxn.

1.4 <<Vlcropux p€BBr{TLrsCrcagaunoe [oAqepKuBaer cBoeBpeMeHHocrbTeM-6I r'tccJren;oltalJvt',MerlcAoJIorpII4, Teopupr Lr opraHr.{3arynu 6yxt'a-rrrepcKoroaJlbrrocrl4)rera> Jllacnopra clequ-BAK P@ no cner[LlaJlbHocrlr 08.00.12 - <ElxraJrrepcKuirylrn, ararrr-CTLIICa)).Aaropcltrt eMKO Lr KollKperno c$opMynprpoBaHa rleJrbtBn{Tb 3aKoHoMepHocrLI r,r orJrl4qBrreJrbHbre oco6ennocrl4ooeolreqelJlnfl k\ )rlIerHbIX [lpol{eAypr,rccJreAoBap1g1flp€T3BLITLLTI-B6r-MeroAnrrecKoroB rrpoqecce QynrcqrEor{prpoBaHr{r npocrofi6yxranrepuz, Soprr'rzpoBaHprfl crarrrqecrcofi nao4errvrnc.liucJreHrir.f, Qznancoaorope3ynbrara.cozcxareneM Ll3rreHbrI/t [poaHaJrLt3rrpoBaHhrrefi ) reilrofi r'rpo@eccuu KaK oreqecrBeHHbrx,HE]FIO I{CCNCAOBAHI.IE TIOAJILIHHTTX 6YXTATTTEPCKLIXTaKrpyAhr B]rAHhrx npeAcraBr{Te-u zapy6excrbrx rrrKoJr, BhrrroJr-KHKI|XIII_XIVSE..{ocronepHocrb rroryqeHHhrx cor4cKareJreM pe3ynbraroB He Bhr3bIBaeT coMHeI{I{.f, B cBt3}r c reM' qro Bce aBTopcKZe npeAJrox(eHurlgMnLrpnqeocHoBaHhrHacKrrx AaHHbrx' anpo6zpoBaHbr a yre6no-MeroAr4rrecKoM rrpoqecce,MHoroKparHo/4orsraAblBall4cb Ha Me)KAyHapoAHbrx xonSepeHllkIrrx, ony6nzroBaHEr BoreqecrseHHofi z sapy6exnofi ne'{arvI, B ToM qkr Jre B Lr3AauuflxWeb ofScience u ScopusLI peKoMeHAoEaHHErx BAK pO.,{uccep:rarlr4rr BbrnorHeHa Ha BbIcoKoM TeopernqecKoM Lr npaKTLrrrecKoMypc)BHe, BCe 3arqrllllaeMbre rroJro)KeHus noJIHo r{ rreTKoapryMeHTkrpoBaHhr, pe3ynb_TaThr lrccneAoB AHU* COAep)KaT HeoclopLtMyro HarrHyroHoBLr3Hyu npaKrrrqecKyro3HaqpIMocrb' Anroporra o6o6rqeH LI KpurzqecKr4 [poaHaJrLr3LrpoBaHo6urzpnufiTEOPCTUqCCTZffi N IIPAKTA'IEAKUfi MATEPI{€IJI IIO TEMELICCJIEAOB Af{KIfl,B .rzcne nara6ouee 3HarrlrMbrx [oJDnreHHbrxcJleAyerBhrAeJrBITb yCTaHOBJIeHTIeaBTopoM Ha]^{Hhrx pe3ynbraroBcBfl3a MelKAy HeAocrarKoM rreKannofi MoHerbr14perxlcrpaqzefi ,qonroBblx o6ssarerbcrB; o6napyxeHr4e o4nofiLt3 paHHLrx KHLr;.,npeAHa3HaqeHxIbIX AJUI p erucrparln a Hecrr creMHbrx3arrLt cefi ; 4OXaS arenbcrBa p aBHonpaBHocrr'n cqera co6cteeHHl{Ka }r cqeroBApyrux 4e6zropoB z KpeAr4ToponTpe:rblfx JrIrrI; Bbrf,BJreHrre MeroAoB r{crrprcJreuut$uuancoBoro pe3yJrbrara B cpeAHeB r3KoBofi 6yxnan r epuLr lr,n,pyrue.AnropeQepar, rrMeer qerKyro ror'rqecK).,o crpyKTypy, B HeMrrocJre,rloBa_T€JrrrHo paccMarprltB€uorcs reoperuqecKLle LI MerOAOrOruqecKuIeacrreKTbr reMhrLTCCJIE.4OBAITI,ufl.Cocrae lr coAepx(aHkre nydnzxaquit cnu(ereJrbcrByror o roM, qrooHLr uoJrHOCTEIO COOTBeTclRyrcT ocxrotsHbrM rra) rHbrMnoJroxreHurrM ArrccepTarILtoHHOrOkrccJreAoBalJn_fl.llorq^rsHHbre HayqHble pe3yJr'Tarbr ptccJreAoBa,,ufrA€rror ocHoBaHrde [oJra-rarE' qro a pa6ote penerrbraKTyaJrbHBreBolpocEr pa3Bprrufr MeroALlqecKoroo6ecue.reHr['I yHl4rpaQauecrcnxrrerHbrx rrporleAyp,c o6ocnosaHueM anropcroftKoHr{elqun QopuzpoBaHllf, Lr pa3BLrrnj[ MeroAr4qecKoroo6ecne.re Hufl krMexaHr43ua Qynxqrlor{HpoBa Hufl paHnr4xfrerHbrx cr4creM..{ocr<xepHocrE Har{Hr;rx pe3ynbraroB noArBepxAaercx arpo6 a+ueftB BbrcrJ/nneHLrrrxHa sapy6exu.srx 14 HauuoH€urbHbrxKoHrpeccaxnpaKTl4qecKax xoH0epenr\krflx, ny6nzrcaqlrefi uarepz€uroBBnHar{Ho_occzficrczx u 3apy-OEX(HbIX VIailAH.LI'^X.B rlenou,noJIo)KLITeJrbrIo oI{eHLrB€urpa6ory, neo6xo4r.ruo odpar}rrbI{I4e Ha SopuynzpoBKy rr4llore3bl ((pa3Br4rr4{BHLTMa-yrernofi rpaKrLrKu npocrofi 6yxran-repul{ s XIm-XV sB.)) (c' 3 anropeSepara) LI3 Koropofi ne BrronHercHo, r4Aerperrb o pa3BurLtr4 KaK TaKoBoM, :-l.u6o o ero onpeAeneHHhrxHarnpaBneHuflxnr4(npu_HaKax, xapaKTeprrcrrlKax pr r.

n.).3 SJTeMeHTOB HarrHHOBrr3Hbr aBTopoM yKa3brBaeTc,octHapyx(eHLIe o21Hoft LI3 caMErxpaHHa rlaM.f,rHbrx KHLrr) (c. 7 anrope6epara),AEIaKo, Ha r{aru B3rJr.f,A, c rorrKr{ 3peHr4, 6yxralrepcKoro y.re aBaxreH He croJrEKoOOH|IPYXTEHI{' KHU|A (XOTXI'IHOe Ha3rraqeHr4e,LI OH LIMEETHEM€IJIOBAXHOC 3HAqEHHE),ACCKoropoe 6rrno ycraHoBneHo corlcKareJreM.BrroraganHhre 3aMeqaHuiI He cHrDKaK)T ypoBeHb rrpoBeAeHHoro,rccJre.rloBa-HlIt, Koropoe coorBercrByer rpe6onanulM,rlpeAb.flBnrreMrrrvrBaHnfl LI HayKr{ P@ rc KaHAlIrarcKrrMALlcceprardzlrM BE]AK Mzuo6pa^:o-u. 8 flono)r{eHr{rr o nop.f,AKeIlpucyxtAeHllfl freHbIX creuenefi.

Myca"ansn A.M. 3acnyxuBaerrrpr4cyxAeHr,rryrenoficrr3rIeHLI KaHAEAara eKoHoMuqecKr4x HayK rro crreqll€urbHocra0g.00.12Eyxranrepcrcrnfi )irrer, cr arucrar:ra.KacnzHa P.f., /[.3.H., npoQeccop Brrcurefi rurconrr 6zsHecaOfAOyBO<KasaHcKnil (llpneonxcxuil) OeAepaaunurfi yHhBepcrrer))K0l't,IH Y0T]\ru CIAgE-.