Отзыв на автореферат 5 (Развитие методического обеспечения учетных процедур XIII-XIV вв. (на примере подлинных бухгалтерских книг средневековых компаний))

OT3bIBHa aemoperfuepam duccepmat4uu MycaotnHa Apmeua<P a3 sLtruLtenpww€1euemo dwtect<o?oo 6 ecneueHun€ n o d nuu u utx 6y x z an m ep c KuxKHMtnqilnoruua Ha mey4yyHemHbtx npoqe dypuz cp e d u e e e Ko 6 btxxiii-xivrco un auee.uil)(ua>t,l,tpedcma+neuttoil Ha coLtcKaHue yqeHoil cmeneuu rcaududama gKoHoA4uttecKLtx HayKna' cneL?tanbHocmu 08.00.l2B-ByxearmepcKuil yuem, cmamucmuKa(loBpeMeHHbIX ycJIoEI4sx, KorAa na6nro4aercx AocraroqHo 6rrcrpoepa3iBI4TPIe 3KOHOMI4KI4I4 ee rfuuanconoro ceKTopa, Bo3Hr4Kaer Heo6xoArzMocrbMoAz$zrtil]lakr f{erHbrx cr4creM, rpe6yroqux paspa6orrucoBpeMeHHbrxyuuSuqzpoBalrHblx Sopna SuuaHcoeofi or.{erHocTlr, Koropbre MorJrrr 6rr crarr,oOqenpI43iHaHHbIMI4, rroHtrHbnMraAnr rxr4poKoro Kpyra rronb3oBarelefi.

B cnssu cyveruofi leopllu l4 ee I4crol)vIr, HanpaBneHHbrfi, gaclaHOBrIeFII4ttuBblf,BJreHr,re 3aKoHoMepuocrefipa3Bl4Trre MeroAurrecKoro o6ecneqeuras MexaHrI3MoBf{erHbrx cr4creM 14 vrx yr{erHbrx upoqe4yp. 14lro:rToMy oI{ ilpl4ooperaer HeManoBa}KHoe 3HarleHr4e B QB'3rl C OTCyTCTBHeMBdryrrrqraoHl4pollaHl4t paHHLIXTerteHI4e .IJII,t.TeJrbHOfO BpeMeHr{ AOCTyrra K cooTBeTcTByrolqur M MexAyHapoAHbrMnclopuqecKr4M $oH4avr,K pe3ynbraraMHeETO3MOX{HOCTV rrplrHflTld.'x yLrACTLrflHCCn eAOBlrccJlenoBawufr 3arranHbrx KoJrJrerLrB MaCrXTaOHbrX MeXAyHapOAHbrX apXUBHbrXAtHpIfl)( IdCT OpkILr.3rorcleopl{T o roM, rqro, Borrpocbr reHe3llca 6yxralrepcKoro yrrera Ao cr4xnop KoMn"[el(c1{o He u3yrlelrbl, a [peAnafaeMoe Alrcceprar{voHHoe rzccneAoBalJLre,oplztel{Tl4poBilH.Hoe Ha u3yqeHr4e rrcTopr4qecKofo orrbrTa pa3BllTrrflpaHHI4xcla uflx efocraHoBJneHu-sefo MoAelefi saB KoHTeKcre B3arzMocBr3r4 6yxrallepcKr4xr4Ha npl4pa[IeHr4e :nanUfi B ClSlacrrEucropzireoKrrx ero acuei<ros.

B eBfl3u c orr{M, 3acny)KrzBaerSI{OHOMI4qTOCKHX AOKTpr4H,HailpaEneHOTeoperuqecKlrxuBxtr{MaHI4s BE,II{Br4r{yrafl aBTopoM, rl4rrore3a pe3Brr'wrfl6yxranrepuu; B XnII-XV se..y.rernofi ilpaKTr4Kr4 upocrofiOua Aana Bo3Mo)KHocrb eMy cSoprr,rynr4poBarbBAi4ccepTa\r4r4. pflA BbTBOAOE, IIO3BOLf,IOIIII4X BOCTTOIHI{Tb HeAOCTaTOT{HOCTb pflI.aSarcron reopl4ld u traropLru 6yxratrepcKoro yr{erazonpeAeJruTb HanpaBneHr{e Hapia:pa6orKy oorBpeMeHHbIX yqe'rHbrx cr4creM, oprreHTLrpoBaHHbrx Ha Aocrr4xeHr4ee4Ianoo6pa:lu vconocraBr{Mocrr4 $unanconofi orr{erHoc'ul4,Me)KAyHapoArrclM, TaK14HaKaKHaHaurzroHuurbHoM ypoBHe.B nu4y rolo, qro AiIHrIoe I4ccJIeAoBaHr4e r4MeerI4cropr4r{ecKrle acrreKTblxapaKTep:acrvrr:lr 6yxranrepoKor'o yr{era, nooroMy K ero Aocror4HcrBy, rro HarxeMyMFIeHraro,cneAyer orHecrrzr, @yu4anaeHT€urbHyro HcrorrHzKoByroI4(lcJIeAoBan288r{ux 10 zcropnqecKrrxucror{Hr{K:oB, r436*y.r4croqHrlKoBAnropBBr{AeSolorconrzrf cpeAHeBeKoBbrx yrrerHbrx KoMrrJreKcoB kr3 apxrrBoB @nopeuqzu,flparo 14 6ra6rnoreru I\dedicea Laurenziana Bo @lopenquz.nJ0z.BJIer{eHHr,IX HcroqHkIKonl o6.ua,4aerrlenocrHocrbrorrocraBJreHHbrx.

I4ccneAoBaTeJrr,cKr4x 3aAarr"pa6olytsrrrrBJleHrrro 3aKoHorropa3lBvrTl1rflAocraroqeEAn.a peueHr4snogeoJrrrJro npoBecrLr cepbe3Hyroepuocrefi kr orJrzrrlrreJlbHbrx oco6euuocrefiMeroAr4rrecKoro odecne.{eHu-sSyHr<qraoHnpotsaHx{.f,3ror4Korrannercv yqerHbrx nporleAyp Bnpoqeccenpocrofi 6yxranrep:zra, SopvzpoBaHvrfl clarr4r{ecKofi uo4ervru(lrll4cJreHvtn'$vruaucoBoro Fre3ynbrara.Kponae'roro BalKHo, Fra Harrruc[orrb3oBaHueM o6rqeuayrHbrxr40[orlByeT MeToAoJlofr4rorrB3rJr-f,A,orMerrrrb, r{To HapflAycucropr4qecKr4x MeroAoB r,rccneAoBaHkrfl. aBTopl4ccneAoBaHvrfl. SKoHoMI{rIecKr4xkrcoIII4anbHbIXAr4crlr4rrnuu.

Oco6oe BHr4Mar{He i} r4caneAoBaHr4r4 yAerreHo MeroAy KoMrrbrorepHofipeKoHcTpyKIII4I/I yLIeTHbIX cI4cT'eM, paspa6oraHHoMy poccuficr<unau f{eHbIMI{.3trclyxzneLel Blu:zv.aHvrfl [pn rzHTep[perar\r4v I4cror{HI4KoB, orpaxarorqrrxorpeAeneHHyro Ae-f,TenbHoclbatpv6ytueHrrfiKOrrOp5lfi,KaHaJrprg, rronr]^{zBlrlvtit. npuzuaHkre BC0nrarreHr4ro,o6uleuayrr,rrix,nwnert, npunaenreltufr Borer{ecreeuuofi nrlTeparype, HoHe o'rpax{eH AHccepraHToM B anropeQepare HLr BHr4 B r4cropr4irecKr4xMeroAax. llpunreneHpre urppr6yrunHoro MeroAaI4MC)ET BAXHOE 3HAI{CHI4E ANfl, AIiANI43A CPEAHCBEKOBbIXcloco6I4ccneAoBaHr4r4crn'ye:l 6 one e uy6 ox oMyn oHr4M aHvrro3T{CTHbIX KOMIIJIEKCOB, T.K.aKo HoMepnoocor6ensocre.ii pa:lBvrrvrfl Merc,Iu4qecr(oro o6ecneqeHkrfrvcrefi M o'r Irkrqr4TeJIbHbIXy{erHbIX npoileAyprrpoqecce rSylxquoHrrpoBaHrrq cpeAHeBeKoBbIX rounanzfi.B[ouoJIHeHI4eurpv1yTuEiHclfl0 aHaJrr43a cpaBrrareJrbHbrM MeTo.4oM rroMofJro aBTopy ycnerxHoBocco3Aar.b o6beKTr4BHyro pearnbHocrbrro3BoJrr4Jrorlofre'rHofi npanrur<u XInI-XIV en.

Bce sroAlrocepraHTy cAeJra'Tb rrHT'epecHble HaxoAxIa c$opvryJll,IpoBarb BbIBoAbIpa3Bl4Trarcr rvroToAr4rlecKoroo6ecle.IeHl{f,){eTHbIXilepBbrx yrrerFrbrx cr4creMuuSoprrraquu 'r'oJrbKolJlpilrruuer]K]4l{cpeAHeBeKoBb-f,.B pa6ore BbIBoA, o roM,Tarc,, Brl3blBaer r,rHlepec, cAenaunrrfiHa3Har{eHr4elpoqeAypSuroHanpaBneHoHar{ToSopuupoBaHl4eo cocloqHr4r4 pacrreroB c Ae6raropaMll vr KpeAr{TopaMI,I.ceroAHq orr4 sJreMeHTbr $zuauconbrx I{HarpyMeHToB tBJlarorc.f,sraxcHefiultuu o6leKTaMI,I 6y><rarrepcKoro yqera, KoHTponfl LI 3KoHoMl4r{ecKoroatFraJrrr3a.'Iarxe Aocrarorrto uHTepecHaBbrrBJreHHafl ilpvluraHa Bo3HI4KHoBeHI4.flIO.r.rroBbIX o6-s:iarertrcrn (r<ar rtaccl{BHbrx r4 aKTlzBurtx), cBt3ar{Hafl c HeAocrarKoM.reKannofi rdoHerbr B nepr4oA peHeccaHca oKoHoMHKI4 (c.6).

O4naro,Bc'oBpeMeHuoffi znrepnperarlIara SyxranrepcKoro 6ata:r'ca AoJIroBr,Ie o6.qsarerbcrBa,no-BrrAkrM,cuy, Soree roqHo ur4euru$nlll4poBarb roJIbKo KaK rIaccI{EHbIe.3ac;rynznaerBHLrMaHr4fl, AoKa3aHHoeHa peaIIbHbIX npuMepax orKpblTueneFlBeHcrBa rpr4MeHentrfl. cr4creMHbrx ganucefi B KHI4re Recordanze (1363r.), r.e.llaqoru (1494), rcoroprrfionHcariAono-rrBne',HvrflKHrrryc'rpaKTara o or{erax vr 3ailvcflx JI.no4o6nrrru Ha3rlaHrreM, KaK rIpeAHa3Har{eHHyIo p'nfl HecI{creMHbIXzitnuceit, To e)crb He r4Mer()rqyro curcreMHblx cn.f,sefi c 6yxralrepcKl,lM yreroM.(<;.14).Kar nu4norr3 aBrope$epara, n pa6ore noKa3aHbr 3HarleHrae Meuopr4ana,uecr6xo4zruoro Anltt nepBz.{Hofi perucrpar\krkr ar4creMHblx sanl4ceu I4 rroAnex<allll4xnepeHocy n f'raauyro KHrrfy,T'arxer4MexaHrr3Ma ero BbIAeneHI4q Iae Recordanze.Bbr3.brBaer I4H'repec Kpl4Tr4r{ecKatoIIeHKa, rlpoBeAeHHafl.

Ha ocHoBeAeraJrbHoro vr:tyqeHurs. paHHrTX KHI4I r<ounanrafiolFrocr{TeJrbrro AeneHr4flfraenoft KHIrrI4 HaO. [aruuu B4lBa pa3Aena:AeuuroHe,crreron 4eSHropon ucqeroB KpeAr4Topon. Cne4yer corJracvrrbes. c MHeHI4eM aBTopa o roM, qro Ha oAHo{ru3uuecx,ce vrnkr ropvAr4qecKoe nzqo rorAa onHoBpeMeHHo orKpblBanprcb ABacqera: 4e6uropct<oit. u KpeArlTopcrofi 3aAonxeHHocrl4, noroMy r{ToB nporI4BHoMcryqae 6rrlo 5rr He Bo3MoxHo opraHl43oBarb KoHTponb 3apacr{erHblMl4oreparluqr\4r,r.focra:ro,rHo 3Haql{uclfi, Ha Halrr B3fJIrA, flBrrflercfl orIeHKa rpe6onanuit rcBeAeHr{ro paHr{vx KHr4f rreT,a rro ABzxeHr4ro HaJrl{qHbrxAeHe}KHbrx cpeAcTB.flpanznruo o'Meqaer aBTop, rrro 3acnyxI4BaerKOTOpOMy 3arrl4cLrorroKarloJlonteHr4e, cofJlacHoHiuII4r{HOCTr4, 3apefIrcrpl4poBaHHbrekrfl,uBury€urr,H{) pa3Hocunr4cb Elnpzxo4)BHLTMaHLTfl<uscitu(B pacxoA), n roB Meltopzale,BpeM.f, KaK B <Entrata>rrepeHocr{Jrr4cb HAKOIIJIEHHbIE AAHHbIC IIOCTYTIICHI4.S HAU4qHbIX[ONH.SMuJrlr 3a HecrKo,JrbKo .unefi.

o6re4r.ruxrcilrve HecKoJrbKo crpaHr4qMeuopvana. Tar<ofifIO,AxoA na(rrno4ae'raflu B coBpetreHHoMAoKyMeHTaJrbHoM o$opnaneur4r4 H€urrzrrHbrxIe)HexHbIX cpeAcrB, HarIpI4Mep e 6anr<ax, rAe npl4MeH-f,rorc-q ropa3Ao 6olee crporr4enpaBl{na oQopuleHl{l BhrAaqI{ ltaJll4qHbrx cpeAcrB, rro cpaBHeHr4roc ux npr4xoAoM.Brtsbrearor raK)Ke I4Hlepec BbuIBJreHHbIe MeroA br Lrcrrr4clrelrLrflSuuancoeorope3ynbrara' npl'4Me)H-f,eMble B cpe,AHeBeroBofi 6yxranreprau.

CneAyetcorJracr4TbctcIl-prIBeAeHIrbIMI4 AOKa3areJIbcrBaMr4 aBTOpaBTOM,qroMeroA pacrleraSznauconoro pe3ynbrara, Irpl4MeHf,enarrfi n 4nofiuofi 6yxranrepuv, ocnoeaHHrrfiHa rlo[ocrlaBJleHl4rr rlonf{eHHrlx AoxoAoB u o6ecnequBlrrr4x Lrx pacxoAoBI4CTIOJIb3OBZIHI4eMcCleIII{alE,HbIX Cr{eroB (troKynKr4 Lr [poAa)Kr4 TOBapOB),npuueuxevltil B HeKoropblxcrarllr{ecKafi MoAenbefoI4Mylr{ecrBa, 4eSzropcrofiKoMrIaHH.f,x,6ur 6oree [porpeccr4BHbrM, qeMv}rrnclre]ts'hrfl, OCHOBaHHa-fluHAr4HBeHTapu3ar\kruKpeAl4Topct<ofi 3aAon)KeHHocrr4, rrpr4MeHseMaflMHOI'I4MI{ Apyt-'vr]Mll KOMlaHI4j[Mr{ B TeqeHve HecKonbKr4x rIocJIeAy}otrIHXcronerzfi.SroT BbIBoli 6rrn c4ela.', cyl.fl ITo aBTope$epary, Ha ocHoBe AerzlJrbHoro arr€urr{3ayqerFIbIX IvIeroAI{K LrC.ilrcneHr4fr Szuanconoro pe3ynbrara, nprlMeHrreMbrxBKoMilaHr4-rrx {x. @aponz (1299-1300rr.),{enn Eene (131g- r324rc.),rc)u(136t5-I410 m.), roroprrfi rroKa3arr krxHeAn6epru4erm l{xyAr4qe (1302-1329oTMeTI4Tb,q:fococTaBJIeHI4K) rOlOeofirrpoBoleHr4_s uHBeHTapu3ar\krn4@pauvecr<oflaruvu e AsuHroHer4AeHTnqHocrb.llp"3ToM BaxHoOTTIeTHOCTZ npeAlxecTByeT STarrBcex ctateit Salawca, T.e.

cBn3b MeronvqecKzx[ollxoAoB {roplrzpoBaHnfl yqernblx rroKa3a'renefi npocJrexr4Baeror cKBo3bO4,na.r<o )KaLlIE,, qro kr3 an'rope$epara HeAocraroqHo BrrAHbrBbrBo4aMI4, AAenaHHbIMr4B Ar4CCepTarIr4r{ vr coBpeMeHHbrMr4BeKa.ar)fl3r4 Me)KAyHarrpaBnelJprfll.{upa3pa6orKl4 6yxralrepcKrlx clrcreM Lr r4x MoAenr4poBaHLrfl.HaIloJIHeHa coBpeMeHHbIMuI Karerop[rr v'kr vr noKa3hrBaer,Xors rlcnpa6otarrro QyHrcqzonupyrorqrafiB Hacrotqee tspeMx 6yxra-rrrepcnufi yrler rlMeer cepbe3Hyro MeroAonorrlqecKyroocHoBy14,HecMorpr Ha 3HarII4TeJrbHbIe ero MoALr$uraqzz, f,BJr-flercs saxHefirxefi3KoHoMllrlr:crofr nayrofi co oBoI4Mu cnequ$r4qecKrlMr4 npeAMeroMVxarasnuer4 MeroAaMr4.3aMeqaHlzrq ruoc.sr peKoMeHAarenrrrrrfi xapaKTep kr He yMoJrrrorHayqHoro 3Har{eHllf, BblrloJrHeuuofi pa6oru.