Vershilo_otz (Виды судебных юрисдикций сравнительно-правовой и исторический подход)

B .n;HccepTa11;i10HHblH coBeT.D: 501.002.20, C03.D:aHHblH Ha 6a3eMocKoBcKoro rocy.n;apcTBeHHoroYHHBepcHTeTa HM. M.B. JloMoHocoBaOT3LIBoqrnI.J;mUII>HOroonnoHeHTaHa.n;HccepTaI.J;HIOllieBeilbKO.lJ:MHTPIDIAneKCaH.n;pOBHlla Ha TeMY: «0co6eHHOCTH npaBOBoro perynHpOBaHIDI pacxo.n;Hl>IXo6.sl3aTenI>CTB cy6oeKTOB PoccHlicKoli <t>e.n;epaI.J:HH B ycnoBIDIX nporpaMMHoro6IO.n;)l{'.eTa»,npe.n;cTaBneHII)'IOIOpH.n;HtieCKHXHayKnoHaCOHCKaHHecneI.J;HailbHOCTH:yqeHOHCTeneHH12.00.04 -KaH.n;H.n;aTa<1>HHaHCOBOenpaBO,HanoroBoe npaBo, 6IO.n;)l{'.eTHoe npaBo):(HccepTaI.J;HOHHruI pa6oTa .lJ:.A.llieBeilbKO HanHCaHa Ha aKTYMI>HYIO TeMy.Byc11osIDix<t>e.n;epaI.J;HHcpopMHposaHIDI6IO.n;)l{'.eToBnporpaMMHO-I.J;eneBbIM6IO.n;)l{'.eTHoliMeTO.D:OM,acHcTeMI>ITaK)l{'.eBPoccHlicKoiiCOOTBeTCTBHHcnpHHI.J;HnaMH ee e.n;HHCTBa, O.D:HOH H3 HaH6onee Ba)l{'.HbIX 3a.n;aq, CTOHI.I.J:HX nepe.n;HaIIIHM rocy.n;apCTBOM Ha COBpeMeHHOM HCTOpHqecKOM 3Tane pa3BHTHH, HBilHeTCHnOBblIIIeHHe ypoBHH npaBOBOro perynHpOBaHIDI OCHOBononaraIOI.I.J:HX HHCTHTYTOB6IO.n;)l{'.eTHOro npaBa.IlepBooqepe.n;Hl>IM nOHHTHeM no OTHOIIIeHHIO K nnaHHpOBaHHIO pacxo.n;oB6IO.n;)l{'.eTa BI>ICTYnaIOT pacxo.n;HI>Ie o6H3aTenI>CTBa.

B.n;ecpHI.J:HTOB6IO.n;)l{'.eToBcy6oeKTOBPoccHHCKOHycnoBIDIX cnO)l{'.HBIIIHXCH<t>e.n;epaI.J:HHHeo6xo.n;HMOCTI>nOBblIIIeHIDI 6IO.n;)l{'.eTHOH .D:HCI.J;HnilHHbI, a TaIOKe COBeprneHCTBOBaHHe npaBOBOfOperynHpoBaHIDIpacxo.n;HhIXo6H3aTenI>CTBBI>IXO.D:HTHanepBI>IHnnaH.BCOOTBeTCTBHH c npHHHTbIMH pacxo.n;Hl>IMH o6H3aTeill>CTBaMH npoHCXO.D:HT OI.J;eHKa6IO.n;)l{'.eTHI>IX accHrHoBaHHH Ha HX BI>monHeHHe. B HaIIIH .D:HH Bee qaI.I.J:e 3ByqaT2rrpH3.bIB.bI IIOB.bICHT.b 3cpcpeKTHBHOCT.b pacxo.n;oB 6IO)l;)l(eTOB coCTOpOH.bI, KaKrocy.n;apcTBeHHhIX .n;e.srTene:H:, TaK M co cTopoHbI HayqHoro coo6mecTBa.

11cxo.n;.sr M3TaKHX rrpe.n;rrochIJIOK, 3cpcpeKTMBHOCTh pacxo,n;oB 6IO,n;)l(eToB MO)KeT crpoMThC.SI, BTOMql{CJie,MHaOCHOBeOQeHKMpe3yJihTaTOBMCIIOJIHeHM.SIpacxo,n;HhIXofoI3aTeJibCTB.BCB.SI3Ho6ocHOBaHHbIXc3TMMB03HHKaeTrrpe,n;JIO)KeHMH,Heo6xo,n;MMOCThHarrpaBJieHHbIXHaBh1pa60TKHHayqHoCOBeprneHCTBOBaHMeMexaHM3Ma IIJiaHMpoBaHM.SI pacxo,n;HhIX o6.sr3aTeJihCTB, a TaK)Ke MX MCIIOJIHeHM.SI.,[(MccepTaQM.SI o6na.n;aeT HayqHOHMCCJie,n;oBaTeJIHBOIIpOCbI6IO,n;)l(eTHOropaccMorpeHM.SIpaccMorpeHMeHXHarrpaBaMHCTMTyTaypoBHeHOBM3HOH.,[(o HaCTo.srmero BpeMeHMHeo60CHOBaHHOpacXO,lJ;HbIXcy6oeKTao6xo,n;MJIHCbo6.sr3aTeJibCTB.PoccMHCKOHCTOpOHOHTipM<I>e.n;epaQHM3TOMBrrepBbierrpoBo,n;MTC.SI B .n;aHHOH ,n;MccepTaQMOHHOH pa6oTe.

HecoMHeHHhIM .n;ocTOMHCTBOMpa60Tbl c Toqm 3peHM.SI HayqHOH HOBM3Hbl .SIBJI.SieTC.SI rrpoBe,n;eHHe paccMorpeHMerrpaBoBoro perynMpoBaHM.SI pacxo,n;HhIX o6.sr3aTeJibCTB cy6oeKTOB PoccMifcKoif<I>e.n;epaQHH BO B3aMMOCB.SI3aHHOH CMCTeMe: IIJiaHMpOBaHMe -3aKOHO,lJ;aTeJibHOeyTBep)K,n;eHMe - rocy.n;apcTBeHHhIH cpMHaHCOBhIH ay,n;MT (KoHrponh).Oco6oro BHMMaHM.SI, Ha Harn B3rJI.SI,n;, 3acJiy)KMBaeT BhICKa3aHHa.SI,[(.A.IlleBeJibKO M,n;e.sr coBeprneHCTBOBaHM.SI 3aKoHo,n;aTeJihCTBa cy6oeKTOB PoccMHCKOH<I>e.n;epaQMMrryTeMrrpMH.SITM.SIMO,n;eJibHOro3aKOHa«06OCHOBaxOQeHKH3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH 6IO,n;)l(eTHhIX pacxo,n;oB cy6oeKTa PoccMHCKOH <I>e.n;epaQMM»138 - 141). B(C.TO )Ke BpeM.SI XOTeJIOCb 601 o6paTMTb BHHMaHMe aBTOpa Ha TO, 1ITOIIOKa e,n;HHbIX rro.n;xo,n;oB K OQCHKe 3cpcpeKTMBHOCTH pacxo.n;oB 6IO,n;)KeTa, a TaK)KepacXO,lJ;HbIXo6.sr3aTeJibCTBHeCJIO)KMJIOCbHMBHayqHOHccpepe,HMB3aKoHo,n;aTeJihCTBe cy6oeKTOB PoccMHCKOH <I>e.n;epaQMM.TaK)Ke aBTop BhICKa3bIBaeT o6ocHoBaHHbie rrpe,n;JIO)KCHM.SI oKOHTPOJihHO-cIJ:eTHhIXopraHOB.n;orroJIHMTeJihHhIMM rronHoMoqM.SJ:MMcy6oeKTOBPoccMHCKOH(C.

148 - 150).Ha.n;eneHMM<I>e.n;epaQMHKpaliHe aKTYaJihHhIMM MBa)KHblMM c TeopeT:H:qeCKOH T01IKH 3peHM.SI rrpe,n;cTaBJI.SIIOTC.SI paccy)K,n;eHM.SI aBTOpaoHeo6xo,n;MMOCTMorrpe.n;eneHM.SIpacxo,n;Horoo6.sr3aTeJibCTBa1Iepe3rro,n;TMII3rry6mfYIHoro o6.s13aTeJibCTBa (C.orrpe~eJieHHH rrapJiaMeHTCKoro26 - 35); 06KOHTPOIDI 3a pacxo~HbIMH o6.sl3aTeJibCTBaMH (C.MbICJib0Heo6xo~HMOCTH6IO~)l(eTHOHcoxpaHeHIDIHa164 - 168). HHTepecHa TaIOKeCOBpeMeHHOM:narrepa3BHTIDICHCTeMbI orrpe~eIDIIOIIJ;HH poJIH <l>e~epaJibHOro Ka3Haqeif CTBa BHCIIOJIHeHHH pacxo~HbIX 06.s13aTeJibCTBe H B KOHTPOJie 3a HHMH (C.118 - 120,c.

185 - 188). ,l(.A. IlleBeJibKO HCCJie~oBaHbI H rrpo6JieMHbie BOIIpOCbI, Cml3aHHbieBttyTPeHHHM rocy~apcTBeHHhIM qrnHaHCOBbIM KOHTPOJieM. TpeTMI rJiaBa B CB513H c3THM rrpH~aeT pa6oTe 3aBeprneHHbIH BM~, a BbIBO~bI, ccpopMY1IHpOBaHHbie B Heli,HMeIOT cym;ecTBeHHOeTeopeT~eCKOeH rrpaKTHqecKoe 3HaqeHHe.HeJib351 He OTMeTHTh aKTYaJII>HOCTh rroJio)l(eHHH aBTopa, BhIHOCHMhIX Ha3am;Hzy. Cpe~H HHX TPe6yeT oco6oro BHHMaHH.sI rrpe~JIO)l(eHIDI aBTopa nocoBeprneHCTBOBaHHIO 3aKoHo~aTeJibCTBa cy6oeKTOB PoccHHCKOH <l>e~epau;HH.CoBeprneHCTBOBaHHe cpopMbI peecTPa pacxo~HbIX 06.s13aTeJihCTB cy6oeKTOBPoccHlicKoli <l>e~epau;HH rryTeM OTPa)l(eHIDI B Heli rrJiaHHpyeMoro pe3yJioTaTa rrpHHCIIOJIHeHHHpacxo~HbIXrrepcrreKTHBeco3~acT06.s13aTeJibCTB,6a3y~JUI6e3yCJIOBHO,~aJII>Helirnerocpe~HecpoqHoliBpa3BHTIDIrrporpaMMHoro6IO~)l(enrpoBaHIDI B cy6oeKTax PoccHlicKoli <l>e~epau;HH.Cy6oeKTbIPoccHlicKoli<l>e~epau;HHMoryTB351Tb3aocHoByrrpHHOpMOTBopqecTBe rrpe~JIO)l(eHHbIH aBTOpOM MO~eJibHbIH 3aKOH «06 OCHOBaxou;eHKH 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH pacxo~oB 6IO~)l(eTa cy6oeKTa PoccHHCKOH <l>e~epau;HH».IlpHH.sITIDIcy6oeKTaMHPoccHHCKOH<l>e~epau;HH3aKoHa06ou;eHKe3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH pacxo~OB COOTBeTCTByeT HX IIOJIHOMOqIDIM, a TaIOKe II03BOJIHTIIOBbICHTb KaqeCTBO 6IO~)l(eTHOH ~HCIJ;HIIJIHHbI B perHOHax.HeJih351 TaIOKe He 3aMeTHTh, Ba)l(HOCTb orrpe~eJieHIDI IIOH5ITHIO pacxo~Horo06.s13aTeJibCTBa cy6oeKTa PoccHHCKOH <l>e~epau;HH ~JI51 HayKH cpHHaHcoBoro H6IO~)l(eTHoro rrpaBa.

EIO~)l(eTHbIH Ko~eKc PoccHHCKOH <l>e~epau;HH B cTaTI>e6orrpe~eIDieT IIOH5ITHe pacxo~Horo 06.s13aTeJibCTBa, KOTopoe .sIBJI5IeTc.s1 e~HHbIM ~JI51Bcex6IO~)l(eToB6IO~)l(eTHOHCHCTeMI>IPoccHHCKOH<l>e~epau;HH.CaMOCTO.sITeJII>Hoe orrpe~eJieHHe IIOH5ITIDI Ha ypoBHe cy6oeKTa PoccHlicKolir4<f>e):(epau:HH B u:eJIOM HBJUieTCH Pa.3YMHbIM ):(JIH cosepmeHCTBOBaHHH HHCTHTyTapaCXO):(H:OIX o6H3aTeJI:OCTB B <l>HHaHCOBOM npaBe.C<l>opMHpoBaHHaHo6H3aTeJI:OCTB):(HccepTaHTOMcy6neKTOBCJIO)KHBIDHeCHBcHcTeMaPoccHMCKOMHayqHOMc<l>epeKJiaccH<l>HKaU:HH<f>e):(epau:HHno,ll;XO,ll;blKpacxo,ll;HbIXcHcTeMaTH3HpoBarraBbl,ll;erremnopa.3HbIXTHnOBpacxo,ll;H:OIX o6H3aTerr:ocTB.

Onpe,ll;eJieHHO TaKaH KJiaccH<l>HKaU:HH HanpaBJieHa HaBbl):(eJieHHe cyru;ecTBeHHbIX npH3HaKOB pacXO):(HbIX o6H3aTeJI:OCTB H HX ):(eikTBHHBO BpeMeHH H no c<l>epaM 3KOHOMHKH.,[(oCTOBepHOCT:O H3JIO)KeHHbIX aBTOpOM HayqH:OIX nOJIO)KeHHM, B:OIBO):(OB HpeKOMeH,ll;aU:HMHopMaTHBH:OiePoccHMCKOMnO):(TBep)K,ll;aeTCHaKTbl,npHHHT:Oie<f>e,ll;epau:HH,):(OKTPHHDI,o6mHpHbIMBHCCJie):(OBaHHeMPoccHMCKOM<l>YH,ll;aMeHTaJI:OHbIMH3yqeHHeMH<f>e,ll;epau:HHonopoliHaHcy6neKTaxHCCJie,ll;osaHHeMnpasosolinpasonpHMeHHTeJI:OHOMnpaKTHKHpa.3JIWIH:OIXrocy,ll;apCTBeHH:OIX opraHOB. ,[(HccepTaU:HOHHaH pa6oTa HMeeT caMOCTOHTeJI:OHblM,3asepmeHHbIM xapaKTep.Co,ll;ep)l<aru;HecH3aKOHO,ll;aTeJihCTBa,BB:OIBO,ll;axHOBblenpe,ll;JIO)KeHHHHaytIHblenonoJIO)KeHHH,cosepmeHCTBOBamno,ll;OnOJIIDllOIIl;HeTeopmo<l>HHaHCOBOro npaBa, HBJUIIOTCH o6ocHOBaHHbIMH H ,ll;OCTOBepHbIMH, npe,ll;CTaBJUIIOTu:eHHOCT:O ):(JUI HaYKH H npaKTHKH.

IloJIO)KeHHH H B:OIBO):(bl ,ll;HCCepTaU:HH MOryTHaMTH csoe OTPa)KeHHe npH ):(aJI:OHelimeli TeopeTHqecKoli pa.3pa6oTKe npo6rreMnpasosoroperyJIHpOBaHH51,KaKpacXO):(HbIXo6H3aTeJI:OCTB,TaKHpacXO):(OB6IO):()KeTa, HanHCaHHH yqe6HHKOB, yqe6H:OIX noco6HM, MOHOrpa<l>HM, aTaK)KenpoBe):(eHHH rreKU:HOHHbIX H npaKTHqecKHX 3aHHTHM no yqe6HbIM ):(HCU:HnJIHHaM«<f>HHaHCOBOe npaso» H «nIO,ll;)KeTHOe npaBO» H OCHOBaHHbIX Ha Hell cneu:Kypcax.BTO )Ke BpeM51, HeCMOTP51 Ha see noJIO)KHTeJI:OHble MOMeHTbl, pa6oTa HeJIHmeHa H HeKOTOp:orx He):(OCTaTKOB.Bo-nepB:orx, npH paccMOTPeHHH npHpO,ll;bl pacxo):(Horo o6513aTerr:ocTBa Bnaparpa<l>e1rrraBbl1aBTOpOMHCCJie,ll;OBaH:OICJIO)l(HBIDHeCHno,ll;XO):(blKonpe,ll;eJieHHIO o6513aTerr:ocTBa TOJI:OKO B paMKax pHMCKoro npasa.

BMecTe c TeM5Bbipa6oTaBIIIruJCjf TeI<ym:ajf CMCTeMa o6jf3aTeJibCTB B rpa)l()];aHCKOM npaBe OCTaJiaCh3a npe.n;MeTOM npoBM,L(eHHOro MCCJie.L(OBaHMjf.Bo-BTOphIX,npe.n;cTaBJijfeTCjfaKrya.JihHhIMnpHpaccMOTPeHMMBonpoca3aKOHO.L(aTeJihHhIX npou;e,zzyp YTBep)l(.L(eHlfjf pacxo.n;HhIX o6jf3aTeJihCTB OTPa3MThoco6eHHOCTM Me)l(6JO.L()l(eTHbIX TpaHccpepTOB, a TaK)l(e MX npaBOByID npHpo.n;y noOTHOIIIeHMIOKpaCXO.L(HhIM06jf3aTeJibCTBaMMPocCMHCKOH<I>e.n;epau;MM,Mcy6oeKTOB PoccMHCKOH <I>e.n;epau;MM.B-TPeThMX,.L(MCKYCCMOHHhIHB.n;MccepTan;MMBonpocaBTopyOTHOCMTeJihHOcJie.n;oBaJIOopraHOB6bIpaccMOTPeThrocy.n;apCTBeHHOHBJiaCTM,KOTOpbie MOryT npoBO.L(MTb ou;eHK)' 3cpcpeKTMBHOCTM pacXO.L(HbIX o6jf3aTeJihCTB,BhIKJIIOqeHHhIX B 6IO.n;)l(eT cy6oeKTOB PoccMHCKOH <I>e.n;epau;MM.

IIpe.n;cTaBAAeTCjJ,qTo aHaJIM3 MX cpyHKIJ;MOHaJihHbIX B03MO)l(HOCTeH no3BOJIMJI 6bI 6oJiee qeTKOccpopMHpoBaTh<I>e.n;epau;MMBnpe.n;Jio)l(eHHOMpa3rpaHMqeHMeMO.L(eJihHOM3aKoHeo6jf3aHHOCTeiinocy6oeKTaPoccMHCKOHnpoBe.n;eHMIOou;eHKM3cpcpeKTMBHOCTM paCXO.L(OB 6IO.L()l(eTa.B-qeTBepThIX,3apaMKaMMnpoBe.n;eHHoroMCCJie.n;oBaHlfjfocTaJIOChM3yqeHMe cneu;HcpHKH npaBoBoro peryJIHpoBaHMjf o6m:ecTBeHHoro KOHTPOAA 3apacxo.n;HhIMM o6jf3aTeJihCTBaMM. BHacTojfm:ee BpeMjf B PoccMHCKOH <I>e.n;epau;MMaKTMBHO pa3BMBaeTCjJ MHCTMTYT o6:w:ecTBeHHOro KOHTpOJijf 3a .n:ej!TeJihHOCTbIOrocy.n;apcTBa.BcpyttKD;MOHMPYJOT6IO.n;)l(eTHOHcy6oeKTaxPoccMHCKOHo6m:ecTBeHHhie.n:ej!TeJihHOCThIOnaJiaThI.rocy.n;apcTBa<I>e.n;epau;MMo6pa3oBaHhIMKOHTPOAA3aOTPa)l(eHMeBHeo6xo.n;MMOCThHaxo.n;MTcBoeBbICTYIIJieHMj!X BbICIIIMX .L(OJI)l(HbIX JIMIJ; PocCMHCKOH <I>e.n;epau;MM M ee cy6oeKTOB.Ilpe.n;cTaBAAeTCjf, qTo M3yqeHMe MHCTMTYTa o6:w:ecTBeHHOro KOHTpOAA no3BOJIMJIOHaHTMrryTMCOBeprneHCTBOBaHMjfcpopMKOHTPOAA3anJiaHHpOBaHMeMMMCnOJIHeHMeM pacXO.L(HhIX 06jf3aTeJibCTB.BMeCTe c TeM Heo6xo.n;MMO OTMeTMTh, qTo Ka)l(,L(Oe M3 BhIHeceHHhIX aBTOpOMHa3a:W:MTYnoJIO)l(eHMH.L(MCcepTan;MOHHOroj!BAAeTCjfMCCJie,L(OBaHlfjf.apryMeHTHpOBaHHbIM,.D:oKa3aHaMXOTPa)l(aeTBa)l(HOCTbKaKHOBM3HY.L(Jljl10TeopeTMqeCKMX npe.n;cTaBJieHMH B MCCJie,zzyeMOH o6JiaCTM, TaK Mc TOqKM 3peHMji MX6rrpaKTWiecKoii 3HaqHMOCTH.